Skip to main content

Full text of "Theoretical Physics"

See other formats


DO 

OU   160413  >m 


&SMANIA  UNIVERSITY  LIBRARY 

53.  O  -  Accession  No.  /  6  S  9 


^hould  be  returned  on  or  beforthe  date  last  marked  below 


A-S-KOMPANEYETS 


TH 


RETICAL 


PHYSICS 


FOREIGN  LANGUAGES  PUBLISHING  HOUSE 
Moscow    1961 


TRANSLATED  FROM  THE  RUSSIAN 
EDITED  BY  GEORGE  YANKOVSKY 


This  translation  has  been  read  and  approved 
by  the  author,  Professor  A.  S.  Kompaneyets 


Printed  in  the  Union  of  Soviet  Socialist  Republics 


CONTENTS 

Page 

From  the  Preface  to  the  First  Edition 7 

Preface  to  the  Second  Edition 9 

Part  I.  Mechanics      11 

Sec.  1.  Generalized  Coordinates 11 

See.  2.  Lagrange's  Equation 13 

Sec.  3.  Examples  of  Lagrange's  Equations      24 

Sec.  4.  Conservation  Laws      30 

Sec.  5.  Motion  in  a  Central  Field 41 

Sec.  6.  Collision  of  Particles 48 

Sec.  7.  Small  Oscillations 57 

Sec.  8.  Rotating  Coordinate  Systems.  Tnertial  Forces 66 

Sec.  9.  The  Dynamics  of  a  Rigid  Body 73 

Sec.  10.  General  Principles  of  Mechanics 81 

Part  II.  Electrodynamics       92 

Sec.  11.  Vector  Analysis 92 

Sec.  12.  The  Electromagnetic  Field.  Maxwell's  Equations 104 

Sec.  13.  The  Action  Principle  for  the  Electromagnetic  Field 117 

Sec.  14.  The  Electrostatics  of  Point  Charges.  Slowly  Varying  Fields  .    .  124 

Sec.  15.  The  Magnetostatics  of  Point  Charges 135 

Sec.  16.  Electrodynamics  of  Material  Media 144 

Sec.  17;  Plane  Electromagnetic  Waves 162 

Sec.  18.  Transmission  of  Signals.  Almost  Plane  Waves 173 

Sec.  19.  The  Emission  of  Electromagnetic  Waves 181 

Sec.  20.  The  Theory  of  Relativity 190 

Sec.  21.  Relativistic  Dynamics 211 

Part  III.  Quantum  Mechanics 229 

Sec.  22.  The  Inadequacy  of  Classical  Mechanics. 

The  Analogy  Between  Mechanics  and  Geometrical  Optics 229 

Sec.  23.  Electron  Diffraction      238 

Sec.  24.  The  Wave  Equation 244 


6  CONTENTS 

Page 

Sec.  25.  Certain  Problems  of  Quantum  Mechanics 252 

Sec.  26.  Harmonic  Oscillatory  Motion  in  Quantum  Mechanics 

(Linear  Harmonic  Oscillator) 265 

Sec.  27.  Quantization  of  the  Electromagnetic  Field 271 

Sec.  28.  Quasi-Classical  Approximation 280 

Sec.  29.  Operators  in  Quantum  Mechanics 291 

Sec.  30.  Expansions  into  Wave  Functions 301 

Sec.  31.  Motion  in  a  Central  Field 312 

Sec.  32.  Electron  Spin 323 

Sec.  33.  Many-Electron  Systems 334 

Sec.  34.  The  Quantum  Theory  of  Radiation 353 

Sec.  35.  The  Atom  in  a  Constant  External  Field 368 

Sec.  36.  Quantum  Theory  of  Dispersion 379 

Sec.  37.  Quantum  Theory  of  Scattering 385 

Sec.  38.  The  Relativistic  Wave  Equation  for  an  Electron 394 

Part  IV.  Statistical  Physics 413 

Sec.  39.  The  Equilibrium  Distribution  of  Molecules  in  an  Ideal  Gas  .  .  413 
Sec.  40.  Boltzmann  Statistics  (Translational  Motion  of  a  Molecule.  Gas 

in  an  External  Field) 430 

Sec.  41.  Boltzmann  Statistics  (Vibrational  and  Rotational  Molecular 

Motion)  447 

Sec.  42.  The  Application  of  Statistics  to  the  Electromagnetic  Field  and 

to  Crystalline  Bodies 457 

Sec.  43.  Bose  Distribution  474 

Sec.  44.  Fermi  Distribution 477 

Sec.  45.  Gibbs  Statistics 498 

Sec.  46.  Thermodynamic  Quantities 512 

Sec.  47.  The  Thermodynamic  Properties  of  Ideal  Gases  in  Boltzmann 

Statistics 535 

Sec.  48.  Fluctuations 546 

Sec.  49.  Phase  Equilibrium 557 

Sec.  50.  Weak  Solutions 568 

Sec.  51.  Chemical  Equilibria 576 

Sec.  52.  Surface  Phenomena 582 

Appendix .  586 

Bibliography 588 

Subject  Index 589 


FROM  THE  PREFACE  TO  THE  FIRST  EDITION 

This  book  is  intended  for  readers  who  are  acquainted  with  the 
course  of  general  physics  and  analysis  of  nonspecializing  institutions 
of  higher  education.  It  is  meant  chiefly  for  engineer -physicists,  though 
it  may  also  be  useful  to  specialists  working  in  fields  associated  with 
physics — chemists,  physical  chemists,  biophysicists,  geophysicists, 
and  astronomers. 

Like  the  natural  sciences  in  general,  physics  is  based  primarily 
on  experiment,  and,  what  is  more,  on  quantitative  experiment. 
However,  no  series  of  experiments  can  constitute  a  theory  until  a 
rigorous  logical  relationship  is  established  between  them.  Theory  not 
only  allows  us  to  systematize  the  available  experimental  material,  but 
also  makes  it  possible  to  predict  new  facts  which  can  be  experimentally 
verified. 

All  physical  laws  are  expressed  in  the  form  of  quantitative  relation- 
ships. In  order  to  interrelate  quantitative  laws,  theoretical  physics 
appeals  to  mathematics.  The  methods  of  theoretical  physics,  which 
are  based  on  mathematics,  can  be  fully  mastered  only  by  those  who 
have  acquired  a  very  considerable  volume  of  mathematical  knowledge. 
Nevertheless,  the  basic  ideas  and  results  of  theoretical  physics  are 
readily  comprehensible  to  any  reader  who  has  an  understanding  of 
differential  and  integral  calculus,  and  is  acquainted  with  vector 
algebra.  This  is  the  minimum  of  mathematical  knowledge  required 
for  an  understanding  of  the  text  that  followrs. 

At  the  same  time,  the  aim  of  this  book  is  not  only  to  give  the  reader 
an  idea  about  what  theoretical  physics  is,  but  also  to  furnish  him 
with  a  working  knowledge  of  the  basic  methods  of  theoretical  physics. 
For  this  reason  it  has  been  necessary  to  adhere,  as  far  as  possible, 
to  a  rigorous  exposition.  The  reader  will  more  readily  agree  with 
the  conclusions  reached  if  their  inevitability  has  been  made  obvious 
to  him.  In  order  to  activize  the  work  of  the  student,  some  of  the 
applications  of  the  theory  have  been  shifted  into  the  exercises,  in 
which  the  line  of  reasoning  is  not  so  detailed  as  in  the  basic  text. 

In  compiling  such  a  relatively  small  book  as  this  one  it  has  been 
necessary  to  cut  down  on  the  space  devoted  to  certain  important 


8  FROM   THE   PREFACE   TO   THE   FIRST   EDITION 

sections  of  theoretical  physics,  and  omit  other  branches  entirely. 
For  instance,  the  mechanics  of  solid  media  is  not  included  at  all 
since  to  set  out  this  branch,  even  in  the  same  detail  as  the  rest  of 
the  text,  would  mean  doubling  the  size  of  the  book.  A  few  results 
from  the  mechanics  of  continuous  media  are  included  in  the  exercises 
as  illustrations  in  thermodynamics.  At  the  same  time,  the  mechanics 
and  electrodynamics  of  solid  media  are  less  related  to  the  fundamental, 
gnosiological  problems  of  physics  than  microscopic  electrodynamics, 
quantum  theory,  and  statistical  physics.  For  this  reason,  very  little 
space  is  devoted  to  macroscopic  electrodynamics:  the  material  has 
been  selected  in  such  a  way  as  to  show  the  reader  how  the  transition 
is  made  from  microscopic  electrodynamics  to  the  theory  of  quasi- 
stationary  fields  and  the  laws  of  the  propagation  of  light  in  media. 
It  is  assumed  that  the  reader  is  familiar  with  these  problems  from 
courses  of  physics  and  electricity. 

On  the  whole,  the  book  is  mainly  intended  for  the  reader  who  is 
interested  in  the  physics  of  elementary  processes.  These  considerations 
have  also  dictated  the  choice  of  material ;  as  in  all  nonencyclopaedic 
manuals,  this  choice  is  inevitably  somewhat  subjective. 

In  compiling  this  book,  I  have  made  considerable  use  of  the  excellent 
course  of  theoretical  physics  of  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits.  This 
comprehensive  course  can  be  recommended  to  all  those  who  wish 
to  obtain  a  profound  understanding  of  theoretical  physics. 

I  should  like  to  express  my  deep  gratitude  to  my  friends  who  have 
made  important  observations:  Ya.  B.  Zeldovich,  V.  G.  Levich, 
E.  L.  Feinberg,  V.  I.  Kogan  and  V.  I.  Goldansky. 

A.  Kompaneyets 


PREFACE  TO  THE  SECOND  EDITION 

In  this  second  edition  I  have  attempted  to  make  the  presentation 
more  systematic  and  rigorous  without  adding  any  difficulties.  In 
order  to  do  this  it  has  been  especially  necessary  to  revise  Part  III, 
to  which  I  have  added  a  special  section  (Sec.  30)  setting  out  the  general 
principles  of  quantum  mechanics;  radiation  is  now  considered  only 
with  the  aid  of  the  quantum  theory  of  the  electromagnetic  field, 
since  the  results  obtained  from  the  correspondence  principle  do  not 
appear  sufficiently  justified. 

Gibbs'  statistics  are  included  in  this  edition,  which  has  made  it 
necessary  to  divide  Part  IV  into  something  in  the  nature  of  two 
cycles:  Sec.  39-44,  where  only  the  results  of  combinatorial  analysis 
are  set  out,  and  Sec.  45-52,  an  introduction  to  the  Gibbs'  method, 
which  is  used  as  background  material  for  a  discussion  of  thermo- 
dynamics. A  phenomenological  approach  to  thermodynamics  would 
nowadays  appear  an  anachronism  in  a  course  of  theoretical  physics. 

In  order  not  to  increase  the  size  of  the  book  overmuch,  it  has  been 
necessary  to  omit  the  theory  of  beta  decay,  the  variational  properties 
of  eigenvalues,  and  certain  other  problems  included  in  the  first 
edition. 

I  am  greatly  indebted  to  A.  F.  Nikiforov  and  V.  B.  Uvarov  for 
pointing  out  several  inaccuracies  in  the  first  edition  of  the  book. 

A.  Kompaneyets 


PART   I 
MECHANICS 

See.  1.  Generalized  Coordinates 

Frames  of  reference.  In  order  to  describe  the  motion  of  a  mechanical 
system,  it  is  necessary  to  specify  its  position  in  space  as  a  function 
of  time.  Obviously,  it  is  only  meaningful  to  speak  of  the  relative 
position  of  any  point.  For  instance,  the  position  of  a  flying  aircraft 
is  given  relative  to  some  coordinate  system  fixed  with  respect  to  the 
earth;  the  motion  of  a  charged  particle  in  an  accelerator  is  given 
relative  to  the  accelerator,  etc.  The  system,  relative  to  which  the 
motion  is  described,  is  called  a  frame  of  reference. 

Specification  of  time.  As  will  be  shown  later  (Sec.  20),  specification 
of  time  in  the  general  case  is  also  connected  with  defining  the  frame 
of  reference  in  which  it  is  given.  The  intuitive  conception  of  a  uni- 
versal, unique  time,  to  which  we  are  accustomed  in  everyday  life, 
is,  to  a  certain  extent,  an  approximation  that  is  only  true  when  the 
relative  speeds  of  all  material  particles  are  small  in  comparison 
with  the  velocity  of  light.  The  mechanics  of  such  slow  movements 
is  termed  Newtonian,  since  Isaac  Newton  was  the  first  to  formulate 
its  laws. 

Newton's  laws  permit  a  determination  of  the  position  of  a  mechanical 
system  at  an  arbitrary  instant  of  time,  if  the  positions  and  velocities 
of  all  points  of  the  system  are  known  at  some  initial  instant,  and  also 
if  the  forces  acting  in  the  system  are  known. 

Degrees  of  freedom  of  a  mechanical  system.  The  number  of  inde-\ 
pendent  parameters  defining  the  position  of  a  mechanical  system  in 
space  is  termed  the  number  of  its  degrees  of  freedom. 

The  position  of  a  particle  in  space  relative  to  other  bodies  is  defined 
with  the  aid  of  three  independent  parameters,  for  example,  its 
Cartesian  coordinates.  The  position  of  a  system  consisting  of  N 
particles  is  determined,  in  general,  by  3JV  independent  parameters. 

However,  if  the  distribution  of  points  is  fixed  in  any  way,  then 
the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  may  be  less  than  3^.  For  example, 


12  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

if  two  points  are  constrained  by  some  form  of  rigid  nondeformable 
coupling,  then,  upon  the  six  Cartesian  coordinates  of  these  points, 
xi>  Vi>  zi>  xz>  y%>  Z2>  *s  imposed  the  condition 

(x2-xl^  +  (y2~yl^  +  (z2  —  z1)^Rl29  (1.1) 

where  J?12  is  the  given  distance  between  the  points.  It  follows  that 
the  Cartesian  coordinates  are  no  longer  independent  parameters: 
a  relationship  exists  between  them.  Only  five  of  the  six  values 
xl9  . . . ,  Z2  are  now  independent.  In  other  words,  a  system  of  two 
particles,  separated  by  a  fixed  distance,  has  five  degrees  of  freedom.  If 
we  consider  three  particles  which  are  rigidly  fixed  in  a  triangle,  then 
the  coordinates  of  the  third  particle  must  satisfy  the  two  equations : 

y^  +  (z,-z1)^Rll,  (1.2) 

y2)*  +  (Zs-z2)*=:Rl,.  (1.3) 

Thus,  the  nine  coordinates  of  the  vertices  of  the  rigid  triangle  are 
defined  by  the  three  equations  (1.1),  (1.2)  and  (1.3),  and  hence  only 
six  of  the  nine  quantities  are  independent.  The  triangle  has  six 
degrees  of  freedom. 

The  position  of  a  rigid  body  in  space  is  defined  by  three  points 
which  do  not  lie  on  the  same  straight  line.  These  three  points,  as  we 
have  just  seen,  have  six  degrees  of  freedom.  It  follows  that  any  rigid 
body  has  six  degrees  of  freedom.  It  should  be  noted  that  only  such 
motions  of  the  rigid  body  are  considered  as,  for  example,  the  rotation 
of  a  top,  where  no  noticeable  deformation  occurs  that  can  affect 
its  motion. 

Generalized  coordinates.  It  is  not  always  convenient  to  describe 
the  position  of  a  system  in  Cartesian  coordinates.  As  we  have  already 
seen,  when  rigid  constraints  exist,  Cartesian  coordinates  must  satisfy 
supplementary  equations.  In  addition,  the  choice  of  coordinate  system 
is  arbitrary  and  should  be  determined  primarily  on  the  basis  of 
expediency.  For  instance,  if  the  forces  depend  only  on  the  distances 
between  particles,  it  is  reasonable  to  introduce  these  distances  into 
dynamical  equations  explicitly  and  not  by  means  of  Cartesian 
coordinates. 

In  other  words,  a  mechanical  system  can  be  described  by  coordinates 
whose  number  is  equal  to  the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  of  the 
system.  These  coordinates  may  sometimes  coincide  with  the  Cartesian 
coordinates  of  some  of  the  particles.  For  example,  in  a  system  of  two 
rigidly  connected  points,  these  coordinates  can  be  chosen  in  the 
following  way:  the  position  of  one  of  the  points  is  given  in  Cartesian 
coordinates,  after  which  the  other  point  will  always  be  situated  on 
a  sphere  whose  centre  is  the  first  point.  The  position  of  the  second 
point  on  the  sphere  may  be  given  by  its  longitude  and  latitude. 


Sec.  2]  LAGRANGE'S  EQUATION  13 

Together  with  the  three  Cartesian  coordinates  of  the  first  point, 
the  latitude  and  longitude  of  the  second  point  completely  define 
the  position  of  such  a  system  in  space. 

For  three  rigidly  bound  points,  it  is  necessary,  in  accordance  with 
the  method  just  described,  to  specify  the  position  of  one  side  of  the 
triangle  and  the  angle  of  rotation  of  the  third  vertex  about  that 
side. 

The  independent  parameters  which  define  the  position  of  a 
mechanical  system  in  space  are  called  its  generalized  coordinates. 
We  will  represent  them  by  the  symbols  g^,  where  the  subscript  a 
signifies  the  number  of  the  degree  of  freedom. 

As  in  the  case  of  Cartesian  coordinates,  the  choice  of  generalized 
coordinates  is  to  a  considerable  extent  arbitrary.  It  must  be  chosen 
so  that  the  dynamical  laws  of  motion  of  the  system  can  be  formulated 
as  conveniently  as  possible. 


Sec.  2.  Lagrange's  Equation 

In  this  section,  equations  of  motion  will  be  obtained  in  terms  of 
arbitrary  generalized  coordinates.  In  such  form  they  are  especially 
convenient  in  theoretical  physics. 

Newton's  Second  Law.  Motion  in  mechanics  consists  in  changes  in 
the  mutual  configuration  of  bodies  in  time.  In  other  words,  it  is 
described  in  terms  of  the  mutual  distances,  or  lengths,  and  intervals 
of  time.  As  was  shown  in  the  preceding  section,  all  motion  is  relative; 
it  can  be  specified  only  in  relation  to  some  definite  frame  of  refer- 
ence. 

In  accordance  with  the  level  of  knowledge  of  his  time,  Newton 
regarded  the  concepts  of  length  and  time  interval  as  absolute,  which 
is  to  say  that  these  quantities  are  the  same  in  all  frames  of  reference. 
As  will  be  shown  later,  Newton's  assumption  was  an  approximation 
(see  Sec.  20).  It  holds  when  the  relative  speeds  of  all  the  particles 
are  small  compared  with  the  velocity  of  light;  here  Newtonian 
mechanics  is  based  on  a  vast  quantity  of  experimental  facts. 

In  formulating  the  laws  of  motion  a  very  convenient  concept  is 
the  material  particle,  that  is,  a  body  whose  position  is  completely 
defined  by  three  Cartesian  coordinates.  Strictly  speaking,  this 
idealization  is  not  applicable  to  any  body.  Nevertheless,  it  is  in 
every  way  reasonable  when  the  motion  of  a  body  is  sufficiently  well 
defined  by  the  displacement  in  space  of  any  of  its  particles  (for 
example,  the  centre  of  gravity  of  the  body)  and  is  independent  of 
rotations  or  deformations  of  the  body. 

If  we  start  with  the  concept  of  a  particle  as  the  fundamental 
entity  of  mechanics,  then  the  law  of  motion  (Newton's  Second  Law) 
is  formulated  thus: 


14  MECHANICS  [Part  I 


~- 


(2.1) 


Here,  F  is  the  resultant  of  all  the  forces  applied  to  the  particle 

i2  f 

(the  vector  sum  of  the  forces)  —r^    is  the  vector  acceleration,  the 
Cartesian  components  of  which  are 

d2z 


The  quantity  m  involved  in  equation  (2.1)  characterizes  the  particle 
and  is  called  its  mass. 

Force  and  mass.  Equality  (2.1)  is  the  definition  of  force.  However, 
it  should  not  be  regarded  as  a  simple  identity  or  designation,  be- 
cause (2.1)  establishes  the  form  of  the  interaction  between  bodies 
in  mechanics  and  thereby  actually  describes  a  certain  law  of  nature. 
The  interaction  is  expressed  in  the  form  of  a  differential  equation 
that  includes  only  the  second  derivatives  of  the  coordinates  with 
respect  to  time  (and  not  derivatives,  say,  of  the  fourth  order). 

In  addition,  certain  limiting  assumptions  are  usually  made  in 
relation  to  the  force.  In  Newtonian  mechanics  it  is  assumed  that 
forces  depend  only  on  the  mutual  arrangement  of  the  bodies  at  the 
instant  to  which  the  equality  refers  and  do  not  depend  on  the  con- 
figuration of  the  bodies  at  previous  times.  As  we  shall  see  later  (see 
Part  II),  this  supposition  about  the  character  of  interaction  forces 
is  valid  only  when  the  speeds  of*  the  bodies  are  small  compared  with 
the  velocity  of  light. 

The  quantity  m  in  equality  (2.1)  is  a  characteristic  of  the  body, 
its  mass.  Mass  may  be  determined  by  comparing  the  accelerations 
which  the  same  force  imparts  to  different  bodies;  the  greater  the 
acceleration,  the  less  the  mass.  In  order  to  measure  mass,  some  body 
must  be  regarded  as  a  standard.  The  choice  of  a  standard  body  is 
completely  independent  of  the  choice  of  standards  of  length  and 
time.  This  is  what  makes  the  dimension  (or  unit  of  measurement) 
of  mass  a  special  dimension,  not  related  to  the  dimensions  of  length 
and  time. 

The  properties  of  mass  arc  established  experimentally.  Firstly,  it 
can  be  shown  that  the  mass  of  two  equal  quantities  of  the  same 
substance  is  equal  to  twice  the  mass  of  each  quantity.  For  example, 
one  can  take  two  identical  scale  weights  and  note  that  a  stretched  ' 
spring  gives  them  equal  accelerations.  If  we  join  two  such  weights 
and  subject  them  to  the  action  of  the  same  spring,  which  has  been 
stretched  by  the  same  amount  as  for  each  weight  separately,  the 
acceleration  will  be  found  to  be  one  half  what  it  was.  It  follows  that 
the  overall  mass  of  the  weights  is  twice  as  great,  since  the  force 
depends  only  on  the  tension  of  the  spring  and  could  not  have  changed. 


Sec.  2]  LAGRANGE'S  EQUATION  15 

Thus,  mass  is  an  additive  quantity,  that  is,  one  in  which  the  whole 
is  equal  to  the  sum  of  the  quantities  of  each  part  taken  separately. 
Experiment  shows  that  the  principle  of  additivity  of  mass  also 
applies  to  bodies  consisting  of  different  substances. 

In  addition,  in  Newtonian  mechanics,  the  mass  of  a  body  is  a 
constant  quantity  which  does  not  change  with  motion. 

It  must  not  be  forgotten  that  the  additivity  and  constancy  of 
masses  are  properties  that  follow  only  from  experimental  facts  which 
relate  to  very  specific  forms  of  motion.  For  example,  a  very  important 
law,  that  of  the  conservation  of  mass  in  chemical  transformations 
involving  rearrangement  of  the  molecules  and  atoms  of  a  body, 
was  established  by  M.  V.  Lomonosov  experimentally. 

Like  all  laws  deduced  from  experiment,  the  principle  of  additivity 
of  mass  has  a  definite  degree  of  precision.  For  such  strong  interactions 
as  take  place  in  the  atomic  nucleus,  the  breakdown  of  the  additivity 
of  mass  is  apparent  (for  more  detail  see  Sec.  21). 

We  may  note  that  if  instead  of  subjecting  a  body  to  the  force  of 
a  stretched  spring  it  were  subjected  to  the  action  of  gravity,  then 
the  acceleration  of  a  body  of  double  mass  would  be  equal  to  the 
acceleration  of  each  body  separately.  From  this  we  conclude  that 
the  force  of  gravity  is  itself  proportional  to  the  mass  of  a  body. 
Hence,  in  a  vacuum,  in  the  absence  of  air  resistance,  all  bodies  fall 
with  the  same  acceleration. 

Inertial  frames  of  reference.  In  equation  (2.1)  we  have  to  do  with 
the  acceleration  of  a  particle.  There  is  no  sense  in  talking  about 
acceleration  without  stating  to  which  frame  of  reference  it  is  referred. 
For  this  reason  there  arises  a  difficulty  in  stating  the  cause  of  the 
acceleration.  This  cause  may  be  either  interaction  between  bodies 
or  it  may  be  due  to  some  distinctive  properties  of  the  reference  frame 
itself.  For  example,  the  jolt  which  a  passenger  experiences  when  a 
carriage  suddenly  stops  is  evidence  that  the  carriage  is  in  nonuniform 
motion  relative  to  the  earth. 

Let  us  consider  a  set  of  bodies  not  affected  by  any  other  bodies, 
that  is,  one  that  is  sufficiently  far  away  from  them.  We  can  suppose 
that  a  frame  of  reference  exists  such  that  all  accelerations  of  the 
set  of  bodies  considered  arise  only  as  a  result  of  the  interaction  between 
the  bodies.  This  can  be  verified  if  the  forces  satisfy  Newton's  Third 
Law,  i.e.,  if  they  are  equal  and  opposite  in  sign  for  any  pair  of  particles 
(it  is  assumed  that  the  forces  occur  instantaneously,  and  this  is  true 
only  when  the  speeds  of  the  particles  are  small  compared  with  the 
speed  of  transmission  of  the  interaction). 

A  frame  of  reference  for  which  the  acceleration  of  a  certain  set  of 
particles  depends  only  on  the  interaction  between  these  particles 
is  called  an  inertial  frame  (or  inertial  coordinate  system).  A  free 
particle,  not  subject  to  the  action  of  any  other  body,  moves,  relative 
to  such  a  reference  frame,  uniformly  in  a  straight  line  or,  in  everyday 


16  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

language,  by  its  own  momentum.  If  in  a  given  frame  of  reference 
Newton's  Third  Law  is  not  satisfied  we  can  conclude  that  this  is 
not  an  inertial  system. 

Thus,  a  stone  thrown  directly  downwards  from  a  tall  tower  is 
deflected  towards  the  east  from  the  direction  of  the  force  of  gravity. 
This  direction  can  be  independently  established  with  the  aid  of  a 
suspended  weight.  It  follows  that  the  stone  has  a  component  of 
acceleration  which  is  not  caused  by  the  force  of  the  earth's  attraction. 
From  this  we  conclude  that  the  frame  of  reference  fixed  in  the  earth 
is  noninertial.  The  noninertiality  is,  in  this  case,  due  to  the  diurnal 
rotation  of  the  earth. 

On  the  forces  ot  friction.  In  everyday  life  we  constantly  observe 
the  action  of  forces  that  arise  from  direct  contacts  between  bodies. 
The  sliding  and  rolling  of  rigid  bodies  give  rise  to  forces  of  friction. 
The  action  of  these  forces  causes  a  transition  of  the  macroscopic 
motion  of  the  body  as  a  whole  into  the  microscopic  motion  of  the 
constituent  atoms  and  molecules.  This  is  perceived  as  the  generation 
of  heat.  Actually,  when  a  body  slides  an  extraordinarily  complex 
process  of  interaction  occurs  between  the  atoms  in  the  surface  layer. 
A  description  of  this  interaction  in  the  simple  terms  of  frictional 
forces  is  a  very  convenient  idealization  for  the  mechanics  of  macro- 
scopic motion,  but,  naturally,  does  not  give  us  a  full  picture  of  the 
process.  The  concept  of  frictional  force  arises  as  a  result  of  a  certain 
averaging  of  all  the  elementary  interactions  which  occur  between 
bodies  in  contact. 

In  this  part,  which  is  concerned  only  with  elementary  laws,  we  shall 
not  consider  averaged  interactions  where  motion  is  transferred  to 
the  internal,  microscopic,  degrees  of  freedom  of  atoms  and  molecules. 
Here,  we  will  study  only  those  interactions  which  can  be  completely 
expressed  with  the  aid  of  elementary  laws  of  mechanics  and  which 
do  not  require  an  appeal  to  any  statistical  concepts  connected  with 
internal,  thermal,  motion. 

Ideal  rigid  constraints.  Bodies  in  contact  also  give  rise  to  forces 
of  interaction  which  can  be  reduced  to  the  kinematic  properties  of 
rigid  constraints.  If  rigid  constraints  act  in  a  system  they  force 
the  particles  to  move  on  definite  surfaces.  Thus,  in  Sec.  1  we  con- 
sidered the  motion  of  a  single  particle  on  a  sphere,  at  the  centre  of 
which  was  another  particle. 

This  kind  of  interaction  between  particles  does  not  cause  a  transition 
of  the  motion  to  the  internal,  microscopic,  degrees  of  freedom  of 
bodies.  In  other  words,  motion  which  is  limited  by  rigid  constraints 
is  completely  described  by  its  own  macroscopic  generalized  co- 
ordinates qa. 

If  the  limitations  imposed  by  the  constraints  distort  the  motion, 
they  thereby  cause  accelerations  (curvilinear  motion  is  always 
accelerated  motion  since  velocity  is  a  vector  quantity).  This  ac- 


Sec.  2]  LAGRANGE'S  EQUATION  17 

celeration  can  be  formally  attributed  to  forces  which  are  called 
reaction  forces  of  rigid  constraints. 

Reaction  forces  change  only  the  direction  of  velocity  of  a  particle 
but  not  its  magnitude.  If  they  were  to  alter  the  magnitude  of  the 
velocity,  this  would  produce  a  change  also  in  the  kinetic  energy  of 
the  particle.  According  to  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy,  heat 
would  then  be  generated.  But  this  was  excluded  from  consideration 
from  the  very  start. 

To  summarize,  the  reaction  forces  of  ideally  rigid  constraints  do 
not  change  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  system.  In  other  words,  they  do 
not  perform  any  work  on  it,  since  work  performed  on  a  system  is 
equivalent  to  changing  its  kinetic  energy  (if  heat  is  not  gener- 
ated). 

In  order  that  a  force  should  not  perform  work,  it  must  be  perpen- 
dicular to  the  displacement.  For  this  reason  the  reaction  forces  of 
constraints  are  perpendicular  to  the  direction  of  particle  velocity 
at  each  given  instant  of  time. 

However,  in  problems  of  mechanics,  the  reaction  forces  are  not 
initially  given,  as  are  the  functions  of  particle  position.  They  are 
determined  by  integrating  equations  (2.1),  with  account  taken  of 
constraint  conditions.  Therefore,  it  is  best  to  formulate  the  equations 
of  mechanics  so  as  to  exclude  constraint  reactions  entirely.  It  turns 
out  that  if  we  go  over  to  generalized  coordinates,  the  number  of 
which  is  equal  to  the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  of  the  system, 
then  the  constraint  reactions  disappear  from  the  equations.  In  this 
section  we  shall  make  such  a  transition  and  will  obtain  the  equations 
of  mechanics  in  terms  of  the  generalized  coordinates  of  the  system. 

The  transformation  from  rectangular  to  generalized  coordinates. 
We  take  a  system  with  a  total  of  3N==n  Cartesian  coordinates  of 
which  v  are  independent.  We  will  always  denote  Cartesian  coordinates 
by  the  same  letter  xi,  understanding  by  this  symbol  all  the  co- 
ordinates x,  y,  z  ;  this  means  that  i  varies  from  1  to  3jY,  that  is,  from  1 
to  n.  The  generalized  coordinates  we  denote  by  #a  (l^Ca^v).  Since 
the  generalized  coordinates  completely  specify  the  position  of  their 
s\'stem,  Xi  are  their  unique  functions: 

xl^xi(ql,  ^2,  ...  ?a,  ...,£v).  (2.2) 

From  this  it  is  easy  to  obtain  an  expression  for  the  Cartesian  com- 
ponents of  velocity.  Differentiating  the  function  of  many  variables 
Xi  (  .  .  .  g«)  with  respect  to  time,  we  have 


dt 


In   the  subsequent   derivation   we  shall  often  have  to  perform 
summations   with   respect   to    all    the    generalized    coordinates    qat 


2-0060 


18  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

and  double  and  triple  sums  will  be  encountered.  In  order  to  save 
space  we  introduce  the  following  summation  convention. 

If  a  Greek  symbol  is  met  twice  on  one  side  of  an  equation,  it  will  be 
understood  as  denoting  a  summation  from  unity  to  v,  that  is,  over  all 
the  generalized  coordinates.  (It  is  not  convenient  to  use  this  convention 
for  the  Latin  characters  which  denote  the  Cartesian  coordinates.) 

Then  the  velocity  --.—  can  be  rewritten  thus: 

_^a'»_  __  djri  ^?«  /o  Q\ 

dt    ~~   #7a     dt  '  '  *~"    ' 

Here  the  summation  sign  is  omitted. 

The  total  derivative  with  respect  to  time  is  usually  denoted  by  a 
dot  over  the  corresponding  variable: 

d*   __  .  dq*        . 

~dt        *"  "dT^V"-  (~'  ' 

In  this  notation,  (2.3)  is  written  in  an  even  more  abbreviated  form: 

•  f)  .?*|*       .  i  c\    f\ 

«=-t~q*.  (2.5) 

Differentiating  (2.5)  with  respect  to  time  again,  we  obtain  an 
expression  for  the  Cartesian  components  of  acceleration: 


The  total  derivative  in  the  first  term  is  written  as  usual: 
A 

dt 

The  Greek  symbol  over  which  the  summation  is  performed  is  denoted 
by  the  letter  (3  to  avoid  confusion  with  the  symbol  a,  which  denotes 
the  summation  in  the  expression  for  velocity  (2.5).  Thus,  we  obtain 
the  desired  expression  for  £,  : 

82xi      .     .     ,    dxi  ..  /rt  0. 

Xi  =  -q*q*  +        q'"  (2'6) 


The  first  term  on  the  right-hand  side  contains  a  double  summation 
with  respect  to  a  and  p. 

Potential  of  a  force.  We  now  consider  components  of  force.  In 
many  cases,  the  three  components  of  the  vector  of  a  force  acting 
on  a  particle  can  be  expressed  in  terms  of  one  scalar  function  U 
according  to  the  formula: 


Sec.  2j  LAGRANGE'S  EQUATION  19 

Such  a  function  can  always  be  chosen  for  the  force  of  Newtonian 
attraction,  and  for  electrostatic  and  elastic  forces.  The  function  U 
is  called  the  potential  of  the  force. 

It  is  clear  that  by  far  not  every  system  of  forces  can,  in  the  general 
case,  be  represented  by  a  set  of  partial  derivatives  (2.7),  since  if 


then  we  must  have  the  equality 

<  F\  =_  ?Fk      _     <*V 

c^k          Pxi  c'.r,  cVfc 

for  all  i,  k,  which  is  not,  in  advance,  obvious  for  the  arbitrary  functions 
F,  ,  Fk  .  The  definite  form  of  the  potential,  in  those  cases  where  it 
exists,  will  be  given  below  for  various  forces. 

Expression  (-.7)  defines  the  potential  function  U  to  the  accuracy 
of  an  arbitrary  constant  term.  U  is  also  called  the  potential  energy 
of  the  system.  For  example,  the  gravitational  force  F  =  —  mg, 
while  the  potential  energy  of  an  elevated  body  is  equal  to  mgz, 
where  {7^980  cm/sec2  is  the  acceleration  of  a  freely  falling  body 
and  z  is  the  height  to  which  it  has  been  raised.  It  can  be  calculated 
from  any  level,  which  in  the  given  case  corresponds  to  a  determi- 
nation of  U  to  the  accuracy  of  a  constant  term.  A  more  precise  ex- 
pression for  the  force  of  gravity  than  F  —  —  mg  (with  allowance 
made  for  its  dependence  on  height  also  admits  of  a  potential,  which 
we  shall  derive  a  little  later  [see  (3.4)]. 

We  denote  the  component  reaction  forces  of  rigid  constraints  by 
Fi.  We  now  note  that 

n 

£f"*dxi=09  (2.8) 

i  -i 

if  the  displacements  are  compatible  with  the  constraints.  Indeed, 
(2.8)  expresses  precisely  the  work  performed  by  the  reaction  forces 
for  a  certain  possible  displacement  of  the  system;  but  this  work 
has  been  shown  to  be  equal  to  zero. 

Lagrange's  equations.*  We  will  now  write  down  the  equations  of 
motion  with  the  aid  of  (2.7)  and  (2.8)  as 

fcfc  +-£»•)—  J^-       <"» 

Here,  of  course,  m1  =  m2  =  ms  is  equal  to  the  mass  of  the  first 
particle,  w4  =  ms=m6  equals  the  mass  of  the  second  particle,  etc. 


*  In  the  first  reading,   the  subsequent  derivation  up  to  equation   (2.18) 
need  not  be  studied  in  detail. 


20  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Let  us  multiply  both  sides  of  this  equation  by  -~-  and  sum  from  1 

to  n  over  i. 

Let  us  first  consider  the  right-hand  side.  We  obviously  have 


in  accordance  with  the  law  for  differentiating  composite  functions. 
For  the  forces  of  reaction  we  obtain 


since  this  equality  is  a  special  case  of  (2.8),  in  which  the  displace- 
ments dxi  are  taken  for  all  constants  q  except  for  #Y;  that  is  why  we 

retain  the  designation  of  the  partial  derivative  -~-  .  It  is  clear  that 

in  such  a  special  displacement  the  work  done  by  the  reaction  forces 
of  the  constraints  is  equal  to  zero,  as  in  the  case  of  a  general  displace- 
ment. 

After  multiplication  by  --—   and  summation,  the  left-hand  side 

of  equality  (2.9)  can  be  written  in  a  more  compact  form,  without 
resorting  to  explicit  Cartesian  coordinates.  It  is  precisely  the  purpose 
of  this  section  to  give  such  an  improved  notation.  To  do  this  we  ex- 
press the  kinetic  energy  in  terms  of  generalized  coordinates: 


1-1  1-1 

Substituting  the  generalized  velocities  by  using  (2.5),  we  obtain 


The  summation  indices  for  q  must,  of  course,  be  denoted  by  different 
letters,  since  they  independently  take  all  values  from  1  to  v  inclusive. 
Changing  the  order  of  summation  for  Cartesian  and  generalized  co- 
ordinates we  have 

n 

Tl     •       .       v~T  fix*       dxt  ,~  ,  ~N 

~T«-ftZ>15;ri£-  <2-13> 


Henceforth,  T  will  have  to  be  differentiated  both  with  respect  to 
generalized  coordinates  qa  and  generalized  velocities  qa.  The  co- 
ordinate qa  and  its  corresponding  generalized  velocity  #a  are  in- 


Sec.  2]  LAGKANGE'S  EQUATION  21 

dependent  of  each  other  since,  in  the  given  position  in  which  the 
coordinate  has  a  given  value  #«  ,  it  is  possible  to  impart  to  the  system 
an  arbitrary  velocity  </a  permitted  by  the  constraints.  Naturally,  qa 

<)  T 
and  </p^  «  are  also  independent.  It  follows  that  in  calculating 


all  the  remaining  velocities  g^-^a.  and  all  the  coordinates,  including 
<7a,  should  be  regarded  as  constant. 

d  T 

Let  us  calculate  the   derivative  -x-—  .  In  the  double  summation 

3qr 

(2.13),  the  quantity  y  can  be  taken  as  the  index  a  and  also  the  index  (3, 
so  that  we  obtain 

8  T       1  .         1       e-r<)xi        l  •        1       d      Sj 


Both  these  sums  are  the  same  except  that  in  the  first  the  index 
is  denoted  by  [3  and  in  the  second  by  a.  They  can  be  combined, 
replacing  (3  by  a  in  the  first  summation  ;  naturally  the  value  of  the 
sum  does  not  change  due  to  renaming  of  the  summation  sign.  Then 
we  obtain 

n 

^  /rt  -  .. 

(2.14) 
v          x 


Let  us  calculate  the  total  derivative  of  this  quantity  with  respect 
to  time: 

d    ^T         »         » 


Here  we  have  had  to  write  down  the  derivatives  of  each  of  the  three 
factors  of  all  the  terms  in  the  summation  (2.14)  separately. 

8  T 

Now  let  us  calculate  the  partial  derivative    -  —  .  As  has  been 

d<?Y 

o  rri 

shown,  ga,  q&  are  regarded  as  constants.  Like  -^r~,  the  derivative 

COf 

dT 
-Q  —  consists  of  two  terms  which  may  be  amalgamated  into   one. 

Differentiating  (2.13),  we  obtain 

3T        .    .     V-T          82xi      dxi  /0  ,-. 

•fl  -   ==9ra  3&  \  mi^  -  -5  -  7T--  (2.16) 

d-          ww  ^  v          ; 


22  MECHANICS  [Part  1 

Subtracting  (2.16)  from  (2.15),  we  see  that  (2.16)  and  the  last  term 
of  (2.15)  cancel.  As  a  result  we  obtain 


%i        /0  im 

(2J7) 


However,   the   expression   on   the   right-hand   side   of  (2.17)   can 

dX' 

also  be  obtained  from  (2.9)  if  we  multiply  its  left-hand  side  by  -~- 
and  sum  over  i.  For  this  reason,  (2.17),  in  accordance  with  (2.10), 

Q    J-J 

is  equal  to  —  «  —  .  Thus  we  find 

^  dgY 

d     dT  _  W  __3U^ 

dt   dq-f         c)</Y  dq-f  '  \-1*      ) 

In  mechanics  it  is  usual  to  consider  interaction  forces  that  are 
independent  of  particle  velocities.  In  this  case  U  does  not  involve  #«, 
so  that  (2.18)  may  be  rewritten  in  the  following  form: 


The  difference  between  the  kinetic  and  potential  energy  is  called 
the  Lagrangian  function  (or,  simply,  Lagrangian)  and  is  denoted  by 
the  letter  L: 

L^T—U.  (2.20) 

Thus  we  have  arrived  at  a  system  of  v  equations  with  v  independent 
quantities  ga  ,  the  number  of  which  is  equal  to  the  number  of  degrees 
of  freedom  of  the  system: 

d    d  L  d  L        A  ^  /  o  o  i  \ 

j,   a"     --  a    -~-=v,  l^a<v.  (2.21) 

dt   dqa.          dqoi  ' 

These  equations  are  called  Lagrange's  equations.  Naturally,  in 
(2.21)  L  is  considered  to  be  expressed  solely  in  terms  of  </a  and  </a, 
the  Cartesian  coordinates  being  excluded.  It  turns  out  that  this 
type  of  equation  holds  also  in  cases  when  the  forces  depend  on  the 
velocities  (see  Sec.  21).* 

The  rules  for  forming  Lagrangc's  equations.  Since  the  derivation 
of  equations  (2.21)  from  Newton's  Second  Law  is  not  readily  evident 
we  will  give  the  order  of  operations  which,  for  this  given  system, 
lead  to  the  Lagrange  equations. 


*  In  this  case,  the  Lagrangian  function  does  not  have  the  form  of  (2.20), 
where  U  is  a  function  of  generalized  coordinates  only.  However,  the  form  of 
equations  (2.21)  is  still  valid. 


Sec.  2]  LAGRANGE'S  EQUATION  23 

1)  The  Cartesian  coordinates  are  expressed  in  terms  of  generalized 
coordinates  : 


2)  The  Cartesian  velocity  components  are  expressed  in  terms  of 
generalized  velocities: 


3)  The  coordinates  are  substituted  in  the  expression  for  potential 
energy  so  that  it  is  defined  in  relation  to  generalized  coordinates: 

U=U  (ql9  . . .,  g«,  •  • .,  #v). 

4)  The   velocities   are   substituted  in  the   expression   for  kinetic 
energy 


-   —   2  ^'".~,  , 

which  is  now  a  function  of  #a  and  ga .  It  is  essential  that  in  generalized 
coordinates,  T  is  a  function  both  of  #«  and  </a. 

5)  The  partial  derivatives  -TTT-  and  -^-  are  found. 

dq&  dq<x. 

6)  Lagrange's  equations  (2.21)  are  formed  according  to  the  number 
of  degrees  of  freedom. 

In  the  next  section  we  will  consider  some  examples  in  forming 
Lagrange's  equations. 

Exercises 

1)  Write  down  Lagrange's  equation,  where  the  Lagrangian  function  has 
the  form: 


2)  A  point  moves  in  a  vortical  plane  along  a  given  curve  in  a  gravitational 
field.  The  equation  of  the  curve  in  parametric  form  is  x  =  x  (s),  z  =  z  (a).  Write 
down  Lagrange's  equations. 

The  velocities  are 

dx   .        ,  .  .        dz   .         ,  . 

x  =     _  8  ^  x  8  z  —     _  8  _=  z  8 

ds  ds 

The  Lagrangian  has  the  form: 

i  =  -y  las'1 +  *'1)i1— %»*(«)• 
Lagrango's  equation  is 

~  m  [(x'*  +  2/2)  «]  —  m  s*  (x'x"  +  z'z")  +  mgz'  =  0  . 


24  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Sec.  3.  Examples  ol  Lagrange's  Equations 

Central  forces.  Central  forces  is  the  name  given  to  those  whose 
directions  are  along  the  lines  joining  the  particles  and  which  depend 
only  on  the  distances  between  them.  Corresponding  to  such  forces, 
there  is  always  a  potential  energy,  U,  dependent  on  these  distances. 
As  an  example,  we  consider  the  motion  of  a  particle  relative  to  a 
fixed  centre  and  attracting  it  according  to  Newton's  law.  We  shall 
show  how  to  find  the  potential  energy  in  this  case  by  proceeding 
from  the  expression  for  a  gravitational  force. 

Gravitational  force  is  known  to  be  inversely  proportional  to  the 
square  of  the  distance  between  the  particles  and  is  directed  along 
the  line  joining  them: 

F-—  a  -2  -r  .  (3.1) 

r2    r  x        ' 

Here  a  is  the  factor  of  proportionality  which  we  will  not  define  more 
precisely  at  this  point,  r  is  the  distance  between  the  particles,  and 

—  is  a  unit  vector.  The  minus  sign  signifies  that  the  particles  attract 

each  other,  so  that  the  force  is  in  the  opposite  direction  to  the  radius 
vector  r.  According  to  (3.1),  the  attractive-force  component  along  x 
is  equal  to 


since  x  is  a  component  of  r.  But  r=V#2  +  ?/2  +  22  >  so 


and  similarly  for  the  two  other  component  forces.  Comparing  (3.3) 
and  (2.7),  we  see  that  in  the  given  case 

I/ =  —  y.  (3.4) 

WTe  note  that  the  potential  energy  U  is  chosen  here  in  such  a  way 
that  U  (oo)  =  0  when  the  particles  are  separated  by  an  infinite  distance. 
The  choice  of  the  arbitrary  constant  in  the  potential  energy  is  called 
its  gauge.  In  this  case  it  is  convenient  to  choose  this  constant  so  that 
the  potential  energy  tends  to  zero  at  infinity. 

It  is  obvious  that  an  expression  similar  to  (3.4)  is  obtained  for 
two  electrically  charged  particles  interacting  in  accordance  with 
Coulomb's  law. 

Spherical  coordinates.  Formula  (3.4)  suggests  that  in  this  instance 
it  is  best  to  choose  precisely  r  as  a  generalized  coordinate.  In  other 
words,  we  must  transform  from  Cartesian  to  spherical  coordinates. 
The  relationship  between  Cartesian  and  spherical  coordinates  is 


Sec.  3] 


EXAMPLES   OF   LAGRANGE'S   EQUATIONS 


shown  in  Fig.  1.  The  z-axis  is  called  the  polar  axis  of  the  spherical 
coordinate  system.  The  angle  &  between  the  radius  vector  and  the 
polar  axis  is  called  the  polar  angle;  it  is  complementary  (to  90°) 
to  the  "latitude."  Finally,  the  angle  9  is  analogous  to  the  "longitude" 
and  is  called  the  azimuth.  It  measures  the  dihedral  angle  between 
the  plane  zOx  and  the  plane  passing  through  the  polar  axis  and  the 
given  point. 

Let  us  find  the  formulae  for  the  transformation  from  Cartesian 
to  spherical  coordinates.  From  Fig.  1  it  is  clear  that 

z  =  rcos&.  (3.5) 

The  projection  p  of  the  radius  vector  onto  the  plane  xOy  is 


Whence, 


p=r  sin  <0. 

x  =  p  cos  9  =  r  sin  &  cos  9  , 
y  =  p  sin  9  =r  sin  £  sin  9  . 


(3.6) 

(3.7) 
(3.8) 


We  will  now  find  an  expression  for  the  kinetic  energy  in  spherical 
coordinates.  This  can  be  done  either  by  a  simple  geometrical  con- 
struction or  by  calculation  according  to  the  method  of  Sec.  2. 


Fig.  1 


Although  the  construction  is  simpler,  let  us  first  follow  the  compu- 
tation procedure  in  order  to  illustrate  the  general  method.  We  have  : 


z  =     cos 

x  =  r  sin 

=  r  sin 


—  'r  sn  ft, 
cos  9  +  r  cos 
sin  +  ^  cos 


cos  9 
sin 


r  sn  &  sn  99, 
sin  &  cos  99. 


Squaring  these  equations  and  adding,  we  obtain,  after  very  simple 
manipulations,  the  following: 


26  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

T=  vm(i2  +  y2  +  z2)  =  -T-  (r*  +  r2&2  +  r2sin2£<p2)  .         (3.9) 

2t  & 

The  same  is  clear  from  the  construction  shown  in  Fig.  2.  An  arbitrary 
displacement  of  the  point  can  be  resolved  into  three  mutually  per- 
pendicular displacements:  dr,  rd$  and  pe&p—  r  sin  ^9.  Whence 


sin2  «•  dy*.  (3.10) 

Since  the  square  of  the  velocity  va=h       ,  (3.9)  is  obtained  from 


(3.10)  simply  by  dividing  by  (dt  )2  and  multiplying  by  ~  . 

Hence,  in  spherical  coordinates,  the  Lagrangian  function  is  expressed 
as 

L  =  1"  (r  2  +  r2sin2&cp2  +  r*  &2)  —U(r).  (3.11) 

z 

Now  in  order  to  write  down  Lagrange's  equations  it  is  sufficient  to 
calculate  the  partial  derivatives.  We  have: 

OL  .        dL  on         dL  2   •   2  a  - 

-  —  _  =  mr  ,     —  -  =  mrz  $  ,     —  =  mrz  sin2  -9-  cp  ; 

'dr  V*  d?  T 

ft  L  •      «>  rv     •  9    ,  no  &  U  &  ]  L  o      •       t\  r\     •  9       &  Lt  ~ 

^—  •=•-  mr  sin2  v  ®2  4-  mr  t>2  —  -  .,  —  ,    -^—  =  mr2  sin  fr  cos  9-  cp2  ,  -  -—  —  0  . 

dr  T  c)r          #9-  T       c?9 

These  derivatives  must  be  substituted  into  (2.21),  which,  however, 
we  will  not  now  do  since  the  motion  we  are  considering  actually  reduces 
to  the  plane  case  (see  beginning  of  Sec.  5). 

Two-particle  system.  So  far  we  have  considered  the  centre  of  at- 
traction as  stationary,  which  corresponds  to  the  assumption  of  an 
infinitely  large  mass.  In  the  motion  of  the  earth  around  the  sun,  or 
of  an  electron  in  a  nuclear  field,  the  mass  of  the  centre  of  attraction 
is  indeed  large  compared  with  the  mass  of  the  attracted  particle.  But 
it  may  happen  that  both  masses  are  similar  or  equal  to  each  other  (a 
binary  star,  a  neutron-proton  system,  and  the  like).  We  shall  show 
that  the  problem  of  the  motion  of  two  masses  interacting  only  with 
one  another  can  always  be  easily  reduced  to  a  problem  of  the  motion 
of  a  single  mass. 

Let  the  mass  of  the  first  particle  be  ml  and  of  the  second  ra2.  We 
call  the  radius  vectors  of  these  particles,  drawn  from  an  arbitrary 
origin,  rx  and  r2,  respectively.  The  components  of  rx  are  xl9  yl9  21; 
the  components  of  r2  are  #2,  ?/2,  z2.  We  now  define  the  radius  vector  of 
the  centre  of  mass  of  these  particles  B  by  the  following  formula: 

j          2  v         ' 

Synonymous  terms  for  the  "centre  of  mass"  are  the  "centre  of  gravity" 
and  the  "centre  of  inertia." 


Sec.  3]  EXAMPLES   OF   LAGRANGE's   EQUATIONS  27 

In  addition,  let  us  introduce  the  radius  vector  of  the  relative  position 
of  the  particles 

r  =  r1—  r2  (3.13) 

Let  us  now  express  the  kinetic  energy  in  terms  of  B  and  r.  From 
(3.12)  and  (3.13)  we  'have 

(3.14) 

v         ' 

r2=R  --         -.  (3.15) 

2  --  v         ' 

The  kinetic  energy  is  equal  to 


Differentiating  (3.14)  and  (3.15)  with  respect  to  time  and  substi- 
tuting in  (3.16),  we  obtain,  after  a  simple  rearrangement, 


y  =      l         2      2  t     z  _  .2  (3  17) 

2  ^    2  (ml  +  m2)  \   •      / 

Tf  we  introduce  the  Cartesian  components  of  the  vectors  R  (X,  Y,  Z) 
and  r  (x,  y,  z),  then  we  obtain  an  expression  for  the  kinetic  energy 
in  terms  of  Cartesian  components  of  velocity. 

Since  no  external  forces  act  on  the  particles,  the  potential  energy 
can  be  a  function  only  of  their  relative  positions:  U=U(x,y,z). 
Thus,  the  Lagrangian  is 


Transition  to  the  centre-of-mass  system.  Let  us  write  down  La- 
grange's  equations  for  the  coordinates  of  the  centre  of  mass.  We  have 


Hence,  in  accordance  with  (2.21) 

X=Y=Z  =  0. 
These  equations  can  be  easily  integrated: 

X  =  XQt  +  X0,     Y=Y0t+Y0,    Z=Z0t+ZQ,         (3.18) 

where  the  letters  with  the  index  0  signify  the  corresponding  values 
at  the  initial  time. 


28  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Combining  the  coordinate  equations  into  one  vector  equation,  we 
obtain 


Thus,  the  centre  of  mass  moves  uniformly  in  a  straight  line  quite 
independently  of  the  relative  motion  of  the  particles. 

Reduced  mass.  If  wo  now  write  down  Lagrange's  equations  for 
relative  motion  in  accordance  with  (2.21)  the  coordinates  of  the 
centre  of  mass  do  not  appear.  It  follows  that  the  relative  motion 
occurs  as  if  it  were  in  accordance  with  the  Lagrangian 


(where  r2  =  i2  +  ?/2  +  z2),  formed  in  exactly  the   same  way  as   the 
Lagrangian  for  a  single  mass  m  equal  to 

(3.20) 


. 
rn1  -f-  w2 

This  mass  is  called  the  reduced  mass. 

The  motion  of  the  centre  of  mass  does  not  affect  the  relative  motion 
of  the  masses.  In  particular,  we  can  consider,  simply,  that  the  centre 
of  mass  lies  at  the  coordinate  origin  R  =  0. 

In  the  case  of  central  forces  (for  example,  Newtonian  forces  of  attrac- 
tion) acting  between  the  particles,  the  potential  energy  is  simply 
equal  to  U  (r)  [this  is  taken  into  consideration  in  (3.10)],  where 


f  z2.  Then,  if  we  describe  the  relative  motion  in  spherical 
coordinates,  the  equations  of  motion  will  have  the  same  form  as  for 
a  single  particle  moving  relative  to  a  fixed  centre  of  attraction. 

The  centre  of  mass  can  now  be  considered  as  fixed,  assuming  R  =  0. 
From  this,  in  accordance  with  (3.14)  and  (3.15),  we  obtain  the  distance 
of  both  masses  from  the  centre  of  mass: 


__  B       t  _ 

1       t      --         '        2 


x  -f- 


We  see  that  if  one  mass  is  much  smaller  than  the  other,  w2  <^  ml9 
then  rl  <^r2,  i.e.,  the  centre  of  mass  is  close  to  the  larger  mass.  This 
is  the  case  for  a  sun-planet  system.  At  the  same  time  the  reduced 
mass  can  also  be  written  thus: 


From  here  it  can  be  seen  that  it  is  close  to  the  smaller  mass.  That  is 
why  the  motion  of  the  earth  around  the  sun  can  be  approximately 
described  as  if  the  sun  were  stationary  and  the  earth  revolved  about  it 
with  its  own  value  of  mass,  independent  of  the  mass  of  the  sun. 


Sec.  3] 


EXAMPLES    OF   LAGRANGE'S    EQUATIONS 


29 


Simple  and  compound  pendulums.  In  concluding  this  section  we 
shall  derive  the  Lagrangian  for  simple  and  compound  pendulums. 

The  simple  plane  pendulum  is  a  mass  suspended  on  a  flat  hinge  at 
a  certain  point  of  a  weightless  rod  of  length  Z.  The  hinge  restricts  the 
swing  of  the  pendulum.  Let  us  assume  that  swinging  occurs  in  the 
plane  of  the  paper  (Fig.  3).  It  is  clear  that  such  a  pend- 
ulum has  only  one  degree  of  freedom.  We  can  take 
the  angle  of  deflection  of  the  pendulum  from  the  ver- 
tical 9  as  a  generalized  coordinate.  Obviously  the  veloc- 
ity of  particle  m  is  equal  to  /<p,  so  that  the   kinetic 
energy  is 

m m  j2  .  2 

77?*r- 

The  potential  energy  is  determined  by  the  height  of 
the  mass  above  the  mean  position  z-— /  (1 — cos  9).          -pi<r  3 
Whence,  the  Lagrangian  for  the  pendulum  is 

L  =  ~-l*y*  —  mgl(l  —  coa<p).  (3.22) 

A  double  pendulum  can  be  described  in  the  following  way:  in  mass 
m  there  is  another  hinge  from  which  another  pendulum,  which  is 
forced  to  oscillate  in  the  same  plane  (Fig.  4),  is  suspended.  Let  the 
mass  and  length  of  the  second  pendulum  be  ml  and  Zx, 
respectively,  and  its  angle  of  deflection  from  the  verti- 
cal, i.  The  coordinates  of  the  second  particle  are 

Xi  =  I  sin  9  +  Zt  sin  <J> , 
zl  =  l  (1 — cos  9)  +  ^  (1  — cos  <L) . 
Whence  we  obtain  its  velocity  components: 

Zj  =  /  sin  9  9  +  Zj_  sin  Ad> . 

Squaring  and  adding  them  we  express  the  kinetic  energy 

of  the  second  particle  in  terms  of  the  generalized  coordinates  9,  <|;  and 

the  generalize^  velocities  9,  <L : 


Tl  = 


2  Ul  cos  (9  — 


The  potential  energy  of  the  second  particle  is  determined  in  terms  of 
zt.  Finally,  we  get  an  expression  of  the  Lagrangian  for  a  double  pen- 
dulum in  the  following  form: 


T 
L  = 


m  -\- 


m, 


i  cos  (9  —  <]>)  9  fy  — 


—  (m 


—  0039)  — 


(3.23) 


30 


MECHANICS 


[Part  I 


All  the  formulae  for  the  Lagrangian  functions  (3.11),  (3.22),  and 
(3.23)  will  be  required  in  the  sections  that  follow. 

Exercises 

1)  Writo  down  Lagrango's  equation  for  an  elastically  suspended  pendulum. 

J/t 

For  such  a  pendulum,  the  potential  energy  of  an  elastic  force  is  U  —  —  (Z  —  Z0)2, 

2* 

whore  J0  is  the  equivalent  length  of  the  unstretched  rod  and  k  is  a  constant, 
characteristic  of  its  elasticity. 

2)  Writo  down  the  kinetic;  energy  for  a  system  of  three  particles  with  masses 
mt,  w2,  and  m3  in  the  form  of  a  sum  of  the  kinetic  energy  of  the  centre  of  mass 
and  the  kinetic  energy  of  relative  motion,  using  the  following  relative  coordi- 
nates : 


Sec.  4.  Conservation  Laws 

The  problem  of  mechanics.  If  a  mechanical  system  has  v  degrees 
of  freedom,  then  its  motion  is  described  by  v  Lagrangian  equations. 
Each  of  these  equations  is  of  the  second  order  with  respect  to  the  time 
derivatives  q  [see  (2.17)].  From  general  theorems  of  analysis  we 
conclude  that  after  integration  of  this  system  we  obtain  2  v  arbitrary 
constants.  The  solution  can  be  represented  in  the  following  form: 


(4.1) 


Differentiating  these  equations  with  respect  to  time,   we  obtain 
expressions  for  the  velocities: 


(4.2) 


Let  us  assume  that  equations  (4.1)  and  (4.2)  are  solved  with  respect 
to  the  constants  C^,  .  .  .  ,  C^v,  so  that  these  values  are  expressed  in 
terms  of  t  and  qlf  .  .  .,  gv,  qv  .  .  .,qv. 

Then 


Sec.  4]  CONSERVATION   LAWS  31 

From  the  equations  (4.3)  we  see  that  in  any  mechanical  system 
described  by  2v  second-order  equations  there  must  be  2  v  functions  of 
generalized  coordinates,  velocities,  and  time,  which  remain  constant 
in  the  motion.  These  functions  are  called  integrals  of  motion. 

It  is  the  main  aim  of  mechanics  to  determine  the  integrals  of 
motion. 

If  the  form  of  the  function  (4.3)  is  known  for  a  given  mechanical 
system,  then  its  numerical  value  can  be  determined  from  the  initial 
conditions,  that  is,  according  to  the  given  values  of  generalized 
coordinates  and  velocities  at  the  initial  instant. 

In  the  preceding  section  we  obtained  the  so-called  centre  -of  -mass 
integrals  R0  and  B0  (3.18). 

Naturally,  Lagrange's  equations  cannot  be  integrated  in  general 
form  for  an  arbitrary  mechanical  system.  Therefore  the  problem  of 
determining  the  integrals  of  motion  is  usually  very  complicated.  But 
there  are  certain  important  integrals  of  motion  which  are  given  directly 
by  the  form  of  the  Lagrangian.  We  shall  consider  these  integrals  in 
the  present  section. 

Energy.  The  quantity 


is  called  the  total  energy  of  a  system.  Let  us  calculate  its  total  deriv- 
ative with  respect  to  time. 
We  have 


___      ___          ___ 

~dt~  -    a  ~0$7        «  ~dt  "0  "fcT  ~J~q^"~  "FfcT  «  ~  ~di"  ' 

The  last  three  terms  on  the  right-hand  side  are  the  derivatives  of  the 
Lagrangian  L,  which,  in  the  general  form,  depend  on  g,  q  and  t. 
In  determining  $  and  its  derivative  we  have  made  use  of  the  sum- 

7       f\  T 

mation  convention.   The   quantity  ^-  -  .—  in  Lagrange's  equations 

*\   -r 

can  be  replaced  by  -=  —  .  The  result  is,  therefore, 

uC[y. 

dff  8L 

-dr=—w  <4-5> 

Consequently,  if  the  Lagrangian  does  not  depend  explicitly  on  time 

(O   T  \ 

~7j—  =  01  ,  the  energy  is  an  integral  of  motion.  Let  us  find  the  con- 

ditions for  which  time  does  not  appear  explicitly  in  the  Lagrangian. 

If  the  formulae  expressing  the  generalized  coordinates  q  in  terms  of 

Cartesian  coordinates  x  do  not  contain  time  explicitly  (which  corre- 


*  a  is  summed  from  1  to  v  (see  Sen.  2). 


32  MECHANICS  [Part  1 

spends  to  constant,  time-independent  constraints)  then  the  transfor- 
mation from  x  to  q  cannot  introduce  time  into  the  Lagrangian. 

O    TT 

Besides,  in  order  that  -7--  —  0 ,  the  external  forces  must  also  be 

G  t 

independent  of  time.  When  these  two  conditions — constant  constraints 
and  constant  external  forces — are  fulfilled,  the  energy  is  an  integral 
of  motion.  To  take  a  particular  case,  when  no  external  forces  act 
on  the  system  its  energy  is  conserved.  Such  a  system  is  called  closed. 

When  frictioiial  forces  act  inside  a  closed  system,  the  energy  of 
macroscopic  motion  is  transformed  into  the  energy  of  molecular 
microscopic  motion.  The  total  energy  is  conserved  in  this  case,  too, 
though  the  Lagrangian,  which  involves  only  the  generalized  coordi- 
nates of  macroscopic  motion  of  the  system,  no  longer  gives  a  complete 
description  of  the  motion  of  the  system.  The  mechanical  energy  of 
only  macroscopic  motion,  determined  by  means  of  such  a  Lagrangian, 
is  not  an  integral.  We  will  not  consider  such  a  system  in  this  section. 

Let  us  now  consider  the  case  when  our  definition  of  energy  (4.4) 
coincides  with  another  definition,  $=T+U.  Let  the  kinetic  energy 
be  a  homogeneous  quadratic  function  of  generalized  velocities,  as 
expressed  in  equation  (2.13).  For  this  it  is  necessary  that  the  con- 
straints should  not  involve  time  explicitly,  otherwise  equation  (2.5) 
would  have  the  form 


where  the  partial  derivative  of  the  function  (2.2)  with  respect  to  time 
is  taken  for  all  constants  #«.  But  then  terms  containing  qa  in  the  first 
degree  would  appear  in  the  expression  for  T. 

Since  we  assume  that  the  potential  energy  U  does  not  depend  on 
velocity  [see  (2.18)  and  (2.19)],  then 

8L         BT 
and  the  energy  is 

JP          2*  T  I  4    £±\ 

6—<ta-Q-q ^>  •  (4.6) 

But  according  to  Euler's  theorem,  the  sum  of  partial  derivatives  of  a 
homogeneous  quadratic  function,  multiplied  by  the  corresponding 
variables,  is  equal  to  twice  the  value  of  the  function  (this  can  easily 
be  verified  from  the  function  of  two  variables  ax2 +  2  bxy  +  cy2). 
Thus, 


that  is,  the  total  energy  is  equal  to  the  sum  of  the  potential  energy 

and  the  kinetic  energy,  in  agreement  with  the  elementary  definition. 

We  note  that  the  definition  (4.4)  is  more  useful  and  general  also 

in  the  case  when  the  Lagrangian  is  not  represented  as  the  difference 


Sec.  4]  CONSERVATION   LAWS  33 

L—T  —  U.  Thus,   in  electrodynamics   (Sec.  15)  L  contains  a  linear 
term  in  velocity.  For  the  energy  integral  to  exist,  only  one  condition 

is  necessary  and  sufficient  :  -^~-  =  0  (if,  of  course,  there  are  no  friction- 

al  forces). 

The  application  of  the  energy  integral  to  systems  with  one  degree 
of  freedom.  The  energy  integral  allows  us,  straightway,  to  reduce 
problems  of  the  motion  of  systems  with  one  degree  of  freedom  to  those 
of  quadrature.  Thus,  in  the  pendulum  problem  considered  in  the 
previous  section  we  can,  with  the  aid  of  (4.7),  write  down  the  energy 
integral  directly: 

_  cos  9)  m  (4  S) 


The  value  £  is  determinable  from  the  initial  conditions.  For  example, 
let  the  pendulum  initially  be  deflected  at  an  angle  cp0  and  released 
without  any  initial  speed.  It  follows  that  (p0  —  0.  Whence 


1—  cos  90).  (4.0) 

Substituting  this  in  (4.8),  we  have 


From  this,  the  relationship  between  the  deflection  angle  and  time 
is  determined  by  the  quadrature 

—— — —  9 —  .  (4.11) 

\/cos  <p  —  cos  90 

Tt  is  essential  that  the  law  governing  the  oscillation  of  a  pendulum 
depend  only  on  the  value  of  the  ratio  l/g  and  is  independent  of  the 
mass.  The  integral  in  (4.11)  cannot  be  evaluated  in  terms  of  elementary 
functions. 

A  system  in  which  mechanical  energy  is  conserved  is  sometimes 
called  a  conservative  system.  Thus,  the  energy  integral  permits  reducing 
to  quadrature  the  problem  of  the  motion  of  a  conservative  system 
with  one  degree  of  freedom. 

Tn  a  system  with  several  degrees  of  freedom  the  energy  integral 
allows  us  to  reduce  the  order  of  the  system  of  differential  equations 
and,  in  this  way,  to  simplify  the  problem  of  integration. 

Generalized  momentum.  We  shall  now  consider  other  integrals  of 
motion  which  can  be  found  directly  with  the  aid  of  the  Lagrangian. 
To  do  this  we  shall  take  advantage  of  the  following,  quite  obvious, 
consequence  of  Lagrange's  equations.  If  some  coordinate  </a  does  not 

appear   explicitly   in   the  Lagrangian  (-^-  =0),  then  in  accordance 

\  09*        I 
with  Lagrange's  equations 


34  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

44^-  =  0-  (4.12) 

dt    dqa  v          ' 

But  then 

r\   7" 

pa  S3  —  -  -  =  const,  (4-13) 

i.e.,  it  is  an  integral  of  motion.  The  quantity  pa  is  called  the  generalized 
momentum  corresponding  to  a  generalized  coordinate  with  index  a. 
This  definition  includes  the  momentum  in  Cartesian  coordinates: 

pL    "I- 

px=zmvx  =  ~  —  .  Summarizing,  if  a  certain  generalized  coordinate  does 

vVx 

not  appear  explicitly  in  the  Lagrangian,  the  generalized  momentum 
corresponding  to  it  is  an  integral  of  motion,  i.e.,  it  remains  constant 
for  the  motion. 

In  the  preceding  section  we  saw  that  the  coordinates  X,  F,  Z  of 
the  centre  of  gravity  of  a  system  of  two  particles,  not  subject  to  the 
action  of  external  forces,  do  not  appear  in  the  Lagrangian.  From  this 
it  is  evidentthat 


Z  =  Pz  (4.14) 

are  constants  of  motion. 

The  momentum  of  a  system  of  particles.  The  same  thing  is  readily 
shown  also  for  a  system  of  N  particles.  Indeed,  for  N  particles  we  can 
introduce  the  concept  of  the  centre  of  mass  and  the  velocity  of  the 
centre  of  mass  by  means  of  the  equations: 


(4.15a) 


(4.15b) 


JTm; 

i 
The  velocity  of  the  ith  mass  relative  to  the  centre  of  mass  is 

r/  =  rr-R  (4.16) 

(by  the  theorem  of  the  addition  of  velocities).  The  kinetic  energy  of 
the  system  of  particles  is 

N  N 

T  =  ~  JTwn  if  =  |2>,  (  V  +  R)2  = 

f-i  ;~i 

N  N  N 

=  y^wi*/1  +  B  2>;r;'  +  y2><*a-  (4.17) 

l-l  i-l  .'-1 


Sec.  4]  CONSERVATION  LAWS  35 

However,  from  (4.15b)  and  (4.16)  it  can  immediately  bo  seen  that 

N 

JTraif/^O,  by  the  definition  of  r,'  and  R.  Therefore,  the  kinetic 

»  =  i 

energy  of  a  system  of  particles  can  be  divided  into  a  sum  of  two  terms : 

the  kinetic  energy  of  motion  of  the  centre  of  mass 


and  the  kinetic  energy  of  motion  of  the  mass  relative  to  the  centre 
of  mass 

N 


The  vectors  f,'  are  not  independent;  as  has  been  shown,  they  are 

N 

governed  by  one  vector  equation J^  w,-r,'  =  0.  Consequently,  they  can 

be  expressed  in  terms  of  an  N- 1  independent  quantity  by  determining 
the  relative  positions  of  the  ith  and  first  masses.  For  this  reason  the 
kinetic  energy  of  N  particles  relative  to  the  centre  of  mass  is,  in  general, 
the  kinetic  energy  of  their  relative  motion,  and  is  expressed  only  in 
terms  of  the  relative  velocities  i^  —  r,.  By  definition,  no  external  forces 
can  act  on  the  masses  in  a  closed  system,  and  the  interaction  forces 
inside  the  system  can  be  determined  only  by  the  relative  positions 
rt— r,. 

Thus,  only  R  appears  in  the  Lagrangian,  and  R  does  not.  Therefore, 
the  overall  momentum  is  conserved: 

ar       (  N     \ 
P  -  ~  =  \£nii  tt  =  const .  (4.18) 

Equality  (4.18),  which  contains  a  derivative  with  respect  to  a  vector, 
should  be  understood  as  an  abbreviated  form  of  three  equations: 

T^  dL  -n          8L          -o          dlj 


For  more  detail  about  vector  derivatives  see  Sec.  11. 

We  have  seen  that  the  overall  momentum  of  a  mechanical  system 
not  subject  to  any  external  force  is  an  integral  of  motion.  It  is  impor- 
tant that  it  is  what  is  known  as  an  additive  integral  of  motion,  i.e., 
it  is  obtained  by  adding  the  momenta  of  separate  particles. 


36  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

It  may  be  noted  that  the  momentum  integral  exists  for  any  system 
in  which  only  internal  forces  are  operative,  even  though  they  may  be 
frictional  forces  causing  a  conversion  of  mechanical  energy  into 
heat. 

If  we  integrate  (4.18)  with  respect  to  time  once  again,  the  result  will 
be  the  centre-of-mass  integral  similar  to  (3.18).  This  will  be  the  so- 
called  second  integral  (for  it  contains  two  constants);  it  contains  only 
coordinates  but  not  velocities.  (3.18)  and  (4.11)  are  also  second 
integrals. 

Properties  of  the  vector  product.  The  angular  momentum  of  a  particle 
is  defined  as 

M-Frp].  (4.19) 

Here  the  brackets  denote  the  vector  product  of  the  radius  vector  of 
the  particle  and  its  momentum.  We  know  that  (4.19)  takes  the  place 
of  three  equations, 

Mx  =  ypz—zpy,     MY  -=  zpx-  ~xpz,     Mz  —  xpy  —  ypx, 

for  the  Cartesian  components  of  the  vector  M. 

Recall  the  geometrical  definition  for  a  vector  product.  We  construct 
a  parallelogram  on  the  vectors  r  and  p.  Then  [rpj  denotes  a  vector 
numerically  equal  to  the  area  of  the  parallelogram  with  direction 
perpendicular  to  its  plane.  In  order  to  specify  the  direction  of  [rp] 
uniquely,  we  must  agree  on  the  way  of  tracing  the  parallelogram  con- 
tour. We  shall  agree  always  to  traverse  the  contour  beginning  with  the 
first  factor  (in  this  case  beginning  with  r).  Then  that  side  of  the  plane 
will  be  considered  positive  for  which  the  direction  is  anticlockwise. 
The  vector  [rp]  is  along  the  normal  to  the  positive  side  of  the  plane. 
In  still  another  way,  if  we  rotate  a  corkscrew  from  r  to  p,  then  it  will 
be  displaced  in  the  direction  of  [rp].  The  direction  of  traverse  changes 
if  we  interchange  the  positions  of  r  and  p.  Therefore,  unlike  a  conven- 
tional product,  the  sign  of  the  vector  product  changes  if  we  inter- 
change the  factors.  This  can  also  be  seen  from  the  definition  of  Carte- 
sian components  of  angular  momentum. 

The  area  of  the  parallelogram  is  rp  sin  a,  where  a  is  the  angle  between 
r  and  p.  The  product  r  sin  a  is  the  length  of  a  perpendicular  drawn 
from  the  origin  of  the  coordinate  system  to  the  tangent  to  the  trajec- 
tory whose  direction  is  the  same  as  p.  This  length  is  sometimes  called 
the  "arm"  of  the  moment. 

The  vector  product  possesses  a  distributive  property,  i.e., 


Hence,  a  binomial  product  is  calculated  in  the  usual  way,  but  the 
order  of  the  factors  is  taken  into  account. 

[a  +  d,  b  +  c]  =  [ab]  +  [ac]  +  [db]  +  [dc]  . 


Sec.  4]  CONSERVATION  LAWS  37 

The  angular  momentum  of  a  particle  system.  The  angular  momentum 
of  a  system  of  particles  is  defined  as  the  sum  of  the  angular  momenta 
of  all  the  particles  taken  separately.  In  doing  so  we  must,  of  course, 
take  the  radius  vectors  related  to  a  coordinate  origin  common  to  all 
the  particles: 

N 


We  shall  show  that  the  angular  momentum  of  a  system  can  be 
separated  into  the  angular  momentum  relative  to  the  motion  of  the 
particles  and  the  angular  momentum  of  the  system  as  a  whole,  similar 
to  the  way  that  it  was  done  for  the  kinetic  energy.  To  do  tin's  Ave  must 
represent  the  radius  vector  of  each  particle  as  the  sum  of  the  radius 
vector  of  its  position  relative  to  the  centre  of  mass  and  the  radius 
vector  of  the  centre  of  mass  ;  we  must  expand  the  expression  for  the 
particle  velocities  in  the  same  way.  Thou,  the  angular  momentum  can 
he  written  in  the  form 

N 


N  N  N  N 


1-1  1=1  »«l  J-l 

111  the  second  and  third  sums,  wo  can  make  use  of  the  distributive 
property  of  a  vector  product  and  introduce  the  summation  sign 
inside  the  product  sign.  However,  both  these  sums  are  equal  to  zero, 
by  definition  of  the  centre  of  mass.  This  was  used  in  (4.17)  for  veloc- 
ities. Thus,  the  angular  momentum  is  indeed  equal  to  the  sum  of  the 
angular  momenta  of  the  centre  of  mass  (M0)  and  the  relative  motion 
(M'): 

M  =  [RP]  +  JTfr'  Pi'J  -  M0  +  M'.  (4.21) 


Let  us  perform  these  transformations  for  the  special  case  of  a 
system  of  two  particles.  We  substitute  rx  and  r2  expressed  [from 
(3.14)  and  (3.15)]  in  terms  of  r  and  R.  This  gives 

M  =  friPil  +  [r2P2]  =  [tt,Pi  +  P2]  +  ( 


Further,  we  replace  ^  by  ml  r1?  p2  by  mz  r2  and  P!+P2  by  P,  after 
which  the  angular  momentum  reduces  to  the  required  form: 


38  MECHANICS  [Part  I 


M  =  [RP]  +  -w^-  [r  r]  =  [RPJ  +  [rp] .  (4.22) 

Here,  "m  ^^    r  =  wr  =  p  is  the  momentum  of  relative  motion. 

We  shall  now  show  that  the  determination  of  angular  momentum 
of  relative  motion  does  not  depend  on  the  choice  of  the  origin.  Indeed, 
if  we  displace  the  origin,  then  all  the  quantities  r/  change  by  the  same 
amount  ri'=r,-"  +  a. 

Accordingly,  angular  momentum  for  relative  motion  will  be 

N  N  N 


N 


because 

N  N 


Thus,  the  determination  of  angular  momentum  for  relative  motion 
does  not  depend  on  the  choice  of  the  origin  of  the  coordinate 
system. 

Conservation  ol  angular  momentum.  We  shall  now  show  that  the 
angular  momentum  of  a  system  of  particles  not  acted  upon  by  any 
external  forces  is  an  integral  of  motion. 

Let  us  begin  with  the  angular  momentum  of  the  system  as  a  whole. 
Its  time  derivative  is  equal  to  zero: 


because  P  =  0  for  any  system  not  acted  upon  by  external  forces,  and 
R  is  in  the  direction  of  P,  so  that  the  vector  product  [RP]  =  0. 

We  shall  now  prove  that  angular  momentum  is  conserved  for 
relative  motion.  The  total  derivative  with  respect  to  time  is 


i  -  1 


Here,  the  first  term  on  the  right-hand  side  is  equal  to  zero  since  r/ 
is  in  the  direction  of  p,'.  We  consider  the  second  term.  Let  us  choose 
the  origin  to  be  coincident  with  any  particle,  for  example,  the  first. 
As  a  result,  M',  as  we  have  already  seen,  does  not  change.  The  potential 
energy  can  only  depend  on  the  differences  rx  —  r2,  rx  —  ra,  .  .  .  ,  ^  —  T&,  .  .  . 


Sec.  4]  CONSERVATION  LAWS  39 

The  other  differences  are  expressed  in  terms  of  these,  for  example, 
Yk — ?I  =  (TI — r/) — (rx — r^).  We  introduce  the  abbreviations. 


p  -rj  t\  -J-T  n  j-j 

Then  the  derivatives-^  —  ,  -^  —  -,  .  .  .  ,  -«  —  .  .  .  will  be  expressed  in  terms 
of  the  variables  px,  .  .  .  ,  pfe  _  i  ,  .  .  .  as  follows  : 


fe-1 

su  su 


Substituting  this  in  (4.23)  we  obtain 


dt    ' 

k~l  /?=»! 


N-1          n      N-l  N-l 


In  this  expression,  only  the  relative  coordinates  px,  ...,PN-I 
remain.  We  shall  now  show  that,  for  a  closed  system,  the  right-hand 
side  is  identically  equal  to  zero.  The  potential  energy  is  a  scalar  function 
of  coordinates.  Hence,  it  can  depend  only  on  the  scalar  arguments 
pfe2>  P/2>  (p/  Pfe)>  totally  irrespective  of  whether  the  initial  expression 
was  a  function  only  of  the  absolute  values  |  r;  —  r*  | ,  or  whether  it 
also  involved  scalar  products  of  the  form  (r» — rk,  r/ — r«).  An  essential 
point  is  that  the  system  is  closed  (in  accordance  with  the  definition, 
see  page  32),  and  the  forces  in  it  are  completely  defined  by  the  relative 
positions  of  the  points  and  by  nothing  else.  Therefore,  the  potential 
energy  depends  only  on  the  quantities  r,- — r*,  and  only  in  scalar 
combinations  (r/ — rfe,  r/ — rrt)  (in  particular,  the  subscripts  i,  I;  k,  n 
can  even  be  the  same;  then  the  scalar  product  becomes  the  square 
of  the  distance  between  the  particles  i,  k). 

To  summarize,  the  potential  energy  U  depends  on  the  following 
arguments: 

u==u  Oi>  P'>  •  •  •>  9k,  •  •  -,  PN-I;  (Pi  P2)>  -  -  •,  (pfep/)]  - 


40  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

In  order  to  save  space  we  will,  in  future,  perform  the  operation  for 
two  vectors,  though  this  operation  can  be  directly  generalized  to  any 
arbitrary  number.  We  obtain 

CJU   __    dU    j)(pf)  dU        fr(plPa) 

~"  "~        ~r  ~  ' 


_£  [V  =    dU  _ 


The  partial  derivatives  of  the  scalar  quantities  pj,  (px  p2)  with  respect 
to  the  vector  arguments  are  in  the  given  case  easily  evaluated.  Thus. 


Each  of  these  equations  is  a  shortened  form  of  three  equations  referring 
to  the  components  (the  components  of  p,  are  &,  TJ/,  &): 


Henco, 


Substituting  (4.25)  into  (4.24)  for  the  case  of  the  two  variables,  we 
obtain 

r/M'  or          .    dU          or          -,      dU          /r  lir          -^        8U 

-ir  =  -  2  [PlpJ  ^.y  -  2  fp2  p2l.  --(W  _  ([Pl  pj  +  [p2  p  J)  ^_p--  . 

But  the  sign  of  a  vector  product  depends  on  the  order  of  the  factors 
[Pi  p2.1  ^  —  T?2  Pi]-  Hence  it  can  also  be  seen  that  [Pl  Pl]  =  —  [Pl  Pl]  =  0 
and  [pspo]^^-  Tlicrefore,  ,  =0,  as  stated. 

The  integral,  like  the  angular  momentum,  can  also  be  formed  when 
the  forces  are  determined  not  only  by  the  relative  position  of  the  par- 
ticles but  also  by  their  relative  velocities.  This  is  the  case,  for  example, 
in  a  system  of  elementary  currents  interacting  in  accordance  with  the 
Biot-Savart  law. 

Additive  integrals  of  motion  for  closed  systems.  We  have  thus  shown 
that  a  closed  system  has  the  following  first  integrals  of  motion: 
energy,  three  components  of  the  momentum  vector  and  three  compo- 
nents of  the  angular-momentum  vector.  Momentum  and  angular 
momentum  are  always  additive,  while  energy  is  additive  only  for  the 
non  interacting  parts  of  a  system. 

All  the  other  integrals  of  motion  are  found  in  a  much  more  compli- 
cated fashion  and  depend  on  the  specific  form  of  the  system  (in  the 
sense  that  one  cannot  give  a  general  rule  for  their  definition). 


SeC.  5]  MOTION    IN    A    CENTIiAL    FIELD  41 

Exorcises 

Describe  the  motion  of  a  point  moving  along  a  cycloid  in  a  gravitational 
field. 

The  equation  of  the  cycloid  in  parametric  form  is 

z  =  —  R  cos  s,     x= 
The  kinetic  energy  of  the  point  is 

T=~  (x2  +  z2)  -  2 

^ 

The  potential  energy  is  U  =  —  rtujR  cos  s. 
The  total-energy  integral  is 

<?  =  2  7ft  ft-  cos2  — -  •  $2  —  mgR  cos  5  =  const  . 

2i 

The  value  $  can  be  determined  on  the  condition  that  the  velocity  £  is  equal 
to  zero  when  the  deflection  is  maximum  s  —  s0;  the  particle  moves  along  the 
cycloid  from  that  position.  Hence, 

<f  =  tug  R  COS  «S'0. 

After  separating  the  variables  and  integrating,  wo  obtain 


—  cos  s0 


Calling  sin  -y  =  u,  wo  rewrite  the  integral  in  the  form : 


arc   sin  - 


In  order  to  find  the  period  of  the  motion,  we  must  take  the  integral  between 
the  limits  — -  MO  and  -\-  UQ  and  double  the  result.  This  corresponds  to  the  oscilla- 
tion of  the  particle  within  the  limits  8=  —  s0  arid  s  =  «v 

Thus  the  total  period  of  oscillation  is  equal  to  4:c  I/  — 

Hence,  as  long  as  the  particle  moves  on  the  cycloid,  the  period  of  its  oscillation 
does  not  depend  on  the  oscillation  amplitude  (Huygens'  cycloidal  pendulum). 
The  period  of  oscillation  of  an  ordinary  pendulufn,  describing  an  arc  of  a  circle, 
is  known,  in  the  general  case,  to  depend  on  the  amplitude  [see  (4.11)]. 

Sec.  5.  Motion  in  a  Central  Field 

The  angular-momentum  integral.  We  shall  now  consider  the  motion 
of  two  bodies  in  a  frame  of  reference  fixed  in  the  centre  of  mass.  If 
the  origin  coincides  with  the  centre  of  mass,  then  R  =  0.  As  was  shown 
in  the  preceding  section,  the  angular  momentum  of  relative  motion 
is  conserved  in  any  closed  system;  specifically,  it  is  also  conserved  in 


42  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

a  system  of  two  particles.  If  the  radius  vector  of  the  relative  position 
of  the  particles  r—  FJ  —  r2,  and  the  momentum  of  relative  motion  is 

( 

'  V         ' 

then  the  angular-momentum  integral  is  reduced  to  the  simple  form  : 

M=[rp]=  const.  (5.2) 

It  follows  that  the  velocity  vector  and  the  relative  position  vector 
all  the  time  remain  perpendicular  to  the  constant  vector  31  ;  in  other 
words,  the  motion  takes  place  in  a  plane  perpendicular  to  M  (Fig.  5). 
When  transforming  to  a  spherical  coordinate 
system,  it  is  advisable  to  choose  the  polar  axis 
along  M.  Then  the  motion  will  take  place  in  the 

plane  xy  or  -9-  =  -"-  ,  sin  £  =  1,  <i>  =  0. 

The  potential  energy  can  depend  only  on  the 
absolute  value  r,  because  this  is  the  only  scalar 
quantity  which  can  be  derived  solely  from  the 
vector  r.  In  accordance  with  (3.9),  the  Lagran- 
gian  for  plane  motion,  with  fr  =  0,  sin  o>  =  l,  is 


L=-TT(r*  +  r*<?*)—U(r)9  (5.3) 

Fig.  5 

where  m  is  the  reduced  mass. 
Angular  momentum  as  a  generalized  momentum.  We  shall  now  show 

Q  •*• 

that  M  z  —  M  is  nothing  other  than  ^p-  ,  i.e.,  the  component  of  angular 

momentum  along  the  polar  axis  is  a  generalized  momentum,  provided 
the  angle  of  rotation  cp  around  that  axis  is  a  generalized  coordinate. 
Indeed,  in  accordance  with  (5.2),  the  angular  momentum  M  is 

M  =  Mz  —  xpy  —  ypx  ~  mr  cos  9  (r  sin  9+7*  cos  99  )  — 

—  mr  sin  9  (r  cos  9  —  r  sin  <py)=mr2  9  (cos2  9  +  sin29)=wr2  9. 

On  the  other  hand,  differentiating  L  with  respect  to  9  we  see  that 

o  y 
P*  =  ~0T  =  ^^  =  MZ  *  (5<4) 

The  expression  for  angular  momentum  in  polar  coordinates  can  also 
be  derived  geometrically  (Fig.  6).  In  unit  time,  the  radius  vector  r 
moves  to  the  position  shown  in  Fig.  6  by  the  dashed  line.  Twice  the 
area  of  the  sector  OAB,  multiplied  by  the  mass  w,  is  by  definition 
equal  to  the  angular  momentum  [cf.  (5.2)].  But,  to  a  first  approxi- 
mation the  area  of  the  sector  is  equal  to  the  product  of  the  modulus 

r  and  -$-  .  The  height  h  is  proportional  to  the  angle  of  rotation  in  unit 


Sec.  5]  MOTION   IN   A   CENTRAL  FIELD  43 

time  and  to  the  radius  itself  so  that  the  area  of  the  sector  is  1/2  r2  9. 
Thus,  a  doubled  area  multiplied  by  the  mass  m  is  indeed  equal  to  the 
angular  momentum. 

The  quantity  1/2  r2  9  is  the  so-called  areal  velocity,  or  the  area 
described  by  the  radius  vector  in  unit  time.  The  law  of  conservation 
of  angular  momentum,  if  interpreted  geometrically, 
expresses  constancy  of  areal  velocity  (Kepler's  Second 
Law). 

The  central  field.  If  one  of  two  masses  is  very  much 
greater  than  the  other,  the  centre  of  mass  coincides  with 
the  larger  mass  (see  Sec.  3).  In  this  case,  the  particle 
with  the  smaller  mass  moves  in  the  given  central  "field  of 
the  heavy  particle.  The  potential  energy  depends  only  on 
the  distance  between  the  particles  and  does  not  depend 
on  the  angle  9.  Then,  in  accordance  with  (4.12),  p^  —  Mz 
is  the  integral  of  motion.  However,  since  one  particle  is 
considered  at  rest,  the  origin  should  be  chosen  coincident 
with  that  particle  and  not  with  some  arbitrary  point,  as 
in  the  case  of  the  relative  motion  of  two  particles.  In 
the  case  of  motion  in  a  central  field,  angular  momentum  is  conserved 
only  relative  to  the  centre. 

Elimination  ol  the  azimuthal  velocity  component.  The  angular- 
momentum  integral  permits  us  to  reduce  the  problem  of  two-particle 
motion,  or  the  problem  of  motion  of  a  single  particle  in  a  central  field, 
to  quadrature.  To  do  this  we  must  express  9  in  terms  of  angular  mo- 
mentum and  thus  get  rid  of  the  superfluous  variable,  in  as  much  the 
angle  9  itself  does  not  appear  in  the  Lagrangian.  Such  variables, 
which  do  not  appear  in  L,  are  termed  cyclic. 

In  accordance  with  (4.7),  we  first  of  all  have  the  energy  integral 

f=~(r*  +  r*i*)+U(r).  (5.5) 

Eliminating  9  with  the  aid  of  (5.4)  we  obtain 

U(r).  (5-6) 


This  first-order  differential  equation  (in  r)  is  later  on  reduced  to 
quadrature.  Before  writing  down  the  quadrature,  let  us  examine  it 
graphically. 

The  dependence  of  the  form  of  the  path  on  the  sign  of  the  energy. 
For  such  an  examination,  we  must  make  certain  assumptions  about 
the  variation  of  potential  energy. 

From  (2.7),  force  is  connected  with  potential  energy  by  the  relation 


44  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

The  upper  limit  in  the  integral  can  be  chosen  arbitrarily.  If  F  (r) 

00 

tends  to  zero  at  infinity  faster  than  —  ,  then  the  integral  I  F  dr   is 

00  f 

convergent.  Then  we  can  put  U  (r)^(  F  dr,  or  £/(oo)—  0.  In  other 


words,  the  potential  energy  is  considered  zero  at  infinity.  The  choice 
of  an  arbitrary  constant  in  the  expression  for  potential  energy  is  called 
its  yawje. 

In  addition  we  shall  consider  that  at  r~0,  U  (r)  does  not  tend  to 

infinity  more  rapidly  than     - ,  as,  for  example,  for  Newtonian  attrac- 

oo 

, .        fT  I*  (t     ,  tt 

turn  U      ---      „  dr-  ---  . 

J  rz  r 

r 

Let  us  now  write  (5.6)  as 


The  left-hand  side  of  this  equation  is  essentially  positive.  For  /-=oo 
the  last  two  terms  in  (5.7)  tend  to  zero.  Thus,  for  the  particles  to  be 
able  to  recede,  from  each  other  an  infinite  distance,  the  total  energy 
must  be  positive  when  the  gauge  of  the  potential  energy  satisfies 
f7(oo)=0. 
Given  a  definite  form  of  U,  we  can  now7  plot  the  curve  of  the  function 


The  index  M  in  U  denotes  that  the  potential  energy  includes  the 

I/2 
"centrifugal"  energy    ./   ^r.  The  derivative  of  this   quantity  with 

Af2 
respect  to  r,  taken  with  the  opposite  sign,  is  equal  to  ""—£-.  If  we  put 

M  ~  wra  9,  the  result  will  be  the  usual  expression  for  "centrifugal 
force."  However,  henceforth,  we  will  call  a  mechanical  quantity  of 
different  origin  the  "centrifugal  force"  (see  Sec.  8).  Let  U  <()  and 
monotonic.  Since  U  (oo)  =  0,  we  see  that  U  (r)  is  an  increasing  function 

of  r.  It  follows  that  the  force  has  a  negative  sign  (since  F  —  —  4—1  , 
i.e.,  it  is  an  attractive  force.  Let  us  assume,  in  addition,  that  at  infinity 
I  W  ('*)  !  >  V  M,2~*  Let  us  summarize  the  assumptions  that  we  have 

made  concerning  UM  (r): 

1)  U\t(r)  is  positively  infinite  at  zero,  where  the  centrifugal  term 
is  predominant. 

2)  at  infinity,  where  U  (r)  predominates,  UM  (r)  tends  to  zero  from 
a  negative  direction. 


Sec.  5]  MOTION   IN   A   CENTRAL  FIELD  45 

Consequently,  the  curve  UM  (r)  has  the  form  shown  in  Fig.  7, 
since  we  must  go  through  a  minimum  in  order  to  pass  from  a  decrease 
for  small  values  of  r  to  an  increase  at  large  values  of  r.* 

In  this  figure  we  can  also  plot  the  total  energy  6\  But  since  the  total 
energy  is  conserved,  the  curve  of  $  must  have  the  form  of  a  horizontal 
straight  line  lying  above  or  below  the  abscissa,  depending  on  the  sign 
of  6. 

For  positive  values  of  energy,  the  line  <?  =  const  lies  above  the  curve 
UM  (r)  everywhere  to  the  right  of  point  A .  Hence  the  difference 
$ — UM(T)  to  the  right  of  A  is  positive. 
The  particles  can  approach  each  other 
from  infinity  and  recede  from  each  other 
to  infinity.  Such  motion  is  termed  infinite. 
As  we  will  see  later  in  this  section,  in  the 
case  of  Newtonian  attraction,  we  obtain 
hyperbolic  orbits. 

For  <5"<0,  but  higher  than  the  mini- 
mum of  the  curve   UM  (r),  the  difference 

&* —  UM  (r),  i.e.,  ^—  ,     remains     positive 

only  between  the  points  B  and  B'  (finite 

motion).  Thus,  between  these    values  of 

the    radius    there    is    included    a  physi-  Fig.  7 

cally  possible  region  of  motion,  to  which 

there     correspond    elliptical     orbits     in    the     case    of    Newtonian 

attraction.  In  the  case  of  planetary  motion  around  the  sun,  point  B 

is  called  the  perihelion  and  point  B1  the  aphelion. 

For  «?  =  ()  the  motion  is  infinite  (parabolic  motion). 

If  U  (/•)>(>,  which  corresponds  to  repulsion,  the  curve  UM(T)  does 
not  possess  a  minimum.  Then  finite  motion  is  clearly  impossible. 

Falling  towards  the  centre.  For  Newtonian  attraction,  U  (0)  tends 
to  infinity  like  — 1/r.  If  we  suppose  that  U  (0)  tends  to  — oo  more 
rapidly  than  — 1/r2,  then  the  curve  UM(^)  is  negative  for  all  r  close 
to  zero.  Then,  from  (5.7),  f 2  is  positive  for  infinitesimal  values  of  r 
and  tends  to  infinity  when  r  tends  to  zero.  If  r  <  0  initially,  then  r 
does  not  change  sign  and  the  particles  now  begin  to  move  towards 
collision.  In  Newtonian  attraction  this  is  possible  only  when  the 
particles  are  directed  towards  each  other;  then  "the  arm"  of  the 
angular  momentum  is  equal  to  zero  and,  hence,  the  angular  momentum 
itself  is  obviously  equal  to  zero,  too,  so  that  UM  (r)  =  U  (r).  If  an 
initial  "arm"  exists  within  the  distance  of  minimum  approach,  then 


M2 
*  Ff  I  U  (r)  |  <  — 2"  at  infinity,  then  the   curve  approaches  zero  on    the 

positive  side,  and  there  can  bo  a  further  small  maximum  after  the  minimum. 
This  form  of  UM  (r)  applies  to  the  atoms  of  elements  with  medium  and  large 
atomic  weights. 


46  MECHANICS  [Part  I 


the  angular  momentum  M  =  mvp  ^  0  (p  is  the  "arm")  and  the  motion 
can  in  no  way  become  radial. 

In  the  case  of  Newtonian  or  Coulomb  attraction  for  a  particle  with 
angular  momentum  not  equal  to  zero,  there  always  exists  a  distance 

M2 
r0'for  which-  —  r  becomes  greater  than  $  —  U  (r0).  This  distance 

determines  the  perihelion  for  the  approaching  particles. 

However,  if  U  (r)  tends  to  infinity  more  rapidly  than  --  ^  then, 

as  r->0,  there  will  be  no  point  at  which  UM  (r)  becomes  zero.  In  place 
of  a  hyperbolic  orbit,  as  in  the  case  of  Newtonian  attraction,  a  spiral 
curve  leading  to  one  particle  falling  on  the  other  results.  The  turns 
of  the  spiral  diminish,  but  the  speed  of  rotation  increases  so  that  the 
angular  momentum  is  conserved,  as  it  should  be  in  any  central  field. 
But  the  "centrifugal"  repulsive  force  turns  out  to  be  less  than  the 
forces  of  attraction,  and  the  particles  approach  each  other  indef- 
initely. 

Of  course,  the  result  is  the  same  if  the  energy  is  negative  (for  example, 
part  of  the  energy  is  transferred  to  some  third  particle,  which  then 
recedes).  In  the  case  of  attractive  forces  increasing  more  rapidly  than 
1/r3,  no  counterpart  to  elliptical  orbits  exists. 

If  three  bodies  in  motion  are  subject  to  Newtonian  attraction,  two 
of  them  may  collide  even  if,  initially,  the  motion  of  these  particles 
was  not  purely  radial.  Indeed,  in  the  case  of  three  bodies,  only  the 
total  angular  momentum  is  conserved,  and  this  does  not  exclude  the 
collision  of  two  particles. 

Reducing  to  quadrature.  Let  us  now  find  the  equation  of  the  tra- 
jectory in  general  form.  To  do  this  we  must,  in  (5.6),  change  from 
differentiation  with  respect  to  time  to  differentiation  with  respect  to  9. 
Using  (5.4)  we  have 

dt  =  lj£-d<p.  (5.9) 

Separating  the  variables  and  passing  to  9  in  (5.6)  gives 

M  dr 


9  = 


Here,  the  lower  limit  of  the  integral  corresponds  to  9  =  0.  If  we  cal- 
culate 9  with  respect  to  the  perihelion,  then  the  corresponding  value 
r  =  r0  can  be  easily  found  by  noting  that  the  radial  component  of 
velocity  r  changes  sign  at  perihelion  (r  has  a  minimum,  and  so  dr  =  0). 
From  this  we  find  the  equation  for  the  particle  distance  at  perihelion : 

*=•?£* +UM-  <6-n> 


Sec.  5]  MOTION  IN   A   CENTRAL  FIELD  47 

Kepler's  problem.  Thus,  the  problem  of  motion  in  a  central  field 
is  reduced  to  quadrature.  The  fact  that  the  integral  sometimes  cannot 
be  solved  in  terms  of  elementary  functions  is  no  longer  so  essential. 
Indeed,  the  solution  of  the  problem  in  terms  of  definite  integrals 
contains  all  the  initial  data  explicitly;  if  these  data  are  known,  the 
integration  can  be  performed  in  some  way  or  other. 

But,  naturally,  if  the  integral  is  expressed  in  the  form  of  a  well-known 
function,  the  solution  can  be  more  easily  examined  in  the  general 
form.  In  this  sense  an  explicit  solution  is  of  particular  interest. 

Such  a  solution  can  be  found  in  only  a  few  cases.  One  of  these  is 
the  case  of  a  central  force  diminishing  inversely  as  the  square  of 
distance.  The  forces  of  Newtonian  attraction  between  point  masses 
(or  bodies  possessing  spherical  symmetry)  are  subject  to  this 
law. 

It  will  be  recalled  that  the  laws  of  motion  in  this  case  were  found 
empirically  by  Kepler  before  Newton  deduced  them  from  the  equations 
of  mechanics  and  the  law  of  gravitation.  It  was  the  agreement  of 
Newton's  results  with  Kepler's  laws  that  was  the  first  verification  of 
the  truth  of  Newtonian  mechanics.  The  problem  of  the  motion  of  a 
particle  in  a  field  of  force  diminishing  inversely  with  the  square  of  the 
distance  from  some  fixed  point,  is  called  Kepler's  problem.  The  prob- 
lem of  the  motion  of  two  bodies  with  arbitrary  masses  always  reduces 
to  the  problem  of  a  single  body  when  passing  to  a  frame  of  reference 
fixed  in  the  centre  of  mass. 

The  expression  "Kepler's  problem"  can  also  be  applied  to  Coulomb 
forces  acting  between  point  charges.  These  can  either  be  forces  of 

attraction  or  repulsion.  In  all  cases  we  shall  write  U  =  — ,  where  a  <  0 
for  attractive  forces  and  a>0  for  repulsive  forces. 

If  we  replace in  (5.10)  by  a  new  variable  x,  the  integral  in  the 

Kepler  problem  is  reduced  to  the  form 


rr4-  — 
dx  +   M 


.        2a 

___    ffi  ._   _    /J»    „  I 

X  + 


—  =  arc  cos 


„  _  , 

M  m  M* 


-—  — 
]     a* 

If   , 

V  M* 


M 

x  ~  -  — 
mr 

M 
x  = 


At  the  lower  limit,  the  expression  inside  the  arc  cos  sign  is  equal 
to  unity  [as  will  be  seen  from  (5.11)],  since  the  lower  limit  was  chosen 
on  the  condition  that  dr  =  0.  But  arc  cos  1—0.  Rearranging  the  result 
of  integration  and  reverting  to  r,  we  obtain,  after  simple  manipu- 
lations, 

M* 

r  = «*»  .  (6J2) 

.    ,    M  ]     a*     ,     2^  V         ' 

—  1  H tf -5TrT  H COS  <p 

a     V   M2         m 


48  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

(5.12)  represents  the  standard  equation  for  a  conic  section,  the 

eccentricity  being  equal  to  I/ 1  4  \2     .  As  long  as  this  expression 

is  less  than  unity,  the  denominator  in  (5.12)  cannot  become  zero, 
because  cos  cp<  1.  But  this  is  true  for "  <$<().  Thus,  when 

<^<0,  the  result  is  elliptical  orbits.  For  this  it  is  necessary  that  a<0, 
i.e.,  that  there  be  an  attraction,  otherwise  (5.12)  would  lead  to  r<0, 
which  is  senseless. 

For  ff  >  0  the  eccentricity  is  greater  than  unity  and  the  denominator 
in  (5.12)  becomes  zero  for  a  certain  9  =  900.  Thus,  the  orbit  goes  to 
infinity  (a  hyperbola).  The  direction  of  the  asymptote  is  obtained  by 

putting  r  =00  in  (5. 12).  This  requires  that  cos  900  —  -»*-  •     — . 

•M-     I/  a2        2<^ 

V  ~M*  +  ~w~ 

The  angle  between  the  asymptotes  is  equal  to  2  900,  when  the  particles 
repel  each  other,  and  to  2  (7^—900),  when  the  particles  attract.  An 
example  of  a  trajectory,  when  the  forces  are  repulsive,  is  shown  in 
Fig.  8,  Sec.  6. 

Exercise 

ar2 

Obtain  iho  equation,  of  the  trajectory  when  U  =  — —  $  >  0. 

2 

See.  6.  Collision  of  Particles 

The  significance  of  collision  problems.  In  order  to  determine  the 
forces  acting  between  particles,  it  is  necessary  to  study  the  motion  of 
particles  caused  by  these  forces.  Thus,  Newton's  gravitational  law 
was  established  with  the  aid  of  Kepler's  laws.  Here,  the  forces  were 
determined  from  iinite  motion.  However,  infinite  motion  can  also  be 
used  if  one  particle  can,  in  some  way,  be  accelerated  to  a  definite 
velocity  and  then  made  to  pass  close  to  another  particle.  Such  a  process 
is  termed  4 'collision"  of  particles.  It  is  not  at  all  assumed,  however, 
that  the  particles  actually  come  into  contact  in  the  sense  of  "collision" 
in  everyday  life. 

And  neither  is  it  necessary  that  the  incident  particle  should  be 
artificially  accelerated  in  a  machine:  it  may  be  obtained  in  ejection 
from  a  radioactive  nucleus,  or  as  the  result  of  a  nuclear  reaction,  or 
it  may  be  a  fast  particle  in  cosmic  radiation. 

Two  approaches  are  possible  to  problems  on  particle  collisions. 
Firstly,  it  may  be  only  the  velocities  of  the  particles  long  before  the 
collision  (before  they  begin  to  interact)  that  are  given,  and  the  problem 
is  to  determine  only  their  velocities  (magnitude  and  direction)  after 
they  have  ceased  to  interact.  In  other  words,  only  the  result  of  the 
collision  is  obtained  without  a  detailed  examination  of  the  process. 
In  this  case,  some  knowledge  of  the  final  state  must  be  available  (or 


Sec.  6]  COLLISION    OF   P  ARTICLES  49 

specified)  beforehand:  it  is  not  possible  to  determine,  from  the  initial 
velocities  alone,  all  the  integrals  of  motion  which  characterize  the 
collision,  and,  hence,  it  is  likewise  impossible  to  predict  the  final  state. 
With  this  approach  to  collision  problems,  only  the  momentum  and 
energy  integrals  are  known. 

However,  another  approach  is  possible :  it  is  required  to  precalculate 
the  final  state  where  the  precise  initial  state  is  given. 

Let  us  first  consider  collisions  by  the  first  method.  It  is  clear  that 
if  only  the  initial  velocities  of  the  particles  are  known,  the  collision  is 
not  completely  determined:  it  is  not  known  at  what  distance  the  par- 
ticles were  when  they  passed  each  other.  This  is  why  some  quantity 
relating  to  the  final  state  of  the  system  must  be  given.  Usually  the 
problem  is  stated  as  follows :  the  initial  velocities  of  the  colliding  par- 
ticles and  also  the  direction  of  velocity  of  one  of  them  after  the  colli- 
sion are  specified.  It  is  required  to  determine  all  the  remaining  quanti- 
ties after  the  collision.  In  such  a  form  the  problem  is  solved  uniquely. 
Six  quantities  are  unknown,  namely  the  six  momentum  components 
of  both  particles  after  the  collision.  The  conservation  laws  provide 
four  equalities:  conservation  of  the  scalar  quantity  (energy)  and 
conservation  of  the  three  components  of  the  vector  quantity  (momen- 
tum). Therefore,  with  six  unknowns,  it  is  necessary  to  specify  two 
quantities  which  refer  to  the  final  state.  They  are  contained  in  the 
determination  of  the  unit  vector  which  specifies  the  direction  of  the 
velocity  of  one  of  the  particles ;  an  arbitrary  vector  is  defined  by  three 
quantities,  but  a  unit  vector,  obviously,  only  by  two.  Actually, 
only  the  angle  of  deflection  of  the  particles  after  the  collision  need  be 
given,  i.e.,  the  angle  which  the  velocity  of  the  particle  makes  with 
the  initial  direction  of  the  incident  particle.  The  orientation  (in 
space)  of  the  plane  passing  through  both  velocity  vectors  is  im- 
material. 

Elastic  and  inelastic  collisions.  A  collision  is  termed  elastic,  if  the 
initial  kinetic  energy  is  conserved  when  the  particles  separate  after 
the  collision  at  infinity,  and  inelastic,  if,  as  a  result  of  the  collision, 
the  kinetic  energy  changes  at  infinity.  In  nuclear  physics,  studies  are 
very  often  made  of  collisions  of  a  more  general  character,  in  which  the 
nature  of  the  colliding  particles  changes.  These  collisions  are  also 
inelastic.  They  are  called  nuclear  reactions. 

The  laboratory  and  centre-o!-mass  frames  of  reference.  When  colli- 
sions are  studied  in  the  laboratory,  one  of  the  particles  is  usually  at 
rest  prior  to  collision.  The  frame  of  reference  fixed  in  this  particle  (and 
in  the  laboratory)  is  termed  the  laboratory  frame.  However,  it  is  more 
convenient  to  perform  calculations  in  a  frame  of  reference,  relative 
to  which  the  centre  of  mass  of  both  particles  is  at  rest.  In  accordance 
with  the  law  of  conservation  of  the  centre  of  mass  (3.18),  it  will  also 
be  at  rest  in  its  own  frame  after  the  collision.  The  velocity  of  the 
centre  of  mass,  relative  to  the  laboratory  frame  of  reference,  is 


60  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

(6.1) 
v       ' 

Here  V0  is  the  velocity  of  the  first  particle  (of  mass  m^  relative  to  the 
second  (with  mass  m2).  In  so  far  as  the  second  particle  is  at  rest  in 
the  laboratory  system,  v0  is  also  the  velocity  of  the  first  particle  relative 
to  this  system. 

The  general  case  of  an  inelastic  collision.  The  velocity  of  the  first 
particle  relative  to  the  centre  of  mass  is,  according  to  the  law  of 
addition  of  velocities,  equal  to 

(6.2) 
v 

and  in  the  same  system,  the  velocity  of  the  second  particle  is 

(6.3) 


Thus,  mx  V10  +  m2  V2o  =  0,  as  it  should  be  in  the  centre-of-mass 
system. 

In  accordance  with  (3.17),  the  energy  in  the  centre-of-mass  system  is 

(6-4) 


Here,  the  reduced  mass  is  indicated  by  a  zero  subscript,  since  in  nuclear 
reactions  it  may  change. 

Let  the  masses  of  the  particles  obtained  as  a  result  of  the  reaction 
be  ws  and  ra4,  and  the  energy  absorbed  or  emitted  Q  (the  so-called 
"heat"  of  the  reaction).  If  Q  is  the  energy  released  in  radiation,  then, 
strictly  speaking,  one  should  take  into  account  the  radiated  momen- 
tum (see  Sec.  13).  But  it  is  negligibly  small  in  comparison  with  the 
momenta  of  nuclear  particles. 

Thus,  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy  must  be  written  in  the  follow- 
ing form: 

-=£+«--=£-.  (6.5) 

Here,  m  =  -  ~-^  —  is  the  reduced  mass  of  the  particles  produced  in 

^3  *T~  ^4 

the  nuclear  reaction,  and  v  is  their  relative  velocity. 

In  order  to  specify  the  collision  completely,  we  will  consider  that 
the  direction  of  v  is  known,  since  the  value  of  v  is  determined  from 
(6.5).  Then  the  velocity  of  each  particle  separately  will  be 


They  satisfy  the  requirement  mz  V30+w4  v40  =  0,  i.e.,  the  law  of 
conservation  of  momentum  in  the  centre-of-mass  system,  and  give 
the  necessary  value  for  the  kinetic  energy 


Sec.  6]  COLLISION   OF   PABTICLES  51 


Now,  it  is  not  difficult  to  revert  to  the  laboratory  frame  of  reference. 
The  velocities  of  the  particles  in  this  system  will  be 


V  -  ___ 
Y 


Equations  (6.7)  give  a  complete  solution  to  the  problem  provided 
the  direction  of  v  is  given. 

Elastic  collisions.  The  computations  are  simplified  if  the  collision  is 
elastic,  for  then  mz  =  mi,  w4  =  w2>  Q  =  0.  It  follows  from  (6.5)  that 
the  relative  velocity  changes  only  in  direction  and  not  in  magnitude. 
Let  us  suppose  that  its  angle  of  deflection  x  is  given.  We  take  the  axis 
Ox  along  v0,  and  let  the  axis  Oy  lie  in  the  plane  of  the  vectors  v  and  v0 
(which  are  equal  in  magnitude  in  the  case  of  elastic  collisions).  Then 

VX  =  VQ  COS  X,         Vy  =  VQ  SHI  X  • 

From  (6.6),  the  components  of  particle  velocity  in  the  centre-of-mass 
system  will,  after  collision,  be  correspondingly  equal  to 


..       _ 

i       20y 

Since  the  velocity  of  the  centre  of  mass  is  in  the  direction  of  the  axis 
Ox,  we  obtain,  from  (6.7),  the  equations  for  the  velocities  in  the 
laboratory  frame  of  reference: 

xjtjo  m2v0sinx 

Viy  ~  V"v  ~  -m~+m~  ' 

_         _         m,v0sinx 

""         -  ~ 


-  -          114  +  tn,          J  2y 

By  means  of  these  equations,  the  deflection  angle  6  of  the  first 
particle  in  the  case  of  collision  in  the  laboratory  system  can  be  related 
to  the  angle  x»  (i-  e.,  its  deflection  angle  in  a  centre-of-mass  system): 

(6.8) 


The  "recoil"  angle  of  the  second  particle  0'  is  defined  as 

v0y  sin  x  4.  X 

-~^-T-COSX~CO  y  (69) 

6'  —   -_-* 
2         2  ' 


52  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

The  minus  sign  in  the  definition  of  tg  0'  is  chosen  because  the  signs 
of  vlY  and  v2y  are  opposite. 

The  case  of  equal  masses.  Equation  (6.8)  becomes  still  simpler  if  the 
masses  of  the  colliding  particles  are  equal.  This  is  approximately  true 
in  the  case  of  a  collision  between  a  neutron  and  proton.  Then,  from 
(6.8). 

tan  6---  tan  --,        0---> 


i.e.,  the  particles  fly  off  at  right  angles  and  the  deflection  angle  of  the 
neutron  in  the  laboratory  system  is  equal  to  half  the  deflection  angle 
in  the  ceritre-of-mass  system.  Since  the  latter  varies  from  0  to  180°, 
0  cannot  exceed  90°.  And,  in  addition,  the  velocity  of  the  incident 
particle  is  plotted  as  the  "resultant"  velocity  of  the  diverging  particles. 
The  collision  of  billiard  balls  resembles  the  collision  considered  here 
of  particles  of  equal  mass,  provided  that  the  rotation  of  the  balls 
about  their  axes  is  neglected. 

The  energy  transferred  in  an  elastic  collision.  The  energy  received 
by  the  second  particle  in  a  collision  is 

JP  __  mzml  (l---cosx)  vj 


(mi +  "!,)• 

Its  portion,  relative  to  the  initial  energy  of  the  first  particle,  is 
<?2  __  2mtw2  (1  —  cos/) 


\2 


(6.10) 


&  7 

From  this  we  obtain  ~~  =  sin2  —•  =sin20  for  particles  of  equal 

0  . 

mass.  Accordingly,  the  portion  of  the  energy  retained  by  the  first 


particle  is  -      ==cos2  0.  In  a  "head-on"  collision  x^18()0,  0-90°. 

0Q 

The  first  particle  comes  to  rest  and  the  second  continues  to  move 
forward  with  the  same  velocity.  This  can  easily  be  seen  when  billiard 
balls  collide. 

The  problem  of  scattering.  Let  us  now  examine  the  problem  of  colli- 
sion in  more  detail.  We  shall  confine  ourselves  to  the  case  of  elastic 
collision  and  perform  the  calculations  in  the  centre-of-mass  system. 
The  transformation  to  the  laboratory  system  by  equations  (6.7)  is 
elementary. 

It  is  obvious  that  for  a  complete  solution  of  the  collision  problem, 
one  must  know  the  potential  energy  of  interaction  between  the  par- 
ticles U  (r)  and  specify  the  initial  conditions,  so  that  all  the  integrals 
of  motion  may  be  determined.  The  angular-momentum  integral  is 
found  in  the  following  way.  Fig.  8.  which  refers  to  repulsive  forces, 


Sec.  6]  COLLISION   OF   PARTICLES  53 

represents  the  motion  of  the  first  particle  relative  to  the  second. 
The  path  at  an  infinite  distance  is  linear,  because  no  forces  act  between 
the  particles  at  infinity.  Since  the  path  is  linear  at  infinity,  it  possesses 
asymptotes.  The  asymptote  for  the  part  of  the  trajectory  over  which 
the  particles  are  approaching  is  represented 
by  the  straight  line  Al\  and  FB  is  the 
asymptote  for  the  part  where  they  recede. 
The  collision  parameter.  The  distance  of 
an  asymptote  from  the  straight  line  OG, 
drawn  through  the  second  point  and  parallel 
to  the  relative  velocity  of  the  particles  at 
infinity,  is  called  the  collision  parameter 
f'aimmg  distance").  It  has  been  denoted 
by  p,  since,  as  can  be  seen  from  Fig.  8,  p  Ls 
also  the  "arm"  of  the  angular  momentum. 
If  there  were  110  interaction  between  the  particles,  they  would  pass 
each  other  at  a  distance  p  ;  this  is  why  p  is  called  the  collision  parameter. 
But  we  know  that  the  angular  momentum  is  very  simply  expressed 
in  terms  of  p.  In  the  preceding  section  it  was  shown  that  it  is  equal 
to  ravp.  Let  us  draw  the  radius  vector  OA  to  some  very  distant  point  A. 
Then  the  angular  momentum  is 

M  =  mvr  sin  a 
(the  angle  a  is  shown  on  the  diagram).  But  rsina  =  p,  so  that 

(6.11) 


Recall  that  here  ra  is  the  reduced  mass  of  the  particles  and  v  is  their 
relative  velocity  at  infinity. 

The  energy  integral  is  expressed  in  terms  of  the  velocity  at  infinity 
thus  : 


since  U  (oo)  =  0. 

The  deflection  angle.  The  deflection  angle  x  is  equal  to  |  re  —  29  ,,  |  , 
where  9CJ  is  half  the  angle  between  the  asymptotes.  The  angle  9  0 
corresponds  to  a  rotation  of  the  radius  vector  from  the  position  OA, 
where  it  is  infinite,  to  a  position  OF,  where  it  is  a  minimum.  Hence, 
from  equation  (5.10)  the  angle  900  is  expressed  as 


oo 

•/• 


M  dr  ,„  1Qv 

*n7aT  "Tr^f-T7"  --TrrT7o  =-"---  v     >  (Q.Lt) 


r0  is  determined  from  (5.11).  In  place  of  M  and  $  we  must  substitute 
into  (6.13)  the  expressions  (6.11)  and  (6.12). 


54 


MECHANICS 


[Part  I 


The  differential  effective  scattering  cross-section.  Let  us  suppose 
that  the  integral  (6.13)  lias  been  calculated.  Then  9^,  and  therefore  x> 
are  known  as  functions  of  the  collision  parameter  p.  Let  this  relation- 
ship be  inverted,  i.e.,  p  is  determined  as  a  function  of  the  deflection 
angle  : 

P  =  P(X)«  (6-14) 

In  collision  experiments,  the  collision  parameter  is  never  defined 
in  practice;  a  parallel  beam  of  scattering  particles  is  directed  with 
identical  velocity  at  some  kind  of  substance,  the  atoms  or  nuclei 
of  which  are  scatterers.  The  distribution  of  particles  as  to  deflection 
angles  x  (or>  more  exactly,  as  to  angles  0  in  the  laboratory  system) 
is  observed.  Thus  a  scattering  experiment  is,  as  it  were,  performed 
very  many  times  one  after  the  other  with  the  widest  range  of  aiming 
distances. 

Let  one  particle  pass  through  a  square  centimetre  of  surface 
of  the  scattering  substance.  Then,  in  an  anuulus  contained  between 
p  and  p-Mp,  there  pass  2?rp  dp  particles.  We  classify  the  collisions 
according  to  the  aiming  distances,  similar  to  the  way  that  it  is  done 
on  a  shooting  target  with  the  aid  of  a  concentric  system  of  rings. 
If  p  is  known  in  relation  to  x>  then  it  may  be  stated  that  dcr=  2;rp  dp  = 

=  27rp~—  dx  particles  will  be    deflected  at  the  angle  between  x 


and 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  scattered  particles  are  in  some  way  detected 
at  a  large  distance  from  the  scattering  medium.  Then  the  whole 
scatterer  can  be  considered  as  a  point  and  we  can  say  that  after 
scattering  the  particles  move  in  straight  lines 
from  a  common  centre.  Let  us  consider  those 
particles  which  occupy  the  space  between 
two  cones  that  have  the  same  apex  and  a 
common  axis  ;  the  half  -angle  of  the  inner  cone 
is  equal  to  x>  and  the  external  cone  x  +  ^X- 
The  space  between  the  two  cones  is  called  a 
solid  angle,  similar  to  the  way  that  the  plane 
contained  between  two  straight  lines  is  called 
a  plane  angle.  The  measure  of  a  plane  angle  is 
the  arc  of  a  circle  of  unit  radius  drawn  about 
the  vertex  of  the  angle,  while  the  measure 

of  a  solid  angle  is  the  area  of  a  sphere  of  unit  radius  drawn  about  the 
centre  of  the  cone.  An  elementary  solid  angle  is  shown,  in  Fig.  9  as 
that  part  of  the  surface  of  a  sphere  covered  by  an  element  of  arc  r/x 
when  it  is  rotated  about  the  radius  OC.  Since  OC=\y  the  radius 
of  rotation  of  the  element  dx  is  equal  to  sin  x-  Therefore,  the  surface 
of  the  sphere  which  it  covers  is  equal  to  2rc  sin  xdx*  Thus,  the  elemen- 
tary solid  angle  is 


Fig.  9 


Sec.  6]  COLLISION   OF  PARTICLES  55 


(6.15) 

The  number  of  particles  scattered  in  the  element  of  solid  angle  is, 
thus, 

da==p*£.J*<L.  (6.16) 

^  dx  sinx  V         ' 

The  quantity  da  has  the  dimensions  of  area.  It  is  the  area  in  which 
a  particle  must  fall  in  order  to  be  scattered  within  the  solid-angle 
element  d£l.  It  is  called  the  effective  differential  scattering  cross-section 
in  the  element  of  solid  angle  dQ. 

Experimentally  we  determine  just  this  value,  because  it  is  the 
angular  distribution  of  the  scattered  particles  that  is  dealt  with 
[in  (6.16)  we  consider  that  p  is  given  in  relation  to  xl-  If  there  are  n 
scatterers  in  unit  volume  of  the  scattering  substance,  then  the  attenu- 
ation of  the  primary  beam  J  in  passing  through  unit  thickness  of 
the  substance,  due  to  scattering  in  an  elementary  solid  angle  dii,  is 

d  Jn  =  —  Jndc=  —  Jnp  ~  —.  —  particles/cm. 

If  we  examine  da  as  a  function  of  x,  we  find  a  relationship  between 
the  collision  parameter  and  the  deflection  angle.  And  this  allows 
us  to  draw  certain  conclusions  about  the  nature  of  the  forces  acting 
between  the  particle  and  the  scattering  centre. 

Rutherford's-  formula.  A  marvellous  example  of  the  determination 
of  forces  from  the  scattering  law  is  given  by  the  classical  experiments 
of  Rutherford  with  alpha  particles.  As  was  pointed  out  in  Sec.  3, 
the  Coulomb  potential  acting  on  particles  decreases  with  distance 

according  to  a  —  law,  in  the  same  way  as  the  Newtonian  potential. 

Consequently,  the  deflection  angle  can  be  calculated  from  the  equations 
of  Sec.  5.  Let  us  first  of  all  find  the  angle  <pco.  It  can  be  determined 
from  equation  (5.12)  by  putting  r  =  oo,  a  >  0  (the  charges  on  the  nucleus 
and  alpha  particle  are  like  charges).  Hence, 


The  integrals  of  motion  S  and  M  are  determined  with  the  aid  of 
(6.11)  and  (6.12).  We  therefore  have 

(6.18) 


I  since  9  =  -*-  —  -f  I  .  We  now  form  the  equation  for  the  effective  di 

ential   scattering   cross-section  in   the   centre-of-mass   svstear  wt 
the  aid  of  (6.16): 


66  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

«*£..  (6.19) 


If  the  scattering  nucleus  is  not  too  light,  this  equation,  to  a  good 
approximation,  also  holds  in  the  laboratory  system. 

Thus,  the  number  of  particles  scattered  in  the  elementary  solid 
angle  d£l  =  2n  sin  x  ^X>  *s  inversely  proportional  to  the  fourth  power 
of  the  sine  of  the  deflection  half-angle.  This  law  is  uniquely  related 
to  the  Coulomb  nature  of  the  forces  between  the  particles. 

Studying  the  scattering  of  alpha  particles  by  atoms,  Rutherford 
showed  that  the  law  (6.19)  is  true  for  angles  up  to  y,  corresponding 
to  collision  parameters  less  than  10~12  cm.  It  was  thus  experimentally 
proved  that  the  whole  mass  of  the  atom  is  concentrated  in  an  ex- 
ceedingly small  region  (recall  that  the  sixe  of  an  atom  is  ^lO"8  cm.). 
Thus,  experiments  on  the  scattering  of  alpha  particles  led  to  the 
discovery  of  the  atomic  nucleus  and  to  an  estimation  of  the  order 
of  magnitude  of  its  dimensions. 

Isotropic  scattering.  As  may  be  seen  from  equation  (6.19),  the 
scattering  has  a  pronounced  maximum  for  small  deflection  angles. 
This  maximum  relates  to  large  aiming  distances  since  particles  passing 
each  other  at  these  distances  are  weakly  deflected,  while  large  distances 
predominate  since  they  dciiiie  a  larger  area.  Thus,  if  the  interaction 
force  between  the  particles  does  not  identically  convert  to  zero  at 
a  finite  distance,  then,  for  small  deflection  angles,  the  expression 
for  c/a  will  always  have  a  maximum.  This  maximum  is  the  more 
pronounced,  the  more  rapidly  the  interaction  force  decreases  with 
distance,  for  in  the  case  of  a  rapidly  diminishing  force,  large  aiming 
distances  correspond  to  very  small  deflection  angles. 

However,  particles  that  are  very  little  deflected  can  in  no  way 
be  detected  experimentally  as  deflected  particles.  Indeed,  the  initial 
beam  cannot  be  made  ideally  parallel.  For  this  reason,  when  investi- 
gating a  scattered  beam,  one  must  always  neglect  those  angles  which 
are  comparable  with  the  angular  deviation  of  the  particles  in  the 
initial  beam  from  ideal  parallelism. 

For  a  sufficiently  rapid  attenuation  of  force  with  distance,  the  region 
of  the  maximum  of  da  in  relation  to  the  angle  %  can  refer  to  such 
small  angles  that  the  particles  travelling  within  these  angles  will 
not  be  distinguished  as  being  scattered  because  of  their  small  deflection 
angles.  On  the  other  hand,  the  remaining  particles  will  be  the  more 
uniformly  distributed  as  to  scattering  angle,  the  more  rapidly  the 
forces  fall  off  with  distance. 

This  can  be  seen  in  the  example  of  particles  scattered  by  an  im- 
permeable sphere  (Exercise  1).  Such  a  sphere  may  be  regarded  as 
the  limiting  case  of  a  force  centre  repulsing  particles  according  to 

the  law  UJir)  =  U0  1—  J  ;  when  n  tends  to  infinity  :  if  r  <  r0,  then  U  (r)->oo, 


Sec.  7]  SMALL   OSCILLATIONS  57 

and  if  r  >r0,  then  U  (r)->0.  When  n==  oo  the  scattering  is  completely 
isotropic.  If  n  is  large,  the  angular  distribution  of  the  particle  is 
almost  isotropic,  and  only  for  very  small  deflection  angles  has  the 
distribution  a  sharp  maximum.  Hence,  a  scattering  law  that  is  almost 
isotropic  indicates  a  rapid  diminution  of  force  with  distance. 

The  scattering  of  neutrons  by  protons  in  the  centre-of-mass  system 
is  isotropic  up  to  energy  values  greater  than  10  Mev  (1  Mev  equals 
1.6  x  10~6  erg).  An  analysis  of  the  effective  cross  -section  shows  that 
nuclear  forces  are  short-range  forces;  they  are  very  great  at  close 
distances  and  rapidly  diminish  to  zero  at  distances  larger  than 
2  x  10~13  cm.  It  must  be  mentioned,  however,  that  a  correct  investi- 
gation of  this  case  is  only  possible  on  the  basis  of  the  quantum  theory 
of  scattering  (Sec.  37). 

Exercises 

1)  Find  tho  differential  effective  scattering  cross  -section  for  particles  by 
an  impermeable  sphere  of  radius  r0. 

The  impermeable  sphere  can  be  represented  by  giving  tho  potential  energy 
in  tho  form  U  (r)  =  0  for  r  >  r0  (outside  the  sphere)  and  U  (r)^oo  for  r<  r0 
(inside  tho  sphere).  Then,  whatever  tho  kinetic  energy  of  tho  particle,  penetra- 
tion into  the  region  r  <rQ  is  impossible. 

In  reflection  from  the  sphere,  the  tangential  component  of  momentum  is 
conserved  and  the  normal  component  changes  sign.  Tho  absolute  value  of  the 
momentum  is  conserved  since  tho  scattering  is  elastic.  A  simple  construction 
shows  m  that  the  collision  parameter  is  related  to  the  deflection  angle  by 

p  «  r0  cos  —  , 
if  p  <  rQ.  Hence  the  general  equation  gives 


so  that  the  scattering  occurs  isotropically  for  all  angles.  Tho  total  effective 
scattering  cross-section  a  is  equal,  in  this  case,  to  7cr02,  as  expected.  Note  that 
if  the  interaction  converted  to  zero  not  at  a  finite  distance  but  at  infinity,  the 
total  scattering  cross-section  would  tend  to  infinity  since  to  any  arbitrarily 
large  approach  distance  p  there  would  correspond  a  certain  deflection  angle, 

and  the  integral       2  :rp  dp  diverges.  In  the   quantum    theory    of  scattering, 

a  is  also  finite  when  the  forces  diminish  fast  enough  with  distance. 

2)  Tho  collision  of  particles  with  masses  ml  and  ra2  is  considered  (the  mass 
of  the  incident  particle  is  mj.  As  a  result  of  the  collision,  particles  with  the 
same  masses  are  obtained  whose  paths  make  certain  angles  9  and  >\>  with  the 
initial  flight  direction  of  the  particle  of  mass  m±.  Determine  the  energy  Q 
which  is  absorbed  or  emitted  in  the  collision. 

See.  7.  Small  Oscillations 

In  applications  of  mechanics,  we  very  often  meet  a  special  form 
of  motion  known  as  small  oscillations.  We  devote  a  separate  section 
to  the  theory  of  small  oscillations. 


58 


MECHANICS 


[Part  I 


The  definition  of  small  oscillations  of  a  pendulum.  In  the  problem 
of  pendulum  oscillations  in  Sec.  4  it  was  shown  that  the  equation 
relating  the  deflection  angle  9  to  time  led,  in  the  general  case,  to 
a  nonelementary  (elliptical)  integral  (4.11).  A  simple  graphical  in- 

vestigation shows  that  the  function  9  (t)  is 
periodic.  Fig.  10  shows  the  curve  U  (<p)=mgl 
(1  —  cos  9),  which  gives  the  relationship  be- 
tween potential  energy  and  deflection  angle. 
The  horizontal  straight  line  corresponds  to 
a  certain  constant  value  of  S.  If  $  <  2  mgl, 
the  motion  occurs  periodically  with  time 
between  the  points  —  90  and  90. 

The  problem  is  greatly  simplified  if 
90^!*  i-e->  ^e  angle  90  is  small  in  com- 
parison with  a  radian.  Then  cos  90  can 

be  replaced  by  the  expansion  1  —  -?"-.  Since  |9|<90»  cos  9  can  also 

be  replaced  by  1  --  —-.  After  this  the  integral  (4.11)  can  be  easily 
evaluated  : 


lo 


1/J     f        rf9  I 

=  —  V—      •—.—---    =-=11— 

r  9    J       >    -    2        '  ^ 


9 
arc  cos  —  . 


(7.1) 


<Po 


Inverting  relation  (7.1),  we  get  the  angle  as  a  function  of  time 

*.  (7.2) 

The  result  is  a  periodic  function.  As  can  be  seen  from  (7.2),  the 
period  9  is  equal  to  2n  J/—  .  The  quantity  I/™  is  called  the  frequency 


of  oscillation 


(7.3) 


This  quantity  gives  the  number  of  radians  by  which  the  argument 
of  the  cosine  in  (7.2)  changes  in  one  second.  Sometimes  the  term 
frequency  denotes  a  quantity  that  is  2  re  times  less  and  equal  to  the 
number  of  oscillations  performed  by  the  pendulum  in  one  second. 

The  inverse  value  -^- ,  is  the  period  of  small  oscillations  of  the  pen- 
dulum. An  important  point  is  that  the  period  and  the  frequency 
of  small  oscillations  do  not  depend  on  the  amplitude  of  oscillation  90. 
The  general  problem  of  small  oscillations  with  one  degree  of  freedom. 
In  order  to  solve  the  small-oscillation  problem,  we  need  not,  initially, 
reduce  to  quadrature  the  problem  of  arbitrary  oscillations;  we  can 
first  perform  an  appropriate  simplification  of  the  Lagrangian. 


Sec.  7]  SMALL    OSCILLATIONS  59 

First  of  all,  we  note  that  any  oscillations,  both  large  and  small,  always 
occur  about  a  position  of  equilibrium.  Thus,  a  pendulum  oscillates 
about  a  vertical.  On  deflection  from  the  position  of  stable  equilibrium, 
a  restoring  force  acts  on  the  system  in  the  opposite  direction  to  the 
deflection.  In  the  equilibrium  position,  this  force  obviously  becomes 
zero  (by  definition  of  the  "equilibrium"  concept). 

Force  is  equal  to  the  derivative  of  potential  energy  with  respect 
to  the  coordinate  taken  with  opposite  sign.  The  equilibrium  condition 
written  in  terms  of  this  derivative  is 


Let  us  denote  the  solution  of  this  equation  by  q  =  q0-  We  assume, 
initially,  that  the  system  has  only  one  degree  of  freedom  and  expand  U 
in  a  Taylor  series  in  the  vicinity  of  the  point  qQ: 

U(q)-U  (q0)  +    °         (q-q0)  +  ±?         (g-j.)'  +  .  .  .    (7.5) 


The  linear  term  relative  to  q  —  q0  vanishes  in  accordance  with  (7.4). 
We  denote  (-0-5-  )  ^J  the  letter  (3.  Then,  confining  ourselves  to  these 
terms  of  the  series,  we  obtain 

U(<D-^U(q»)  +  -t(q-q0)*.  (7.6) 

The  force  near  the  equilibrium  position  is 

F  to)  =  ~  *dT  =  —  P  to  —  ?o)  -  (7.7) 

For  this  force  to  be  a  restoring  force  (i.e.,  for  it  to  act  in  the  direction 
opposite   to    the   deflection),    the   following   inequality   must    hold: 


This  is  the  stability  condition  for  the  equilibrium  ;  the  function  U  (q) 
must  increase  on  both  sides  of  the  point  q=qQ,  It  follows  that  the 
potential  energy  at  that  point  must  be  a  minimum.  This  is  shown 
in  Fig.  10  at  9  =  0. 

Let  us  now  examine  the  expression  for  kinetic  energy.  If,  in  the 
general  formula  for  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  particle, 


we  put  x  =  x(q),  y  =  y(q),  z  =  z(q),  then  T  reduces  to  the  form 


. 
+(dq 


60  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

The  quantity  in  the  brackets  depends  only  on  </;  and  so  the  kinetic 
energy  of  a  particle  can  be  represented  in  the  form 

T=  J-a(?)j».  (7.9) 

Let  us  now  expand  the  coefficient  a  (q)  in  a  series,  in  terms  of 
q~  qQf  in  the  vicinity  of  the  equilibrium  position: 


In  order  that  the  particle  should  not  move  far  from  the  equilibrium 
position,  its  velocity  must  be  small.  In  other  words,  the  zero  member 

of  the  kinetic  energy  expansion  -t>-  a  (ql})  q2  is  already  of  the  same  order 
of  smallness  for  small  oscillations  as  tho  second  term  in  the  expansion 

Q 

of  U  ((/),  i.e.,  ^-(q  —  </0)2  .  When  q^q0  all  the  energy  of  oscillation 

is  kinetic,  while  for  maximum  deflection  all  the  energy  is  potential. 

i  A 

Therefore  ^  a  (q0)  q*  and      (q  —  <?0)2  are  of  the  same  order  of  magnitude, 

and  the  remaining  terms  in  the  series   [including  those  containing 
(q  —  f/0)</2]  can  be  neglected.  We  shall  show  that  the  mean  values 

of  both  the  quantities  .^a  (</0)  q2  and  |   (q  —  qQ)2  are  the  same  after 

we  determine  q  as  an  explicit  function  of  time. 

In  future,  the  coordinate  q  will  be  measured  from  the  equilibrium 
position,  i.e.,  we  shall  put  </0=^0.  Then  [omitting  U  (0),  which  does 
riot  affect  the  equations  of  motion]  the  Lagrangian  can  be  written 
in  the  following  form: 


Thus,  Lagraiige's  equation  will  be  written  as 

oc(0)§  +  pgr  =  0.  (7.11) 

Denoting 


w    -   a(0)  a(0)       '  v>>i"' 

we  reduce  (7.12)  to  the  general  form  for  the  oscillation  equation: 

>2g  =  0.  (7.13) 


Various  forms  for  the  solutions  of  small-oscillation  problems.  The 

general   solution   of  this   equation,    which   contains   two   arbitrary 
constants,  may  be  written  in  one  of  three  forms: 


Sec.  7]  SMALL   OSCILLATIONS  61 


q  =  Cl  cos  co  t  +  C»  sin  co£,  (7.14a) 

g  =  (7cos(co£  +  y),  (7.14b) 

7  =  Re{C"cfwl}.  (7.14c) 

The  symbol  Ke{}  signifies  the  real  part  of  the  expression  inside  the 
braces.  The  constant  C"  inside  the  braces  is  complex:  C'  =  Cl  —  iC2. 
The  constants  are  chosen  in  accordance  with  the  initial  conditions. 
The  constant  y  is  called  the  initial  phase,  and  C  is  the  amplitude. 
If  we  are  only  interested  in  the  frequency  of  small  oscillations, 
and  not  the  phase  or  amplitude,  it  is  sufficient  to  use  equation  (7.12), 

verifying  that  the  second  derivative  I  V-a-1    is  positive. 

A  system  which  is  described  by  equation  (7.13)  is  called  a  linear 
harmonic  oscillator. 

It  can  be  seen  from  equations  (7.10),  (7.12),  and  (7.14b)  that  the 
averages  of  the  potential  energy  and  kinetic  energy  of  the  oscillator 
during  one  period  are  the  same  because  the  averages  of  the  squares 
of  a  sine  or  cosine  are  equal  to  one  half: 


sin*  (<o*  +  Y)  -          sin2  (a*  +  y)  dt  =  -     ;    cos*  (at  +  y)  = 


Small  oscillations  with  two  degrees  of  freedom.  We  shall  now  con- 
sider oscillations  with  several  degrees  of  freedom.  As  an  example, 
Jet  us  first  take  the  double  pendulum  of  Sec.  3.  If  we  confine  ourselves 
to  small  oscillations,  we  must  consider  that  the  deflections  9  and  <p 
are  close  to  zero,  (i.e.,  the  pendulum  is  close  to  a  vertical  position). 
Then,  by  substituting  the  equilibrium  values  of  the  coordinates 
9  and  <];,  cos  (9  —  ^)  in  the  kinetic  energy  must  be  replaced  by  cos  0  =  1 
as  in  the  problem  of  oscillations  with  one  degree  of  freedom  where 
cos  9  and  cos  <L,  in  the  expression  for  potential  energy,  must  be  re- 

2  t  2 

placed  by  1  --  |-  and  1  --  ^-  .  Then  the  Lagrangian  will  have  the  form 


L  =  ,  V  +      L  Hy  +  mMty  _  _  i.  lg(?2  _  ^ 

(7.15) 
Let  us  examine  this  in  a  somewhat  more  general  form: 

U  (0)  — 


62  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Here,  the  coefficients  an,  a12,  and  a22  are  assumed  to  be  constant 
numbers  expressed  in  terms  of  the  equilibrium  values  gx  and  q2. 
Comparing  (7.15)  and  (7.16),  we  find  that  in  the  problem  of  the  double 
pendulum 

an  =  (m  +  raj)  I2  ,      a12  =  mlll1,     a22  =  ml  l\  ; 


In  the  general  case,  the  coefficients  pn.  p12  and  (322  are  expressed 
by  the  equations 


where  the  derivatives  are  also  taken  in  the  equilibrium  positions. 
For  the  equilibrium  to  be  stable,  we  must  demand  that  the  following 
inequality  be  satisfied: 

^(?)—  ^(0)  =  Y(Pii«J  +  2p12?lgt  +  paag;)>0.          (7.17) 

Under  this  condition,  U  has  a  minimum  at  the  point  ^  =  0,  q^  =  0. 
Let  us  rewrite  the  left-hand  side  of  (7.17)  in  identical  form 


This  expression  remains  positive  for  all  values  of  ql  and  q2,  provided 
the  coefficients  of  both  quadratics  in  q  are  greater  than  zero: 

Pn>0,  (7.18) 

(7.19) 


In  future,  we  shall  consider  that  the  conditions  (7.18)  and  (7.19), 
together  with  analogous  conditions  for  an,  a12,  and  oc22,  are  satisfied. 
We  shall  now  write  down  Lagrange's  equations.  We  have 


Whence 

a  ar  =  °»    1  (7 


In  order  to  satisfy  these  equations,  we  shall  look  for  a  solution 
in  the  form 


As  in  (7.14c),  the  real  part  of  the  solution  (7.21)  must  be  taken. 


Sec.  7]  SMALL   OSCILLATIONS  63 

The  equation  for  frequency.  Substituting  (7.21)  in  (7.20),  we 
obtain  equations  relating  A1  and  Az: 


"      '     *  \  (7.22) 

/  Q  *,*x2\/*l/n  ..9.\yl  /^l  ^  ' 

(p12  — a12co  }  £ 


Transferring  terms  in  A2  to  the  right-hand  side  of  the  equation 
and  dividing  one  equation  by  the  other,  we  eliminate  Al  and  A%: 


Reducing  (7.23)  to  a  common  denominator,  we  arrive  at  the  bi- 
quadratic equation 


(<xna22  —  afa)  to4  —  (  Pna22  +  £22*11  —  2a12(i12)  to2  + 

+  PiiP22—  Ma  =  0.  (7.24) 

Substituting  here  the  expressions  for  a,*,  (3ifc  from  (7.15),  we  obtain 
an  equation  for  the  frequencies  of  a  double  pendulum 


If  we  introduce  still  another  contraction  in  notation  (for  the  given 
problem)  -~-  —  \  —  -  =  fji,  the  expression  for  frequencies  will  be  of 
the  following  form: 


It  is  easy  to  see  that  this  expression  yields  only  the  real  values 
of  the  frequencies.  However,  we  shall  show  this  in  more  general 
form  for  equation  (7.24).  Let  us  assume  that  the  following  function 
is  given: 

F  (  co2)  =  (aua22  —  of,)  co*  —  (  pna22  +  p22an  —  2p12a12)  <»*  +  PiiP22  —  Pfi  > 

which  passes  through  zero  for  all  values  of  G>  that  satisfy  equation 
(7.24).  F  (co2)  is  positive  for  to2  =  0  and  for  to2  =  00,  since  Pnp22  — 
—  Pi2  >  ®>  ana22  —  ai2  >  ^-  Let  us  now  substitute  into  this  function 

Q 

the  positive  number  co2=~1-.  After  a  simple  rearrangement  we 
obtain 

P22  -  Pl2  «22)2  <  0  . 

Thus,  as  co2  varies  from  0  to  oo,  F  (co2)  is  first  positive,  then  negative, 
and  then  again  positive.  Hence,  it  changes  sign  twice,  so  that  equation 
(7.24)  has  two  positive  roots  coj,  cojj  and,  as  was  asserted,  all  the 
values  for  frequency  are  real. 


64  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

The  quantity  co  has  four  values,  both  pairs  of  which  are  equal 
in  absolute  value.  If  we  represent  the  solution  in  the  form  (7.21), 
it  is  sufficient  to  take  only  positive  G>. 

Normal  coordinates.  Let  us  put  these  roots  in  (1.22).  To  each  of 

^ 

them  there  will  correspond  a  definite  ratio  of  the  coefficients  -~-  .  For 

Ai 

i  —  I,  2  we  have 


n 

'  «• 

A  " 

Pl2 


According  to  (7.23),  the  same  ratio  is  also  obtained  from  the  second 
equation  of  (7.22).  For  example,  for  the  double  pendulum 

6i? 

£;=•  //^A    ?  ;  *  i's  equal  to  1  or  2  depending  on  the  sign  in  front 

of  the  root  in  the  solution  for  co2. 

Each  frequency  co;  defines  one  partial  solution  of  the  system 
(7.20).  Since  the  system  is  linear,  the  general  solution  is  the  sum 
of  these  particular  solutions.  Let  us  write  this  as 


*' .  (7.26) 

We  must,  of  course,  take  only  the  real  parts  of  the  expressions  on 
the  right. 

We  now  introduce  the  following  notation: 

4(JV«i'  ==  Qi ,     A<?  €*<**'  =  Qt .  (7.27) 

According  to  (7.27),  the  quantities  Qi  and  Q2  satisfy  the  differential 
equations 

Qj  +  co^-O;  (32  +  col92-0.  (7.28) 

Each  of  these  equations  can  be  obtained  from  the  Lagrangiaii 

Lt=*2Q1—l'<*1<K,  (7.29) 

which  describes  oscillation  with  one  degree  of  freedom. 

Thus,  in  terms  of  the  variables  Qi,  the  problem  of  two  related 
oscillations  with  two  degrees  of  freedom  q^  q2  has  been  reduced 
to  the  problem  of  two  independent  harmonic  oscillations  with  one 
degree  of  freedom  Ql  and  Q2.  The  coordinates  Ql  and  Q2  are  termed 
normal. 

In  equations  (7.20),  we  cannot  arbitrarily  put  31  =  0  or  g2  =  0: 
if  the  quantity  ql  oscillates,  then  it  must  cause  q2  to  oscillate.  In 
contrast,  the  oscillations  of  the  quantities  Ql  and  Q2  are  in  no  way 
related  [as  long  as  we  limit  ourselves  to  the  expansion  (7.16)  for  L]. 


Sec.  7]  SMALL   OSCILLATIONS  65 

From  equations  (7.26),  we  can  express  Qi  and  Q%  i*1  terms  of  ql  and  q2 : 


If,  for  example,  we  choose  the  initial  values  of  q  and  q  so  that  at 
this  instant  Q±  =  0  and  Q±  =  0,  then  the  oscillation  with  frequency  G^ 
will  riot  occur  at  all.  For  this  it  is  sufficient,  at  t  =  0,  to  take  the  co- 
ordinates and  velocities  in  a  relationship  such  that  £2  9i  —  #2 ==  0 
and  £2£i — ?2==^-  In  °ther  words,  only  the  frequency  co2  will  occur, 
and  the  oscillations  will  be  strictly  periodic.  When  both  frequencies 
Oj  and  co2  are  excited  they  are  generally  speaking  incommensurable, 
i.e.,  their  ratio  cannot  be  expressed  as  a  rational  fraction),  the  oscil- 
lation q  is  no  longer  periodic,  since  the  sum  of  two  periodic  functions 
with  incommensurable  periods  is  not  periodic. 

Expressing  energy  in  normal  coordinates.  From  the  form  of  the 
Lagrangian  (7.29)  it  can  be  immediately  concluded  that  the  expression 
for  energy  in  normal  coordinates  reduces  to  the  form 

-h  <*>?#?),  (7.31) 

since  L  =  T  —  U  and  (^  =  T+U.  This  result  is  true  for  small  oscil- 
lations with  any  number  of  degrees  of  freedom. 

We  must  note  that  if  the  normal  coordinates  are  expressed  directly 

by  equations  (7.30),  then  the  separate  energy  terms  -^  (Qf  +  ^fQi), 
will  also  be  multiplied  by  certain  numbers  a,-.  However,  if  we  replace 
Qi  by  Qi  Vo7,  then  these  numbers  are  eliminated  from  the  expression 
for  energy,  which  is  then  reduced  to  the  form  (7.31).  An  example 
of  this  procedure  is  given  in  the  exercises. 

Thus,  the  energy  of  any  system  performing  small  oscillations  is 
reduced  to  the  sum  of  the  energies  of  separate,  independent  linear 
harmonic  oscillators.  As  a  result  of  this,  consideration  of  oscillation 
problems  is  greatly  simplified  since  the  linear  harmonic  oscillator  is, 
in  many  respects,  one  of  the  most  simple  mechanical  systems. 

The  reduction  to  normal  coordinates  turns  out  to  be  a  very  fruitful 
method  in  studies  of  the  oscillations  of  polyatomic  molecules,  in 
the  theory  of  crystals,  and  in  electrodynamics.  In  addition,  normal 
coordinates  are  useful  in  technical  applications  of  oscillation  theory. 

The  case  ol  equal  frequencies.  If  the  roots  of  equation  (7.24)  coincide, 
the  general  solution  must  not  be  written  in  the  form  (7.26),  but 
somewhat  differently,  namely, 

ql  =  A  cos  co£  4-B  sin  co£,      ) 

At  TV       -  \  (7-32) 

q2=A  cos  co£  +  B  sin  co£ .    J 

5-0060 


66  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Four  arbitrary  constants  appear  in  this  solution,  and  this  is  as 
it  should  be  in  a  system  with  two  degrees  of  freedom. 

An  example  of  such  a  system  is  a  pendulum  suspended  by  a  string 
instead  of  a  hinge.  In  the  approximation  (7.32),  it  turns  out  that 
the  pendulum  describes  an  ellipse  centred  about  the  equilibrium 
position.  Account  taken  of  the  subsequent  terms  in  the  expansion 
of  the  potential  energy  in  powers  of  deflection  shows  that  the  axes 
of  the  ellipse  do  not  remain  stationary,  but  rotate. 

Exercise 

Find  the  natural  frequencies  and  normal  oscillations  of  a  double  pendulum, 
taking  the  ratios  of  load  masses  y.  =  3/4  and  the  rod  lengths  X  =  5/7. 

From  the  equation  for  the  oscillation  frequencies  of  a  double  pendulum, 

we  obtain  <o*  =  ~  ~r  » <°a  =   T^  ~r  •  Further,  ^  -  —  7/3,  £2  =  7/5. 

L     I  1U     I 

Let  us  now  write  down  the  expression  for  kinetic  energy.  For  simplicity, 
we  write  l  =  g~ m—l  so  that  only  ratios  of  X  and  JJL  will  appear  in  all  the  equa- 
tions. This  gives  ocn  —  1  -f  (Jt  —7/4,  a12  =  (xX  —  15/28,  a22  =  jiX2  =  75/196;  pn  —  1  +jjt  = 
=  7/4,  p12  =  0,  p22  =  (jiX—  15/28.  Let  us  determine  the  coefficients  a,-.  To  do  this 
we  must  calculate  the  kinetic  energy 

7  •    2        15      • 

4       l          2  14       l 


V5" 

Consequently,  wo  must  put  at  =  —  -~  ,  a2  =  1/2  . 

Denoting  —  --  -  and  —^-   again  by  the  letters  <?i  and  Q2,  we  have  the 

A  £i 

expression  for  potential  energy 


as  it  should  be  according  to  (7.10).  The  generalized  coordinates  are  related  to 
the  normal  coordinates  by 

5\/3"/7 


Thus,  if  7  9  =  —  3  <];,  and  7  9  =  —  3  \  initially,  then  we  have  Q2  =  0  for  all 
time,  so  that  both  pendulums  oscillate  with  one  frequency  colf  with  the  constant 
relationship  between  the  deflection  angles  7  9  —  —  3  ^  holding  all  the  time. 
Both  pendulums  are  deflected  to  opposite  sides  of  the  vertical.  The  other  normal 
oscillation,  with  frequency  w2,  occurs  for  a  constant  angular  relationship 
7  9  =  5  4>. 

Sec.  8.  Rotating  Coordinate  Systems.  Inertial  Forces 

The  equivalence  of  inertia!  coordinate  systems.  The  particular 
significance  of  inertial  coordinate  systems  in  mechanics  was  pointed 
out  in  Sec.  2.  In  such  systems,  all  accelerations  are  produced  by 


Sec.  8]  ROTATING   COORDINATE   SYSTEMS   INERTIAL  FORCES  67 

interaction  between  bodies.  It  is  impossible  to  find  a  strictly  inertial 
system  in  nature  (any  system  is  noninertial  if  the  motions  of  bodies 
in  it  are  observed  over  a  sufficiently  long  period  of  time). 

In  the  exercise  at  the  end  of  this  section  we  shall  consider  the 
Foucault  pendulum,  whose  plane  of  oscillation  rotates  with  a  speed 
depending  only  on  the  geographical  latitude  of  its  location.  This 
rotation  cannot  be  explained  by  an  interaction  with  the  earth,  because 
the  gravitational  force  cannot  make  the  pendulum  rotate  from  east 
to  west  instead  of  from  west  to  east.  *  However,  if  we  consider  several 
oscillations,  then  the  rotation  of  the  plane  is  still  insignificant  and 
can  be  ignored.  Then  it  is  sufficient  to  consider  that  gravity  alone 
is  acting  on  the  pendulum  and  that  the  coordinate  system  fixed 
in  the  earth  is  approximately  inertial  over  a  period  of  several  oscil- 
lations. 

The  concept  of  an  inertial  system  is  meaningful  as  an  approximation 
and  is  a  very  convenient  idealization  in  mechanics.  In  such  a  co- 
ordinate system,  the  interaction  forces  are  measured  by  the  acceler- 
ations of  the  bodies. 

Let  a  coordinate  system  be  defined  for  which  it  is  known  that, 
to  the  required  degree  of  accuracy,  it  can  be  regarded  as  inertial. 
Then  another  coordinate  system,  moving  uniformly  relative  to  it, 
is  also  inertial  within  the  same  degree  of  accuracy.  Indeed,  if  all 
the  accelerations  in  the  first  system  are  due  to  interaction  forces 
between  bodies,  then  no  additional  accelerations  can  appear  in  the 
second  system  either.  Therefore,  both  systems  are  inertial.  Either 
of  them  may  be  considered  at  rest  and  the  other  moving,  since  motion 
is  always  relative. 

The  principle  of  relativity.  One  of  the  basic  principles  of  mechanics 
is  that  all  laws  of  motion  have  an  identical  form  in  all  inertial  co- 
ordinate systems,  since  these  systems  are,  physically,  completely 
equivalent.  This  principle  of  the  equivalence  of  all  inertial  systems 
is  known  as  the  relativity  principle,  for  it  is  connected  with  the 
relativity  of  motion. 

It  should  be  noted  that  this  in  no  way  signifies  that  inertial  and 
noninertial  coordinate  systems  are  equivalent:  in  the  latter,  not 
all  the  accelerations  can  be  reduced  to  interaction  forces,  so  that 
there  is  no  physical  equivalence  between  two  such  systems. 

Mathematically,  the  principle  of  relativity  is  expressed  by  the  fact 
that  equations  of  motion  for  one  inertial  system  preserve  their  form 
after  the  variables  have  been  transformed  to  another  inertial  system. 

The  equations  for  the  transformation  from  one  inertial  system 
to  another  can  be  obtained  only  on  the  basis  of  certain  physical 

*  In  this  case  the  plane  of  oscillation  must  pass  through  the  vertical,  since, 
otherwise,  the  pendulum  would  have  an  initial  angular  momentum  relative 
to  the  vertical  and  would  describe  an  ellipse  whose  semiaxes  rotate  (see  end 
of  Sec.  7). 


68  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

assumptions.  In  Newtonian  mechanics  it  is  always  taken  that  the 
interaction  forces  between  bodies,  in  particular,  gravitational  forces, 
are  transmitted  instantaneously  over  any  distance.  Thus,  the  dis- 
placement of  any  body  immediately  transmits  a  certain  momentum 
to  any  other  body,  no  matter  where  it  is  located.  As  a  result,  a  clock 
located  in  a  certain  inertial  system  can  be  instantaneously  synchronized 
with  a  clock  moving  in  another  inertial  system.  Thus,  in  Newtonian 
mechanics,  time  is  considered  universal.  In  transforming  from  one 
inertial  system  to  another  (the  latter  with  a  velocity  F  relative  to 
the  former)  it  is  taken  that  the  time  t  is  the  same  in  both  systems. 

Later  on  we  shall  see  that  this  assump- 
tion is  approximate  and  holds  only  when 
the  relative  velocity  of  the  systems  is 
considerably  less  than  the  velocity  of 
light. 

*i  The    Galilean    transformation.    Let  us 

I         ,      construct     coordinate    systems     in    two 
-j — x      inertial   frames   of  reference    such    that 
their   abscissae   are   in   the    direction   of 
Fig.  11  the  relative   velocity    V   and   the   other 

coordinate  axes  are  also  mutually  parallel. 

Then  from  Fig.  11  it  will  be  immediately  seen  that  the  abscissa  of 
point  x  in  the  system  which  we  shall  call  stationary  is  related  to  the 
abscissa  in  the  moving  system  by  the  simple  relation 

x=x'  +  Vt,  (8.1) 

provided  that  the  origins  coincided  at  the  instant  t  —  Q.  The  co- 
ordinate construction  does  not  impose  any  limitations  on  the  generality 
of  the  transformation  equations.  The  remaining  transformations  lead 
simply  to  the  identities 

y  =  y',  z=z'.  (8.2) 

The  relationship  t  —  t'  is  a  hypothesis  which  is  correct  only 
for  values  of  V  considerably  less  than  the  velocity  of  light 
(Sec.  20). 

Condition  (8.1)  is  absolutely  symmetrical  with  respect  to  both 
inertial  systems:  if  we  consider  that  the  one  in  which  the  variables 
are  primed  is  stationary  and  the  other  in  motion,  (8.1)  retains  the 
same  form;  one  should,  of  course,  replace  F  by  —  F.  In  the  given 
case,  symmetry  exists  because  t' —t.  If  t^£t',  the  transformation 
equations  x  —  x'  +  Vt  and  x'  ~x —  Vt'  would  contradict  each  other. 
But  it  would  seem  that  equation  (8.1)  is  obtained,  quite  obviously, 
from  Fig.  11.  Thus,  if  we  do  not  consider  time  as  identical  for  all 
inertial  systems,  the  mathematical  formulation  of  the  relativity 
principle  should  be  more  complicated  than  that  obtained  on  the 
basis  of  equation  (8.1);  and,  we  must  definitely  give  up  this  "obvious- 


Sec.  8]  ROTATING   COORDINATE   SYSTEMS  INERTIAL  FORCES  69 

ness,"  which  is  so  rooted  in  our  everyday  experience  with  velocities 
that  are  small  compared  with  the  velocity  of  light. 

The  equations  of  Newtonian  mechanics  involve,  on  the  right-hand 
side,  the  forces  of  interaction  between  particles.  These  forces  depend 
on  the  relative  coordinates  of  the  particles  and,  for  this  reason, 
they  do  not  change 'with  transformation  (8.1),  since  Vt  is  cancelled 
in  the  formation  of  differences  between  the  coordinates  of  any  pair 
of  particles.  The  left-hand  sides  of  the  equations  contain  accelerations, 
i.e.,  the  second  derivatives  of  the  coordinates  with  respect  to  time. 
But  since  time  enters  linearly  in  (8.1)  and  is  the  same  in  both  systems, 
x=x'.  Thus,  the  equations  of  mechanics  are  of  iden- 
tical form  in  any  inertial  frame  of  reference. 

To  summarize,  the  equations  of  mechanics  do  not 
change  their  form  when  the  variables  undergo  trans- 
formations (8.1).  In  other  words,  it  is  common  to  say 
that  the  equations  of  mechanics  are  invariant  to  these 
transformations,  which  are  usually  called  Galilean 
transformations . 

The  constancy  (invariance)  of  mechanical  laws 
under  Galilean  transformations  is  the  essence  of  the 
relativity  principle  of  Newtonian  mechanics. 

Here  we  must  bear  in  mind  that  the  relativity 
principle,  which  expresses  the- equivalence  of  all  iner- 
tial coordinate  systems,  expresses  a  far  more  general 
law  of  nature  than  the  approximate  equations  of  transformation 
(8.1),  (8.2).  The  extension  of  the  relativity  principle  to  electromag- 
netic phenomena  involves  the  replacement  of  these  equations  by 
more  general  ones,  which  reduce  to  the  former  equations  only  when 
all  velocities  are  much  smaller  than  that  of  light. 

Rotating  coordinate  systems.  Several  new  terms  appear  in  the 
equations  of  mechanics  when  transforming  to  rotating  coordinate 
systems.  Let  us  first  obtain  the  equations  for  this  transformation. 

In  Fig.  12  the  axis  of  rotation  is  represented  by  a  vertical  line. 
The  origin  0  is  on  the  axis  of  rotation.  Let  r  be  the  radius  vector 
of  a  point  A  rotating  around  the  axis.  Then,  for  a  rotation  angular 
velocity  co  (radians  per  second)  the  linear  speed  of  the  point  will  be 

v  =  co  •  r  sin  a  ,  (8.3) 

since  the  radius  of  rotation  is  p  —r  sin  a  (see  Fig.  12).  Let  the  rotation 
be  anticlockwise.  If  point  A  lies  in  the  plane  of  the  paper,  then  the 
velocity  v  is  perpendicular  to  the  plane  of  the  paper  and  directed 
towards  the  back  of  the  paper.  This  permits  us  to  obtain  a  relationship 
between  the  linear  and  angular  velocities  in  vector  form.  We  represent 
the  angular  velocity  by  a  vector  directed  along  the  axis  of  rotation 
and  associated  with  the  direction  of  rotation  by  the  corkscrew  rule. 


70  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

Then,  if  the  rotation  occurs  in  an  anticlockwise  direction,  the  vector  to 
is  directed  upwards  from  the  paper.  From  this  it  follows  that 

v=[cor].  (8.4) 

This  expression  ensures  a  correct  magnitude  and  direction  for  the 
linear  velocity  of  the  point. 

Let  us  assume  that  point  A,  in  addition  to  rotation,  is  somehow 
displaced  relative  to  the  origin  0  with  velocity  v'  =  r.  The  resultant 
velocity  of  the  point  relative  to  a  noiirotating  system  will  be 
represented  as  the  sum  v'  +  v.  The  kinetic  energy  of  the  point  relative 

to  the  nonrotating  system  is  -«-  (v  +  v')2,   and   the   Lagrangian    is 
£  =  -£  (v  +  v')2-C7(r)  =  ^(v'  +  [cor])2-J7(r).          (8.5) 

Let  us  now  write  down  Lagrange's  equations  for  motion  relative 
to  a  rotating  system,  i.e.,  considering  r  a  generalized  coordinate. 

In  order  to  do  this  we  must  calculate  the  derivatives  -^-  and-0—  : 

or  or 

let  it  be  noted  that  differentiation  with  respect  to  a  vector  denotes 
a  shortened  way  of  writing  down  the  differentiation  with  respect 
to  all  of  its  three  components.  The  general  rules  for  such  differentiations 
will  be  given  in  Sec.  11;  here  we  shall  calculate  the  derivatives  for 
each  component  separately. 

Let  <o  be  along  the  direction  of  the  z-axis.  Then,  in  vector  com- 
ponents, L  will  be  of  the  form 

L=    -  [(i-cot,)2  +  (y  +  coo:)2  +  z2]  —  U(x,y9z)  .  (8.6) 


Whence  we  obtain 

dL  ..  v        dL  /.    ,         v        dL 


dL  /•    ,          v         8U          dL  ..  .         dU 

—  =  m<*(y+<*x)  —  -^-,     —  =  —  mco  (x  —  coy)  —  -^- 

dL  __        dU 

dz  ~~         dz    * 

Lagrange's  equations  in  component  form  appear  thus: 

f\  T^ 
7/1(0;  —  <oi/)  —  mco  (y  +  cox)  —  may  +  -g  —  =  0  , 

o  7"7 

m  (y  +  coi)  +  mo  (x  —  co?/)  +  m&x  +  -j—  =  0  , 


Sec.  8]  KOTATING   COORDINATE    SYSTEMS   INERTIAL  FORCES  71 

Let  us  leave  on  the  left  only  the  second  derivatives  and  rewrite 
the  last  three  equations  as  a  single  vector  equation: 

m[co[r<o]]—  --.  (8.7) 


Expanding  the  double  vector  product  on  the  right  by  means  of 
the  equation  [A  [BC]]  =  B  (AC)  —  C  (AB),  and  transforming  to  com- 
ponents, we  can  see  that  (8.7)  is  equivalent  to  the  preceding  system 
of  three  equations.  A  direct  differentiation  with  respect  to  the  vectors  r 
and  f  would  have  led  to  (8.7),  without  the  expression  in  terms  of 
components. 

Inertial  forces.  The  first  three  terms  on  the  right  in  (8.7)  essentially 
distinguish  the  equations  of  motion,  written  relative  to  a  rotating 
coordinate  system,  from  the  equations  written  relative  to  a  non- 
rotating  system. 

The  use  of  a  noninertial  system  is  determined  by  the  nature  of 
the  problem.  For  example,  if  the  motion  of  terrestrial  bodies  is  being 
studied,  it  is  natural  to  choose  the  earth  as  the  coordinate  system, 
and  not  some  other  system  related  to  the  Galaxy  (the  aggregate 
of  stars  in  the  Milky  Way).  If  we  consider  the  reaction  of  a  passenger 
to  a  train  that  suddenly  stops,  we  must  take  the  train  as  frame  of 
reference  and  not  the  station  platform.  When  the  train  is  braked 
sharply,  the  passenger  continues  to  move  forwards  "inertially"  or, 
as  we  have  agreed  to  say,  he  continues  to  move  uniformly  relative 
to  an  inertial  system  attached  to  the  earth.  Thus,  relative  to  the 
carriage,  it  is  the  familiar  jerk  forward.  At  the  same  time  it  is  obvious 
that  the  noninertial  system  is  the  train  and  not  the  earth,  since 
no  one  experiencies  any  jerk  on  the  platform. 

The  additional  terms  on  the  right  of  equation  (8.7)  have  the  same 
origin  as  the  jerk  when  the  train  stopped;  they  are  produced  by 
noninertiality  (in  the  given  case,  rotation)  of  the  coordinate  system. 
Naturally,  the  acceleration  of  a  point  caused  by  noninertiality  of 
the  system  is  absolutely  real,  relative  to  that  system,  in  spite  of  the 
fact  that  there  are  other,  inertial,  systems  relative  to  which  this 
acceleration  does  not  exist.  In  equation  (8.7)  this  acceleration  is 
written  as  if  it  were  due  to  some  additional  forces.  These  forces 
are  usually  called  inertial  forces.  In  so  far  as  the  acceleration  associated 
with  them  is  in  every  way  real,  the  discussion  (which  sometimes 
arises)  about  the  reality  of  inertial  forces  themselves  must  be  con- 
sidered as  aimless.  It  is  only  possible  to  talk  about  the  difference 
between  the  forces  of  inertia  and  the  forces  of  interaction  between 
bodies. 

But  if  we  consider  the  force  of  Newtonian  attraction,  we  cannot 
ignore  the  striking  fact  that,  like  the  forces  of  inertia,  it  is  proportional 
to  the  mass  of  the  body.  As  a  result  of  this,  the  equations  of  mechanics 
can  be  formulated  in  such  a  way  that  the  difference  between  gravi- 


72  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

tational  forces  and  incrtial  forces  does  not  at  all  appear  in  the  equations ; 
all  these  forces  turn  out  to  be  physically  equivalent.  However,  this 
formulation  is,  of  course,  connected  with  a  re-evaluation  and  a 
substantial  revision  of  the  basis  of  mechanics.  It  is  the  subject  of 
Einstein's  general  theory  of  relativity,  which  is  discussed  in  somewhat 
more  detail  at  the  end  of  Sec.  20. 

Coriolis  force.  Let  us  now  consider  in  more  detail  the  inertial  forces 
appearing  in  (8.7),  which  are  due  to  a  rotating  coordinate  system. 

The  first  term  in  (8.7)  occurs  as  a  result  of  nonconstancy  of  angular 
velocity.  It  will  not  interest  us.  The  second  term  is  called  the  Coriolis 
force.  For  a  Coriolis  force  to  appear,  the  velocity  of  a  point  relative 
to  a  rotating  coordinate  system  must  have  a  projection,  other  than 
zero,  on  a  plane  perpendicular  to  the  axis  of  rotation.  This  velocity 
projection  can,  in  turn,  be  separated  into  two  components:  one, 
perpendicular  to  the  radius  drawn  from  the  axis  of  rotation  to  the 
moving  point,  and  the  other,  directed  along  the  radius.  The  most 
interesting,  as  to  its  action,  is  the  component  of  the  Coriolis  force 
due  to  the  radial  component  of  velocity.  It  is  perpendicular  both 
to  the  radius  and  to  the  axis  of  rotation.  If  a  body  moves  perpen- 
dicularly to  a  radius,  then  its  Coriolis  acceleration  is  radial,  and 
therefore  analogous  in  its  action  to  the  centripetal  acceleration  which 
will  be  considered  a  little  further  on. 

We  note  that  the  Coriolis  force  cannot  be  related,  even  formally, 
to  the  gradient  of  a  potential  function  U. 

There  are  many  examples  of  the  deflecting  action  of  the  Coriolis 
force  in  nature.  The  water  of  rivers  in  the  Northern  Hemisphere 
which  flow  in  the  direction  of  the  meridian,  i.e.,  from  north  to  south, 
or  from  south  to  north,  experience  a  deflection  towards  the  right- 
hand  bank  (if  we  are  looking  in  the  direction  of  flow).  This  is  why 
the  right-hand  bank  of  such  rivers  is  steeper  than  the  left.  It  is  easy 
to  form  the  corresponding  component  of  the  Coriolis  force.  The 
angular-velocity  vector  of  the  earth's  rotation  is  directed  along  the 
earth's  axis,  "upwards"  from  the  north  pole.  The  waters  of  a  river, 
which  flows  southwards  at  the  mean  latitudes  of  the  Northern  Hemi- 
sphere, have  a  velocity  component  perpendicular  to  the  earth's 
axis  and  directed  away  from  the  axis.  This  means  that  the  Coriolis 
acceleration  of  the  water,  relative  to  the  earth,  is  in  a  westerly  direction 
or,  relative  to  a  river  flowing  southwards,  to  the  right.  If  the  river 
flows  in  a  northerly  direction,  the  deflection  will  be  towards  the 
east,  i.e.,  again  to  the  right.  In  the  southern  hemisphere  the  deflection 
occurs  leftwards. 

The  warm  Gulf  Stream  which  flows  northwards  is  deflected  towards 
the  east,  which  is  of  tremendous  importance  for  the  climate  of  Europe. 
In  general,  the  Coriolis  force  considerably  affects  the  motion  of  air 
and  water  masses  on  the  earth,  though  when  compared  in  magnitude 
with  the  gravitational  force  it  is  very  insignificant.  Indeed,  the  angular 


SeC.  9]  THE   DYNAMICS   OF  A  RIGID   BODY  73 

velocity  of  the  earth,  as  it  completes  one  rotation  about  its  axis 
in  24  hours,  is  a  little  less  than  10~4  rad/sec,  while  the  velocity  of 
a  particle  of  water  or  air  can  be  taken  as  having  an  order  of  magnitude 
of  102  cm/sec.  From  this  the  Coriolis  acceleration  has  an  order  of 
magnitude  of  10~2  cm/sec2,  which  is  one  hundred  thousand  times 
less  than  the  acceleration  caused  by  the  force  of  gravity. 

The  Coriolis  force  also  causes  the  rotation  of  the  plane  of  oscillation 
of  a  Foucault  pendulum.  With  the  aid  of  the  Foucault  pendulum, 
we  can  prove  the  rotation  of  the  earth  about  its  axis  without  astro- 
nomical observations.  In  a  nonrotating  system,  the  plane  of  oscillation 
must  be  invariable  in  accordance  with  the  law  of  conservation  of 
angular  momentum. 

Centrifugal  force.  The  third  vector  term  in  equation  (8.7)  is  the 
usual  centrifugal  force.  Indeed,  it  is  perpendicular  to  the  axis  of 
rotation  and,  in  absolute  value,  is  equal  to 

|  m  [d/[tor]]  |  =  mto  |  [cor]  |  —  mi*  (cor  sin  a)  =  mco2r  sin  a .    (8.8) 

Here,  the  first  equality  takes  account  of  the  fact  that  the  vectors  to 
and  [tor]  are  perpendicular  to  each  other,  so  that  the  absolute  value 
of  the  vector  product  is  equal  to  the  product  of  their  absolute  values. 
But  r  sin  a  is  equal  to  the  distance  from  the  axis  of  rotation,  so 
that  this  force  satisfies  the  usual  definition  of  a  centrifugal  force. 

Exercise 

Let  us  consider  the  rotation  of  the  plane  of  oscillation  of  a  Foucault  pendulum 
under  the  action  of  the  earth's  rotation  about  its  axis. 

The  axis  Ox  at  a  given  point  on  the  earth  is  drawn  in  a  northerly  direction 
and  the  axis  Oy  in  an  easterly  direction.  Then,  if  <*B=  <*>  sin  0,  where  0  is  the 
latitude  of  the  locality,  we  have  the  equation  of  motion 

x=  —  6)2#_2£cDB,     y  =  _ .coj?/  +  2£toB,     co2  =  J7 

Multiplying  the  first  equation  by  y  and  the  second  by  x  and  then  sub- 
tracting, we  got 

-*-(yx-xy)  =  -  A(yi+  si),^  . 

Integrating  and  transforming  to  polar  coordinates  (x  =  r  cos  9,  y  ~  r  sin  9) : 

r*v=r*<*B. 
Whence,  after  cancelling  the  r2's,  we  have 

9  =  WB  =  <o  sin  0  , 
which  gives  the  angular  velocity  of  rotation  of  the  piano  of  oscillation. 

Sec.  9.  The  Dynamics  of  a  Rigid  Body 

The  dynamics  of  a  rigid  body  is  a  large  independent  chapter  of 
mechanics  and  is  very  rich  in  technical  applications.  Our  aim  is 
to  give  only  a  brief  account  of  the  basic  concepts  of  this  branch 


74  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

of  mechanics  inasmuch  as  it  contains  instructive  examples  of  general 
laws.  In  addition,  certain  mechanical  quantities  that  characterize 
a  rigid  body  are  necessary  for  an  understanding  of  molecular  spectra. 

The  kinetic  energy  of  a  rigid  body.  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  1,  a  rigid 
body  has  six  degrees  of  freedom.  Three  of  them  relate  to  the  trans- 
lational  motion  of  the  centre  of  mass  of  a  body  in  space.  The  re- 
maining three  degrees  of  freedom  correspond  to  rotation  (relative 
to  this  centre  of  mass). 

In  Sec.  4,  it  was  shown  that  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  system  consists 
of  the  kinetic  energy  of  the  motion  of  the  whole  mass  of  the  body 
concentrated  at  the  centre  of  mass,  and  the  kinetic  energy  of  the 
relative  motion  of  the  separate  particles  of  the  system.  In  the  case 
of  a  rigid  body,  relative  motion  reduces  to  rotation  with  the  value 
of  angular  velocity  co  the  same  for  all  particles.  Naturally,  both  the 
magnitude  and  the  direction  of  to  may  vary  with  time. 

Let  us  calculate  the  kinetic  energy  of  rotation  of  a  rigid  body. 
In  the  general  case,  the  density  p  of  the  body  may  not  be  uniform 
over  the  whole  volume  of  the  body,  and  may  depend  on  the  co- 
ordinates: p  —  p  (#,  y,  z)  =  p  (r).  The  mass  of  an  element  of  volume  dV 
is  equal  to  dm~p  dV.  The  velocity  of  rotation  v  is,  from  (8.4),  [cor], 
Therefore,  the  kinetic  energy  of  the  volume  element  is  equal  to 

y  p  [cor]2dF.  The  kinetic  energy  of  the  whole  body  is  represented  by 
the  integral  of  this  quantity  with  respect  to  the  volume 

(9.1) 

Expressing  the  square  of  the  vector  product  in  terms  of  the  compo- 
nents co,  we  have 

[cor]2  =  co2r2  sin2  a  =  co2r2  —  co2r2  cos2  a  =  co2r2  —  (cor)2. 
Here  a  is  the  angle  between  co  and  r.  But 


(cor)2  =  (cojctf  +  coy«/  +  co*z)2  = 


Since  the  body  is  rigid,  the  components  co*,  coy,  co*  can  be  taken 
out  of  the  volume  integral.  Combining  terms  which  are  similar  in  the 
components  co,  we  obtain  for  T: 


9xzdV  — 
—  coy  co*  J  9yz  dV  .  (9.2) 


Sec.  9]  THE   DYNAMICS   OF  A  RIGID   BODY  75 

Moments  of  inertia.  All  the  integrals  appearing  in  (9.2)  depend  only 
on  the  shape  of  the  body  and  its  density  distribution,  and  do  not  de- 
pend on  the  motion  of  the  body  (in  a  coordinate  system  fixed  in  the 
body).  We  denote  them  as  follows: 


=/ p  (yz  +  *2) dV,  Jxr=-j  pxydV, 


(9.3) 


The  quantities  with  the  same  indexes  are  called  moments  of  inertia, 
while  those  with  different  indexes  are  called  products  of  inertia. 
In  the  notation  of  (9.3),  the  kinetic  energy  has  the  form 

T  =  —  (JxxCOx  +  «/yyCOy  +  JzztoZ  +  2Jxy6>xCOy  +  2Jxztoxtoz  +  2jy^COyCO^)  . 

(9.4) 

With  the  aid  of  the  summation  convention  used  in  Sec.  2,  when  eval- 
uating Lagrange's  equations  the  kinetic  energy  can  be  written  in  the 
following  concise  form : 

T^-^J  «£<**<*£. 

Principal  axes  of  inertia.  Let  us  suppose  that  Oxyz  is  a  coordinate 
system  fixed  in  a  body.  In  this  system  all  the  quantities  Jxx ,  . . . ,  Jyz 
are  constant.  Let  us  take  another  coordinate  system  Ox'y'z'  which  is 
also  fixed  in  the  body.  The  old  coordinates  of  any  point  are  expressed 
in  terms  of  its  new  coordinates  by  the  well-known  formulae  of  analyti- 
cal geometry: 

x  =  x'  cos  /.  (#',  x)  +  y'  cos  /_  (yr,  x)  +  z'  cos  /_  (z',  x) , 
y  =  x'  cos  L  (#',  y)  +  y'  cos  /_  (yf,  y)  +  z'  cos  L  (*',  y) , 
z  =  x'  cos  L  (x',  z)  +  y'  cos  /.  (y1,  z)  +  z'  cos  /_  (zf,  z) , 

or,  if  we  denote  cos  <  (xa'x$)  by  the  symbol  A^*,  then,  with  the  aid  of 
the  summation  convention 

*^3  ==*^<x  -"•oc3* 

The  same  formulae  are  used  to  express  also  the  components  of  any 
vector,  and  in  particular  03,  relative  to  the  old  axes,  in  terms  of  the 
components  coa'  relative  to  the  new  axes. 

Let  us  substitute  these  expressions  into  the  kinetic  energy  (9.4) 
and  collect  the  terms  containing  the  products  eoj/fcV,  co^'co/,  toy'ci)/  and 


76  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

the  squares  to*'2,  o>y'2,  to/2.  We  shall  now  show  that  we  can  always 
rotate  the  coordinate  axes  so  that  the  coefficients  of  the  new  products 
tox'coy',  cox'co*',  aVco/  become  zero.  Indeed,  any  rotation  of  the  coordinate 
system  can  be  described  with  the  aid  of  three  independent  parameters, 
for  a  coordinate  system  is  like  an  imaginary  rigid  body  and  its  posi- 
tion in  space  is  defined  by  the  three  angles  of  rotation  (see  Sec.  1). 
These  three  angles  can  be  chosen  so  that  the  sums  of  the  products  of 
the  cosines  of  the  angles  between  the  axes,  for  tox'coy',  co^'ox*'  and  coy'co*' 
become  zero.  The  remaining  expressions  for  co*'2,  coy'2,  and  to*'2  will  be 
called  Jl9  J2,  «/3,  so  that 


The  kinetic  energy  is  written  in  the  following  form  in  the  new  coordi- 
nate axes: 

T  -  \  (J>?  +  J*<*\  +  Js<»t).  (0.5) 

These  axes  are  called  the  principal  axes  of  inertia  of  the  body,  they 
can  be  defined  relative  to  any  point  connected  with  the  body.  By  defi- 
nition, the  products  of  inertia  convert  to  zero  in  the  principal  axes  of 
inertia.  The  moments  of  inertia  in  the  principal  axes  are  called  princi- 
pal moments  of  inertia.  They  are  denoted  by  Jl9  J2,  J3. 

The  angular  momentum  of  a  rigid  body.  Let  us  now  calculate  a  pro- 
jection of  the  angular  momentum  of  a  rigid  body.  From  the  definition 
of  angular  momentum  we  obtain 

M*  =  J  p  [rvMF  =  J  p  [r  [tor]]xdF  -  J  p  (to.vr2  —  x  (cor))  dV  = 
^  cox  Jp(2/2  +  z2)dV  —  coy  f  pxydV  —  <o*  f  pxzdF  = 

=  Jxx  CO*  +   +  Jxy  C0y  +  Jxz  6)z  (9.6) 

or,  in  shortened  form, 


Comparing  (9.6)  and  (9.4),  we  see  that 

^T1 

*—•£;' 

My  and  Mz  appear  analogous.  In  vector  form,  we  may  write 


(9.8) 


Equations  (9.7)  and  (9.8)  again  express  the  fact  that  the  angular 
momentum  is  a  generalized  momentum  related  to  rotation.  In  this 
sense,  (9.7)  corresponds  to  (5.4).  The  only  difference  is  that  the  com- 
ponents to  are  not  total  time  derivatives  of  some  quantities.  This  will 


Sec.  9]  THE   DYNAMICS   OF   A   RIGID    BODY  77 

be  shown  a  little  later  in  the  present  section.  In  that  sense,  to*,  in 
(9.7),  is  not  altogether  similar  to  9  in  (5.4). 

If  the  coordinate  axes  coincide  with  the  principal  axes  of  inertia, 
then  the  expression  for  angular  momentum  is  even  simpler  than 
(9.6): 

AT 

*i  =  ls:  =  Ji«i  (9.9) 

and  similarly  for  the  other  components. 

Moment  of  forces.  Let  us  now  find  equations  which  describe  the 
variation  of  angular  momentum  with  time.  The  derivative  of  angular 
momentum  of  a  particle  is 


where  the  first  term  becomes  zero  since  r  and  p  are  parallel.  Integrating 
this  equation  over  the  volume  of  the  rigid  body  and  taking  advantage 
of  the  additive  property  of  angular  momentum,  we  have 

K.  (9.10) 

The  right-hand  side  of  (9.10),  which  we  denote  by  K,  is  called  the 
resultant  moment  of  the  forces  applied  to  the  body.  If  F  is  the  gravi- 
tational force  (which  occurs  in  the  majority  of  cases)  then  K  can  also 
be  written  as 


=  —  Jp<7[rz0]dF, 


where  z0  is  the  unit  vector  in  a  vertical  direction.  But  since  the  vector 
z0  is  a  constant,  it  should  be  put  outside  the  integration  sign: 


K  =  [z0,  JpgrrdFJ, 


If  the  body  is  supported  at  its  centre  of  mass,  then,  by  the  definition 
of  centre  of  mass,  the  integral  for  all  three  projections  pr  will  be  zero. 
Then  K  =  0  and  the  total  angular  momentum  will  be  conserved.  This 
occurs  in  the  case  of  a  gyroscope. 

For  the  conservation  of  angular  momentum  of  a  rigid  body  it  is 
sufficient  that  K  =  0;  but  for  any  arbitrary  mechanical  system, 
angular  momentum  is  conserved  only  when  there  are  no  external 
forces. 

Euler's  equations.  Equation  (9.6)  gives  a  relationship  between  M 
and  co.  The  quantities  «/**,  . . .,  Jyz  are  constant  only  in  a  coordinate 
system  fixed  in  the  rigid  body  itself.  If  we  write  equation  (9.10)  for 
a  stationary  coordinate  system,  then,  differentiating  M  with  respect 
to  time,  we  must  also  find  the  derivatives  of  Jxx,  . . . ,  JYZ  with  respect 
to  time,  which  is  very  inconvenient.  Therefore,  it  is  preferable  to 


78  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

transform  the  equation  to  a  coordinate  system  fixed  in  the  body, 
taking  into  account  the  accelerated  motion  of  that  system.  The  varia- 
tion of  the  vector  M  relative  to  the  moving  axes  consists  of  two  com- 
ponents :  one  is  due  to  the  variation  of  the  vector  itself,  while  the  other 
is  due  to  the  motion  of  the  axes  onto  which  it  is  projected.  For  the  vector 
M  this  variation  is  equal  to  [u>M],  similar  to  the  way  that  it  was  equal 
to  [cor]  for  the  radius  vector  r  in  Sec.  8.  When  the  coordinate  system 
is  rotated,  any  vector  varies  like  a  radius  vector. 

Let  the  coordinate  axes  be  taken  in  the  direction  of  the  principal 
axes  of  inertia.  Obviously,  the  moments  of  inertia  relative  to  these 
coordinates  are  constant.  For  this  reason,  the  time  derivative  of 
Ml  =  Jl<f)1  is 

Ml  =  J±  c^  +  [coM]!  =  J1vl  +  o>2  M3  —  co3  M2  =  Jjco,,  +  (J3  —  J2)  co3o>2  . 

Equating  this  expression  to  the  magnitude  of  the  projection  of  the 
moment  of  force  on  the  first  axis  of  inertia,  and  doing  the  same  for 
the  other  axes,  we  obtain  the  required  system  of  equations 


(9.11) 


These  equations  were  obtained  by  L.  Euler  and  are  named  after 
him.  They  can  be  reduced  to  quadrature  for  any  arbitrary  values  of 
integrals  of  motion  in  the  following  cases  : 

1)  JK1  —  K2~K3  =  0  (point  of  support  at  the  centre  of  mass)  for 
arbitrary  values  of  the  moments  of  inertia; 

2)  J2  =  J3  ^  Jj  and  the  point  of  support  lies  on  the  axis  of  symmetry, 
relative  to  which  two  moments  of  inertia  are  equal.  This  is  the  so- 
called  symmetrical  top. 

For  more  than  a  hundred  years,  no  other  case  of  a  solution  of  system 
(9.11)  by  quadratures  was  known.  Only  in  1887  did  S.  V.  Kovalevskaya 
find  another  example  (see  G.  K.  Suslov,  Theoretical  Mechanics, 
Gostekhizdat,  1944).  Kovalevskaya  showed  that  the  three  listed  cases 
exhaust  all  the  possibilities  of  integrating  the  system  (9.11)  by  quadra- 
tures for  arbitrary  constants  (integrals)  of  motion. 

A  free  symmetrical  top.  All  three  cases,  and  in  particular  the  Kova- 
levskaya case,  are  very  complicated  to  integrate.  Therefore,  we  shall 
only  consider  the  simplified  first  case,  when  J2  =  J3  (a  free  symmetrical 
top). 

From  the  first  equation  of  (9.11),  it  immediately  follows  that 
a>1==  const.  For  brevity,  we  write  the  value 


Q.  (9.12) 

The  second  two  equations  of  (9.11)  are  written  thus: 


Sec.  9] 


THE   DYNAMICS   OF   A  RIGID    BODY 


79 


<J>2  4-  £}<o3  =  0 ,     o>3  — £ico2  =  0.  (9.13) 

Equations  (9.13)  are  easily  integrated  if  we  represent  the  components 
co2  and  co3  in  the  following  form: 


=  coj^  cos  fit ,     co3  — 


(9.14) 


Here,  o>|  +  co|  =  co^  is  a  constant  quantity.  Thus,  the  angular- 
momentum  projection  on  the  axis  of  symmetry  and  the  sum  of  the 
squares  of  the  angular-momentum  projections  on  the  other  two  axes 
are  conserved.  This  means  that  the  angular-momentum  vector  rotates 
about  the  axis  of  symmetry,  i.  e.,  the  first  axis  of  inertia,  with  angular 
velocity  fl;  the  vector  makes  with  it  a  constant  angle,  the  tangent 

of  which  is  -^~ .  This  is  the  situation  in  a  system  of  moving  axes. 

Of  course,  in  a  system  of  stationary  axes,  the  total  angular  momen- 
tum is  conserved  in  magnitude  and  direction,  since  the  resultant 
moment  of  force  is  equal  to  zero.  In  this 
system,  the  axis  of  symmetry  of  the  top 
rotates  about  the  angular-momentum 
direction  making  a  constant  angle  with 
it.  Such  motion  is  called  precession.  Pre- 
cessional  motion  is  only  stable  for  rela- 
tively small  external  perturbations.  The 
stabilizing  action  of  gyroscopes  is  based 
on  this  principle. 

Eulerian  angles.  We  shall  now  show 
how  to  describe  the  rotation  of  a  rigid 
body  with  the  aid  of  parameters  which 
specify  its  position.  Such  parameters  are 
the  Eulerian  angles  shown  in  Fig.  13.  The 
figure  depicts  two  coordinate  systems: 
a  fixed  system  Oxyz  and  a  system 
Ox'y'z'  fixed  in  the  rigid  body.  It  is  most  convenient  to  take  x',  y',  z' 
along  the  principal  axes  of  inertia  through  the  point  of  support.  Then 
the  Eulerian  angles  are: 

&  is  the  angle  between  the  axes  z  and  z', 

9  is  the  angle  between  the  line  OK  of  intersection  between  the  planes 
xOy  and  x'Oy'  and  the  #'-axis, 

fy  is  the  angle  between  the  line  OK  and  the  #-axis. 

If  the  angle  fy  varies,  then  the  angular- velocity  vector  <J/  is  directed 
along  the  axis  Oz  since  that  vector  is  perpendicular  to  the  plane  of 

angle  of  rotation  ^.  Thus  9  must  be  taken  along  the  axis  Oz'  and  & 
along  the  line  OK. 

Let  us  now  express  the  angular-velocity  projections  (i.  e.,  &19  co2, 
co3,)  onto  the  principal  axes  of  inertia  in  terms  of  the  generalized  ve- 
locities 4»,  <p,  &• 


80  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

co3  is  the  projection  of  the  angular  velocity  on  the  axis  Ozf  (zr  is 
the  third  axis).  As  was  shown,  9  is  projected  exclusively  on  this  axis 
and  the  projection  of  fy  is  equal  to  ^  cos  &,  since  #  is  the  angle  between 
the  axes  Oz  and  Ozr.  Hence, 

0)3—9  -f^cosfl-  .  (9.15) 

In  order  to  find  the  projections  of  the  angular  velocity  on  the  other 
two  axes,  we  draw  a  line  OL  which  lies  in  the  plane  x'Oy'  and  is  per- 
pendicular to  OK. 

From  Fig.  13  it  can  be  seen  that 

/_LOx'  =  -J—  9  and  /_zOL  =  ^  +  a, 

since  the  straight  line  OL  lies  in  the  plane  zz'  ',  as  do  all  lines  perpendic- 
ular to  OK.  The  projection  of  fy  on  OL  is  equal  to  —  A  sin  &,  and  the 
projection  on  Ox'  is  equal  to  —  ^  sin  ^  cos  iy  —  9)=  —  <j>  sin  & 

sin  9.  The  projection  of  ^  on  Oy'  is  ^  sin  -9-  cos  9.  The  projection  of  & 
on  Ox'  and  Oy'  can  be  directly  found  by  means  of  the  diagram  ;  they 
are  £  cos  9  and  9-  sin  9.  The  result  is  therefore 

co!  —  &  cos  9  —  ^sin#sin9  ,  (9.16) 

(9.17) 


From  equations  (9.15),  (9.16),  and  (9.17)  it  will  be  seen  that  co1? 
co2  and  co3  are  not  total  time  derivatives  of  any  quantities  and,  in 
that  sense,  do  not  exactly  agree  with  the  usual  notion  of  generalized 
velocities  (as  do  9,  ij;,  $-). 

If  we  substitute  into  (9.5)  the  expressions  for  co1,  o>2,  co3  in  terms  of 
the  Eulerian  angles,  we  obtain  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  rigid  body  as  a 
function  of  the  generalized  coordinates  9,  <p,  &. 

The  symmetrical  top  in  a  gravitational  field.  We  shall  find  the  Lagran- 
gian  for  a  symmetrical  top  whose  point  of  support  lies  on  the  axis  of 
symmetry  at  a  distance  I  below  the  centre  of  mass.  Then  the  height 
of  the  centre  of  mass  above  the  point  of  support  is  z  =  l  cos  #.  Hence, 
the  potential  energy  of  the  top  is 

U  =  mgz  =  mgl  cos  0-  .  (9.18) 

The  kinetic  energy  of  the  top,  expressed  in  terms  of  the  Eulerian 
angles,  is 

T  =  ~  Jt  (co?  +  col)  +  4-^3^1  = 

M  £ 

=  y«M^2  +  <Psin2£)  +  ^  J3(^  +  <j,cos£)2.  (9.19) 

The  difference  between  the  quantities  (9.19)  and  (9.18)  gives  the 
Lagrangian  for  a  symmetrical  top.  The  sum  gives  the  total  energy  &  . 


Sec.  10]  GENERAL   PBINCIPUSS    OF    MECHANICS  81 

Since  L  does  not  contain  time  explicit^,  the  energy  is  an  integral 
of  motion: 

£  =  T  +  U  =  const  .  (9.20) 

We  can  find  two  more  integrals  of  motion,  noting  that  the  angles  9 
and  <J>  do  not  appear  explicitly  in  L  (9  is  eliminated  only  in  the  case 
of  a  symmetrical  top).  These  integrals  of  motion  are 

p,  7" 

#p  =  -p-  =  ^3  (?  +  ^  cos  *)  =  const  ,  (9-21) 

o  i" 

p^  =  —•-  =  e/x  sin2  ^^  -|-  J3  cos  ft  (9  +  <j>  cos  ft)  =  const  .       (9.22) 

If  we  eliminate  9  and  ^  from  equations  (9.21)  and  (9.22)  and  substi- 
tute them  into  the  energy  integral,  the  latter  will  contain  only  the 
variable  #,  which  allows  us  to  reduce  the  problem  to  quadrature. 

Substituting  (9.21)  in  (9.22),  we  obtain 

p^  =  Jl  sin2&  fy  -f-  fa  cos  &  , 
whence 


The  energy  integral,  after  substituting  p9  and  p^  is 

**-»"»**  +  *-  +  mgl  cos  »  .  (9.23) 


Thus,  the  problem  is  reduced  to  motion  with  one  degree  of  freedom 
ft,  as  it  were.  The  corresponding  "kinetic  energy"  is  —  J^2,  and  the 

'  'potential  energy"  is  represented  by  those  energy  terms  which  depend 
on  &.  This  potential  energy  becomes  infinite  for  £  =  0,  and  &  —  n. 
Hence,  for  0  <0-  <TT  it  has  at  least  one  minimum.  If  this  minimum 

corresponds  to  9-  >  —>  then  the  rotation  of  the  top,  whose  centre  of 

mass  is  above  the  point  of  support,  is  stable.  Small  oscillations  are 
possible  near  the  potential  energy  minimum.  These  oscillations  are 
superimposed  on  the  precessional  motion  of  the  top  which  we  have 
already  noted.  They  are  called  nutations. 

Sec.  10.  General  Principles  of  Mechanics 

In  this  part  of  the  book,  mechanics  is  explained  mainly  through  the 
use  of  Newton's  equations  (2.1).  Going  over  to  generalized  coordinates, 
we  obtain  from  them  Lagrange's  equations  and  a  series  of  further 
deductions.  In  this  section  it  will  be  shown  that  the  system  of  Lagran- 
ge's equations  can  be  obtained  not  only  from  Newton's  Second  Law, 
but  also  from  a  very  simple  assertion  about  the  value  of  the  integral 

6-0060 


82  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

of  the  Lagrangian  taken  with  respect  to  time.  The  basic  laws  of  mechan- 
ics thus  formulated  are  usually  called  integral  principles. 

The  particular  importance  of  these  principles  is  that  they  allow 
us  to  understand,  in  a  unified  manner,  the  laws  relating  to  various 
areas  of  theoretical  physics  (mechanics  and  electrodynamics),  thus 
opening  up  a  field  for  broad  generalizations. 

Action.  For  a  certain  mechanical  system,  let  it  be  possible  to  define 
the  Lagrangian 

L=L(q,qJk),  (10.1) 

as  dependent  on  the  generalized  coordinates  q,  velocities  q,  and  the 
time  t.  We  shall  consider  that  all  the  coordinates  and  all  the  velocities 
are  independent.  Let  us  choose  some  continuous,  but  otherwise  arbi- 
trary, dependence  of  the  coordinates  upon  the  time  q  (t).  The  functions 
q  (t)  can  be  in  complete  disagreement  with  the  actual  law  of  motion. 
The  only  requirement  imposed  on  q  (t)  is  that  the  functions  q  (t)  should 
be  smooth,  i.  e.,  that  they  should  provide  for  differentiation  and  should 
correspond  to  the  rigid  constraints  present  in  the  system. 

The  time  integral  of  the  Lagrangian  is  called  the  action  of  the  sys- 
tem: 

'i 

S  =  JL(q,  q,  t)  dt.  (10.2) 

'o 

The  magnitude  of  this  integral  depends  upon  the  law  chosen  for 
q  (t),  and  is,  in  that  sense,  arbitrary.  In  order  to  examine  the  relation- 
ship between  the  action  and  the  function  q  (t),  it  is  convenient  to  cal- 
culate the  change  of  S  for  a  transition  from  some  arbitrary  law  q  (t) 
to  another,  infinitely  close  but  also  arbitrary,  law  qf  (t). 

Variation.  Fig.  14  shows  two  such  conceivable 
paths.  Time  is  taken  along  the  abscissa,  and 
one  of  the  generalized  coordinates  q,  represent- 
ing the  totality  of  generalized  coordinates,  is 
plotted  on  the  ordinate  axis. 

For  the  specification  of  future  operations,  we 
shall  consider  that  both  paths  pass  through  the 
same  points,  g0  and  ql9  at  the  initial  and  final 
instants  of  time, 
-p.     14  The    vertical    arrow    shows    the    difference 

between  two  conceivable,  infinitely  close  paths  at 
some  instant  of  time  other  than  initial  or  final. 

This  difference  is  usually  called  the  variation  of  q  and  is  denoted  by 
8q.  The  symbol  S  should  emphasize  the  difference  between  variation 
and  the  differential  d\  the  differential  is  taken  for  the  same  path  at 
various  instants  of  time,  while  the  variation  is  taken  for  the  same 
instant  of  time  between  different  paths. 


Sec.  10]  GENERAL  PRINCIPLES   OF   MECHANICS  83 

Since  the  neighbouring  paths  in  Fig.  14  have  different  forms,  the 
speed  of  motion  along  them  will  also  differ.  Together  with  the  variation 
of  the  coordinate  8q  between  paths,  we  can  also  find  the  variation 

in  velocity  8q.  We  shall  show  that  8q  =  -jr8q.  Indeed,  8q  =  q'  (t) — q  (t), 

at 

where  q'  and  q  are  values  of  the  coordinates  for  neighbouring  paths. 

But  the  derivative  of  the  difference  -=-  §q  is  equal  to  the  difference  of 

at     *          ^ 

the  derivatives  q'  (t) — q(t)=8q. 

Let  us  now  find  the  variation  of  the  Lagrangian,  i.  e.,  the  difference 
of  the  function  for  two  adjacent  paths.  Since  L  =  L  (q,  q,  t)  and  the 
variation  is  taken  at  the  same  instant  of  time,  i.  e.,  S£  =  0,  we  obtain 


Let  us  rearrange  the  second  term.  Taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that 

— 


q  =  —  8q  ,  we  can  write  it  thus  : 


The  last  equation  simply  expresses  a  transformation  by  parts. 
Substituting  it  into  (10.3),  we  find 


d 


The  integral  of  the  variation  of  L  is  equal  to  the  variation  of  action 
8$,  since  the  difference  between  integrals  taken  between  the  same 
limits  is  equal  to  the  difference  between  the  integrands. 

The  first  term  in  (10.4)  can  be  integrated  with  respect  to  time, 
because  it  is  a  total  derivative.  The  variation  of  action  is  then  reduced 
to  the  form 

'o         'o 

We  have  agreed  to  consider  only  those  paths  which  pass  through  the 
same  points,  qQ  and  ql9  at  the  initial  and  final  instants  of  time.  Hence, 
at  these  instants  the  variation  $q  becomes  zero  by  convention,  and 
the  integrated  term  disappears.  The  expression  8$  is  reduced  to  the 
following  integral: 

.  (10.6) 

The  extremal  property  of  action.  If  the  chosen  path  coincides  with 
the  actual  path  of  motion,  the  coordinates  satisfy  Lagrange's  equation: 


84  MECHANICS  [Part  I 


Substituting  this  in  (10.6),  we  see  that  the  variation  of  action  tends 
to  zero  close  to  the  actual  path.  The  change  in  magnitude  is  equal  to 
zero  either  close  to  its  extreme,  or  close  to  the  "stationary  point" 
(for  example,  the  function  ?/  —  #3  has  such  a  point  at  x  =  Q,  where 
2/'  =  0,  iz/"  =  0).  Three  cases  can,  in  general,  be  realized:  a  minimum, 
a  maximum  and  a  stationary  point. 

For  example,  let  a  point,  not  subject  to  the  action  of  any  forces 
other  than  constraint  reactions,  move  freely  on.  a  sphere.  Then  its 
path  will  be  an  arc  of  a  great  circle.  But  through  any  two  points  on 
the  sphere  there  pass  two  arcs  of  a  great  circle  representing  the  largest 
and  smallest  sections  of  the  circumference.  One  corresponds  to  a  maxi- 
mum, and  the  other,  to  a  minimum,  8.  If  the  beginning  arid  end  of  the 
path  are  diametrically  opposite,  the  result  is  a  stationary  point. 

The  principle  o!  least  action.  We  have  proven,  on  the  basis  of  Lag- 
range's  equations,  that  8S  —  0.  We  can  proceed  in  a  different  way: 
by  asserting  that  close  to  the  actual  path  passing  between  the  given 
initial  and  final  positions  of  the  system  the  increment  of  action  is 
equal  to  zero,  we  can  derive  Lagrange's  equations.  Ordinarily,  the 
action  on  an  actual  path  is  minimal,  and  therefore  the  assertion  we 
have  made  is  called  the  principle  of  least  action.  Action  was  written 
in  the  form  (10.2)  by  Hamilton.  Much  earlier,  the  principle  of  least 
action  was  mathematically  formulated  by  Euler  for  the  special  case 
of  paths  corresponding  to  constant  energy. 

For  us,  it  is  not  essential  that  the  action  should  be  a  minimum,  but 
that  it  should  be  steady,  88  =  0. 

Lagrango's  equations  are  derived  from  the  principle  of  least  action 
by  means  of  proving  the  opposite.  We  assume  the  right-hand  side  of 
equation  (10.6)  to  be  zero,  8$  =  0,  and  the  variation  8q  to  be  arbitrary. 
Then,  if  the  expression  inside  the  parentheses  is  not  equal  to  zero, 
the  sign  of  the  variation  8q  can  always  be  chosen  to  be  the  same  as 

7\  T  A     y\  T 

for  the  quantity  -~—  —  ^-  ^-.  ,  because  the  variation  is  arbitrary.  If, 

f\  T  ft     P  7" 

for  example,  the  sign  of  the  quantity  -^  ---  -^  -^p-  changes  several 

times  along  the  path  of  integration,  then  the  sign  of  8q  must  also  be 
changed  accordingly  at  those  points  so  that  the  integrand  of  (10.6) 
should  everywhere  be  non-negative.  But  the  integral  of  a  non-nega- 
tive function  cannot  equal  zero  unless  the  function  is  equal  to  zero 

everywhere.  Therefore,  8$  =  0  only  when-^—  •  —  -rr-^-  becomes  zero 

^  oq          at    oq 

along  the  whole  path  of  integration,  for  otherwise  the  variation  8q 
can  be  so  chosen  that  88  >0.  We  have  shown  that  if  we  proceed 
from  the  principle  of  least  action  as  a  requirement  for  the  motion  along 
an  actual  path,  then  that  path  must  satisfy  Lagrange's  equations. 


Sec.  10]  GENERAL  PRINCIPLES   OF   MECHANICS  86 

The  advantages  of  using  action.  The  principle  of  least  action  may  at 
first  sight  appear  artificial  or,  in  any  case,  less  obvious  than  Newton's 
laws,  to  whose  form  we  are  accustomed.  For  this  reason  we  shall  try 
to  explain  where  its  advantages  lie. 

First  of  all,  let  it  be  noted  that  Lagrange's  or  Newton's  equations 
are  always  associated  •  with  some  coordinates  whose  choisc  is,  to  a 
significant  extent,  arbitrary.  In  addition,  the  choice  of  coordinate 
system,  relative  to  which  the  motion  is  described,  is  also  arbitrary. 
Yet  the  motion  of  particles  along  actual  paths  in  a  mechanical  sys- 
tem expresses  a  certain  set  of  facts  which  cannot  depend  on  the 
arbitrary  manner  of  their  description.  For  example,  if  the  motion 
leads  to  a  collision  of  particles,  that  fact  must  always  be  represented 
in  any  description  of  the  system. 

But  it  is  precisely  the  integral  principle  that  is  especially  useful  in  a 
formulation  of  laws  of  motion  not  related  to  any  definite  choice  of 
coordinates,  the  value  of  the  integral  between  the  given  limits  being 
independent  of  the  choice  of  integration  variables.  The  extremal 
property  of  an  integral  cannot  be  changed  by  the  way  in  which  it  is 
calculated. 

The  integral  principle  S$  =  0  is  equivalent,  purely  mathematically, 
to  Lagrange's  equations  (2.21).  But  in  order  to  apply  it  to  any  actual 
system,  we  must  have  an  explicitly  expressed  Lagrangian.  It  may  be 
found  from  those  physical  requirements  which  should  be  imposed  on 
an  invariant  law  of  motion  that  is  independent  of  the  choice  of  coordi- 
nate axes  and  the  frame  of  reference. 

As  a  result  of  the  invariance  of  the  principle  of  least  action,  we  can 
consider  the  laws  of  mechanics  in  a  very  general  form,  and  this, 
therefore,  opens  the  way  for  further  generalizations. 

The  determinacy  of  the  Lagrangian.  Before  finding  an  explicit 
form  for  the  Lagrangian,  we  must  put  the  qiiestion:  Is  the  determined 
function  we  are  looking  for  single-valued  ?  We  shall  show  that  if  we 
add  the  total  time  derivative  of  any  function  of  coordinates  and  time, 

-IT-  /  (q,  t),  then  Lagrange's  equations  remain  unchanged.  This  can  be 

verified  either  by  simple  substitution  into  (10.7),  or  directly  from  the 
integral  principle.  Writing 

L=L'+±f(q,t),  (10.8) 

we  see  that 

'i  'i  'i  ti 

(10.9) 


The  variations  of  /  appear  in  the  variation  of  S  only  at  the  limits  of 
integration.  But  since  we  have  arranged  that  /  depends  on  the  coordi- 


86  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

nates  and  time,  but  not  on  the  velocities,  the  variation  of  /  is  expressed 
linearly  in  terms  of  the  variations  of  the  coordinates,  and  is  zero  at 
the  limits  of  integration.  Therefore, 


(10.10) 


Hence,  the  Lagrangian  is  determined  only  to  the  accuracy  of  the 
total  time  derivative  of  the  function  of  coordinates  and  time. 

Defining  forms  of  the  Lagrangian.  We  shall  now  formulate  in  more 
detail  those  requirements  which  the  integral  principle  expressing  laws 
of  mechanics  must  satisfy. 

First  of  all  we  note  that  the  form  of  this  principle  must  be  the  same 
for  different  inertia!  systems,  since  all  such  systems  are  equivalent. 
This  statement  follows  from  the  relatively  principle  (see  Sec.  8). 
The  essence  of  the  relativity  principle  consists  in  the  fact  that  the 
choice  of  an  inertial  coordinate  system  is  arbitrary,  while  the  physical 
consequences  of  the  equations  of  motion  cannot  be  arbitrary. 

Similarly  arbitrary  is  the  choice  of  the  origin  and  the  initial  instant 
of  time  and  also  orientation  of  the  coordinate  axes  in  space. 

It  must,  of  course,  be  borne  in  mind  that  the  form  of  action  is  by  no 
means  determined  by  speculation  ;  this  form  represents  no  less  a  gener- 
alization of  physical  experience  than  the  laws  of  Newton.  However, 
the  principle  of  least  action,  best  expresses  the  invariance  of  physical 
laws  to  the  method  of  their  formulation.  Quite  naturally,  the  form  of 
the  invariance  (in  relation  to  rotations,  translations,  reflections,  etc.) 
is  itself  a  certain,  very  broad,  generalization  of  experience,  and  must 
by  no  means  be  considered  as  a  priori. 

Considering  now  the  problem  of  finding  the  form  of  the  Lagrangian, 
let  us  first  of  all  determine  the  action  of  a  free  particle  in  an  inertial 
coordinate  system.*  In  such  a  system,  the  particle  moves  uniformly 
in  a  straight  line,  i.  e.,  with  constant  velocity.  (This  statement  is  based 
on  the  experimental  fact  that  inertial  systems  exist  in  nature).  Thus, 
the  Lagrangian  for  a  free  particle  in  an  inertial  system  cannot  con- 
tain any  coordinate  derivatives  other  than  velocity. 

By  definition,  a  free  particle  is  very  far  away  from  any  other  bodies 
with  which  it  could  interact.  Therefore,  its  Lagrangian  must  not  change 
its  form  upon  displacement  of  the  origin  to  any  arbitrary  point  fixed 
in  the  given  inertial  system.  In  other  words,  the  Lagrangian  of  such  a 
particle  does  not  depend  explicitly  on  the  coordinates. 

In  this  way,  one  can  conclude  that  the  Lagrangian  does  not  depend 
explicitly  on  time. 


*  See  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits,  Mechanics,  Fizmatgiz,  1958. 


Sec.  10]  GENERAL   PRINCIPLES   OF   MECHANICS  87 

The  orientation  of  the  coordinate  axes  is  arbitrary  as  well  as  the 
choice  of  the  origin.  For  the  Lagrangian  to  be  independent  of  the  orien- 
tation of  coordinate  axes,  it  must  be  scalar  quantity. 

To  summarize,  then,  the  Lagrangian  is  a  scalar  that  depends  only 
on  the  velocity  of  the  free  particle  relative  to  the  given  inertial  system. 
The  only  scalar  quantity  which  can  be  formed  from  a  vector  is  the 
absolute  value  of  the  vector.  Therefore, 


The  form  of  this  function  can  be  found  from  the  relativity  principle, 
in  accordance  with  which  the  Lagrangian  must  not  change  with  the 
transformation  from  one  inertial  system  to  another.  In  Newtonian 
mechanics,  this  transformation  is  effected  with  the  aid  of  equations 
(8.1),  (8.2),  i.e.,  Galilean  transformations.  The  Galilean  transforma- 
tions led  to  the  law  of  addition  of  velocities  : 


where  V  is  the  relative  velocity  of  the  inertial  systems.  Therefore, 
the  Lagrangian  must  remain  invariant  with  respect  to  Galilean  trans- 
formations. 

Since  the  Lagrangian  is  determined  to  a  total  derivative,  it  is  suffi- 
cient (for  its  invariance)  for  the  following  equality  to  be  satisfied: 

£  =  L(^)  =  L[(v'  +  V)2]  =  L(i;'2)  +  g)  (J0.ll) 

where  the  functions  L  (v2)  and  L  (v'2)  have  the  same  form  in  accordance 
with  the  principle  of  relativity. 

Any  transformation  (8.1),  (8.2),  in  which  the  relative  velocity  V 
is  finite,  can  be  obtained  by  a  set  of  infinitely  small  transformations 
applied  successively.  It  is,  therefore,  sufficient  to  consider  a  transforma- 
tion in  which  the  relative  velocity  of  the  inertial  systems  V  is  very 
much  smaller  than  the  particle  velocity  v.  Then,  to  a  very  good  approx- 
imation, the  quantity  (v'+V2)  is  equal  to 


where  the  term  of  the  second  order  of  smallness  is  discarded. 

Expanding  L  [(v'  +  V)2)]  in  a  series,  we  obtain,  to  the  same  approx- 
imation, 


Comparing  this  with  (10.11),  we  find: 

3L    gy'Y-    dL    gy<*r/ 

0(v'a)  ""  d(v'*)       V    dt    ~~      dt 


88  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

However,  the  expression  on  the  left-hand  side  of  the  equation  can 

/•)  7 

be  a  total  derivative  of  the  function  of  coordinates  only  if  g    /a    is 
independent  of  velocity.  Introducing  the  notation 

BL          m  , 

-7jT^r2y  =  -y  =  const , 

we  obtain 

di~  ~~~dim      ' 
for,  otherwise,   .  (  ,2)    could  not  be  put  inside  the  derivative  sign. 

In  this  way  we  have  shown  that  the  Lagrangian  for  a  free  particle 
is  equal  to 

£(V2)  =  -^-ra.  (10.12) 

The  Lagrangian  for  a  system  of  noninteracting  particles  is  equal 
to  the  sum  of  the  Lagrangians  of  these  particles  taken  independently, 
since  it  is  the  only  sum  of  quadratic  expressions  of  the  type  (10.12) 
that  changes  by  a  total  derivative  when  Vi==v,/+V  (where  i  is  the 
particle  number)  is  substituted. 

In  order  to  write  down  L  for  a  system  of  interacting  particles,  we 
must,  of  course,  make  certain  physical  assumptions  about  the  nature 
of  the  interaction. 

1)  The  interaction  does  not  depend  on  the  particle  velocities.  This 
assumption  is  justified  for  gravitational  and  electrostatic  forces,  and 
is  not  justified  for  electromagnetic  forces.  It  should,  however,  be  noted 
that  electromagnetic  interactions  involve  ratios  of  particle  velocities 
and  the  velocity  of  light  c,  and  therefore,  to  the  approximation  of 
Newtonian  mechanics,  they  must  be  considered  as  negligibly  small. 
The  Lagrangian  of  Newtonian  mechanics  is  not  universal  and  is  appli- 
cable only  to  a  limited  group  of  phenomena,  when  all  V{  <^  c. 

2)  The  interaction  docs  not  change  the  masses  of  the  particles. 

3)  The  interaction  is  invariant  with  respect  to  Galilean  transforma- 
tions. 

From  these  conditions  it  can  be  seen  that  the  interaction  appears 
in  the  Lagrangian  in  the  form  of  a  scalar  function  determined  only 
by  the  relative  distribution  of  the  particles: 


(10.13) 


From  this  expression,  we  can  find  the  conservation  laws  for  energy, 
linear  momentum,  and  angular  momentum  (see  Sec.  4). 

The  Hamiltonian  function.  We  shall  now  use  the  principle  of  least 
action  in  order  to  transform  a  system  of  equations  of  motion  to  other 
variables.  Namely,  in  place  of  coordinates  and  velocities  we  shall 


Sec.  10]  GENERAL   PBINCIPLES    OF   MECHANICS  89 

employ  coordinates  and  momenta.  Let  us  assume  that  velocities  are 
eliminated  from  the  relations 

P  =  -ff.  (10.14) 

Since  the  Lagraiigian  depends  quadratically  on  the  velocities,  equa- 
tions (10.14)  are  linear  in  the  velocities  and  can  always  be  solved.  We 
shall  obtain  for  coordinates  and  momenta  a  more  symmetrical  system 
of  equations  than  Lagrange's  equations. 

The  passing  from  velocities  to  momenta  was  performed  to  some  ex- 
tent when  we  substituted  the  integrals  of  motion  in  the  expression  for 
energy,  for  example,  in  (5.4),  (9.21),  (0.22). 

Now,  in  place  of  the  velocities  we  shall  introduce  into  the  energy 
the  momenta  for  all  the  degrees  of  freedom,  (and  not  only  for  the  cyclic 
ones,  i.  e.,  those,  whose  coordinates  do  not  appear  explicitly  in  L). 
Energy  expressed  in  terms  of  coordinates  and  momenta  only  is  called 
the  Hamiltonian  function  of  the  system  or,  for  short,  the  Hamiltonian  : 

<?[q,q(p)]^Jf(q,p)=qp-L.  (10.15) 

Thus,  for  example,  if  we  replace  &  by  ~  in  (9.23),  we  obtain  the 
Hamiltonian  for  a  symmetrical  top: 

(10.16) 

Hamilton's  equations.  In  order  to  derive  the  required  system  of 
equations,  we  write  the  expression  for  the  principle  of  least  action, 
expressing  L  in  terms  of  jtf*  : 

ti 

(10.17) 


Here  it  is  assumed  that  q  is  expressed  in  terms  of  p  and  q. 
Let  us  calculate  the  variation  88: 


The  second  term  inside  the  parentheses  can  be  integrated  by  parts, 
similar  to  the  way  that  it  was  done  in  (10.5).  This  gives 


The  integrated  part  becomes  zero  when  limits  of  integration  have  been 
substituted.  The  independent  variables  are  now  p  and  q.  The  variation 


90  MECHANICS  [Part  I 

of  p,  as  well  as  the  variation  of  q,  is  completely  arbitrary  in  sign.  For 
88  to  bo  equal  to  zero,  the  following  equations  must  be  satisfied: 


This  system  of  equations  is  more  symmetrical  than  Lagrange's 
equations.  Instead  of  v  second-order  Lagrangian  equations,  we  have 
2  v  first-order  equations  (10.18).  They  are  called  Hamilton's  equa- 
tions. 

Reducing  the  order  with  the  aid  ol  the  energy  integral.  If  #F  does  not 
depend  on  time,  we  can  exclude  time  completely  from  the  equations 
by  dividing  all  the  equations  (10.18),  except  one,  by  the  said  equation. 
Then  we  have 


if-—  w-  (10-19> 

dp 

Here,  for  simplicity,  this  operation  has  been  performed  for  a  system 
with  one  degree  of  freedom.  The  integration  of  (10.19)  yields  one  con- 
stant. The  second  constant  will  be  determined  by  quadrature  from  the 
equation 

(10.20) 


where    „  -  is  a  certain  function  q  which  can  be  obtained  by  integrating 
(10.19).  The  constant  of  integration  in  (10.20)  is  the  initial  instant  £0. 

The  connection  between  momentum  and  action.  We  shall  now  show 
that  if  action  is  calculated  for  the  actual  paths  of  a  system,  then  mo- 
mentum can  be  very  simply  expressed  in  terms  of  this  action.  For  this 
we  shall  consider  the  change  in  action  when  the  ends  of  the  integra- 
tion interval  are  displaced  along  the  actual  paths.  From  (10.7),  the 
expression  under  the  integral  sign  in  (10.5)  is  equal  to  zero  on  such 
paths.  But  the  integrated  part  does  not  become  zero  ;  only  the  varia- 
tions in  it  must  be  replaced  by  differentials,  since  we  are  considering 
the  displacement  of  the  ends  of  the  integration  interval  along  given 
paths.  Therefore, 

dS^^dq-^-dqQ=pdq-pQdq0  (10.21) 

in  agreement  with  the  definition  of  momentum  (4.13). 

But  action  calculated  along  an  actual  path  is  uniquely  determined 
by  its  initial  and  final  points  8  =  8  (qQ,  q).  So 

dS  =  --dq0+-8-dq.  (10.22) 


SeC.  10]  GENERAL  PRINCIPLES   OF   MECHANICS  91 

Comparing  (10.21)  and  (10.22),  we  obtain  the  very  important  rela- 
tionship between  momentum  and  action 

*-•£•   *•---£•  (10-23) 

which  is  very  essential  for  the  formulation  of  quantum  mechanics. 

Exercise 

Write  down  the  Hamiltonian  and  Hamilton's  equations  for  a  particle 
in  a  central  field. 


PART    II 
ELECTRODYNAMICS 


Sec.  11.  Vector  Analysis 

The  equations  of  electrodynamics  gain  considerably  in  conciseness 
and  vividness  if  they  are  written  in  vector  notation.  In  vector  notation, 
the  arbitrariness  associated  with  the  choice  of  one  or  another  coordi- 
nate system  disappears,  and  the  physical  content  of  the  equations 
becomes  more  apparent. 

We  have  assumed  that  the  reader  is  acquainted  with  the  elements  of 
vector  algebra,  such  as  the  definition  of  a  vector  and  the  various  forms 
of  vector  products.  However,  in  electrodynamics,  vector  differential 
operations  are  also  used.  This  section  is  devoted  to  a  definition  of  vec- 
tor differential  operations  and  to  proofs  of  their  fundamental  proper- 
ties, which  will  be  needed  later. 

The  vector  of  an  area.  We  first  of  all  give  a  definition  of  the  vector 
of  an  elementary  area  rfs.  This  is  a  vector  in  the  direction  of  the  normal 
to   the  area,  numerically   equal  to  its  surface  and  related  to    the 
direction    of   traverse    of   the 
contour   around   the   area  by 
the   corkscrew  rule   (Fig.  15). 

d* 


Fig.  15 


Fig.  16 


We  shall  make  use  of  a  right-handed  coordinate  system  x,  y,  z,  in 
which,  if  we  look  from  the  direction  of  the  z-axis,  the  ar-axis  is  rotated 
towards  the  t/-axis  in  an  anticlockwise  sense  (Fig.  16).  In  this  system, 


Sec.  11]  VECTOR  ANALYSIS  93 

the  vector  area  can  be  resolved  into  components  which  are  expressed 
thus : 

dsx—dydz,  dsy  =  dzdx,  dsx=dxdy. 

Vector  flux.  Now  suppose  that  a  liquid  of  density  1   ("water") 
flows  tlirough  the  area,  the  flow  velocity  being  represented  by  the 
vector  v.  We  shall  call  the  angle  between  v  and  ds,  a.  Fig.  17  shows 
the  flow  lines  of  the  liquid  passing  through  ds. 
They  are  parallel  to  the  velocity  v.  Let  us  calcu- 
late the  amount  of  liquid  that  passes  tlirough  the  ds^ 
area  ds  every  second.  Obviously,  it  is  equal  to  the 
amount  that  passes  through  the  area  ds',  placed    ^ 
perpendicular  to  the  flux  and  intersected  by  the 
same  flow  lines  as  pass  through  ds.  This  quantity  is 
simply  equal  to   v  ds',   because  every  second  a 
liquid  cylinder  of  base  ds'  and  height  v  passes 
through  the  area  ds'.  But  ds'  —  ds  cos  a,  whence             j?ig.  17 
the  quantity  of  liquid  we  are  concerned  with  is 

dJ=v  ds'  =  v  ds  cos  a^=vds.  (11.1) 

By  analogy,  the  scalar  product  of  any  vector  A  (taken  at  the  point 
of  infinitesimal  area)  on  ds  is  called  the  flux  of  the  vector  A  across 
the  area  ds.  Similar  to  the  way  that  the  flow  of  liquid  across  a  finite 
area  s  is  equal  to  the  integral  of  dJ  with  respect  to  the  surface, 

J-Jvds,  (11.2) 

the  integral 

(11.3) 


is  called  the  flow  (flux)  of  the  vector  A  across  any  area. 

The  area  vector  is  introduced  so  that  we  can  make  use  of  the 
noncoordinate  and  convenient  notation  of  (11.3).  The  integrals 
appearing  in  (11.3)  are  double.  In  terms  of  the  projections  of  (11.3) 
we  can  write 


J=\  AdsE=J  \Axdydz  +  (JAydzdx 


where  the  limits  of  the  double  integrals  are  determined  from  the  cor- 
responding projections,  onto  the  coordinate  planes,  of  the  contour 
bounding  the  surface. 

The  Gauss-Ostrogradsky  theorem.  Let  us  now  calculate  the  vector 
flux  through  a  closed  surface.  For  this  we  shall  consider,  first  of  all, 
the  infinitesimal  closed  surface  of  a  parallelepiped  (Fig.  18).  We 
shall  make  the  convention  that  the  normal  to  the  closed  surface 
will  always  be  taken  outwards  from  the  volume. 


94  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

Let  us  calculate  the  flux  of  the 
vector  A  across  the  area  A  BCD 
(the  direction  of  traverse  being  in 
agreement  with  the  direction  of  the 
normal).  Since  the  flux  is  equal  to 
the  scalar  product  of  A  by  the  vec- 
tor area  A  BCD,  in  the  negative 
^-direction  (and  hence  equal  to 
dydz),  we  obtain  for  this  infinitely 

small  area 

Fig.  18 

dJABCD  =  —  Ax  (x)  dy  dz. 

We  get  a  similar  expression  for  the  area  A'B'C'D',  only  in  this  case 
the  projection  dsx  is  equal  to  dy  dz,  and  Ax  is  taken  at  the  point 
x  +  dx  instead  of  x.  And  so 

dJA'ffc'D'  —  Ax  (x  +  dx)  dy  dz. 

Thus  the  resultant  flux  through  both  areas,  perpendicular  to  the 
#~axis,  is 

+  dJADCD  =  [Ax(x  +  dx)  —  Ax  (x)]  dy  dz  =  -—-dxdydz. 


-— 

(11.4) 

We  have  utilized  the  fact  that  dx  is  an  infinitely  small  quantity, 
and  we  have  expanded  Ax(x  +  dx)  in  a  series.  The  resultant  fluxes 
across  the  boundaries  perpendicular  to  the  y  and  z  axes  are  formed 
similarly.  The  resultant  flux  across  the  whole  parallelepiped  is 


A  finite  closed  volume  can  be  divided  into  small  parallelepipeds, 
and  the  relationship  (11.6)  applied  to  each  one  of  them  separately. 
If  we  sum  all  the  fluxes,  the  adjacent  boundaries  do  not  give  any 
contribution,  since  the  flux  emerging  from  one  parallelepiped  enters 
the  neighbouring  one.  Only  the  fluxes  through  the  outer  surface 
of  the  selected  volume  remain,  since  they  are  not  cancelled  by  others. 
But  the  right-hand  sides  of  (  1  1.6)  will  be  additive  for  all  the  elementary 
volumes  dV  —  dx  dy  dz,  yielding  the  very  important  integral  theorem: 

-  <"-6> 


It  is  called  the  Gauss-Ostrogradsky  theorem. 

The  divergence  of  a  vector.  The  expression  appearing  on  the  right- 
hand  side  under  the  integral  sign  can  be  written  down  in  a  much 
shorter  form.  We  first  of  all  notice  that  it  is  a  scalar  expression, 
since  there  is  a  scalar  on  the  left-hand  side  in  (11.6)  and  dV  is  also 


Sec.  11]  VECTOR  ANALYSIS  95 

a  scalar.  This  expression  is  called  the  divergence  of  the  vector  A 
and  is  written  thus: 


The  divergence  can  be  defined  independently  of  any  coordinate 
system,  if  (11.5)  is  used.  Indeed,  from  (11.5)  the  definition  for  diver- 
gence follows  as 

fAds 
divA=sUm^~  —  .  (11.8) 

F->-0         V 

The  divergence  of  a  vector  at  a  given  point  is  equal  to  the  limit 
of  the  ratio  of  the  vector  flux  through  the  surface  surrounding  the 
point  to  the  volume  enveloped  by  the  surface,  when  the  surface  is 
contracted  into  the  point. 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  vector  A  denotes  the  velocity  field  of 
some  fluid.  Then,  from  the  definition  (11.8),  it  can  be  seen  that  the 
divergence  of  the  vector  A  is  a  measure  of  the  density  of  the  sources 
of  the  fluid,  for  it  is  obvious  that  the  more  sources  there  are  in  unit 
volume,  the  more  fluid  will  flow  out  of  the  closed  volume.  If  div  A 
is  negative,  we  can  speak  of  the  density  of  vents.  But  it  is  more 
convenient  to  define  the  source  density  with  arbitrary  sign.  We 
note  that  from  (11.7)  there  follows  the  quantity 


since  r  has  components  x,  y,  z. 

Contour  integrals.  We  shall  now  consider  the  vector  integral  of 
a  closed  contour  having  the  following  form: 

z).  (11.10) 

This  single  integral  is  called  the  circulation  of  the  vector  over  the 
given  contour.  For  example,  if  A  is  the  force  acting  on  any  particle, 
then  A  dl  =  A  dl  cos  a  is  the  work  done  by  the  force  on  the  contour 
element  dl  and  C  is  the  work  performed  in  covering  the  whole  contour. 

Stokes5  theorem.  We  shall  now  prove  that  the  circulation  of  the 
vector  A  around  the  contour  can  be  replaced 
by  the  surface  integral  "pulled   over"  the       y 
contour. 

Let  us  consider  the  projection  of  an  in- 
finitely small  rectangular  contour  onto  the 
plane  yz.  Let  this  projection  also  have  the 
form  of  a  rectangle  shown  in  Fig.  19.  We 


shall  calculate  the  circulation  of  A  around  Fig.  19 


96  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

this  rectangle.  The  side  A  B  contributes  a  component  Ay  (z)  dy 
arid  side  CD  the  component  —  Ay(z  +  dz)dy,  where  the  minus 
sign  must  be  written  because  the  direction  of  the  vector  CD  is 
opposite  to  that  of  the  vector  AB.  We  obtain,  for  the  sum  due  to 
the  sides  AB  and  CD, 


(wo  have  expanded  Ay  (z  +  dz)  in  a  series  for  dz),  while  for  the  sides 
BC  and  DA, 

dA 
A;  (y  +  dy)  dz  —Az  (y)  dz  -  -  Q?-  dydz  . 

The  resultant  value  for  circulation  in  the  yz-plane  is 


The  notation  Bx  is  clear  from  the  equation.  Let  us  now  find  out 
what  meaning  this  expression  has.  From  the  definition  of  (11.10), 
circulation  is  a  scalar  quantity  and,  hence,  on  the  right  side  of  equation 
(11.11)  there  must  also  be  a  scalar  quantity.  If  the  contour  lies  in 
the  plane  yz,  this  quantity  is  of  the  form  dC~Bxdsx\  consequently, 
for  an  arbitrary  orientation  of  the  contour,  the  relationship  (11.11) 
must  have  the  form  of  the  scalar  product 


where  Bx,  By,  Bz  must  necessarily  be  the  components  of  a  vector, 
since,  otherwise,  dC  could  not  be  a  scalar.  From  (11.11), 

/?  —  3AZ  _  dAy  .-       ~. 

*~~~~W.  —  aT-  (ii.id) 

In  order  to  findrthe  circulation  for  infinitely  small  contours  in 
the  xz,  yz  planes,  it  is  sufficient  to  perform  a  cyclic  permutation 
of  the  indices  x,  y,  z.  This  permutation  yields  the  components  By,  Bz  : 


The  vector  B  has  a  special  name:  it  is  called  the  rotation  or  curl 
of  the  vector  A  and  is  denoted  thus: 

B=rot  A. 

rot  A  is  expressed  in  terms  of  unit  vectors  i,  j,  k,  directed  along 
the  coordinate  axes: 


C.  11]  VECTOR    ANALYSIS  97 


Changing  to  the  notation  (11.16),  we  see  that  the  component  of 
rot  A  normal  to  the  area  appears  in  equation  (11.11): 


J 


A  dl  =  rot*  A  <fa  ,  (11.17) 


where  the  subscript  n  of  rot  A  indicates  that  we  must  take  the  pro- 
jection of  rot  A  normal  to  the  area,  i.e.,  coinciding  with  the  vector  ds. 
(11.17)  permits  us  to  define  rot  A  in  a  noncoordinate  manner,  similar 
to  the  way  that  we  defined  div  A  in  (11.8),  namely: 

(Adi 
rotn  A  --=  lim  -  ---  ,  (11.18) 

5  ->  0  '9 

or  the  projection  of  rot  A,  normal  to  the  area  at  the  given  point, 
is  the  limit  of  the  ratio  of  the  circulation  of  A,  over  the  contour 
of  the  area,  to  its  value  when  the  contour  is  contracted  into  the  point. 

So  that  the  integral  JA  dl  should  not  become  zero,  we  must  have 
closed  vector  lines,  to  some  extent  following  the  integration  contour, 
which  lines  are  simila.r  to  the  closed  lines  of  flow  in  a  liquid  during 
vortox  motion.  Hence  the  term  curl,  or  rotation. 

If  the  circulation  is  calculated  from  a  finite  contour  then  the  contour 
can  be  broken  up  into  infinitely  small  cells  to  form  a  grid.  For  the 
sides  of  adjacent  cells,  the  circulations  mutually  cancel  since  each 
side  is  traversed  twice  in  opposite  directions;  only  the  circulation 
along  the  external  contour  itself  remains.  The  integral  on  the  right- 
hand  side  of  equation  (11.17)  gives  the  flux  of  rot  A  across  the  surface 
"pulled  over"  the  contour.  Thus,  we  obtain  the  desired  integral 
theorem 

[Adl-JrotAds,  (11.19) 

which  is  called  Stokes'  theorem. 

Differentiation  along  a  radius  vector.  The  divergence  and  rotation 
of  a  vector  are  its  derivatives  with  respect  to  the  vector  argument. 
They  can  be  reduced  to  a  unified  notation  by  means  of  the  following. 
We  introduce  the  vector  symbol  V  (nabla*)  with  components 


Then,  from  (11.7),  we  obtain  for  the  divergence  of  A: 


*  Nabla  is  an  ancient  musical  instrument  of  triangular  shape.  This  symbol 
is  also  called  del. 

7-0060 


98  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

(11.21) 


x  - 


i.e.,  a  scalar  product  of  nabla  and  A. 
From  (11.16),  we  have  for  the  rotation 

rot  A  ~-  i  (Vy  Ax  —  Vz  A  y)  -t-  j  (  V*  Ax  —  V*  Az)  +  k  (  V*  AY  —  Vy  Ax 

«LVA].  (11.22) 

We  use  the  identity  symbol  --.  here  in  order  to  emphasize  the  fact 
that  we  are  simply  dealing  with  a  new  system  of  notation.  We  shall 
see,  however,  that  this  system  is  very  convenient  in  vector  analysis. 
We  note,  with  reference  to  algebraic  operations,  that  nabla  is  in 
all  cases  similar  to  a  conventional  vector.  We  shall  use  the  expression 
"multiplication  by  nabla"  if,  when  nabla  operates  on  any  expression, 
that  expression  is  differentiated.  Sometimes,  nabla  is  multiplied  by 
a  vector  without  operating  on  it  as  a  derivative,  in  that  case  it  is 
applied  to  another  vector  [see  (11.30),  (11.32)]. 

Gradient.  If  we  operate  with  V  on  a  scalar  9,  we  obtain  a  vector 
which  is  called  the  gradient  of  the  scalar  9: 


«V9=i+J         +  k.  (11.23) 

Its  components  are: 

V,9  =  |J,     V,9-|J,     V.9-4J-  (H-24) 

From  equations  (11.24),  it  can  be  seen  that  the  vector  V9  is  per- 
pendicular to  the  surface  9  =  const.  Indeed,  if  we  take  a  vector  dl 
lying  on  this  surface,  then,  in  a  displacement  dl,  9  does  not  change. 
This  is  written  as 

0>        (11.25) 


i.e.,  V9  is  perpendicular  to  any  vector  which  lies  in  the  plane  tangential 
to  the  surface  9  =  const,  at  the  given  point,  which  accords  with  oiir 
assertion. 

Differentiation  of  products.  We  now  give  the  rules  governing 
differential  operations  with  V. 

First  of  all,  the  gradient  of  the  product  of  two  scalars  is  calculated 
as  the  derivative  of  a  product: 


(11.26) 

The  divergence  of  a  product  of  a  scalar  with  a  vector  is  calculated 
thus  : 

div  9  A  =  (Vep,  9  A)  +  (VA,  9  A)  =  (AV?)  +  9  (VA)  - 

=^A  grad  9  +  9  div  A.  (11.27) 

Here  the  indices  9  and  A  attached  to  V  show  what  V  is  applied  to. 


Sec.  11]  VECTOR   ANALYSIS  99 

We  find  the  rotation  of  9  A  in  a  similar  manner: 

rot  9  A=  [V9,  9  A]  +  [V^,  9  A]  =  [grad  9,  A]  +  9  rot  A  .     (11.28) 
Now  we  shall  operate  with  V  on  the  product  of  two  vectors: 
div  [AB]-(V  [AB])  =  (V^  [AB])  +  (Vu  [AB]). 


We  perform  a  cyclic  permutation  in  both  terms,  since  V  can  be 
treated  in  the  same  way  as  an  ordinary  vector.  In  addition,  we  put  B 
after  VB  in  the  second  term,  and  here,  as  usual,  we  must  change 
the  sign  of  the  vector  product.  The  result  is 

div  [AB]  =  (B  [VA  A])  —  (A  [VB  B])=B  rot  A  —  A  rot  B.  (11.29) 

Let  us  find  the  rotation  of  a  vector  product.  Here  we  must  use  the 
relationship  [A[BC]]  -B  (AC)  —  C  (AB): 

rot  [AB]  =  [VA  [AB]]  +  [VB  [AB]]  =  (VA  B)  A  —  (VA  A)  B  +  (  VB  B)  A  — 
—  (AVB)  B  =  (BV)  A  —  B  div  A  +  A  div  B  —  (AV)  B.  (11.30) 

Here  we  note  the  new  symbols  (BV)  and  (AV)  operating  on  the 
vectors  A  and  B.  Obviously,  (AV)  and  (BV)  are  symbolic  scalars, 
equal,  by  definition  of  V,  to 

(AV)  =  A,  Vx  +  AyVY  +  A,V,  =  Ax^  +  Ar-^  +  A,  -J--  ,         (11.31) 

and  similarly  for  (BV).  Then,  (AV)  B  is  a  vector  which  is  obtained 

by  application  of  the  operation  (11.31)  to  all  the  components  of  B. 

Of  the  operations  of  this  kind,  we  have  yet  to  calculate  grad  AB  : 

grad  (AB)  =VA  (AB)  +VB  (AB). 
We  use  the  same  transformation  as  in  the  preceding  case: 

grad  (AB)  =  (BVA)  A  +  [B  [VAA]]  +  (AVB)  B  +  [A  [VBB]]  = 

=  (BV)  A  +  (AV)  B  +  [B  rot  A]  +  [A  rot  B].  (  1  1.32) 

Certain  special  formulae.  We  note  certain  essential  cases  of 
operations  involving  V. 

From  the  definition  of  divergence  (11.7),  we  obtain  from  (11.27) 
and  (11.9) 

div^=  -1  divr  +  r  grad-»  =  ~  -  -^  -  0  .         (11.33) 
Further, 


and  in  general 

rotr  =  0.  (11.34) 


100  KLECTBO  DYNAMICS  [Part    II 

We  now  take 


and  for  all  components  of  r  at  once 

(AV)r  =  A.  (11.35) 

In  addition,  we  apply  V  to  a  vector  depending  only  on  the  absolute 
value  of  the  radius  vector.  We  note  first  of  all  that 


fCf.  (3.3.),  where   1/r  is  differentiated],  so  that 

Vr  =  y.  (11.36) 

Using  the  rule  for  differentiating  a  function  of  a  function,  we  have 
div  A  (r)  =  -.-  Vr  =  AL.  (11.37) 


Here  A  is  a  total  derivative  of  A  (r)  with  respect  to  the  argument  /*, 
i.e.,   a    vector  whose  components  are  the  derivatives  of  the  three 
components  of  A  (r)  with  respect  to  r:  Ax,  Av,  As. 
Further, 

rotA<r)=|ArJJ-]  =  J^-.  (11.38) 

Repeated   differentiation.  Let   us   investigate   certain  results  con- 
cerning repeated  operations  with  V. 

The  rotation  of  the  gradient  of  any  scalar  is  equal  to  zero: 

rot  grad  9  -  |  "V,V?I  =  [VVJ  9=0,  (11.39) 

since  the  vector  product  of  any  vector  (including  V)  by  itself  is  equal 
to  zero.  This  can  also  be  seen  by  expanding  rot  grad  9  in  terms  of  its 
components.  The  divergence  of  a  rotation  is  also  equal  to  zero: 

div  rot  A  =  (V  [VA])  =  ([VV]  A)-=0  .  (11.40) 

Let  us  write  down  the  divergence  of  the  gradient  of  a  scalar  9  in 
component  form.  From  equations  (11.7)  and  (11.24)  we  have 

divgrad9HVV)<p=8-+  S-  +  -S--ACP.          (11.41) 
Here  A  (delta)  is  the  so-called  Laplacian  operator,   or  Laplaciaii: 

A=   *L+    a2_  +  _^_ 

dx*   ~r   dy*   ""     dz*  ' 


Sec.  11] 


VECTOR   ANALYSIS 


101 


Filially,  the  rotation  of  a  rotation  can  be  expanded  as  a  double 
vector  product: 

rot  rot  A-  [V  [VA]]=V  (VA)— (VV)  A-grad  div  A— A  A  .  (11.42) 

The  last  eqiiation  can  be  regarded  as  a  definition  of  AA.  In  curvi- 
linear coordinates,  A'cp  and  A  A  are  expressed  differently. 

Curvilinear  coordinates.  We  shall  further  show  how  the  gradient, 
divergence,  and  rotation,  as  well  as  A  of  a  scalar  appear  in  curvilinear 
coordinates. 

Curvilinear  coordinates  ql9  q2,  q3  are  termed  orthogonal  if  only  the 
quadratic  terms  dql,  dql,  dql  appear  in  the  expression  for  the 
element  of  length  dl2,  and  not  the  products  dq^  dq2,  dql  dq&  dq%  rf</3, 
similar  to  the  way  that  dl2  =  dx2  +  dy2  +  dz2  in  rectangular  coordinates. 
In  orthogonal  coordinates 

dl2  =  fil  dql  +  hl  dq\-\-hl  dql .  (11.43) 

For  example,  in  spherical  coordinates  qr  =  r,  q2  =  $,q3  =  cp.  The  element 
of  length  is 


so  that 


sn 


Let  us  construct  an  elementary  parallelepiped  (Fig.  20).  Then  the 
components  of  the  gradient  will  be 

Cf 


— 


d  q3 


C 


(11.44) 


In  order  to  find  the  divergence  we  repeat 
the  proof  of  the  Gauss-Ostrogradsky  theorem 
for   Fig.  20.  The   area  ADCB  is  equal  to  h2  \ 
vector  A  through  it  is 


Fig.  20 
i  dq2  dq%.  The  flux  of 


Here,  A2  and  A3  are  also  taken  for  a  definite  value  of  qv  The  sum  of  the 
fluxes  through  the  areas  ADCB  and  A'B'C'D'  is 


where  we  have  used  the  expansion  of  the  quantity  h2  h%  A±  at  the 
point  ql  +  dqt  in  terms  of  dql9  jn  a  way  similar  to  (11.4).  The  total  flux 
across  all  the  boundaries  is 


102  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 


dj  ^   ?7  (h*  h*  AI)  +   r  (AS  hi  AZ)  +  ~i  (AI  *•  ^s)  dqi  dq*  dq*  * 

Let  us  now  take  advantage  of  the  definition  of  divergence  (11.8): 

dJ  -div  A-  /4  A2  ^3  ^?i  ^2  d#3  =div  Adi  V  . 
Hence, 


(11.45) 

If,  instead  of  Av  A%,  A3,  we  substitute  the  expressions  (11.44),  the 
result  will  be  the  Laplacian  of  a  scalar  in  orthogonal  curvilinear  coor- 
dinates. Thus,  in  spherical  coordinates  it  is 


With  the  aid  of  Stokes'  theorem,  we  can  also  calculate  the  rotation 
in  curvilinear  coordinates.  We  shall  give  it  for  reference  without 
proof: 

,    .         l    /  d     A    7  8      f 

rotl  A  =  -  A*   3  ~  '*        2 


ro  D 


, 

rot« 

3 


-A-  ~~~"  i  "  7"*"  l  ~~/\     •**•  i  •  ^i         o      -^*-  1  '  t'o  l  « 
Mi  \  0ft  ^^i     3  3/ 

.  I     I    d      A     i  B       4     j    \ 

A  =  ,—,-  \  ~—A~h»  —  «    -  .4  T  //!   . 

M|  \a?i  a«a       J     V 


(11.47) 


Exercises 

Whore  (from  the  requirements  of  the  problem)  expressing  in  terms  of  coordi- 
nates is  not  demanded,  it  is  recommended  that  only  the  vector  equations  of  the 
present  section  (11.2ti)-(11.42)  be  used. 

1)  Calculate  the  expressions:  Answers: 

a)  A—     (r^O).  A  —  =divgrad—  *=*  — div  —  =  0. 

b)div9(r)r,   rot  9  (r)  r  .  89  4- 7-9;  0. 

c)  V  (Ar),   TAC  A  =  const.  At 

d)V(A(r)r).  A+l(rA). 

e)  div  9  (r)  A  (r),  rot  9  (r)  A  (r) .  1  (rA)  +  1  (pA) .  _t  [rAj  +  f  [rA]  t 

f )  div  [r  [Ar]],    A  =  const.  —  2  (Ar)  . 

g)  rot  [r  [Ar]],    A  =  const.  3  [rA] . 

h)AA(r)    [CM.  (11,42)].  i  + -?- JL 

r 

i)   V(A(r)B(r)).  1 

r 

j)  rot[Ar],    A  =  const.  2 A. 

k)  div  [Ar],    A  -  const.  0 

DA!.  ^a 

r  r> 


See.  11]  VECTOR  ANALYSIS  103 

2)  Write  down  A^  in  cylindrical  coordinates. 

3)  Write  down  the  three  components  of  AA  in  spherical  coordinates. 

4)  Two  closed  contours  are  given.  The  radius  vector  of  points  of  the  first 
contour  is  rx,  of  the  second  contour,  r>.  The  elements  of  length  along  each 
contour  are  dl^  and  d\2,  respectively.  Prove  that  the  integral 


is  equal  to  zero,  4  TT,  8  w,  and  n-4  it,  depending  upon  how  many  times  the  first 
contour  is  wound  round  the  second,  linking  up  with  the  latter.  v\  denotes  diffe- 
rentiation with  respect  to  rx  (Ampere's  theorem). 

Changing  the  order  of  integration  and  performing  a  cyclic  permutation  of  the 
factors,  we  have 


We  apply  Stokes'  theorem  (11.19)  to  the  integral  in  d}l: 


Wo  use  equation  (11.30)  ;  rotj  denotes  differentiation  with  respect  to  tho  compo- 
nents rx;  and  d\2  in  such  a  differentiation  may  be  regarded  as  a  constant  vec- 
tor: 


In 

to 

accoi 
zero. 
rotx  1  ' 

LVll', 

'dance 
Tliere 

with 
rerru 

|    .      -2J  ' 

exercise 
ains,  ther 

,  di.]- 

—  \ifi2  v 

la,  the 
efore, 

(dlaVi 

if  vi  1  r  r  1  " 
last  term  containing  At  - 

\  *                      —       /ji  *-, 

.  v 

1   l  r   r 
1 

equal 

1': 
i) 

i-M  1S 
i 

T7 

Vl|'i- 

-r2l 

)Vl|rx-ra| 

Vi   I  r  r 

'2!   ' 

since  a  function  of  the  difference  TI  —  r.2  is  differentiated. 

For  short,  we  write  r=rx  —  r2.  Then  the  required  integral  will  be 

*  =  —  J  (d\2  V2)  J  <*Si  Vi  |ri_ra|    =  —  J  (dl*  Vi)  J  ^»i  V  —  • 

We  shall  now  explain  tho  geometrical  sense  of  the  second  integrand,  i.e., 

d^  v  —  =  --  -  —  L-^-  •  -y  .    Tho  scalar  product  -  -  -  is  the  projection   of 

an  element  of  the  surface  d^  pulled  over  the  first  contour,  on  the  radius  vector 

r  drawn  from  a  point  on  the  second  contour.  In  other  words,  -  -  -  is  equal 

to  the  projection  of  the  area  da  ±  on  a  plane  perpendicular  to  r.  This  projection, 
divided  by  r2,  is  equal  to  the  solid  angle  d&  at  a  point  r2  on  the  second  contour 

subtended  by  the  area  dsr  The  integral  I  -  —  3  —  -  is,  therefore,  that  solid  angle 

n  which  is  obtained  if  a  cone  is  drawn  with  vertex  at  the  point  r2,  so  that  the 
generating  line  of  the  cone  formed  the  contour  lt. 

The  differential  (d\2  V2)  Q  is  the  increment  of  solid  angle  O  obtained  in 
shifting  along  the  contour  12  a  distance  d\2.  Thus, 


J  (d\2  V2)  Q 


The  integral  of  this  quantity  around  a  closed  contour  is  equal  to  the  total 
change  in  solid  angle  in  traversing  the  contour  12.  Let  the  initial  point  of  cir- 
cumvention lie  on  the  surface  «x.  Then  the  solid  angle  subtended  by  the  surface 


104  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  TT 

at  the  origin  is  —  2  TC.  If  the  contours  aro  linked,  then  the  solid  angle  will  be 
2  T:  after  the  circumvention,  since  the  ure,a  is  observed  from  a  terminal  point 
on  the  other  side.  If  the  contours  are  riot  linked,  then  the  solid  angle  is  once 
again  its  initial  value,  —  2  TC,  arid  the  integral  is  equal  to  zero.  Thus,  when  the 
contours  are  linked  n  times,  the  integral  in  d\2  is  equal  to  4  TC  n. 


Sec.  12.  The  Electromagnetic  Field.  Maxwell's  Equations 

Interaction  in  mechanics  and  in  electrodynamics.  The  interaction 
of  charged  bodies  in  electrodynamics  is  principally  an  interaction  of 
charges  with  an  electromagnetic  iield.  However,  the  physical  concept 
of  the  iield  in  electrodynamics  differs  essentially  from  the  field  concept 
in  Newtonian  mechanics. 

We  know  that  the  space  in  which  gravitational  forces  act  is  called  a 
gravitational  iield.  The  values  of  these  forces  at  any  point  of  the  Held 
is  determined,  in  Newtonian  mechanics,  by  the  instantaneous  positions 
of  the  gravitating  bodies,  no  matter  how  far  they  are  from  the  given 
point.  In  electrodynamics,  such  a  iield  representation  is  not  satis- 
factory :  during  the  time  that  it  takes  an  electromagnetic  disturbance 
to  move  from  one  charge  to  another,  the  latter  can  move  a  very  great 
distance.  Elementary  charges  (electrons,  protons,  mesons)  very  often 
have  velocities  close  to  the  velocity  of  propagation  of  electromagnetic 
disturbances. 

Modern  gravitational  theory  (the  general  theory  of  relativity,  sec 
Sec.  20)  shows  that  gravitational  interaction,  too,  propagates  with  a 
finite  velocity.  But  since  macroscopic  bodies  move  considerably 
slower,  within  the  scale  of  the  solar  system,  the  finite  velocity  of 
propagation,  of  gravitational  forces  introduces  only  an  insignificant 
correction  to  the  laws  of  motion  of  Newtonian  mechanics. 

Tn  the  electrodynamics  of  elementary  charges,  the  finite  velocity  of 
propagation  of  electromagnetic  disturbances  is  of  fundamental  signi- 
ficance. When  speaking  of  point  charges,  the  action  of  a  field  on  the 
charge  is  always  determined  only  by  the  field  at  the  point  where  the 
charge  is  located,  and  only  at  the  instant  when  the  charge  is  at  this 
point.  As  opposed  to  the  "action  at  a  distance"  of  Newtonian  mecha- 
nics, such  interactions  are  termed  "short-range." 

If  the  energy  or  momentum  of  a  charged  particle  is  changed  under 
the  action  of  a  field,  they  can  be  imparted  directly  only  to  the  electro- 
magnetic field,  since  a  finite  interval  of  time  is  necessary  for  the  energy 
and  momentum  of  other  particles  to  be  changed.  But  this  means  that 
the  electromagnetic  field  itself  possesses  energy  and  momentum, 
whereas  in  Newtonian  mechanics  it  was  sufficient  to  assume  that  only 
the  interacting  particles  possessed  energy  and  momentum.  It  follows 
from  this  that  the  electromagnetic  field  is  itself  a  real  physical  entity 
to  exactly  the  same  extent  as  the  charged  particles.  The  equations  of 
electrodynamics  must  describe  directly  the  propagation  of  electro- 


See.  12]  THE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD.    MAXWELL  \S    EQUATIONS  105 

magnetic  disturbances  in  space  and  the  interaction  of  charges  with  the 
field. 

Interaction  between  charges  is  effected  through  the  electromagnetic 
field.  Such  laws  as  the  Coulomb  or  Biot-Savart  laws  (in  which  only 
the  instantaneous  positions  and  the  instantaneous  velocities  of  the 
charges  appear)  are  of  an  approximate  nature  and  are  valid  only  when 
the  relative  velocities  of  the  charges  are  small  compared  with  the 
propagation  velocity  of  electromagnetic  disturbances. 

It  will  be  shown  later  that  this  velocity  is  a  fundamental  constant 
which  appears  in  the  equations  of  electrodynamics.  It  is  equal  to  the 
velocity  of  light  in  vacuo  and,  to  a  high  degree  of  precision,  is 
3  x  IQIQ  cm/sec. 

A  field  in  the  absence  of  charges.  The  independent  reality  of  the 
electromagnetic  field  is  particularly  evident  from  the  fact  that  electro - 
dynamic  equations  admit  of  a  solution  in  the  absence  of  charges. 
These  solutions  describe  electromagnetic  waves,  in  particular  light 
waves,  in  free  space.  Thus,  electrodynamics  has  shown  that  light  is 
electromagnetic  in  nature. 

In  the  course  of  two  centuries,  the  protagonists  of  the  wave  theory 
of  light  considered  that  light  waves  were  propagated  by  a  special 
elastic  medium  permeating  all  space,  the  so-called  "ether."  In  order 
to  represent  the  spread  of  oscillations  it  was,  naturally,  necessary  to 
have  something  oscillating.  This  "something"  was  called  the  ether. 
Proceeding  from  an  analogy  with  the  propagation  of  sound  waves 
in  a  continuous  medium,  the  ether  was  endowed  with  the  properties 
of  a  fluid,  physical  phenomena  being  explained  simply  by  reducing 
them  to  definite  mechanical  displacements  of  bodies.  In  particular, 
light  phenomena  were  regarded  as  displacements  of  particles  of  the 
special  medium,  the  ether. 

In  this,  a  peculiar  "abhorrence  of  a  vacuum"  was  apparent  or,  more 
exactly,  a  purely  speculative  representation  of  empty  space  where 
"nothing  exists"  and,  hence,  where  nothing  can  occur.  Physicists  did 
not  at  once  come  to  realize  that  the  electromagnetic  field  itself  was 
just  as  real  as  the  more  tangible  "ponderable  matter."  Electrodynamic 
laws  are  those  elementary  concepts,  from  which  the  interaction  of 
atoms  should  be  deduced,  which  interaction  accounts  for  the  proper- 
ties of  real  fluids  that  are  incomparably  more  complicated  than  the 
properties  of  a  field  in  "empty  space/'  i.e.,  in  the  absence  of  charges. 
There  is  no  sense  in  reducing  a  field  to  an  imaginary  fluid  merely  in 
order  to  avoid  the  idea  of  "empty  space."  Physical  space  is  the  carrier 
of  the  electromagnetic  field  and  is,  therefore,  inseparable  from  the 
state  and  motion  of  real  objects.  As  regards  the  term  "ether,"  which 
still  persists  in  the  field  of  radio,  it  expresses  nothing  other  than  the 
electromagnetic  field. 

The  electromagnetic  field.  Let  us  now  establish  the  basic  equations 
of  electrodynamics.  We  shall  proceed  from  certain  elementary  laws, 


106  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

which  we  assume  the  reader  knows  from  a  general  course  of  physics 
or  electricity.  These  laws  will  first  be  used  in  the  absence  of  matter 
consisting  of  atoms  or,  as  is  usually  said  in  electrod3^namics,  in  the 
absence  of  a  "material  medium."  By  this  term  we  must  not  under- 
stand any  encroachment  on  the  material  nature  of  the  electromagnetic 
iield  itself.  From  the  electrodynamic  equations  for  free  space  we  shall, 
later  on,  derive  the  equations  for  an  electromagnetic  field  in  a  medium 
(a  conductor  or  dielectric). 

As  is  known,  the  electromagnetic  field  in  a  medium  is  described  by 
four  vector  quantities:  the  electric  field,  the  electric  induction,  the 
magnetic  iield,  and  the  magnetic  induction.  The  force  acting  on  unit 
electric  charge  at  a  given  point  in  space  is  called  the  electric  field 
intensity.  In  future,  instead  of  the  field  intensity,  we  shall  simply 
speak  of  the  field  at  a  given  point  in  space.  The  magnetic  field  intensity 
or,  for  short,  the  magnetic  field  is  defined  analogously.  Separate  magne- 
tic charges,  unlike  electric  charges,  do  not  exist  in  nature;  however, 
if  we  make  a  long  permanent  magnet  in  the  form  of  a  needle,  then  the 
magnetic  force  acting  at  its  ends  will  be  the  same  as  if  there  existed 
point  charges  at  the  ends. 

A  rigorous  definition  of  the  electric  and  magnetic  induction  vectors 
will  be  given  in  Sec.  1C,  where  the  field  equations  in  a  medium  will  be 
derived  from  the  equations  for  point  charges  in  free  space.  It  need 
only  be  recalled  that  in  free  space  there  is  no  need  to  use  four  vectors 
for  a  description  of  the  electromagnetic  field,  only  two  vectors  being 
sufficient:  the  electric  and  magnetic  fields. 

System  of  units.  We  shall  consider  that  all  electromagnetic  quanti- 
ties are  expressed  in  the  CGSE  system,  i.e.,  in  the  absolute  electro- 
static system  of  units.  In  this  system  the  dimensions  of  electric  charge 
are  gnW«  •  cm3/»/sec  and  the  dimensions  of  field  intensity,  both  electric 
and  magnetic,  are  gmVi/cmVa  •  see.  If  we  substitute  charge,  expressed 
in  this  .system  of  units,  into  the  equation  for  Coulomb's  law,  then  the 
interaction  force  between  charges  is  expressed  in  dynes  (gm  •  cm/sec2). 

Electromotive  force.  Let  us  recall  the  definition  for  electromotive 
force  in  a  circuit :  this  is  the  work  performed  by  the  forces  of  the 
electric  field  when  unit  charge  is  taken  along  the  given  closed  circuit. 
And  it  is  absolutely  immaterial  what  the  given  circuit  represents: 
whether  it  is  filled  with  a  conductor  or  whether  it  is  merely  a  closed 
line  drawn  in  space.  Let  us  write  down  the  expression  for  electromotive 
force  (abbreviated  as  e.  m.  f.)  in  the  notation  of  Sec.  11.  The  force 
acting  ou  unit  charge  at  a  given  point  is  the  electric  field  E.  The  work 
done  by  this  force  on  an  element  of  path  d\  is  the  scalar  product  Ed  1. 
Then,  the  work  done  on  the  whole  closed  circuit,  or  the  e.  m.  f.,  is 
equal  to  the  integral 

e.m.f.-  j*Edl.  (12.1) 


Sec.  12]  THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC   FIELD.    MAXWELL'S   EQUATIONS  107 

Magnetic-field  flux  across  a  surface.  Let  us  suppose  that  some 
surface  is  bounded  by  the  given  circuit.  We  shall  denote  the  magnetic 
field  by  the  letter  H.  The  magnetic-field  flux  through  an  element  of 
the  chosen  surface  is,  by  the  definition  given  in  Sec.  11,  d  O  —  HdS. 
The  magnetic-field  flux  through  the  whole  surface,  bounded  by  the 
circuit,  is 

O  =  fHds.  (12.2) 

It  can  be  conveniently  represented  thus.  Let  us  consider  a  section 
of  the  surface  through  which  unit  flux  A  *  =  1  (in  the  CGSE  system) 
passes.  We  draw  through  this  section  of  the  surface  a  line  tangential 
to  the  direction  of  the  field  at  some  point  on  the  surface.  A  line  which 
is  tangential  to  the  direction  of  the  field  at  its  points  is  called  a  magnetic 
line  of  force.  For  this  reason,  the  total  flux  4»  is  equal,  by  definition, 
to  the  number  of  magnetic  lines  of  force  crossing  the  surface. 

Magnetic  lines  of  force  are  either  closed  or  extended  to  infinity. 
Indeed,  a  magnetic  line  offeree  may  begin  or  end  only  at  a  single  charge, 
but  separate  magnetic  charges  do  not  exist  in  nature.  In  a  permanent 
magnet  the  lines  of  force  are  completed  inside  the  magnet. 

From  this  it  follows  that  a  magnetic  flux  through  any  surface, 
bounded  by  a  circuit,  is  the  same  at  a  given  instant.  Otherwise,  a 
number  of  the  magnetic  lines  of  force  would  have  to  begin  or  end  in 
the  space  between  the  surfaces  through  which  different  fluxes  pass. 
Consequently,  at  a  given  instant,  a  constant  number  of  magnetic 
lines  of  force,  i.e.,  a  constant  magnetic  field  flux  passes  across  any 
siirface  bounded  by  the  circuit.  Therefore,  the  flux  can  be  ascribed 
to  the  circuit  itself,  irrespective  of  the  surface  for  which  it  is  calculated. 

Faraday's  induction  law.  Faraday's  induction  law  is  written  in  the 
form  of  the  following  equation: 

e.m.f.  — i£.  (12.3) 

If  all  the  quantities  are  expressed  in  the  CGSE  system,  then  the 
constant  of  proportionality  c  is  a  universal  constant  with  the  di- 
mensions of  velocity  equal  to  3  x  1010  cm/sec. 

Usually,  Faraday's  law  is  applied  to  circuits  of  conductors ;  however, 
e.  in.  f.  is  simply  the  quantity  of  work  performed  by  unit  charge  in 
moving  along  the  circuit,  and,  for  a  given  field  value  through  the 
circuit,  cannot  depend  upon  the  form  of  the  circuit.  The  e.  m.  f.  is 

simply  equal  to  the  integral  f  Edl.  In  a  conducting  circuit,  this  work 

can  be  dissipated  in  the  generation  of  Joule  heat  ("an  ohmic  load"). 
However,  it  is  completely  justifiable  to  consider  the  circuit  in  a  vacuum 
also.  In  this  case,  the  work  performed  on  the  charge  is  spent  in  increas- 
ing the  kinetic  energy  of  the  charged  particle,  as,  for  instance  in  the 
case  in  an  induction  accelerator,  the  betatron. 


1(>8  0LECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Maxwell's  equation 'fop  rot  E.  Thus,  equation  (12.3)  refers  to  any 
arbitrary  closed  circuit.  WeliuTwtitute  the  definitions  (12.1)  and  (12.2) 
into  this  equation: 

(12.4) 


The  left-hand  side  of  the  equation  can  be  transformed  by  the 
Stokes  theorem  (11.19)  and,  on  the  right-hand  side,  the  order  of  the 
time  differentiation  and  surface  integration  can  be  interchanged,  since 
they  are  performed  for  independent  variables.  In  addition,  taking 
this  integral  over  to  the  left-hand  side,  we  obtain 

8  =  0.  (12.5) 

But,  the  initial  circuit  is  completely  arbitrary,  i.e.,  it  can  have 
arbitrary  magnitude  and  shape.  Let  us  assume  that  the  integrand,  in 
parentheses,  of  (12.5)  is  not  equal  to  zero.  Then  we  can  choose  the  sur- 
face and  the  circuit  that  bounds  it  so  that  the  integral  (12.5)  does  not 
become  zero.  Thus,  in  all  cases,  the  following  equation  must  be  satis- 
fied: 

rotE  +  y  ajJ-=-0.  •"'  (12.6) 

Tn  comparison  with  (12.3),  this  equation  does  not  contain  anything 
new  physically ;  it  is  the  same  induction  law,  but  rewritten  in  differen- 
tial form  for  an  infinitely  small  circuit  (contour).  In  many  applications 
the  differential  form  is  more  convenient  than  the  integral  form. 

We  shall  see  later  that  the  constant  c  is  equal  to  the  velocity  of 
light  in  free  space.  ? 

The  equation  for  4'iv  II.  As  we  have  already  said,  magnetic  lines  of 
force  are  either  closed  or  go  off  to  infinity.  Hence,  in  any  closed  surface, 
the  same  number  of  magnetic-field  lines  enter  as  leave.  The  magnetic- 
field  flux  in  free  space,  across  any  closed  surface,  is  equal  to  zero: 

f*Hds-0.  (12.7) 

Transforming  this  integral  to  a  volume  integral  according  to  the 
Gauss-Ostrogradsky  theorem  (11.6),  we  obtain 

>.  (12.8) 

Due  to  the  fact  that  the  surface  bounding  the  volume  is  completely 
arbitrary,  we  can  always  choose  this  volume  to  be  so  small  that  the 
integral  is  taken  over  the  region  in  which  div  H  has  constant  sign  if 

it  is  not  equal  to  zero.  But  then,  in  spite  of  (12.7)  and  (12.8),  j  div  H  d  F 

will  not  be  equal  to  zero.  For  this  reason,  the  divergence  of  H  must 
become  zero: 


vSeC,  12J  THE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD.    MAXWELL'S    EQUATIONS  109 

divH  =  0.  (12.9) 

(12.9)  is  the  differential  form  of  (12.7)  for  an  infinitely  small  volume. 
In  Sec.  11  it  was  shown  that  the  divergence  of  a  vector  is  the  density 
of  sources  of  a  vector  field.  The  sources  of  the  field  are  free  charges 
from  which  the  vector  (force)  magnetic-field  lines  originate.  Thus, 
(12.9)  indicates  the  absence  of  free  magnetic  charges. 

Equations  (12.6)  and  (12.9)  are  together  called  the  first  pair  of 
Maxwell's  equations.  ,M 

Let  us  now  introduce  thev  second  pair. 

The  equation  for  (UvJE..  The  electric-field  flux  through  a  closed  surface 
is  not  equal  to  zero,  but  to  the  total  electric  charge  e  inside  the  surface 
multiplied  by  4  TC  (Gauss'  theorem)  : 

v  Jli     -.      fEds  =  47ue.    v  (12.10) 

This  theorem  is  derived  from  Coulomb's  law  for  point  charges. 
The  field  due  to  a  point  charge  v  is  expressed  by  the  following  equation: 


Here,  r  is  a  radius  vector  drawn  from  the  point  situated  at  the  charge 
to  the  point  where  the  field  is  defined.  The  field  is  inversely  propor- 
tional to  r2  and  is  directed  along  the  radius  vector. 

Let  us  surround  the  charge  by  a  spherical  surface  centred  on  the 

charge.  The  element  of  surface  for  the  sphere  rfs  is  r2d£l  --,  where 
d  Q  is  an  elementary  solid  angle  and  —  indicates  the  direction  of  the 
normal  to  the  surface.  The  flux  of  the  field  across  the  surface  element  is 


The  flux  across  the  whole  surface  of  the  sphere  is  I  ed£l^=e  |d£fc^ 

~4  TT  e.  But  since  lines  of  force  begin  only  at  a  charge,  the  flux  will 
be  the  same  through  the  sphere  as  through  any  closed  surface  around 
the  charge.  Therefore,  if  there  is  an  arbitrary  charge  distribution  e 
inside  a  closed  surface,  then  equation  (12.10)  holds. 

In  order  to  rewrite  this  equation  in  differential  form,  we  introduce 
the  concept  of  charge  density.  The  charge  density  gjs  the  charge  con- 
tairied  in  unit  volume,  so  that  the  total  charge  in  the  volume  is  related 
to  the  density  by  the  following  equation: 


e^lpdF.  (12.11) 

Ae 
Hence,  p=lim  -^ .  Introducing  the  charge  density  in  (12.10),  we 

obtain      AF->O 


110  ELECTKODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

0.  (12.12) 


Repeating  the  same  argument  for  this  integral  as  we  used  for  (12.8), 
we  have 

divE-=4jcp.  (12.13) 

According  to  (11.  8)  we  can  say  that  the  density  of  sources  of  an 
electric  field  is  equal  to  the  electric  charge  density  multiplied  by  4  ru. 

The  density  function  for  point  charges.  The  density  function  for 
point  charges  is  obtained  by  a  limiting  process.  Let  us  initially  assume 
that  a  iinite  quantity  of  charge  is  distributed  in  a  small,  but  finite, 

volume  A  V.  Then  p  must  be  regarded  as  the  ratio  -^  . 

If  we  let  the  volume  A  V  tend  to  zero,  then  the  density  will  have  a 
very  peculiar  form:  it  will  turn  out  to  be  equal  to  zero  everywhere 
except  at  the  place  where  the  charge  is  situated,  and  at  that  point  it 

will  convert  to  infinity,  since  the  numerator  of  the  fraction  -rrr  is 
finite  and  the  denominator  is  infinitely  small.  However,  the  integral 


remains  equal  to  the  charge  e  itself.  Thus,  the  concept  of  charge  density 
can  also  bo  used  in  the  case  of  a  point  charge.  In.  this  case,  p  is  under- 
stood to  be  a  function  which  is  equal  to  zero  everywhere  except  at  the 
point  of  the  charge.  The  volume  integral  of  this  function  is  either  equal 
to  the  charge  e  itself,  if  the  charge  is  situated  inside  the  integration 
region,  or  zero,  if  the  charge  is  outside  the  region  of  integration. 

The  charge  conservation  law.  One  of  the  most  important  laws  of 
electrodynamics  is  the  law  of  conservation  of  charge.  The  total  charge 
of  any  system  remains  constant  if  no  external  charges  are  brought  into 
it.  In.  all  charge  transformations  occurring  in  nature,  the  law  of  con- 
servation of  charge  is  satisfied  with  extreme  precision  (while  the  law 
of  conservation  of  mass  is  approximate!). 

In  order  to  formulate  the  charge-conservation  la\v  in  differential 
form,  we  must  introduce  the  concept  of  current  density.  This  vector 
quantity  is  defined  as 

j  =  pv,  (12.14) 

where  v  is  the  charge  velocity  at  the  point  where  the  density  p  is 
defined.  The  dimensions  of  charge  density  are  charge/cm3,  and  of 
current  density,  charge/cm2  •  sec  (i.e.,  the  dimensions  of  charge  pass- 
ing in  unit  time  through  unit  area).  For  a  point  charge,  v  denotes 
its  velocity  and  p  the  density  function  defined  above. 
The  total  current  emerging  from  an  area  is 

/  =  [jds=  fp(vds).  (12.15) 


Sec.  12]  THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIKLD.    MAXWELL'S    EQUATIONS  111 

It  must  be  equal  to  the  reduction  of  charge  inside  the  surface  in 
unit  time,  i.e., 

l  =  -~  (12.16) 

(the  charge-conservation  law  in  integral  form).  Substituting  e  from 
(12.11)  and  transforming  /  by  the  Gauss-Ostrogradsky  theorem, 
we  obtain 

F=0.  (12.17) 

Since  the  volume,  over  which  the  integration  is  performed  is  arbitrary, 
the  conservation  law  for  charge  in  differential  form  follows  from 
(12.17): 

^  +  divj  =  -|£  +  divpv  =  0.  (12.18) 

Displacement  current.  From  direct-current  theory,  it  is  known 
that  current  lines  are  always  closed.  Indeed,  open  circuited  lines 
indicate  that  there  is  either  an  accumulation  or  deficiency  of  charge 
at  their  ends.  But  we  can  also  define  vector  lines  such  that  they 
will  always  be  closed  (or  will  have  to  go  off  to  infinity)  in  the  case 

of  alternating  currents.  For  this  we  substitute  the  derivative  -?-  , 
according  to  (12.13),  into  the  equation  of  the  charge-conservation 
law  (12.18).  This  derivative  is  equal  to  — -—-div-^— .  Hence,  we 
always  have  the  relation 


Comparing  (12.19)  and  (12.9),  we  see  that  the  vector  lines 

.  1     3E 

J    •"   47c     dt 

are  always  closed.  The  vector ~  is  called  the  displacement  cur- 
rent  density.   Together    with    the    charge -transport 
current  j,  the  displacement  current  forms  a  closed 
system  of  current  lines. 

The  displacement  current  can  be  more  vividly 
demonstrated  in  the  following  way.  Fig.  21  shows 
a  capacitor  whose  plates  are  joined  by  a  conductor. 
The  current  /  flowing  in  the  conductor  is  equal 
to  the  change  of  charge  on  the  plates  in  unit  ~. 
time :  j  __  &e_  lg* 

But  the  charge  on  the  plates  is  related  to  the  field  in  the  capacitor 
by  the  relationship 


112  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 


where  /  is  the  area  of  the  plates.  Whence 

r   _      f       2K 

47T       ~dt     ' 

Consequently,  the  quantity  --  ---  7—  can  be  interpreted  as  the  density 
of  some  current  which  completes  the  conduction  current,  of  density 
7  =  -  This  corresponds  to  the  more  general  equation  (12.19). 

The  conception  that  the  magnetic  action  of  a  displacement  current 
does  not  difter  from  the  magnetic  action  of  ordinary  current  is  basic 
to  MaxweJlian  electrodynamics. 

Magnetomotive  force.  By  analogy  with  electromotive  force  f  Edl, 

r 
we   deli  ne   the   magnetomotive   force     11  e/1,    where   the    integration 

is  performed  over  a  closed  circuit.  Using  the  Biot-Savart  law  for 
direct  currents,  it  may  be  shown  that  the  magnetomotive  force  in 
a  closed  circuit  is  equal  to  the  electric  current,  /,  crossing  a  surface 

47C 

bounded  by  the  circuit,  multiplied  by  --•  In  other  words, 


(12.20) 

This  relationship  can  be  shown  most  simply  by  assuming  that 
a  direct  current  /  is  flowing  through  an  infinitely  long  straight-line 
Circuit.  We  shall  calculate  the  magnetomotive  force  in  a  circuit  of 
circular  form,  the  current  line  passing  through  the  centre  of  the 
circle  perpendicular  to  its  plane.  The  magnetic  field  is  tangential 

to  the  circle  and  equal  to  //  —  -"  rin  accordance  with  the  Biot-Savart 

law,  where  r  is  the  radius  of  the  circle.  Thus,  for  the  circuit  we  have 
chosen,  the  absolute  value  of  II  is  constant  and  the  magnetomotive 

force  is  equal  to  2nrH^  —  ^    . 

For  a  circuit  of  arbitrary  form,  we  should  use  the  Biot-Savart 
law  in  differential  form: 


Then  the  magnetomotive  force  is  represented  by  the  integral 


However,  in  accordance  with  Ampere's  theorem  (exercise  4,  Sec.  11), 
this  integral  is  equal  to  —  —  if  the  circuit  in  which  the  magneto- 


motive force  is  calculated  is  linked  with  the  current-carrying  circuit. 


Sec.  12]  THE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD.    MAXWELL'S    EQUATIONS  113 


The  equation  H&r.  EQlLH.  Following  Maxwell,  we  shall  assume  that 
equation  (12.20)  is  also  true  for  displacement  current  if  the  lield 
is  variable.  The  current  lines  will  then  always  be  closed,  and  in  cal- 
culating magnetomotive  force  we  can  use  all  the  arguments  that 
we  have  used  for  continuous  current.  In  the  case  of  varying  fields 
and  currents,  /,  in  the  formula  for  magnetomotive  force,  denotes 

the  total  current  passing  through  the  circuit,  i.e.,  the  sum  |  j  ds  +  ~r— 
j-rfds.  Naturally,  this  assumption  is  not  obvious  beforehand 

and  is  justified  by  the  fact  that  Maxwell's  equations  provide  for  the 
explanation  or  prediction  of  the  entire  assemblage  of  phenomena 
relating  to  rapidly  changing  electromagnetic  fields  (the  displacement 
current  does  not  usually  exist  for  slowly  varying  fields). 

Let  us  assume  that  the  total  current  is  formed  by  the  current 
produced  by  charge  transport  (of  density  equal  to  j)  combined  with 

a  displacement  current  with  density  -.  -  (  -  .  In  accordance  with 
our  assumption, 


(12.21) 


Transforming   the   left-hanJ    side   of  (12.20)   in   accordance    with 
Stockcs'  theorem  (11.19)  and  combining  with  /,  we  obtain 


Applying  the  same  argument  to  eqiiation.  (12.22)  as  applied  to 
(12.5),  we  arrive  at  the  differential  equation 

rotll-  1J?A_1^L=0.  (12.23) 

c     dt  c  v  ' 

It  is  easy  to  see  that  this  equation  agrees  with  the  law  of  charge 
conservation.  Indeed,  we  operate  on  it  by  div.  According  to  (11.40), 
div  rot  H  =0,  so  that  we  are  left  with 


Substituting  div  E  from  (12.13),  we  arrive  once  again  at  (12.18),  i.e., 
the  law  of  conservation  of  charge. 

Equation  (12.23)  is  not  merely  an  expression  for  the  Biot-Savart 
law  in  differential  form.  In  (12.23),  we  have  introduced  the  displace- 
ment current,  which  is  not  involved  in  the  theory  of  continuous 
currents. 

The  Maxwell  system  of  equations.  Let  us  once  again  write  down 
the  system  of  Maxwell's  equations  for  free  space. 

8-0060 


114  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

The  first  pair: 


divH  =  0.  (12.25) 

The  second  pair: 


(12.27) 

In  these  equations  we  consider  p  and  j,  i.e.,  the  charge  and  current 
distributions  in  space,  to  he  known.  The  unknowns,  to  be  determined, 
are  the  fields  E  and  II.  Each  of  them  has  three  components. 

In  spite  of  the  fact  that  both  pairs  form,  together,  eight  equations, 
only  six  of  them  are  independent,  according  to  the  number  of  field 
components.  Indeed  the  three  components  of  each  rotation  are 
constrained  by  div  rot  =-  0  and,  hence,  are  not  independent  of  one 
another. 

Electromagnetic  potentials.  We  can  introduce  new  unknown  quan- 
tities such  that  each  equation,  will  contain  only  one  unknown.  In 
tins  way  the  overall  number  of  equations  is  reduced.  These  new 
quantities  are  called  electromagnetic  potentials. 

We  choose  the  potentials  so  that  the  first  pair  of  Maxwell's  equations 
are  identically  satisfied,  hi  order  to  satisfy  equation  (12.25),  it  is 
sufficient  to  put 

II  -rot  A,  (12.28) 

where  A  is  a  vector  called  the  vector  potential.  Then,  according  to 
(11.40),  the  divergence  of  II  will  be  equal  to  zero  identically.  We 
shall  look  for  the  electric  field  in  the  form: 


where  9  is  a  quantity  called  the  scalar  potential. 

From  (11.39)  rot^Vcp=0.  Substituting  (12.28)  and  (12.29)  in 
(12.24),  we  obtain  the  identity. 

The  detcrminacy  of  potentials.  The  electromagnetic  fields  E  and  H 
are  physically  determinate  quantities  since,  through  them,  the  forces 
acting  on  charges  and  currents  can  be  expressed.  The  fields  are  ex- 
pressed in  terms  of  potential  derivatives.  Therefore,  potentials  are 
determined  only  to  the  accuracy  of  the  expressions  that  cancel  in 
differentiation.  These  expressions  shoiild  be  chosen  so  that  the  po- 
tentials satisfy  equations  of  the  simplest  form.  We  shall  now  find 
the  most  general  potential  transformation  which  does  not  change  the 
fields. 

From  equation  (12.28)  it  can  be  seen  that  if  we  add  the  gradient 
of  any  arbitrary  function  to  the  vector  potential,  the  magnetic 


Sec.  12]  THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD.    MAXWELL'S   EQUATIONS  115 

field  will  not  change,  since  the  rotation  of  a  gradient  is  identically 
equal  to  zero.  Putting 

A  =  A'+V/(*,y,M),  (12.30) 

we  see  that  the  magnetic  field,  expressed  in  terms  of  such  a  modified 
potential,  remains  unchanged: 


In  order  that  the  addition  of  V/  should  not  affect  the  electric  field, 
we  must  also  change  the  scalar  potential: 

?  =  <P'-4ff,  (12.31) 

where  /  is  the  same  function  as  in  (12.30).  Then,  for  the  electric 
field,  we  obtain 


_._--- 

_      i  a  A'      _  , 

~~~TTr~~  V(p  • 

Consequently,  the  electric  field  does  not  change  either.  Thus, 
the  potentials  are  determined  to  the  accuracy  of  the  transformations 
(12.30),  (12.31),  which  are  called  gauge  transformations. 

The  Lorentz  condition.  Let  us  now  choose  an  arbitrary  function  / 
such  that  the  second  pair  of  Maxwell's  equations  leads  to  equations 
for  the  potentials  of  the  simplest  possible  form.  Substituting  (12.28) 
and  (12.29)  in  (12.26)  gives 

rotrotA=-^--j-j>-V9  +  -±fi,  (12.32) 

We  express  rot  rot  A  with  the  aid  of  (11.42).  Then  (12.32)  is  reduced 
to  the  following  form: 


We  shall  now  try  to  eliminate  the  quantity  inside  the  brackets. 
We  denote  it,  for  brevity,  by  the  letter  a,  and  we  perform  the  trans- 
formations (12.30)  and  (12.31)  on  the  potentials.  Then  the  quantity 
a  is  reduced  to  the  form 

0=divA  +  14f=divA'  +  |4f  +  A/-i-g-.  (12.34) 

The  function  /  has,  so  far,  remained  arbitrary.  Let  us  now  assume 
that  it  has  been  chosen  so  as  to  satisfy  the  equation 

A/---  =  «.  (12.35) 


116  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Then,  from  (12.34),  it  is  obvious  that  the  potentials  will  be  subject 
to  the  condition 

~4r7-^°-  (12-36) 


This  is  called  the  Lorentz  condition. 

As  was  shown,  the  expression  of  fields  in  terms  of  potentials  is 
not  changed  by  a  gauge  transformation.  For  this  reason  we  shall 
always  consider,  in  future,  that  this  transformation  is  performed 
HO  that  the  Lorentz  condition  is  satisfied;  the  primes  in  the  potentials 
can  then  bo  omitted. 

The  equations  for  potentials.  From  the  Lorentz  condition  and 
(12.33),  we  obtain  the  equation  for  a  vector  potential: 


It  is  now  also  easy  to  obtain  the  equation  for  a  scalar  potential. 
From  (12.27)  we  have 

i    P 
div  E  =  ----  TTT  div  A  —  A9  =  **?  • 

C     f)t 

Substituting  div  A  from  the  Lorentz  condition  (12.36),   we  obtain 

(12.38) 


Equations  (12.37)  and  (12.38)  each  contain  only  one  unknown. 
Therefore,  each  equation  for  potential  does  not  depend  on  the  rest 
and  can  be  solved  separately. 

The  equations  for  potential  are  second  order  with  respect  to  coor- 
dinate and  time  derivatives.  For  a  solution,  it  is  necessary  to  give 
not  only  the  initial  values  of  the  potentials,  but  also  the  initial  values 
of  their  time  derivatives. 

Gauge  invarianco.  As  we  shall  see  later,  especially  in  the  following 
section  and  in  Sec.  21,  which  is  devoted  to  the  motion  of  charges 
in  an  electromagnetic  field,  it  is  necessary,  in  many  cases,  to  use 
equations  involving  potentials.  But,  since  potentials  are  ambiguous, 
we  must  take  care  that  the  form  of  any  equation  involving  potentials 
does  not  change  under  gauge  transformations  (12.30)  and  (12.31),* 
since  such  transformations  involve  a  completely  arbitrary  function 
/  which  can  be  chosen  to  be  of  any  form.  It  is  clear  that  no  physical 
result  can  depend  on  the  choice  of  this  function,  i.e.,  on  an  arbitrary 
gauge  transformation.  In  other  words,  equations  involving  potentials 
must  bo  gauge  invariant. 

*  This  does  not  refer  to  equations  (12.37)  and  (12.38),  from  which  the  poten- 
tials are  determined  in  accordance  with  the  condition  (12.36). 


Sec.  13]         THE  ACTION  PRINCIPLE  FOB  THE  ELECTROMAGNETIC  FIELD  117 

Sec.  13.  The  Action  Principle  for  the  Electromagnetic  Field 

The  variational  principle  lor  the  electromagnetic  field.  In  the  first 
part  of  this  book  it  was  shown  that  the  equations  of  mechanics, 
obtained  from  Newton's  laws  (Sec.  2),  lead  to  the  principle  of  least 
action  (Sec.  10).  We  obtained  the  equations  of  electrodynamics  in* 
the  preceding  sectioi}  by  proceeding  from  certain  simple  physical 
laws  and  the  assumption  about  the  magnetic  effect  due  to  displace- 
ment current.  In  this  section,  Maxwell's  equations  will  be  reduced 
to  the  variational  principle,  which  is  the  principle  of  least  action 
for  the  electromagnetic  field,  i 

Electrodynamics  is  not  equivalent  to  the  mechanics  of  particle 
systems  or  to  the  mechanics  of  liquids,  which  are  based  on  Newton's 
laws.  All  the  same,  to  a  very  considerable  extent,  electrodynamical 
laws  are  analogous  to  the  laws  of  mechanics.  This  analogy  can  best 
be  seen  from  the  principle  of  least  action  for  the  electromagnetic 
field. 

The  variational  formulation  best  of  all  allows  us  to  derive  the 
conservation  laws  for  the  electromagnetic  field.  The  corresponding 
integrals  of  motion  for  a  field  coincide  with  the  well-known  mechani- 
cal integrals- — energy,  linear  momentum,  and  angular  momentum. 
In  a  closed  system  consisting  of  charged  particles  and  a  field,  the 
total  energy,  total  linear  momentum,  and  total  angular  momentum 
of  the  charges  and  field  are  conserved. 

In  this  sense,  electrodynamics  is  indeed  "a  dynamics"  of  the  elec- 
tromagnetic field,  though  this  by  no  means  signifies  that  the  laws 
of  electrodynamics  can  be  obtained  from  Newton's  laws.  Both  are 
equivalent  to  certain  integral  variational  principles,  but  the  action 
functions  are,  of  course,  of  entirely  different  form. 

It  is  a  noteworthy  fact  that  Maxwell  at  first  tried  to  construct 
mechanical  models  of  the  ether,  but  in  his  later  work  he  rejected 
them  and  obtained  the  general  equations  of  electrodynamics  by 
means  of  a  generalization  of  known  elementary  laws  of  electro- 
magnetism. 

The  Lagrangian  function  for  a  field.  In  order  to  formulate  the  prin- 
ciple of  least  action  it  is  necessary  to  have  an  expression  for  the 
Lagrangian.  The  choice  of  Lagrangian  in  mechanics  is  determined 
by  considerations  based  on  the  relativity  principle  of  Newtonian 
mechanics,  which  is  formulated  with  the  aid  of  Galilean  transfor- 
mations (Sec.  8).  As  wiU  be  explained  in  detail  in  Sees.  20  and  21, 
Galilean  transformations  are  not  valid  in  electrodynamics  and  are 
replaced  by  the  more  general  Lorentz  transformations,  based  on 
the  Einstein  relativity  principle.  These  transformations  allow  the 
Lagrangian  for  the  electromagnetic  field  to  be  uniquely  found; 
this  will  be  done  in  Sec.  21.  In  this  section,  the  choice  of  Lagrangian 
is  justified  by  the  fact  that  the  already  familiar  Maxwell  equations 


118  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

are  obtained  from  it.  Similarly,  in  Part  I,  the  principle  of  least  action 
was  formulated  after  Lagrarige's  equations  had  been  obtained  on 
the  basis  of  Newton's  laws.  TJiis  confirmed  the  truth  of  the  integral 
principle. 

In  finding  the  Lagrangian  for  a  system  of  free  particles,  a  summa- 
tion is  performed  over  the  coordinates  of  the  particles.  The  electro- 
magnetic field,  if  we  use  the  terminology  of  mechanics,  is  a  system 
with  an  infinite  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  because,  for  a  complete 
description  of  tho  Held,  we  must  know  all  its  components  at  all  points 
of  space,  where  they  differ  from  zero.  But  the  points  of  space  form 
a  nondenumorabh?  set,  i.e.,  they  cannot  be  numbered  in  any  order, 
For  this  reason,  for  tho  electromagnetic  field  the  summation  in  the 
Lagrangian  is  replaced  by  an  integration  with  respect  to  continuously 
varying  parameters,  i.e.,  coordinates  of  points  in  which  the  field 
is  given.  The  point  coordinates  are  analogous  to  the  indices  which 
label  the  degrees  of  freedom  of  a  mechanical  system. 

The  equations  of  mechanics  are  second  order  in  time  with  respect 
to  generalized  coordinates  (jk.  The  equations  for  potentials  (12.37) 
and  (12.38)  are  also  second  order  in  time.  Therefore,  potential  quanti- 
ties should  be  chosen  as  the  generalized  coordinates. 

In  other  words,  A  (r,  t),  9  (r,  t)  correspond  to  qi*  (t),  where  A  and  9 
are  potentials  which  are  generalized  coordinates  of  an  electromagnetic 
field.  The  value  of  the  radius  vector  r  for  the  point  at  which  the  po- 
tential is  taken  corresponds  to  the  number  of  the  generalized  co- 
ordinate k. 

In  order  to  write  down  the  complete  Lagrangian  function,  we 
must  first  of  all  defino  it  in  an  element  of  volume  dV  and  integrate 
over  tho  volume  occupied  by  the  field.  It  has  already  been  mentioned 
that  in  this  section  we  will  proceed  immediately  from  a  Lagrangian 
that  leads  to  correct  Maxwell  equations;  the  choice  of  this  Lagrangian 
as  based  on  considerations  related  to  the  relativity  principle  will 
be  left  to  Sec.  21.  The  Lagrangian  is  of  the  following  form: 


Since  tho  potentials  are  liable  to  be  generalized  coordinates  of  the 
field,  expression  (13.1)  should  be  rewritten  thus: 


Here,  in  place  of  a  summation  over  the  degrees  of  freedom,  an 
integration  over  the  volume  has  been  performed. 
Tho  extremal  property  of  action  in  electrodynamics.  We  shall  now 

show  that  action,   i.e.,   S  =  I  L  dt,  possesses  the  same   variational 
property  in  electrodynamics  as  it  does  in  mechanics:  its  variation 


Sec.  13]         THE  ACTION  PRINCIPLE  FOR  THE  ELECTROMAGNETIC  FIELD  119 

becomes  zero  if  the  field  satisfies  the  correct  equations  of  motion 
(in  this  case,  the  Maxwell  equations). 
We  shall  begin  with  variation  with  respect  to  the  scalar  potential  9  : 

V.  (13.3) 

As  was  shown  in  Sec.  10,  variation  and  differentiation  are  com- 
mutative so  that   SV9  =  V  8  9.   According   to   (12.29)  we  replace 

the  term  (~^  +V<p\  by  —  E.  Therefore, 


We  shall  now  make  use  of  equation  (11.27),  in  accordance  with 
which 

E  V  $9  =  div  (£89)  -  89  div  E  .  (13.5) 

We  then  obtain 


=/  [  -"-^-F  *9  (^  -  P)]  dV.  (13.6) 


The  first  term  in  (13.6)  can  be  transformed  into  a  surface  integral, 
so  that  $   L  will  have  the  form 

F.  (13.7) 

We  shall  consider  that  the  first  integral  is  taken  over  a  surface 
on  which  &  9  becomes  zero,  similar  to  the  way  that,  in  Sec.  10,  8  q 
was  equal  to  zero  at  the  limits  of  integration  (a  surface  is  the  limit 
for  a   volume  integral). 
Therefore, 


(13.8) 

However,  since 

(13.9) 


[see  (12.27)],  S9  L  and  hence  89S,  becomes  zero  as  expected. 
Let  us  now  vary  L  with  respect  to  A.  This  variation  has  the  form 


8AL=rrj_  (i^A       |lsaA_  i  rotASrotA    JSA, 

J   L  4?r   \  C     d£  /   C        c>2  4rr  c     J 

(13.10) 

Once  again  we  interchange  the  differentiation  and  variation  signs 
and,  where  possible,  we  replace  the  potentials  by  fields  after  variation. 
We  obtain  S  A  L  in  the  following  form  : 

F.   (13.11) 


120  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    11 

Let  us  write  down  the  transformation  by  parts: 

II  rot  8 A :  --  -  div  [USA]  +  8 A  rot  II .  (13.13) 

The  last  equation  follows  from  (11.29).  To  take  advantage  of 
(13.12),  we  must  write  down  the  variation  of  the  action  $  instead 
of  the  variation  of  L.  Then  the  first  term  of  (13.12)  can  be  directly 
integrated  with  respect  to  time,  and  8^  S  will  be 

t,  'i  ii 

8A*S'---  (S^Ldt^  --r   -  f ESAdK      +-/-  [dt  f[II8AJeZs  + 

A  J     A  4-Kr,  J  '      4rr  J          J   L  J 


(13.14) 

The  variation  S  A  is  equal  to  zero  at  the  initial  and  final  instants 
of  time  £0  and  tl9  as  well  as  over  the  surface  bounding  the  field. 
Therefore, 


A,        (.3.15) 

and  since  the  field  satisfied  the  equation 

rot.\l=..±™.+  *ZL  (13.16) 

[see  (12.26)],  &A  ti  is  equal  to  zero. 

The  first  pair  of  Maxwell's  equations  is,  of  course,  satisfied  identi- 
cally if  the  fields  are  expressed  in  terms  of  potentials  in  accordance 
with  (12.28)  and  (12.20). 

Thus,  Maxwell's  equations  can  be  interpreted  as  equations  of  the 
mechanics  of  an  electromagnetic  field.  They  could  be  obtained  from 
the  variational  method,  starting  from  the  Lagrangian  (13.1)  and  the 
requirement  that  the  variation  of  action  should  be  equal  to  zero 
for  any  arbitrary  variations  of  the  scalar  and  vector  potentials. 
For  this  it  is  sufficient  to  repeat  the  arguments  set  out  in  Sec.  10, 
as  applied  to  integrals  (13.8)  and  (13.16). 

The  invariance  of  action  with  respect  to  a  potential  gauge  trans- 
formation. We  shall  now  show  that  action  is  invariant  under  gauge 
transformations  (12.30)  and  (12.31),  despite  the  fact  that  it  involves 
not  only  fields,  but  also  potentials  contained  in  the  last  two  terms 
of  equat  ion  (13.1).  We  shall  call  the  corresponding  part  of  the  action  S1  : 


^  -P9).  (13.17) 


Sec.  13]          THE  ACTION  PRINCIPLE  FOR  THE  ELECTROMAGNETIC  FIELD  121 

Let  us  now  apply  gauge  transformations  (12.30)  and  (12.31)  to 
A  and  cp.  This  gives 


dV          -  P9<  +  +  ?  .  (13.18) 

We  transform  by  parts  terms  containing  /: 

j  V/=  div  (/j)  -  /  div  j  ,     p  -£{-  =  -jy  (P/)  -  /  -/f  • 

Substituting  this  in  the  integral  /S^  and  performing  the  integration, 
as  iu  (13.14),  we  have 


o 

+  jdt  j  dV  [43-  -  P*'  -  /(div  j  +  -*J)|  -  (13.10) 

However,  the  integrated  terms  do  not  affect  the  Maxwell  equations 
since,  when  performing  a  variation  of  /S\,  both  S^  L  and  SA  /> 
are  equal  to  zero  at  the  boundaries  of  the  integration  region.  We 
have  already  encountered  this  in  (10.9).  The  term,  proportional 

to  /,  under  the  integral  sign,  is  multiplied  by  the  quantity  div  j  +  -  p  , 

which  is  identically  equal  to  zero  according  to  the  charge  conser- 
vation law  (12.18)'.  Thus.  ^  retains  the  form  (13.17). 

The  energy  of  a  field.  Maxwell's  equations  also  apply  to  a  free 
electromagnetic  field  not  containing  charges  or  currents.  For  this 

it  is  sufficient  to  omit  from  them  the  terms  •  "*-  and  4  n  p.  in  ac- 

c  r 

cordance  with   (13.1)  and  (13.2),  the  Lagrangian  for  a  free  field  is 

rdV.    (13-20) 


We  shah1  now  determine  the  energy  of  an  electromagnetic  field 
by  proceeding  from  the  general  equation  (4.4).  First,  let  it  be  recalled 
that  the  values  of  potentials  at  all  points  of  space  arc  generalized 

coordinates.  But  then  the  derivatives  --      are  generalized  velocities. 

o  t 

Consequently,  the  expression 


reduces  to  the  form 


by  means  of  the  comparison 


122  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

We  shall  now  show  that  energy  is  expressed  only  in  terms  of  the 
field,  and  not  in  terms  of  potentials.  Using  (12.29)  we  write  down 
the  energy  thus: 


This  expression  is  not  invariant  with  respect  to  a  gauge  transformation 
and  must  be  transformed. 

Transforming  the  term  EV<?   by  parts,   we  have,  from   (11.27), 

EV?  =  div  (£9)  —  9divE  ~div9E, 

since  div  E  =0  for  a  field  free  of  charges.  The  volume  integral  of 
div  rp  E  is  transformed  into  a  surface  integral.  However,  according 
to  the  meaning  attached  to  L0  and  $  ,  the  integration  should  be 
performed  over  the  whole  region  occupied  by  the  field  (this  is  analog- 
ous to  summation  over  all  the  degrees  of  freedom  of  the  system). 
At  the  boundary  of  this  region,  the  field  is  equal  to  zero  by  definition, 
so  that  the  surface  integral  in  the  expression  for  energy  also  becomes 
zero.  From  this  we  obtain  the  required  expression  for  the  energy 
of  an  electromagnetic  field  in  the  absence  of  charges: 

$  =  -1-  J  (E2  +  II2)  A  V.  (13.21) 

Hence,  the  quantity 

»=J^«l  (13.22, 

may  be  interpreted  as  the  energy  density  of  the  electromagnetic 
field.  It  is  invariant  with  respect  to  a  gauge  transformation  of  a 
potential. 

Conservation  of  the  total  energy  of  field  and  charges.  We  shall 
now  show  that  the  energy  $  (13.21),  together  with  the  energy  of  the 
charges  contained  in  the  field,  is  conserved,  i.e.,  g  is  the  energy  in  the 
usual,  mechanical,  sense  of  the  word,  and  not  some  quantity  which 
is  formally  analogous  to  it  only  as  regards  its  derivation  from  the 
variatioual  principle. 

To  do  this  wo  multiply  equation  (12.26)  scalarly  by  E  and  (12.24) 
scarlarly  by  H,  and  subtract  the  second  from  the  first.  This  gives 
the  following  relationship: 


1    /T^    aE       •      IT    ^H\  V 

—  E  -5—  +  H  -^r--  =  E 

c  \       dt  dt  I 


V         4-U          TT         4.TI 

E  rot  H  —  H  rot  E 


Now  taking  advantage  of  equation  (11.29),  we  reduce  the  equation 
obtained  to  the  form 

p        •¥¥«    V 

-pvE.  (13.23) 


Sec.  13]          THE  ACTION  PRINCIPLE  FOR  THE  ELECTROMAGNETIC  FIELD  123 

Here  we  have  put  j  =  p  v  by  definition.  We  now  integrate  (13.23) 
over  some  volume,  though  not  necessarily  the  whole  volume  oc- 
cupied by  the  field,  and  transform  the  integral  of  div  to  a  surface 
integral : 

(13.24) 


Let  us  first  consider  the  second  integral  on  the  right.  By  definition, 
the  quantity  p  d  V  is  the  charge  element  de.  The  product  E  d  e  is 
the  electric  force  acting  on  this  charge  element.  The  scalar  product 

d  e  E  v  =  d  e  •  E  •  -,--  is  equal  to    the   work   done   on   the   element 

of  charge  in  unit  time  or— put  in  another  way — to  the  change  in 
kinetic  energy  T  of  the  charge  in  unit  time.  Later,  we  shall  show 
that  the  magnetic  field  does  not  perform  work  on  charges  (Sec.  21). 
To  summarize,  equation  (13.24)  can  also  be  written  as  follows  [the 

dT 
last   integral  in  (13.24)  will  be  represented  in  the  form    -T—  ,   i.e., 

the  work  done  in  unit  time] : 

-~  (£  +  T)  -  — J-£^  [EH]  dV .  (13.25) 

The  Poynting  vector.  Thus,  the  decrease  in  energy,  in  unit  time, 
of  an  electromagnetic  field  and  of  the  charged  particles  contained 

therein  is  equal  to  the  vector  flux  —'  -  [E  H]  across  the  surface  bound- 
ing the  field.  If  this  surface  is  infinitely  distant  and  the  field  on  it 
is  equal  to  zero,  what  we  have  is  simply  the  energy  conservation 
law  for  an  electromagnetic  field  and  for  the  charges  within  it.  Other- 
wise, if  the  volume  is  finite,  the  right-hand  side  of  equation  (13.25) 
indicates  what  energy  passes  in  unit  time  through  the  surface  bound- 
ing the  volume.  Hence,  the  quantity 

U  =  -^-[EH]  (13.26) 

represents  the  energy  crossing  unit  area  in  unit  time  or,  more  simply, 
the  energy  density  flux  vector  (the  Poynting  vector). 

Field  momentum.  Similar  computations,  which  we  shall  not  give, 
show  that  an  electromagnetic  field  possesses  momentum.  The  mo- 
mentum of  a  field  is  given  by  the  following  integral: 

1     [EH]dF.  (13.27) 


If  the  electromagnetic  field  interacts  with  some  obstacle,  for 
example,  the  walls  of  the  enclosure  in  which  it  is  contained,  or  with 
a  screen,  then  the  momentum  of  the  field  is  transmitted  to  the  ob- 
stacle. The  momentum  transmitted  normally  to  unit  area  in  unit 


124  jjLECTUODYXAMrcs  [Part   II 

time  is  nothing  other  than  the  pressure  (since  momentum  trans- 
mitted in  unit  time  is  force).  For  this  reason,  electrodynamics  pre- 
dicts that  electromagnetic  fields  (and,  as  a  particular  case,  light 
waves)  are  capable  of  exerting  a  pressure  on  matter. 

Angular  momentum  of  a  field.   According  to   (13.27),   the   field- 
momentum  density  is 


From  this  it  follows  that  the   angular-momentum  density  is 


and  the  total  angular  momentum  of  the  field  is 

M-  •/  -f[r[EII]]dP.  (13.28) 

•JrTCC     J 

Linear  momentum  and  angular  momentum  of  a  field  satisfy  the 
conservation  laws  together  with  similar  quantities  for  the  charge 
contained  in  the  field.  The  value  of  the  angular  momentum  of  a 
field  is  very  essential  in  the  quantum  theory  of  radiation. 


Sec,  14.  The  Electrostatics  of  Point  Charges. 
Slowly  Varying  Fields 

An  important  class  of  approximate  solutions  of  electro-dynamical 
equations    comprises    slowly    varying    fields,    for    which    the    terms 

-~(  A  and  —  -'      in  Maxwell's  equations  can  be  neglected.  The  re- 

maining terms  form  two  sets  of  equations,  which  are  entirely  inde- 
pendent of  each  other: 

(14.1) 


rotE  =  0  (14.2) 

and 

divH  =  0,  (14.3) 

rot  II  --=  -J-1-  .  (14.4) 

The  first  two  equations  contain  only  the  electric  field  and  the  den- 
sity of  the  charge  producing  the  field;  the  second  two  equations 
involve  only  the  magnetic  field  and  current  density,  the  right-hand 
sides  of  the  equations  being  regarded  as  known,  functions  of  coordinates 
and  time.  Since  there  are  no  time  derivatives  in  (14.1)-(14.4), 
the  time  dependence  of  the  electric  field  is  the  same  as  the  electric- 


Sec.  14]  THE    ELECTROSTATICS    OF    POINT    CHARGES  125 

charge  densities,  and  the  time  dependence  of  the  magnetic  field 
is  the  same  as  the  current  densities.  Hence,  to  the  approximation 
of  (14.1)-(14.4),  the  field  is,  as  it  were,  established  instantaneously, 
in  correspondence  with  the  charge  and  current  distribution  that 
generated  it. 

The  fact  is  that  any  change  in  the  field  is  transmitted  in  space 
with  the  velocity  of  light  c.  If  we  consider  the  field  at  a  distance  E 
from  a  charge,  the  electromagnetic  disturbance  will  reach  it  in  a 

r> 

time  —  .  The  charge,  of  velocity  v,  will  be  displaced,  during  that 

c  if 

time,     through    a    distance    r  —  .   The  approximation    (14.1)-(14.4) 

c  R 

can  be  applied  only  when  the  displacement  v  —  does  not  lead  to 

c 

any  essential  redistribution  of  the  charge.  For  example,  let  a  system 
consist  of  two  equal  charges  of  opposite  sign,  which  succeed  in  chang- 

ing places  in  a  time  —  .   Then,  the  electric  field  at  a  distance  12,  at 

It       c 
the  instant  i  =  —  ,   will  have  a  direction  opposite  to  the  one  it  had 

during  the  instantaneous  propagation  at  the  instant  t  —  0. 

Hence,  if  the  dimensions  of  the  system  of  charges  arc  r  and  their 
velocities  v  (r  and  v  determine  the  orders  of  magnitude),  then  equations 
(14.1)-(14.4)  can  be  used  at  the  distance  R  from  the  system,  for 

r          f?  c 

which  the  inequality  —  >  —  or   R  <^  r      is   satisfied. 

We  shall  consider  the  limiting  case,  when  v  <^  c.  Then  the  region 
of  applicability  of  our  approximation  will  be  very  large. 

Equations  (14.1),  (14.2)  are  called  the  equations  of  electrostatics, 
and  (14.3)  and  (14.4),  the  equations  of  magnetostatics. 

Scalar  potential  in  electrostatics.  In  order  to  satisfy  equation  (14.2), 
we  put 

E  =  —V9.  (14.5) 

According  to  (14.20),  9  is  the  scalar  potential.  The  equation  for  the 
scalar  potential  is  obtaining  from  (14.1) 

divgrad9  =  A9  =  —  4jcp  ,  (14.6) 

which  also  follows  from  (12.38)  if  we  equate  to  zero  the  nonstatic 

1      02 
- 


Let  us  find  the  solution  to  equation  (14.6)  for  a  point  charge,  i.e., 
we  put  p  equal  to  zero  everywhere  except  at  one  point  of  space. 
Let  us  put  the  origin  at  this  point.  Then  9  can  depend  only  on  the 
distance  from  the  origin  r. 

In  Sec.  11  an  expression  for  the  Laplacian  A  was  obtained  in 
spherical  coordinates  (11.46).  In  the  special  case,  when  the  required 
function  depends  only  on  r,  we  obtain  from  (11.46) 


126  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

I     d     9  d<? 


Let  us  integrate  this  equation  between  rl  and  r2,  first  multiplying 
it  by  r2.  Since  the  region  of  integration  does  not  contain  the  origin, 
where  the  point  charge  is  situated,  the  integral  of  the  right-hand 
side  becomes  zero.  Hence, 

r2  ^9   _  -2  d<*  .     r2  A'.  —  A  —  const 

/«  —  .-     '  —  f  i  —  -.  —  ,       /     —  •  —  -  —  ^j_  —  Lfdiioi'  . 

2  dr2          1  drl  '  dr 

Therefore  the  potential  is 


The  constant  B  is  equal  to  zero  if  we  take  the  potential  to  be  equal 
to  zero  at  an  infinite  distance  away  from  the  charge.  Let  us  now 
determine  the  constant  A.  For  this,  we  integrate  equation  (1-4.6) 
over  a  certain  sphere  surrounding  the  origin.  Since  the  Laplacian 
A  9  is  div  grad  9,  the  volume  integral  can  be  transformed  into  an 
integral  over  the  surface  of  the  sphere.  This  integral  is 

|grad9rfs---  I   %  r2fZ£i=  471^4  . 
On  the  right-haud  side  we  have 
— 


since  the  integration  region  includes  the  point  where  the  charge  is 
situated.  Thus  A  ---  —  e. 

The  potential  of  the  point  charge  is 


e 


9-y.  (14.8) 

We  obtain  the  same  thing  for  a  spherically  symmetrical  volume- 
charge  distribution,  if  the  potential  is  calculated  outside  the  volume 
occupied  by  the  charge.  In  other  words,  the  potential  of  a  charged 
sphere  at  all  external  points  is  the  same  as  the  potential  of  an  equal 
point  charge  situated  at  the  centre  of  the  sphere.  A  similar  result 
is,  of  course,  obtained  for  the  gravitational  potential.  This  fact  is 
used  in  most  astronomical  problems,  where  celestial  bodies  are  con- 
sidered as  gravitating  points. 

If  the  origin  does  not  coincide  with  the  charge,  and  the  charge 
coordinates  are  #,  y,  z  (radius  vector  r)  then  the  potential  at  point 
X,  Y,  Z  (radius  vector  R)  is 


Sec.  141  THE    ELECTROSTATICS    OF   POINT    CHARGES  127 

The  potential  of  a  system  of  charges.  The  potential  due  to  several 
charges  ev  e2,  e3,  . .  . ,  e,-,  . . . ,  whose  positions  are  given  by  the  radius 
vectors  r1,  r2,  . . . ,  r1',  at  the  point  R,  is 


9  = 


~   |R  — r'|       ^  V~(X- ~ 


Using  the  summation  convention,  any  radicand  in  this  formula 
can  be  rewritten  in  the  form 


But,  in  order  to  save  space,  we  shall  use  the  notation  (X\  —  x^)  2 
instead  of  (X\  —  •  x^)  (X^  —  x^)  .  Then  the  potential  due  to  a  system 
of  point  charges  is  written  as 


But  we  must  remember  that  inside  the  brackets  is  a  summation 
for  X  from  1  to  3. 

Note  also  that  the  potentials  due  to  separate  charges  at  the  point 
R  are  additive,  since  equation  (14.6)  is  linear  in  9.  And  so  the  full 
solution,  due  to  all  the  charges,  is  equal  to  the  sum  of  all  the  partial 
solutions  for  each  charge  separately. 

The  potential  due  to  a  charge  system  at  a  large  distance.  Let  us 
now  assume  that  the  origin  is  situated  somewhere  inside  the  region 
occupied  by  the  charges  (for  example,  at  the  centre  of  the  smallest 
sphere  embracing  all  charges),  and  that  all  the  radius  vectors  r1' 
satisfy  the  inequalities 

|B|  >  |r'|.  (14.11) 

In  other  words,  we  shall  look  for  the  potential  of  a  system  of  charges 
at  a  great  distance  from  it.  Then  the  function  (14.10)  can  be  expanded 
in  a  Taylor's  series  in  terms  of  a;',  y\  z{.  We  shall  perform  the  expansion 
up  to  the  quadratic  term  inclusively,  but  we  shall  first  write  it  only 
for  one  term  of  the  sum  over  all  the  charges,  omitting  the  index 
i.  The  expansion  is  of  the  form: 


—  y)*  +  (Z  —  *)»]-'/, 

.  +  -!*.«.  -  [«]-'/,  .  (14.12) 


The  summation  convention  permits  writing  in  concise  form  the  Taylor 
series  for  a  function  of  several  variables.  Since  Xl~  R2,  we  obtain 
the  expression  for  the  first  derivative 

i  -  —  -  __  --  -  _^~  ---  -1   -  —  -X»  n  4r  1  *\ 

dXv.    R~~dX~v.dR    R~        R*~'         l1*-1^ 


128  ELKCTKOOYN'AMICS  [Part    II 

where  we  have  used  equation  (11.36)  which,  in  the  notation  of  this 
section,  is  of  the  form  ~f    '    --  '  *  . 

V  \  \j.  /  1 

Thus,  the  term  in  the  sum  (14.12),  which  is  linear  in  r[JL,  is  equal  to 

j-,i  A'M         >-X  I-  //  Y  -i-  zZ     _  T  R  , 

/j>n  yJ3  "~~     yxi  "  •  ^14,  1-4) 

it  is  somewhat  more  difficult  to  calculate  the  term  which  is  quadratic 
in  ,r{Jl,  ov   We  first  write  down  the  second  derivative: 

62          I        __  d_  Xv.  _    __  1     d_X^_  _  Y   _^  __  L 
iJXlLci'Xv~/t     "         c'-Yv     7?3  /?J~~0~Y7  'L1TX^   7?3  ' 

rrhe  partial  derivative    '  |X  is  equal  to  zero  for  a  /-  v  and  to  1  for 

o  JVv  v 

[ji  --=  v.   Further, 

f;        1  c)Jf      d     _}  _        __    A\       3  :r.Yv 

c^  A\  "A"        c»A\    ^7?  ~Zf3  ""  "     S"  "  ~/iT     "  ""  '^5  " 

}>y  the  rule  for  differentiation  of  involved  functions. 
Thus,  we  obtain 

__^*  _       i_—  „     L  dX>Ji          S.YnXv 

"^X^~A\  "77  /e3^  a  A^v  "^        ^/e5    ""  " 

Hence,  the  required  expansion  ;R  —  rj-1  is  of  the  form 


We  shall  now  subtract  from  the  quadratic  term  a  quantity  equal 
to  zero: 

r2        1        c*        1      __  .r-   |    //a   i-  :2         l^ 

2    '   ,4i      r'A'j"  "«"     "  (5  "^~/f 


[A  ^  -    -  0  from  (14.8)].  Then  the  last  term  in  (14.15),  written  in  terms 

dvanta 
r  _ 

~     '• 


of  components,  is  (taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that  -^  v-  --  ^v 


'-  »«(  T)  +  **•(  '"  )-(-  •  J-  ;±-*}(*2±£±*  -  id. 


Here,  it  is  quite  obvious  that  a  term  equal  to  zero  has  been  sub- 
tracted,  for   A"2  +  Y*+Z2=^R2.    Rearranging    the    terms,    we   have 

_  i  \  ,  L2      rM 

IP  i  +  r      r)  x 

3A'^    ,   .      srzi 

**  ___  _L_   "^t/y  __         —I 

M      7?5      ^-^2     7?5     J- 


See.  14] 


THE    ELECTROSTATICS    OF   POINT   CHARGES 


129 


The  expansion  (14.15)  must  be  substituted  in  the  equation  for 
potential  (14.10)  and  summed  over  all  the  charges.  We  introduce 
the  following  abbreviated  notation: 

d^  y>,r<;  (14.16) 


(14.17) 


(14.18) 


The  vector  d  (i.e.,  the  three  quantities  dx,  dy,  dz)  and  the  six 
quantities  qxx,  qYY,  qzz,  qxy,  qxz,  qyz,  depend  only  on  the  charge 
distribution  in  the  system,  and  not  on  the  place  at  which  the  potential 
is  determined.  In  the  notation  of  (14.16)-(14.18),  the  potential 
at  large  distances  away  from  the  system  is  of  tho  form 

^  __  x«,-    ,    (dR)    ,    1  „ 


with  the  terms  of  different  indices  of  the  type  qxy  actually  appearing 
twice  in  the  summation  (for  example,  q12  and  the  equal  term  r/21). 

The  vector  d  is  called  the  dipole  moment  of  the  charge  system. 
The  six  quantities  q  are  called  the  quadrupole  moment  components. 

The  dipole  moment.  We  shall  now  examine  the  expression  obtained 


for  potential.  The  zero  term 


corresponds  to  the  approximation 


R 


according  to  which  all  the  charge  is  considered  to  be  concentrated 
at  the  origin.  In  other  words,  it  corresponds  to  a  substitution  of  the 
entire  charge  system  by  a  single  point  charge.  This  approximation 

is  clearly  insufficient  when  the  system  is  neutral,  i.e.,  if  JT'  et-  =  0. 

» 

This  case  is  very  usual,  since  atoms  and  molecules  are  neutral  (their 
electronic  charge  balances  the  charge  on  the  nuclei). 

9-0060 


130  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

Let  us  assume  that  the  total  charge  is  equal  to  zero  and  then 
consider  the  first  term  of  the  expansion,  involving  the  dipole  moment. 

This  term  decreases  like^r,  i.e.,  more  rapidly  than  the  potential 

of  the  charged  system.  Besides,  it  is  proportional  to  the  cosine  of 
the  angle  between  d  and  R.  The  simplest  thing  is  to  produce  a  neutral 
system  by  taking  two  equal  and  opposite  charges.  Such  a  system 
is  called  a  dipole.  Its  moment  is 


d  =  £elF  =  e(rl-  r2)  (14.20) 

in  accordance  with  the  definition  (used  in  general  courses  of  physics) 
that  the  dipole  moment  is  the  product  of  charge  by  the  vector  joining 
the  positive  and  negative  charges. 

It  can  be  seen  from  equation  (14.20)  that  the  definition  of  dipole 
moment  does  not  depend  on  the  choice  of  coordinate  origin,  since 
it  involves  only  the  relative  position  of  charges.  We  shall  show  that 
the  dipole  moment  always  possesses  this  property. 

Indeed,  if  we  displace  the  origin  through  some  distance  a,  then 
the  radius  vectors  of  all  the  charges  change  thus: 

r1  =  r'1  +  a 
Substituting  this  in  the  expression  for  the  dipole  moment,  we  obtain 


because  J^ej  =  0. 

But  if  the  system  is  not  neutral,  then  we  choose  a  in  the  following 
manner : 


27* 

This  choice  is  analogous  to  the  choice  of  centre  of  mass  for  a  system 
of  masses.  Thus,  we  can  say  that  the  vector  a  determines  the  electri- 
cal centre  of  a  system  of  charges.  For  a  neutral  system  it  is  impos- 
sible to  determine  a,  since  the  denominator  of  (14.22)  is  equal  to 
zero.  If  for  a  charged  system  we  choose  a  according  to  (14.22),  then 

J^i-r''  =  0,  i.e.,  the  dipole  moment  of  a  charged  system,  relative 

t 
to  its  electric  centre,  is  equal  to  zero. 

We  thus  have  the  following  alternatives :  either  the  system  is  neutral, 
and  then  the  expansion  (14.29)  begins  with  a  dipole  term  independent 


Sec.  14]  THE   ELECTROSTATICS   OP   POINT   CHARGES  131 

of  the  choice  of  coordinate  origin,  or  the  system  is  charged,  and  then 
the  dipole  term  in  the  expansion  is  equal  to  zero  for  a  corresponding 
choice  of  origin. 

Quadrupole  moment.  In  the  expansion  (14.19),  we  now  consider 
the  second  term  containing  the  quadrupole  moment.  A  quadrupole 
is  a  system  of  two  dipoles  of  moment  d,  which  are  equal  in  magnitude 
and  opposite  in  direction.  It  is  clear  that  a  potential  expansion  for 
such  a  system  will  have  neither  a  zero  nor  first  term,  so  that  equation 
(14.19)  contains  only  a  second  term  on  the  right-hand  side.  The  sim- 
plest quadrupole  can  be  formed  by  placing  four  charges  at  the  vertices 
of  a  parallelogram,  where  the  charges  are  of  equal  magnitude  but 
with  pairs  of  charges  having  opposite  signs.  The  charges  alternate 
when  we  traverse  the  vertices  of  the  parallelogram.  Such  a  system 
is  neutral.  However,  a  charged  system,  too,  can  have  a  quadrupole 
moment.  It  indicates  to  what  extent  the  charge  distribution  in  the 
system  differs  from  spherical  symmetry.  Indeed,  in  this  section  it 
was  shown  that  the  potential  due  to  a  spherically  symmetrical  charge 

system  decreases  in  strict  accordance  with  a  •=-  law,  and  the  potential 
due  to  a  quadrupole  follows  a  -^3-  law.  For  this  reason,  the  quadrupole 

term  in  the  potential  expansion  can  arise  only  in  the  case  of  a  non- 
spherical  charge  distribution. 

The  principal  axes  of  a  quadrupole  moment.  Let  us  now  determine 
in  what  sense  the  quadrupole  moment  characterizes  a  nonspherical 
distribution.  In  equation  (14.22),  an  analogy  was  established  between 
the  centre  of  inertia  of  a  mass  system  and  the  electric  centre  of  a 
system  of  charges.  In  a  similar  way,  equations  (14.17),  (14.18)  allow 
us  to  establish  a  certain  correspondence  between  the  components 
of  quadrupole  moment  and  moments  of  inertia  of  a  system  of  masses 
Jxx,  .  .  .,  Jyz  (see  Sec.  9),  defined  in  equations  (9.3). 

We  can  disregard  the  fact  that  a  summation  appears  in  equations 
(14.17)  and  (14.18),  while  (9.3)  involves  integration.  This  difference 
will  not  exist  if  we  take  a  continuous  charge  distribution  or  a  dis- 
crete mass  distribution  (as  for  nuclei  in  a  molecule).  We  shall  take 
the  latter.  In  addition,  we  shall  forget  for  a  moment  that  the  compo- 
nents of  the  moment  of  inertia  involve  masses  and  not  charges. 
Then  the  relationship  between  the  quadrupole  moment  and  the 
moment  of  inertia  is  of  the  form: 

Qxx  ^  —  Jxx  +  -3"  (Jxx  +  Jyy  +  Jzz),  Qxy  ^  —  Jxy, 
(Jyy  ~  —  Jyy  +  ~§  (Jxx  +  Jyy  +  Jzz),  <fxz  ^  ~  Jxz, 
Qzz  ^  —  Jzz  +  -q-  (Jxx  +  Jyy  +  Jzz),  Qyz  ^  —  Jyz  • 


132  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

The  sign  ^  above  the  equality  symbol  indicates  correspondence 
between  terms.  Indeed,  according  to  (9.3)  the  first  line  gives 


-  r''2)  -=  ««  • 

i  i 

The  relations  in  the  second  column  are  obvious. 

In  Sec.  9  it  was  shown  that  moments  of  inertia  can  be  reduced 
to  principal  axes,  i.e.,  a  coordinate  system  can  be  found  for  which 
the  products  of  inertia  are  zero.  But  since  the  relations  between  q 
and  J  are  true  for  any  coordinate  system,  the  components  of  the 
quadrupole  moment  of  different  signs  also  become  zero  in  these 
same  principal  axes.  In  the  principal  axes,  the  quadrupole  moment 
is  expressed,  in  terms  of  moments  of  inertia,  as 


(14.23) 


If  the  system  possesses  spherical  symmetry,  then  J1-r=J2^-J3, 
so  that  ql~-q^--q9^o.  Therefore,  the  presence  of  a  quadrupole 
moment  in  a  system  of  charges  indicates  that  the  charge  distribution 
is  not  spherically  symmetrical.  However,  a  reverse  assertion  would 
not  be  true:  if  the  quadrupole  moment  is  equal  to  zero,  the  system 
of  charges  may  not  be  spherically  symmetrical.  It  will  then  be  neces- 
sary, in  expansion  (14.19),  to  take  into  account  terms  of  higher  order. 

It  will  be  noted  that  from  (14.23)  there  follows  directly  the  identity 
7i  ~t  #2  ~l  ft  —  0,  i-e->  only  two  °f  fche  three  principal  components  of 
a  quadrupole  moment  are  independent. 

The  relations  (14.23)  should  be  regarded  literally  if  we  are  talking 
about  a  gravitational  potential.  We  know  that  the  earth  is  not  strictly 
spherical,  but  is  flattened  at  the  poles.  Therefore,  the  earth's  gravi- 
tational force  contains  terms  which  are  not  governed  by  an  inverse 
square  law.  This  affects  the  motion  of  the  moon,  and  ah1  the  more 
so  that  of  artificial  satellites  moving  closer  to  the  earth. 

Quadrupole  moment  when  axes  of  symmetry  exist.  Equations  (14.23) 
become  simpler  if  two  moments  of  inertia  of  a  body  are  equal,  for 
example,  Jl-^J.2.  Then 

ffi^y^.-^i)^    -   I-, 

ft  ^  y  (^3  -  ^i)  -  -  y  > 
2 


Sec.    14]  THE    ELECTROSTATICS    OF   POINT    CHARGES  133 

In  this  case,   the   quadrupole   moment   has   only  one   independent 
component  q.  Its  sign  is  called  the  sign  of  the  quadrupole  moment. 

The  quantity  q  =  £  ei  (z?  —  -^-1  . 

If  the   charges   were    distributed   with   spherical   symmetry,    we 
would  have   the  equality    JTrei-f4<l=  3  JT'efZ1'*,    for  then    £e<xi*  ~ 

i  i  i 

—  2^c{y{'  —  £eiZ*  and  q,  too,  would  be  equal  to  zero. 

The  positive  sign  of  q  shows  thatJTV/z'2  >  -^  J^r*",  i.e.,  it  indicates 

i  i 

a  charge  distribution  extending  along  the  c-axis.  From  (14.19),  the 
potential  due  to  such  a  quadrupole  with  one  component  q  is 


1     /3.Y2  1  \        1     /33'2          1  \        q  13Z*          1   \  __ 

4  ?  \-7fT-  -  -&  }     -  4  9  (-fir  -    -Jp)    1     2  \  Rr        ~&]  " 

*-''    r8       2Z2\  3      /#;       3^ 

/.^      /    "  4?\    v?6 


Thus,  the  potential  of  a  quadrupole  depends  on  the  angle  &  according 
to  the  law  ]  -  3  cos2  &,  where  &  is  the  angle  between  the  axis  of 
symmetry  of  the  quadrupole  and  the  radius  vector  of  the  point 
at  which  the  potential  is  determined. 

Similar  deviations  from  spherical  symmetry  have  been  found  in 
the  electrostatic  potential  of  many  nuclei.  The  quadrupole  moments 
of  nuclei  give  us  an  insight  into  their  structure. 

The  energy  of  a  system  of  charges  in  an  electrostatic  field.  We 

shall  now  calculate  the  energy  of  a  system  of  charges  in  an  external 
electric  field.  The  potential  energy  of  a  charge  in  a  field  is  equal 
to  f/--pcp,  because  the  force  acting  on  the  charge  is  equal  to 
F  -  --  Vt/--  —  eV9^eE.  The  energy  of  a  system  of  charges  is  thus 

17=-  5>,9(r'),  (14.25) 


where  r1'  is  the  radius  vector  for  the  ith  charge. 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  field  does  not  change  much  over  the  space 
occupied  by  the  charges,  so  that  the  potential  at  the  site  of  the  ith 
charge  can  be  expanded  in  a  Taylor's  series: 

9  «  -  *  (0)  +  *-+      *^  .  (14.26) 


134  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

We  shall  transform  the  last  term  in  the  same  way  as  in  the  expansion 
(14.15);  taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that  9  is  the  potential  of  the 
external  field  (and  not  the  field  produced  by  the  given  charges), 

so  that  A?=0>  we  subtract  from  9  the  quantity  -3-  A?  equal  to  zero. 
Then,  after  summation  over  i,  we  obtain 


(U.27) 


Here,  the  value  of  the  field  (V9)0  =  E0  at  the  origin  has  been 
substituted  into  the  term  involving  the  dipole  moment.  Relating 
equation  (14.27)  to  the  principal  axes  of  the  quadrupole  moment,  we  get 


-  (dB.)  -        7l  +  qz  +  ?,          )  .        (14.28) 

111  the  case  of  a  neutral  system,  the  term  involving  dipole  moment 
is  especially  important.  The  quadrupole  term  accounts  for  the  ex- 
tension of  the  system,  since  it  involves  field  derivatives.  It  is  interesting 
to  note  that  if  the  system  is  spherically  symmetrical,  i.e.,  if  it  has 
a  quadrupolo  moment  equal  to  zero,  there  is  no  correction  to  finite 
dimensions.  Higher  order  corrections  are  also  absent,  so  that  the 
potential  energy  will  always  depend  only  on  the  value  of  the  potential 
at  the  centre.  This  is  why  spherical  bodies  not  only  attract,  but 
are  also  attracted,  as  points.  Of  course,  these  assertions  are  mutually 
related  by  Newton's  Third  Law  which  holds  for  electrostatics,  since 
the  field  is  determined  by  the  instantaneous  configuration  of  charges. 

Exercises 

1)  Show  that  the  mean  value  of  the  potential  over  a  spherical  surface  is 
equal  to  its  value  at  the  centre  of  the  sphere,  if  the  equation  A  9  =  0  is  satisfied 
over  the  whole  volume  of  the  sphere.  Relate  this  to  the  result  obtained  for 
the  potential  energy  of  a  spherically  symmetrical  system  of  charges  in  an 
external  field. 

The  potential  should  be  expanded  in  a  series  involving  the  radius  powers 
of  the  sphere.  In  integration  over  the  surface,  all  the  terms  containing  x,  y, 
and  z  an  odd  number  of  times  become  zero.  The  terms  containing  xt  yt  and  z 
an  even  number  of  times  can  be  rearranged  so  that  they  are  proportional 
to  A  9,  A  A  9  ,  and  so  on.  There  remains  only  the  zero  term  of  the  expansion, 
which  proves  the  theorem. 

2)  Calculate  the  electric  field  of  a  dipole. 


Sec.  15]  THE  MAGNETOSTATICS  OF  POINT  CHABQES  135 

Sec.  15.  The  Magnetostatics  of  Point  Charges 

The  equations  ol  magnetostatics.  In  the  previous  section  it  was  shown 
that  if  the  velocities  of  the  charges  are  small  in  comparison  with 
the  velocity  of  light,  then  the  magnetic  field  satisfies  the  following 
system  of  equations: 

divH  =  0,  (15.1) 

rotfl  =  — j.  (15.2) 

c 

They  are  called  the  equations  of  magnetostatics.   From  equation 
(15.2)  it  follows  that 

4rc  -1-'-a    =0.  (15.3) 


Thus,  for  (15.2)  to  make  strict  sense,  the  currents  must  bo  subjected 
to  the  condition  div  j  —  0.  But  this  condition  is  not  directly  satisfied 
for  point  charges,  and  only  the  charge  conservation  equation  (12.18) 
holds. 

Mean  values.  The  condition  div  j  =  0  for  moving  point  charges 
can  only  be  satisfied  for  an  average  over  some  interval  of  time  tQ. 
We  shall  define  the  mean  value  of  a  certain  function  of  coordinates 
and  velocities  of  charges  /  (r,  v)  in  the  following  way : 

7=-f  f/(r,vM<.  (15.4) 

*0     J 

0 

This  averaging  operation  is  commutative  with  differentiation  of 
the  function  with  respect  to  coordinates,  since  it  is  performed  with 
respect  to  a  fixed  frame  of  reference  and  not  to  the  coordinates  of 
the  charges. 

Let  us  now  average  equation  (12.28): 


0  0 

Integration  of  the  right-hand  side  part  can  be  performed  directly: 


Let  us  now  assume  that  the   difference   p  (tQ)  —  p  (0)  increases 
more  slowly  than  the  time  interval  tQ  itself.  Then,  if  we  choose  £0 

sufficiently  large,  the  ratio  p    0'-""" p  '  '  can  be  as  small  as  required. 

*o 

Because  of  this,  the  mean  value  of  the  current  may  indeed  satisfy 
the  equation 


136  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

divj-0.  (15.5) 

Consequently,  equation  (15.2)  and  all  subsequent  equations  in 
this  section  must  be  regarded  as  mean  with  respect  to  time;  this 
will  be  denoted  by  a  bar  over  each  quantity  relating  to  the  motion 
of  charges  (no  bar  will  be  put  over  II). 

The  definition  of  steady  motion.  Let  us  assume  that  the  condition 

lim   '    °  ~"  -  --:  0  is  satisfied  not  only  for  charge  density,  but  also  for 

/ft->oo  *0 

any  function  relating  to  the  motion  of  charges.  Such  motion  is  termed 
stationary  or  steady. 

A  special  case  of  stationary  motion  is  periodic  motion,  for  example, 
cyclic  motion.  However,  for  a  stationary  state  it  is  sufficient  that  the 
charges  remain  all  the  time  in  a  limited  region  of  space,  for  the 
difference  /  (£0)  -—  /  (0)  then  remains  finite. 

The  equations  of  this  section  will  relate  to  the  stationary  motion 
of  point  charges. 

The  equations  for  vector  potential.  In  order  to  satisfy  equation  (15.  1  ), 
we  put,  as  in  Sec.  12  [see  (12.8)], 

II  -rot  A,  (15.6) 

where  A  is  the  vector  potential.  Equation  (15.6)  does  not  fully  deter- 
mine A  since,  if  we  add  to  A  the  gradient  of  any  arbitrary  function  /, 
as  in  (12.30),  the  expression  for  II  will  not  change.  Thus,  an  additional 
condition  must  be  imposed  on  A.  The  Lorentz  condition  suggests 
that  we  must  have 

divA-0.  (15.7) 

Then,  substituting  (15.6)  in  (15.2),  we  obtain 


rot  II  =  rot  rot  A  -  --      .  (15.8) 

But  according  to  (11.42) 

rot  rot  A  =--  grad  div  A  —  A  A  =  --  —  A  A  ,  (15.9) 

and  we  have  used  condition  (15.7).  Therefore,  A  satisfies  the  equation 

AA=-^-j  =  -^Lpy,  (15.10) 

which  is  entirely  analogous  to  equation  (14.6)  for  the  scalar  potential. 
Equation  (15.10)  can  be  obtained  from  (12.37)  directly  if  we  discard 

the  term  —  3-    -5-  which  is  superfluous  in  magnetostatics. 

The  vector  potential  lor  a  point  charge.  The  solution  of  (15.10) 
appears  exactly  the  same  as  the  solution  of  (14.6)  given  by  equation 
(14.8)  for  a  separate  point  charge:  each  component  of  A  satisfies 


Sec.  15]  THE   MAGNETOSTATICS   OF   POINT   CHARGES  137 

equation   (14.6),  the  only  difference  being  that  on  the  right-hand 

side   there    appear   the   functions  — ^ ov*,  — ^-  p^y,  — *-  pv*.  it  follows 

c  c  c 

that  the  vector  potential  for  a  point  charge  is 


We  shall  now  show  that  A  satisfies  condition  (15.7).  The  divergence 
must  be  taken  with  respect  to  the  radius  vector  R  at  the  point  at 
which  A  is  determined. 

But  VR|  R  —  r  |  =  -Vr]  R-  r  1 ,  so  that 


,.      4         e     ._  1  e     r-T  I  e     d 

di  v  A  =  -  WR  ~  _  -  vVr  -^777  '  '  *  T  IT 


(15.12) 


Hie  expression  on  the  right-hand  side  of  this  equation  is  the  total 

time  derivative  of  the  quantity  -p^  ---  rrr.  From  the  steady  -state 

j  K  —  r  (£)  | 

condition,  it  is  equal  to  zero. 

The  Biot-Savart  law.  We  shall  now  calculate  the  magnetic  field 
of  a  point  charge.  Using  equation  (11.28),  we  obtain 


— -rl 


This  equation  refers,  of  course,  only  to  steady  motion.  In  particular 
it  is  applied  to  constant  current. 

Vector  potential  at  large  distances  from  a  system  of  stationary 
currents.  The  vector  potential  for  a  system  of  point  charges  is  equal 
to  the  sum  of  vector  potentials  for  each  charge  separately: 


We  shall  now  obtain  approximate  formulae  which  are  valid  at  large 
distances  from  the  system,  similar  to  those  obtained  in  electrostatics. 
For  this,  we  substitute  an  expansion  of  inverse  distance  in  (15.13) 

[see  (14.14)]. 

1         -    l   -  r'R  (15  U] 

R-r'',   ~  R        •>"'  <1&'14> 

The  quadratic  term  is  not  taken  into  account  this  time.  The  ex- 
pression for  vector  potential,  to  the  approximation  of  (15.14),  is 
of  the  form 


138  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  II 


since   f1  =  v1. 

The  zero  term  of  the  expansion  is  a  total  derivative  and,  by  the 
steady-state  condition,  is  equal  to  zero.  We  now  transform  the  first 
term  of  the  expansion,  using  the  identity 


0  =     tZe*  (RrO  r'  =£«  (Rr<)  v'  +2>  (BV)  r<  .       (15.16) 

i  »  » 

From  this  identity  it  follows  that  in  (15.15)  we  can  substitute 
half  the  difference  of  the  expressions  on  the  right-hand  side  of  (15.16). 
Then  the  vector  potential  will  be 


A  =  T 

We  now  interchange  the  signs  of  the  summation  and  vector  product  : 


Magnetic  moment.  The  sum  appearing  inside  the  brackets  in  (15.18) 
is  called  the  magnetic  moment  of  the  system  of  charges  (or  system 
of  currents).  The  mean  magnetic  moment  is  written  thus: 


The  equation  for  the  vector  potential  (15.18)  can  be  written,  by 
means  of  the  magnetic  moment,  in  the  following  form: 


<15-20> 

The  field  ot  a  magnetic  dipole.  Let  us  now  calculate  the  magnetic 
field.  By  definition 

H=rotA=rot[v-~  ,jji]. 

Since  jl  is  a  constant  vector,  equation  (11.30)  gives 
H 


Sec.  15]  THE    MAONETOSTATICS   OF  POINT   CHARGES  139 

because  A~p-  =°-  Further,  (ft  V)  R=jZ  [see  (11.35)].  In  order  to  cal- 
culate (f*V)-jjo-,  we  use  equation  (11.36).  This  yields 


Finally,  collecting  both  terms,  we  arrive  at  an  equation  for  H: 
H  =  8B(Bfl 

For  comparison,  we  deduce  the  expression  for  the  electric  field 
of  a  dipole: 

(15.22) 


Thus,  both  expressions  for  the  field  (both  electric  and  magnetic) 
are  of  entirely  analogous  form.  The  only  difference  is  that,  instead 
of  the  electric  moment,  the  equation  for  magnetic  field  involves 
the  magnetic  moment.  This  explains  its  name. 

In  the  case  of  a  charge  moving  in  a  flat  closed  orbit,  the  definition 
of  magnetic  moment  (15.19)  coincides  with  the  elementary  definition 
of  moment  in  terms  of  "magnetic  shell."  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  5 
[see  (5.2),  (5.4)],  the  product  [rv]  is  twice  the  area  swept  out  by  the 

radius  vector  of  the  charge  in  unit  time,  or  [rv]  =  2  -y- .  By  definition 
of  the  mean  value  (15.4) 

ji  =  J-  f-l^ldJ  =  -4-s.  (15.23) 

^        t0  J    c    dt  ct0  v  ' 

o 

Here,  tQ  is  the  time  of  orbital  revolution  of  the  charge.  In  this  time, 
the  charge  passes  every  point  on  the  orbit  once;  hence  the  mean 

current  is   equal  to   /  =  — .  This  yields  the  definition  of  magnetic 
moment  familiar  from  general  physics: 

ji  =  ^— -.  (15.24) 

The  similarity  of  equations  (15.21)  and  (15.22)  shows  the  equivalence 
of  a  closed  current  (i.e.,  a  magnetic  shell)  and  a  fictitious  dipole 
with  the  same  moment  p.  The  field  at  large  distances  from  a  system 
of  currents  is  produced,  as  it  were,  by  the  effective  dipole. 

The  relationship  between  magnetic  and  mechanical  moments.  An 
especially  interesting  case  is  that  when  all  the  charges  of  a  system 
are  of  the  same  kind  (for  example,  when  they  are  all  electrons). 


140  KLECTRO  DYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Then  the  magnetic  moment  is  proportional  to  the  mechanical  moment. 
Indeed,  for  a  system  of  charges  with  identical  ratios  —  ,  we  obtain 


Pi   -  -rt—  y  [r'Vl  -  b  -  Fm  [r«'  VJ  =       --  V[r'p']  -  -  --  M  . 
r*         2c  4-*  l       J        2mc^*t       l       J         2mc  4*  L    rj         2mc 

(15.25) 

Equation  (15.25)  has  very  important  applications. 
A  system  of  point  charges  in  an  external  magnetic  field.  We  now 

consider  the  question  of  the  interaction  of  a  system  of  currents  with 
an  external  magnetic  field.  For  this  we  must  have  an  equation 
describing  the  interaction  of  a  point  charge  with  the  field.  We  obtained 
equation  (13.17)  for  the  general  spatial  charge  distribution.  In  this 
equation,  the  transition  to  point  charges  is  obtained  by  changing 
the  integral  to  a  summation  over  the  charges.  The  term  obtained 
for  action  is  of  the  form 


where  the  indices  i  in  A  and  cp  denote  that  the  potentials  are  taken 
at  the  same  point  as  the  ith  charge. 

In  magnetostatics,  only  slowly  moving  charges  for  which  v<^.c 
are  studied.  Newtonian  mechanics  can  then  be  applied  to  their  motion. 
In  the  absence  of  a  field,  the  action  function  of  the  particles  is  of  the 
form 


It  will  be  shown  in  Sec.  21  that  this  expression  holds  only  when  r<  c. 
In  magnetostatics,  where  this  condition  is  satisfied,  the  action  function 
of  a  system  of  charges  in  an  external  field  is  obtained  by  adding 
(15.27)  and  (15.26): 


The  field  due  to  the  charges  themselves  does  not  appear  in  this 
equation.  The  expression  for  the  integrand  is  the  Lagrangian  of  the 
system.  It  involves  velocity  linearly  as  well  as  quadratically  (in 
the  expression  for  kinetic  energy),  and,  for  this  reason,  does  not  have 
the  form  that  we  used  in  Part  I,  L  =  T  —  U. 

However,  the  general  relationships  still  hold.  Therefore,  from  the 
Lagrangian  the  expression  for  momentum  is  obtained  in  terms  of 
velocity 

P'-^^'  +  -^-  (15-29) 


Sec.  15]  THE    MAGNETOSTATICS    OF   POINT   CHARGES  141 

Let  us  determine  the  energy  in  terms  of  momentum  using  the  basic 
equation  (4.4): 


A,V-         -  -  --  A..V  +  <, 

<15-30> 


so  that  the  term  which  is  linear  with  respect  to  velocity  is  eliminated 
from  the  expression  for  energy  in  terms  of  velocity. 

The  Ha  mil  to  ni  an  function  for  a  system  of  charges  in  an  external 
magnetic  field.  The  linear  term  in  velocity  of  the  Lagrangian  affects 
the  form  of  the  Hamiltonian.  Let  us  write  down  3?  from  its  definition 
(10.15).  To  do  this  it  is  necessary  to  substitute  into  the  energy  ex- 
pression, by  means  of  equation  (15.29),  momenta  instead  of  velocities  : 

v1'  ------  —  (?,•  -  -  A,)  .  (  i  (15.31) 

mi  \FI        c      V  \\      ^  v  ' 

The  Hamiltoman  is  ;  I  V1  l 

''        (15'32) 


Let  us  assume  that  the  magnetic  field,  in  which  the  system  is 
situated,  is  weak  and  uniform  (at  least  within  the  limits  of  the  system). 
The  vector  potential  for  a  homogeneous  field  will  be  represented  as 

A  =-  *-[Hr]  .  (15.33) 

Indeed,  then  rot  A-H  [from  (11.30),  (11.35)  and  (11.33)].  And  also 
div  A-0  from  (11.29)  and  (11.34). 

Since  the  magnetic  field  is  weak  we  can  neglect  in  (15.32)  the  term 
involving  A?.  Then,  substituting  (15.33)  in  (15.32),  we  find  an  ex- 
pression for  J^: 

<15-34> 


The  last  term  in  (15.34)  gives  the  required  addition  to  the 
Hamiltonian.  Since  this  term  is  proportional  to  H,  we  can  replace  p, 
by  w,-v»  in  it  to  the  same  accuracy,  i.e.,  neglecting  terms  of  order  H2. 
Performing  a  cyclic  permutation  of  the  factors  in  (15.34)  and  putting 
the  sum  inside  a  vector  product  sign,  we  obtain  an  expression  for 
the  addition  to  the  Hamiltonian: 

X"  =  -  (H  JT--^  [r-Vj)  =  -  (Hn)  .  (15.35) 

i 

This  expression  is  very  similar  to  the  energy  of  a  system  of  charges 
in  a  homogeneous  electric  field  which  involves  only  the  electric  dipole 
moment  of  the  system  of  charges.  Note  that  this  term  is  of  the  form 


142  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

—  (dE)    [see   (14.28)].   This   indicates   a  further  similarity   between 
electric  and  magnetic  moments. 

Larmor's  theorem.  Let  us  now  compare  the  expression  for  the 
momentum  of  a  charge  placed  in  a  constant  homogeneous  magnetic 
field  with  that  for  the  momentum  of  a  particle  relative  to  a  rotating 
coordinate  system.  From  (15.29)  and  (15.33),  the  former  is 


--  [Hr]  9  (15>36) 

the  latter  can  be  easily  found  from  (8.5): 

p  =  mv'  +  m[cor].  (15.37) 


We  now  consider  a  steadily  moving  system  of  identical  charges 
(for  example,  an  atom  or  molecule);  the  nuclei,  being  heavier,  are 
regarded  as  fixed.  Let  us  assume  that  in  the  absence  of  any  external 
magnetic  field,  the  motion  in  the  system  is  known.  Then,  comparing 
equations  (15.36)  and  (15.37),  it  is  easy  to  see  that  if  we  consider  the 
motion  of  these  charges  relative  to  axes  rotating  with  angular  velocity 

<•>=-—-,  (15.38) 

it  will  not  differ  from  motion  relative  to  fixed  axes  in  the  absence 
of  a  magnetic  field.  The  equations  of  motion  relative  to  rotating 
axes  will  have  their  usual  form  p,=F,,  where  F,  is  the  force  acting 
on  the  ith  charge  in  the  absence  of  any  external  magnetic  field, 
because  the  correction  to  the  momentum  due  to  the  angular  velocity  G> 
[defined  in  accordance  with  (15.38)]  will  cancel  with  the  correction 
due  to  the  magnetic  field.  The  magnetic  field  must  be  sufficiently 
weak  so  that  the  change  in  magnetic  force  with  rotation  can  be 
neglected. 

We  can  say,  therefore,  that,  with  the  application  of  a  constant 
and  uniform  weak  external  magnetic  field,  a  system  of  charges  with 

identical  —  ratios  begins  to  rotate  with  a  constant  angular  velocity 

_  /-/ 
|  WL  |  =  ~2~  -  .  This   statement  is  called  Larmor's  theorem,   and  G>Z 

is  the  Larmor  frequency. 

Precession  of  the  magnetic  moment.  If  a  system  possesses  a  magnetic 
moment  fx  for  motion  which  is  undisturbed  by  a  magnetic  field, 
then,  when  a  magnetic  field  is  superimposed,  this  moment  will  move 
around  the  direction  of  the  magnetic  field,  similar  to  the  free  top 
in  equations  (9.14)  (note  that  <o  is  in  the  direction  of  the  axis  of 
rotation,  i.e.,  in  the  direction  of  the  magnetic  field).  The  precession 
of  magnetic  moment  about  the  field  is  called  the  Larmor  precession. 

Magnetic  moment  in  an  inhomogeneous  field.  Let  us  suppose  that 
the  magnetic  field  possesses  a  small  inhomogeneity.  Then,  in  the 
equations  of  motion,  the  term 


Sec.  15]  THE   MAGNETOSTATICS   OF  POINT  CHARGES  143 

F  =  -  VJf  '  =  V  (Hfji)  (15.39) 


denotes  the  force  acting  on  the  moment  and  tending  to  move  it 
as  a  whole.  Expanding  (15.39)  by  (11.32),  we  obtain 


But  for  an  external  field  rot  H  is  equal  to  zero  so  that  the  force  is 

(15.40) 


This  is  the  well-known  force  of  attraction  to  a  magnet.  It  is 
maximum  near  the  poles  of  the  magnet  where  the  inhomogeneity 
of  the  field  is  greatest. 

Exercise 

Study  the  magnetic  moment  y.  moving  in  a  magnetic  field  given  by  the 
components  Hz  =  —  H0;  Hx  =  H  ±  cos  <o  t;  Hy  =  Hl  sin  w  t.  Consider  the 

e#o  * 

cases   co  =  to0  —  ~o~~"~»   <*>  ->  0. 

The  equation  describing  a  vector  rotating  with  angular  velocity  o/,  is, 
according  to  Sees.  8  and  9, 


Whence  we  obtain  an  equation  for  the  precession  of  magnetic  moment  in  a 
magnetic  field 


By  multiplying  both  sides  of  this  equation  by  n,  we  convince  ourselves 
that  the  absolute  value  of  magnetic  moment  jx  is  conserved.  It  is,  therefore, 
sufficient  to  write  the  equations  only  for  the  components  \ix  and  (jty,  replacing 
V-z  by  V  V?  —  p£  —  \fy  . 

Using  the  abbreviated  notation  to0  ==  —  —  —  j  cot  =  —  —  —  [Cf.    (1.5.38)],   we 


multiply  the  equation  for  (iy  by   ±  *  and  combine  with  the  equation  for 
to  obtain 

•         (Vx  ±  ipy)  =  ±  ivodtx  ±  *^y)  ±  tttjeiwl  V   JX2  —  I**—  I*      • 


We   seek   the   solution  in   the   form  y.x  ±  *Vy  —  ^  ±  e  ^  f  ^  ,  and   get   the 
following  equation  for  amplitudes  A  ±  : 


Multiplying  these  equations,  we  find 

A              A                                          V-2™!                                      A  l1^ 

A  +  A  -  =        ^    -      ^2    ;     A  ±  =     .  i 

When   6>  =  eo0  ("paramagnetic  resonance"),  the  moment   rotates   in    the 

plane  x  y  with  frequency  o0.  When  <•>  ->  0,  i.e.,  in  the  case  of  an  infinitely 
slow  rotation  of  the  field,  the  moment  strictly  follows  the  field,  its  direction 
all  the  time  being  the  same  as  that  of  the  field. 


144  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    I] 

Sec.  16.  Electrodynamics  of  Material  Media 

Field  in  a  medium.  We  know  that  material  media  consist  of  nuclei 
and  electrons,  i.e.,  of  very  small  charges  in  very  rapid  motion.  There 
fore,  in  a  small  region  of  a  body — a  region  having  atomic  dimensions- 
all  electromagnetic  quantities  (field,  charge  density,  and  current; 
change  very  rapidly  with  time.  In  two  neighbouring  small  regions 
these  quantities  may,  at  the  very  same  instant,  have  completely 
different  values.  Therefore,  if  we  examine  the  field  in  a  medium  ful] 
of  charges  in  detail,  then  we  will  observe  only  a  rapidly  and  irregularly 
varying  function  of  coordinates  and  time. 

Mean  values.  The  inhomogeneities  of  a  field  are  of  atomic  dimensions, 
However,  such  a  detailed  picture  of  the  field  is  not  usually  of  an} 
interest.  As  usual,  in  any  description  of  macroscopic  bodies,  it  is 
essential  to  know  mean  values  for  a  large  number  of  atoms.  For  exam- 
ple, in  mechanics,  mean  density  values  are  used.  For  this  mean  tc 
have  any  significance,  we  must  isolate  a  volume  of  the  body  contain- 
ing a  large  number  of  atoms,  determine  its  mass  and  divide  by  the 
volume. 

This  volume  must  be  so  large  that  the  microscopic  atomic  structure 
of  the  substance  cannot  affect  the  mean  value  of  the  density.  At  the  same 
time,  the  mean  macroscopic  value  must  be  constant  over  that  volume, 
This  will  be  readily  seen  from  the  following.  Let  the  volume  be  arbi- 
trarily divided  into  two  equal  parts.  Then  the  mean  for  each  part 
should  not  differ  from  the  mean  for  the  whole  volume. 

Such  a  volume  is  termed  physically  infinitesimal.  We  shall  call  it 
F0.  If  we  take  all  its  dimensions  to  be  large  compared  with  atomic 
dimensions,  then  the  mean  value  should  not  depend  on  the  shape  oi 
the  surface  bounding  the  volume;  the  latter  may  be  spherical,  cubi- 
cal, etc. 

Besides  averaging  over  volume,  it  is  also  necessary  to  perform 
averaging  over  time.  The  interval  of  time  over  which  the  average  i& 
to  be  taken  must  be  large  compared  with  the  times  of  atomic  motions, 
though  still  sufficiently  small  so  that  the  mean  values  over  two  semi- 
intervals  do  not  differ  from  one  another. 

Let  the  volume  have  the  form  of  a  cube  of  side  a.  We  shall  denote 
the  coordinates  of  its  centre  by  x,  y,  z.  The  time  interval,  over  which 
the  averaging  is  performed,  will  be  called  £0,  and  the  instant  corre- 
sponding to  the  centre  of  the  interval  will  be  denoted  by  t.  The  coordi- 
nates of  any  point  inside  the  cube,  relative  to  the  centre,  will  be  called 
£,  TJ,  £,  and  instants  of  time  measured  from  t,  will  be  denoted  by  &. 
Thus,  the  limits  of  variation  of  the  quantities  are  given  by  the  follow- 
ing inequalities: 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS   OF   MATERIAL  MEDIA  145 

The  actual  value  of  any  quantity  at  a  definite  instant  of  time  is 
/  (x  +  %,  y+f\,  z  +  £,  *+•&).  It  is  related  to  a  mathematically  infinitely 
small  volume  dV^dZ,  df\  d^  and  an  interval  of  time  db.  The  average 
value,  over  a  physically  infinitesimal  volume  V0  and  interval  of  time 
£0,  is  obtained  if  /  is  integrated  over  dV  dt  and  the  integral  divided 
by  F0£0,  in  accordance  with  the  usual  definition  of  an  average  : 

J(x,  y,  z,  t)  - 

a/0        al         al         V 


(16.1 

This  average  value  /  (x,  y,  2,  t)  refers  to  the  point  x,  y,  z,  and  time  t. 
The  electrodynamics  of  such  mean  values  is  termed  macroscopic,  as 
opposed  to  microscopic,  which  has  to  do  with  a  field  due  to  separate 
point  charges  and  a  field  in  free  space. 

The  mean  thus  determined  is  differeiitiable  with  respect  to  time  and 
coordinates.  As  parameters  it  involves  the  coordinates  of  the  centre  of 
a  physically  infinitely  small  volume  x,  y,  z,  and  the  time  t.  Obviously, 
we  can  differentiate  with  respect  to  these  values: 

^-7(*,y,  M)  - 

a/2  -/,  -/,  '•/• 

^~VT  S  d*>  J  d^  S  d^  J^-^/^-i-S'  y±v,*\-l,  t+*)- 

i0---/.    -•/.    --/.  -v.  _  dj 

_-,_„.     (lb.Z) 

In  other  words,  the  mean  value  of  the  derivative  of  a  quantity  is 
equal  to  the  derivative  of  its  mean  value. 

Density  of  charge  and  current  in  a  medium.  Under  the  action  of 
the  electric  and  magnetic  field,  there  occurs  a  redistribution  of  the 
charges  and  currents  in  any  substance.  When  Maxwell's  equations 
are  averaged,  the  mean  density  of  the  redistributed  charge  is  p  and 
that  of  the  current  is  j.  We  shall  express  p  and  j  in  terms  of  other 
values  which  will  later  make  it  possible  to  give  the  averaged  Maxwell 
equations  a  very  symmetrical  form. 

We  define  the  dipole-moment  density  in  a  substance  by  the  follow- 
ing formula: 

(16.3) 


The  dipole  moment  P  in  unit  volume  is  called  the  electric  polarization 
of  the  medium.  If  the  substance  is  completely  neutral,  its  dipole 

moment  is  uniquely  determined  as  ^e^r1'    [see  (14.21)].  Going  over 
to  a  continuous  charge  distribution,  we  write 

10-0060 


146  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

d=fpreZF.  (16.4) 

Integral  (16.3)  can  be  identically  written  in  the  form: 

JPdF  =  -JrdivPdF.  (16.5) 

This  relationship  can  most  simply  be  proved  by  writing  in  terms  of 
components,  for  example, 


(xPx 

Xl 

V»  %  ** 

f  \x(Py)     dxdz+  j   (x(Pz)     dxdy  —  J  J  fp*da;di/dz. 


The  limits  of  integration  are  at  the  external  boundaries  of  the  medium, 
where  the  values  P*,  Py,  P*  are  zero.  This  proves  (16.5).  Comparing 
(16.4)  and  (16.5)  we  obtain 

J  r  (div  P  +  ~p)  dV  =  0  .  (16.6) 

However,  since  the  shape  and  dimensions  of  the  body  are  arbitrary, 
the  quantity 

divP  +  p  =  0  (16.7) 

must  be  zero. 

Thus,  the  mean  density  of  a  charge  "induced"  by  the  field  is  equal 
to  the  divergence  of  the  electric  polarization  vector  taken  with  oppo- 
site sign. 

In  a  similar  way,  we  can  express  the  mean  density  of  induced  cur- 
rent. To  do  this  we  define  the  magnetic  polarization  vector,  equal  to 
the  magnetic-moment  density,  as 

(16.8) 

But    the     magnetic     moment,     by    definition,    is    expressed    as 

_  ,.j  Q.  fr1'  v'1 
=  2^  —  2  —  -.  Applied  to  the  current  distribution,  this  gives 


We  shall  now  prove  an  identity  analogues  to  (16.5): 

(16.10) 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS   OP   MATERIAL   MEDIA  147 

For  this,  it  is  simplest  to  go  over  to  components: 
[rrotM]*dF  =  J  (yrot*M-zrotyM)dF  = 


The  terms   —  y         —   and  —  z  —  ~-  are  integrated    by   parts.  All 

the  integrated  quantities  become  zero  when  the  limits  are  inserted, 
so  that,  in  agreement  with  (16.10),  only  2  Mx  remains.  Now,  comparing 
(16.9)  and  (16.10)  we  obtain 

.dF  =  j^^-dV  .  (16.11) 

In  order  to  determine  j  fully,  we  calculate  its  divergence  and  apply 
the  charge  conservation  law  (12.18)  written  for  mean  values  [see 
(16.2)]: 

div  j  -  -  ^  -  div  ^-  .  (16.12) 

From  (16.11)  and  (16.12),  j  is  uniquely  determined  as 

j^^  +  crotM.  (16.13) 

Indeed,  this  expression  satisfies  both  equations.  Finding  the  diver- 
gence of  both  parts  of  (16.13),  we  arrive  at  (16.12),  since  div  rot  M  =  0. 

8  If 
Further,  substituting  the  quantity-^—  in  the  left-hand  side  of  (16.10), 

we  get 


According  to  (16.3)  and  (16.4),  P  is  replaced  by  pr.  But,  [r,  pr]  =  0, 

OT> 

so  that  the  term  -^—  does  not  contribute  to  equation   (16.11).  The 

identity  (16.13)  is  thus  proved. 

Averaging  Maxwell's  equations.  We  shall  now  consider  the  averaging 
of  Maxwell's  equations.  From  (16.2),  differentiation  and  averaging 
are  commutative,  so  that  a  bar  can  simply  be  put  over  the  first  pair 
in  order  to  denote  that  they  have  been  averaged: 

-,  (16.15) 


divH=  —  0.  (16.16) 

The  mean  value  of  an  electric  field  E  is  called  the  electric  field  in  a 
medium.  We  shall  hereafter  write  it  without  the  bar,  which  denotes 
that  it  has  been  averaged,  taking  it  for  granted  that  only  mean  values 


148  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

will  always  be  taken  in  a  medium.  The  mean  value  of  the  magnetic 
field  is  called  the  magnetic  induction  and  is  denoted  by  the  letter  B. 
ft  is  all  the  more  unnecessary  to  write  a  bar  over  it  because  the  concept 
of  induction,  which  is  not  equal  to  field,  makes  sense  only  for  a  medium. 
The  asymmetry  in  the  terminology  for  electric  and  magnetic  fields 
will  bo  explained  later. 

In  this  notation,  the  first  pair  of  Maxwell's  equations  takes  the 
following  form: 

wtE  =-!-£.,  (16-17) 

divB-0.  (16.18) 

Now  let  us  average  the  second  pan*  of  Maxwell's  equations  : 


(16.20) 

We  substitute  p  and  j  from  (16.7)  and  (16.13)  and  rearrange  the 
terms  somewhat,  obtaining  the  two  following  equations  (the  bars  are 
again  omitted): 

rot(B  —  47cM)  -  —  -|-(E  +  4:rP)  ,  (16.21) 


div  (E  +  47rP)  =  0  .  (16.22) 

We  introduce  the  following  new  designations: 

E   [47cP-D.  (16.23) 

I)  is  called  the  electric  induction. 
Further, 

B  —  47cM^H.  (16.24) 

II  is  called  the  magnetic  field  in  a  medium,  which,  therefore,  does  not 
equal  the  mean  value  of  the  magnetic  field  in  a  vacuum. 

In  the  notations  (16.23)  and  (  1  6.24),  the  second  pah*  is  written  similar 
to  t  he  first  pair  : 

rot  II  ^  J~?£,  (16.25) 

divD-0.  (16.26) 

The  similarity  between  (16.26)  and  (16.18)  explains  why  it  was 
convenient  to  call  the  mean  value  of  the  magnetic  field  the  magnetic 
induction:  here,  both  electric  and  magnetic  induction  vectors  have  no 
sources  in  the  medium.  The  similarity  between  (16.25)  and  (16.17) 
justifies  the  term  magnetic  field  given  to  the  vector  H  (16.24). 

The  incompleteness  of  the  system  of  equations  in  a  medium.  Thus, 
due  to  a  suitable  system  of  notation,  the  first  and  second  pairs  of 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS    OF    MATERIAL   MEDIA  149 

Maxwell's  equations  in  a  medium  have,  as  it  were,  become  more  symmet- 
rical than  those  in  a  vacuum.  But  we  must  not  forget  that  this  system 
has  now  ceased  to  be  complete:  as  before,  there  are  eight  equations 
(of  which  only  six  are  independent)  and  twelve  unknowns  B,  E,  D,  H 
(with  three  components  for  each  vector).  Consequently,  the  system 
(16.17),  (16.18),  (16.25),  and  (16.26)  cannot  be  solved  until  a  relationship 
is  found  between  inductions  and  fields.  This  relationship  cannot  be 
obtained  without  knowing  the  specific  structure  of  the  material 
medium. 

Dielectrics  and  conductors.  We  shall  consider,  first  of  all,  how  charges 
behave  in  a  medium  in  the  presence  of  a  constant  electric  field.  The 
field  will  displace  the  positive  charges  in  one  direction,  arid  the  nega- 
tive ones  in  another.  As  a  result,  polarization  P  will  arise.  Two  essen- 
tially different  cases  can  occur  here. 

1)  Under  the  action  of  the  field  inside  the  body,  a  certain  finite 
polarization  P,  dependent  on  the  field,  is  established.  This  polariza- 
tion may  be  represented  vividly  (though  in  very  simplified  fashion!) 
as  a  displacement  of  charges  from  the  equilibrium  positions  which  they 
occupied  in  the  absence  of  the  field  to  new  equilibrium  positions — 
much  like  the  way  a  load  suspended  on  a  spring  is  displaced  in  a  gravi- 
tational field.  If  a  finite  polarization  (dependent  on  the  field  inside  the 
body)  is  established,  that  body  is  called  a  nonconductor  or  dielectric. 

2)  In  a  constant  electric  field  acting  inside  the  body,  the  charges  do 
not  arrive  at  equilibrium,  and  a  definite  rate  of  polarization  increase, 

-^—  ,  is  established.  In  this  case,  through  every  section  of  the  conductor 

dP 

perpendicular  to  the  vector  -^~ ,  there  pass  electric  charges  or,  what 

amounts  to  the  same  thing,  a  flow  of  current.  From  equation  (16.13), 

the  derivative  -TT-  may  indeed  be  interpreted  as  a  current  component. 

ct 

As  regards  the  second  current  component,  c  rot  M,  it  relates  to  the 
instantaneous  value  of  quantities  and  cannot  characterize  the  change 
of  anything  with  time.  For  this  reason,  the  classification  of  bodies  into 
conductors  and  dielectrics  is  obtained  from  the  behaviour  of  the 

...      dP 

quantity  -^— . 

The  displacement  of  charges  under  the  action  of  a  field  can  roughly 
be  likened  to  a  load  falling  in  a  viscous  medium  with  friction,  when,  as 
is  known,  a  definite  speed  of  fall  is  established. 

A  medium,  in  which  a  constant  electric  field  produces  a  constant 
electric  current,  is  called  a  conductor. 

If  a  constant  electric  field  is  produced  in  free  space  and  a  conducting 
body  of  finite  dimensions  is  introduced  into  it  (for  example,  a  conduct- 
ing sphere  or  ellipsoid),  the  charges  in  the  body  will  be  displaced  so 
that  a  field  equal  to  zero  will  be  established  inside  the  conductor.  For 
this,  the  mean  charge  density  inside  the  body  must  also  equal  zero, 


160  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

because  the  lines  of  force  of  the  field  originate  and  terminate  at  charges. 
Under  the  action  of  such  a  field,  the  charges  inside  the  conductor 
would  be  displaced.  This  means  that  an  equilibrium  will  be  established 
inside  the  conductor  only  when  all  the  induced  charges  emerge  to  the 
surface.  They  will  be  distributed  on  the  surface  of  the  body  so  that  the 
mean  field  inside  the  conductor  is  zero,  and  the  lines  of  force  outside 
the  conductor  will  arrive  normal  to  every  point  of  the  surface. 

Continuous  current  in  a  conductor.  A  continuous  current  can 
flow  in  a  conductor  only  along  a  closed  conducting  circuit.  And  the 
electric  field  must  always  have  a  component  along  the  direction 
of  the  circuit.  Then  charges  of  given  sign  will  always  move  in  one 
direction,  thereby  producing  a  closed  current.  The  work  performed 
by  unit  charge  in  moving  around  the  circuit  is  called  the  e.m.f.  acting 
in  the  circuit: 


.f.  =  J  Edl.  (16.27) 


e.  m 

This  formula  differs  from  (12.1)  in  that  E  denotes  the  field  acting 
inside  the  conductor. 

External  sources  ol  e.m.f.  In  a  conductor,  a  constant  e.m.f.  can 
only  exist  at  the  expense  of  some  external  source  of  energy,  for  example, 
a  primary  cell.  When  a  current  passes  in  the  circuit  of  the  cell,  ions 
are  neutralized  on  the  electrodes,  thus  yielding  the  source  of  energy 
that  maintains  the  e.m.f. 

If,  as  usual,  we  put  E  =  —  ^9,  then  the  expression  for  e.m.f. 
will  be 


.f.  =  -  J 


e.m 


Therefore,  the  e.ra.f.  may  be  defined  as  the  change  in  potential 
in  going  round  a  closed  path.  Thus,  the  potential  is  not  a  unique 
function  of  a  point :  for  each  traverse,  it  changes  by  the  value  of  the 
e.m.f.  in  the  circuit. 

The  magnetic  properties  ol  bodies.  We  shall  now  consider  the 
magnetic  properties  of  bodies.  In  a  constant  magnetic  field,  a  definite 
equilibrium  state  will  always  be  established  in  the  medium.  Here 
we  must  distinguish  between  the  following  two  cases. 

1)  In  the  absence  of  a  field,  the  atoms  or  molecules  of  a  substance 
possess  certain  characteristic  magnetic  moments  that  differ  from 
zero. 

As  was  shown  in  the  previous  section,  the  energy  of  every  separate 
elementary  magnet  in  a  magnetic  field  is  —  [i  H.  Hence,  the  energy 
of  elementary  magnets  that  have  a  positive  moment  projection 
on  the  field  is  less  than  the  energy  of  elementary  magnets  with  a 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS   OF   MATERIAL   MEDIA  151 

negative  moment  projection.  Atoms  and  molecules  are  in  random 
thermal  motion.  As  a  result  of  this  motion  and  of  the  action  of  a 
magnetic  field,  an  advantageous  energy  state  is  established  in  which 
positive  moment  projections  on  the  field  predominate.  For  more 
detail  about  this  equilibrium  see  Part  IV. 

It  will  be  noted  that  the  projection  of  an  isolated  magnetic  moment 
on  the  magnetic  field  is  constant — it  merely  performs  a  Larmor 
precession  around  the  field.  But  the  interaction  between  molecules 
disturbs  the  motion  of  separate  moments,  and  results  in  the  establish- 
ment of  a  state  with  a  mean  magnetic  polarization  other  than  zero. 

2)  The  atoms  or  molecules  of  a  body  do  not  possess  their  own 
magnetic  moments  in  the  absence  of  a  field. 

As  was  shown  in  the  previous  section,  when  an  external  magnetic 
field  is  applied,  the  motion  of  charges  in  atoms  or  molecules  changes 
due  to  the  Larmor  precession.  Indeed,  a  precession  of  angular  veloc- 
ity co  =  — —  is  superimposed  on  motion  undisturbed  by  a  magnetic 

field.  In  exercise  4  of  this  section  it  will  be  shown  that  this  precession 
leads  to  the  appearance  of  a  magnetic  moment  in  a  system  of  charges. 
We  shall  only  note  here  that  the  direction  of  the  magnetic  moment 
induced  by  the  field  must  be  in  opposition  to  the  direction  of  the 
magnetic  field;  this  follows  from  Lenz's  induction  law.  Indeed,  an 
induced  current  produces  a  magnetic  field  in  a  direction  opposite 
to  that  of  the  inducing  field. 

A  substance  in  which  an  external  magnetic  field  produces  a  resultant 
moment  in  the  same  direction,  is  called  paramagnetic.  If  the  magnet- 
ization is  in  the  opposite  direction  to  the  field,  the  substance  is  dia- 
magnetic. 

Ferromagnetism.  There  are  crystalline  bodies  in  which  the  magnetic 
moments  are  aligned  spontaneously,  i.e.,  in  the  absence  of  any  external 
magnetic  field.  Such  bodies  are  called  ferromagnetic.  The  magnetic 
polarization  of  the  body  itself  is  related  to  the  directions  of  the 
crystalline  axes.  For  example,  in  iron,  whose  crystals  have  cubic 
symmetry,  the  intrinsic  magnetization  coincides  with  one  of  the 
sides  of  the  cube.  This  direction  is  called  the  direction  of  ready  magnet- 
ization. In  order  to  deflect  the  magnetic  polarization  from  the  direction 
of  ready  magnetization,  work  must  be  performed. 

A  single  crystal  of  a  ferromagnetic  substance  will  be  magnetized 
so  that  the  resultant  energy  is  a  minimum — equilibrium  always 
corresponds  to  minimum  energy.  However,  it  does  not  necessarily 
follow  from  this  that  all  of  the  single  crystal  is  magnetized  in  one 
direction :  in  this  case  it  will  possess  an  external  magnetic  field  whose 

energy  is  -g—  \  H2dV.  This  quantity  is  always  positive  and  increases 

the  total  energy.  But  if  the  single  crystal  is  divided  into  regions 
or  layers  whose  magnetization  alternates  in  direction,  then  the 


152  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

external  field  can  be  eliminated  since  neighbouring  layers  (or,  as 
they  are  called,  domains)  produce  fields  of  opposite  sign.  In  the  tran- 
sition region  between  domains,  the  polarization  gradually  turns  from 
the  direction  of  ready  magnetization  in  one  domain  to  the  reverse 
direction  in  the  other  domain.  Clearly,  if  a  certain  direction  is  the 
direction  of  ready  magnetization,  then  the  directly  opposite  direction 
also  possesses  this  property.  The  structure  of  the  transition  region 
has  been  studied  theoretically  by  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits. 

The  domain  structure  of  crystals  was  later  demonstrated  experi- 
mentally. If  a  very  thin  emulsion  of  particles  of  a  ferromagnetic 
substance  is  spread  over  the  smooth  surface  of  a  ferromagnetic  single 
crystal,  the  particles  will  be  distributed  along  lines  where  the  inter- 
faces between  domains  intersect  the  surface  of  the  crystal. 

Since,  between  domains,  the  polarization  is  deflected  from  the 
direction  of  ready  magnetization,  it  is  necessary  to  perform  work 
to  establish  the  transition  region.  Summarizing,  if  the  whole  single 

crystal  consists  of  one  domain,  its  energy  increases  at  the  expense 

i     * 
of  work  done  in  creating  an  external  field,   equal  to    -^—     HzdV\ 

if,  however,  the  crystal  consists  of  many  domains,  the  energy  increases 
at  the  expense  of  the  additional  energy  of  the  transition  regions. 
The  equilibrium  state  will  be  that  state  in  which  the  energy  is  least. 
The  energy  of  a  field  increases  with  the  volume  it  occupies,  that 
is,  as  the  cube  of  the  linear  dimensions  of  the  crystal.  The  energy 
of  the  transition  regions  increases  in  proportion  to  their  total  area. 
In  a  crystal  of  sufficiently  small  dimensions,  there  can  exist  only 
one  transition  region  whose  area  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the 
linear  dimensions  of  the  single  crystal.  Therefore,  in  such  a  small 
crystal,  the  volume  energy  changes  according  to  a  cubic  law  with 
respect  to  dimensions,  while  the  surface  energy  varies  according 
to  a  square  law.  In  a  sufficiently  small  crystal,  the  volume  energy 
becomes  less  than  the  surface  energy;  such  a  crystal  is  not  separated 
into  domains  but  is  magnetized  as  a  whole.  This  has  been  experi- 
mentally established  in  crystals  with  dimensions  of  10~4-10~6  cm. 
The  thickness  of  domains  in  large  crystals  of  appropriate  ferromagnet- 
ics is  of  the  same  order. 

An  example  of  the  shape  of  a  domain  as  proposed  by  Landau 

and  Lifshits  is  shown  in  Fig.  22.  The  arrows 

denote  the  direction  of  the  polarization  in  each 
domain.  The  serrations  at  the  boundary  almost 

completely  destroy  the  external  magnetic  field ; 

Fig.  22  the  *nies  °f  magnetic  induction  inside  the  crystal 

are  closed  through  them,  and  do  not  emerge. 

The  magnetization  of  a  ferromagnetic  in  an  external  field.  If  a 

magnetic  field  is  applied  to  a  ferromagnetic  crystal  in  the  direction  of 
ready  magnetization,  then  those  regions,  for  which  the  polarization 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS   OF   MATERIAL   MEDIA  153 

is  in  opposition  to  the  field,  are  contracted  with  displacement  of 
the  interfaces  and  may  disappear  completely  in  a  comparatively 
small  field.  Then  the  crystal  is  magnetized  to  saturation.  In  order 
to  magnetize  the  crystal  to  saturation  in  a  direction  that  is  not  coin- 
cident with  the  initial  direction  of  polarization  in  the  domains,  con- 
siderably larger  fields  are  required. 

In  a  poly  crystalline  body,  such  as  ordinary  steel,  the  separate 
single  crystals  are  oriented  more  or  less  at  random  relative  to  one 
another.  In  any  case,  the  directions  of  ready  magnetization  are  not 
the  same  for  the  separate  crystals.  When  an  external  magnetic  field 
is  applied,  the  different  crystals  are  magnetized  differently  and  the 
magnetization  curve  is  not  as  steep  as  is  possible  in  the  case  of  a 
separate  crystal.  The  magnetic  interaction  between  separate  crystals 
results  in  a  definite  magnetic  polarization  remaining  after  steel  has 
been  magnetized  and  the  field  subsequently  removed.  This  is  what 
is  known  as  hysteresis. 

Magnetic  interaction  of  atoms.  Let  it  be  noted,  in  addition,  that 
the  magnetic  interaction  between  separate  elementary  (atomic) 
magnets  is  not  at  all  adequate  in  explaining  the  cause  of  ferromagnetism. 
The  energy  of  interaction  between  two  elementary  magnetic  moments 
is  of  the  order  10~16  erg,  while  the  energy  of  thermal  motion  at  room 
temperature  is  about  10  14  erg  (see  Part  IV).  This  is  why  random 
thermal  motion  should  destroy  the  orderly  magnetization  already 
at  a  temperature  of  about  1°  above  absolute  zero.  Actually,  ferro- 
magnetism of  steel  disappears  in  the  neighbourhood  of  1,000°  above 
absolute  zero,  thus  corresponding  to  an  interaction  energy  between 
elementary  magnets  in  the  order  of  10~13  erg. 

Ferromagnetism  is  of  quantum  origin  and  cannot  be  explained 
with  the  aid  of  classicial  analogues. 

The  relationship  between  fields  and  inductions.  A  substance  is 
always  in  equilibrium  in  a  constant  external  magnetic  field.  To  this 
equilibrium  there  corresponds  a  very  definite  induction  and  polari- 
zation. In  a  weak  field,  the  relationship  between  the  quantities  is 
linear.  For  this  reason,  the  magnetic  induction  is  expressed  linearly 
in  terms  of  the  magnetic  field  in  a  medium: 


(16.29a) 

In  a  dielectric,  where  a  static  equilibrium  polarization  corresponds 
to  a  definite  electric  field,  there  is  a  similar  relationship  for  weak 
fields. 

D-sE.  (16.29b) 

The  quantity  x  is  called  the  permeability  and  e  is   the  dielectric 
constant. 

It  should  be  noted  that  in  ferromagnetics  the  region  for  which 
a  linear  law  is  applicable  has  an  upper  limit  of  not  very  large  fields 


154  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

(102-104  CGSE),  since  saturation  sets  in;  in  diamagnetic  and 
paramagnetic  substances  at  room  temperatures  a  linear  law  applies 
for  all  actually  attainable  fields. 

The  vector  nature  of  electric  and  magnetic  fields.  The  question 
may  arise:  Why  is  magnetic  induction  expressed  linearly  solely  in 
terms  of  magnetic  field,  while  electric  induction  is  expressed  solely 
in  terms  of  electric  field? 

In  order  to  answer  this  question  we  must  examine  the  vector 
properties  of  electromagnetic  quantities  in  more  detail. 

Two  separate  systems  of  rectangular  coordinates  exist  in  space: 
a  right-hand  system  and  a  left-hand  system.  They  are  related  to 
each  other  like  left  and  right  hands,  if  the  thumbs  are  in  the  direction 
of  the  o;-axes,  the  forefingers  aJong  the  y-axes,  and  the  middle 
fingers  along  the  z-axes.  It  is  obvious  that  no  rotation  in  space  can 
make  these  two  systems  coincide.  However,  one  system  transforms 
to  the  other  if  the  signs  of  the  coordinates  in  it  are  reversed.  Of 
course,  both  coordinate  systems  are  completely  equivalent  physi- 
cally. The  choice  of  any  one  of  them  is  completely  arbitrary.  Therefore, 
the  form  of  any  equation  expressing  a  law  in  electrodynamics  should 
not  change  under  a  transformation  from  a  right-hand  to  a  left-hand 
system. 

Let  us  now  take  Maxwell's  equation  (12.24).  In  order  to  perform 
a  transformation  to  another  coordinate  system,  it  is  sufficient  to 
change  the  signs  of  the  coordinates.  This  changes  the  sign  of  the 
vector  operation  rot,  because  this  operation  denotes  a  differentiation 
with  respect  to  coordinates.  What  happens,  then,  to  the  electric 
field  components  ?  Since  only  one  of  two  vectors  is  differentiated  with 
respect  to  the  coordinates,  namely  E,  the  sign  of  one  of  them  must 
change  in  order  to  retain  the  form  of  the  equation.  It  is  easy  to  see 
that  vector  E  will  change  sign.  Indeed,  the  right-hand  side  of  equation 
div  E  =  4  TT  p  is  a  scalar  and  does  not  change  in  sign.  On  the  left- 
hand  side,  the  sign  of  the  div  operation  changes  and,  hence,  the  signs 
of  all  the  components  of  E  must  also  change.  Therefore,  the  com- 
ponents of  the  magnetic  field  do  not  change  sign  in  a  transformation 
from  a  left-hand  to  a  right-hand  system. 

In  a  rotation  of  a  coordinate  system,  the  projections  of  any  vector 
are  transformed  by  the  same  equations  of  analytical  geometry  as 
the  coordinates.  As  was  shown,  the  change  of  sign  for  all  three  coordi- 
nates is  not  equivalent  to  any  rotation.  It  turns  out  that  some  vectors, 
such  as  E,  behave  quite  similarly  to  a  radius  vector  r;  when  the  signs 
of  the  components  of  the  radius  vector  r  are  changed,  the  signs  of 
all  the  components  of  E  also  change.  Other  vectors,  such  as  H,  behave 
like  a  radius  vector  under  coordinate  rotations,  and  not  like  a  radius 
vector  in  the  transformation  from  a  right-hand  to  a  left-hand  system. 

Vectors  that  behave  like  E  are  called  true  or  polar  vectors,  while 
those  behaving  like  H  are  called  pseudovectors  or  axia)  vectors. 


SeC.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS    OF    MATERIAL    MEDIA  155 

Velocity,  force,  acceleration,  current  density,  and  vector  potential 
are,  in  addition  to  the  electric  field,  real  vectors  while  magnetic 
moment,  angular  momentum  and  angular  velocity  are  pseudo- 
vectors. 

The  fact  that  angular  momentum  is  a  pseudo vector  can  easily  be 
seen  from  its  definition:  M  =  [rp].  Both  factors  of  the  vector  prod- 
uct, r  and  p,  change -signs,  so  that  M  does  not  change  in  sign. 

A  pseudovector  cannot  be  linearly  related  to  a  real  vector  in  electro- 
dynamics because  the  sign  in  any  such  equality  would  depend  on 
the  choice  of  coordinate  system,  which  contradicts  physical  facts. 
For  this  reason  the  vectors  B  and  H,  D  and  E  appear  separately  in 
the  linear  laws  (16.29a)  and  (16.29b). 

The  equations  for  conductors  in  a  constant  field.  We  shall  now 
consider  the  equations  of  electrodynamics  of  constant  fields  for 
conductors.  As  has  already  been  indicated,  it  is  not  a  constant  value 
of  polarization  that  is  established  in  a  conductor  in  a  constant  field, 

#P 

but  a  constant  rate  of  increase  of  polarization  -=-r .  This  quantity  has 

O  T| 

the  meaning  of  current  density  j'.  The  derivative  -^— ,  appearing  on 
the  right-hand  side  of  Maxwell's  equations,  may  be  replaced  thus: 

Tf-**-£-4«J''  <16-30> 

because  the  field  is  constant.  Here,  the  current  j'  is  also  continuous. 

The  magnetic  field  is  a  pseudovector  and  cannot  be  linearly  related 
to  the  current  density.  We  note  that  for  metals  the  linear  relationship 
between  field  and  current  (Ohm's  law)  does  not  break  down,  no 
matter  how  strong  the  field. 

The  quantity  cr  is  called  the  specific  conductance,  or  conductivity. 
In  the  CGSE  system  its  dimensions  are  inverse  seconds.  For  metals  cr 
is  of  the  order  1017  sec"1. 

Slowly  varying  fields.  So  far,  an  electromagnetic  field  in  a  medium 
has  been  regarded  as  strictly  constant  with  time.  But  if  the  field 
varies  sufficiently  slowly  with  time,  it  may  also  be  considered  as 
constant.  Let  us  give  a  general  criterion  whereby  we  can  say  what 
field  may  be  regarded  as  slowly  varying. 

We  assume  that  a  constant  field  is  switched  on  at  some  initial 
instant  of  time  t  =  0.  A  stationary  state  is  not  established  in  the 
medium  at  once  but  only  after  a  certain  interval  of  time  0  has  elapsed. 
If,  for  example,  the  medium  is  a  dielectric,  then,  in  that  time,  a  def- 
inite polarization  is  established  corresponding  to  the  given  field; 
in  a  metal,  0  characterizes  the  time  taken  for  a  constant  current 
to  be  established.  0  is  called  the  relaxation  time.  If,  during  the  relax- 
ation time,  the  field  changes  by  only  a  small  fraction  of  its  value 
it  can  be  regarded  as  constant  within  the  accuracy  of  that  small 
fraction.  In  other  words,  the  criterion  of  slowness  of  variation  of  a 


156  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

field  is  this :  within  the  relaxation  time  a  stationary  state,  correspond- 
ing to  the  given  value  of  field,  has  time  to  establish  itself  in  the  medium. 
Such  fields  are  termed  slowly  varying.  For  them,  the  same  values 
of  permeability,  dielectric  constant,  and  conductivity  can  be  sub- 
stituted into  Maxwell's  equations,  as  for  constant  fields. 

Let  us  write  down  Maxwell's  equations  for  a  slowly  varying  field  in  a 
conductor.  In  the  expression 

c>D        8E  #P        3E 


the  first  term  can  be  neglected  in  the  majority  of  cases  because  it 
in  no  way  exceeds  - -;  if ,  as  occurs  in  metals,  a  is  of  the  order  of  1017, 

then    aE  >  E/Q.   Whence    Maxwell's  equations    are  obtained  for   a 
slowly  varying  field  in  a  conductor: 

A.  TI  **7rj  47TCrJi  /ir*    fui\ 

rotH  -^       J- = ,  (16.32) 

c  c 

rotE    -  -A^H  (16.33) 

C       O  It 

divxH-0.  (16.34) 

This  system  is  complete  and,  together  with  the  boundary  con- 
ditions (see  exercises  1  and  5  in  this  section),  is  sufficient  for  the  deter- 
mination of  slowly  varying  fields  in  a  conductor. 

Rapidly  varying  fields.  Let  us  now  consider  the  case  of  rapidly 
varying  fields,  i.e.,  fields  which  change  more  rapidly  than  the  relax- 
ation process  or  the  establishment  of  a  definite  stationary  stato 
in  the  medium.  Then  the  state  of  the  medium  depends  not  only 
on  the  instantaneous  value  of  the  field,  but  also  on  its  values  at 
previous  instants  of  time;  in  other  words,  it  depends  on  the  way 
in  which  the  field  changes  with  time.  Such  a  relationship  is  very 
complicated  in  the  general  case.  It  is  simplified  if  the  field  is  weak : 
then,  at  any  rate,  we  may  expect  the  relationship  to  be  linear. 

Expansion  in  harmonic  components.  Let  us  examine  the  general 
form  of  the  linear  relationship.  To  do  so  we  represent  the  field  as 
follows : 


E  (t)  -JTEfeCosfcofc*  +  9*)  >  (16.35) 

k 

i.e.,  we  expand  it  in  harmonic  components.  The  more  values  of  the 
amplitudes  E*,  frequencies  cofc,  and  phases  <pfc,  we  take,  the  better 
the  approximation  for  the  variation  of  E.  However,  if  the  relationship 
between  induction  and  field  is  linear,  then  the  induction  is  also  of 
the  form  of  a  sum  of  harmonic  components:  Dk  cos  (cok£  +  9*), 
where  (and  this  is  most  important)  each  term  in  the  sum  for  induction 
is  determined  by  the  term  of  the  same  frequency  in  (16.35). 


Soc.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS    OF   MATERIAL   MEDIA  157 

This  does  not  contradict  the  general  statement  that  the  induction 
is  determined  by  the  entire  time  dependence  of  a  rapidly  varying 
field;  for  a  harmonic  relationship  between  field  and  time,  it  is  fully 
given  by  its  amplitude,  phase,  and  frequency.  And  a  component  of 
the  field  with  a  certain  frequency  can  in  no  way  give  rise  to  induction 
components  with  another  frequenc3r  if  the  relationship  between 
field  and  induction  is  linear,  for  no  linear  relationship  exists  between 
trigonometric  functions  of  different  arguments.  Therefore,  if  we 
write  the  functions  even  with  the  same  frequency  but  with  different 
phases  9^  and  fyk,  we  do  not  directly  obtain  a  linear  relationship 
either.  However,  if  we  use  a  complex  form  and  express  the  field  and 
induction  in  terms  of  exponentials  by  means  of  the  equations 


!(«)=   _ 

(16.36) 

•=^a 

k 

(the  star  denotes  a  complex  conjugate  quantity),  then  a  linear  rela- 
tionship between  field  and  induction  can  be  written  in  the  following 
form : 

Dfe  •=  efeEfc  or  D  (to)  --  s  (to)  E  (to) .  (16.37) 

The  quantities  D&  and  Efc  are  complex.  From  a  comparison  of 
(16.35)  and  (16.36)  it  can  be  seen  that  they  differ  from  the  real  field 

and  induction  amplitudes  by  the  complex  factors  —  el*k  and  -  -  e^k . 

Thus,  the  dielectric  constant  ek  ~  £  (  to)  must  also  be  a  complex 
quantity.  A  complex  permeability  ^  (to)  is  similarly  introduced. 
Maxwell's  equations  in  complex  form.  Let  us  now  write  down 
Maxwell's  equations  for  complex  field  components.  It  must  be  noted 
that  they  are  a  function  of  time  according  to  an  e-'63'  law.  We  shall 
divide  the  equations  by  these  factors  and  get  the  following  system 
of  Maxwell's  equations  for  rapidly  varying  harmonic  fields: 

rot  II  —  i--s(co)E,  (16.38) 

c 

rotE-i  "-/(to)H,  (16.39) 

diveE  =  0,  (16.40) 

div/H  -0.  (16.41) 

The  imaginary  parts  of  the  dielectric  constant  and  permeability 
lead  to  the  energy  of  a  rapidly  varying  field  being  spent  on  the  gener- 
ation of  heat  in  the  substance  (see  exercise  18). 


158 


ELECTROD  Y  N  AMICS 


[Part  II 


We  note,  in  addition,  that  for  rapidly  varying  fields  the  division 
of  bodies  into  conductors  and  dielectrics  is  conditional  and  is  deter- 
mined by  the  relationship  between  the  imaginary  and  real  parts 
of  the  dielectric  constant.  A  substance  retains  the  character  of  a 
conductor  up  to  such  frequencies  of  a  rapidly  varying  field  as  satisfy 

the  inequality  —  >  6. 

Exercises 

1)  Show  that  on  tho  boundary  between  two  media  the  tangential  compo- 
nents of  tho  fields  and  the  normal  components  of  induction  are  continuous. 

Integrate  the  equations  for  the  inductions  over  a  small  flat  cylinder, 
and  tho  equations  for  fields  over  a  narrow  quadrilateral  bounding  the  inter- 
face (Fig.  23a  and  b). 

2)  Show  that  a  magnetic  field  varying  sinusoidally  with   time   is  damped 
with  depth  in  the  conductor  (x  =  !)• 

From  equations  (16.32) -(16.34)  we  have 


dx 


d  K 
~dx 


Y  _  __  *L 

z  ' 


4  77 


whence 


whore  a;  is  a  coordinate,  normal  to  tho  surface  of  a  conductor. 

3)  Show  that  equations  (16.32)-(  16.34)  aro  formally  applicable  to  the 
case  of  rapidly  varying  fields,  if  the  relationship  between  field  and  time  is 
considered  harmonic.  In  this  case  the  conductivity  a  is  proportional  to  the 
imaginary  part  of  e,  and  the  real  part  of  c  is  equal  to  zero. 


Fig.  23 


b) 


4)  Calculate  the  permeability  of  a  substance  whose  molecules  do  not  possess 
intrinsic  magnetic  moments. 

Tho  additional  velocity  of  charges,  when  a  magnetic  field  is  applied,  is 
v  —  [<o  r],  where  <o  is  given  by  Larmor's  theorem  (15.38);  whence  the  magnetic 
momont  is  determined  from  the  general  expression  (15.19).  The  mean  pro- 
jection of  this  moment  on  H  is  obtained  by  averaging  over  the  angles  between 
H  and  r.  From  this  wo  find  the  magnetic  polarization  and,  finally,  x: 


where  N  is  the  number  of  molecules  in  unit  volume  and   (rl)2,is  the   mean 
square  of  the  radius  of  rotation  of  the  t'th  charge. 

5)  Show  that  an  electric  field  near  the  surface  of  a  charged  conductor  is 
equal  to  4  TC  y,  whore  y  is  the  surface  density  of  static  charge  on  the  conductor. 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS   OF   MATERIAL  MEDIA  159 

We  use  the  same  method  as  in  exercise  1  of  integrating  equation  (12.27) 
over  a  small  flat  cylinder  bounding  the  conductor  on  both  sides,  with  account 
taken  of  the  fact  that  the  field  inside  the  conductor  is  equal  to  zero.  For  quasi- 
stationary  fields  -^—  =  /'«,  where  j'n  is  the  projection  of  ]'  on   the   external 
ot 

normal. 

6)  Calculate  the  energy  of  a  system  of  charged  conductors  in  a  vacuum. 

•  »        Tfl2 

We  substitute  E  =  —  v  <P  in  the  definition  of  energy  &  eleotr  =  I  •« —  d  V 

and  integrate  by  parts,  taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that  in  a  vacuum 
A  9  =  0.  Since,  from  exorcise  5  in  this  section,  the  field  close  to  a  conductor 
is  equal  to  4  TT  y ,  and  the  surface  of  a  conductor  is  equipotential,  wo  reduce 
to  the  form 

&  electr  =  ~tT/,  e*  W  • 

i 
where  e\  is  the  charge  on  the  tth  conductor  arid  9;  is  its  potential. 

7)  Determine  how  a  constant  uniform  electric  field  changes  if  a  conducting 
sphere  is  introduced  into  it. 

The  field  potential  must  be  sought  in  the  form  9  =  —  li!0  r  -1 ,    where 

the  vector  d  is  in  tho  same  direction  as  the  initial  uniform  field  E0.  d  is  deter- 
mined from  the  condition  that  the  tangential  component  —  E  —  y  9  on 
the  sphere  is  equal  to  zero. 

8)  Determine  in  what  way  a  constant  uniform  electric  field  E0  varies  if 
a  dielectric  sphere  of  dielectric  constant  e  is  introduced  into  it. 

The  field  potential  outside  the  sphere  must  bo  sought  in  the  same  form 
as  in  problem  7,  but,  inside  the  sphere,  it  must  be  sought  in  tho  form  — •  E'  r, 
where  E' —  const.  Determine  tho  vectors  d  and  E'  from  tho  boundary  condi- 
tions derived  in  exerciso  1. 

9)  Find  the  electric  field  which  arises  in  space  when  a  point  charge  e  is 
brought  to  a  distance  a  from  an  infinite  flat  conducting  surface. 

We  drop  a  perpendicular  from  the  point  at  which  the  charge  is  situated 
to  the  surface  of  tho  conductor  and,  at  a  distance  a  inside  the  conductor,  wo 
place  an  equal  and  opposite  (fictitious)  charge  e.  Then,  the  field  component 
tangential  to  the  surface  becomes  zero.  Tho  field  outside  the  conductor  is 
everywhere  equal  to  the  vector  sum  of  tho  fields  due  to  the  real  and  fictitious 
charges. 

10)  Find  the  electric  field  when  a  point  charge  e  is  brought  to  a  distance 
a  from  an  infinite  flat  surface  of  a  dielectric  with  constant  e.  The  dielectric 
is  infinitely  deep. 

We  make  the  same  construction  as  in  exercise  9.  We  look  for  the  field 

e'  r 
inside  the  dielectric  of  the  form  — ~,  where  FJ  is  a  radius  vector  from  tho  point 

ri 
at  which  the  real  charge  is  situated;  the  field  outside  the  dielectric  is  of  the 

c  TI        &"  r« 
form  — 3™  +  •     o     where  r2  is  a  radius  vector  drawn  from  the  "image"  of  the 

r\  ^a 

charge.  The  constants  e'  and  e,"  are  determined  from  the  boundary  conditions 
of  exercise  1. 

11)  Assuming  that   x  —  1>   determine  the  magnetic  energy   of  a   system 
of  conductors  carrying  a  steady  current. 

Starting  from  the  equation  $  mag  =  — —  I H2  d  Vt  we  substitute  H  =  rot  A 

O7T    J 

and  integrate  by  parts  using  (11.29).  The  surface  integral  at  infinity  is  equal 


160  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

to  zero.  Then  we  use  (16.32)  and  reduce  ^mag  to  the  form 


12)  Express  the  magnetic  energy  for  a  system  of  currents  in  terms  of  a 
double  integral  over  the  volumes  of  the  conductors. 

We  replace  the  summation  over  the  charges,  in  equation  (15.13),  by  a 
volume  integration.  This  gives 


1     ff  IWJ(r') 
=  !cf  JJ  -T^:-^ 


For  line  conductors  wo  can  substitute  /  di  instead  of  \dV,  provided  dV 
and  dV'  are  volume  elements  of  different  conductors.  Then  the  mutual  magnetic 
energy  for  two  line  conductors  i,  k  is 

&tk  mns  '-  -  '  o 


whoro  |  r,-  —  rk  \  is  the  distance  between  the  elements  of  contours  d\i  and 
d\k.  When  i  =••-  k  we  must  regard  the  conductor  as  thin,  though  not  infinitely 
thin,  otherwise  the  integral  diverges.  The  intrinsic  magnetic  energy  for  one 
conductor  is 


j\/tft  is  called  the  mutual  induction  coefficient,  and  MU  is  the  self-induction 
coefficient. 

13)  Writo  down  the  Lagraiigian  for  a  system  of  currents,  assuming  that 
thoro  is  capacity  coupling  between  the  conductors  by  virtue  of  capacitors 
conrioctocl  in  the  circuit. 

Because  of  the  linearity  of  oloctrodynamical  equations,  the  potential  of 
the  ith  conductor  is  expressed  linearly  in  terms  of  the  charges  on  all  the  con- 
ductors: 

9-2; 

k 
From  exorcise  6,  we  obtain  the  electric  energy. 

„          _  1    VV 

G  elect  r  ~  ~7T  / ,  ^ik  &i  &k  • 

Tho  charge  on  the  plates  of  a  capacitor  is  related  to  the  incoming  current 
by  6fc  ---  /fc.  With  the  aid  of  exorcise  12  we  obtain  the  magnetic  energy 

I     V^T  1     \^r 

i.fc  "  i,k 

From  See.   13  the  Lagrangian  (neglecting  sign)  is  — —     (H-  -  E2)  dV,  whence 

O  7C  J 

L    -  o  mafif  —  o  electr   —  ~j~  / , 
[cf.  (17.16)]. 


Sec.  16]  ELECTRODYNAMICS    OF    MATERIAL    MEDIA  161 

14)  Determine  the  work  performed  in  unit  time  by  a  varying  electromagnetic 
field  in  a  medium. 

We  write  equation  (13.23)  for  the  external  space  not  occupied  by  the  sub- 
stance, where  p  =  0.  From  the  boundary  conditions  of  exercise  1,  it  follows 
that  the  normal  component  of  the  Poynting  vector  U  is  continuous  at  the 
boundary  of  the  body.  From  this,  applying  the  same  transformations  to  equa- 
tions (16.17)  and  (16.25),  as  load  to  (13.23),  we  find 


where  —=  —  may  be  expressed  in  terms  of  the  change  in  energy  of  the  field  in 
d  t 

the  external  space. 

15)  Calculate  the  energy  transformed  into  heat  in  unit  time  in  a  conductor 
situated  in  a  constant  field.  Assume  H  to  be  a  single-valued  function  of  B. 

o|»  o 

For  such  a  body,  where  H  and  B  are  related  uniquely,  H  -jr—  =  -^—-  /  (B)  , 

B* 
where  /  (B)  is  some  function  of  B.  For  example,  for  B  =  y.  H,  /  =*  ->—  .    The 


result  of  the  preceding  t3xercise  gives 

"*    f/(BLdF_    1 

tit          dt  J     4  TT  4  TT 


see  (16.30)  and  (16.31).  For  a  constant  field,  there  is  zero  on  the  left-hand 
side  of  the  equation,  while  the  right-hand  side  is  an  essentially  positive  quantity. 
This  energy  must  therefore  bo  converted  into  heat  according  to  the  energy 
conservation  law. 

16)  AVrito  down  Lagrange's  equation  for  a  system  of  currents  taking  into 
account  the  conversion  of  energy  into  heat. 

From  exercise    14,   the  hoat  generated  in  unit   time   may   be   written  as 

y^rj  Ij,  where  ri  is  the  resistance  of  the   i"th  conductor.  Wo  search  for  Lag- 

range's  equation  with  the  right-hand  side  in  the  form 

d    d  L        d  L 

—7 ^~. r—  =  v;  . 

at   oe{         <J&i 

From  the  definition  (4.4)  we  find  -— —  as 

Ci  t 

d     dL 

.  -^       >     t>:    I 

dt 

Whence  v,-  =  —  n  Ii  ~  —  r;  ei . 

17)  Reasoning  in  the  same  way  as  for  exercise  15,  show  that  if  H  is  a  double- 

O  Trt  O  -n 

valued  function  of  B,  having  one  value  for  -^—  <  0  and  the  other  for  — —  >  0, 

d  t  c>  t 

then,  for  a  periodic  variation  of  B,  tho  heat  generated  in  one  period  is  equal 
TT  /I  tt 
r ,  where  the  integral  is  taken  over  one  period. 


to    f- 


18)  Show  that  if  e  (w)  and  x  («)  possess  imaginary  parts,  heat  is  generated 
in  a  rapidly  varying  field. 


11  -0060 


162  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  IT 

Tho  density  of  heat  generation  may  bo  represented  as  the  divergence  from 

^ 

the  Poynting  vector  U  ==-:-- [E  H]  .  In  forming  quadratic  complex  quan- 
tities, we  must  tako  into  account  their  time  dependence.  For  example,  if  we 
take  E  and  H  with  a  factor  e~»w,  their  product  will  be  proportional  to  e~2  ««•>'. 
After  time  averaging,  this  factor  will  yield  zero.  Therefore  wo  must  take  only 
products  of  the  form  [EH*J  4-  [E*H].  Now,  u.sing  equations  (16.38)  and 
(16.39),  wo  obtain 

~  cliv  ([E*  II]  4-  [E  H*])  =  - /-- 1 6i  (c  -  e*)  EE*  4-  -~  ico  (•/  -  •/*)  HH*  . 

4  7C  TC  TC  *x  <v 

Hero,  both  parts  of  the  equation  are  real,  and  if  e  ~  GJ  4-  ify  an(l  X  ^  7.\  +  *  X«» 
then  on  tho  right-hand  side  thore  is  the  expression — —  «o  (e2  EE*  -h  X2  HH*)  . 

From  this  it  can  bo  soon  that  e2  >  0  and  x2  >  0,  since  tho  energy  of  tho  field 
is  absorbed  by  tho  modiutn. 

19)  Calculate  tho  dielectric  constant  of  a  medium,  considering  that  all 
tho  charges  in  it  are  connected  by  elastic  forces  with  tho  equilibrium  positions. 
The  characteristic  oscillation  frequency  of  tho  charges  is  «0  arid  tho  frequency 
of  tho  field  is  o>. 

Tho  radius  vector  of  a  charge  satisfies   the  differential   equation 

m  ( i  4-  «§  r)  -  e  E°  e—  i ««  =  e  E . 

Its  solution  has  tho  frequency  of  tho  external  field  and  may  bo  written  as 

eE 


r  =  — 


-0>2) 


Tho  polarization  can  bo  obtained  from  this  by  multiplying  by  tho  number 
of  charges  in  unit  volume  N  and  by  e.  Since  tho  induction  D  is  equal  to  e  E 

4  TT  N  e2 

or  E  4   4  TT  I*,  wo  find  that  e  =  1  4 —      --, =- .  For  w  -*  0,  wo   obtain   the 

m(wj  — w») 

static    dielectric    constant  e0  —  1  4 » — •  For  co  ->-  oo,   e  (to)   is    obtained 

?no>§  »      \    / 

r  •  r       r  i  4  *  N  e* 

for  very  largo  frequencies  or  for  Iroo  charges  e  =  1  —  -         2  -  . 

Sec-  17.  Plane  Electromagnetic  Waves 

General  equations.  In  this  section  we  shall  first  consider  the  solutions 
of  Maxwell's  equations  for  free  space,  i.e.,  in  the  absence  of  charges. 
These  solutions,  as  we  shall  see,  are  of  the  form  of  travelling  waves. 
Analogous  solutions  also  exist  for  a  nonabsorbing  material  medium. 
These  solutions  will  also  be  found  in  the  present  section. 

In  the  absence  of  charges  or  currents,  the  equations  for  scalar 
and  vector  potentials  are  written  thus: 

0,  (17.1) 

A9--^  =  0,  (17.2) 

with  the  additional  condition  (12.36) 


Sec.  17]  PLANE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES  163 

divA  +  4^0.  (17.3) 

Equations  of  the  form  (17.1)  or  (17.2)  are  called  wave  equations. 

The  solution  of  a  wave  equation.  We  shall  look  for  particular  solu- 
tions of  equations  (17.1)  and  (17.2)  which  depend  only  011  one  coordi- 
nate (for  example,  x)  and  on  time.  Then  the  wave  equations  can  be 
rewritten  in  the  following  manner: 


and  the  supplementary  condition  takes  the  form 

»^+_L»».=0.  (17.6) 

dx  c     dt  v          ' 

We  shall  now  find  the  solution  of  (17.4)  or  (17.5)  without  imposing 
any  further  restrictions.  We  shall  temporarily  introduce  the  following 
notation  : 

x  +  ct  =  %, 

(17.7) 

X  —  Cl  =  7)  . 

We  transform  (17.5)  to  these  independent  variables.  (17.5)  can  be 
rewritten  symbolically  as 


Then 

£9    _    c>9     d£  #9    dt\  #9  #9 

~$x  =  T  IT  ~d#"  +  ~^r  "^  =  ^T    ~^T  * 

JL_^.  —  ^L  Ji^l  _i_  _^JL^ZL  —  _£?.  __   5<p 
T~aT  ""  "aT"c""a?  +  "^T"c""a7  ~"  "THf  ""  "a^"' 

because,    for    constant    ^  (i.e.,   d^  =  0),  -^  =  1  and  T~  =  1,      while 

<7  37  G  X 

for  constant  #  (i.e.,  dx  =  0),  —  -^-  =  --  -rrf  =  1  in  accordance  with 

c    ot  c    ot 

the  same  equations.  Thus,  symbolically 

_i_  +  J__L==2A    -A-__LA  =  9_i_. 

^a?  ^   c    dt  b^^      'dx          c    rot        ~  c^  ' 

i   a  w  a__    i    g  \     __      &«9    _ 

a?  ^   c    dtl\dx          c    dtjV  ~       d^d-ri  ~~     ' 
Hence,  wave  equations  (17.4)  and  (17.5)  are  written  thus: 


164  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Integrating  any  of  them  "with  respect  to  £,  we  obtain 

~  =  C  (•',),  %-C'W-  (17.10) 

It  is  not  difiicult  now  to  integrate  with  respect  to  TJ: 

f,  ri 

A  -  J  C  (•/))  d  v)  +  C\  (5)  ,    9  ^  /  C"  (-/))  cZvj  +  t;  (5)  . 

Finally,  the  required  solution  is  written  as: 

A-A^YjH-A^),     9-9i(*iH-9a(5),  (17.11) 

since  the  substitution  of  (17.11)  into  (17.9)  gives  zero  identically. 
Passing  to  the  variables  it*,  /,  we  can  write  the  solutions  to  (17.4), 
(17.5): 

A  =  A!  (a;  —  c«)  +  A2  (x  +  rO  >     9  =  9i  (•*  —  C0  +  92  (a  +  cl)  .         (17.12) 

Plane  travelling  waves.  The  solution  depending  on  x+ct  does 
not  depend  on  the  solution  whose  argument  is  x  —  c  I  ;  these  are 
two  linearly  independent  solutions.  Therefore  it  is  sufficient  to  con- 
sider one  of  them  : 

A  =  A(*-cO,  (17.13) 

9  =  9(.r  —  <jf).  (17.14) 

In  order  to  satisfy  the  supplementary  condition  (17.6),  we  perform 
a  gauge  transformation: 

9(.i;-.fO  =  9f^-cO-y-~./(a:--cO  =  9'  +  /          (17.15) 

(the  dot  over  /  denotes  differentiation  with  respect  to  the  whole 
argument  Y)  =  x  —  c  t).  But,  if  we  put  9'  =  —  /,  we  obtain  simply 
9^0.  Then,  from  (17.6),  we  also  obtain  Ax=  0.  Thus,  for  a  solution 
of  the  form  considered,  depending  on  x  —  ct  only,  the  Lorenz  con- 
dition is  satisfied  most  simply  by  substituting  9=0,  Ax—  0. 
The  electric  field  component  x  is  equal  to  zero: 


From  the  general  result  of  Sec.   12,  this  property  of  Ex  does  not 
depend  on  a  potential  gauge  transformation. 

The  magnetic  field  component  x  is  also  equal  to  zero: 


Sec.  17] 


PLANE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES 


165 


We  find  the  remaining  field  components: 

F  _        1  dAY  __  :      ^  __        1  &A-  __    ; 
Ay~"""7~ar~^yj  A;r-~"T~^T"™^^3 


(17.18) 


From  this  equation  it  follows  that  E  and  H  are  perpendicular, 
because 

EH  =fiy#y  +  £*#*=<>.  (17.19) 


They  are  equal  in  absolute  magnitude,  since  E  -=  H  —   \/A*  +  A%. 

The  solution  of  the  form  (17.13)  has  a  simple  physical  meaning. 

Let  us  take  the  value  of  E  at  an  instant  of  time  t  =~  0  on  the  plane 
x  =  0.  It  is  equal  to  E  (0).  Tt  is  clear  that  the  E  (0)  will  have  the 
samo  value  at  the  instant  of  time  t  on  the  plane  x  =  c  t,  because 
E  (x  —  ct)  —  E  (0)  on  that  plane.  We  can  also  say  that  the  plane 
on  which  the  field  E  is  equal  to  E  (0)  is  translated  in  space  through 
a  distance  ct  in  a  time  /,  i.e.,  it  moves  with  a  velocity  c.  The  samo 
applies  to  any  plane  x  =  XQ,  for  which  there  was  some  value  of  field 
E  (x0)  at  the  initial  instant  of  time.  To  summarize,  all  planes  with 
the  given  value  of  iield  are  propagated  in  space  with  velocity  c. 
Therefore,  the  solution  E  (#  —  ct)  is  called  a  travelling  plane  wave. 

We  note  that  the  form  of  the  wave  docs  not  change  as  it  moves; 
the  distance  between  planes  x  =  xl  and  x  =  #2,  for  which  K  is  equal 
to  E  (XL)  and  E  (#2),  is  constant.  This  result 
holds  for  any  arbitrary  form  of  wave,  pro- 
vided it  is  travelling  in  free  space. 

Repeating,  the  velocity  of  propagation 
of  a  wave  in  empty  space  does  not  depend 
on  its  shape  or  amplitude  and  it  is  equal  to 
a  universal  constant  c. 

The  transverse  nature  of  waves.  The  elec- 
tric and  magnetic  fields,  as  we  have  seen 
from  (17.19),  are  perpendicular  to  the 
direction  of  wave  propagation,  as  well  as  to 
each  other.  This  is  why  it  is  said  that  elec- 
tromagnetic waves  are  transverse  (as  op- 
posed to  longitudinal  sound  waves  in  air,  for 
which  the  oscillations  occur  in  the  direction  of  propagation).  The 
direction  of  propagation,  the  electric  field,  and  the  magnetic  field  are 
shown  in  Fig.  24.  In  it,  n  is  a  unit  vector  along  the  #-axis. 

In  future  it  will  be  sufficient  to  take  only  one  component  of  the 
electric  field.  For  this  it  is  necessary  to  take  one  of  the  coordinate 
axes,  for  example  the  ?/-axis,  in  the  direction  of  the  electric  field, 
which  in  no  way  limits  the  generality.  This  is  shown  in  Fig.  24. 


Fig.  24 


166  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

The  ^-coordinate  will  be  written  in  the  form  x  —  rn,  so  that 

Ey  =  Ay(rn  —  ct)  .  (17.20) 

But  in  this  notation  it  is  not  necessary  to  relate  the  vector  n,  in  the 
direction  of  propagation  to  the  #-axis.  A  solution  with  argument 
of  the  form  (17.20)  is  applicable  to  any  direction  of  n,  provided, 
naturally,  that  n,  E,  and  H  are  mutually  perpendicular. 

The  momentum  density  of  the  wave  [see  (13.27)]  is  equal  to 


and  is  directed  along  n.  The  energy  density  is 


87C  ~     47T 

It  differs  from  the  momentum  density  by  the  factor  c.  This,  as 
we  shall  see  later,  is  very  essential  for  the  quantum  theory  of 
light. 

Pressure  ol  light.  If  a  wave  falls  on  an  absorbing  obstacle,  for 
example,  011  a  black  wall,  and  is  not  reflected,  then  its  momentum 
is  transmitted  to  the  wall  in  accordance  with  the  conservation  law. 
But  momentum  transmitted  to  a  body  in  unit  time  is,  by  Newton's 
Second  Law,  nothing  other  than  force.  It  follows  that  there  is  a  force 

A2 
of  -    7  for  every  square  centimetre  of  the  absorbing  barrier,  upon 

which  the  wave  is  normally  incident.  Force  referred  to  unit  surface 
is,  by  definition,  the  pressure  of  the  electromagnetic  wave  on  the 
barrier.  Consequently,  electrodynamics  predicts  the  existence  of 
light  pressure.  This  was  observed  and  measured  by  P.  N.  Lebedev. 
Harmonic  waves.  A  special  interest  is  attached  to  travelling  waves 
for  which  the  function  E  (x  —  ct)  is  harmonic.  The  most  general 
harmonic  solution  is  of  the  following  form: 

B=Ro{Pc"'"(<"Ir)}>  (17.21) 

where  the  symbol  Re  {}  denotes  the  real  part  of  the  expression 
inside  the  braces,  F  is  a  complex  vector  of  the  form  Fj  +  i  F2  [Cf. 
(7.14c)],  and  co  is  the  wave  frequency  in  the  same  sense  as  in  equation 
(7.3).  co  is  the  number  of  radians  per  second  by  which  the  argument 
of  the  exponential  function  changes. 

The  wave  vector.  The  vector  co  —  is  called  the  wave  vector.  It  is 

c 
denoted  by  the  letter  k: 

k^to^-.  (17.22) 


»SeC.  17]  PLANE   ELECTROMAGNETIC   WAVES  107 

The  geometric  meaning  of  k  is  easy  to  explain.  We  define  the  wave- 
length, i.e.,  the  distance  &  r-n  in  space  at  which  E  assumes  the  same 
value.  Let  the  required  wavelength  be  X.  Then 

A  Ar-n 

I  (0  -  JO)  ------  27TI  ,,_     Xrt 

e      <  =  e         c      =e      ,  (17.23) 

because  the  period  of  the  function  eix  is  equal  to  2  n.  Hence, 

X=    2-  .  (17.24) 

CO 

Comparing  the  wavelength  with  the  wave  vector,  we  obtain 

k  =  ^-n,  X--^  -.  (17.25) 

A  1C 

Polarization  of  a  plane  harmonic  wave.  Let  us  now  study  the 
nature  of  the  oscillations  of  an  electric  field.  To  do  this,  we  write  the 
vector  F  in  the  form 

F  =  l\  +  il\  -:  («!  —  i  Eo)  e''a  .  (17.26) 

We  choose  the  phase  a  so  that  the  vectors  Et  and  E2  are  mutually 
perpendicular.  We  multiply  equation  (17.20)  by  e~i<x  and  square. 
Then  we  obtain 

(Ex  —  ;E2)2  =  El-—E**  =  e-2l*(Fl  -  Fl  +  2i(P1F2))  .  (17.27) 

We  have  taken  advantage  of  the  fact  that  Ej  and  E2  are  perpendic- 
ular. Because  of  this  (Ex  —  fcE2)2  is  a  purely  real  quantity.  Therefore, 
the  imaginary  part  of  the  right-hand  side  of  expression  (17.27)  must 
be  piit  equal  to  zero.  Representing  e~2lot  as  cos  2  a  —  i  sin  2  a,  we 
obtain 

-  (Fl  -  Fl)  sin  2a  +  2  (F!  F2)  cos  2  a  =---=  0 
or 


whence  the  angle  a  is  determined  for  the  given  solution  (17.21). 
It  is  now  easy  to  express  Ex  and  E2.  Indeed,  from  (17.26),  EJL  — 
—  E2  =  (Ft  +  iY2)  e-»a  =  Fj  cos  a  +  F2  sin  a  —  i  (t\  sin  a  —  F2  cos  a), 
so  that 

E,  =  FT  cos  a  +  Fo  sin  a  ,  1 

[  (17.29) 

E2  =  Fx  sin  a  —  F2  cos  a  .  J 

We  now  include  a  constant  phase  in  the  exponent  (17.21)  and,  for 
short,  put 

a  _  co  |j  _  2JLJ  ==  <|,  .  (17.30) 


163  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  TI 

Then,  in  the  most  general  case,  the  electric  field  for  a  plane  harmonic 
wave  will  be 

E  =  Re  {(Ex  -  i  E2)  e'*}  =  E1cos  fy  +  E2sin  ty  .          (17.31) 

Here,  the  vectors  Et  and  E2  are  defined  as  perpendicular. 

Let  us  assume  that  a  wave  is  propagated  along  the  .z-axis. 
The  ?/-axis  is  directed  along  E1?  and  the  z-axis  along  E2.  Hence,  from 
(17.31),  we  obtain 

EY  =  E1  cos  fy  ,     A1*  =  #2  sin  ^  .  (17.32) 


Let  us  eliminate  the  phase  <|».  We  divide  the  first  equation  by  Kl  , 
the  second  by  E2  ,  square  and  add.  Then  the  phase  is  eliminated  and 
an  equation  relating  the  field  components  remains: 

—  *  -4-  ~    —  1  /i  7  wi 

K\  +  El  ~  L'  lU-^J 

It  follows  that  tho  electric  field  vector  describes  an  ellipse  in  the 
//z-plane  moving  along  tho  #-axis  with  velocity  c,  and  passes  round 
the  whole  ellipse  on  one  wavelength.  Relative  to  a  fixed  coordinate 
system,  the  electric  field  vector  describes  a  helix  wound  on  an  elliptic 
cylinder.  The  pitch  of  the  helix  is  equal  to  the  wavelength. 

Such  an  electromagnetic  wave  is  termed  ellipticallv  polarized.  It 

represents  the  most  general  form  of  a  plane  harmonic  wave  (17.21). 

If  one  of  the  components  is  equal  to  zero,  for  example  Ej  —  0  or 

E2  =  0,  then  the  oscillations  of  E  occur  in  one  plane.  Such  a  wave 

is  termed  plane  polarized. 

When  EI  is  equal  to  E2  ,  the  vector  E  describes  a  circle  in  the 
?/;:-plane.  Depending  on  the  sign  of  Ez  ,  the  rotation  around  the 

circle  occurs  in  a  clockwise  or  anti- 
clockwise direction.  Accordingly, 
the  wave  is  termed  right-handed 
or  left-handed  polarized.  These 
waves  are  shown  in  Fig.  25.  For 
the  same  value  of  phase  i,  the 
rotation  occurs  either  in  a  clockwise 
or  anticlockwise  direction. 

The  sum  of  two  waves  of  equal 
amplitude,     which     are     circularly 

polarized,  gives  a  plane  polarized  wave.  The  relationship  between 
their  phases  determines  the  plane  of  polarization.  Thus,  if  the  waves 
shown  in  Fig.  25  are  added,  the  oscillations  E2  and  —  E2  mutually 
cancel  and  only  the  plane  polarized  oscillation  Ex  remains. 

In  turn,  a  circularly  polarized  oscillation  is  resolved  into  two 
mutually  perpendicular  plane  oscillations. 

Certain  crystals,  for  example  tourmaline,  are  capable  of  polarizing 
light. 


SeC.  17]  PLANE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES  109 

Unpolarized  light.  In  nature,  it  is  most  common  to  observe  un- 
polarized  (natural)  light.  Naturally,  such  light  cannot  be  strictly 
monochromatic  (i.e.,  possessing  strictly  one  frequency  co),  for,  as  we 
have  just  shown,  monochromatic  light  is  always  polarized  in  some 
way.  But  if  we  imagine  that  the  components  Et  and  E2  in  Fig.  25 
are  not  related  by  a  strict  phase  relationship  (17.32),  but  randomly 
change  their  relative  phases,  then  the  resultant  vector  will  also 
change  its  direction  in  a  random  manner.  However,  for  this,  it  is 
necessary  that  the  oscillation  frequencies  should  vary  in  time  within 
some  interval  A  co,  since  the  difference  of  phase  between  two  oscil- 
lations of  strictly  constant  and  identical  frequency  is  constant. 

The  propagation  of  light  in  a  medium.  We  shall  now  consider  the 
question  of  the  propagation  of  light  in  a  material  medium.  At  the 
end  of  the  preceding  section  we  said  that  the  quantities  z  and  ^ 
have  meaning  only  for  oscillations  of  a  definite  frequency  <o.  To 
simplify  notation,  we  shall  not  use  the  symbol  for  a  real  part  Re  {}, 
remembering  that  the  real  part  is  always  taken.  Since  all  the  quanti- 
ties depend  on  time  according  to  an  c-|>6)'  law,  the  derivative  I 

()  t 

reduces  to  a  multiplication  by  — -iv.  Then  the  system  of  Maxwell's 
equations  can  be  written  in  the  following  form: 

rotH=  — -l?LeE,  (17.34) 


(17.35) 


0.  (17.37) 

Once  again  we  look  for  a  solution  in  the  form  of  a  plane  wave. 
Since  the  time  relationship  is  already  eliminated,  all  the  quantities 
depend  only  on  one  coordinate,  for  example,  upon  x.  From  (17.35) 
and  (17.37),  it  follows  that 


or 


because  a  solution  that  is  constant  over  all  space  does  not  represent 
any  wave.  Thus,  the  waves  are  transverse.  Equations  (17.34)  to 
(17.37)  are  satisfied  if  we  substitute  Ey  =  E  (x),  EZ  =  Q,  Hy  =  0, 
HZ  —  H  (x),  or,  in  other  words,  if  the  electric  field  is  directed  along 
the  y-axis  and  the  magnetic  field  along  the  z-axis  (a  right-handed 
system). 


170  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Indeed,  there  then  remain  the  following  equations: 

**L=—*2-sE,  (17.38) 

(17.39) 


Eliminating  any  of  the  quantities  E  or  H,  we  obtain  equations 
which  are  identical  in  form.  For  example 


whence 

E  =  Fe*Tv**  *-"*'.  (17.41) 

If  the  wave  is  propagated  in  any  arbitrary  direction,  and  not 
along  the  #-axis,  then  the  solution  (17.41)  is  rewritten  thus  [here, 
the  symbol  Re  {}  is  included  for  a  comparison  with  (17.21)]: 


#  =  RepV~'wV — rvex;j.  (17.42) 

And  so,  compared  with  (17.21),  the  wave  velocity  has  been  multi- 
plied by  ~T-  /  .  Accordingly,  the  wave  vector  will,  instead  of  (17.22), 
formally  satisfy  the  equation 

k  =  —  Vsx  W-  (17.43) 

However,  -  ' --  is  the  velocity  of  light  in  a  medium,  and  (17.43) 


is  the  wave  vector,  provided  e  and  %  are  real  numbers.  Then  equation 
(17.43)  will  be  fully  analogous  to  (17.25).  In  this  case,  the  solution 
(17.42)  is  periodic  in  space  and  in  time  and  describes  a  plane  wave 

travelling  with  velocity  —^= 

v«x 
The  ratio  of  the  wave  velocity  in  free  space  to  that  in  a  medium  is 

called  the  refractive  index  of  the  medium  for  waves  of  given  frequency 
co.  We  note  that  for  visible-light  frequencies,  e  (co)  has  nothing  in 
common  with  its  static  value.  For  example,  water  has  a  dielectric 

constant  of  81,  so  that  v's  =  N/81  =9,  while  the  refractive  index  in 
the  visible  frequencies  is  approximately  equal  to  1.33  (x.  can  be  consid- 
ered equal  to  1). 

Absorption  of  light  in  a  medium.  We  now  consider  a  more  general 
case  of  complex  e  =  S!  +  £sa  (for  simplicity  we  shall  put  X=  1).  As  was 
shown  in  exercise  18,  Sec.  16,  the  imaginary  part  of  s  accounts  for 
absorption  of  light.  We  shall  denote  the  root  of  the  complex  dielectric 
constant  thus : 


Sec.  17] 


PLANE    ELECTBOMAGNETIC    WAVES 


171 


VT  =  Vsj  +  i  e2  =  vx  +  z  v2  .  (17.44) 

Let  us  substitute  this  expression  into  the  exponent  of  equation 
(17.42),  putting  7ix~l,  ny  =  0,  nz  —  0.  Since  t2  — —  1,  wo  obtain 

/  .XVj  \  .VVgtO 

E  =  Ko{Fe""l<°^       <  '{e""7"".  (17.45) 

Thus,  the  wave  is  damped  in  propagation. 
Its  amplitude  diminishes  e  times  at  a  distance  — •— .  A  solution  of  the 

cov2 

form  (17.45)  cannot  exist  in  a  region  which  extends  to  infinity  in  all 
directions  because  x=  —  oo  substituted  into  (17.45)  yields  E  — oo. 
A  solution  which  is  damped  in  space  can  be  used,  for  example,  when 
an  electromagnetic  wave  from  free  space  is  incident  on  an  absorbing 
medium.  And  the  ;r-axis  in  (17.45)  must  be  considered  as  directed  into 
the  medium. 

Exercises 

1)  Consider  tho  reflection  of  a  piano  electromagnetic  wavo  from  tho  inter- 
face between  two  transparent  (nonabsorbing)  media  a  and  6  with  refractive 
indexes  vld  s=  vrf  and  v^  ^  v&  (v2d  =  v2&  =  0).  Solve  the  problem  in  two 
cases:  1)  the  electric  vector  lies  in  the  plane  drawn  through  tho  normal  to  the 
interface  and  through  tho  wavo  vector  k,  II)  tho  electric  vector  is  parallel 


Fig.  20 


to  the  interface  between  the  two  media.  Calling  tho  angle  of  incidence  0  and 
the  angle  of  refraction  &,  find  the  ratio  of  tho  amplitudes  of  tho  incident  and 
reflected  waves  for  both  cases,  I  and  II  (Fig.  26). 

At  the  interface,  the  normal  components  of  the  inductions  and  the  tangential 
components  of  tho  fields  must  bo  equal.  In  order  to  satisfy  the  conditions  at 
the  boundary,  it  is  necessary  to  introduce  a  third  wave,  which  is  reflected 
from  the  interface.  We  shall  take  tho  equation  of  tho  interface  to  be  y  =  0. 

The  phase  of  the  incident  wave  at  the  interface  is  -2-  nx  x  =  ~  x  sin  8,   that 

c  c 

for  the  reflected  wave  —  x  sin  6X ,  and  that  for  tho  refracted  wavo  —  x  sin  l> . 
All  three  phases  must  coincide  over  the  whole  interface,  whence 

vrt  sin  0  =  v&  sin  &   (the  law  of  refraction), 
0  =  0!  (the  law  of  reflection). 


172  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Taking  into  account  that  //  =  v  E  [this  is  easily  obtained  from  (17.39) 
and  (17.41)],  wo  write  iho  boundary  conditions  (see  exorcise  1,  Sec.   1*5): 

V*  (E  sin  0  —  #!  sin  6)  =  vg  E2  sin  $  , 
E  cos  0  -|-  El  cos  0  —  Ez  cos  -0-  , 


where  E,  A\  and  /£2  are  the  electric  fields  in  the  incident,  reflected  and  retract- 
ed wavoH.  We  can  see  that,  by  eliminating  E,  l^l  and  E»  from  those  conditions, 
\vo  again  obtain  Iho  law  of  refraction.  The  ratio  of  tho  amplitudes  is 


E 


tanJOj— -J))^  j^ 

larT(oT"#j    *  *  ' 


If    0  -f  ft  =  ~ ,  then  A\  —  0  and  reflection  does  not  occur.  (How  can  this 

be  verified  by  double  reflection  ?) 

Tn  case  If  wo  must  write  down  tho  boundary  conditions  and  obtain  the 
equation 

'"     ,_»»«» -.»)..  (ID 

sin  (0  -{•-  ft)  v      ' 

(1)  and  (ft)  are  called  tho  Fresno!  equations. 

2)  In    tho  case  -—  sin  0>  1  (total   internal   reflection),  show   that    instead 

of  equation   (L)  and   (IT),   a  roHoctinn  coofficient  of  unity  is  obtained.   Find 
at  what  depth  tho  wave,  passing  in  the  medium  &,  is  attenuated  e  times. 

3)  Kind  tho  frequency  of  electromagnetic  oscillations  in  an  infinite  square 
prism  with   perfectly  reflecting   walls,   assuming  a  longitudinal   electric   field 
constant  along  the  length  of  tho  prism.  Consider  that  tho  field  inside  tho  prism 
does  not  become  zero. 

Wo  must  consider  that  tho  tangential  component  of  the  electric  Hold  at 
the  walls  of  tho  prism  is  equal  to  zero,  so  that  tho  normal  component  of  tho 
I'oynting  \ector  U  should  become  zero.  Tho  solution  to  Maxwell's  equations 

can  1)0  obtained  from  tho  potential  Ax  —  A0  sin sin-^-e— -iw ,  Ay  —  ,4~  = 

^-rp  ^=  0  (tho  .r-eoordinato  is  taken  along  the  axis  of  the  prism).  It  is  of  the  form 

Ex  —  E0  sin  — —  sin  —z-  e~ <wf , 

Jf  r  T  "•*%  TC  If         iwf 

Hv  =  II Q  cos  —  sin  —  —  e         , 
1          °          a  a 


cos  - 

a 


on  tho  condition  that 

E0  =  //o  and  o>3  =  ^-  ca 

(a  is  tho  side  of  the  square). 

4)  Solvo  the  same  problem  for  a  travelling  wave  in  the  prism  (a  waveguide). 
Tho  field  in  a  waveguide  is  not  zero  anywhere  except  at  the  walls. 

The  form  of  tho  vector  potential  in  the  previous  problem  suggests  one  of 
the  following  possible  solutions: 


Sec.  18]  TRANSMISSION    OF    SIGNALS.    ALMOST   PLANE    WAVES  173 

Ax  =  A^e-  ''  «"-**>  sin  -^-  sin—  , 
a  a 

Ay  =  Awe-1  <«-**>  cos  2L  sin—  , 

d  Ql 

Az  =  9  =  0  . 
In  order  to  satisfy  the  condition  div  A  =  0,  we  must  demand  that 

ikAox  —  —  Aoy  —  0. 

The  normal  (to  the  walls)  components  of  the  vector  U  are  again  equal  to  zero 
since  EX  =  Q  at  the  walls. 

We  determine  the  frequency  from  equation  (12.37): 


From  here  it  can  bo  seen  that  the  frequency  obtained  in.  the  .example  3)  is 
the  smallest  wave  frequency  that  can  be  propagated  in  the  prism.  This  wave 
corresponds  to  X  =  oo. 

5)  Show  that  when  two  waves,  which  are  circularly  polarized  in  opposite 
directions,  and  which  have  equal  amplitudes  (but  with  frequencies  differing 
by  a  small  quantity  Ao>)  and  are  travelling  in  one  direction,  are  combined, 
a  wave  is  obtained  whoso  polarization  vector  rotates  to  an  extent  depending 
on  the  distance  of  propagation. 

Sec.  18.  Transmission  of  Signals. 
Almost  Plane  Waves 

The  impossibility  of  transmitting  a  signal  by  means  of  a  mono- 
chromatic wave.  A  plane  monochromatic  wave  (17.42)  extends  with- 
out limit  in  all  directions  of  space  and  in  time.  Nowhere,  so  to  speak, 
does  it  have  a  beginning  or  an  end.  What  is  more,  its  properties  are 
everywhere  always  the  same  ;  its  frequency,  amplitude  and  the  distance 
between  two  travelling  crests  (i.e.,  the  wavelength  X)  are  always 
constant.  All  this  can  be  easily  seen  by  considering  a  sinusoid  or  helix. 

Let  us  now  pose  the  problem  of  the  possibility  of  transmitting  an 
electromagnetic  signal  over  a  distance.  In  order  to  transmit  the  signal, 
an  electromagnetic  disturbance  must  be  concentrated  in  a  certain 
volume.  By  propagation,  this  disturbance  can  reach  another  region  of 
space:  detected  by  some  means  (for  example,  a  radio  receiver),  it  will 
transmit  to  the  point  of  reception  a  signal  about  an  event  occurring 
at  the  point  of  transmission.  Likewise,  our  visual  perceptions  are  a 
continuous  recording  of  electromagnetic  (light)  disturbances  origi- 
nating in  surrounding  objects. 

A  signal  must  somehow  be  bounded  in  time  in  order  to  give  notice 
of  the  beginning  and  end  of  any  event. 

In  order  to  transmit  a  signal  the  amplitude  of  the  wave  must,  for 
a  time,  be  somehow  changed.  For  example,  the  amplitude  of  one  of  the 
waves  of  a  sinusoid  must  be  increased  and  we  must  wait  until  this 
increased  amplitude  arrives  at  the  receiving  device.  A  strictly  mono- 
chromatic wave,  i.e.,  a  sinusoid,  has  the  same  amplitude  everywhere 


174  ELECTKOD YNAMICS  [Part    II 

and  is  therefore  not  suitable  for  the  transmission  of  signals  in  time. 
In  the  same  way,  an  ideal  plane  wave  with  a  given  wave  vector  cannot 
transmit  the  image  of  an  object  limited  in  space. 

The  propagation  of  a  nonmonochromatic  wave.  We  shall  now  con- 
sider what  can  be  done  by  superimposing  several  sinusoids  upon  one 
another.  Suppose  that  the  frequencies  of  all  these  travelling  waves 

are  included  within  an  interval  co0 ^  co  <:  co0  -\ — 5-  .    We    shall 

consider  that  the  frequency  interval  A  co  is  considerably  smaller  than 
the  "carrier"  frequency  co0.  The  amplitudes  of  all  the  waves  EQ  (co) 
will  be  assumed  to  be  identical  for  any  frequency  within  the  chosen 
interval,  and  equal  to  zero  outside  that  interval. 

Then  the  resultant  oscillation  will  be  represented  by  the  integral 
of  all  the  partial  oscillations : 

to0  +  A  to/2 

E  =  f  EQ  (co)  e~i(^~kx)d  co  =  EQ      j       eT*  (6i'-*-v)  rfco  .       (18.1) 

6)0—  A  6)/2 

In  this  equation  not  only  the  frequency  is  variable,  but  also  the 
absolute  value  of  the  wave  vector  k  (the  so-called  wave  number). 

According  to  (17.22),  it  is  equal  to  —  in  free  space  and,  in  a  material 

c 

medium,  k  =^%,  where  v  in  turn  is  a  function  of  frequency.  In  future, 

in  this  section,  we  shall  always  assume  v2  — 0,  i.e.,  that  there  is  no 
absorption. 

Since  the  frequency  lies  within  a  small  interval,  k  can  be  expanded 
in  a  series  in  powers  of  co — -co0: 

k  (co)  =  k  (co0)  +  (co  —  co0)  |~~J    .  (18.2) 

Substituting  (18.2)  in  the  integral  (18.1),  we  obtain  the  following 
expression  for  the  resultant  field: 

Aco 

Aco 

<ou          -^  - 

We  now  introduce  a  new  integration  variable  £=  co  —  co0.  Then  the 
integration  can  be  easily  performed  and  the  field  reduces  to  the  follow- 
ing form: 

A  co/2 


A  co/2 

0    .     if       ldk 
*•—  -7— 


\     I  Aco  i 
I   .r   -     - 

kJ-^  JL  .  (18.4) 


x 
0 


Sec.  18] 


TRANSMISSION    OF    SIGNALS.    ALMOST   PLANE    WAVES 


175 


The  shape  of  the  signal.  Let  us  now  examine  the  expression  obtained. 
It  consists  of  two  factors.  The  first  of  them,  J00e-»(<0»'—  *•*>,  repre- 
sents a  travelling  wave  homogeneous  in  space  with  a  mean  *  'carrier" 
frequency  w0.  However,  the  amplitude  of  the  resultant  wave  is  no 
longer  constant  in  space  because  of  the  second  factor: 


2l     6111    \     I    t    ~~~    I          j  I         it    I  - 

U        U"/Q    J 


,      ldk\ 
t— -  1-j— I 


__  I        1    1      \ 

f[.       ldk\ 
s=s 


where  the  designation  g  and  fy  are  obvious  from  the  equations.  This 
factor  has  a  greatest  maximum  at  a;=(-^-J0  ty  i.e.,  when  the  argument 

of  the  sine  and  the  denominator  are  equal  to  zero.  The  other  extremes 
will  be  the  less  the  greater  their  number 
(Fig.  27).  The  greatest  maximum  is  equal 

to  A  co  (since  -5^1  =1    for    i|;  =  0).    This 

maximum  is  not  situated  at  a  fixed  place, 
but  moves  in  space  with  a  velocity 


ffW 


V  =  -yy- 

dk 


(18.5) 


because,  from  the  definition  of  the  point 
of  maximum     =  Q,  it  follows  that 


~~JT 

dk 


Tt 


Fig.  27 


As  we  indicated  at  the  beginning  of  this  section,  a  signal  can  be 
transmitted  from  one  point  of  space  to  another  by  means  of  a  displace- 
ment of  the  maximum,  since  this  maximum  is  distinguished  from  other 
maxima. 

A  disturbance  of  this  kind  concentrated  in  space  is  called  a  wave, 
packet. 

The  propagation  of  a  signal  of  arbitrary  shape.  A  wave  packet  need 
not  necessarily  have  the  form  shown  in  Fig.  27.  By  choosing  a  rela- 
tionship for  EQ  (to)  other  than  that  in  equation  (18.1)  (i.e.,  by  choosing 
not  a  constant  amplitude  in  the  interval  Aw,  but  a  more  complicated 
frequency  function),  the  shape  of  g  (^)  can  be  changed.  For  instance, 
the  resultant  amplitude  may  have  the  shape  of  a  rectangle,  so  that 
the  transmitted  signal  will  resemble  the  dash  in  the  Morse  code.  If 
the  frequency  w0  is  within  the  radio  -frequency  range,  then  the  signals 
can  follow  upon  one  another  within  audio  frequency,  in  this  way  repro- 
ducing music  or  speech. 

The  frequency  range  and  the  duration  of  the  signal.  In  order  to  trans- 
mit a  signal,  it  is  always  necessary  to  choose  a  range  of  frequencies. 


176  KLECTKODYNAMICS  [Part  It 

Let  us  determine  this  range.  Suppose  that  the  receiving  device  is 
situated  at  some  point  x  =  const.  The  width  of  the  received  signal 
can  be  seen  from  Fig.  27.  In  units  of  <|>,  it  is  equal  to  n  in  order  of  magni- 
tude. Therefore,  the  duration  of  the  signal  is  determined  from  the 
equation 


In  other  words,  the  duration  of  the  signal  A£  is  related  to  the  frequency 
interval  Aco  necessary  for  its  transmission  by  the  expression 

Aco-A£~  2n.  (18.6) 

It  should  be  noted  that  this  estimate  refers  only  to  the  order  of 
magnitude  of  A  to  and  A£.  The  determination  of  A  <p  is,  to  some  extent, 
arbitrary.  In  certain  cases  Aeo-A£  >  2  TU,  so  that  the  estimate  (18.6) 
is  a  lower  figure. 

If  a  radio  station  is  required  to  transmit  sounds  audible  to  the  human 
ear,  then  the  quantity  A£  is  not  greater  than  0.5  x  10~4  sec,  since 
the  limit  of  audibility  is  2  x  104  oscillations  per  sec.  From  this 


The  range  of  Aco  is  always  less  than  the  "carrier"  frequency  co0 
which,  even  for  the  longest-wave  transmitting  stations,  is  not  less 
than  1.5  x  105  x  2  TT.  In  practice,  an  interval  of  A  to  three  or  four  times 
less  than  the  value  given  is  quite  sufficient,  since  clipping  off  the 
very  highest  frequencies  in  music,  singing  or  speech  does  not  introduce 
any  essential  distortion. 

Television  transmissions  require  a  considerably  greater  frequency 
interval,  because  an  image  must  be  reproduced  25  times  every  second; 
and,  in  turn,  the  image  consists  of  tens  of  thousands  of  separate  signals 
(points).  As  a  result,  the  carrier  frequency  is  about  2?cx6x  107, 
corresponding  to  the  metric  band  of  radio  waves.  Such  waves  are  prop- 
agated over  a  relatively  small  radius.  They  are  screened  by  the  cur- 
vature of  the  earth's  surface  like  light.  The  relation  (18.6)  is  always 
correct  in  order  of  magnitude;  therefore,  for  distant  television  trans- 
missions, it  is  necessary  to  have  either  relay  stations,  very  high-placed 
transmitters,  or  cable  lines. 

Phase  and  group  velocity.  We  shall  now  consider  in  more  detail  the 
velocity  with  which  signals  are  transmitted.  From  (18.5),  the  velocity 
of  a  wave  packet  is 


It  differs  from  the  propagation  velocity  of  the  constant  phase  sur- 
face, which  is  expressed  in  terms  of  frequency  and  wave  number  as 


Sec.  18]  TRANSMISSION    OF    SIGNALS.    ALMOST   PLANE    WAVES  177 

Indeed,  the  expression  for  a  travelling  monochromatic  wave  can  be 
written  in  the  following  form  : 


Comparing  this  formula  with  the  general  expression  for  a  travelling 
wave  E  =  E  (x  —  ut),  we  arrive  at  (18.7).  The  velocity  of  the  wave  is  u, 
and  not  c,  because  (18.7)  is  by  no  means  necessarily  related  to  the  pro- 
pagation of  a  plane  wave  in  a  vacuum. 

u  =  ~  is  called  the  phase  velocity  of  the  wave  ;  v  is  called  the  group 

velocity  of  the  wave  packet  obtained  by  superimposing  a  group  of 
waves.  In  a  vacuum,  v  and  u  coincide  because  to  —  ck.  However,  if 
there  is  dispersion,  i.e.,  a  dependence  of  the  refractive  index  on  the 

frequency,  then  co  =  —  k  so  that  v^k. 

The  group  velocity  may  be  regarded  as  the  velocity  of  propagation 
of  a  signal  only  when  it  is  less  than  the  velocity  of  light  in  free  space  c. 
If  the  expression  (18.5)  formally  gives  v  >  c,  we  cannot  avoid  a  more 
careful  analysis  that  takes  into  account  absorption.  As  a  result,  it 
turns  out  that  an  electromagnetic  signal  in  the  form  of  a  very  weak 
precursor  is  propagated  with  a  velocity  c,  but  the  major  portion  of  the 
wave  energy  arrives  at  the  point  of  reception  with  a  lesser  velocity 
(see  A.  Sommerfeld,  Optik,  Wiesbaden,  1950). 

As  an  example  of  the  calculation  of  group  velocity  we  shall  take  the 
dependence  of  frequency  on  the  wave  vector  in  the  form  : 

to2  =  a2  +  c2  &2  . 

This  form  is  obtained  for  a  waveguide  (see  exercise  4,  Sec.  17,  or 
exercise  19,  Sec.  16,  in  the  limiting  case  of  extremely  large  frequencies). 
Whence  the  group  velocity  is 


CO 

and  since  ck  <  to,  we  have  v  <  c. 

Here,  the  phase  velocity  proves  to  be  greater  than  c: 


CO  CO 

U=  -j-  =  C— 7-  >C  . 
k  ck 

We  note  that  uv='c*. 

In  vector  form  the  group  velocity  is  defined  as  follows : 

T-£.  (18-8) 

If  we  make  use  of  a  more  accurate  dispersion  law  (obtained  in  exer- 
cise 19,  Sec.  16),  then  for  to2  ~to02  there  proves  to  be  a  frequency 
region  for  which  e  (co)  is  negative.  For  such  frequencies  the  refractive 
index  is  purely  imaginary  and  the  expressions  (18.5)  and  (18.8)  become 
meaningless. 

12-0060 


178  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

The  form  ol  a  wave  in  space  and  the  range  of  the  wave  vectors.  An 

expression  similar  to  (18.6)  can  also  be  obtained  for  the  form  of  a  wave 
in  space  at  a  definite  instant  of  time.  For  this  we  must  put  t  =  const 
and  then,  once  again  taking  A<p  ^TU,  we  obtain 

.   ,         AG>    dk 


Afc.Az~  27u.  (18.9) 

This  means  that  if  we  want  to  limit  the  extent  of  an  electromagnetic 
disturbance  to  a  region  A#,  we  must  perform  a  superposition  of  mono- 

chromatic waves  in  the  interval  of  values  k  of  order  -r-^-  .  In  three 

Arc 

dimensions  (18.9)  is  rewritten  thus: 

&kx  -  A#~  2n  , 

AiyA«/~  2n,  (18.10) 


The  limiting  accuracy  of  radiolocation.  We  shall  explain  the  relations 
(18.10)  by  means  of  a  graphic  example.  Let  us  suppose  that  an  electro- 
magnetic wave  has,  in  some  way,  to  be  bounded  on  the  sides,  as  in  the 
case  of  a  radiolocation  (radar)  beam.  Let  us  find  the  greatest  accuracy 
with  which  the  locator  can  register  the  position  of  an  object  at  a  dis- 
tance I.  Obviously,  this  accuracy  is  given  by  the  transverse  diameter 
of  the  beam  d  at  a  distance  I  from  the  locator. 

Let  the  frequency  at  which  the  locator  works  be  equal  to  co,  then 

the  corresponding  wavelength  is  X  =  —  ^-  .  If  the  electromagnetic  wave 

were  to  be  propagated  in  unbounded  space  it  would  have  an  accu- 
rately defined  wave  vector 


(n  is  a  unit  vector  in  the  direction  of  the  beam).  If  the  wave  has  a 
cross  section  d,  then  k  can  110  longer  be  regarded  as  an  accurately 
defined  vector  along  n.  In  order  to  write  down  an  expression  for  the 
electromagnetic  wave  at  any  point  in  space  occupied  by  the  beam, 
it  is  necessary  to  take  a  group  of  plane  waves  whose  vectors  k  lie  inside 
a  cone  described  by  a  certain  angle  of  flare.  The  maximum  deviation 
of  the  wave  vectors  of  these  plane  waves  from  the  mean  vector  k, 
determined  from  (18.11),  will  be  called  k±.  Here,  we  do  not  have  in 
mind  a  cone  with  a  sharply  bounded  surface,  but  only  an  estimate 
of  the  angular  flare  of  the  beam.  According  to  (18.10)  k±  is  related  to  the 
whole  cross  section  of  the  beam  by  the  following  relation  : 

7u.  (18.12) 


Sec.  18]  TRANSMISSION    OF   SIGNALS.    ALMOST   PLANE    WAVES  179 

Here,  we  have  put  &x  —  d,  A  If  =  2  KL  because  the  inaccuracy  k± 
obtains  on  both  sides  of  the  axis  of  the  beam. 

The  dimensions  of  the  reflector  of  the  locator  itself  can  be  ignored  if 
the  diameter  of  the  beam  is  considered  at  a  great  distance  ;  and  this  is 
of  practical  interest.  In  other  words,  d  is  determined  only  by  the 
relationship  (18.12)  and  is  independent  of  the  dimensions  of  the  re- 
flector. 

The  divergence  of  the  beam  of  rays  at  every  point  is  measured  by 

the  ratio  -—•  .  For  this  reason,  the  ratio  of  the  cross  section  of  the  beam 

fc 
d  to  the  distance  from  the  locator  I  cannot  be  less  than  the  quantity 

- 


This  relationship  is  shown  in  Fig.  28  for  the  limiting  case  of  the 
equality.  However,  it  must  be  borne  in  mind  that  it  is  not  in  reality 
an  equality  but  an  estimate  of  order  of  magnitude.  (  1  8.  1  2)  is  also  approx- 
imate and  the  symbol  >  must  be  written  in  it. 

Thus,  we  have  obtained  two  estimates  for  k±  : 

k  JL  >  -T    (lower  estimate) 
and,  from  (18.13), 


kd        nd  K  £ 

--  =       -    (upper  estimate) .  Fig.  28 


Eliminating  k±  from  these  estimates,  we  obtain 
or  finally 


ltd  TT 

~7x~  ~  ~d 


d>VT\.  (18.14) 

For  example,  if  Z=100  km  and  X  =  l  m,  then  the  position  of  the 
object  cannot  be  determined  with  an  accuracy  exceeding  320  m. 
This  is  why  the  dimensions  of  the  reflector  could  be  neglected  in  the 
estimate. 

The  limit  of  applicability  of  the  concept  of  a  ray.  Equations  (18.10) 
indicate  within  what  limits  the  concept  of  a  ray  is  applicable  in  optics. 
Obviously,  one  can  talk  about  a  ray  in  a  definite  direction  only  when 

AJMfc,  (18.15) 

i.e.,  when  the  transverse  broadening  of  the  wave  vector  is  considerably 

2  TT  2  TT 

less  than  the  wave  vector  itself.  But  A&  ~  — - r-  and  k~ so  that 

d  x 

(18.15)  is  equivalent  to  the  condition 

d>X.  (18.16) 

12* 


180  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

In  other  words,  the  dimensions  of  the  region  in  which  the  concept 
of  a  light  ray  is  defined  must  be  considerably  larger  than  the  wave- 
length of  the  light  wave.  For  example,  a  small  circle  in  the  wall  of  a 
camera-obscura  of  diameter,  say,  1  mm  is  considerably  greater  than 
the  wavelength  of  visible  light,  which  is  of  an  order  of  magnitude 
0.5  x  10~4  cm.  Therefore,  the  image  obtained  in  a  camera-obscura  is 
formed  with  the  aid  of  light  rays. 

The  optics  of  light  rays  is  called  geometrical  optics.  A  ray  is  defined 
only  when  its  direction  is  given,  i.e.,  the  normal  to  the  wave  front. 
If  we  are  given  a  beam  of  nonparallel  (for  example,  converging)  rays, 
then  the  wave  front  is  curved.  But  the  radius  of  its  curvature  at  each 
point  is  considerably  greater  than  the  wavelength.  Such  a  converging 
beam  of  rays  represents  a  set  of  normals  to  an  "almost  plane"  wave. 
The  curvature  of  the  wave  front  close  to  the  focus  of  the  rays  may 
become  comparable  with  the  wavelength,  and  then  there  arise  devia- 
tions from  geometrical  optics.  Such  deviations  are  called  diffraction 
effects.  They  are  also  observed  when  a  light  wave  falls  on  some  opaque 
obstacle.  In  accordance  with  geometrical  optics,  we  should  have  ob- 
tained a  sharp  shadow — a  transition  from  a  region  where  the  field  differs 
from  zero  to  a  region  where  it  is  equal  to  zero.  But  Maxwell's  equa- 
tions do  not  permit  such  solutions,  which  are  discontinuous  in  free 
space  (cf.  the  boundary  conditions,  exercise  1,  Sec.  16).  In  actual  fact, 
there  always  exists  a  transition  zone  between  "light"  and  "shadow," 
in  which  the  wave  amplitude  changes  in  a  complicated  oscillatory 
way. 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  limiting  dimensions  of  an  object  which  may  be  observed  in 
a  microscope  using  light  of  wavelength  X. 

Denoting  the  semiangle  of  the  cone  of  rays,  drawn  from  the  microscope 
objective  to  the  object,  by  6,  we  have  Afc  =  fc  sin  0.  Whence 


Afc        A;  sin  6        sin0 

It  is  therefore  convenient  to  use  a  beam  of  rays  with  large  solid  angles 
and  small  wavelengths. 

2)  Show  that  if  the  dispersion  law  of  exercise  19,  Sec.  16,  is  used,  then  v  <  c. 
We  write  down  an  expression  for  the  inverse  of  v: 

I         8k  = 
v        d  co 

This  loads  to  the  inequality 

co    de 


The  derivative-^ — is  everywhere  positive  so  that,  for   s>l,   the   inequality 
can  be  seen  directlv.  When  e  <  1  we  have 


Sec.  19]  THE    EMISSION    OF   ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES  181 


/ 


.  _ 
2  Sw  ~  (w*-<o2)2  f        \      m        ~ 

Squaring  both  sides  of  the  inequality,  it  is  easy  to  see  that  this  quantity  is 
greater  than  I/  1  H  --  a_Ma  =  Ve~. 

Sec.  19.  The  Emission  of  Electromagnetic  Waves 

Basic  equations  and  boundary  conditions.  So  far  we  have  considered 
electromagnetic  waves  irrespective  of  the  charges  producing  them. 
In  this  section  we  shall  consider  the  emission  of  waves  by  point  charges 
moving  in  a  vacuum.  The  basic  system  of  equations  in  this  case  is 
(12.37)  and  (12.38)  together  with  the  Lorentz  condition  (12.36).  We 
rewrite  these  equations  anew: 


dt* 


We  begin  the  solution  with  (19.2)  proceeding  in  the  following  man- 
ner. We  assume  that  p  differs  from  zero  only  in  an  infinitesimal  vol- 
ume dV.  We  find  the  potential  9  for  such  a  "point"  radiator.  By  virtue 
of  the  linearity  of  equation  (19.2),  the  potential  of  the  entire  spatial 
distribution  of  charge  appearing  on  the  right-hand  side  of  (19.2)  is 
equal  to  the  integral  of  the  potentials  due  to  infinitesimal  small  ele- 
ments of  charge  8e=pdV. 

In  order  to  determine  the  solution  uniquely,  we  must  impose  a  cer- 
tain boundary  condition.  It  is  assumed  that  the  charges  are  situated 
in  infinite  space,  i.e.,  that  there  are  no  conductors  or  dielectrics  any- 
where. 

In  free  space,  a  boundary  condition  can  be  imposed  only  at  an  infinite 
distance  away  from  the  charges.  In  accordance  with  the  posed  problem 
of  radiation,  it  is  natural  to  suppose  that  there  was  no  field  for  an 
infinitely  large  interval  of  time  before  the  initiation  of  radiation  at  an 
infinitely  large  distance  from  the  radiator: 

9(£->  — oo,     r->oo)==0, 

(19.4) 
A(t— >  —  oo,     r->oo)  =  0. 

If  no  boundary  conditions  are  imposed  on  the  solution  of  an  inhomo- 
geneous  equation,  then  any  solution  of  the  homogeneous  equation  can 
always  be  added  to  it  so  that  a  unique  answer  cannot  be  obtained. 

The  radiation  of  a  small  element  of  charge.  Let  us  begin  with  an  infinitesi- 
mal charge  element  8e  =p  dV.  We  place  it  at  the  coordinate  origin.  Then 


182  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

the  solution  of  (19.2)  will  possess  spherical  symmetry.  In  Sec.  11,  an  ex- 
pression for  the  Laplacian  operator  A  was  derived  in  spherical  coordi- 
nates (11.46).  As  in  the  case  of  a  static  charge  [equation  (14.7)],  we 
must  retain  only  the  term  involving  differentiation  with  respect  to  r 
and,  this  time,  obviously,  we  must  also  differentiate  with  respect  to 
time.  For  the  time  being  we  consider  that  the  charge  density  at  all 
points,  except  the  origin,  is  equal  to  zero.  Therefore,  for  all  points 
for  which  r^O,  equation  (19.20)  is  written  thus: 


Temporarily,  we  put 

v  »  ^i  11  c\  a\ 

9  = .  (ly.o) 

Then 

~07  ^  7"  ~0r~  ~~  T2" '     r~07==r~0r~~~' 

0209  02O  0O  0O  02<$ 

0r        0/*  0r20/*          0/*  07*2* 

Substituting  this  in  (19.5)  and  multiplying  by  r  (by  convention,  r  is 
not  equal  to  zero),  we  obtain 


But  this  is  the  equation,  of  the  form  (17.5),  for  the  propagation  of  a 
wave.  Its  solution  is  similar  to  (17.12): 


The  solution  ^  depends  on  the  argument  t  +  —  ,  and  the  solution 


O2  depends  on  the  argument  t  --  .  The  first  of  these  arguments, 


t-\  —  ,  for  r->oo,  £->  —  oo  has  a  completely  indeterminate  form  oo  —  oo, 


c 


i.e.,  it  is  equal  to  anything.  From  the  condition  (19.4),  the  function  <& 
becomes  zero  when  r->oo,  t->  —  oo.  Therefore  Ox  becomes  zero  for 
any  value  of  the  argument,  i.e.,  it  is  equal  to  zero  everywhere.  (The 

potential  at  infinity  must  tend  to  zero  more  strongly  than  —  so  that 

there  should  be  no  radiation;  see  below  in  this  section.)  For  the 
function  O2,  condition  (19.4)  denotes  that  <D2  (  —  oo)=0.  In  other 
words,  the  function  O2  tends  to  zero  at  minus  infinity.  It  does  not 
follow  from  this,  of  course,  that  it  is  equal  to  zero  everywhere.  Thus, 


Omitting  the  index  2,  we  write  the  expression  for  9  as  follows: 


Sec.  19]  THE    EMISSION    OF   ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES  183 

9  =  7-*  («-£)•  (»»•») 

The  function  <I>  is  not  as  yet  determined.  From  the  form  of  its  argu- 
ment we  conclude  that  it  describes  a  travelling  wave  in  the  direction 
of  increasing  radii  (because  £>0).  Such  a  wave  is  termed  diverging. 

Retarded  potential.  The  value  of  the  function  at  r  =  0,  £  =  0  is  shifted 

to  the  point  r  in  a  time  t  =  ~  or,  in  other  words,  the  potential  at  the 

c 

point  r  and  time  t  is  determined  by  the  charge,  not  at  the  instant  of 
time  t,  but  at  an  earlier  instant  t  --  .  The  term    -  is  a  measure  of  the 

'  c  c 

retardation  occurring  as  a  result  of  the  finite  velocity  of  propagation 
of  the  wave. 

But  when  the  retardation  —  becomes  a  very  small  quantity,  the 

c 

potential  very  close  to  the  charge  must  be  determined  by  the  instan- 
taneous value  of  the  charge  de  (t).  We  know  from  Sec.  14  that  the 

8& 

potential  due  to  a  point  charge  is  equal  to    --  (14.8),  whence 


<b(t)   _  8e(a)  _  p  (t)  d  V 

r  r  r 

Therefore, 


p(i)dF,  (19.10) 

and  the  retarded  potential  of  a  point  charge  9  it  —  -I  is,  in  accordance 
with  (19.9)  and  (19.10),  equal  to 

JllltrfF.  (19.11) 

^  ' 


Now,  displacing  the  coordinate  origin  to  another  point,  we  obtain, 
like  (14.9), 


^«_J»=Jl)=MLnr2.T±V(IK.  (19.12) 

Here  it  is  assumed  that  the  charge  density  is  given  at  the  point 
r  (x,  y,  z),  and  the  potential  is  calculated  at  the  point  R  (X,  Y,  Z), 
thus  introducing  the  explicit  dependence  of  p  on  the  spatial  argument  r. 
Finally,  in  order  to  obtain  the  complete  solution  to  (19.2),  we  must 
integrate  (19.12)  over  all  the  volume  elements,  i.e.,  with  respect  to 
a  v  ==' cLoc  dy  0/2 1 

9=  I  |R-°r|    '       dV'  (19.13) 

For  point  charges,  p  denotes  the  special  function  that  was  defined 
in  Sec.  12. 


184  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

Equation  (19.1)  has  exactly  the  same  form  as  (19.2)  and  its  solution 
satisfies  the  same  boundary  conditions.  Therefore,  the  vector  poten- 
tial is  written  quite  analogously  to  (19.13): 


ry  /in  IA\ 

|R-_r|  "P.  (LJ.U) 

Comparing  (19.14)  with  (15.10),  which  gives  A  for  a  stationary 
current,  we  see  that  j  depends  on  the  argument  r  in  two  ways:  first, 
directly,  in  accordance  with  its  spatial  distribution  and,  secondly, 
via  the  time  argument;  since  the  system  of  currents  is  not  infinitely 
small,  but  has  finite  dimensions,  the  retardation  of  a  wave  from 
various  points  of  the  system  is  different. 

Retarded  potential  at  a  large  distance  from  a  system  of  charges. 
We  shall  now  look  for  the  form  of  the  solutions  of  (19.12)  and  (19.13) 
at  a  great  distance  away  from  the  radiating  system.  We  note  that  the 
integrand  depends  on  the  argument  R  in  both  integrals  in  two  ways: 
in  the  denominator  and  via  the  argument  t.  The  function  in  the 
denominator  depends  very  smoothly  on  R.  Its  expansion  in  terms 

of  powers  of  R  yields  terms  which  tend  to  zero  like  -^-  at  large  dis- 
tances away  from  the  system.  As  will  be  shown  later,  they  do  not 

add  anything  to  the  radiation   (for  n>l).   So   we  simply  replace 

l  I 

TRlITT  ^7  ~jf  •  At  large  distances  from  the  system,  the  term  |  R — r  |  , 

appearing  in  the  argument  t  of  the  numerator,  looks  like  this: 

I      —    I  — .    .  —  —          — ^    —     —       ,  (  .  .  o) 

where  n  is  a  unit  vector  in  the  direction  of  R.  The  subsequent  terms 
of  the  expansion  (19.15)  contain  R  in  the  denominator  and  are  insignif- 
icant. Thus,  at  a  large  distance  from  the  radiating  system,  the  poten- 
tials are: 


An  estimate  of  the  retardation  inside  a  system.  The  term  -  y    in 

the  arguments  of  the  integrands  of  (19.16)  and  (19.17)  indicates  by 
how  much  an  electromagnetic  wave,  coming  from  the  more  distant 
parts  of  the  radiating  system,  is  retarded  in  comparison  with  a  wave 
radiated  by  the  nearer  parts  of  the  system.  In  other  words,  the  term 

— —  determines  the  time  that  the  electromagnetic  wave  takes  in 
passing  through  the  system  of  charges.  If  the  velocity  of  the  charges 


Sec.  19]  THE    EMISSION    OF   ELECTROMAGNETIC    WAVES  185 

is  equal  to  v,  then,  in  that  time,  they  are  displaced  through  a  distance 

v  -^51.  The  retardation  inside  the  system  is  negligible  when  this 
c 

distance  is  small  in  comparison  with  the  size  of  the  system  r.  Therefore, 

if  v         <^r  (or,  more  simply,  v<^.c),  then  the  charges  do  not  have 
c 

time  to  change  their-  positions  noticeably  during  the  time  of  propa- 
gation of  the  wave  in  the  system. 

However,  in  order  that  nothing  should  really  change  in  the  system, 
the  charges  must  also  maintain  their  velocities  in  that  time,  because 
the  vector  potential  depends  on  the  currents,  i.e.,  on  the  particle 
velocities.  This  imposes  a  further  condition  which  is  formulated  in  the 
following  manner.  Let  the  charges  oscillate  and  radiate  light  of  fre- 

quency co.  The  wavelength  of  the  light  is  equal  to  X  =  —  —  .  In  the  time 

—  the  phase  of  the  charge  oscillations  changes  by  co  -  ~  .  This  change 
c  c 

must  be  small  in  comparison  with  2  TT,  whence  it  follows  that  the  size 
of  the  system  must  be  small  compared  with  the  wavelength  of  the 
radiated  light  in  order  that  the  retardation  inside  the  system  should 

be  insignificant.  Thus,  the  term  -^51  fn  the  argument  of  the  integrand 

c 

is  small  provided  two  inequalities  are  fulfilled:  v<^c}  r<^X. 

The  vector  potential  to  a  dipole  approximation.  Let  us  assume  that 
both  the  inequalities  obtained  have  been  fulfilled.  We  omit  the  term 

-  —  in  the  time  argument  in  the  expression  for  vector  potential  (19.17). 
Then  the  whole  integrand  will  refer  to  the  same  instant  of  time 

t  ----  and  we  obtain 

c 


Recall  now  that  j  =  pv  and  that  the  charges  are  point  charges. 
Then  the  integral  (19.18)  is  reduced  to  a  summation  over  separate 
charges  : 


T> 

Here,  the  lower  index  t  ---  denotes  that  the  whole  sum  must  be 

c  drj 

taken  at  that  instant  of  time.  But  v1'  —  -y-,  so  that 


Here  we  have  used  the  definition  for  dipole  moment  (14.20).  We 
note  that  (19.20)  involves  only  a  time  derivative  d.  Therefore,  the 


186  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

transformation  (14.21),  which  corresponds  to  a  change  of  coordinate 
origin,  does  not  change  d  either  for  a  charged  system  or  for  a  neutral 
system.  In  particular,  (19.20)  holds  also  for  a  single  charge. 

The  approximation  (19.20),  in  which  A  is  expressed  in  terms  of  a 
derivative  of  the  dipole  moment  of  the  system  as  a  whole,  is  termed  a 
dipole  approximation. 

The  Lorentz  condition  to  a  dipole  approximation.  In  Sec.  17,  a  poten- 
tial gauge  transformation  for  travelling  plane  waves  was  chosen  such 
that  the  scalar  potential  became  zero.  We  shall  make  the  same  gauge 
transformation  for  diverging  spherical  waves.  To  do  this  we  must 
subject  the  vector  potential  to  the  following  condition: 

divA  =  0,  (19.21) 

which  is  obtained  from  (19.3)  if  we  take  9  =  0. 

In  condition  (19.21)  we  should  not  differentiate  A  with  respect  to 
R  in  the  denominator:  each  such  differentiation  increases  the  degree 
of  R  by  unity,  while  the  potential  is  determined  at  a  large  distance 
from  the  radiating  system.  Only  terms  inversely  proportional  to  R 

•n 

contribute  to  the  radiated  energy  (see  below).  The  unit  vector  n  =  -p-, 

which  will  appear  in  differentiation,  need  not  be  differentiated  a  second 
time,  since  that  would  also  give  rise  to  superfluous  degrees  of  R  in  the 
denominator. 

We  choose  an  arbitrary  gauge  function  in  the  form 

_  I          R  \ 

n  n  *  /  --  ,  i 

11  UL  \  v  ^—  - 

/=  -— '  -£—  —  .  (19.22) 

Then,  applying  equation  (11.37),  it  is  easy  to  see  that  the  condition 
(19.21)  is  fulfilled: 


1      1  f 

And  the  scalar  potential  is  cancelled  by  --  -~. 

c   (/  1 

Field  to  a  dipole  approximation.  Let  us  now  calculate  the  electro- 
magnetic field.  We  need  to  differentiate  only  inside  the  argument 

t  --  -.  In  calculating  the  magnetic  field,  we  make  use  of  (11.38)  and 
of  the  fact  that  rot  grad  /  =  0: 

H  =  rot  A  =  -i-  rot  d 
The  electric  field  is 


1  0A         10  _.  d      ,       1        ,    3. 

T-      "  ~     Vf  =  -  -•  +  -*  (nd)  = 


(19.24) 


Sec.  19] 


THE   EMISSION   OF   ELECTROMAGNETIC   WAVES 


187 


From  these  equations  it  can  be  seen  that  the  electric  field,  the 
magnetic  field,  and  the  vector  n  are  mutually  perpendicular.  In  addi- 
tion, H  =  E,  since  E*=  [Hn]2-//2— (Hn)2,  and  Hn  =  0,  since  H  and 
ii  are  perpendicular.  Consequently,  the  wave  at  a  point  R  at  a  great 
distance  away  from  a  radiating  system  is  of  the  nature  of  a  plane 
electromagnetic  wave.  This  result  was  to  be  expected  because  the 
field  is  calculated  far  away  from  charges,  where  the  wave  front  may 
be  approximately  regarded  as  plane  and  the  solution  becomes  the 
same  as  obtained  in  Sec.  17. 

Fig.  29  gives  a  general  picture  of  the  field.  We  situate  the  vector  d 
at  the  centre  of  a  sphere  of  large  radius  R  so  that  d  coincides  with  the 
polar  axis  or,  in  other  words,  is  directed  towards  the  "north  pole." 
Let  us  draw  the  radius  vector  of  some  point.  Through  this  point,  we 
draw  the  meridian  and  the  parallel.  Then  the  electric  field  is  tangential 
to  the  meridian  and  is  directed  "towards 
the  south,"  while  the  magnetic  field  is 
tangential  to  the  parallel  and  is  directed 
"towards  the  east."  It  can  be  seen  from 
equations  (19.23)  and  (19.24)  that  the 
field  becomes  zero  at  the  poles  and  max- 
imum 011  the  equator,  i.e.,  on  a  plane 

perpendicular  to  d.  The  field  distribu- 
tion in  space  does  not  possess  spherical 
symmetry.  We  note  that  the  trans- 
verse field  cannot  be  spherically  sym- 
metrical for  purely  geometrical  reasons. 
The  zone,  in  which  the  field  is  calculat- 
ed according  to  equations  (19.23)  and 
(19.24),  is  called  a  wave  zone. 

The  intensity  of  dipole  radiation.  Let  us  now  find  the  energy  lost 
by  the  system  in  radiation.  We  must  calculate  the  energy  flux  crossing 
an  infinitely  distant  surface.  The  energy  flux  density,  or  the  Poynting 
vector,  is 

(19.25) 


Fig.  29 


Hence,  the  energy  flux  is  directed  along  a  radius,  as  it  should  be  in  a 
wave  zone.  The  total  energy  crossing  a  sphere  of  radius  R  in  unit  time  is 


dt 


because  the  vector  ds  is  directed  along  n.  Further, 
where  £  is  the  polar  angle.  From  (19.23) 


(19.26) 
TU  sin8-d£, 


(19.27) 


188  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

By  substituting  (19.27)  in  (19.26),  cancelling  R2,  and  integrating,  we 
obtain  an  expression  for  the  energy  radiated  in  one  second: 


---. 
dt    ~  3  ~&  '  . 

We  note  that  all  the  terms  in  the  expression  for  fields  containing  R 
in  the  denominator  to  a  higher  degree  than  the  first  would  not  con- 
tribute anything  to  (19.28)  for  a  sufficiently  large  R.  It  is  for  this  reason 
that  only  first  degree  terms  in  J?have  been  retained  in  the  denominator. 

The  significance  of  equation  (19.28).  Equation  (19.28)  expresses  a 
result  of  fundamental  importance  —  energy  is  radiated  whenever  a 

charge  is  accelerated.  Indeed,  d  =  JT'e,-  f  '  .   Hence  it  is  necessary  —  so 

that  d  should  differ  from  zero  —  that  the  charges  should  be  in  accel- 
erated motion  irrespective  of  the  sign  of  the  accelerations. 

But  then  electrons  moving  in  an  atom  should  radiate  energy  con- 
tinuously and  should  fall  into  the  nucleus  ;  every  electron  is  in  accelera- 
tion motion,  otherwise  its  motion  could  not  be  finite  (see  Sec.  5). 

In  actual  fact  atoms  are  obviously  stable  and  the  electrons  do  not 
fall  into  the  nucleus. 

Here,  we  realize  that  classical,  Newtonian,  mechanics  can  in  110 
way  be  applied  to  the  motion  of  an  electron  in  an  atom.  In  the  third 
part  of  this  book  we  shall  explain  the  stability  of  atoms  using  quantum 
mechanics,  where  the  very  concept  of  motion  differs  qualitatively 
from  that  in  classical  mechanics. 

Magnetic  dipole  and  quadrupole  radiation.  We  have  indicated  that 
charges  must  be  in  accelerated  motion  to  radiate.  But  a  simple  example 
can  be  given  when  equation  (19.28)  yields  zero  even  for  accelerated 
charges.  Let  the  system  consist  of  two  identical  charged  particles. 
According  to  Newton's  Third  Law  their  accelerations  are  equal  and 

opposite  in  sign,  so  that  d  =  £&*  '  =  ^(r1  +  f2)=:0.  In  this  case 

i 

this  law  is  applicable  because,  to  a  dipole  approximation,  the  retar- 
dation of  electromagnetic  interactions  inside  the  system  is  considered 
as  negligibly  small  and,  hence,  the  interaction  forces  between  charges 
are  regarded  as  instantaneous.  But  there  is  then  no  need  to  take 
account  of  the  momentum  transmitted  to  the  field  and  the  total  mo- 
mentum of  the  particles  is  conserved,  thereby  leading  to  the  condition 
?!=  —  r2.  For  this  case,  approximation  (19.18)  does  not  describe  the 
radiation  and  it  becomes  necessary  to  use  higher-order  approximations. 

If,  in  the  expansion  in  powers  of  —  ,  a  further  term  is  retained  in 

c 

addition  to  the  zero  term,  then  a  radiation  is  obtained  which  depends 
on  the  change  in  magnetic  quadrupole  and  dipole  moments  of  a  system 
of  charges.  It  is  essential  that  this  expansion  be  not  in  terms  of  inverse 


Sec.  19]  THE    EMISSION   OF  ELECTROMAGNETIC   WAVES  189 

powers  of  R,  as  in  electrostatics  and  magnetostatics,  but  in  powers 
of  the  retardation  inside  the  system. 

We  have  already  mentioned  that  the  retardation  inside  the  system 

is    small   when    v  <^  c  and   r  <^  X.   The  ratio  —    is   involved  in  the 

c 

magnetic  moment  of  the  system.  Therefore,  those  terms  in  the  ex- 
pansion (involving  powers  of  the  retardation)  which  are  proportional 

to  -  ~  ,  account  for  magnetic  dipole  radiation.  The  quadrupole  moment 

of  the  system  involves  an  additional  power  of  r  compared  with  the 
dipole  moment,  and  so  quadrupole  radiation  is  related  to  those  terms 

of  the  expansion  which  are  proportional  to  ~  .  Higher  approximations 

A 

are  important  in  those  cases  for  which  lower-order  approximations, 
for  some  reason  or  other,  become  zero,  as  is  the  case  of  the  two  identical 
charges. 

The  field  due  to  a  magnetic  dipole  radiator  is  similar  to  the  field 
of  a  radiating  electric  dipole.  Unlike  the  field  represented  in  Fig.  29, 
the  magnetic  field,  for  magnetic  dipole  radiation,  lies  in  the  plane  jx, 
(i.e.,  it  is  along  a  meridian),  while  the  electric  field  is  along  a  parallel. 
The  equation  for  intensity  is  similar  to  (19.28),  though  it  involves 

(ti)2  instead  of  (d)2.  Since  the  magnetic  moment  is  proportional  to  —  , 

c 

the  intensity  of  magnetic  dipole  radiation  is  less  than  the  intensity  of 
electric  dipole  radiation  in  the  ratio  I  —  1  . 

The  field  of  a  radiating  electric  quadrupole  has  a  more  complicated 
configuration.  The  expression  for  the  intensity  of  such  radiation 
involves  the  square  of  the  third  derivative  of  the  quadrupole  moment 
of  the  system.  In  order  of  magnitude,  the  intensity  of  quadrupole 

(r  \2 
—I   . 

Exercises 

1)  Calculate  the  time  that  it  takes  a  charge,  moving  in  a  circular  orbit 
around  a  centre  of  attraction,  to  fall  into  the  centre  as  a  result  of  the  radiation 
of  electromagnetic  waves.  Regard  the  path  as  always  approximately  circular. 

2)  A  particle  with  charge  e  and  mass  m  passes,  with  velocity  v,  a  fixed 
particle  of  charge  e19  at  a  distance  p.  Ignoring  the  distortion  in  the  orbit  of 
the  oncoming  particle,  calculate  the  energy  that  this  particle  loses  in  radiation. 

00  00 

A  AJP       2      &2      fr-12.7,       2     e*ef     f          dt  w       e*«f 

Answer:   A^---      |,  |«d«-  -—  A-  J    (p>  +  ^i)a  •-•—1-. 


3)  Why  is  it  that  when  two  identical  particles  collide  (e1=e2,  m1  =  m2), 
magnetic  dipole  radiation  does  not  result  if  the  interaction  is  calculated  according 

2      LL2 

to  the  Coulomb  law  ?  The  intensity  of  magnetic  dipole  radiation  is    -«•  -—•  . 


190  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

4)  A  plane  light  wave  falls  on  a  free  electron  causing  it  to  oscillate.  The 
electron  begins  to  radiate  secondary  waves,  i.e.,  it  scatters  the  radiation. 
Find  the  effective  scattering  cross  section,  defined  as  the  ratio  of  the  energy 
scattered  in  unit  time  to  the  flux  density  of  the  incident  radiation. 

We  proceed  from  the  fact  that  r  = and  then  determine  —y—  from (19. 28). 

Dividing  by  the  energy  flux  — — ,  we  obtain 


Sec.  20.  The  Theory  ol  Relativity 

The  law  of  addition  of  velocities  and  electrodynamics.  In  Sec.  15, 
the  interactions  of  charges  with  a  magnetic  and  an  electric  field  was 
reviewed  [see  (15.34)].  But  the  motion  of  the  charges  was  considered 
slow,  in  other  words,  the  velocity  satisfied  the  inequality  v  <^  c. 

Yet  this  inequality  is  by  no  means  always  satisfied.  Electrons  ob- 
tained in  beta  decay,  particles  in  cosmic  rays,  and  particles  in  accel- 
erators move  with  velocities  close  to  that  of  light.  Hence,  it  is  necessary 
to  obtain  the  laws  of  mechanics  for  these  ultra-highspeed  charged 
particles. 

If  we  attempt  to  apply  Newtonian  mechanical  laws  to  these  particles 
we  will  encounter  an  insurmountable  contradiction — the  law  of 
addition  of  velocities  cannot  be  applied  in  electrodynamics  in  its 
usual  form  (see  Sees.  8  and  10). 

The  equations  of  Newtonian  mechanics  are  of  the  same  form  for 
all  inertial  systems  moving  uniformly  relative  to  each  other.  In  such 
systems  there  are  no  inertial  forces.  Naturally,  under  no  circumstances 
can  the  principle  of  the  equivalence  of  inertial  systems  be  violated, 
otherwise  we  should  have  to  assume  that  there  existed  a  reference 
system  at  absolute  rest.  We  must  also  consider  that  the  equations  of 
electrodynamics  appear  the  same  for  all  inertial  systems  in  free  space — 
in  the  form  (12.24)-(12.27).  It  follows  from  these  equations  that  the 
velocity  of  propagation  of  electromagnetic  disturbances  is  equal  to  c 
and  is  the  same  for  all  directions  in  space.  If  it  turned  out  that  in 
some  inertial  systems  the  velocity  of  light  depended  upon  the  direction 
of  its  propagation,  then  these  systems  would  not  be  equivalent  to  a 
system  in  which  the  velocity  of  light  is  the  same  in  all  directions.  In 
this  system,  the  electrodynamical  equations  would  admit  of  a  solution 
in  the  form  of  a  spherical  wave — a  solution  similar  to  the  one  that  was 
obtained  in  the  preceding  section.  In  all  other  inertial  systems,  the 
velocity  of  light  would  depend  on  the  direction  of  the  wave  normal. 

An  analogy  would  arise  with  the  propagation  of  sound  in  air :  the 
velocity  of  sound  in  a  system  at  rest  relative  to  the  air  does  not  depend 
on  direction,  but  in  a  system  moving  relative  to  the  air  the  velocity 


Sec.  20]  THE    THEORY    OF    RELATIVITY  191 

of  sound  is  less  in  the  direction  of  motion  and  more  in  the  opposite 
direction  as  a  consequence  of  the  law  of  velocity  addition. 

So  far,  it  has  been  considered  that  light  is  transmitted  in  an  elastic 
medium,  "the  ether,"  and  it  has  been  regarded  as  self-evident  that  the 
velocity  of  light  must  be  governed  by  the  same  law  of  velocity  addition 
as  the  velocity  of  sound  in  air.  Then  a  reference  system  fixed  in  the 
"ether"  would  have  to  be  regarded  as  being  at  absolute  rest,  while  all 
the  remaining  systems,  as  in  absolute  motion.  In  these  systems  the 
velocity  of  light  would  depend  on  its  direction  of  propagation,  in 
accordance  with  the  law 

c'=c  +  v,  (20.1) 

where,  for  simplicity,  only  that  direction  is  taken  which  coincides  with 
the  relative  velocity  of  the  system. 

Michelson's  experiment.  A  direct  experiment  was  performed  which 
showed  that  the  velocity  of  light  cannot  be  combined  with  any  other 
velocity  and,  in  all  reference  systems,  it  is  equal 
to  a  universal  constant  c.  This  was  the  famous 
Michelson  experiment  (1887)  which  we  shall 
describe  in  brief.  ^A  ray  of  light  falls  on  a 
half-silvered  mirrorS/S  (Fig.  30),  where  it  is 
split  up  :  a  part  of  the  light  is  reflected  and  falls  ^ 

on  mirror  A  while  the  other  part  is  transmitted  ' 

and  falls  on  mirror  B.  Let  SA  be  perpendicular         * 
to  the   motion  of  the   earth  and  let  SB   be 
parallel  to  the  earth's  motion.  The  light  reflect- 
ed from  the  mirrors  A  and  B  returns  to  the 
plate  SS;  the  ray  BS  is  reflected  from  it  and  ^ 

falls   on  screen  C  while  the  ray  AS  is  trans-        _  ^u 
mitted  to  the  screen  directly.  Thus,  both  rays  Fig.  30 

are  entirely  equivalent  as  regards  transmissions 

and  reflections,  though  in  the  sections  AS  and  BS  the  light  is  propa- 
gated differently  relative  to  the  earth's  motion. 

Let  us  assume  now  that  the  velocity  of  light  is  combined  with  the 
motion  of  the  earth  according  to  the  usual  law  of  addition  of  veloc- 
ities. Then,  along  the  path  SB,  the  velocity  of  light  relative  to  the 
earth  is  equal  to  c  —  V,  and  c+V  along  the  return  path,  where  V 
is  the  velocity  of  the  earth.  The  time  light  takes  to  travel  along  the 
entire  path  SBS  in  both  directions  is 

I  I  2lc  21        21VZ 


where  I  —  SB.  We  have  used  the  fact  that  F<^c.  Along  the  section 
SA  the  velocity  of  light  and  the  earth's  velocity  are  perpendicular  to 
each  other  (in  a  reference  system  fixed  in  the  apparatus).  If  again  the 
law  of  velocity  addition  holds,  then  the  velocity  of  light  relative  to 


192  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

the  apparatus,  along  the  section  SA,  is  equal  to  Vc2 — F2  (c  is  the 
hypotenuse  of  the  triangle,  F  and  Vc2  —  F2  are  the  sides).  The  time 
taken  by  the  light  to  travel  along  the  whole  path  SAS,  equal  to  2  Z,  is 

21      _  21       IV2 


C3 

Thus,  the  difference  in  the  passage  times  along  the  paths  8B8 
and  SAS  is  equal  to  — y-  .  By  means  of  repeated  reflections,  the  path 

can  be  made  sufficiently  long  (several  tens  of  metres).  Choosing  it 
properly,  we  can  arrange  that  the  proposed  time  difference  for  the  paths 
SA  S  and  S  BS  is  equal  to  a  half-period  of  oscillation.  The  rays  on  the 
screen  C  should  then  mutually  cancel.  In  order  to  be  certain  that  the 
cancellation  has  occurred  as  a  result  of  the  combination  of  the  velocity 
of  light  with  the  velocity  of  the  earth,  and  not  by  accident,  it  is  suffi- 
cient to  rotate  the  apparatus  through  45°  so  that  the  direction  of  the 
earth's  velocity  would  be  along  the  bisector  of  the  angle  A  SB.  Then 
the  difference  in  time  taken  by  the  rays  to  travel  along  the  paths 
SAS  and  SBS  should  at  least  become  equal  to  zero;  hence,  if,  in  the 
previous  position,  the  rays  mutually  cancelled  as  a  result  of  the  com- 
bination of  the  velocity  of  light  with  the  earth's  velocity  then,  in  the 
new  position,  the  rays  would  mutually  reinforce  each  other.  In  other 
words,  the  interference  bands  on  the  screen  would  be  displaced  by 
half  a  wavelength. 

Actually,  no  change  in  the  path  difference  between  the  rays  occurs 
when  the  apparatus  is  rotated,  i.e.,  the  expected  effect  is  completely 
absent.  An  addition  of  the  velocity  of  light  and  the  earth's  velocity 
does  not  occur. 

The  negative  result  of  Michelson's  experiment  is  completely  under- 
standable if  we  reject  the  postulate  of  an  "ether."  Nevertheless, 
at  the  time  when  the  experiment  was  performed,  no  one  as  yet  under- 
stood that  electrodynamics  does  not  require  an  "ether"  in  order  to 
become  as  complete  and  clear  a  science  as  mechanics.  The  fact  that 
the  law  of  addition  of  velocities — a  truism  for  physicists  in  the  past — 
failed  to  hold,  appeared  as  an  inexplicable  paradox. 

In  addition,  Michelson's  experiment  apparently  contradicted  the 
phenomenon  of  astronomical  abberation  of  light  and  Fizeau's  experi- 
ment. (These  will  be  considered  later  in  this  section  in  the  light  of  the 
theory  of  relativity.) 

Einstein's  relativity  principle.  We  shall  not  give  the  history  of  the 
painful  attempts  to  explain  this  paradox  but,  instead,  we  will  straight- 
way present  the  correct  solution  to  the  problem  as  given  by  A.  Ein- 
stein in  1905.  It  is  known  as  the  special  theory  of  relativity.  Despite  the 
delusion  widespread  among  laymen,  this  term  by  no  means  expresses 
the  relativity  of  our  physical  knowledge.  It  expresses  the  mutual 
equivalence  of  all  inertial  systems  moving  relative  to  one  another. 


Sec.  20]  THE  THEORY  OF  RELATIVITY  193 

The  equations  of  electrodynamics  do  not  imply  the  presence  of  any 
elastic  medium  ("ether")  for  the  transmission  of  electromagnetic 
disturbances.  We  have  already  discussed  this  in  Sec.  12.  The  reality 
is  the  electric  field  itself.  For  this  reason,  the  equations  of  electro- 
dynamics are  just  as  independent  of  the  choice  of  inertial  reference 
system  as  the  equations  of  mechanics.  Both  sets  of  equations  describe 
motion,  i.  e.,  the  change  of  state  with  time  directly.  Mechanics  de- 
scribes the  change  of  mass  configuration,  while  electrodynamics  de- 
scribes changes  of  the  electromagnetic  field.  The  forms  of  the  equations 
of  motion  cannot  change  as  a  result  of  the  choice  of  inertial  system. 

This  is  why  the  result  of  Michelson's  experiment  does  not  contradict 
the  notion  of  relativity  of  motion,  but  confirms  it.  Michelson's  experi- 
ment shows  that  the  velocity  of  light  in  free  space  is  the  same  in  all 
inertial  systems.  The  velocity  of  propagation  of  interactions  is  a  funda- 
mental constant  in  the  equations  of  electrodynamics.  These  equations 
are  invariant  to  a  transformation  from  one  inertial  system  to  another 
only  when  the  velocity  of  propagation  of  the  interactions  in  both  sys- 
tems is  the  same.  And  so  the  result  of  Michelson's  experiment  contra- 
dicts only  the  law  of  addition  of  velocities,  i.  e.,  Galilean  transforma- 
tions (8.1)  and  (8.2).  This  law  of  addition  of  velocities  is  confirmed 
experimentally  only  for  relative  velocities  and  for  velocities  of  motion 
that  are  small  compared  with  the  velocity  of  light  c.  Obviously,  it 
must  be  replaced  by  a  more  precise  law  for  the  region  of  high  velocities. 
But  this  more  precise  law  must  also  hold  in  mechanics  for  large  par- 
ticle velocities.  This  can  be  seen  from  the  following  reasoning. 

Let  the  charges  in  a  specific  inertial  system  interact  in  some  way 
with  the  electromagnetic  field  producing  certain  events  (for  example, 
collisions  between  the  charges).  They  may  be  precalculated  on  the 
basis  of  the  equations  of  mechanics  and  electrodynamics.  In  trans- 
forming to  another  inertial  system,  the  equations  of  mechanics  and 
electrodynamics  must  retain  their  form,  otherwise,  other  consequences 
will  follow  from  the  transformed  equations  taken  together ;  in  partic- 
ular, those  events  which  were  precalculatecl  and  occur  in  the  first 
inertial  system  do  not  necessarily  take  place  in  another  system. 
But  events  such  as  collisions,  for  example,  are  objective  facts;  they 
should  be  observed  in  all  coordinate  systems.  Yet  if  we  apply  Galilean 
transformations  (8.1)  then  the  equations  of  Newtonian  mechanics  will 
not  change,  while  the  equations  of  electrodynamics  will  change,  since 
the  law  of  addition  of  velocities  (10.12)  is  not  applicable  in  electro- 
dynamics. Therefore,  we  must  find  transformations  to  replace  the 
Galilean  transformations  such  as  would  leave  both  the  equations  of 
mechanics  and  the  equations  of  electrodynamics  invariant.  But  then 
it  would  become  necessary  to  make  the  laws  of  Newtonian  mechanics 
more  precise,  since  they  are  correct  only  for  low  particle  velocities. 

A  physical  theory  which  cannot  predict  facts  independently  of  the 
mode  of  their  description  is  imperfect  and  contradictory.  It  is  this 

13  -  0060 


194  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

that  makes  us  reconsider  the  basic  facts  of  mechanics,  no  matter  how 
self-evident  they  seem  to  be  in  our  everyday  experience,  which  has 
to  do  with  the  motions  of  bodies  at  velocities  that  are  small  compared 
with  that  of  light. 

The  Lorentz  transformations.  We  look  for  transformations  of  a  more 
general  form  than,  the  Galilean  transformations  for  passing  from  one 
inertial  system  to  another.  Like  the  Galilean  transformations,  they 
must  satisfy  certain  requirements  of  a  general  nature.  These  require- 
ments may  be  expressed  as  follows. 

1)  The  transformation  equations  are  symmetrical  with  respect  to 
both  systems.  We  shall  denote  the  quantities  that  refer  to  one  system 
by  letters  without  primes  (x,  y,  z,  t),  while  those  that  refer  to  the  other 
system  will  be  primed  (#',  y',  z',  t').  We  denote  the  velocity  of  the  primed 
system  with  respect  to  the  unprimed  system  by  F.  Then  the  mathe- 
matical form  of  the  equations  expressing  unprimed  quantities  in 
terms  of  primed  quantities  (and  the  velocity  F)  is  the  same  as  that 
of  the  equations  for  the  reverse  transformation,  if  we  change  the  sign 
of  the  velocity  in  them.  This  requirement  is  necessary  for  the  equiva- 
lence of  both  systems. 

2)  The  transformation  must  convert  the  finite  points  of  one  system 
to  the  finite  points  of  the  other,  i.e.,  if  (x9  y,  z,  t)  are  finite,  then  a 
transformation  with  finite  coefficients  must  leave  (xr,  y',  z',  t')  finite 
values. 

Condition  (1)  greatly  restricts  the  possible  form  of  the  transforma- 
tions. For  example,  it  can  be  seen  that  the  transformation  functions 
cannot  be  quadratic,  because  the  inversion  of  a  quadratic  function 
leads  to  irrationality,  just  as  that  of  the  function  of  any  degree  other 
than  the  first.  A  linear-fractional  transformation  (i.e.,  the  quotient  of 
two  linear  expressions) — under  certain  limitations  imposed  on  the 
coefficients — may  be  inverted  retaining  the  same  form.  For  example, 
for  one  variable  the  direct  and  the  inverse  linear-fractional  functions 
look  like 

/  ax-}-b  b  —  fx' 

ex-}-  f  '          ~~  ex'  —  a 

But  this  function  does  not  satisfy  condition  (2):  if  x'  =a/e,  x  be- 
comes infinite.  Therefore,  a  linear  function  is  the  only  possible  one. 

3)  When  the  relative  velocity  of  two  systems  tends  to  zero,  the 
transformation  equations  yield  an  identity  (x'  =x,  y'  =y,  z'  =2,  t'  =t). 

4)  A  law  of  the  addition  of  velocities  is  obtained  from  the  transfor- 
mation equations  such  that  it  leaves  the  velocity  of  light  in  free  space 
invariant:  c'=c. 

Summarizing,  we  can  say  that  the  transformation  equations:  1) 
maintain  their  form  when  inverted,  2)  are  linear,  3)  become  identities 
for  small  relative  velocities,  4)  leave  the  velocity  of  light  in  free  space 
unchanged. 


Sec.  20]  THE    THEORY    OF   BELAT1VITY  195 

These  four  conditions  are  sufficient.  The  required  equations  can  be 
obtained  most  simply  if  one  of  the  coordinate  axes  (for  example,  the 
#-axis)  is  taken  in  the  direction  of  the  relative  velocity.  Then  the  other 
axes  will  not  be  affected  by  the  transformation. 

We  return  to  Fig.  11  (page  68),  but  we  will  not  make  the  arbitrary 
assumption  that  t  =  t'  (experiment  supports  this  only  for  small  relative 
velocities  of  both  systems).  Let  us  see  what  results  from  the  conditions 
(l)-(4).  If  the  velocity  is  along  the  #-axis,  then,  as  has  just  been  found, 
y'  =  y,  z'  —z.  This  can  be  seen  simply  from  Fig.  11.  In  the  most  general 
form,  linear  transformations  of  x  and  t,  appear  thus  : 

x'  =  ax  +  $t  ,  (20.2) 

t'  =  y#  +  St.  (20.3) 

The  constant  terms  need  not  be  written  in  these  equations  ;  they  can 
be  included  in  the  definition  of  x  or  x'  through  choice  of  the  coordinate 
origin. 

Let  us  apply  equation  (20.2)  to  the  origin  of  the  primed  system, 
x'  =  0.  This  point  moves  with  velocity  V  relative  to  the  unprimed  sys- 
tem. Hence,  x—Vt.  Substituting  re'=^0,  x=Vt  in  (20.2),  we  obtain, 
after  eliminating  t, 

<xF-hP  =  0.  (20.4) 

We  shall  solve  equations  (20.2)  and  (20.3)  with  respect  to  x  and  t. 
Elementary  algebraic  computations  give 

x=,^=^_  (20.5) 

aS  —  PY 

'=-  (20'6) 


Let  us  now  apply  condition  (1).  For  this  we  note  that  the  coefficients 
(5  and  y,  which  interrelate  the  coordinate  and  time,  must  change 
sign  together  with  the  velocity  V.  Otherwise,  if  the  x  and  xr  axes 
are  turned  in  the  opposite  direction  the  equations  will  not  preserve 
their  form,  and  this  is  impermissible.  Thus,  the  equations  for  the 
inverse  transformation  from  unprimed  quantities  to  primed  have 
the  same  form  as  (20.2)  and  (20.3): 

x  -  art  -  $t'  ,  (20.7) 

t  =  —  ya;'  +  S*'  .  (20.8) 

Comparing  (20.7)  and  (20.5),  we  obtain 

«  =  T8=TT  .  (20-9) 

-P  =  -aT_V-  <2<UO> 

13* 


196  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

From  (20.10)  it  follows  that 

a8  —  py=l.  (20.11) 

Then,  from  (20.9),  we  obtain 

<x  —  8.  (20.12) 

No  other  relationships  are  obtained  from  the  comparison  of  the 
direct  equations  with  the  inverse  equations. 

We  now  use  condition  (4).  We  divide  equation  (20.2)  by  (20.3): 


(20-13) 


Let  #  be  a  point  occupied  by  a  light  signal  emitted  from  the  origin 
of  the  unprimed  system  at  an  initial  instant  of  time  £  =  0.  Obviously, 

~  =c.  But  in  accordance  with  condition  (4),  -7  =c.  Hence, 

t  v 


. 
yc  -t-  8 


(20.14) 

v  ' 


We  substitute  the  relations  (20.4)  and  (20.12)  into  (20.14)  in  order 
to  eliminate  p  and  8.  There  remains  a  relation  between  a  and  y: 

yc2  +  ac  =  ac  —  aF  , 
whence 

Y--OC-J.  (20.15) 

We  now  substitute  (20.15),  (20.4)  and  (20.12)  into  (20.11)  and  obtain 
an  equation  for  a: 

(20.16) 


In  extracting  the  square  root,  we  must  take  the  positive  sign 
in  accordance  with  condition  (3),  because  then  (20.3)  becomes  t1  —t 
for  a  small  relative  velocity.  A  minus  sign  would  yield  t'  =  —  t, 
which  is  meaningless. 

Now  expressing  all  the  coefficients  a,  (3,  y,  and  8  in  accordance 
with  equations  (20.16),  (20.4),  (20.15),  and  (20.12),  respectively,  and 
substituting  (20.3)  into  (20.2),  we  arrive  at  the  required  trans- 
formations : 


X'  =      *~t—  ,  (20.17) 


(20.18) 


Sec.  20]  THE    THEORY   OF   RELATIVITY  197 

These  equations  are  called  Lorentz  transformations.  From  (20.7) 
and  (20.8),  the  inverse  transformations  are  of  the  form 

(20.19) 


(20.20) 


In  order  to  explain  the  meaning  of  these  equations  we  shall  apply 
them  to  some  special  cases.  Let  a  clock  be  situated  at  the  origin 
x'  =0  of  the  primed  system.  It  indicates  a  time  t'.  Then,  from  equation 
(20.20),  it  follows  that 


The  clock  which  is  at  rest  relative  to  its  reference  system  we  call 
the  observer's  dock.  It  can  be  seen  from  (20.21)  that  one  observer, 
comparing  his  clock  with  that  of  another  observer,  will  always  observe 
that  the  latter  clock  is  slow,  i.e.,  that  t'<^t.  If  a  clock  is  situated 
at  the  origin  of  the  unprimed  system  (i.e.,  at  the  point  #  =  0),  the 
transformation  equation  to  the  primed  system  is  of  the  same  form, 

since,  from  (20.18),  we  now  obtain     t'  =          t  —  —  .  This  not  only 


does  not  contradict  (20.21),  but  expresses  that  very  fact:  a  clock 
moving  relative  to  an  observer  is  slow  compared  with  his  own  clock. 

In  the  theory  of  relativity,  a  single  universal  time  does  not  exist 
as  in  Newtonian  mechanics.  It  is  better  to  say  that  the  absolute 
time  of  Newtonian  mechanics  is,  in  actual  fact,  an  approximation, 
correct  only  for  small  relative  velocities  between  clocks.  The  absolute- 
ness of  Newtonian  time  has  sometimes  given  cause  to  regard  it  as 
an  a  priori,  logical  category  independent  of  moving  matter. 

At  any  rate,  Newton,  by  accepting  instantaneous  action  at  a 
distance,  naturally  had  to  consider  time  as  universal  ;  if  we  formally 
put  c  =  oo  in  (20.18),  we  obtain  t'  =t.  The  instantaneous  transmission 
of  signals  would  allow  us  to  synchronize  clocks  in  all  inertial  systems 
independently  of  their  relative  velocities.  In  Newtonian  mechanics, 
gravitational  forces  played  the  part  of  such  instantaneous  signals. 

It  is  sometimes  thought  that,  knowing  the  velocity  of  light  c, 
we  can  introduce  a  correction  into  the  readings  of  clocks  in  different 
inertial  systems  such  that  the  rate  of  time  will  everywhere  be  the 
same.  But  it  is  precisely  equation  (20.21)  that  describes  the  relative 


198  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

passage  of  time  in  both  reference  systems  after  a  correction  has  been 
introduced  for  the  finite  time  of  propagation  of  light.  Time  reduction, 
as  has  already  been  shown,  is  completely  reciprocal.  Consequently, 
it  can  in  no  way  be  accounted  for  by  any  change,  resulting  from 
motion,  in  the  properties  of  clocks.  The  time  reduction  effect  is  purely 
kinematical. 

It  must  also  be  added  that  in  speaking  about  clocks  we  by  no  means 
necessarily  have  in  mind  clocks  which  have  been  made  by  human 
hands;  any  natural  periodic  process  that  gives  a  natural  time  scale 
will  do  as  well,  for  example,  the  oscillations  in  a  light  wave.  It  is 
clear  that  the  physical  properties  of  a  radiating  atom  cannot  in  the 
least  depend  upon  the  inertial  system  in  which  the  atom  is  described. 
This  is  what  gives  us  the  right  to  assert  that  equation  (20.21)  refers 
to  similar  clocks. 

At  the  same  time  we  must  remember  that  it  is  impossible  to  define 
time  without  relation  to  some  periodic  process,  i.e.,  irrespective  of 
motion. 

Relativity  and  objectivity.  The  relativity  of  time  by  110  means 
indicates  a  rejection  of  the  objectivity  of  its  measurement  in  any 
given  system  of  reference.  It  is  entirely  of  no  consequence  what 
observer  is  observing  the  clock.  The  relative  character  of  time  in 
inertial  systems  is  the  only  thing  that  counts.  We  have  all  long  since 
become  accustomed  to  the  relativity  of  the  datum  line  of  time  measure- 
ment related  to  time  zones  (i.e.,  to  the  sphericity  of  the  earth).  The 
theory  of  relativity  teaches  us  that  the  time  scale  is  also  relative. 

The  fact  that  an  objective  concept  may  be  relative  can  be  seen 
from  the  following  example.  In  the  Middle  Ages  it  was  thought 
that  even  direction  in  space  was  absolute,  and  it  was  then  thought 
impossible  to  imagine  that  the  earth  was  spherical  since  it  would 
then  follow  that  our  antipodes  would  have  to  walk  upside  down! 
The  concept  of  "up"  or  "down"  was  related  not  with  the  direction 
of  a  plumb-line  at  a  given  point  on  the  globe,  but  with  certain  other 
categories  characteristic  of  the  ideology  of  the  Middle  Ages.  The 
vertical  directions  in  Moscow  or  Vladivostok  form  a  substantial 
angle  between  each  other,  but  nobody  nowadays  would  think  of 
arguing  about  which  of  them  is  the  more  "vertical."  The  concept 
of  verticality  is  completely  objective  at  every  point  on  the  globe, 
but  is  relative  for  different  points.  In  the  same  way,  time  is  objective 
in  each  inertial  system,  but  is  relative  between  them. 

Contraction  of  the  length  scale.  We  shall  now  consider  the  question 
of  the  measurement  of  length.  In  order  to  find  out  the  length  of 
a  moving  body  ("its  scale"),  we  must  simultaneously  plot  the  co- 
ordinates of  its  ends  in  a  fixed  system.  Obviously,  a  fixed  observer 
has  no  fundamentally  different  means  of  measurement,  for,  otherwise, 
he  would  have  to  stop  the  motion  of  the  scale  (i.e.,  transfer  it  to 
his  reference  system).  If  the  ends  of  the  scale  are  fixed  by  a  stationary 


Sec.  20]  THE   THEORY   OF  RELATIVITY  199 

observer  at  one  time*  we  must  put  £  =  0.  From  (20.17),  there  follows 
an  expression  for  the  length  of  a  moving  scale  Aa;'  measured  by  a 
fixed  observer: 

A*'  =  n      **       -.  (20.22) 


Like    (20.21),    this  equation  has  a  symmetrical  inversion.   If  a 
Amoving"   observer  measures  a   "stationary"  scale,   we   must  put 

V  =-=0;  it  then  turns  out  that     Lx  =  -—  --  ~x      _  .    We  conclude  from 


V'--?' 


(20.22)  that  a  moving  scale  is  shortened  relative  to  a  stationary 
observer.  The  contraction  occurs  in  the  direction  of  motion. 

Lorentz  supposed  that  this  scale  compression  does  not  appear  to 
both  inertial  systems,  but,  for  some  unknown  reason,  occurs  when 
the  scale  moves  relative  to  the  "ether."  Lorentz  and  others  attempted 
in  this  way  to  explain  the  negative  result  of  Michelson's  experiment. 
Yet  the  very  symmetry  of  the  direct  and  inverse  Lorentz  trans- 
formations (20.17)-(20.20)  (they  were  known  before  the  advent  of 
the  theory  of  relativity),  from  which  the  contraction  of  length  follows 
only  as  a  special  case,  shows  convincingly  that  there  is  no  system 
at  absolute  rest  relative  to  an  "ether."  It  may  be  noted  that  by  the 
beginning  of  the  twentieth  century,  the  "ether,"  which  had  been 
introduced  by  Huygens  as  a  medium  that  transmitted  light  oscillations, 
remained  in  physics  simply  as  a  rudimentary  concept.  The  discovery 
and  confirmation  of  the  electromagnetic  nature  of  light  made  the 
hypothetical  elastic  medium  quite  superfluous  (see  Sec.  12).  Only 
the  theory  of  relativity  disclosed  the  real  meaning  of  the  Lorentz 
transformations.  But  then,  many  concepts  regarded  as  absolute  in 
Newtonian  mechanics,  turned  out  to  be  related  to  the  motion  of 
inertial  systems. 

The  formula  lor  addition  of  velocities.  We  shall  now  find  an  equation 
for  the  addition  of  velocities  arising  from  the  Lorentz  transformations. 
Differentiating  (20.17)  and  (20.18)  and  dividing  one  by  the  other, 
we  obtain 

.*£L_F 

*gr^vl=       dtv    .      -  -*--/- .  (20.23) 

dt  x  V  dx  Vvx  v  ' 

~~  1~"" 


*  The  idea  of  the  simultaneity  of  two  operations  performed  in  the  same 
coordinate  system  may  be  uniquely  defined  with  the  aid  of  light  signals.  Indeed, 
observers  at  rest  relative  to  each  other  at  a  given  distance  can  always  check 
their  time  with  the  aid  of  light  signals  by  introducing  a  constant  correction 
for  the  known  time  of  propagation. 


200  BLECTBODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

Noting  that  dy'  =dy  and  dz'  =dz,   we  have  a  transformation  of 
the  velocity  components  perpendicular  to  V: 


dy'         ,         dt   V  *       c8    _     yy  c*    ...,          "  *  *       ,2024) 

-dFs^  =  — — F-35— -  — — v^r"'Vz         I — F5T~'  (20'24) 

* :« 


For  small  velocities,  (20.23)  and  (20.24)  become  the  ordinary 
equations  for  addition  of  velocities.  This  can  be  seen  if  we  let  c  tend 

to  infinity,  i.e.,  by  putting  —  =0. 

It  is  easy  to  see  that  if  v  =  Vv*  +  v$  +  v\  =  c ,  then  likewise 
v'  =c,  i.e.,  the  absolute  value  of  the  velocity  of  light  does  not  change 
in  passing  from  one  inertial  system  to  another.  But  the  separate 
components  of  the  velocity  of  light,  which  are  less  than  c,  may  of 
course  change ;  the  direction  of  a  light  ray  relative  to  different  observers 
differs,  since  there  is  110  absolute  direction  in  space. 

Alteration  of  light.  In  this  connection  let  us  consider 
the  phenomenon  of  the  aberration  of  light.  Astronomical 
aberration,  or  the  deflection  of  light,   consists  in  the 
\          fact  that  stars  describe  ellipses  in  the  sky  in  the  course 
\         of  a  year.  Their  origin  is  easy  to  explain :  the  velocity 
\        of  the  earth,  in  annual  motion,  combines  differently 
\       with  the  velocity   of  the   light   emitted   by   the   star 
\      (Fig.  31).  If  the  velocity  vector  of  the  starlight  relative 
\    to  the  sun  is  ES  then  the  resultant  direction  of  the 


5    velocity,  for  one  position  of  the  earth,  is  ETl  and,  in 
Fig.  31        half  a  year's  time,  ET2.  These  directions  are  projected 
on  different  points  of  the  celestial  sphere  so  that  in 
the  course  of  a  year  a  star  describes   a  closed   ellipse.  In  angular 

units,    the   semi  major    axis   of  the    ellipse  is  always  equal  to  — 

V  1 

where  V  is  the  velocity  of  the  earth.  —  =  1QOQO  =  20". 25. 

We  may  ask  the  question:  Why  does  not  the  velocity  of  light 
in  Michelson's  experiment  combine  with  the  earth's  velocity  but 
remains  equal  to  c,  while  the  phenomenon  of  aberration  shows  that 
velocities  combine  (we  note  that  Michelson's  experiment  was  also 
performed  with  an  extra-terrestrial  source  of  light).  The  explanation 
is  that  in  Michelson's  experiment  it  was  the  absolute  value  of  the 
velocity  of  light  c  that  was  measured  (from  the  path  difference  of 
the  rays),  while  in  the  aberration  of  light  there  is  a  change  in  the 
direction  of  the  velocity  of  light  as  a  result  of  the  combination  of 
its  components  with  the  velocity  of  the  earth.  Considering  that  the 
velocity  of  light  relative  to  the  sun  is  perpendicular  to  the  plane 


Sec.  20]  THE   THEORY   OF   RELATIVITY  201 

of  the  earth's  orbit,  we  must  put  v*  =  0,  vy—c,  vz  =  Q  into  (20.23) 
and  (20.24).  Then  the  components  of  the  velocity  of  light  relative 
to  the  earth  are 


And,  in  accordance  with  Michelson's  experiment,  v'x2-{-v'y2=c2.  The 
direction  of  the  projection  of  the  velocity  of  light  onto  the  plane 
of  the  earth's  orbit  (ecliptic)  is  reversed  in  the  course  of  half  a  year, 
which  is  the  reason  why  aberration  occurs. 

Similar  equations  are  obtained  in  the  more  complicated  case  when 
the  rays  from  the  star  are  not  perpendicular  to  the  plane  of  the 
ecliptic.  They  coincide  with  the  equations  that  follow  from  a  simple 

F3 
addition  of  velocities  if  terms  of  the  order  — -=-  are  neglected. 

c 

Before  the  theory  of  relativity  was  put  forward,  it  was  wrongly 
supposed  that  the  aberration  of  light  contradicted  Michelson's  experi- 
ment. 

Fizeau's  experiment.  Fizeau's  experiment,  which  determined  the 
velocity  of  light  in  a  moving  medium,  was  also  believed  to  contradict 
Michelson's  experiment.  Fizeau's  method  was  this.  A  beam  of  light 
was  divided  into  two  parts  using  a  half-silvered  mirror  (Fig.  32). 
These  beams  were  passed  through  tubes  with  flowing  water;  one 
beam  in  the  direction  of  flow  and  the  other  in  the  opposite  direction. 
For  comparison,  the  same  beams  were  passed  through  tubes  in  which 
the  water  was  at  rest.  By  subsequent  reflections  the  beams  once 
again  combined  and  cancelled  each  other  when  the  path  difference 
between  them  was  equal  to  an  integral  number  of  half  wavelengths 
(i.e.,  when  they  were  in  opposite 
phase).  Coherence  between  them  was 
obtained  due  to  the  fact  that  they 
both  came  from  the  same  source.  In 
still  water,  the  path  difference  was  chosen 
so  that  the  rays  were  reinforced,  i.e.,  the  ~* 
phase  difference  was  equal  to  an  even 
number  of  half  wavelengths.  The  path  Fig.  32 

difference  in  flowing  water  was  varied. 

Since  the  frequency  of  the  light  and  the  tube  lengths  remained  un- 
changed, the  change  in  path  length  indicated  a  change  in  the  velocity 
of  light  relative  to  the  tubes. 

First  of  all,  we  note  that  the  result  of  Fizeau's  experiment  in  no 
way  contradicts  the  general  ideas  about  the  relativity  of  motion. 
A  reference  system  fixed  in  flowing  water  is  not  equivalent  to  a 
system  fixed  in  the  tube,  if  we  are  studying  the  propagation  of  light 
in  water. 


202  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

Since  the  velocity  of  light  in  water  is  equal  to  — ,  where  v  is  the  re- 
fractive index  of  the  water,  the  general  equation  for  the  addition 
of  velocities  (20.23)  shows  that  —  does  not  remain  a  constant  quantity 

when  passing  to  another  coordinate  system.  At  the  same  time,  we 
cannot  use  the  simple  velocity-addition  equation,  because  the  de- 
nominator of  equation  (20.23)  differs  from  unity  by —  (F  is  the  veloc- 
ity of  the  water).  Considering  that  V<^c  and  expanding  the  de- 
nominator in  a  series  up  to  the  linear  term  inclusive,  we  find  the  change 
in  the  velocity  of  light  in  moving  water  (see  exercise  1): 


It  was  precisely  this  value,  which  differs  from  that  given  by  the 
simple  velocity-addition  law,  that  was  obtained  by  Fizeau.  Since 

Michelson  measured  c  and  Fizeau  measured—,  there  is  no  contra- 
diction between  them. 

Interval.  Despite  the  fact  that  x  and  t  are  changed  separately  by 
the  Lorentz  transformations  we  can  construct  a  quantity  which 
remains  invariant  (unchanged).  It  is  easy  to  verify  that  this  property 
is  possessed  by  the  difference  c2t2  —  x2.  Indeed, 

T72~,'2 

c2*/2  +  -     ?  -+  2Vx't' 
----  c     ,,-  -  -, 


x'z  +  V*t'z  +  2  Vx't' 

X*  =  -a 


or 

c*t*  —  x2^  c2*'2  —  x'2  =-  s2  .  (20.25) 

The  quantity  s  is  called  the  interval  between  two  events;  that 
which  occurred  at  the  coordinate  origin  x  =  Q  and  initial  time  £  =  0, 
and  another  event  that  occurred  at  the  point  x  and  time  t. 

The  word  "event"  may  also  be  regarded  in  its  most  common 
everyday  sense  provided  that  its  coordinates  and  time  may  be  defined. 
If  the  first  event  is  not  related  to  the  origin  of  the  coordinate  system 
and  the  initial  instant,  then 

^  -  c2  (*t  -  tj*  -  (x2  -  xj2  -  c2  (*;  -  t[)2-  (x'2  -  x[)2  .  (20.26) 


Sec.  20] 


THE   THEORY   OF  BELATIVITY 


203 


Considerable  importance  is  attached  to  the  interval  between  two 
infinitely  close  events: 


-  dx* . 


(20.27) 


'    A*       i 

Absolute 
future 


It  is  not  at  all  necessary  to  consider  that  both  events  occurred  on 
the  abscissa.  Since  dy'^dy  and  dz'  =  dz,  the  interval  is  always  in- 
variant : 

ds*  -  c*dt*  -  dx*  -  dy*  -  dz*  =  c*dt*  -  dl*  =  c*dt'*  -  dl'* .     (20.28) 

The  interval,  written  in  the  form  (20.28),  is  not  related  to  any  definite 
direction  of  velocity. 

Space  and  time  intervals.  The  interval  provides  for  a  very  vivid 
way  of  studying  various  possible  space -time 
relationships  between  two  events.  Let  the  spatial 
distance  between  the  points  at  which  the  events 
occurred  be  taken  along  the  abscissa,  and  the 
interval  of  time  between  them,  along  the  ordinate 
axis  (Fig.  33).  To  begin  with,  let  ct  >  I ,  for  example, 

$2  =  C2£2  „  I*  (20.29) 

We  shall  plot  the  values  of  ct  and  I  corresponding 
to  two  definite  events  measured  in  quite  different 
inertial  systems.  No  matter  what  values  are  ob- 
tained as  a  result  of  these  measurements  of  ct  and 
Z,  the  interval  s  (20.29)  between  the  events  is  the 
same.  It  follows  that  the  locus  of  the  points,  for 
all  possible  spatial  distances  I  and  time  intervals  Fig.  33 

ct,  is  an  equilateral  hyperbola  s2^c2t2  —  I2.  Two 
branches  of  the  hyperbola  are  possible :  one  lies  in  the  past  relative 
to  the  event  that  occurred  at  £  =  0,  #--^0,  while  the  other  is  completely 
in  the  future.  It  is  easy  to  see  that  such  a  relationship  inevitably 
results  if  the  events  are  causally  related.  Let  the  events,  in  some 
reference  system,  be  known  to  occur  in  the  same  place,  for  example, 
sowing  and  reaping.  To  this  system  there  corresponds  the  point  0 
(sowing)  and  the  point  A  (reaping).  But  since  all  points  of  the  given 
branch  of  the  hyperbola  lie  at  £>0,  the  sowing  in  any  reference 
system  must  occur  earlier  than  reaping. 

We  can  also  proceed  from  causally  related  events  which  in  our 
coordinate  system  do  not  occur  at  one  point  of  space,  such  as  firing 
and  hitting  the  target  (they  occur  at  one  point  in  a  system  fixed 
in  the  bullet).  To  the  system  fixed  in  the  bullet  there  now  corresponds 
a  vertical  section  OA  in  Fig.  33,  while  to  our  system  there  corresponds 
some  inclined  line  drawn  from  the  origin  to  a  point  on  the  same 
upper  hyperbola.  Thus,  here  too,  the  second  event — that  of  hitting 
the  target — occurs  after  the  shot  in  any  reference  system. 


204  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

If  the  velocity  of  the  bullet  (or  any  material  particle)  is  v,  then 
02._.c2g2  —  J2>o.  it  necessarily  follows  from  the  inequality  (20.29) 
that  l  =  vt<d  or  v<c,  if  a  reference  system  exists  in  which  both 
events  occurred  at  a  single  point  in  space.  For  this  reason,  the  velocity 
of  any  material  particle  can  only  be  less  than  the  velocity  of  light  c. 

The  region  above  the  first  asymptote  is  called  "absolute  future" 
relative  to  the  initial  event. 

Although  the  example  of  a  bullet  hitting  a  target  may  appear 
to  be  a  special  case,  in  actual  fact  the  foregoing  reasoning  may  be 
used  for  all  cases  when  an  effect  is  related  to  a  cause  by  some  material- 
transfer  process,  either  in  the  form  of  a  particle  or  in  the  form  of 
a  wave  packet.  A  reference  system  may  be  related  to  moving  matter, 
and  therefore  any  velocity  of  material  transport  satisfies  the  inequality 


Consequently,  the  theory  of  relativity  never  contradicts  the  objective 
nature  of  causality.  And  it  is  precisely  the  sequence  of  cause  and 
effect  which  determines  the  direction  of  time. 

We  can  also  consider  other  pairs  of  events.  For  example,  let  one 
event  occur  on  the  sun  and  the  other,  five  minutes  later,  on  the 
earth.  Light  travels  from  the  sun  to  the  earth  in  eight  minutes; 
for  the  two  given  events  ct<l,  s2=-c2t2  —  12<Q.  For  purely  physical 
reasons,  such  events  can  in  no  way  be  related  causally  because  the 
velocity  of  transport  of  matter  does  not  exceed  c.  For  such  events, 
the  interval  term  Z2  is  not  equal  to  zero  in  any  system  of  reference. 
And  so  there  is  no  coordinate  system,  relative  to  which  events  related 
by  an  imaginary  (s2<0)  interval  occur  at  a  single  point  of  space. 
Yet,  on  the  other  hand,  their  time  sequence  has  not  been  defined: 
coordinate  systems  exist  in  which  the  first  event  occurs  before  the 
second,  and  there  are  systems  in  which  the  second  event  occurs 
before  the  first.*  Thus,  the  theory  of  relativity  denies  the  absolute 
nature  of  the  simultaneity  of  two  events  occurring  at  different  points 
in  space  and  separated  by  an  imaginary  interval.  0  and  B  in  Fig.  33 
are  such  events.  B  lies  on  the  hyperbola  which,  relative  to  O,  belongs 
partly  to  the  future  and  partly  to  the  past.  But  0  and  B  can  in  no 
way  be  related  causally,  since  no  interaction  can  arrive  at  B  from  O 
instantaneously. 

Hence,  the  relativity  of  simultaneity  does  not  contradict  the  absolute 
nature  of  causality. 

The  region  between  the  asymptotes  is  called  absolutely  distant, 
relative  to  the  coordinate  origin. 

The  light  cone.  The  asymptotes  to  the  hyperbola  l=ct  are  of  special 
interest.  For  them,  s  =  0. 


*  For  example,  the  second  event  occurred  earlier  than  the  first  relative 
to  any  system  moving  in  the  direction  from  the  earth  to  the  sun  with  a  velocity 

exceeding—  c,  as  may  easily  be  seen  from  (21.20). 

o 


Sec.  20]  THE    THEORY    OF   RELATIVITY  205 

The  relationship  l  =  ct  holds  for  two  events  related  by  an  electro- 
magnetic signal,  for  example,  for  the  emission  and  absorption  of 
a  radio  signal.  For  these  two  events,  5  =  0  in  all  reference  systems, 
because  the  velocity  of  light  is  invariant  and  we  must  always  have 
that  l  —  ct.  Since  the  curve  in  Fig.  33  in  actual  fact  corresponds  to 
3+1  dimensions  (three  spatial  arid  one  time)  instead  of  a  plane,  the 
locus  of  zero  intervals  is  picturesquely  called  "a  light  cone." 

Proper  time.  The  concept  of  proper  time  of  a  particle  is  closely 
related  to  that  of  interval.  This  is  the  time  measured  in  a  coordinate 
system  fixed  to  a  particle.  The  displacement  of  the  particle  relative 
to  this  system  is  equal  to  zero  by  definition.  Hence,  the  proper  time 
that  has  elapsed  between  any  two  positions  of  the  particle  is  pro- 
portional to  the  interval  calculated  for  these  two  positions: 


(20.30) 

Here,  v  is  the  velocity  of  the  particle  relative  to  an  arbitrarily  chosen 
reference  system  in  which  the  interval  of  time  is  equal  to  dt.  From 
(20.30)  and  also  (20.21),  the  proper  time  is  always  the  shortest. 
For  finite  time  intervals 

tQ=  (  dt  1/1  -  ~  <  f  dt,  (20.31) 

J  t  C  J 

i.e., 

tQ^t.  (20.32) 

From  (20.32)  there  follows  a  consequence  with  which,  at  first 
sight,  it  is  difficult  to  agree.  Characteristic  time  is  the  time  which 
determines  the  rhythm  of  life  processes  in  the  human  organism.  And 
for  this  reason  if  an  imaginary  traveller  leaves  the  earth  with  a  velocity 
close  to  that  of  light,  and  later  returns  to  the  earth,  then,  in  accordance 
with  (20.32),  he  will  have  grown  less  old  than  a  person,  initially 
of  the  same  age,  remaining  on  the  earth. 

The  asymmetry  between  the  traveller  and  person  that  remained 
on  the  earth  is  explained  by  the  fact  that  the  traveller  was  not  moving 
inertially — he  first  travelled  away  and  then  returned.  For  this,  it 
was  necessary  for  him  to  turn  about  in  some  way,  i.e.,  to  lose  the 
property  of  inertiality  retained  by  observers  on  the  earth.  It  may  be 
noted  that  the  time  spent  in  turning  may  make  up  an  infinitesimally 
small  amount  of  the  time  of  travel,  if  the  journey  itself  is  sufficiently 
long.  This  is  why  the  turning  operation  cannot  in  any  way  re-establish 
equality  between  t  and  £0.  But  this  operation  is  necessary  in  order 
that  the  comparison  between  the  ages  of  both  observers  can  be 
performed,  i.e.,  to  return  them  to  the  same  point  of  space  and  to 
a  single  coordinate  system.  Thus,  disregarding  the  "striking"  formu- 
lation of  the  traveller  experiment,  we  may  say  that  time  in  a  non- 


206  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

inertial  system  may  differ  to  any  extent  from  the  time  in  an  inertial 
system,  even  though  the  noninertial  system  may  deviate  from 
inertiality  for  an  extremely  short  time. 

The  case  of  the  human  traveller  is,  of  course,  purely  imaginary, 
technically  speaking.  But  a  relationship  of  the  type  (20.32)  is  observed 
in  the  decay  of  mesons  in  cosmic  rays.  The  mean  life  of  a  positive 
Tc-meson,  of  mass  273  electronic  masses,  in  decaying  to  a  jA-meson, 
of  mass  207  electronic  masses,  together  with  a  neutral  particle,  is 
2  x  10~8  sec  (the  negative  Tt-meson  is  most  often  captured  by  nuclei). 
This  time  is  measured  for  a  7u-meson  stopped  in  the  substance,  i.e., 
it  is  proper  time.  The  velocity  of  the  meson,  like  that  of  any  other 
particle,  does  not  exceed  c.  If  the  relationship  (20.32),  expressing 
the  relativity  of  time,  did  not  exist,  then  a  rapid  re-meson  with  a 
velocity  of  the  order  of  c  would  on  the  average  travel  through 
c  x  2  x  10~8  cm  =  600  cm  of  air.  Actually,  the  mean  path  of  a  7u-meson 
is  considerably  greater  due  to  the  fact  that  its  life-time,  in  a  co- 
ordinate system  fixed  in  the  air,  is  considerably  greater  than  its 
proper  life-time. 

Frequency  and  wave-vector  transformations  of  electromagnetic 
waves.  Proceeding  from  invariants,  we  may  find  out  in  what  way 
the  noninvariant  quantities  involved  are  transformed  in  passing 
from  one  reference  system  to  another.  We  shall  now  show  that  the 
transformation  properties  of  wave-vector  components  and  frequency 
are  those  of  coordinates  and  time. 

In  order  to  prove  this,  it  is  sufficient  to  note  that  the  phase  of  a 
wave  is  invariant.  Indeed,  the  phase  characterizes  some  event,  for 
example,  the  fading  of  the  electric  and  magnetic  fields  at  a  certain 
instant  of  time  and  at  a  certain  point  in  space.  If  we  examine  this 
wave  in  another  coordinate  system,  then  the  coordinates  and  time 
(corresponding  to  this  event)  will  have  other  values,  though  the  event 
itself  cannot  change,  of  course.  This  is  easy  to  understand  if  we 
imagine  that  the  electric  and  magnetic  fields  are  measured  by  the 
readings  of  some  inertialess  device.  Two  such  devices,  situated  at 
the  same  point  of  space  at  a  certain  instant,  but  in  motion  relative 
to  each  other,  must  together  indicate  the  zero  value  of  the  field. 
Otherwise,  the  coordinate  system  in  which  the  electromagnetic  field 
is  equal  to  zero  will  in  some  way  be  distinguished  from  the 
others. 

From  (17.21)  and  (17.22),  the  expression  for  the  phase  of  a  wave  is 

fy  =  xkx  +  yky  +  zJcz  —  <*t . 

This  quantity  must  be  invariant  in  transforming  to  another  coordinate 
system.  Let  us  express  x'  and  t'  in  accordance  with  (20.17)  and  (20.18) 
and  substitute  them  into  the  condition  of  invariance  of  phase : 


Sec.  20]  THE  THBOBY  OF  RELATIVITY  207 

xkx  +  y  ky  +  zkz  —  u>t  =  x'  k'x  +  y'  kr'  +  z'  k^  —  co'  t'  = 


Now  comparing  the  coefficients  of  x,  y,  z,  and  t,  we  obtain  the 
transformation  equations  for  the  wave-vector  components  and 
frequency: 

' 


(20-33) 

(20.34) 
(20.35) 

(20.36) 


These  are  entirely  analogous  to  equations   (20.19)   and   (20.20). 

The  longitudinal  and  transverse  Doppler  effect.  If  the  frequency 
of  a  source  of  light  with  respect  to  its  own  coordinate  system  is  equal 
to  co',  and  the  angle  between  its  velocity  and  the  line  of  sight  is 

equal  to  &',  so  that  k'x  =  lc'  cos  &'  =  — cos  <9-',  then  we  obtain  from 
(20.36) 

c/(l  H cos^'J 

co  =  —  \r_LTg5.     7-  .  (20.37) 


In  particular,  if  the  source  moves  along  the  line  of  sight  (i.e.,  towards 
the  observer), 

(20.38) 


F2 

c2 


These  equations  describe  the  well-known  Doppler  effect,  by  means 
of  which  the  radial  velocities  of  stars  are  measured.  The  square  root 
in  the  denominator  gives  a  correction  introduced  by  the  theory  of 
relativity  into  the  formula  usually  used. 

If  the  velocity  of  the  source  is  perpendicular  to  the  ray,  then, 
from  the  requirement  that  kx  =  0,  we  also  obtain  a  change  in  frequency, 

although  it  is  of  second  order  with  respect  to  —  : 

c 


208  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  II 

(20.39) 


This  transverse  effect  was  observed  by  Ives  in  the  radiation  from 
moving  ions  (in  canal  rays)  when  the  ratio  —  was  sufficient  to  detect 

the  frequency  displacement  spectroscopically.  This  gives  direct 
experimental  proof  of  the  contraction  of  the  time  scale  in  relative 
motion. 

A  comparison  of  inertial  forces  and  the  force  of  gravitation.  Let 
us  now  investigate  the  transformation  from  inertial  to  noninertial 
systems.  We  define  the  latter  as  a  system  in  which  there  are  inertial 
forces. 

All  inertial  forces  have  the  common  property  that  they  are  pro- 
portional to  the  mass  of  the  body.  Among  the  interaction  forces, 
only  one  force  is  known  Avhich  possesses  that  property — this  is  the 
force  of  Newtonian  gravitation.  The  fact  that  gravitational  force 
is  proportional  to  the  mass  of  the  body  is  very  well  known,  though 
very  surprising  all  the  same.  The  mass  of  a  body  may  be  defined 
from  Newton's  Second  Law  when  any  kind  of  force  (electric,  magnetic, 
elastic,  etc.)  acts  on  the  body.  It  is  therefore  very  difficult  to  under- 
stand why  the  force  of  interaction  between  bodies,  namely,  the 
force  of  gravitation,  is  proportional  to  that  very  mass  involved  in 
the  expression  for  Newton's  law  [see  (2.1)].  As  is  well  known,  all 
other  interaction  forces  are  independent  of  mass. 

In  addition,  the  very  form  of  the  gravitation  law  itself  somewhat 
contradicts  our  physical  intuition — in  accordance  with  this  law, 
gravitational  forces  are  transmitted  over  any  distance  instantaneously. 

Einstein  called  attention  to  the  profound  significance  of  the  analogy 
between  inertial  forces  and  the  force  of  gravitation.  In  certain  cases 
these  forces  are  indistinguishable  in  their  action.  For  example,  when 
an  aeroplane  performs  a  turn  and,  in  doing  so,  inclines  the  plane 
of  its  wings,  the  passengers  feel,  as  before,  that  the  direction  of  gravity 
acting  on  them  is  perpendicular  to  the  floor  of  the  cabin.  In  this  case, 
a  resultant  force  consisting  of  gravity  and  a  centrifugal  force  operates 
like  the  force  of  gravity — they  are  both  proportional  to  the  mass 
and  act  on  all  the  bodies  inside  the  aircraft  in  the  same  way.  It  is 
physically  impossible  to  separate  these  two  forces  without  con- 
sidering objects  outside  the  aircraft. 

When  a  lift  begins  to  rise  the  gravitational  force  is,  as  it  were, 
increased — the  force  of  inertia  due  to  the  acceleration  of  the  lift 
is  added  to  it. 

In  these  examples  (almost  trivial),  the  inertial  and  gravitational 
forces  are  equivalent  "on  a  small  scale,"  that  is,  in  certain  small 
regions  of  space.  In  large  regions,  there  is  a  certain  essential  difference 


SeC.  20]  THE    THEORY    OF    RELATIVITY  209 

between  the  behaviour  of  inertial  forces  and  gravity.  The  latter 
diminishes  with  the  distance  from  the  centre  of  attraction,  while 
inertial  forces  either  remain  constant  or  increase  without  limit.  Thus, 
centrifugal  force  increases  in  proportion  to  the  distance  from  the 
axis  of  rotation.  The  force  of  inertia  in  a  coordinate  system  fixed 
in  an  accelerating  lift  is  the  same  at  any  distance  away  from  the  lift. 

The  general  theory  o!  relativity.  The  basic  idea  of  Einstein's  gravi- 
tational theory  is  that  motion  in  a  gravitational  field  is  the  same 
sort  of  inertia!  motion  as  the  accelerating  of  passengers  relative 
to  a  braking  carriage.  It  is  precisely  for  this  reason  that  acceleration 
due  to  the  action  of  gravity  does  not  depend  on  the  mass  of  the  body. 
In  order  to  understand  why  the  force  of  gravitation,  as  opposed 
to  the  well-known  inertial  forces,  becomes  zero  at  an  infinite  distance 
away  from  attracting  bodies,  we  must  assume  that  the  space  close 
to  the  attracting  bodies  does  not  have  the  geometrical  properties 
of  Euclidean  space.  In  other  words,  we  must  take  it  that  space  and 
time  obey  non-Euclidean  geometrical  laws  in  the  sense  of  the  ideas 
first  developed  by  Lobachevsky  and  later  by  Riemann.  Free  motion 
in  such  non- Euclidean  (Riemamiiaii)  space  is  curvilinear.  However, 
since  it  is  precisely  the  i>roperties  of  space  itself  that  determine 
the  curvature,  acceleration  of  bodies  does  not  depend  upon  their 
masses  (if  we  can  neglect  the  effect  of  the  latter  on  the  gravitational 
field)  in  the  same  sense  as  the  field  of  a  falling  stone  does  not  affect 
the  gravitational  field  of  the  earth. 

Thus,  gravitational  and  inertial  forces  are  indistinguishable  in 
small  regions  of  space.  In  such  regions,  a  noniiiertial  coordinate 
system  is  equivalent  to  an  inertial  system  in  which  an  additional 
gravitational  field  is  operative,  with  the  same  acceleration  of  falling 
bodies  which,  in  the  noninertial  system,  is  ascribed  to  inertial  forces. 
For  this  reason,  this  theory  of  gravitation  is  also  called  the  general 
theory  of  relativity  in  contrast  to  the  special  theory  of  relativity, 
which  considers  only  inertial  systems. 

Since  the  equations  of  motion  in  the  genera]  theory  of  relativity 
(in  the  same  way  as  all  equations  of  motion)  are  formulated  in  differ- 
ential form,  equivalence  on  a  small  scale  is  quite  sufficient  for  writing 
down  the  equations. 

However,  we  must  remember  that  a  rotating  coordinate  system 
is  not,  as  a  whole,  equivalent  to  a  gravitational  field.  Indeed,  a  rotating 
system  can,  generally,  only  be  determined  for  distances  from  the 
axis  of  rotation  for  which  the  velocity  of  rotation  is  less  than  that 
of  light.  This  is  why  a  rotating  system  is  not  equivalent  to  a  noii- 
rotating  system,  which  has  meaning  in  infinite  space,  too. 

The  mechanics  of  Einstein's  general  theory  of  relativity  is  con- 
siderably more  complicated  than  Newtonian  mechanics, -'which  is 
included  in  this  theory  as  a  limiting  case.  But  Einstein's  theory  is 
free  from  the  gnosiological  concepts,  so  alien  to  us,  of  the  hypothesis 

14  -  0060 


210  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

of  action  at  a  distance.  The  properties  of  space  and  time  in  Einstein's 
theory  are  studied  in  inseparable  unity  with  the  motion  of  matter, 
and  not  only  as  a  requisite  for  the  motion  of  matter.  Abstract  space 
and  time,  which  in  Newtonian  physics  were  sometimes  regarded  as 
almost  belonging  to  logical,  a  priori  categories,  do  not  exist  in  Ein- 
stein's gravitational  theory — in  the  general  theory  of  relativity,  space 
and  time  are  endowed  with  physical  properties. 

The  consequences  of  Einstein's  gravitational  theory.  Einstein's 
refined  gravitational  theory  leads  to  a  series  of  results  that  may  be 
verified  by  astronomical  observation. 

1)  The  perihelion  of  Mercury  should  rotate  through  43  *  per  century. 
This  is  in  excellent  agreement  with  astronomical  facts. 

2)  Rays  of  light  from  stars  passing  near  the  limb  of  the  sun  should 
be  displaced  towards  it,  since  light  is  not  propagated  rectilinearly 
in  non-Euclidean  space.  This  result  also  agrees  closely  with  accurate 
observations  made  during  solar  eclipses. 

3)  Spectral  lines  in  heavy  stars  should  be  shifted  towards  the  red 
end  of  the  spectrum,  and  this,  too,  is  found  to  be  the  case. 

For  the  first  time  in  the  history  of  science,  the  general  theory 
of  relativity  made  it  possible  to  pose  the  cosmological  problem,  i.e., 
the  problem  of  the  structure  and  development  of  the  Universe. 
The  present  state  of  the  cosmological  problem  is  far  from  a  solution 
due  to  insufficient  astronomical  data  and  to  the  mathematical  diffi- 
culties associated  with  Einstein's  gravitational  equations.  It  should 
be  noted  that  before  the  general  theory  of  relativity,  the  cosmological 
problem  was  posed  in  a  purely  speculative  way;  Einstein's  theory 
indicated  the  path  for  scientific  investigation  and  has  led  to  a  series 
of  important  results. 

Exercises 

1)  Calculate  the  change  in  the  velocity  of  light  propagated  through  flowing 
water  in  Fizoau's  experiment. 


Disregarding  the  theory  of  relativity,  the  result  would  be  u  J-  =  --  ±  V . 

2)  Obtain  a  precise  equation  for  the  aberration  of  light,  with  an  arbitrary 
inclination  &  of  the  ray  of  the  ecliptic. 

cos  0- 

Answer:  cos&'^- =- . 

1 cos  & 

c 

3)  Write  down  the  equations  for  the  Lorentz  transformations  for  an  arbitrary 
direction  of  the  velocity  V  relative  to  a  coordinate  system. 


Sec.  21]  RELATIVISTIC    DYNAMICS  211 

rV  r'V 

In  our  equations  x  —-  —^-  ,   .c'  =- •  —  .  The  component  perpendicular  to  the 

velocity  is 

,        V(rv)         ,      VJr'V) 
F2        -  r  y*        • 

From  (20.17) 

21-V, 
^V        _F 

V    ~   "I/          72"  ' 
[/  ^2" 

y 

Multiplying  this    equation    by  -==-  and  adding  equations,  we  obtain 


4)  Write  down  the  Lorentz- transformation  equations  for  the  components 
of  acceleration. 

5)  Show  that  the  "four-dimensional  volume  element"  dx  dy  dz  dt  is  invariant 
with  respect  to  a  Lorontz  transformation. 

(f/2  \ i/  /  1/2  \  -i/a 

1  -  -^-1      from   (20.22)   and  dt  =  dt'  1 1  -  ~\ 

from  (20.21),  whence  tho  statement  follows. 

(>)  A  light  beam  is  within  a  solid-angle  element  rfQ.  Show  that  Lorentz 
transformations  leave  the  quantity  co2^Q  invariant. 

Uso  the   result  of  exercise   2:  dQ.  --=-  -2nd  cos  ft. 


Sec.  21.  Relativistic  Dynamics 

Action  for  a  particle  in  the  theory  of  relativity.  The  adjective  rel- 
ativistic  denotes  invariaiiee  with  respect  to  Lorentz  transformations, 
which  invariance  satisfies  the  relativity  principle.  For  example, 
Maxwell's  equations  in  free  space  are  relativistic. 

In  effect,  the  Lorentz  transformation  is  derived  from  the  require- 
ment that  the  equations  of  electrodynamics  remain  invariant.  There- 
fore, the  proof  of  the  relativistic  invariance  of  Maxwell's  equations, 
which  proof  will  be  given  somewhat  later  in  this  section,  is  simply 
in  the  nature  of  a  confirmation. 

The  situation  with  mechanics  is  altogether  different.  Newtonian 
mechanics  satisfies  only  the  Galilean  relativity  principle,  which  holds 
for  velocities  small  compared  with  c.  Therefore,  it  is  necessary  to 
find  equations  of  mechanics  such  that  they  will  be  invariant  with 
respect  to  Lorentz  transformations. 

In  Sec.  10  it  was  shown  how  to  develop  a  mechanics  by  proceeding 
from  the  principle  of  least  action.  And  it  was  found  possible  to  deter- 
mine the  form  of  the  Lagrangian  of  a  free  particle  by  proceeding 
from  two  basic  assumptions  [see  equations  (10.11)-(10.13)]: 

14* 


212  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

1)  Action  is  invariant  to  Galilean  transformations; 

2)  The  Lagrangian  of  a  free  particle  depends  only  on  the  absolute 
value  of  velocity;  the  velocity  vector  v  cannot  be  involved  in  it 
because,  in  the  absence  of  an  external  field,  there  are  no  distinguishable 
directions  (in  space)  relative  to  which  the  vector  v  can  be  given. 

In  relativistic  mechanics  the  first  condition  is  replaced  by  the 
in  variance  to  a  Lorentz  transformation,  while  the  second  condition 
remains  unchanged.  Both  conditions  are  satisfied  by  an  action  function 
of  the  form 

8  =  J  a  ds  =  j  ac  |/1-^  dt  ,  (21.1) 

where  we  have  used  the  relationship  (20.30)  between  ds  and  dt.  Agree- 
ment with  the  first  condition  can  be  seen  from  the  fact  that  action 
is  expressed  in  terms  of  interval  only,  while  agreement  with  the 
second  condition  is  obvious.  No  other  invariant  quantities  can  be 
constructed  from  dl  and  dt  except  the  interval,  whence  the  uniqueness 
of  the  choice  (21.1). 

The  Lagrangian  for  a  free  particle.  In  order  to  define  the  constant  a, 
we  examine  the  limiting  form  of  (21.1)  for  a  small  particle  velocity. 
If  v<^c, 


From  the  definition  of  the  Lagrangian  (10.2) 

S  =  JLdt  (21.3) 

it  follows  that  the  Lagrangian  is 

____  2 

(21.4) 


The  first  term  in  (21.4)  is  constant  and  can  be  omitted  as  not  appearing 
in  Lagrange's  equation  [see  (10.8)].  The  second  term  should  be 
compared  with  the  Lagrangian  for  a  free  particle  in  Newtonian 
mechanics  : 

L=2f.  (21.5) 

Whence 

K^  —  mc.  (21.6) 

The  meaning  of  m  here  is  the  mass  of  the  particle  measured  in  a 
coordinate  system  in  which  the  particle  is  at  rest  (or  infinitely  near 
rest).  Thus,  by  its  very  definition,  the  quantity  m  is  relativistically 
invariant.  Finally,  we  have  the  Lagrangian  in  the  form 

-        .  (21.7) 


Sec.  21]  RELATIVISTIC    DYNAMICS  213 

Momentum  in  relativistic  mechanics.  From  (21.17),  we  immediately 
obtain  an  expression  for  momentum  in  the  theory  of  relativity: 

(21.8) 


As  required,  at  small  particle  velocities  it  reduces  to  the  Newtonian 
expression  p  =  rav. 

Sometimes  the  quantity  — (i.p..?  the  proportionality  factor 

V 1  —  02/c2 

between  velocity  and  momentum)  is  called  the  mass  of  motion  of 
the  particle,  as  opposed  to  the  rest  mass  m.  To  avoid  confusion  we 
will  not  use  the  expression  "mass  of  motion,"  and  will  take  the 
term  mass  to  mean  the  quantity  m  which  is  relativistically  invariant 
by  definition. 

The  limiting  nature  of  the  velocity  of  light.  The  limiting  character 
of  the  velocity  of  light,  about  which  we  have  already  spoken  in 
Sec.  20,  can  be  seen  from  equation  (21.8).  As  the  velocity  of  a  particle 
approaches  the  velocity  of  light,  its  momentum  tends  to  infinity. 
The  only  exception  is  a  particle  whose  mass  is  equal  to  zero.  Its 
momentum,  written  in  the  form  (21.8),  gives  the  indeterminate  form 
0/0  for  v  —  c  and  can  remain  finite.  But  then  the  velocity  of  this 
particle  must  always  equal  c.  This  property,  as  we  know,  is  relativist- 
ically invariant  since  the  velocity  of  light  is  the  same  in  all  inertial 
systems.  The  momentum  of  such  a  particle  must  be  given  in- 
dependently of  its  velocity  [and  not  according  to  equation  (21.8)], 
since  the  velocity  is  already  determined  and  is  equal  to  c.  A  velocity 
greater  than  c  is  utterly  meaningless  because  it  involves  an  imaginary 
quantity  for  momentum. 

Energy  in  the  theory  of  relativity.  Let  us  now  determine  the  energy 
of  a  particle.  In  accordance  with  the  general  definition  for  energy  (4.4), 


T 
-Z,= 


y-s 


Equation  (21.9)  once  again  confirms  the  limiting  nature  of  the  veloc- 
ity of  light.  When  v  tends  to  c,  the  energy  of  the  particle  <f  tends  to 
infinity.  In  other  words,  an  infinitely  large  quantity  of  work  must  be 
performed  in  order  to  impart  to  the  particle  a  velocity  equal  to  that 
of  light. 

Best  energy.  From  equation  (21.9),  the  energy  of  a  particle  at  rest 
is  equal  to  me2.  Let  us  apply  this  equation  to  a  complex  particle  ca- 
pable of  spontaneously  decaying  into  two  or  three  particles.  Many 
atomic  nuclei  and  also  unstable  particles  (mesons)  are  capable  of  such 
disintegration.  In  the  disintegration,  the  energy  must  be  conserved, 


214  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part    II 

<?  =  <?1  +  <f2,  (21.10) 

because  disintegration  is  spontaneous,  caused  not  by  any  external 
interaction,  but  by  some  internal  motion  in  the  complex  particle. 
The  Lagrangiaii  for  this  motion  is  not  known  explicitly,  but  in  any 
case  it  cannot  involve  time.  Therefore,  the  energy  of  a  complex  particle 
before  disintegration  is  equal  to  the  energy  of  the  two  particles  formed 
after  the  disintegration,  when  there  is  no  longer  any  interaction 
between  them. 

The  energy  of  all  these  particles  is  expressed  in  accordance  with 
equation  (21.9),  as  applied  to  all  free  particles  (whether  simple  or 
complex)  when  their  motion  is  considered  as  a  whole.  The  only  possible 
form  of  the  Lagrangian  for  such  motion  is  (21.7),  from  which  it  follows 
that  the  energy  is  in  the  form  (21.9).  Substituting  this  expression  in 
(21.10)  and  noting  that  the  initial  particle  was  at  rest,  we  obtain 

..  (21.11) 


But  the  terms  S^  and  <^2  on  the  right  are  correspondingly  greater  than 
W]C2  and  ra2c2,  whence  we  obtain  the  fundamental  inequality 

m^m1  +  m2.  (21.12) 

Hence  the  mass  of  a  complex  particle  capable  of  spontaneous  dis- 
integration is  greater  than  the  sum  of  the  masses  of  its  component 
particles.  In  Newtonian  mechanics,  the  mass  characterizing  the  motion 
of  the  system  as  a  whole  [see  the  last  term  of  equation  (4.17)]  is  equal 
to  the  sum  of  the  masses  of  the  component  particles. 

If  we  define  the  difference 

_mc*  (21.13) 


as  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  particle  (for  small  energies  it  reduces  to 
T  =  -^Tr- 1  and  call  me2  the  rest  energy,  then  it  can  be  seen  from  the  law 

of  conservation  of  energy  (21.11)  that  part  of  the  rest  energy  of  a 
complex  particle  is  converted  into  kinetic  energy  of  the  component 
particles,  and  part  is  converted  into  their  rest  energy.  Only  the  total 
energies  6\  and  not  the  kinetic  energies  27,  satisfy  the  conservation 
law  because  the  kinetic  energy  of  a  complex  particle  as  a  whole  is 
equal  to  zero  before  disintegration  and  cannot  be  equal  to  the  essen- 
tially positive  kinetic  energy  of  the  disintegration  products. 

In  chemical  reactions,  the  change  in  the  rest  masses  of  the  reacting 
substances  occurs  in  the  order  of  10~9  (and  less)  of  the  total  mass. 


SeC.  21]  BBLATIVISTIC    DYNAMICS  215 

In  nuclear  reactions,  where  the  particle  velocities  are  of  the  order  c/10, 
the  change  in  mass  may  approach  one  per  cent. 

When  an  electron  and  positron  (a  positive  electron)  are  annihilated, 
their  energy,  including  rest  energy,  is  totally  converted  into  the  energy 
of  electromagnetic  radiation. 

As  we  shall  see  from  quantum  theory,  radiation  is  propagated  in 
space  in  the  form  of  separate  particles — so-called  light  quanta  (quan- 
tum mechanics  teaches  that  this  is  compatible  with  the  wave  proper- 
ties of  radiation!).  The  velocity  of  a  light  quantum  is  equal  to  c  so 
that  its  mass  is  identically  equal  to  zero.  For  this  reason,  the  total 
rest  mass  of  the  particles  taking  part  in  the  annihilation  process  is 
2  me2  before  the  annihilation  and  zero  afterwards. 

However,  the  change  in  the  energy  of  the  electromagnetic  field  is, 
of  course,  equal  to  2  me2,  provided  the  electron  and  positron  did  not 
have  any  additional  kinetic  energy.  We  could,  by  convention,  call  the 
energy  of  an  electromagnetic  field,  divided  by  c2,  its  mass.  With  such 
a  definition  of  mass,  the  total  "mass"  would  be  conserved.  But  com- 
pared with  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy,  such  a  law  of  conserva- 
tion of  "mass"  does  not  contain  anything  new;  it  only  repeats  the  law 
of  conservation  of  energy  in  other  units. 

It  is  precisely  the  rest  mass  that  is  best  to  use  in  describing  nuclear 
reactions,  for  a  change  in  rest  mass  determines  the  energy  which  may 
be  generated  as  a  result  of  the  reaction  (in  the  form  of  kinetic  energy 
of  the  disintegration  products,  or  in  the  form  of  radiated  energy). 

There  is  no  sense  in  calling  the  energy  of  a  light  quantum  divided  by 
the  square  of  the  velocity  of  light,  its  mass,  because  this  quantity 
does  not  in  any  way  characterize  light  quanta.  Tin's  quantity  has  one 
value  in  one  reference  frame  and  another  value  in  another  frame, 
because  the  energy  of  any  particle  depends  upon  the  reference  system 
relative  to  which  its  motion  is  defined.  Yet  rest  mass  is  a  quantity 
that  characterizes  the  particle.  For  example,  the  resfc  mass  of  an  elec- 
tron, involved  in  the  expressions  for  all  its  mechanical  integrals  of 
motion,  is  equal  to  9  x  10~28  gm.  The  corresponding  quantity  for  a 
quantum  is  identically  equal  to  zero,  and,  in  this  sense,  characterizes 
a  light  quantum  in  the  same  way  that  the  quantity  9  x  10~28  gm  is 
characteristic  of  an  electron. 

The  mass  of  a  particle  determines  the  relationship  between  the 
momenttim  and  velocity  of  the  particle  in  accordance  with  equation 
(21.8).  It  is  impossible  to  determine  the  mass  of  a  particle  by  its 
momentum  alone,  since  particles  with  the  same  momenta  can  have 
quite  different  masses.  For  this  reason,  it  is  meaningless  to  state 
(though  this  is  sometimes  done)  that  the  existence  of  light  pressure 
(i.e.,  momentum  of  the  electromagnetic  field)  proves  that  the  light 
quantum  has  a  finite  mass. 

It  is  sometimes  said  that  a  mass  of  one  gramme  is  capable  of  releasing 
an  energy  of  9  x  1020  ergs  (i.e.,  1  c2).  However,  if  the  substance  con- 


216  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

sists  of  atoms  the  possibility  of  generating  this  energy  is  still  question- 
able since  up  to  now  not  a  single  process  is  known  in  which  the  total 
quantity  of  protons  and  neutrons  (collectively  called,  nucleons)  is 
changed.*  This  is  why,  the  relative  change  in  rest  mass  in  nuclear 
reactions  is  always  measured  in  fractions  of  one  percent. 

The  possibilities  of  various  reactions  are  also  limited  by  the  conser- 
vation of  total  charge. 

The  Hamiltonian  for  a  free  particle.  We  shall  now  express  energy  in 
terms  of  momentum.  Squaring  equation  (21.9)  and  subtracting  from  it 
equation  (21.8),  after  it  has  been  squared  and  multiplied  by  c2,  we 
obtain 

^2_c2p2==m2c4-  (21.14) 

We  have  called  the  energy  expressed  in  terms  of  momentum  the 
Hamiltonian  [see  (10.15)].  Hence, 


p*  .  (21.15) 

Whence  we  obtain  a  relationship  between  the  energy  and  momentum 
of  a  particle  that  has  no  rest  mass : 

£  =  cp.  (21.16) 

The  Lorentz  transformation  for  momentum  and  energy.  We  shall 
now  find  out  how  energy  and  momentum  behave  with  respect  to  a 
Lorentz  transformation.  From  equation  (21.8)  we  get 

mvx        mdx         dx 

ds  ' 


dy  dz 

ds  '       "z  ds  ' 

mc2dt  o  dt 

"~ r=mc  "57 


(21.17) 


The  quantities  m,  c  and  ds  are  invariant.  Hence,  the  components 
px,  py  and  pz  are  transformed  similar  to  dx,  dy,  and  dz,  i.e.,  similar 
to  x,  y,  and  z.  In  accordance  with  the  last  equation,  energy  transforms 
like  time.  We  can  make  the  following  comparison:  px~  x,  pv~  yy 
Pz~  z,  d?  ~c2t. 


*  In  order  to  annihilate  the  whole  mass  we  would  have  to  first  prepare 
"antimatter"  (when  ordinary  matter  interacts  with  antimatter  they  are  mutually 
annihilated,  cf.  Sec  38).  But  this  would  require  a  like  expenditure  of  energy. 


SeC.  21]  BBLATIVISTIC    DYNAMICS  217 

Now  substituting  momentum  and  energy  in  the  Lorentz  transfor- 
mation (20.17)  and  (20.18),  we  obtain 


(21.18) 


Pi  =  P*  ,  (21.20) 


We  note  that  a  correct  transition  from  (21.18)  to  a  nonrelativistic 
equation  for  the  transformation  of  energy  is  obtained  only  when  the 
rest  energy  me2  is  substituted  in  place  of  $' ,  for  then  p'x  =  px — mV 
(i.e.,  v'x  —  vx — F)  in  agreement  with  the  Galilean  law  for  addition  of 
velocities. 

Hence,  if  we  demand  that  the  Lorentz  transformation  yield  the 
correct  limiting  transition  to  a  Galilean  transformation,  it  is  necessary 
to  include  the  rest  energy  of  the  particles  in  their  total  energy.  Con- 
versely, the  kinetic  energy  T  (21.13)  does  not  give  a  correct  limiting 
transition. 

Further,  we  note  that  if  we  form  the  expression  <?2 — c2  p2  from  equa- 
tions (21.17)  we  obtain 

—  c  p  —  m  c  ^  jj-i  j  —  me 

in  accordance  with  (21.14) 

The  velocity  of  a  system  of  particles  in  the  theory  of  relativity.  We 

shall  now  show  how  to  determine  the  velocity  of  a  system  of  particles 
in  relativity  theory.  We  shall  consider  two  particles.  Between  the  veloc- 
ity, momentum,  and  energy  of  each  particle  there  exists  the  relation 

p--^-.  (21.22) 

It  is  obtained  if  we  divide  (21.8)  by  (21.9).  The  same  equation  can 
also  be  obtained  somewhat  differently.  Let  us  determine,  from  (21.18), 
the  velocity  V  of  the  coordinate  system  relative  to  which  the  momen- 
tum of  the  particle  is  equal  to  zero.  Putting  p'x  =  0  on  the  left-hand  side 
of  (21.18)  we  will  have,  on  the  right, 


or,  if  the  velocity  is  not  along  the  #-axis  at  all,  in  accordance  with 
(21.22)  V=pc2/<?  =  v.  As  applied  to  a  single  particle,  the  statement 


218  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

v==  V  is  trivial  and  simply  denotes  that  the  momentum  of  the  particle, 
relative  to  a  coordinate  system  moving  with  the  same  velocity  as  the 
particle  itself,  is  equal  to  zero. 

We  now  apply  equation  (21.18)  to  two  particles  in  order  to  find  the 
velocity  of  the  coordinate  system  relative  to  which  their  total  momen- 
tum is  equal  to  zero.  The  total  momentum  in  the  primed  system  is 
pi+pi—p',  and  the  total  energy  tf\  +<?'2—  <?'•  Let  us  take  the  z-axis 
along  p'.  Since  tho  Lorentz  transformation  is  linear  and  homogeneous, 
it  has  the  same  form  for  the  sum  of  two  quantities  as  for  each  separate- 
ly. Therefore,  we  immediately  obtain  an  equation  similar  to  (21.22): 

v__  ''(Pi  !  J>i)  /<>!  23) 

*  -  *r\  *rm  (     } 

Tho  primes  may  be  omitted  here.  In  order  to  obtain  the  limiting  tran- 
sition to  the  velocity  of  the  centre  of  mass  in  Newtonian  mechanics 
from  (21.23),  it  is  necessary  to  take  Pi  — M^,  P2  =  w2v2,  «?i  =  wtc2, 
^2  =  m2  c2>  i-e->  ^no  Particle  energies  are  replaced  by  their  rest  energies. 

Tho  quantity  V,  expressed  in  terms  of  the  particle  velocities  accord- 
ing to  equations  (21.8)  and  (21.9),  does  not  have  the  form  of  a  total 
derivative  of  any  quantity  with  respect  to  time.  Therefore,  it  is  im- 
possible in  relativistic  mechanics  to  determine  its  coordinates  in  terms 
of  the  velocity  of  the  centre  of  mass.  It  is  better  to  say  that  if  we 
attempt  to  express  the  coordinates  of  the  centre  of  mass  by  means  of 
a  classical  (or  some  other)  equation  it  is  impossible  to  represent  V 
in  the  form  of  a  time  derivative  of  these  coordinates,  except  in  the 
trivial  case  when  \l  and  v2  are  constant.  This  is  why  the  concept  of 
centre  of  mass  for  particles  moving  in  accelerated  motion  cannot  be 
used. 

As  regards  relative  velocity,  vx- — V2,  it  is  meaningless  in.  relativistic 
mechanics,  since  there  is  no  simple  law  for  the  combination  of  veloc- 
ities. 

Action  for  particles  in  an  electromagnetic  field.  Let  us  now  turn 
to  the  equations  of  motion  for  a  charged  particle  in  an  electromagnetic 
field.  We  already  know  the  part  of  the  action  function  which  describes 
the  interaction  of  charges  and  Held.  From  equation  (13.17),  this  is  Sv 
Since  the  variation  of  Sl  leads  to  Maxwell's  equations,  we  can  be  cer- 
tain of  the  relativistic  invariaiice  of  /S^.  As  applied  to  point  charges, 
we  have  already  written  S1  in  magnctostatics  in  equation  (15.26). 
But  action  for  free  charges  in  the  next  equation,  (15.27),  was  suitable 
only  for  small  particle  velocities. 

We  now  know  the  Lagrangian  for  a  fast  particle  in  the  absence  of  a 
field  (21.7).  Thus,  the  Lagrangian  in  an  external  field  is  equal  to  the 
sum  of  the  relativistically  invariant  expressions  (21.7)  and  (15.26): 


P=  -wic2l  -~  +~Av-e<p.  (21.24) 


Sec.  21]  BELATIVISTIO   DYNAMICS  219 

We  now  obtain  an  expression  for  momentum  and  energy.  Momen- 
tum is 

(21.25) 


Here,  p0  denotes  momentum  in  the  absence  of  a  field. 
From  (4.6),  the  energy  is 


(21.26) 

where  <OQ  is  the  energy  in  the  absence  of  an  external  field;  according 
to  (21.9),  it  is  equal  to 


Thus,  the  linear  term  in  velocity  does  not  appear  in  the  energy 
expressed  in  terms  of  momentum.  It  will  be  seen  here  that  the  Lagran 

gian  is  not  of  the  form  T —  U  because  it  involves  the  linear  term  -  A  v. 

The  Hamiltonian  for  a  charge  in  an  external  field.  From  (21.25) 
we  obtain 

Po  =  p--lA,  (21.27) 

and,  from  (21.26), 

^0=£'-C9.  (21.28) 

But  we  already  know  the  expression  for  SJQ  in  terms  of  p0  from  equa- 
tion (21.15),  which  relates  to  the  energy  and  momentum  of  a  free 
particle.  Substituting  p0  and  S\  in  (21.15)  in  accordance  with  the 
last  equations,  we  obtain  the  Hamiltonian  of  a  charge  in  a  field: 


Jf  =  ym2  C4  +  c2  (p  -  --  A)'  -|-  e  9  .  (21.29) 

The  equations  of  motion  of  a  charge  in  an  external  field.  From  (21.29) 
we  can  obtain  the  equations  of  motion  for  a  charge  in  an  external 
field.  However,  it  is  simpler  to  make  use  of  the  Lagraiigiaii  (21.24). 
We  know  that  Lagrange's  equations  are  of  the  following  form: 

d    *L        dL 
~dt~d7  -~aF-U'  (21-3°) 

where  equation  (21.30)  replaces  three  equations  of  the  form  (2.21) 
for  the  coordinates  of  v  and  r. 


220  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part   II 

The  derivative  ~  is  equal  to  p^p0+~-A,  so  that  its  total  time 

G  V  C 

derivative  is 

d    dL  dp0     ,     e   dA  /^i  o^\ 

dt    dv          dt          c    dt    ' 

In  order  to  expand  the  expression  —=-- ,  we  first  write  it  down  for 
one  component: 

dAx  __  dAx        dAx  dx^    ,    dAy  dy_       dAz  dz^  __  dAx        ,    _.  ^ 
dt     ~~     dt      ""    dx     dt    ~*~    dy     dt    ~^~     dz     dt  ~~     dt          ^   •    '      * 

(21.32) 

[see  (11.31)],  whence,  going  to  a  vector  equation  and  substituting 
in  (21.31),  we  have 

^1^==^  +  A/^L  +  (vV)  A)  .  (21.33) 

Let  us  now  calculate  the  right-hand  side  of  (21.30).  Instead  of  -^— we 
can  write  the  completely  equivalent  expression  VL: 


The  gradient  V  (Av)  denotes  coordinate  differentiation,  where  only 
A  and  not  v  depends  explicitly  on  the  coordinates.  Thus,  applying 

o  r 

equation  (11.32),  we  find  -~  : 

~  s  Vi  =  —  (W)  A  +  -  [vrot  A]  -  e<p  .  (21.34) 

o  r  c  c 

Now,  substituting  (21.33)  and  (21.34)  in  (21.30)  and  taking  all  the 
terms  involving  potentials  to  the  right-hand  side,  we  obtain 


(21.35) 


The  right-hand  side  of  (21.35)  involves  the  electromagnetic  fields  in 
accordance  with  their  definition  in  terms  of  potentials  (12.28)  and 
(12.20). 

Hence,  the  equation  of  motion  of  a  charge  involves  only  the  field 
and  not  the  potential,  as  follows  from  the  condition  of  gauge  invariance. 
After  substituting  the  fields  the  equation  takes  the  form 

d         mv  -.,    ,     e  r  TTT 

+[ 


The  right-hand  side  of  (21.36)  is  called  the  Lorentz  force.  In  addition 
to  the  usual  term,  eE,  which  we  know  from  electrostatics,  it  involves 


Sec.  21]  BELATIVISTIC   DYNAMICS  221 

a  term  similar  to  the  Coriolis  force.  It  is  related  to  the  part  of  the 
Lagrangian  which  is  linear  in  velocity. 

The  magnetic  part  of  the  Lorontz  force,  —  [vH],  is  very  similar  to  the 

expression  for  the  force  acting  on  a  current  in  an.  external  magnetic 
field  and,  naturally,  can  be  obtained  from  it.  We  did  not  have  to  use 
this  method  of  derivation  because  the  part  of  the  Lagrangian  which 
describes  the  interaction  between  charges  and  field  was  already  known 
from  Sec.  13.  And  besides,  the  relativistic  invariance  of  (21.36),  which 
emerges  obviously  from  derivation  from  the  invariant  Lagrangian 
function,  is  considerably  more  difficult  to  grasp  from  the  elementary 
definition  of  a  magnetic  force  acting  on  a  current. 

The  work  performed  by  a  field  on  a  charge.  From  equation  (21.36), 
we  can  obtain  an  expression  for  the  work  done  by  an  electromagnetic 
field  on  a  charge.  We  know  by  definition  that  the  work  is  equal 
to  the  change  in  kinetic  energy.  Let  us  multiply  scalarly  both  parts 

of  (21.36)  by  v.  We  shall  then  have  the  expression  -~°-  on  the  left- 
hand  side.  But  v^  -  -inaccordancewithHamilton>sequation(10.18), 

so  that  v  -^5-  =  -?--  4~  =  -f  -  =  ~Jr  >  and  on  the  left-hand  side  what 
dt          dp0     dt  at          dt 

Ave  have  is  the  required  quantity  for  the  change  of  kinetic  energy 
in  unit  time.  On  the  right-hand  side  the  term  v  [v  H]  =  [vv]  H  =  0 
and  there  remains  only  the  work  done  by  the  electric  force  : 


As  was  to  be  expected,  the  magnetic  force  —  [vH]  does  not  per- 

form work  on  the  charge  because  it  is  perpendicular  to  the  charge 
velocity  at  every  given  instant  of  time. 

The  Lorentz  transformation  for  the  field  components.  From  (21.37) 
and  equation  (21.36),  if  we  write  it  in  terms  of  components,  it  is 
easy  to  obtain  the  Lorentz  transformation  equations  for  the  field 
components.  These  equations  must  be  written  so  that  their  form 
does  not  change  in  passing  from  one  coordinate  system  to  another. 
Let  us  take  equation  (21.36)  for  the  component  of  momentum  on 

.r,  and  multiply  it  by~.  We  shall  also  multiply  equation  (21.37) 

fj  t  v 

by  -7—  and  also  by  -^  ,  where  V  is  the  relative  velocity  of  the  coordinate 

system.  After  this  we  subtract  (21.37)  from  (21.36).  Then  on  the  left- 
hand  side  we  have 


222  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  II 

On  the  right-hand  side  we  will  have  the  expression 

/>/F     dt  _L    l    IT     dV  l    JJ     dz\          eV  Iff     dx  _l_  W     dy  _L  F      dz\ 

e  \rjx-^ HZ  -5 — kl  v~j~l 2  •  \"Jx—j r  J^y  ~3 r  J^z  ~r~l ~ 

\        ds        c  ds         c        y  ds  J          c2    \        da  y  ds  ds  J 

oW  tdt         V    dx\        eln          V  ™\<ly         <>/„     LVp\dz 

=  &  rjx\-r 9 r~"l    i \"x "Jvt~~f l^*v~^ ^*I^T~» 

\ds        c2    ds  I  '    c\  c      y/  ds        c\     y  '     c        /  ds 

But  ds  is  invariant.  Therefore,  the  quantities  on  the  right-hand 
side  must  be  transformed  in  accordance  with  the  basic  equations 
(20.17)  and  (20.18).  Differentiating  these  equations,  we  obtain 


dt  __  V    rZ.r  __  rZ, 

ds        c2    ds         ds    I/  c2    '      ds          ds    *      ds          ds 


Now,  dividing  both  sides  of  the  equation  by  /I r  and  multi- 

d  s  I 

plying  by  ^-r ,  we  will  have  an   equation  for  the  ^-component  of 

momentum  in  the  new  coordinate  system: 


In  accordance  with  the  principle  of  relativity,  this  equation  must 
be  written  in  the  same  way  as  for  the  unprimed  coordinate  system: 

*?'*  _,,#/.     e  ji<  <W        G   pr>  dz' 
dt'    ""  *'jj*  ^  i11*  'dt'  ~~  c  uv  dV  ' 

Comparing  the  last  two  equations,  we  obtain  the  field  transformation 
equations: 

E'X=-EX,  (21.38) 

77y  +  JL^ 
H}--        __r-      .-,  (21.39) 

V1  -^ 


-       -  Ey 


(21.40) 


In  the  same  way,  though  from  other  equations  (21.36),  is  it  easy 
to  find  other  equations  for  field  transformation: 

HX=HX,  (21.41) 


Sec.  21] 


RELAT1VISTIO   DYNAMICS 


223 


~\-    


(21.43) 


Consequently,  in  contrast  to  coordinates,  it  is  not  the  longitudinal 
but  the  transverse  components  that  are  transformed  in  the  field. 

The    change    in    field,    in    passing    from    one 
coordinate  system  to  another,   is   verified   to   a 

nonrclativistic     approximation    (i.e.,   to  the  ac- 

pr\  \ 

curacy  of  terms  of  the  order    -\    in    a    unipolar 

induction  experiment.  A  diagram  of  the  ex- 
periment is  shown  in  Fig.  34.  The  magnet  NS 
rotates  around  its  longitudinal  axis.  Two  col- 
lectors connected  by  a  fixed  conductor  are  joined 
to  the  centre  of  the  magnet  and  to  its  axis. 
When  the  magnet  is  rotated,  an  e.m.f.  appears 
in  the  wire.  This  experiment  is  frequently  inter- 
preted as  meaning  that  wlieu  the  magnet  is 
rotated  the  wire  "cuts"  its  lines  of  force  as 
if  the  lines  were  attached  to  the  magnet  like 
brushes. 

Actually,  unipolar  induction  must  be  understood  as  follows.  There 
is  only  a  magnetic  field  H  in  the  coordinate  system  attached  to  the 
magnet,  while  the  electric  field  is  equal  to  zero.  Heuce,  in  a  system 
fixed  in  the  wire,  relative  to  which  the  magnet  moves,  an  electric 
field,  too,  should  be  observed  in  accordance  with  (21.42)  or  (21.43). 

This  field  is  of  an  order  of  magnitude      -  //  and  produces  the  e.m.f. 

We  note  that  a  coordinate  system  is  defined  only  when  both  the 
electric  and  magnetic  fields  are  specified.  It  is  insufficient  to  specifiy 
only  one  of  them. 

The  invariants  of  an  electromagnetic  field.  From  equations  (21.38)- 
(21.43),  it  is  easy  to  obtain  the  following  two  invariants: 


Fig.  34 


E'*  -  #'2  -  E*  -  H2 , 
E'H'-EH. 


(21.44) 
(21.45) 


From  the  invariance  of  these  expressions  it  follows  that  the  electro- 
magnetic field  of  a  plane  wave  appears  similar  in  all  systems.  Indeed, 
in  a  plane  wave,  E  =  H  or  E2 — H2  =  Q.  This  property  is  invariant 
according  to  (21.44).  Further,  E  j_  II,  so  that  (E  H )  —  0.  This 
property  is  invariant  according  to  (21.45). 

The  quantity  (E  H)  is  invariant  with  respect  to  a  Lorentz  trans- 
formation. But  with  respect  to  a  replacement  of  x,  y,  z  by  -#,  -y,  -z 


224  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  II 

(i.e.,  an  inversion  of  the  signs  of  the  coordinates),  it  is  not  invariant, 
because  in  this  case  E  changes  sign  while  H  does  not  (see  Sec.  16). 
The  quantity  E2  —  H2  is  invariant  even  when  the  coordinate  signs 
are  inverted.  But  this  quantity  is  the  Lagrangiaii  for  a  free  electro- 
magnetic field.  Integrated  over  the  invariant  volume  dx,  dy,  dz,  dt 
(exercise  5,  Sec.  20),  it  yields  invariant  action,  as  required,  while 
the  quantity  (EH)  does  not  give  a  real  invariant. 

The  linearity  of  Maxwell's  equations  with  respect  to  field.  A  real 
invariant  can  be  formed  from  the  quantity  EH  merely  by  squaring. 
It  is,  of  course,  not  at  all  obvious  beforehand  why  such  a  quantity 
as  well  as  the  square  of  the  invariant  E2  —  H2  cannot  appear  in  the 
Lagrangiaii  for  an  electromagnetic  field.  The  same  can  be  said  of 
higher-order  terms  which  do  not  change  sign  in  the  substitution  of 
x  by  -x,  etc.  But  if  some  terms  —  other  than  quadratic  with  respect 
to  field  —  are  left  in  the  Lagrangiaii,  then  Maxwell's  equations  will 
contain  nonlinear  terms. 

The  essential  difference  between  nonlinear  and  linear  equations 
is  that  the  sum  of  two  solutions  of  a  nonlinear  equation  is  not  its 
solution.  Indeed,  if  two  electromagnetic  waves  are  propagated  in 
a  vacuum  they  are  simply  combined,  and  in  no  way  distort  each 
other.  In  nonlinear  theory,  the  velocity  is  a  function  of  the  wave 
amplitude,  while  in  electrodynamics  the  velocity  of  light  is  a  universal 
constant. 

For  this  reason,  the  choice  of  the  Lagrangian  in  the  simplest  form 
E2  —  H2  expresses  the  experimental  fact  that  the  law  of  variation 
of  any  electromagnetic  field  in  space  and  in  time  is  in  no  way  dependent 
upon  whether  another  field  is  operative  in  that  same  charge-free 
region  of  space. 

Actually  the  quantum  electromagnetic  field  theory  indicates  the 
existence  of  certain  nonlinear  effects.  In  the  range  of  phenomena 
for  which  classical  electrodynamics  is  applicable,  these  effects  are 
not  essential. 

Transformation  of  charge  density  and  current  density.  From  the 
definition  of  charge  density  one  can  find  the  law  of  its  transformation. 
Since  charge  is  an  invariant  quantity,  we  have 

de  =  pdxdydz  =  Pod#0d?/0dz0,  (21.46) 


where  p0  is  the  charge  density  in  a  system  relative  to  which  it 
is  at  rest  and,  hence,  the  quantity  is  also  invariant  by  definition. 
Whence, 

dx0dy0dz0  dt  dt  /rtl    .„. 

P  =  Po  =  Po  d£  =  Poc  -37  '  (2L47> 


where  we  have  used  (20.30)  and  exercise  5,  Sec.   20.  The  current 
density  is 


SeC.  21]  BELATIVISTIC    DYNAMICS  225 

dx    dt  dx 

j,  =  ptfc  =  Poc  -gj-  -dT  =  Po«  -37  , 


From  here  it  can  -be  seen  that  the  current  components  are  trans- 
formed like  coordinates,  while  charge  density  is  transformed  like 
time. 

Let  us  consider  a  conductor  in  which  a  current  is  flowing.  In  the 
coordinate  system  in  which  the  conductor  is  at  rest,  it  remains  neutral, 
but  in  other  systems  a  charge  density  must  appear  on  it.  This  fact 
does  not  contradict  the  invariance  of  total  charge,  but  follows  from 
it  in  accordance  with  (21.46)-(21.48). 

The  invariance  of  action  for  the  field.  Let  us  now  verify  that  the 
action  term  (13.17)  describing  the  interaction  of  field  and  charge 
is  invariant.  It  follows  from  (21.27)  and  (21.28)  that  the  vector 
potential  transforms  like  momentum  (i.e.,  like  a  radius  vector), 
while  the  scalar  potential  transforms  like  energy  (i.e.,  like  time). 
For  this  reason  the  product 

Aj  —  99 

behaves,  with  respect  to  a  Loreiitz  transformation,  like  an  interval; 
in  other  words,  it  remains  invariant.  Integrated  over  the  invariant 
"four-dimensional"  volume  dx  dy  dz  dt,  it  yields  the  invariant  action 
term  $x.  Hence,  Maxwell's  equations  are  obtained  from  the  invariant 
action  function  S,  so  that  they  are  also  invariant  themselves.  This 
could  also  have  been  verified  from  equations  (21.38)-(21.43). 


Exercises 

1)  Find  the  scalar  and  vector  potentials  of  a  freely  moving  charge. 

In  its  own  coordinate  system,  the  scalar  potential  is  90  =  —  and  the  vector 

ro 

potential  is  equal  to  zero.  Hence,  in  a  system  relative  to  which  the  charge 
moves,  its  scalar  potential  is 

9o  e 

9  =  '  " 


and  the  vector  potential  is 

v 

A  = 


15  -  0060 


226  ELECTBODYNAMICS  [Part  II 

Further,  r0  must  be  expressed  in  terms  of  coordinates  in  the  fixed  system 


(x  -  vt) 


We  can  put  £  instead  of  ttf,  i.e.,  the  abscissa  of  the  moving  charge.  The 
electromagnetic  disturbance  arrives  at  the  given  point  x,  y,  z  from  the  point  £', 
where  the  charge  was  situated  earlier.  We  have 


from  the  definition  of  lag.  Putting  5  =  vt  in  r0,  we  obtain  an  expression  for  9 
and  A  in  terms  of  JR'. 


2)  Find  the  motion  of  a  charge  in  a  constant  uniform  magnetic  field. 
If  the  field  is  in  the  direction  of  the  2-axis,  the  equations  of  motion  are 
of  the  following  form: 

dpx  _  e    dy  dpy  _  __  e_^_jr         dpz  _ 

dt        c    dt       '        dt  c    dt       '         dt 

Further,  p2  =  const,  p|  =  const,  pj  +  p}  =  const, 


We  look  for  the  coordinates  x  and  y  in  the  form: 


For  R  and  co  the  following  expressions  result: 
_    &v  ecH 

M"~^H9      <0~~£r~- 

The  particle  moves  along  a  helix.  For  small  velocities,  to  reduces  to  the 

constant  value  . 

me 

3)  Find  the  motion  of  a  charge  in  a  constant  uniform  electric  field.  The 
equations  of  motion  are 

J*£*      *JB        *^L-c\         *V*-H        *#<Lw.*^d?L 


From  the  last  equation  we  obtain 


*\/m2c*  4-  c2  (p|  ~f-  p$  +  p|)  —  ^/m2  c4  -f  ca  (pJ0  +  pJ0  -f  p!0) 
From  the  first  equation 

These  equation  integrals  together  give  x  as  a  function  of  t. 


Sec.  21]  BELATIVISTIC   DYNAMICS  227 

If  pz9  =  0,  then  dividing  px  by  py>  wo  have  an  expression  for  -5  —  in  terms 

of  x  (by  eliminating  t  from  the  energy  integral).  The  trajectory  is  of  the  form 
of  a  catenary. 

4)  Find  the  motion  of  a  charge  in  a  central  attractive  Coulomb  field. 

The  energy  integral  is  of  the  form 


Further,  denoting  the  azimuth  by  ^,  we  obtain 

dr  m 


-       -  _    __  —  ff\    —  _ 

dt     ir-=-^r  '     Pr~  dt 


F-T' 


Whence 

1     dr  __   pr 
~~~ 


Substitution  of  pr  in  the  energy  integral  and  separation  of  the  variables  r 
and  fy  leads  bo  an  elementary  quadrature.  The  trajectory  for  finite  motion 
(&  <  we2)  is  similar  to  an  ellipse,  but  with  a  rotating  perihelion. 

5)  Examine  the  collision  of  a  travelling  particle  of  zero  mass  with  a  particle 
of  mass  m  at  rest.  Determine  the  energy  of  the  incident  particle  after  collision, 
if  its  angle  of  deflection  #  is  known. 


Answer:  $' '- 


H 


6)  Find  the  motion  and  radiation  of  a  charge  connected  elastically  to 
some  point  of  space  (with  frequency  o>0)  and  situated  in  a  uniform  magnetic  field 
HZ  =  H,  Hx  =  Hy  =  0. 

The  oscillations  of  the  charge  are  governed  by  the  following  nonrelativistio 
equations  : 


-\  --  Hyt 
c 

--  Hx, 
c 

mz=  —  mcojjz. 

The  third  equation  does  not  depend  on  the  first  two.  The  first  two  equations 
are  easily  solved  if  we  put  x  =  aeit*t,  y  =  bei<*tf  Then 

a(cog-6>2)—  *co--—  6  =  0, 
?nc 

b  (co§  —  <o2)  +  iv>  --  a  —  0. 

Let  us  multiply  the  second  equation  by  i  and  first  subtract  it  from  the 
first,  and  then  add  it.  The  combinations  a±ib  then  satisfy  the  equations 


15* 


228  ELECTRODYNAMICS  [Part  II 

Cancelling  a±ib,  we  arrive  at  the  equations  for  frequencies 

e//co 
«'-«*±-^-  =  0. 

We  regard  -  as  small  compared  with  co0,  replace  co  by  co0  in  the  term  ------  , 

and  represent  the  difference  to*  —  to2  as  (to  -\-  co0)  (to  —  co0),  which  is  approximately 
equal  to  2oj0  (to  —  to0).  Then  we  obtain  expressions  for  the  frequencies  of  both 
oscillations  : 


They  differ  from  the  undisplaced  frequency  by  -'  —  ,  i.o.,  by  the  Larmor 

frequency  COL. 

From  the  equations  for  a  and  6,  after  substituting  co  —  c^T  COL,  we  have, 
to  the  same  degree  of  approximation, 

a  =  ±  i  b  . 

If  we  represent  the  coordinates  in  real  form,  we  obtain  for  both  oscillations 
x  —-  a  cos  (to0  ^  COL)  t  ;  y  =  ±  a  sin  (to0  ^  COL)  £. 

Thus,  the  radius  vector  of  a  particle  performing  oscillations  with  frequency 
to0  4-  «L  rotates  in  a  clockwise  direction,  while  for  oscillations  with  frequency 
to0  —  a>L  it  rotates  in  an  anticlockwise  direction.  Thus,  in  accordance  with 
Larmor's  theorem,  the  frequency  COL  is  added  to  the  frequency  co0  or  subtracted 
from  it,  depending  upon  the  direction  in  which  the  charge  rotates  (wo  note 
that  the  sign  of  COL  is  changed  for  a  negative  charge). 

Let  us  consider  the  radiation  of  such  a  charge  in  a  magnetic  field.  We  know 
that  the  electric  vector  of  the  radiated  electromagnetic  wave  lies  in  the  same 
plane  as  the  charge  displacement  vector.  Jf  radiation  is  observed  to  bo  due 
to  the  z-component  of  the  dipole  moment,  its  electric  vector  is  along  the  z-axis 
and  is  proportional  to  5  .  Thus,  the  radiation  is  plane-polarized  and  is  of  frequency 
co0.  The  oscillation  occurring  along  the  fiold  and  having  an  undisplaced  frequency 
radiates  electromagnetic  waves,  which  are  polarized  in  the  same  plane  as  the 
magnetic  field.  This  oscillation  does  not  radiate  at  all  in  the  direction  of  the 
magnetic  field,  but  the  oscillations  with  frequency  co0  ±  COL  radiate  circularly- 
polarized  waves,  and  the  electric  -field  vector  rotates  in  the  same  direction 
as  the  charge  displacement  vector. 

All  three  frequencies  radiate  in  a  direction  perpendicular  to  the  field.  How- 
ever, since  the  charge  oscillations  are  viewed  from  one  side  in  this  position 
in  circular  rotation,  the  vector  of  electric  -field  oscillations  lies  in  a  plane  per- 
pendicular to  the  constant  external  magnetic  field,  so  that  waves  with  fre- 
quencies co0  -t  COL  are  now  also  plane-polarized.  In  observations  that  are  not 
at  right  angles  to  the  field,  we  obtain  elliptically-polarized  oscillations  and  a 
plane-polarized  oscillation  of  frequency  c.>(). 

The  calculations  set  out  here  form  the  classical  theory  of  the  Zeeman  effect. 
The  line  splitting  that  is  actually  observed  for  various  values  of  magnetic 
field  is  correctly  described  only  by  quantum  theory  (Sec.  34). 


PART  III 
QUANTUM  MECHANICS 

Sec.  22.  The  Inadequacy  of  Classical  Mechanics. 
The  Analogy  Between  Mechanics  and  Geometrical  Optics 

The  instability  of  the  atom  according  to  the  classical  view.  Ruther- 
ford's experiments  in  1910  established  that  the  atom  consists  of 
light  negative  electrons  and  a  heavy  positive  nucleus  of  dimensions 
very  small  compared  to  the  atom  itself  (see  Sec.  6).  For  such  a  system 
to  be  stable,  it  is  necessary  that  the  electrons  should  revolve  around 
the  nucleus  like  planets  about  the  sun,  for  unlike  charges  at  rest 
would  come  together. 

This  stability  condition  of  the  atom  is,  nevertheless,  insufficient. 
In  the  case  of  motion  in  an  orbit,  electrons  will  experience  centri- 
petal acceleration,  but,  as  was  shown  in  Sec.  19,  a  charged  particle 
undergoing  acceleration  radiates  electromagnetic  waves,  thereby 
transmitting  its  energy  to  the  electromagnetic  field.  Thus,  the  energy 
of  an  electron  moving  around  a  nucleus  should  continuously  diminish 
until  the  electron  falls  onto  the  nucleus.  This  statement  is  in  striking 
contradiction  to  the  obvious  fact  of  the  stability  of  atoms. 

The  Bohr  theory.  In  1913,  N.  Bohr  suggested  a  compromise  as  a 
way  out  of  this  difficulty.  According  to  Bohr,  an  atom  has  stable 
orbits  such  that  an  electron  moving  in  them  does  not  radiate  electro- 
magnetic waves.  But  in  making  a  transition  from  an  orbit  of  higher 
energy  to  one  with  lower  energy,  an  electron  radiates ;  the  frequency 
of  this  radiation  is  related  to  the  difference  between  the  energies 
of  the  electron  in  these  two  orbits  by  the  equation 

h  co  =  ^  —  <^2  > 

where  A  is  a  universal  constant  equal  to  1.054X  10~27  erg-sec. 

Both  of  Bohr's  principles  were  in  the  nature  of  postulates.  But 
it  was  possible  with  their  aid  to  explain,  in  excellent  agreement  with 
.experiment,  the  observed  spectrum  of  the  hydrogen  atom  and  also 
the  spectra  of  a  series  of  atoms  and  ions  similar  to  the  hydrogen  atom 


230  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

(for  example,  the  positive  helium  ion,  which  consists  of  a  nucleus 
and  one  electron).  Despite  the  fact  that  both  of  these,  essentially 
quantum,  postulates  of  Bohr  were  completely  alien  to  classical 
physics  and  could  in  no  way  be  explained  on  the  basis  of  classical 
concepts,  they  represented  an  extraordinary  step  forward  in  the 
theory  of  the  atom. 

Indeed,  the  first  postulate  contains  the  statement  that  not  every 
state  of  the  atom  is  stationary,  but  only  certain  states.  This  statement, 
as  we  now  know,  derives  from  quantum  mechanics  just  as  directly 
as  elliptical  planetary  orbits  derive  from  Newtonian  mechanics. 

The  Bohr  theory  was  very  successful  in  explaining  the  spectra 
of  single-electron  atoms.  But  the  very  next  step,  a  two-electron 
atom  such  as  the  helium  atom,  did  not  yield  to  consistent  calculation 
by  the  Bohr  theory.  The  theory  was  even  less  capable  of  explaining 
the  stability  of  the  hydrogen  molecule.  For  this  reason,  the  situation 
in  physics,  notwithstanding  a  number  of  brilliant  results  of  the  Bohr 
theory,  was  completely  unsatisfactory.  Besides  the  particular  diffi- 
culties that  we  have  noted  here,  the  Bohr  theory  was,  on  the  whole, 
eclectic,  since  it  was  inconsistent  in  its  combination  of  classical  and 
quantum  concepts. 

Light  quanta.  The  inadequacy  of  classical  ideas  appeared  most 
obvious  in  the  problem  of  the  stability  of  the  atom.  But  earlier 
there  were  many  facts  which  classical  (i.e.,  nonquantum)  physics 
failed  to  explain.  A  case  in  point  is  the  theory  of  an  electromagnetic 
field  in  equilibrium  with  matter  (for  more  detail,  see  Sec.  42).  Here, 
classical  theory  leads  to  an  absurd  result — the  total  energy  of  an 
electromagnetic  field  in  equilibrium  with  radiating  matter  is  expressed 
in  the  form  of  a  divergent,  i.e.,  infinite,  integral. 

In  order  to  give  a  satisfactory  description  of  experimental  facts, 
Planck,  in  1900,  postulated  that  sources  of  radiation  emit  and  absorb 
energy  of  the  electromagnetic  field  in  -finite  amounts.  These  discrete 
quantities,  or  quanta,  as  they  were  called  by  Planck,  are  proportional 
to  the  frequency  of  the  emitted  or  absorbed  radiation.  It  is  easy  to 
see  that  the  factor  of  proportionality  must  be  the  same  as  in  Bohr's 
second  postulate  (actually,  Planck  introduced  a  quantity  2  77  times 

greater,  but  used  a  frequency  v  =  -£- ,  equal  to  the  number  of  oscil- 
lations per  second).  Bohr's  second  postulate  relates  the  properties 
of  discreteness  of  stationary  states  of  a  radiating  system  (atom), 
occurring  in  line  spectra,  to  the  energy  of  the  emitted  quanta.  Classi- 
cally, it  is  just  as  impossible  to  explain  this  discreteness  as  it  is  to 
explain  Planck's  initial  hypothesis. 

The  duality  of  electrodynamical  concepts.  At  the  beginning  of 
the  twentieth  century,  the  classical  theory  of  light  also  turned  out 
to  be  incapable  of  explaining  many  facts  without  appealing  to  an 
additional  hypothesis  concerning  light  quanta.  But  at  the  same  time, 


Sec.  22]          THE  ANALOGY  BETWEEN  MECHANICS  AND  GEOMETRICAL  OPTICS       231 

there  was  a  whole  range  of  phenomena,  such  as  diffraction  and  inter- 
ference of  light,  which  appeared  to  be  intimately  bound  up  with 
its  wave  nature.  It  did  not  seem  possible  to  explain  these  phenomena 
in  terms  of  classical  corpuscular  concepts. 

Another  group  of  phenomena  could  be  explained  only  on  the  basis 
of  Planck's  hypothesis  concerning  light  quanta,  and  was  in  most 
obvious  contradiction  to  the  classical  wave  conceptions.  Let  us  note 
two  such  phenomena. 

I  refer,  firstly,  to  the  so-called  photoemissive  effect,  i.e.,  the  emission 
of  electrons  from  the  surface  of  a  metal  in  a  vacuum  when  the  metal 
is  illuminated  by  ultraviolet  rays.  The  energy  of  the  photoelectrons 
depends  only  on  the  radiation  frequency  and  is  independent  of  its 
intensity.  This  can  only  be  understood  if  we  assumed  that  the  energy 
of  electromagnetic  radiation  is  absorbed  in  the  form  of  quanta,  /tco. 
Then  the  kinetic  energy  of  an  electron  will  be  equal  to  the  energy 
of  the  quantum  minus  the  electronic  work  function  (the  energy 
needed  to  remove  the  electron  from  the  metal). 

Einstein,  to  whom  this  explanation  of  the  laws  of  the  photoelectric 
effect  belongs,  went  further  and  assumed  that  electromagnetic 
radiation  is  not  only  absorbed  and  emitted  in  the  form  of  quanta, 
but  is  also  propagated  in  that  form. 

Since  the  energy  of  a  quantum  is  equal  to  Aco,  and  its  velocity 

is  c,  it  should  possess  a  momentum  — —  (see  Sec.  21).  It  follows  that 

a  quantum  is  a  particle  of  zero  mass.  It  will  be  noted  that  the  energy 
and  momentum  of  an  electromagnetic  wave  are  related  in  exactly 
this  way  (see  Sec.  17). 

The  second  phenomenon  which  exhibited  the  quantum  properties 
of  radiation  provided  for  confirmation  of  Einstein's  hypothesis 
concerning  the  momentum  of  light  quanta.  In  the  scattering  of 
X-radiation  by  electrons,  the  latter  may  be  regarded  as  free,  since 
the  characteristic  frequencies  of  their  motion  in  a  substance  are  very 
small  compared  with  the  frequency  of  the  incident  radiation  (we 
have  considered  such  scattering  in  exercise  4,  Sec.  19).  It  is  essential 
that  in  accordance  with  classical  theory  the  scattered  radiation 
must  be  of  the  same  frequency  as  the  incident  radiation.  But  exper- 
iment showed  that  the  frequency  of  the  scattered  radiation  is  less 
than  the  frequency  of  the  incident  radiation,  and  depends  upon 
the  angle  at  which  the  scattering  is  observed  (Compton  effect).  The 
displaced  frequency  can  be  calculated  in  relation  to  the  scattering 
angle,  if  it  is  assumed  that  the  act  of  scattering  occurs  as  the  col- 
lison  of  two  free  particles — a  moving  quantum  and  an  electron  at 
rest.  A  collision  of  this  sort  was  considered  in  exercise  5,  Sec.  21, 
especially  for  the  case  of  an  incident  particle  with  zero  mass.  The 
equation  obtained  there  gives  a  perfectly  correct  description  of  the 
frequency  shift  in  the  Compton  effect,  if  we  consider  that  the  energy 


232  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

of  the  quantum  is  equal  to  &  =  Aco  and  its  momentum  p  =  h  k 
(or  h  co/c  in  absolute  magnitude). 

Quantum  mechanics.  Thus,  in  the  theory  of  light  and  the  theory 
of  the  atom,  a  peculiar  dualism  arose:  one  and  the  same  physical 
reality  (the  electromagnetic  field  or  the  atom)  was  described  by 
two  contradictory  theories:  classical  and  quantum.  A  way  out  of 
this  situation  was  found  in  consistent  quantum  theory,  where  all 
motion  possesses  certain  wave  properties,  which,  however,  cannot 
be  detected  in  the  motion  of  macroscopic  bodies,  but  are  essential 
in  the  description  of  the  motion  of  such  microscopic  particles  as 
quanta  and  electrons.  The  criterion  to  be  used  in  order  to  determine 
whether  it  is  necessary  to  take  into  account  the  wave  properties 
of  a  given  motion  will  be  given  in  the  following  section.  The  only 
thing  to  note  here  is  that  it  involves  the  constant  h. 

The  basic  principles  of  quantum  mechanics  received  direct  experi- 
mental verification  after  the  discovery  of  electron  diffraction,  whose 
laws  are  very  similar  to  the  diffraction  laws  of  electromagnetic  waves. 
All  atomic  phenomena  are  qualitatively  and  quantitatively  fully 
accounted  for  by  quantum  mechanics. 

The  present  state  of  nuclear  theory.  Nuclear  phenomena  are  some- 
what more  complex.  At  the  present  time,  we  do  not  know  the  laws 
governing  the  interaction  of  nuclear  particles.  These  laws  are  closely 
related  to  the  properties  of  special  nuclear  fields,  which  properties 
differ  in  many  respects  from  those  of  the  electromagnetic  field.  At 
the  present  time,  we  still  do  not  know  the  theory  of  nuclear  fields. 
It  may  also  be  that  there  is  still  insufficient  experimental  data  for 
the  development  of  such  a  theory.  Therefore,  nuclear  theory  is,  to 
date,  considerably  less  developed  than  atomic  theory,  in  which  all 
interactions  are  of  an  electromagnetic  nature  and  well  known.  In 
any  case,  the  difficulties  experienced  by  modern  nuclear  theory 
lie  outside  the  region  in  which  nonrelativistic  quantum  mechanics 
can  be  applied,  and  in  no  way  affect  its  basis. 

The  correspondence  between  geometrical  optics  and  classical 
mechanics.  An  essential  role  has  been  played  in  the  formation  of 
quantum  theory  by  analogy  between  classical  mechanics  and  wave 
optics.  A  correspondence  will  be  established  between  them  in  the 
present  section.  Since  geometrical  optics  is  a  limiting  case  of  wave 
optics,  an  analogy  between  geometrical  optics  and  classical  mechanics 
permits  of  transition  to  the  wave  equations  of  quantum  mechanics 
by  means  of  a  generalization.  Let  us  establish  an  analogy  between 
the  equations  of  mechanics  and  geometrical  optics,  quite  formally 
for  the  time  being.  Its  meaning  will  be  given  later. 

Surfaces  of  constant  phase.  Let  us  explain  the  significance  of  the 
wave  phase  in  geometrical  optics.  To  do  this,  we  perform  the  limiting 
transition  from  wave  optics  to  geometrical  optics.  We  write  the 
expression  for  the  field  in  the  form 


Sec.  22]          THE  ANALOGY  BETWEEN  MECHANICS  AND  GEOMETRICAL  OPTICS      233 

E  =  E0(M)cos-^^-.  (22.1) 

A 

Here,  X  is  the  wavelength,  which  is  regarded  as  small  compared  with 
the  linear  dimensions  of  the  region  occupied  by  the  field.  In  the  limiting 
case  of  a  plane  wave  the  phase  is 


(22.2) 

[Of.  (17.21),  (17.22)].  Since  co  =  -^--,  k  =  -^>  where  u  is  the 
phase  velocity,  it  is  convenient  to  obtain  a  relationship  containing  X 
explicitly,  describing  the  phase  as  9  =  y- 

The  expression  for  the  field  must  be  substituted  into  the  wave 
equation 

<22-3> 


In  differentiating  with  respect  to  i  and  r,  we  retain  only  those  terms 
containing  the  highest  degree  of  X  in  the  denominator  because  X  is 
a  small  quantity.  Hence, 


X 

cos- 


0**  =      ~°  x  dt*  0iiA  x       ~°  x2  \  dt  I  wo  x 

As  stated,  the  first  term  in  the  last  expression  must  be  discarded 
when  X->0.  Whence, 


and  similarly 


_  x 

=~~  COST 


obtain  a  first-order  differential  equation  for  the  phase  9  =  —  -  : 


Substituting  these  expressions  into  the  wave  equation  (22.3),  we 

2L 
x 

(22.4) 
In  the  limiting  case  of  a  plane  wave,  it  follows  from  (22.2)  that 

k  =  -|^~V9  (22.5) 

and 

o>=~4f>  <22'6) 

where 


234 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


But,  according  to  (22.4),  this  same  equation  is  satisfied  also  by  the 
quantities  -~t  -jr  in  the  expression  of  the  almost  plane  wave  (22.1). 

It  follows  that  we  can  take  equations  (22.5)  and  (22.6)  as  definitions 

for  the  wave  vector  and  frequency  of  an  almost  plane  wave. 

The  wave  vector  is  directed  along  the  normal  to  a 
surface  of  constant  phase  9=^ const,  i.e.,  along  a 
light  ray  at  a  given  point  of  space.  The  propa- 
gation of  an  almost  plane  wave  may  be  represented 
as  the  displacement  in  space  of  a  family  of  surfaces 
of  constant  phase.  In  Fig.  35,  these  surfaces  are 
shown  in  cross  section  by  solid  lines,  and  the 
light  rays  are  dashed  lines. 

At  various  instants  of  time  t,  a  surface  of 
definite  value  9  =  90  occupies  various  positions  in 
space  corresponding  to  the  equation  9  (r,  t)  =  90.  We 
determine  the  propagation  velocity  of  this  surface. 

To  do  this,  we  proceed  from  the  condition  obtained  by  differentiating 

9  =  const: 


Let  dr  be  a  vector  in  a  direction  normal  to  the  surface.  Then 
is  the  absolute  value  of  k.  From  (22.5)  and  (22.6),  we  obtain' 


"5F 


dt 


"07 


which  coincides  with  the  definition  of  phase  velocity  (18.7). 

Phase  and  group  velocities  are,  in  general,  different,  since  group 
velocity  is  equal  to 

V  =  j£.  (22.7) 

It  is  essential  that  for  an  almost  plane  wave,  co  may  be  expressed 
as  a  function  of  k,  just  as  is  done  in  the  case  of  a  plane  wave. 

Surfaces  of  constant  action.  We  shall  now  consider  a  family  of  tra- 
jectories of  identical  particles  moving  in  some  force  field.  For  example, 
these  may  be  shrapnel  particles  formed  when  a  shell  is  exploded 
(though  not  pieces  of  the  shell  itself  having  different  masses!);  it 
must  be  considered  here  that  the  shrapnel  explosions  occur  at  the 
same  place  continuously,  so  that  the  particles  fly  one  after  the  other 
along  each  trajectory  lagging  only  in  time.  It  is  not  absolutely  neces- 
sary to  consider  particles  emerging  from  one  point.  Trajectories  may 
be  taken  which  are  normal  to  some  initial  surface.  Each  particle  emerg- 
ing at  t  — 10  has  a  definite  trajectory  depending  on  its  initial  coordinates 


Sec.  22]          THE  ANALOGY  BETWEEN  MECHANICS  AND  GEOMETRICAL  OPTICS      235 

and  initial  velocity.  The  value  of  the  action  S  for  each  particle  may  be 
calculated  along  these  trajectories  from  the  equation   [see  (10.2)] 

S^^Ldt.  (22.8) 

<0 

Since  at  the  instant  t  —  t0  the  position  of  a  particle  is  determined  by 
its  trajectory,  and  L  is  a  known  function  of  coordinates,  velocities, 
and  time,  L{q(t),  q(t),  t},  the  action  along  each  trajectory  is  also 
known  as  a  function  of  time. 

Let  us  join  by  surfaces  the  points  of  all  the  trajectories  for  which 
the  value  of  S  is  constant.  The  equation  of  this  surface  is  S  (r,  t)  =  $0. 
In  accordance  with  (22.8),  this  surface  coincides  at  the  initial  instant 
of  time  with  the  surface  from  which  the  particles  emerged. 

The  relationship  of  momentum  and  energy  with  action.  The  surfaces 
of  constant  action  are  displaced  in  space  and  are  orthogonal  to  the 
particle  trajectories,  because,  from  (10.23), 

__  dS          _^_         _, ds 

and,  in  general, 

p  =  —  ==V$.  (22.9) 

r        dT  v          ' 

The  partial  derivatives  are  proportional  to  the  direction  cosines  of 
the  normal  to  the  surface  S=SQ. 

Let  us  calculate,  in  addition,  the  partial  derivative  of  S  with  respect 
to  time.  Since  the  action  depends  upon  the  coordinates  and  the  time, 
its  total  derivative  is  equal  to 

BS  =  dS       d^_  dr_  ,~2  IQ\ 

But  from  (22.8) 

dS 


Q    Of 

Substituting  this  into  the  left-hand  side  of  (22.10),  and  p  =  -=--  into 
the  right-hand  side  of  the  same  equation,  we  obtain 


(22.11) 


Similar  quantities  in  an  optical-mechanical  analogy.  Comparing 
equations  (22.9)  and  (22.11)  with  (22.5)  and  (22.6),  we  conclude 
that  a  surface  of  constant  action  of  a  system  of  particles  is  propagated 
similar  to  a  surface  of  constant  phase  :  the  momentum  of  particles  is 
similar  to  the  wave  vector,  while  the  particle  energy  is  similar  to  the 


236  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

frequency.  In  accordance  with  Hamilton's  equation  (10.18),  the  particle 
velocity  v  analogous  to  the  group  velocity  of  a  wave  is 


(22.12) 


The  velocity  of  a  surface  of  constant  action  is 

88 
u  = 


dt  ~.  (22.13) 


This  value  by  no  means  coincides  with  the  particle  velocity.  Thus,  for 
free  particles 

a  me2  mv 


so  that  u  =  — .  The  quantity  u  is  analogous  to  the  phase  velocity  of  the 

waves. 

The  expression  for  group  velocity  (22.7)  corresponds  to  Hamilton's 
equation  (22.12).  In  Sec.  18  it  was  shown  that  the  group  velocity  corre- 
sponds to  the  velocity  of  propagation  for  a  wave  packet,  i.e.,  a  disturb- 
ance concentrated  within  a  certain  region  of  space.  Thus,  the  analogy 
between  mechanics  and  geometrical  optics  establishes  a  correspondence 
between  a  particle  and  a  wave  packet. 

The  transition  to  geometrical  optics  provides  for  representation  of 
the  solution  of  the  wave  equation,  in  a  certain  region  of  space,  in  the 
form  of  a  plane  wave ;  however,  the  quantities  defining  this  wave,  such 
as  the  frequency  and  the  wave  vector,  are  themselves  slowly  varying 
functions  of  coordinates  and  time.  The  relationship  between  frequency 
and  wave  vector  will  be  of  the  form  co  =  co  (k,  r),  where  the  quantities 
k  and  r  that  describe  the  wave  propagation  satisfy  the  same  Hamilton- 
ian  equations  as  p  and  r  of  a  particle  moving  along  a  trajectory.  It 
is  essential  here  that  the  vector  k  should  not  change  much  in  magni- 
tude and  direction  over  a  distance  of  one  wavelength,  and  that  the 
frequency  co  should  not  change  greatly  in  one  oscillation  period. 

G>  =  C&  for  a  plane  wave  in  free  space;  this  is  completely  analogous 
to  the  relationship  (21.16)  between  the  energy  and  momentum  of  a 
particle  of  zero  mass. 

If  light  is  propagated  in  an  inhomogeneous  medium,  the  phase 
velocity  u,  appearing  in  equation  (22.4),  is  a  variable  quantity.  For 
example,  when  light  is  refracted  at  the  boundary  of  two  media,  u 
has  different  values  on  both  sides  of  the  boundary.  The  propagation 
of  light  in  an  inhomogeneous  medium  is  similar  to  the  motion  of  a 
particle  in  a  medium  of  variable  potential  energy. 


C.  22]  THE  ANALOGY  BETWEEN  MECHANICS  AND  GKOMETBIOAL  OPTICS       237 

The  optical-mechanical  analogy  was  established  by  Hamilton  in 
>25.  However,  up  to  the  time  of  the  formation  of  quantum  mechanics 
e.,  up  to  1925),  the  physical  significance  of  this  analogy  was  not 
iderstood. 

The  law  of  transformation  and  the  dimensions  for  similar  quantities. 
ie  analogy  between  optical  and  mechanical  quantities  is  relativisti- 
lly  invariant.  Comparing  formulae  (20.33)-(20.36),  for  the  trans- 
rmation  of  wave  vector  and  frequency,  with  (21.18)-(21.21),  for 
e  transformation  of  momentum  and  energy,  we  see  that  similar 
lantities  are  transformed  in  a  similar  manner. 
The  optical  and  mechanical  quantities  differ  only  in  dimensions. 
lus,  phase  has  zero  dimensions  while  action  has  the  dimensions  of 

L  dt,  i.e.,  gm.  cm2/sec.  Accordingly,  the  wave  vector  and  momentum, 

id  the  frequency  and  energy,  likewise  differ  by  the  dimensions  of 

tion.  As  can  be  seen  from  a  comparison  of  the  Lorentz  transfor- 

ations  for  these  quantities,  the  proportionality  factor  is  an  invariant 

lantity. 

In  the  following  section  we  shall  show  that  the  analogy  between 

schanics  and  geometrical  optics  emerges  as  a  limiting  relation  from 

e  precise  wave  equation  of  quantum  mechanics. 

Exercises 

1)  Formulate  the  equation  of  surfaces  of  constant  action  for  a  system 
particles  emerging  from  a  single  point  in  space  x  =  0,  z  =  0,  in  the  plane 
=  0  in  a  gravitational  field.  The  absolute  value  of  the  particle  velocities 
VQ  and  their  direction  is  arbitrary. 
We  have 

vx^vx,         x  =  mvX,       x  =  vxt, 

qt2 


iminating  the  initial  conditions  for  velocities,  we  obtain 

x        dti  mz       mgt       dS        cy 

--         -  ---      -  - 


ieed,  from  the  expression  for  S  we  obtain 

8S        mUx\*      lz\*  g*tn       mv* 

*-  -  IT  ~  -FIAT)  +  IT)  +  gz+  ~r\  -  -y-- 

2)  Proceeding  from  the  fact  that  phase  is  analogous  to  action,  show  that 
ht  of  given  frequency  is  propagated  along  trajectories  for  which  the  prop- 
ition  time  of  constant  phase  is  least  (Format  principle). 

At  constant  frequency 

f.   ,  f  ndr 

9=     kar  =  <o     -  . 

it  the  product  n  di  is  equal  to  the  displacement  of  the  surface  in  a  direction 
rmal  to  it.  It  follows  that  --  is  the  propagation  time  dt.  In  accordance 

fch  the  variational  principle,  which  governs  phase  as  well  as  action,  the  time 
ist  be  least. 


238  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Sec.  23.  Electron  Diffraction 

The  essence  of  diffraction  phenomena.  Classical  mechanics  is  anal- 
ogous only  to  geometrical  optics  and  by  no  means  to  wave  optics. 
The  difference  between  mechanics  and  wave  optics  is  best  of  all  illus- 
trated by  the  example  of  diffraction  phenomena. 

Let  us  consider  the  following  experiment.  Let  there  be  a  screen  with 
two  small  apertures.  Let  us  assume  that  the  distance  between  the 
apertures  is  of  the  same  order  of  magnitude  as  the  apertures  themselves. 
Temporarily,  we  cover  one  of  the  apertures  and  direct  a  light  wave 
on  the  screen.  We  shall  observe  the  wave  passing  through  the  aper- 
ture by  the  intensity  distribution  on  a  second  screen  situated  behind 
the  first.  Let  us  now  cover  the  second  aperture.  The  intensity  distri- 
bution will  be  changed.  Now  let  us  open  both  apertures  at  once.  An 
intensity  distribution  will  be  obtained  which  will  not  in  any  way 
represent  the  sum  of  the  intensities  due  to  each  aperture  separately. 
At  the  points  of  the  screen,  at  which  the  waves  from  both  apertures 
arrive  in  opposite  phase,  they  will  mutually  cancel,  while  at  those 
points  at  which  the  phase  for  both  apertures  is  the  same,  they  will 
re-inforce  each  other.  In  other  words,  it  is  not  the  intensities  of  light, 
i.e.,  the  quadratic  values,  that  are  added,  but  the  values  of  the  fields 
themselves. 

This  type  of  diffraction  can  occur  only  because  the  wave  passes 
through  both  apertures.  Only  then  are  definite  phase  differences  ob- 
tained at  points  of  the  second  screen  for  rays  passing  through  each 
aperture. 

We  disregard  here  the  diffraction  effects  associated  with  the  passage 
through  one  aperture.  These  phenomena  are  due  to  the  phase  differ- 
ences of  the  rays  passing  through  various  points  of  the  aperture. 
Instead  of  examining  such  phase  differences  we  consider  that  the 
phase  of  a  wave  passing  through  each  aperture  is  constant,  but  we 
take  into  account  the  phase  differences  between  waves  passing  through 
different  apertures.  Nothing  is  essentially  changed  by  this  simplification. 

X-ray  diffraction.  In  order  to  observe  the  diffraction  of  X-rays  which 
are  of  considerably  shorter  wavelength  than  visible  light,  they  can  be 
made  to  scatter  by  correctly  arranged  atoms  in  a  crystal  lattice.  Waves, 
scattered  by  different  planes  of  the  lattice,  have  constant  phase  differ- 
ences 2  TU,  4  TC,  . . . ,  etc.,  for  definite  scattering  directions.  The  distance 
between  planes  of  the  lattice,  the  scattering  angles  at  which  maxima 
are  observed,  and  the  wavelength  are  related  by  a  simple  formula 
(the  Wolf-Bragg  condition).  From  this  equation  we  can  determine 
the  wavelength  of  X-radiation. 

Diffraction  by  a  crystal  lattice  is  somewhat  more  complicated  than 
in  the  experiment  with  two  apertures,  though,  fundamentally,  it 
occurs  for  the  same  reasons ;  the  wave  is  scattered  by  all  the  atoms  of 
the  lattice,  and  the  total  amplitude  of  the  scattered  wave  is  the  result 


Sec.  23]  ELECTRON  DIFFRACTION  239 

of  adding  all  the  amplitudes  of  the  waves  scattered  by  all  the  atoms, 
with  the  path  differences  of  the  rays,  i.e.,  the  phase  differences,  taken 
into  account. 

Electron  diffraction.  The  very  same  phenomena  is  observed  when 
electrons  (and  also  neutrons  and  other  microparticles)  are  scattered 
by  crystals.  As  we  know,  electrons  act  on  a  photographic  plate  or  a 
luminescent  screen  in  a  way  similar  to  X-rays ;  as  a  result,  direct  exper- 
iment shows  that  microparticles  undergo  diffraction  that  is  governed 
by  the  same  laws  as  the  diffraction  of  electromagnetic  waves. 

However,  for  this,  each  electron  must  be  scattered  by  all  the  atoms 
of  the  lattice,  because  the  electrons  travel  entirely  independently  of 
each  other;  there  can  be  no  coherence  (i.e.,  a  constant  phase  difference) 
between  them,  nor  can  any  arise.  They  may  even  pass  through  the 
crystal  singly  (see  below).  Only  light  waves  which  are  originated  from 
the  same  light  source  exhibit  diffraction  in  such  a  manner:  a  stable 
diffraction  pattern  is  obtained  because  the  same  wave  passes  through 
both  apertures.  If  the  waves  passing  through  the  apertures  originated 
at  different  sources  they  could  not  cancel  or  reinforce  each  other  at 
fixed  points  of  the  screen.  The  alternation  of  light  and  dark  regions 
would  depend  on  the  relative  phases  with  which  the  waves  passed 
through  the  apertures;  a  constant  phase  difference  cannot  be  main- 
tained for  light  from  different  sources. 

Electron  diffraction  demonstrates  that  the  laws  of  motion  in  the 
microworld  are  wave-like  in  character;  to  obtain  the  same  diffraction 
pattern  for  X-rays,  each  electron  must  be  scattered  by  all  the  atoms  of 
the  lattice.  This  is  clearly  incompatible  with  the  concept  of  a  definite 
electron  trajectory. 

Diffraction  phenomena  prove  that  electron  motion  is  associated  with 
a  phase  of  a  certain  magnitude. 

The  de  Broglie  wavelength.  From  diffraction  experiments  we  can, 
without  difficulty,  determine  the  wavelength  both  for  electrons  and 
for  X-rays.  For  electrons,  it  turns  out  to  be  very  simply  related  to 
their  velocities.  Let  us  write  down  the  expression  for  the  wave  vector 
obtained  from  experiment: 

k  =  £.  (23.1) 

Here,  A  is  a  universal  constant  having  the  dimensions  of  action  spoken 
of  in  the  preceding  section  (p.  229).  It  is  equal  to  1.054  x  10~27  erg-sec. 
Earlier,  it  was  much  more  common  to  use  a  constant  2  n  times  bigger. 
The  value  for  h  used  in  this  book  is  frequently  denoted  by  A. 

The  relation  (23.1)  was  suggested  in  1923  by  L.  de  Broglie,  before 
the  first  experiments  on  electron  diffraction.  The  quantity 

27T  _ 

A-~F-- 

is  called  the  de  Broglie  wavelength. 


240  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Equation  (23.2)  shows  that  a  certain  wavelength  can  be  ascribed 
to  the  motion  of  each  body,  but  in  the  motion  of  macroscopic  bodies 
it  is  extremely  small  as  a  result  of  the  smallness  of  h  compared  with 
the  quantities  which  characterize  the  motion  of  macroscopic  bodies, 
where  the  orders  of  magnitude  correspond  to  the  cgs  system.  There- 
fore, diffraction  phenomena  do  not  actually  restrict  the  applicability 
of  classical  mechanics  to  macroscopic  bodies. 

The  limits  of  applicability  of  classical  concepts.  The  relationship 
between  the  quantities  is  entirely  different  when  equation  (23.2) 
is  applied  to  the  motion  of  an  electron  in  an  atom.  The  size  of  an  atom 
is  determined,  for  example,  from  experiments  on  X-ray  diffraction  or, 
more  simply,  by  dividing  the  volume  of  one  gram-atom  of  condensed 
material  (solid  or  liquid)  by  the  Avogadro  number  N  =  6.024  x  1023. 
The  atomic  radius  is  of  the  order  of  0.5  x  10~8  cm.  From  this  it  is 
easy  to  evaluate  the  velocity  of  an  electron  by  equating  the  "centri- 
fugal force"  -^-  to  the  force  of  attraction  to  the  nucleus,  equal  to  -^ 
in  a  hydrogen  atom.  For  the  velocity,  the  value  obtained  is 


V  f^f 


whence  the  wavelength  (23.2)  is 

27th  1/jrJ 
A~      e      V  m   ' 

Substituting  the  numerical  values  m~10-27  gm,  e~4.8  x  io~10  CGSE, 
we  convince  ourselves  that  the  wavelength  is  approximately  six  times 
larger  than  r.  In  other  words,  a  distance  of  the  order  of  an  atomic 
diameter  can  accommodate  one  third  of  a  wave :  this  corresponds  to 
dimensions  which  are  characteristic  of  diffraction  phenomena  and  com- 
pletely "smears  out"  the  trajectory  over  the  atom. 

Hence  the  motion  of  an  electron  in  an  atom  is  wave  motion.  Just 
as  the  concept  of  a  ray  has  no  place  in  optics,  if  the  light  is  propagated 
in  a  region  comparable  with  the  wavelength,  so  the  concept  of  an  elec- 
tron trajectory  becomes  meaningless  for  the  motion  of  an  electron  in 
an  atom. 

The  electron  is  not  a  wave,  but  a  particle!  It  is  necessary  to  warn 
the  reader  against  certain  common  delusions.  First  of  all,  contrary  to 
what  is  often  written  in  the  popular  literature,  the  electron  is  never 
a  wave  even  in  quantum  considerations.  Without  any  doubt  the  elec- 
tron remains  a  particle;  for  example,  it  is  never  possible  to  observe 
part  of  an  electron.  If  a  photographic  plate  replaces  the  second  (rear) 
screen  in  the  diffraction  experiment,  then  at  the  point  of  incidence  of 
each  electron  there  will  appear  a  single  point  of  blackening.  The  point 
distribution  characteristic  of  a  diffraction  pattern  will  also  result  when 


Sec.  23]  ELECTRON  DIFFRACTION  241 

the  electrons  pass  through  a  crystal  singly.  *  Thus,  it  is  not  the  electron 
that  becomes  a  wave,  but  the  laws  of  motion  in  the  microworld  that 
are  wave-like  in  character. 

It  is  clear  that  a  diffraction  pattern  can  in  no  way  be  obtained  from 
a  single  electron.  Since  each  electron  gives  a  single  point  on  the  screen, 
we  must  have  very  many  separate  points  in  order  to  obtain  the  correct 
alternation  of  light  and  dark  regions  on  the  plate. 

At  the  same  time,  diffraction  would  be  utterly  impossible  if  both 
screen  apertures  or  all  the  crystal  atoms  did  not  actually  participate 
in  the  passage  of  one  and  the  same  electron.  In  the  diffraction  experi- 
ment, electron  trajectories  simply  do  not  exist.  What  is  actually  wave- 
like  in  the  motion  of  a  particle  will  be  shown  later. 

In  all  its  properties,  the  electron  is  a  particle.  Its  mass  and  charge 
always  belong  to  it  and  are  never  divided  in  any  diffraction  experiment 
or  any  other  experiment  that  we  know. 

The  incompatibility  of  trajectories  and  diffraction  phenomena. 
Another  common  delusion  is  that  the  electron  supposedly  does  possess 
a  trajectory  but  that  we  are  as  yet  unable  to  observe  it  due  to  imper- 
fections in  technical  facilities,  or  to  the  inadequacy  of  our  physical 
knowledge.  In  actual  fact,  the  diffraction  experiment  shows  that  the 
electron  definitely  does  not  have  a  trajectory,  just  as  diffracted  light 
is  not  propagated  in  rays.  To  think  that  the  development  of  physics 
will  in  future  show  the  existence  of  an  electron  trajectory  in  the  atom 
is  just  as  unreasonable  as  to  hope  for  the  return  of  phlogiston  in  heat 
theory,  or  of  a  geocentric  world  system  in  astronomy. 

Statistical  regularity  and  the  individual  experiment.  The  absence  of 
trajectories  by  no  means  signifies  that  we  have  lost  all  regularity.  On 
the  contrary,  an  identical  diffraction  experiment,  performed,  of  course, 
with  a  large  number  of  separate  electrons  of  definite  velocity,  always 
yields  an  identical  diffraction  pattern.  Thus,  causal  regularity  undoubt- 
edly exists.  However,  it  is  statistical  in  character  appearing  in  a  very 
large  number  of  separate  experiments,  because  each  electron  passage 
through  a  crystal  may  be  regarded  as  a  separate  independent  result. 

Diffraction  phenomena  lead  to  a  regular  distribution  of  points  on  a 
photographic  plate  in  the  same  way  that  a  large  number  of  shots  at 
a  target  is  subject  to  a  law  of  dispersion.  However,  as  opposed  to  bullets 
which  fly  along  trajectories  and  therefore  give  a  smooth  distribution 
curve  for  the  places  where  they  strike  the  target,  the  blackened  grains 
on  a  photographic  plate  caused  by  electrons  are  produced  in  a  more 
intricate  manner  characteristic  of  wave  motion.  The  distribution  of  bullet 
fits  is  due  to  indeterminacy  in  the  initial  firing  conditions  and  becomes 
less  in  the  case  of  better  aiming,  while  the  random  character  of  electron 


*  In  somewhat  different  form,  this  was  shown  by  direct  experiment  by 
V.  A.  Fabrikant,  N.  G.  Sushkin  and  L.  M.  Biberman,  using  currents  of  very 
low  intensity. 


16  -  0060 


242  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

behaviour  presents  a  perfectly  regular  diffraction  pattern  and,  for  a 
given  electron  velocity,  can  in  no  way  be  reduced. 

In  addition,  it  may  be  noted  that  the  statistical  regularity  in  a 
diffraction  experiment  has  nothing  to  do  with  the  statistical  regular- 
ities which  govern  the  motion  of  a  large  ensemble  of  interacting  par- 
ticles. As  has  already  been  repeated  several  times,  the  same  pattern 
is  obtained  completely  independently  of  the  way  in  which  the  elec- 
trons pass  through  the  crystal  —  all  at  once,  or  singly.  A  certain  phase 
governing  the  motion  exists  only  because  each  electron  interferes  with 
itself. 

Electron  trajectories  in  a  Wilson  cloud  chamber.  It  still  remains  to 
examine  in  more  detail  the  question:  In  which  cases  do  we,  neverthe- 
less, deal  with  the  concept  of  an  electron  trajectory  ?  In  a  cloud  cham- 
ber, in  a  cathode  -ray  oscilloscope,  and  in  many  other  instruments, 
electron  trajectories  can  be  precalculated  very  well  from  the  laws  of 
classical  mechanics.  In  a  cloud  chamber,  there  even  remains  a  cloud 
track  along  the  line  of  motion  of  an  electron.* 

First,  recall  that  under  certain  conditions  light  is  also  propagated 
along  definite  trajectories  (rays).  Geometrical  optics  is  applicable  when 
the  inaccuracy  in  defining  the  wave  vector  Afc,  subject  to  the  inequal- 
ity 

7r  (23.3) 


[see  (18.9)],  is  small  in  comparison  with  k.  Substituting  Afc*  for  an 
electron  in  equation  (23.1),  we  obtain  the  analogous  expression  of 
quantum  theory: 

(23.4) 


This  is  the  so-called  uncertainty  relation  of  quantum  mechanics.  The 
concept  of  an  electron  trajectory  has  reasonable  meaning  if  the  un- 
certainties of  all  three  momentum  components  kpx,  A^y,  A^  are 
small  compared  with  the  momentum  itself: 

&px<px,  &py^py,  &PZ<PZ.  (23.5) 

It  may  be  pointed  out  that  we  have  all  along  been  saying  c  'electron" 
simply  to  be  specific.  The  same  applies  to  a  proton,  neutron,  meson 
and  the  like. 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  track  of  an  electron  in  a  cloud  chamber  is 
0.01  cm  wide  and  the  electron  energy  is  equal  to  1.000  ev  =  1.6  x  10~9 


erg  (1  electron-volt  =  4'8  =  1.6  X  10~12  erg).  According  to  (23.4) 


*  An  electron  passing  through  a  gas  ionizes  the  atoms  in  its  path.  The 
supersaturated  vapour  with  which  the  chamber  is  filled  condenses  on  the  ions. 
Upon  illumination,  the  droplets  appear  in  the  form  of  a  cloud  track. 

**  Sometimes,  Ap*,  A#  are  meant  to  signify  not  the  "spreadings"  px  and  x 
in  themselves,  but  their  mean  square  values.  Then,  Apx  Aa?  >  h. 


Sec.  23]  ELECTRON   DIFFRACTION  243 

the  component  of  momentum  perpendicular  to  the  trajectory  has  an 
indeterminacy 

6.6  x  10-"   ^66><10_25> 

and  the  momentum  itself  is 

p  =  V2m  $  =  V2.9  x  10~36  =  1.7  x  10-18. 

It  follows  that  the  relationships  (23.5)  are  satisfied  to  an  accuracy 
of  up  to  four  parts  in  ten  million.  The  observation  of  a  track  in  a 
cloud  chamber  does  not  allow  us  to  determine  the  trajectory  with 
accuracy  sufficient  to  notice  deviations  (in  electron  motion)  from  the 
laws  of  classical  mechanics. 

The  limitations  of  the  concepts  of  classical  mechanics.  Thus,  quantum 
mechanics  does  not  abolish  classical  mechanics,  but  contains  it  as  a 
limiting  case,  much  the  same  as  wave  optics  includes  the  geometrical 
optics  of  light  rays  as  a  limiting  case.  As  we  shall  see  later,  quantum 
mechanics  is  concerned  with  the  same  quantities  as  classical  mechan- 
ics, i.e.,  energy,  momentum,  coordinates,  moment.  But  the  finiteness 
of  the  quantum  of  action  h  imposes  a  limitation  on  the  applicability 
of  any  two  classical  concepts  (for  example,  coordinates  and  momen- 
tum) for  one  and  the  same  motion. 

The  coordinate  and  momentum  of  an  electron  cannot  simultaneously 
have  precise  values  because  the  motion  is  wave-like.  To  attempt  to 
define  these  precise  values  is  just  as  meaningless  physically  as  it  is 
to  seek  precise  trajectories  for  light  rays  in  wave  optics.  In  the  same 
way  that  it  is  impossible  to  obtain,  as  a  result  of  improvements  in 
optical  devices,  a  precise  definition  for  light  rays  in  wave  optics,  any 
progress  in  measuring  techniques  as  applied  to  the  electron  will  not 
allow  us  to  determine  its  trajectory  more  precisely  than  indicated  by 
the  relation  (23.4),  since  strictly  speaking  the  trajectory  does  not  exist. 

Attempts  are  sometimes  made  to  interpret  relation  (23.4)  errone- 
ously. It  is  taken  that  a  trajectory  cannot  be  determined  because 
the  precision  of  the  initial  conditions  does  not  exceed  Ap*  and  A# 
connected  by  relation  (23.4).  This  would  mean  that  some  actual  tra- 
jectory does  exist  but  that  it  lies  within  a  more  or  less  narrow  region 
of  space  and  within  a  certain  range  of  momenta.  The  "real"  trajectory 
is  likened  to  the  imaginary  trajectory  from  a  gun  to  a  target  before 
firing.  The  path  of  the  bullet  is  not  precisely  known  beforehand,  if 
only  because  strictly  identical  powder  charges  cannot  be  obtained. 
But  this  inaccuracy  in  the  initial  conditions  for  the  bullet  only  leads 
to  a  smooth  dispersion  curve  for  the  hits  on  the  target,  while  the  distri- 
bution of  electrons  indicates  diffraction  effects.  The  presence  of  dif- 
fraction shows  that  no  *  'real-though-unknown -to-us"  trajectory  exists. 
As  a  matter  of  fact,  relation  (23.4)  by  no  means  indicates  with  what 
error  certain  quantities  may  be  measured  simultaneously,  but  to  what 

16* 


244  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

extent  these  quantities  have  precise  meaning  in  the  given  motion. 
It  is  this  that  the  uncertainty  principle  of  quantum  mechanics  expresses. 
The  term  "uncertainty"  emphasizes  the  fact  that  what  we  are  con- 
cerned with  is  not  accidental  errors  of  measurement  or  the  imperfection 
of  physical  apparatus,  but  the  fact  of  momentum  and  coordinate  of 
a  particle  being  actually  nonexistent  in  the  same  state. 


Sec.  24.  The  Wave  Equation 

The  wave  function.  Diffraction  of  light  occurs  because  the  wave 
amplitudes  are  added.  When  the  wave  phases  coincide  the  intensity 
(which  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the  resultant  amplitude)  is 
maximum;  when  the  phases  are  opposite  the  intensity  is  minimum. 
In  the  diffraction  of  electrons,  a  quantity  similar  to  intensity  is  meas- 
ured by  the  blackening  of  a  plate,  which  blackening  is  proportional 
to  the  number  of  electrons  incident  on  unit  area.  The  distribution  of 
the  blackened  grains  on  the  plate  obeys  the  same  law  as  in  the  case 
of  the  diffraction  of  X-rays  (in  the  sense  of  alternation  of  maxima  and 
their  relative  positions).  Thus,  in  order  to  explain  the  diffraction  of 
electrons  we  must  assume  that  with  their  motion  there  can  be  associat- 
ed some  wave  function  whose  phase  determines  the  diffraction  pattern. 

At  the  end  of  this  section,  we  will  show  in  the  general  case  that  such 
a  wave  function  must  be  complex,  since  a  real  wave  function  cannot 
correspond  to  just  any  type  of  motion. 

Probability  density.  Electrons  move  independently  of  one  another 
and  pass  through  a  crystal  singly,  as  it  were.  Therefore,  the  number 
of  electrons  in  an  element  of  volume  dV  is  proportional  to  the  proba- 
bility of  the  appearance  of  one  electron.  Probability  (a  quantity  simi- 
lar to  light  intensity)  must  be  quadratic  with  respect  to  the  wave 
function,  in  the  same  way  that  light  intensity  is  quadratic  in  wave 
amplitude.  But  since  probability  is  a  real  quantity,  it  can  only  depend 
on  the  square  of  the  modulus  of  the  wave  function.  Let  us  put 

dw  =  |  <p  (x9  y,  z,  t)  \*dV.  (24.1) 

Here  Aw  is  the  probability  of  finding  an  electron  in  the  volume  dV 
at  the  instant  t ;  then  |  <J>  |2  is  the  probability  referred  to  unit  volume 
or,  otherwise,  the  probability  density. 

The  linearity  of  the  wave  equation.  Like  in  optics,  where  the  laws 
of  propagation  of  the  wave  itself  are  studied  on  the  basis  of  Maxwell's 
equations,  the  intensity  being  found  by  squaring  the  wave  amplitude, 
it  is  necessary  in  quantum  mechanics  to  find  the  equation  governing 
the  quantity  fy  and  not  the  probability  density.  This  equation  must 
be  linear.  Indeed,  two  interfering  waves,  when  combined,  give  a  result- 
ant wave.  In  order  to  obtain  the  same  interference  pattern  as  in 
optics,  it  is  necessary  to  perform  a  simple  algebraic  addition  of  the 


Sec.  24]  THE  WAVE  EQUATION  245 

functions ;  both  the  summands  and  the  sum  must  satisfy  the  same  wave 
equation.  But  only  the  solution  of  linear  equations  satisfy  this  require- 
ment. The  phases  of  the  waves  are  very  essential  here  since  in  order  to 
formulate  the  laws  of  diffraction  it  is  necessary  to  know  not  only  the 
behaviour  of  the  squares  of  the  amplitude  but  also  that  of  their  phases. 

In  other  words,  we  must  have  an  equation  for  the  wave  function 
itself  of  the  particle  <Jj  (x,  y,  z,  t). 

The  wave  function  of  a  free  particle.  Proceeding  from  the  analogy 
between  geometrical  optics  and  mechanics,  it  is  easy  to  construct  a 
wave  corresponding  to  a  free  particle  not  subject  to  the  action  of 
external  forces.  We  know  that  the  state  of  a  free  particle  is  character- 
ized by  its  momentum  p.  But,  in  accordance  with  relationship  (23.1), 

a  wave  with  wave  vector  k  =  -j-  corresponds  to  a  particle  with  momen- 
tum p.  It  follows  that  the  wave  function  of  a  free  particle  depends  on 
coordinates  in  the  following  way  (we  write  it  in  complex  form): 

i  P- 

eiJ«  =  el~h  . 

The  time  dependence  of  a  wave  function  is  also  determined  very 
simply,  if  we  recall  that  the  frequency  of  a  wave  corresponds  to  the 
particle  energy  (Sec.  22).  The  proportionality  factor  between  them 
has  the  dimensions  of  action.  As  was  shown  at  the  end  of  Sec.  22,  the 
factor  of  proportionality  must  be  the  same  as  between  the  wave  vector 
and  momentum ;  this  follows  from  the  condition  of  relativistic  invar- 
iance  of  the  correspondence  between  mechanical  and  optical  quanti- 
ties.* Hence 

<*)  =  -f"  •  <24-2) 

Whence  we  obtain  the  wave  function  of  a  free  particle 

(24.3) 
The  group  velocity  of  the  waves  is 

v  =  |f  =  ?f-  .  (24.4) 

dk          dp  v          ' 

Hence,  it  coincides  with  the  particle  velocity  as  it  should  in  accordance 
with  (22.12),  thereby  confirming  (24.2). 

The  relation  between  wave  function  and  action.  We  note  that  the 
wave  function  (24.3)  may  be  written  in  the  form 

ty  =  e  IT  ,  (24.5) 


*  Or  at  least  from  in  variance  to  Galilean  transformations. 


246  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

where  8  is  the  action  of  the  particle.  Indeed,  the  action  of  a  free  par- 
ticle is 

&=-**+pr,  (24.6) 

because  from  this  we  obtain 


F  —    dT    —  v  w,          ^  —  a<    , 

as  should  be  the  case  according  to  equations  (22.9)  and  (22.11). 

Equation  (24.5)  confirms  the  relationship  established  also  in  Sec.  22 
between  the  wave  phase  and  the  action  of  a  particle. 

The  wave  equation  for  a  free  particle.  The  analogy  between  mechanics 
and  optics  by  no  means  presupposes  that  the  equations  of  mechanics 
are  written  in  a  relativistically  invariant  form.  It  is  sufficient  to  recall 
that  the  analogy  had  already  been  established  by  Hamilton  in  1825. 
The  significance  of  the  analogy  consists  in  the  fact  that  a  correspond- 
ence is  established  between  quantities :  momentum  and  wave  vector, 
energy  and  frequency,  action  and  phase.  In  future,  except  in  those 
cases  where  it  is  specifically  stated  otherwise,  we  shall  proceed  from 
the  nonrelativistic  form  of  the  equations  of  mechanics. 

Let  us  now  find  the  differential  equation  satisfied  by  the  wave  func- 
tion (24.3).  We  have 

**.=       ",[,,  (24.7) 


_dj<___3_     ~ 


h 


8x  2  '"  (24.8) 

dz  fy  px 

~dx*  ^         W 


Erom  (24.7)  and  (24.8)  we  obtain 
h  *  +  &' 


(here  we  are  already  using  nonrelativistic  expressions!),  or  in  abbre- 
viated form 


where  A    s  the  Laplacian  operator.  Equation  (24.10)  holds  because 
g  =  -£—  ,  as  can  be  seen  from  (24.9). 

The  Schrodinger  equation.  Let  us  now  generalize  equation  (24.10) 
to  the  case  of  a  particle  moving  in  an  external  potential  field  U.  In 

order  to  have  a  relation  analogous  to   ^  =  -j-  —  h  U  since  S  =  ~— 
for  a  free  particle  in  (24.9),  we  must  put 


See.  24]  THE    WAVE   EQUATION  24J 

E.  Schrodinger  formulated  this  equation  in  1925,  generalizing  the 
de  Broglie  relations  for  free  electrons  to  the  case  of  bound  electrons 
(this  was  also  before  the  discovery  of  electron  diffraction). 

Equation  (24.11)  directly  follows  from  (24.10)  for  the  simplest  case 
[7  =  const,  because  then  it  is  satisfied  by  the  same  substitution  of 
(24.3),  though  with  the  momentum  value  p  =  V~2m($  —  U) .  From 
here  it  is  only  one  step  to  generalization  to  the  case  of  variable  poten- 
tial energy. 

But  this  generalization  must  in  no  way  be  regarded  as  the  deriva- 
tion of  the  Schrodinger  equation  from  the  equations  of  prequantum 
physics,  for  it  expresses  a  new  physical  law. 

Its  relationship  to  classical  physics  can  be  seen  in  the  limiting  tran- 
sition, which  is  fully  analogous  to  the  transition  from  wave  optics 
to  geometrical  optics. 

The  limiting  transition  to  classical  mechanics.  Let  us  substitute  the 
expression  for  the  wave  function  (24.5)  in  (24.11).  This  expression  must 
hold  in  the  above  limiting  transition  because  then  the  wave  phase 
surfaces  9=  const  correspond  to  surfaces  of  constant  action  S  =  const 
for  particles. 

9=X'  (24.12) 

Instead  of  the  formal  relationship  considered  in  Sec.  22,  we  now 
have  an  equality,  since  we  have  introduced  a  new,  universal  physical 

constant  h.  Thus,  we  put 

._$_ 

Whence 

d<\i  __   i    dS   , 
~df  ~~  ~h~dT^ '' 
^L  —    *    d#    , 


i   8ZS   , L/a>Sf 

~h"dx*V  ~~  fcMlte" 


Let  us  substitute  these  derivatives  in  (24.11).  Then,  after  eliminating 
p,  we  obtain  the  equality 


The  limiting  transition  from  quantum  to  classical  mechanics  is 
attained  by  considering  the  de  Broglie  wavelength  very  small  com- 
pared with  the  region  in  which  motion  occurs.  Since  the  wavelength 
is  proportional  to  the  quantum  of  action  A,  the  same  limiting  transition 
may  be  performed  formally  by  considering  that  h  tends  to  zero. 
This  means  that  all  the  quantities  having  the  dimensions  of  action 


248  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

are  so  large  compared  with  the  quantum  h,  that  the  latter  can  be 
neglected.  In  (24.13),  passing  to  the  limit  &  =  0,  we  have 


a's'  _ 
~~~0T~    2m     l~"  *"'"' 

or  g  =  -^  +  U  from  (22.9)  and  (22.11). 

The  limiting  transition  that  we  have  performed  here  almost  com- 
pletely repeats  the  transition  from  wave  optics  to  geometrical  optics 
carried  out  in  Sec.  22. 

The  correspondence  between  classical  and  quantum  theory.  We 
have  seen  that  the  Schrodinger  wave  equation  does  in  fact  give  a 
correct  limiting  transition.  This  equation  is,  as  it  were,  a  fourth 
member  in  the  following  correspondence: 

geometrical  optics >   classical  mechanics 

I  1 

wave  optics ->      quantum  mechanics  I 

The  vertical  arrows  denote  a  transition  from  rays  or  trajectories 
to  wave  patterns,  while  the  horizontal  arrows  denote  a  transition 
from  waves  to  particles.  The  latter  relates  only  to  nonquantum 
electrodynamics  because  in  the  transition  to  quantum  field  equations 
the  need  arises  for  a  corpuscular  representation  (see  Sec.  27).  Here, 
we  consider  only  the  analogy  between  quantum  mechanics  and 
classical  wave  optics. 

The  range  of  application  of  various  theories.  The  regions  in  which 
quantum  mechanics  and  wave  optics  can  be  applied  do  not  overlap 
anywhere ;  in  wave  optics  or,  what  is  just  the  same,  in  electrodynamics, 
the  velocity  of  light  c  is  regarded  as  finite  but  the  quantum  of  action  h 
is  considered  arbitrarily  small.  In  nonrelativistic  quantum  mechanics, 
c  is  considered  arbitrarily  large  while  h  has  a  finite  value.  A  quantum 
theory  of  the  electromagnetic  field,  in  which  both  h  and  c  have  finite 
values  (i.e.,  the  velocity  ranges  are  comparable  with  c,  and  quantities 
with  the  dimensions  of  action  are  comparable  with  h),  has,  in  essentials, 
also  been  completed  at  the  present  time.  At  any  rate,  any  concrete 
problem  requiring  the  application  of  quantum  electrodynamics,  may 
be  uniquely  solved  to  any  required  degree  of  precision,  and  the  results 
agree  with  experiment.  The  existence  of  a  light  quantum  as  an  in- 
dependent particle  is  not  a  supplementary  hypothesis  which  must 
be  made  in  order  to  formulate  quantum  electrodynamical  equations. 
The  consistent  quantization  of  electromagnetic  field  equations 
necessarily  leads  to  the  corpuscular  aspect  of  the  theory  (for  more 
detail  see  Sec.  27). 


Sec.  24]  THE  WAVE  EQUATION  249 

The  nonrelativistic  particle  quantum  mechanics  (i.e.,  constructed 
on  the  relation  $  =  -J~-  +  U)  is,  in  the  region  for  which  it  is  applicable, 

a  theory  which  is  just  as  consummate  as  Newtonian  mechanics. 
Like  the  equations  of  Newtonian  mechanics,  the  wave  equation 
(24.11)  is  valid  only  for  particle  velocities  small  compared  with  the 
velocity  of  light.  But  still,  in  the  region  for  which  it  is  applicable, 
it  is  just  as  firmly  established  (in  the  same  sense)  as  are  the  Newtonian 
laws  for  the  motion  of  macroscopic  bodies. 

The  grounds  for  this  are  absolutely  the  same — both  nonrelativistic 
quantum  theory  and  Newtonian  mechanics  agree  with  the  widest 
range  of  experimental  data,  never  contradicting  them  and  providing 
for  correct  and  unique  predictions.  In  addition,  they  nowhere  contain 
contradictory  statements.  The  latter  condition  is,  of  course,  not 
sufficient  for  a  physical  theory  to  be  correct  but  it  is  at  least  necessary. 
The  Bohr  theory,  or  the  old  quantum  mechanics  (as  it  is  otherwise 
known)  did  not  satisfy  this  requirement;  in  addition  to  the  classical 
concept  of  trajectory,  it  involved  the  quantum  concept  of  discreteness 
of  states.  For  this  reason,  it  had  always  been  clear  that  the  Bohr 
formulation  of  quantum  theory  was  not  final  and  should  be  revised, 
no  matter  how  wide  the  range  of  experimental  facts  that  it  explained. 

Quantum  mechanics  permitted  the  construction  of  a  consistent 
theory  of  atomic  structure.  The  actual  calculation  of  wave  functions 
for  electrons  in  complex  atoms  is  a  problem  of  enormous  mathematical 
complexity.*  However,  it  is,  of  course,  by  no  means  the  purpose 
of  quantum  mechanics  to  calculate  the  spectra  of  complex  atoms: 
the  essential  point  is  that  quantum  mechanics  allows  us  to  systematize 
atomic  and  molecular  states  in  such  a  way  that  the  very  nature 
of  the  spectra  is  understood,  whereas  classical  mechanics  could  not 
explain  even  the  stability  of  the  atom.  Thanks  to  quantum  mechanics 
such  fundamentally  important  facts  as  the  chemical  affinity  of  atoms 
or  Mendeleyev's  periodic  law  are  now  understood. 

In  its  domain,  quantum  mechanics  will,  of  course,  perfect  methods 
of  approach  to  various  concrete  problems.  The  correctness  of  its 
general  principles  will  serve  as  a  basis  for  such  refinement. 

The  normalization  condition  for  a  wave  function.  Let  us  return 
to  the  wave  equation  (24.11).  We  shall  write  it  for  a  wave  function  <p 
and  a  conjugate  function  fy*  (in  the  second  equation  we  have  to 
replace  —  i  by  i): 


*  It  is  considerably  simplified  thanks  to  approximation  methods  suggested 
by  V.  A.  Fok. 


250  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Let  us  multiply  the  first  equation  by  <|**,  and  the  second  by  fy, 
and  subtract  the  second  from  the  first.  The  term  ip*  Ufy  is  eliminated 
and  the  remaining  terms  give 

-      (24-15) 


The  left-hand  side  of  the  last  equality  is  transformed  to  the  form 

_  fc_JLj;»j,  —  —  AJLm2 
We  can  write  the  right-hand  side  more  fully  thus: 

hz                                                    hz 
_ /^* £±ih  —  d>Adf*)  =  — (d>*  divgrad  A  —  &  divgrad  d**)  = 

2971  2tTf\t 

=  — ^ —  d*v  (41*  grftd ^  —  ^ grad  ^*) 

[see   (11.27)].  Finally,  we  represent  the  equality  obtained  in  the 
following  form: 


The  left-hand  side  of  this  equality  is  the  time  derivative  of  the  prob- 
ability density  of  finding  a  particle  close  to  some  point  of  space. 
Let  us  integrate  (24.16)  over  the  whole  volume  in  which  the  particle 
might  be  situated.  If  this  volume  is  finite  then  beyond  its  boundaries  fy 
and  ij>*  must  be  equal  to  zero.  But  then,  from  the  Gauss-Ostrogradsky 
theorem 


It  follows  that  the  integral  itself  does  not  depend  upon  time.  It  is 
easy  to  see  that  it  must  be  equal  to  unity  because  this  is  the  probability 
of  an  electron  being  somewhere,  i.e.,  the  probability  of  a  trustworthy 
event.  The  condition 


J  |  ^2^7^!  (24.18) 


is  called  the  normalization  condition  of  a  wave  function. 

If  the  electron  motion  is  infinite,  i.e.,  ip  nowhere  becomes  zero, 
the  normalization  condition  appears  more  complicated.  However, 
in  practice,  it  is  always  possible  to  consider  that  the  volume  in  which 
the  electron  is  situated  is  very  large  and  finite,  so  that  the  condition 
(24.18)  can  be  used.  The  physical  results,  naturally,  do  not  depend 
upon  the  arbitrary  choice  of  volume. 

Probability-flux  density.  If  we  integrate  (24.16)  over  any  arbitrary 
volume,  we  obtain 


Sec.  24]  THE    WAVE    EQUATION  251 


(24'19) 

If  on  the  left  we  have  the  change  in  the  probability  of  finding 
an  electron  inside  the  given  volume,  then  on  the  right-hand  side 
we  must  have  the  flux  of  the  probability  of  it  passing  through  the 
boundary  surface  of  the  volume.  According  to  (24.19)  the  density 
rf  the  probability  flux  is  equal  to 


It  follows  that  a  real  wave  function  gives  j  =  0,  i.e.,  it  cannot 
be  used  for  describing  the  current  of  an  electron.  Therefore,  in  a  general 
lefinition,  the  wave  function  ^  must  be  a  complex  quantity. 

The  equation  for  stationary  states.  Let  us  assume  that  potential 
energy  does  not  depend  explicitly  upon  time.  Then  classical  mechanics 
leads  to  conservation  of  energy  of  the  system.  The  action  of  such 

.    o 

a  system  involves  a  term  —  St.  But  since  fy  =e   h    in  quantum 
mechanics,  too,  we  must  seek  a  wave  function  in  the  form 

.  fft 
ty  =  e    '  *  <M*,y,z).  (24.21) 

Substituting  this  in  (24.11)  and  omitting  the  zero  subscript,  we  obtain 
}he  equation 

#<1>.  (24.22) 


As  we  shall  see  in  the  next  section,  this  equation  has  a  solution 
which  does  not  satisfy  definite  necessary  conditions  for  all  values 
of  $.  Thus,  it  turns  out  that,  in  contrast  to  the  energy  in  classical 
mechanics,  the  energy  of  a  quantum  system  cannot  always  be 
arbitrarily  given. 

Exercise 

Prove  that  if  there  are  two  solutions  of  (24.22)  for  different  values  of  energy 
ff  and  <$",  then 


J 


The  functions  ^*  (r%  &)  and  ^  (r,  #')  satisfy  the  equations 


-- 


252 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


Let  us  multiply  the  first  equation  by  ^>  the  second  by  t[»*,  and  subtract  the 
second  from  the  first.  Integrating  over  the  whole  volume,  similar  to  (24.19), 
and  then  transforming  the  volume  integral  on  the  left  to  a  surface  integral, 
we  obtain  the  equation 


_£")  f  tt*(r,g)ty(r,&' 


It  follows  that  if  S ^§',  then  the  second  factor  is  equal  to  zero  as  required. 
This  is  the  so-called  orthogonality  property  of  wave  functions.  It  will  be  shown 
in  more  general  form  in  Sec.  30  because  it  forms  one  of  the  most  important 
principles  of  quantum  mechanics. 


Sec.  25.  Certain  Problems  of  Quantum  Mechanics 

In  this  section  we  shall  obtain  solutions  to  the  wave  equation 

for  certain  cases  which  are  partly  illustrative  and  partly  auxiliary. 

Nevertheless,  many  important  laws  are  explained  from  these  examples. 
We  have  already  obtained  the  solution  of  the  wave  equation  for 

a  free  particle  (24.3).  We  shall  now  examine  the  solutions  for  bound 

particles. 
A  particle  in  a  one-dimensional,  infinitely  deep  potential  well.  Let 

us  suppose  that  a  particle  is  constrained  to  move  in  one  dimension 
U  remaining  in  an  interval  of  length  a,  so 

that  Q^x^a.  We  can  imagine  that  at 
the  points  x  =  0  and  x  ==  a,  there  are  ab- 
solutely impenetrable  walls  which  reflect 
the  particle.  A  limitation  of  this  type  is 
represented  with  the  aid  of  the  potential 
energy  curve  shown  in  Fig.  36.  U  —  oo 
at  x<0  and  x>a.  We  put  U  =  Q  at 
0<#<a;  this  is  the  potential  energy 
gauge.  To  leave  the  region  0^x<a,  a 
particle  would  have  to  perform  an  in- 
finitely large  quantity  of  work.  Thus, 


x 


Fig.  36 


the  probability  for  the  particle  to  be  at  x  —  0  or  x  —  a  is  equal  to  zero. 
With  the  aid  of  (24.1),  we  obtain 

^(0)  =  &(a)  =  0  .  (25.1) 

These  boundary  conditions  may  also  be  justified  by  means  of  a  limiting 
transition  from  a  well  of  finite  depth.  This  will  be  done  later. 

Insofar  as  the  potential  energy  is  time  independent,  the  wave 
equation  must  be  written  in  the  form  of  (24.22).  The  motion  is  one- 

»2 

dimensional  and,  therefore,  we  must  take  the  total  derivative  -^T2 
in  place  of  A.  From  this  we  have 


(26.2) 


Sec.  25]  CERTAIN   PROBLEMS    OF    QUANTUM    MECHANICS  253 

We  introduce  the  shortened  notation 

-^^x-,  (25.3) 

so  that  the  wave  equation  will  be  of  the  form 

*£~  =  -x*ty.  (25.4) 

The  solution  to  (25.4)  is  well  known: 

<p  =  C1  sin  Y.X  +  C2  cos  Y.X  .  (25.5) 

But  from  (25.1)  ip  (0)  =  0  so  that  the  cosine  term  must  be  omitted 
by  putting  (72  =  0.  There  remains 

<p  =  CI  sin  x  x .  (25.6) 
We  now  substitute  the  second  boundary  condition 

<Jj  (a)  =  Cl  sin  x  a  =  0 .  (25.7) 
This  is  an  equation  in  ^.  It  has  an  infinite  number  of  solutions: 

xa  =  (n+l)7r,  (25.8) 
where  n  is  any  integer  equal  to  or  greater  than  zero: 

0  <  n  <  oo  .  (25.9) 

We  discard  the  value  n==  —  1  because,  for  n—  —  1,  the  wave  function 
becomes  zero  everywhere,  ^  =  8^0  =  0.  Hence,  |<p|2  =  0,  so  that  the 
particle  simply  does  not  exist  anywhere  (a  "trivial  solution").  Now 
substituting  /  from  the  definition  (25.3)  and  solving  (25.8)  with  respect 
bo  energy,  we  find  an  expression  for  the  energy 

^ h*  >+l)2.  (25.10) 


Eigenvalues  of  energy  and  eigenlunctions.  The  boundary  condition 
imposed  on  a  wave  function  is,  for  a  given  problem,  just  as  necessary 
as  the  wave  equation  itself.  However,  as  can  be  seen  from  (25.10), 
the  boundary  condition  is  not  satisfied  for  all  values  of  the  energy, 
but  only  for  values  belonging  to  a  definite  series  of  numbers  by  which 
the  problem  under  consideration  is  given.  It  will  be  seen  later  on 
that,  depending  upon  the  conditions,  these  numbers  may  form  a 
discrete  series  or  a  continuous  sequence.  They  are  called  eigenvalues 
of  the  energy  of  a  quantum  mechanical  system.  The  wave  functions 
belonging  to  the  energy  eigenvalues  are  called  eigenf unctions. 

The  foregoing  example  is  the  simplest,  one  in  which  the  energy 
eigenvalues  form  a  discrete  series.  The  energy  of  a  free  particle  forms 
a  continuous  series  of  eigenvalues.  Indeed,  the  only  condition  which 


254  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

can  be  imposed  on  the  wave  function  of  a  free  particle  consists  in 
the  fact  that  it  must  be  finite  everywhere,  because  the  square  of 
its  modulus  is  the  probability  density  of  finding  the  particle  at  a 
given  point  in  space.  But  the  function  (24.3)  remains  finite  for  all 
real  values  of  p  and  $. 

The  assembly  of  energy  eigenvalues  of  a  particle  is  termed  its 
energy  spectrum.  The  energy  spectrum  in  an  infinitely  deep  potential 
well  is  discrete,  while  the  energy  spectrum  of  a  free  particle  is 
continuous. 

The  solution  of  Schrodinger's  equation  (24.22)  for  stationary  states 
is  always  associated  with  finding  the  energy  spectrum.  In  contrast 
to  the  Bohr  theory,  where  the  discreteness  of  the  states  appeared 
as  a  necessary  but  foreign  appendage  to  classical  motion,  in  quantum 
mechanics  the  very  nature  of  the  motion  determines  the  energy 
spectrum.  This  will  be  seen  especially  clearly  in  the  examples  to  follow. 

The  nodes  or  zeros  of  a  wave  function.  The  function  ^  becomes  zero  n 
times  in  the  interval  0  —  a  (except  at  its  ends).  The  quantity  of 
zeros  ("nodes")  of  a  wave  function  is  equal  to  the  number  of  the 
subscript  of  the  energy  eigenvalue. 

This  result  is  easily  understood  from  the  following  considerations. 
In  the  interval  0  —  a  (for  n  =  0)  there  is  one  sinusoidal  half -wave ; 
for  n=l9  there  is  one  complete  wave;  for  n  =  2,  there  is  one  and  a 
half  waves,  etc.  Thus,  the  greater  n  is,  the  less  the  de  Broglie  wave- 
length X.  But  energy  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the  momentum, 
i.e.,  it  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square  of  X,  in  accordance 
with  (23.2).  Therefore,  the  less  X  is,  the  greater  the  energy.  This 
conclusion  holds,  of  course,  for  wave  functions  that  are  not  of  a  purely 
sinusoidal  shape,  though  not  as  a  general  quantitative  relationship 
but,  instead,  qualitatively — the  more  zeros  or  * 'nodes"  that  the  wave 
function  has,  the  greater  the  energy.  The  least  energy  state  has  no 
zeros  anywhere  except  at  the  limits  of  the  interval  x  —  Q  and  x~a. 
It  is  called  the  ground  state,  all  the  other  states  being  termed  excited. 

Normalization  of  a  wave  function.  It  remains  to  determine  the  co- 
efficient Cl  in  order  to  define  a  wave  function  completely.  We  shall 
find  it  from  the  normalization  condition  (24.18): 


2 

0  0 

x         sin2xa;\k__  C\a  


-)t- 

The  second  term  of  the  integrated  expression  becomes  zero  at  both 
limits  in  accordance  with  (25.8).  Thus, 


SeC.  25]  CERTAIN   PROBLEMS    OF   QUANTUM   MECHANICS  255 


,-yr- 


rin*(n+1)*  .  (25.12) 


Real  wave  functions.  The  wave  function  (25.12)  is  real.  Therefore, 
from  (24.20),  the  current  in  this  state  is  equal  to  zero.  This  can  also 
be  seen  in  the  following  way.  The  wave  function  (25.12)  can  be  ex- 
panded into  the  sum  of  two  exponentials.  Each  such  exponential 
represents,  together  with  a  time  factor,  the  wave  function  of  a  free 
particle  (24.3),  one  of  them  corresponding  to  a  momentum  p  =  hx 
and  the  other,  to  the  same  momentum  but  with  opposite  sign.  Thus, 
a  state  with  wave  function  (25.12)  is  represented  as  the  superposition 
of  two  states  with  opposite  momenta,  these  states  having  equal 
amplitudes.  The  mean  momentum  for  a  particle  moving  in  a  potential 
well  according  to  classical  mechanics  is  equal  to  zero;  it  changes 
sign  for  every  reflection  from  the  walls  of  the  well.  In  this  sense, 
we  can  say  that  the  mean  momentum  is  also  equal  to  zero  for  quantum 
motion.  The  difference  is  that  at  every  given  instant  classical  mo- 
mentum possesses  a  definite  value,  while  the  quantum  momentum 
of  a  particle  in  a  well  never  has  a  definite  value  ;  the  wave  function 
involves  states  with  momenta  of  both  signs.  This  corresponds  to 
the  uncertainty  principle;  since  the  particle  coordinate  is  within 
the  limits  0<a;^a,  the  momentum  cannot  have  an  exact  value. 

In  addition,  we  note  that  in  this  particular  problem  of  a  rectangular 
well  the  square  of  the  momentum  has  a  definite  value  since  the 
uncertainty  is  extended  only  to  the  sign  of  the  momentum.  The 
square  of  the  momentum  in  this  case  is  proportional  to  the  energy. 
The  square  of  the  momentum  for  a  well  of  any  arbitrary  shape  is 
also  not  fixed. 

A  particle  in  a  three-dimensional  infinitely  deep  potential  well. 
Let  us  now  suppose  that  a  particle  is  contained  in  a  box  whose  edges 
are  al9  a2,  a3.  Generalizing  the  boundary  conditions  (25.1),  we  conclude 
that  the  wave  function  becomes  zero  on  all  the  sides  of  the  box: 


=  ty(x,a2,z)  =  <l>(x,y,az)  =  Q.  (25.13) 

The  wave  equation  must  now  be  written  in  three-dimensional  form: 


It  is  convenient  to  write  the  solution  as  follows: 

4>  =  Cfsinx1o;  •  sinx2i/  •  sinx3z.  (25.15) 

It  is  written  only  in  terms  of  sines  and  not  cosines  so  as  to  satisfy 
the  first  line  of  the  boundary  conditions  (25.13).  We  substitute  (25.15) 


256  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

in  (15.14)  and,  utilizing  the  fact  that  for  every  factor  of  (25.15)  there 
exists  an  equality  of  the  form, 

~  sin  Y.^X  =  —  x*  sin  K^X  ;  (25.16) 

this  gives 

To  satisfy  equation  (25.14)  the  energy  must  involve  xx,  x2  and  x3 
in  the  following  way: 

^  =  JLL  (Xj  +  X2  +  xj) .  (25.17) 

The  quantities  y.l9  x2,  x3  are  determined  from  the  second  line  of  the 
boundary  conditions  (25.13).  The  factors  of  (25.15)  convert  to  zero 
either  at  x  =  al9  or  y~a2  or  z  —  a3.  In  other  words, 


sin  xx  «i  =  0  ,      Xj  ax 

sinx2a2  =  0,      X2a2  =  7i27i:;  (25.18) 

sin  x3a3  =  0  ,      x3  a3  = 


Here  nl9  n2  and  ns  are  integers  of  which  none  are  equal  to  zero  (other- 
wise <p  would  be  equal  to  zero  over  all  the  box). 

Substituting  x1?  x2,  x3  from  (25.18)  in  (25.17),  we  have  the  energy 
eigenvalues 

7T2/?2  ln\          nl         n\\ 
=  -  '  25'19 


The  least  possible  energy  is 

'«i=-t£(-i+-i+-5i)-  <25-20> 

It  follows  that  the  value  <^  =  0  is  impossible. 

Calculating  the  number  of  possible  states.  To  each  value  of  the  three 
numbers  nl9  n2,  and  n3,  there  corresponds  a  single  particle  state. 
Let  the  numbers  nl9  n29  and  n3  be  large  in  comparison  with  unity. 
Such  numbers  may  be  differentiated:  the  differential  dn±  denotes 
a  number  interval  which  is  small  compared  with  nl9  but  still  including 
many  separate  integral  values  of  n±.  Then  it  stands  to  reason  that 
there  are  exactly  dn:  possible  integers,  l^dn^n^  included  within 
the  interval  dn^  (and  similarly  within  the  intervals  dn2  and  dn3). 
Let  us  plot  nl9  n2,  and  n3  on  coordinate  axes.  In  this  space  we  construct 
an  infinitely  small  parallelepiped  of  volume  dnt  dn2  dn%.  In  accordance 
with  the  foregoing,  there  are  dn-^  dn2  dn3  groups  of  three  integers 
%,  n2,  n3  in  this  parallelepiped,  each  corresponding  to  one  possible 
state  of  the  particle  in  the  box.  Altogether,  the  number  of  such 
states  in  the  examined  interval  of  values  nl9  n2  and  n3  is 

dN  (nl9n29n3)  =  dnldnzdn3.  (25.21) 


Sec.  25] 


CERTAIN    PROBLEMS    OF    QUANTUM    MECHANICS 


257 


Substituting  here  xlf  x2  and  x3  from  (25.18),  we  obtain  another  ex- 
pression for  the  number  of  states: 


dN  (x1)x2)x3)  = 


where  V  —  ala2  a3  is  the  volume  of  the  box.  The  numbers  xx,  x2  and 
x3  take  only  positive  values. 

It  was  pointed  out  above  that  to  each  value  of  x  there  correspond 
two  values  of  the  momentum  projection,  which  are  equal  in  magnitude 
and  opposite  in  sign.  Therefore,  if  we  compare  the  number  of  states 

included  in  the  intervals  dxls    and  —f-  ==  -~~  then  there  are  half 

ii  n 

as  many  states  for  the  latter.  Correspondingly,  the  number  of  states 
in  the  interval  of  values  of  momentum  dpx  dpy  dpz  is 


dN  (Px,  ft,  ft)  = 


(25.23) 


where  pX)  py  and  px  assume  all  real  values  from  —  oo  to  oo. 

Equation  (25.23)  agrees  with  the  uncertainty  relation  (23.4).  If 
the  motion  is  bounded  along  x  by  the  interval  al9  then  only  those 
states  differ  physically  for  which  the  momentum  projections  differ 

by  not  less  than     TC    .   Hence,  there  are   -^  —  rr~r  =     ^  ?—  states 

J  «!  '  (2-nkla^  2nh 

within  the  interval  dpx.  Multiplying  —«r-Pr-  •  a|~T~  *  °2  f*  we  arr*ve 
at  (25.23).  In  order  to  ensure  coincidence  of  numerical  coefficients 
with  the  results  of  rigorous  derivation  from  the  wave  equation  when 
evaluating  the  number  of  states  from 
the  uncertainty  relation  the  quantity 
2-nh  was  selected  on  the  right-hand  side 
of  (23.4)  or  2n  from  (18.10). 

We  shall  now  consider  the  number  of 
states  after  changing  somewhat  the  inde- 
pendent variables.  We  plot  the  quantities 
x1?  x2  and  x3  on  the  coordinate  axes 
(Fig.  37).  Let  us  construct  in  this  "space" 
a  sphere  whose  equation  looks  like 


The    numbers    x5    x     and 


x3    are   posi- 


Fig.  37 


tive  so  that  we  shall  be  interested  only 
in  one  eighth  of  the  sphere;  this  octant  is  shown  in  Fig.  37.  How 
many  states  are  included  between  the  octants  of  two  spheres  with 
radii  K  and  K  +  dK?  The  number  of  states  is  equal  to  the  integral 
of  (25.22)  over  the  whole  volume  between  the  octants,  or 


17  -0060 


258  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 


f 

S5  J 


x          .7t  /or  0/n 

f  x2,  xs)  =  -     3  -  =  -     2  —  '     (25-24) 


This  is  evident  simply  from  the  fact  that  the  volume  is  equal  to  the 

4-  172 

surface  of  the  octant  -^p-  multiplied  by  dK.  But  from  (25.17)  K 
is  very  simply  related  to  the  energy  of  the  particle: 


Whence 

'    •  (25-25) 


Thus,  the  number  of  states  included  between  §  and  $-{-d$  in- 
creases in  direct  proportion  to  t^1/2.  In  a  one-dimensional  potential 

well  we  would  obtain  dN  =  dn=  —  *•  =  -%r?  !  IPIT-  Equation  (25.25) 

a  V  ' 


has  great  significance  in  all  that  is  to  follow.  We  observe  that  this 
formula  involves  only  the  volume  of  the  vessel  F,  irrespective  of 
the  ratio  of  the  edges  al9  a2,  and  a3.  In  mathematical  physics  courses 
it  is  shown  that  the  result  (25.25)  holds  for  energy  eigenvalues  which 
are  sufficiently  large  compared  with  the  energy  of  the  ground  state. 
The  number  of  states  is  proportional  to  the  volume  of  the  vessel 
and  is  independent  of  its  shape. 

A  one-dimensional  potential  well  of  finite  depth.  We  shall  now  con- 
sider a  one-dimensional  potential  well  of  finite  depth.  We  specify 

it  in  the  following  way  :  U  =  oo  at  —  oo  < 
<a<0,  U  =  0  for  O^x^a  and  U=U0 
for  a<x^.  oo.  In  other  words,  the  potential 
energy  for  x>  0  is  everywhere  equal  to  J70, 
except  within  a  region  of  width  a  near  the 
coordinate  origin,  which  region  we  called 
the  well.  For  x<0  the  potential  energy  is 


a J      infinite  (see  Fig.  38).* 

Fig.  38  Since    the    solution   will   be   of  different 

analytical    form    inside    and    outside    the 

well,  we  must  find  the  conjugation  conditions  for  the  wave  func- 
tion at  the  boundary. 

Let  us  take  the  wave  equation. 

79  JO      I 

(25.26) 


*  It  was  shown  in  Sec.  19  that  the  three-dimensional  wave  equation  can 
be  reduced  to  a  single-dimensional  one,  with  the  difference  that  the  variable  r 
must  be  positive  by  its  very  meaning.  This  may  be  attained  formally  by  situating 
an  infinitely  high  potential  wall  at  r  =  0.  Fig.  38  actually  refers  to  a  spherical 
potential  well  with  an  angular-momentum  value  equal  to  zero,  when  there 
is  no  "centrifugal"  term  in  the  potential  energy  [see  (5.8)  and  (31.5)]. 


Sec.  25]  CERTAIN   PROBLEMS   OF    QUANTUM   MECHANICS  259 


and  integrate  both  sides  over  a  narrow  region  a  —  8<#<  a  +8, 
including  the  point  of  discontinuity  of  the  potential  energy  x  =  a. 
The  integration  gives 

a+8 

»[(4±.)        -(4*-)       l-f(/-Z7)+«fa.         (25.27) 
2  m  l\  dx  I  a+8        \dx  I  a_8  ]        J  v  '  T  v  ' 

a—  8 

Even  though  £7  suffers  a  discontinuity  at  the  boundary  of  the  well, 
on  the  right  it  remains  everywhere  finite  by  arrangement.  Therefore, 
when  8  approaches  zero,  the  integral  on  the  right  also  approaches 
zero.  It  follows  that  the  left-hand  side  of  (25.27)  is  also  zero.  In  other 
words, 

(*+.)        »(<+.)        .  (26.28) 

\dxla+o         \dxla-Q'  ' 

the  limit  of  the  derivative  on  the  right  is  equal  to  its  limit  on  the  left. 

This  argument  would  not  hold  in  the  problem  of  an  infinitely 

deep  well  because  then  the  integral  in  (25.27)  would  be  indeterminate. 

Besides  we  notice  that  the  derivative  —^  is  finite  at  the  points  x  =a±  8 

simply  because  the  only  solutions  of  equation  (25.26)  are  those  with 
finite  derivatives  (exponential  function,  sine  or  cosine). 

We  shall  now  show,  by  means  of  a  limiting  transition,  that  even 
the  wave  function  itself  does  not  suffer  a  discontinuity  at  the  boundary. 
Let  U  initially  have  a  finite  discontinuity  region  of  width  8  and  let 
the  discontinuity  of  the  function  fy  be  A.  Before  passing  to  the  limit 

the  derivative  in  the  region  of  discontinuity  is  of  the  order  of  ~-  ~  —  , 

so  that  when  8->0,  it  diverges.  Let  us  now  multiply  both  sides  of 
(25.26)  by  fy  and  perform  a  transformation  by  parts: 


Let  us  integrate  the  transformed  expression  between  a  —  8  and 
a  +  (5.  We  then  obtain 


a+8  a+8 


a—  8  a—  8 

(25.59) 

We  shall  now  perform  the  foregoing  limiting  process  by  indirect  proof. 
We  may  write  the  integrated  terms  thus: 


a+8 


because  the  derivative  -r^-,   as  was  shown,  is  not  subject  to  a  dis- 
continuity. Within  the  assumed  discontinuity  region  of  the  ^-function, 


260  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

-r^-  is  of  the  order  of  -f-  ,  but  at  the  boundaries  of  the  region  it  reverts 

dx  o 

to  values  which  are  independent  of  8  and  are  therefore  finite  in  the 
limit.  Hence,  the  whole  integrated  part  on  the  left  in  (25.29)  is  of  the 

order  of  A-  j-r-H       •  The  remaining  integral  is  estimated  as 


Hence  it  tends  to  infinity  as  S  tends  to  zero.  The  right-hand  side  of 
(25.29)  is  finite  for  §->0.  Thus,  by  assuming  that  fy  has  a  finite  dis- 
continuity A  we  have  arrived  at  a  contradiction.  It  follows  that  fy 
is  continuous  at  the  point  a  together  with  its  first  derivative. 

Solutions  in  two  regions.  The  wave  equation  for  the  region 
(inside  the  well)  is  of  the  form 


We  take  its  solution 

(25.30) 


where  x  is  defined  from  (25.3).  The  solution  involving  the  sine  only 
is  taken  because  at  the  left-hand  edge  of  the  well,  where  the  potential 
energy  suffers  an  infinite  discontinuity,  fy  satisfies  the  boundary 
condition  (25.1):  9(0)  =  0. 

The  wave  equation  outside  the  well,  when  x>a,  is 

-IT^.  (25.31) 

0/  T  v  ' 


__  -. 

2m    dx2        v  0/  T 

First  of  all  let  us  take  the  case  £>>U0.  Then,  introducing  the  ab- 
breviated notation 

*?!(*_  ffo)53X|,  (25.32) 

we  obtain  (25.31)  in  the  standard  form  (25.4) 


whence 

fy  =  (72  sin  xx  x  +  (73  cos  xx  x  .  (25.33) 

We  must  now  satisfy  the  boundary  conditions  on  the  right-hand 
edge  of  the  potential  well  where  U  suffers  only  a  finite  discontinuity. 
According  to  these  conditions  the  wave  function  is  itself  continuous,  i.e.  , 

Cl  sin  xa  =  C2  sin  XA  a  +  O3  cos  Xj  a  (25.34) 

and  its  derivative 

x  G!  cos  xa  =  xx  Cz  cos  ^  a  —  xx  (73  sin  Kta  .  (25.35) 


Sec.  25]  CERTAIN   PROBLEMS    OF   QUANTUM   MECHANICS  261 

From  these  equations  we  can  determine  (72  and  (73  in  terms  of  Cv 
i.  e.,  completely  express  the  solution  outside  the  well  in  terms  of  the 
solution  inside  the  well.  The  equations  (25.34)  and  (25.35)  are  linear 
with  respect  to  (72  and  G3  and  have  solutions  for  all  values  of  coefficient. 

n         x1sinxasinx1a+ 

==  - 


Therefore,  the  boundary  conditions  may  be  satisfied  for  any  real  values 
of  x  and  xr  Thus,  Schrodinger's  equation  is  solvable  for  all  &.  There 
is  no  discrete  energy  eigenvalues  for  $  >  U0. 

We  could  adjust  the  potential  energy  in  this  problem  to  zero  at 
infinity,  i.e.,  consider  it  equal  to  zero  for  x  >  a  and  equal  to  —  U 
for  a>#^0.  Then  the  case  which  we  have  just  considered  would 
correspond  to  positive  eigenvalues  of  the  total  energy. 

Now  let  $  <  UQ.  We  introduce  the  quantity 


(25.36) 


The  wave  equation  is  now  written  differently  from  that  for  $  >  C70, 
namely 

d*<b         ~9  . 
-~  =  X2U>. 
dx*  T 

Its  solution  is  expressed  in  terms  of  the  exponential  function 

<J,  =  <74  e^  +  £5  e  -Sr  .  (25.37) 

But  the  exponential  eZx  tends  to  infinity  as  x  increases.  For  x  ==  oo  it 
would  give  an  infinite  probability  for  finding  the  particle,  and  no 

00 

finite  value  could  be  assigned  to  the  integral  f  |  fy  |2  Ax  .  It  follows  that 

o 

a  physically  meaningful  solution  exists  only  for  64  =  0  and  must  be 
of  the  form 

ty^Cse-™  (25.38) 

Let  us  again  try  to  satisfy  the  boundary  conditions  at  x  =  a.  This 
time  they  appear  as  follows: 

C^sinxa  =  (75e~xa  ,  (25.39) 

x  C^cos  xa  =  —  x  C5  e-*'  .  (25.40) 

Let  us  divide  equation  (25.40)  by  (25.39)  in  order  to  eliminate  Cl 
and  (75.  We  then  obtain 

x  cot  xa  =  —  x  .  (25.41) 


262 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


From  this  equation  we  find  the  expression  for  sin  xa  : 

1  .  1 


sin  xa  ==  ± 


_i 


cotaxa 


.._  _  i 


(25.42) 


Let  us  reduce  this  equation  to  a  more  convenient  form.  From  (26.3) 


.  xa , 


so  that 


smxa  =  ±- 


.  xa, 


(25.43) 


only  those  solutions  should  be  chosen  for  which  ctg  xa  is  negative,  in 
accordance  with  (25.41),  i.e.,  xa  must  lie  in  the  second,  fourth,  sixth, 
eighth,  etc.,  quadrants. 

We  shall  solve  this  equation  graphically  (Fig.  39).  The  left-hand  side 

of  equation  (25.43)  is  repre- 
sented by  a  sinusoid,  while 
the  right-hand  side  is  repre- 
sented by  two  straight  lines 

of  slopes  ±  — 7=^== .  If 


the  absolute  value  of  the 
slopes  of  the  angle  of  incli- 
nation of  these  lines  is  less 
than  2/Tu,  they  have  one  or 
several  common  points  with 
Fig.  39  the  sinusoid  in  the  quadrants 

corresponding  to  the  roots 

of  (25.41).  The  trivial  point  of  intersection  xa  =  0  does  not  count 
because,  for  x  =  0,  the  wave  function  is  zero  everywhere.  Thus,  in  a 
well  of  finite  depth  of  the  form  considered,  there  are  only  several 
energy  eigenvalues. 
If 


8    ma2  ' 


there  are  in  general  no  points  of  intersection  of  the  straight  lines  with 
the  sinusoid  corresponding  to  energy  eigenvalues.  In  Fig.  39  the 
points  of  intersection  in  the  even  quadrants  are  marked  by  small 
circles. 


SeC.  25]  CERTAIN  PROBLEMS   OP   QUANTUM  MECHANICS  263 

Finite  and  infinite  motion.  We  shall  now  relate  the  shape  of  the 
energy  spectrum  to  the  type  of  motion.  For  $  >  UQ  the  solution 
outside  the  well  is  of  the  form  (25.33).  It  remains  finite  also  for  an 

infinitely  large  x.  Therefore,  the  integral   J  |  fy  |  2  dx  taken  over  the 

region  of  the  well  is  infinitesimal  compared  with  the  same  integral 
taken  over  all  space.  In  other  words,  there  is  nothing  to  prevent  the 
particle  going  to  infinity.  Such  motion  was  termed  infinite  in  Sec.  5. 
For  <f  <  C70,  the  solution  (25.38),  if  it  exists,  is  exponentially  damped 
at  infinity.  Hence,  the  probability  of  the  particle  receding  an  infinite 
distance  from  the  origin  is  equal  to  zero — the  particle  remains  at  a 
finite  distance  from  the  well  all  the  time.  This  motion  was  termed 
finite  in  Sec.  5. 

Thus,  infinite  motion  has  a  continuous  energy  spectrum  while  finite 
motion  has  a  discrete  spectrum  consisting  of  separate  values.  If  the 
depth  of  the  well  is  very  small,  the  finite  motion  may  be  absent.  It  has 
no  counterpart  in  classical  mechanics.  Finite  motion  is  always  possible 
in  a  potential  well  if  |  $  \  <  U. 

The  result  that  we  have  obtained  does  not  only  refer  to  a  rectangular 
potential  well.  Indeed,  if  the  potential  energy  is  taken  to  be  zero  at 
infinity,  then  the  solution  with  positive  total  energy  is  of  the  form 
(25.33)  for  sufficiently  large  x,  while  the  solution  with  negative  total 
energy  is  of  the  form  (25.38).  The  latter  contains  only  one  arbitrary 
constant  while  (25.33)  contains  two  constants.  Both  solutions  must  be 
extended  to  the  coordinate  origin  in  order  that  the  condition  fy  (0)  =  0 
can  be  satisfied  at  the  origin  (we  consider  that  x  is  always  greater 
than  zero).  Obviously,  if  we  have  two  constants  at  our  disposal  we 
can  always  choose  them  so  that  the  condition  fy  (0)  =  0  is  satisfied.  * 
Contrarily,  a  solution  of  the  form  (25.38)  containing  one  constant 
becomes  zero  at  the  origin  only  for  certain  special  values  of  x. 

A  continuous  spectrum  corresponding  to  infinite  motion  may  be 
accounted  for  in  the  following  way.  A  free  particle  moving  in  unbound- 
ed space  has  a  continuous  spectrum.  The  wave  function  of  the  particle 
in  infinite  motion  differs  from  the  wave  function  of  a  free  particle 
only  in  the  region  of  a  potential  well.  But  the  probability  of  finding 
the  particle  in  this  region  is  infinitesimal  if  the  whole  region  of  motion 
is  sufficiently  large.  Therefore,  the  wave  function  for  infinite  motion 
coincides  with  the  wave  function  of  a  free  particle  in  *  "almost"  the 
entire  space,  i.e.,  in  that  region  of  space  for  which  the  probability 
of  finding  the  particle  is  equal  to  unity,  and  the  energy  spectrum 
turns  out  to  be  the  same  as  for  a  free  particle. 

The  wave  function  in  a  region  where  the  potential  energy  is  greater 
than  the  total  energy.  If  UQ  tends  to  infinity  the  function  outside  the 


*  If  *(0)  =  0^(0)  +  C72<MO) ,  then  ^  =  -  -J^. 


264  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

well  very  rapidly  tends  to  zero.  In  the  limit  C70  -»  oo,  it  tends  to  zero 
however  close  to  the  boundary  #  —  a,  thereby  giving  the  boundary 
condition  (25.1). 

In  the  case  of  a  finite  U0  the  wave  function  outside  the  well  does 
not  become  zero  at  once.  Therefore  a  finite  probability  exists  that 
the  particle  will  be  outside  the  well  at  a  finite  distance  from  it. 

This  would  have  been  completely  impossible  in  classical  mechanics, 
as  is  obtained  from  (25.38)  in  the  limiting  transition  h  —.  >0  for  x  =  co 
and  tp  however  small  outside  the  well.  This,  naturally,  should  be  the 
case  :  if  the  particle  is  situated  outside  the  well  its  kinetic  energy  is 
$  —  UQ<Q.  But  the  velocity  of  such  a  particle  is  an  imaginary 
quantity.  In  classical  mechanics  it  means  that  a  given  point  of  space 
is  absolutely  unattainable  for  the  particle  at  the  given  value  of  its 
energy  <^.  In  quantum  mechanics,  a  coordinate  and  velocity  never 
exist  in  the  same  states  as  precise  quantities.  Earlier,  we  interpreted 
this  in  terms  of  the  uncertainty  relation,  i.  e.,  we  considered  cases  for 
which  precision  in  the  concept  of  velocity  for  a  certain  state  was 

restricted  by  the  limits  -  -^  —  .  However,  this  is  a  lower  limit  and  has 

to  do  with  particles  which  are  almost  unaffected  by  forces.  The  appear- 
ance of  an  imaginary  velocity  in  the  equation  for  a  bound  particle 
shows  that  the  very  concept  of  velocity  is  not  applicable  to  a  region 
of  space,  however  large,  for  which  U  >  $  .  We  can  express  this  diifer- 
ently  by  saying  that,  for  U  >$,  the  uncertainty  in  the  kinetic  energy 
is  always  greater  than  the  difference  U  —  $. 

To  summarize,  in  classical  mechanics  there  is  no  counterpart  to 
the  motion  of  a  bound  particle  outside  a  well. 

Exercises 

1)  The  potential  energy  is  equal  to  zero  for  x  <  0  and  equal  to  J70  for  x>  0 
(the  potential  threshold).  Incident  from  the  left  are  particles  with  energies 
&  >  (70.  Find  the  reflection  coefficient. 

The  wave  function  on  the  left  is 


-  _-. 

C\e     h    +  C2e       h    . 

On  the  right,  above  the  threshold,  the  function  is 


C3e      *    ,  where  p' »  \/2m  (&  —  U) . 

Find  the  ratio  IC2)2/!^!2  from  the  boundary  conditions  at  a?  =  0,  i.e.,  the 
ratio  of  the  squares  of  the  amplitudes  of  the  reflected  and  incident  waves. 
The  ratio  is  equal  to  unity  for  &  <  U0. 

2)  The  potential  energy  is  equal  to  zero  for  x  <  0  and  for  x  >  a.  U  =  UQ 
for  0<a?<a  (a  potential  barrier).  Particles  are  incident  from  the  left  with 
energies  less  than  C70.  Find  the  coefficient  of  reflection. 


Sec.  26]  HARMONIC    OSCILLATORY    MOTION  265 

The  wave  function  to  the  left  of  the  barrier  is  equal  to  e*kx  -f  Ce~ikx  I  k  —  ~- 1  ; 

under  the  barrier,  i.e.,  for  0<#<a,  the  wave  function  is  C&**  C&**.  We 
look  for  a  wave  function  of  the  form  C^kx  beyond  the  barrier.  This  means 
that  beyond  the  barrier  the  only  wave  is  that  travelling  to  the  right  (i.e., 
only  the  transmitted  wave),  while  in  front  of  the  barrier  wo  find  both  the  incident 
wave  and  the  reflected  wave.  The  constants  C,  C19  G2t  C73  are  determined  from 
the  continuity  condition  of  the  wave  function  and  its  first  derivative  at  the 
boundaries  of  the  barrier.  The  expressions  for  the  constants  C  and  (73  are  as 
follows : 

2(x2+  fc2)shxa 

~~  (x  -f  ik)2e— *<*  ~  (x 


(x  +  ik)2e  -*<*  —  (x  —  i 
The  particle  flux  on  the  left  and  right  of  the  barrier  is,  respectively, 


Substituting  C  and  C3  it  is  easy  to  see  that  both  the  expressions  for  flux  coincide 
as  expected. 

If  xa>  1,  i.e.,  the  barrier  is  transparent  to  a  very  small  extent,  we  have 

C  --  1,     C3= 

x 

Thus  the  flux  diminishes  exponentially  with  the  thickness  of  the  barrier. 

It  will  also  be  noted  that  the  total  particle  flux  through  the  barrier  is  pro- 
portional to  the  particle  density  in  front  of  the  barrier,  because  the  boundary 
conditions  are  linear  and  homogeneous  with  respect  to  the  wave  functions. 
By  specifying  the  amplitude  of  the  wave  function  on  the  left  we  determined 
the  density  and  flux  of  the  particles. 

3)  Verify  the  orthogonality  property  for  wave  functions  (the  exercise 
in  the  preceding  section)  for  a  particle  in  a  box  of  finite  and  infinite  depth. 

Sec.  26.  Harmonic  Oscillatory  Motion  in  Quantum  Mechanics 
(Linear  Harmonic  Oscillator) 

The  wave  equation  lor  an  oscillator.  In  Sec.  7  we  considered  har- 
monic oscillations  with  one  degree  of  freedom.  The  Hamiltonian  func- 
tion of  this  system,  called  a  linear  harmonic  oscillator,  is  of  the  form 


Forming  Hamilton's  equations,  we  obtain 


—  —     —  ,  -^ 

*  dx  '  dp 

Eliminating  py  we  arrive  at  the  usual  equation  of  harmonic  oscillations 
(7.13): 


266  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

In  quantum  mechanics  the  wave  equation  corresponding  to  this 
motion  has  the  form  [see  (24.22)] 

--       +  J5f!!-*-'+-  <26'2> 


Indeed,  since  the  motion  has  only  one  degree  of  freedom,  instead  of 
the  Laplacian  A,  we  must  simply  write  the  second  derivative.  The 

,  .   ,  .  T   .      mco2cca 

potential  energy  is  equal  to  —  -  —  . 

Let  us  now  introduce  other  units  of  measurement,  in  particular, 

we  shall  take  the  unit  of  length  equal  to   /  —  l—  ,  so  that 

»        ^  v  mco  ' 

x  =  1/1515.  (26.3) 

\  mco  ^  v         ' 

The  quantity  £  is  dimensionless.  The  derivative  -—?-  is  equal  to 


-,--  „-=--  --.--.  (26.4) 

dx        \     h        d%  v         ' 

Further,  we  put 

2<?  =  £-7ico.  (26.5) 

In  terms  of  these  dimensionless  variables,  equation  (26.2)  assumes 
the  form 

_.!*!£  + 52  <j,  =  e<|,.  (26.6) 

Equation  (26.6)  does  not  contain  any  parameters  of  the  problem, 
i.e.,  co,  m,  and  h.  For  this  reason  the  eigenvalue  s  can  only  be  an 
abstract  number.  Comparing  this  with  the  expression  for  energy 
(26.5),  we  see  that  the  energy  eigenvalue  of  an  harmonic  oscillator  is 
proportional  to  its  frequency  co. 

The  transition  to  another  dependent  variable.  It  appears  convenient 
to  introduce  a  new  dependent  variable: 

(|)  =  e-Ty(5).  (26.7) 

Whence 


(26.8) 


~ 


We  substitute  (26.8)  in  (26.6)  and  perform  the  necessary  rearrange- 
ment. The  new  dependent  variable  g  (£)  having  been  introduced,  the 
equation  assumes  the  form 


Sec.  26]  HARMONIC    OSCILLATORY   MOTION  267 

(26.9) 


Integration  in  the  form  of  a  series.  It  is  possible  to  integrate  equation 
(26.9)  by  expanding  it  in  a  power  series  of  the  form: 

00 

g  (?)  =  So  +  9!  I  +  9*  ?  +  ft  ?  +  •  •  •  =2>$"-         (26-10) 


n»0 


In  order  to  determine  the  coefficients  of  the  expansion  gn,  we  must 
substitute  the  series  (26.10)  into  equation  (26.9),  differentiate  it  by 
terms  and  compare  the  expressions  for  the  same  powers  of  5.  The 
first  derivative  is 


so  that 


The  second  derivative  is 

oo 

-*.         (26.12) 


In  the  last  summation  we  changed  the  summation  index,  denoting 
it  by  the  letter  k.  We  shall  now  revert  to  n,  assuming  k  —  2  =  n, 
.  Then 


+  2)  (n  +  1)^,5".  (26.13) 


Now  substituting  (26.13)  and  (26.11)  into  equation  (26.9)  and  collecting 
coefficients  of  £n,  we  obtain 

00 

[—(n  +  2)  (n  +  l)«7M+2  +  2njr«  —  (e—  l)ffj  -  0  .  (26.14) 


We  know  that  for  a  power  series  to  be  equal  to  zero,  all  its  coefficients 
must  convert  to  zero.  Thus, 


(»7i)-  (26'15) 

In  this  way  the  expansion  proceeds  in  powers  of  (52)  because  the 
coefficients  gn  go  alternately. 

Examining  the  series.  Let  us  assume  initially  that  gQ^Q.  Then, 
from  equation  (26.13),  we  find  in  turn  gr2,  gr4,  .  .  .,  gzk.  Not  a  single  odd 


268  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

coefficient  will  appear  in  the  series  if  g±  =  0.  On  the  contrary,  if  gQ  =  0, 
(/^O,  then  no  even  coefficients  will  appear  in  the  series;  for  this 
reason  it  is  sufficient  to  examine  solutions  containing  only  even  or 
only  odd  powers  of  £.  To  be  specific  let  us  first  take  the  series  in  even 
powers. 

Let  us  examine  the  behaviour  of  the  series  (26.10)  for  large  values 
of  £.  Terms  involving  high  powers  of  5,  i.  e.,  large  n  are  then  predomi- 
nant. But  if  n  is  a  large  number  then,  in  equation  (26.15),  we  can  neg- 
lect all  constant  numbers  where  they  appear  in  the  sum  or,  difference 
with  n.  If  n  is  large  the  equation  will  take  on  the  form 

g,+i  =  2-gn.  (26.16) 

IV 

Let  n  =  2  n1  so  that  ri  now  changes  by  unity  only.  Putting  this  in 
(26.16),  we  obtain 

gi>  +  i=-±rg'*;  (26.17) 

where  we  have  introduced  the  notation  g'n'  =s  g2n*  ===gn\g'n>  are  coeffi- 
cients of  the  series  in  powers  of  (£2). 

If  we  now  take  a  function  containing  only  odd  powers  of  £,  then 
the  terms  involving  g^nf-\-i  will  n°^  differ,  for  large  n',  from  the 
terms  of  a  series  in  even  powers  of  £  because  unity  can  be  neglected 
in  comparison  with  2  ri  .  Therefore,  the  form  of  the  coefficients  for 
large  ri  is  identical  both  for  series  in  even  and  odd  powers  of  £. 

From  (26.17)  we  find  an  expression  for  g'n'-\-\\ 


Whence  the  expression  for  gfe)  in  the  case  of  large  £  is  of  the  form: 

-  =  &*•  <2<U9> 


n'  «-  0  n'  —  0 


Thus,  the  asymptotic  expression  for  g(%)  is  the  exponential  function 
e*2.  But  then,  in  accordance  with  the  definition  of  g(fy  (26.7),  the 
asymptotic  form  of  ^(£)  for  large  5  *s 


=    2 


However,  this  form  of  ^  is  not  acceptable  :  the  wave  function  must 
remain  finite  at  infinity  because  its  square  is  probability. 

The  condition  for  eigenvalues.  There  is  only  one  possibility  for 
obtaining  a  finite  value  of  fy  at  infinity.  It  is  necessary  that  the  series 
(26.10)  should  terminate  at  a  certain  n  and  that  all  the  subsequent 


Sec.  26]  HABMONIC    OSCILLATORY   MOTION  269 

coefficients  <7«  +  2»  <7«f4>  etc.,  be  identically  equal  to  zero.  It  can  be 
seen  from  equation  (26.15)  that  gn  +  2  becomes  zero  when 

£==271+1,  (26.20) 

where  n  is  any  integer  or  zero.  Since  gn  +  t  is  linearly  expressed  in 
terms  of  gn  +  2  >  it  is  sufficient  for  gn  +  2  to  convert  to  zero  to  have  the 
series  terminate  at  gn.  It  follows  that  when  e  satisfies  (26.20)  the 
function  g(%)  becomes  a  polynomial.  The  product  of  the  polynomial 

£a 

0(£)  with  the  exponential  —  2"  always  tends  to  zero  as  £  tends  to 

infinity.  Hence  ^  (oo)  =  0.  As  was  pointed  out  at  the  end  of  the  last 
section,  such  motion  is  finite  in  the  same  sense  as  in  classical  mechan- 
ics :  the  probability  that  the  particle  will  recede  an  infinite  distance 
is  equal  to  zero.  To  finite  motion  there  corresponds  a  discrete  energy 
spectrum;  from  (26.5)  and  (26.20) 

*B  =  -^-e  =  *fi>(»+y).  (26.21) 

The  least  possible  value  of  energy  6\  =  —  "-  *  As  we  have  already 

said  in  Sec.  25  a  state  with  energy  <^0  is  called  the  ground  state.  For 
this  state  the  series  gfe)  is  already  terminated  at  the  zero  term,  because 
the  number  of  the  eigenvalue  of  energy  determines  the  degree  of  the 
polynomial  gn(£>).  The  wave  function  of  the  ground  state  is  of  the 
especially  simple  form: 

~ 


This  function  does  not  have  any  zeros  at  a  finite  distance  from  the 
coordinate  origin,  which  must  be  the  case  in  the  ground  state.  It  may 
be  noted  that  the  state  with  zero  energy  would  correspond  to  a  par- 
ticle at  rest  at  the  origin.  However,  such  a  state  is  not  compatible  with 
the  uncertainty  principle,  since  it  has,  simultaneously,  a  coordinate 
and  velocity. 

Oscillator  wave  functions.  Let  us  also  find  the  eigenfuiictions  for  the 

first  and  second  excited  states.  In  the  first  state  ffl  —  Aco  (  1  -f  -^\  = 
3 

=  -^-  A  co.  The  series  will  be  terminated  if  we  assume  <70  =  0,  ffi^®* 
A 

Then  e  =  3  from  (26.20)  and  gr3=0r5=0r2w  +  1  =  0,  etc.,  from  (26.15). 
The  even  coefficients  may  be  assumed  at  once  equal  to  zero,  for  which 
purpose  it  is  sufficient  to  take  gr0  =  0.*  In  general,  all  functions  with 
even  n  turn  out  even,  while  those  with  odd  n  are  odd.  In  accordance 
with  what  has  just  been  said,  the  wave  function  with  n  =  1  is 


*  If  gr0  ^  0  for  e  =  3,  then  the  series  in  even  powers  of  £  would  have  extended 
to  infinity,  which,  as  was  shown,  is  impossible. 


270 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


2  .  (26.23) 

This  function  becomes  zero  for  £  =  0,  i.e.,  it  has  one  node. 

In  the  same  way  it  is  easy  to  find  ip2-  Indeed,    <^2  —  A  co  12  +  -^-1  = 

=  -~-&G),   s==5.  From  (26.15),  the  coefficient  </2  is 


so  that 


(26.24) 


(26.25) 


£  1 

The  nodes  of  this  function  are  situated  at  the  points   s  —  db  — ^—-  - 

In  general,  the  function  fyn  has  n  nodes.  The  functions  for  several 
small  values  of  n  are  shown  in  Fig.  40. 

We  show  the  eigenvalue  distribution  and  the  potential  energy 
curve  in  Fig.  41.  It  is  very  curious  that  the 
eigenvalues  are  separated  by  equal  intervals. 
The  oscillator  problem  qualitatively  resembles 


Fig.  40 


Fig.  41 


that  of  an  infinitely  deep  rectangular  well  (Sec.  25),  but  the  energy 
level  in  the  well  increases  in  proportion  to  the  square  of  the  number. 

Exercises 

1)  Show  that,  neglecting  a  constant  factor,  the  function  gn  ( £)  may  be  written 
in  the  form 

ft,ra-.*/-dVl 


'/AY1 
U/ 


Verify  this  by  substitution  in  equation  (26.9),  in  which  e  =  2?H-l. 

2)  Normalize  the  functions  %  and  ^,  taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that 


-  00 

(see  exercises  of  Sec.  39). 


Sec.  27]  QUANTIZATION    OP   THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD  271 

Sec.  27.  Quantization  of  the  Electromagnetic  Field 

The  electromagnetic  field  as  a  mechanical  system.  An  electromagnetic 
field  in  a  vacuum  may  be  regarded  as  a  mechanical  system ;  this  was 
shown  in  Sec.  13.  It  possesses  a  Lagrangian  function,  action,  and  so 
on.  We  are,  therefore,  justified  in  posing  the  problem  of  quantization 
of  this  system,  i.e.,  applying  quantum  mechanics  to  it. 

The  basic  difference  between  electrodynamics  and  the  mechanics 
of  point  masses  is  that  the  degrees  of  freedom  of  an  electromagnetic 
field  are  distributed  continuously:  in  order  to  specify  the  field  at  a 
given  instant  of  time,  we  must  define  its  value  at  every  point  of  space. 
In  this  sense  electrodynamics  resembles  the  mechanics  of  liquids  or 
elastic  bodies,  if  one  regards  them  as  continuous  media  ignoring  the 
atomic  structure  of  the  substance.  The  degrees  of  freedom  of  a  field 
are  labelled  by  the  coordinates  of  points  in  space,  while  the  amplitude 
values  of  the  potential  are  generalized  coordinates  [see  (13.2)].  Poten- 
tials are  usually  chosen  as  generalized  coordinates  because  they  satisfy 
second-order  equations  in  time,  as  do  generalized  coordinates  in 
mechanics. 

The  potentials  satisfy  the  Lorentz  condition,  which  reduces  to 
div  A  =  0,  provided  the  gauge  transformations  are  chosen  so  as  to 
eliminate  the  scalar  potential. 

The  electromagnetic  field  coordinates  defined  in  this  way  are  not 
independent  of  one  another.  Indeed,  the  equations  of  electrodynamics 
involve  coordinate  derivatives,  i.e.,  differences  of  field  values  at 
infinitely  close  points.  In  this  sense,  field  equations  resemble  the 
equations  for  coupled  oscillations :  they  are  linear,  but  each  one  in- 
volves several  generalized  coordinates  instead  of  one.  The  equations  for 
coupled  oscillations  can  be  reduced  to  normal  coordinates  which  are 
mutually  independent.  The  same  can  be  done  with  the  wave  equations 
of  electrodynamics,  thus  separating  the  dependent  variables  therein. 
This  considerably  simplifies  the  application  of  quantum  mechanics 
to  radiation. 

Clearly  shown  here  is  the  generality  of  the  methods  of  analytical 
mechanics:  they  permit  determining  generalized  coordinates  and 
momenta  in  such  manner  that  quantum  laws  can  then  be  applied 
uniquely. 

The  electromagnetic  field  in  a  closed  volume.  We  must  first  of  all 
represent  the  electromagnetic  field  as  some  kind  of  closed  system, 
since  quantum  mechanics  is  most  conveniently  applied  to  such 
systems.  We  can  assume,  for  example,  that  the  radiation  is  contained 
in  a  box  with  mirror-type  reflecting  walls.  At  the  walls  of  such  an 
imaginary  box  (#  =  0  or  x—a^  y  =  Q  or  y  —  a2,  z  =  0  or  z=a3)  the 
normal  components  of  the  Poynting  vector  TJ  become  zero.  However, 
it  is  simpler  to  suppose  that  the  field  is  periodic  in  space,  and  the  lengths 
of  the  periods  in  three  perpendicular  directions  are  equal  to  the  di- 


272  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

mensions  of  the  box;  the  period  of  the  field  along  x  is  equal  to  al9 
that  along  y  is  equal  to  «2>  an^  that  along  z  is  equal  to  «3.  In  other 
words, 

A  (x,  y,z)=A(x  +  alt  y,  z)  =  A  (x>  y  +  a2,  z)  == 

=  A(*,y,3  +  a,).  (27.1) 

We  have,  as  it  were,  divided  space  into  physically  identical  regions, 
after  which  it  is  sufficient  to  consider  a  single  region. 

The  solution  of  equations  describing  a  harmonic  field  in  free  space 
was  found  in  Sec.  17  [see  (17.21)].  Introducing  a  time  dependence  into 
the  amplitude  factor,  we  represent  the  potential  in  the  following  form  : 

A  (k,  r,  t)  =  Ak  (t)e**  +  A*  (t)  e~'*  ,  (27.2) 

where  its  reality  is  shown  explicitly. 

The  potential  satisfies  the  Lorentz  condition  which,  for  a  plane 
wave,  can  be  reduced  to  the  form  divA  =  0  (since  9  =  0);  whence, 
by  (11.27),  we  obtain 


'*kr)  +  div(A*e-'kr)  == 
=  (AkVe{kr)  4-  (A*  Ve-'to) 


In  order  that  this  equation  be  satisfied  for  all  r,  the  coefficient  of 
each  exponential  term  must  convert  to  zero.  In  other  words,  the 
vectors  Ak  and  At  are  perpendicular  to  the  wave  vector  k: 


(kAk)=0,     (kAy  =  0.  (27.3) 

For  each  k  there  exist  two  mutually  perpendicular  vectors  A£  (or  =  1,2  ) 
corresponding  to  two  possible  wave  polarizations.  Any  vector  in  a 
plane  perpendicular  to  k  can  be  resolved  into  Ak1}  and  Ak2). 

We  shall  now  apply  the  periodicity  condition  (27.1)  to  each  term  of 
(27.2)  separately.  For  the  first  term  we  obtain 


=  A 

whence  it  follows  that 


Therefore  the  components  of  the  wave  vector  should  be 


L-    —    2TCn2         Tf    —   * TC  ™3  /97  A\ 

A/y   ,       tt/z  ,  \£i  I  .Tty 

where  nlf  n2,  n3  are  integers  of  any  sign. 

Consequently,  each  harmonic  oscillation  is  given  by  three  integers 
^i>  ^2»  %  an(i  a  polarization  CT,  which  can  take  two  values.  As  indicated 
in  Sec.  13,  A°lrtaWs  is  a  generalized  coordinate.  The  number  of  such 


Sec.  27]  QUANTIZATION    OF   THE    ELECTBOMAGNETIC    FIELD  273 

coordinates  is  infinite,  but  at  least  forms  a  denumerable  set,  and  not  a 
continuous  set  equivalent  to  the  set  of  all  points  in  space. 

This,  then,  is  the  basic  simplification  introduced  by  the  periodicity 
condition.  This  condition  is,  of  course,  only  a  mathematical  con- 
venience, there  being  no  basic  periods  ax,  a2,  and  «3  in  any  final 
physical  result. 

An  electromagnetic  field  is  specified  if  its  oscillation  amplitudes  are 
known  for  all  values  of  nl9  n2,  7i3,  and  a.  The  general  solution  is  equal 
to  the  sum  of  partial  solutions  due  to  the  linearity  of  electrodynamical 
equations  (27.2): 

A  (r,  0  =27  A°  <k>  r>  0  -27<A2c'kr  +  Are-"")  .  (27.5) 

k,  a  k,  a 

Energy  of  the  field.  An  electric  field  is  calculated  in  accordance  with 
(12.29)  and  (27.5): 

E  =  -  =  -27<A2*kr  +  AT  *-''kr)  -  (27.6) 


k,o 
The  amplitudes  of  the  field  depend  harmonically  upon  time,  so  that 

A£  =  —  *<okA£,    A£*=fccokA£.  (27.7) 

Therefore 

E  =  4j7cok(AZe''kr--  Ajfe-'*)  -  (27.8) 

k,<7 

The  magnetic  field  is  determined  from  (21.28)  and  (12.28): 


H  -  rot  A  =2?([Ve''kr>  Ak1  +  H?  e~l  kr>  Ak*D  = 

k,0 

-  iJTakAjp  e''kr-  [kA£*]e—  •"«).  (27.9) 

k,a 

Let  us  now  calculate  the  field  energy.  According  to  (13.21) 

dV.  (27.10) 


To  obtain  E2  we  perform  summation  over  k,  k',  cr,  and  cr': 


k.k'a.o' 

-  A£*  Afc-i  (k-k/)'  +  A°*A£*e-'-(k  »  k/)')  .  (27.11) 

It  is  expedient,  when  integrating  jE/2  over  a  volume,  to  change  the 
order  of  summation  and  integration,  each  volume  integral  being 


18  -  0060 


274  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

reduced  to  the  product  of  three  integrals  of  the  following  type: 


--  («,+  «')  n    (r2ni  ("i  +  ni>  }_1 

=   e*>      l     l  dx^^--.t~~4~l  -0 
J  2  7^  (>*!  +  <) 


o 


/V71,X 

(27.12) 


for  nl  -f  T&I  =£  0. 


If  Tij  +  ??i  —  0  this  integral  is  equal  to  ax.  Therefore  the  triple  integral 
assumes  one  of  two  values: 

f-'-'J;^!!;         ,27,3) 

It  follows  that  in  the  expression  for  E*  the  double  summation  with 
respect  to  k  and  k'  becomes  a  single  one  after  integration,  and  we  must 
replace  k'  by  —  k  in  the  terms  involving  the  product  A£  A£''.  In 
terms  containing  A£  Ak'*  we  replace  k'  by  k  due  to  the  factor 
c~'k/r.  Thus, 


V  =  -  7JT--  (  AJ  A^k  -  A£  A?  -  A£*  Ajf  +  A  f  A^k)  .   (27.  14) 

k,  c,  o' 

But  (given  a  /  a')  A£  and  A^k,  AJ  and  AJ'*  are  orthogonal 
vectors.  Therefore,  instead  of  the  double  summation  with  respect  to  or 
and  a',  there  also  remains  a  single  sum  with  respect  to  <r: 

JE*dV=  -  5-J[>k(AkAlk+  Af  A^-  2  A£  A*)-     (27.15) 


k,o 


When  calculating  the  integral  of  the  square  of  the  magnetic  field 
we  make  use  of  the  rule  (27.13).  But  since  the  product  [k'  A£'] 
is  replaced  by  —  [kA^k]  if  k'  —  -  —  k,  we  get 


J  +  2[kA°]  [kAj'J).  (27  J  6) 

k,  a,  o' 

The  vector  products  may  be  expressed  by  known  formulae: 

(kAjp  (kAf  )  -  FA-Af,          (27.17) 


where  we  have  used  the  trans  versality  condition  (27.3).  This  expression 
becomes  zero  for  a/  CT'. 
Thus, 

JH*dV=  7jT&2(A£Alk+A£*Al*k+2A£A<,*).  (27.18) 

k,o 

Combining  (27.14)  and  (27.18)  and  taking  advantage  of  the  fact 

AU~x      .2         ^2   /-2      ----     __  x 


Sec.  27]  QUANTIZATION    OF   THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD  275 

o>|A£A£*.  (27.19) 

k,o 

Passing  to  real  variables.  In  order  to  apply  the  usual  equations  of 
quantum  mechanics  to  the  electromagnetic  field,  it  is  convenient  to 
pass  to  real  variables 

n  / 5-  /'  a-  r>CT  \ 

(27.20) 


<27-21) 

where  e£  is  a  unit  vector  in  the  direction  of  polarization  of  the  wave. 
We  get  $  expressed  in  terms  of  a  sum  of  energies,  or  of  the  Hamiltonian 
functions  for  linear  harmonic  oscillators: 

-  <27-22) 


If  we  regard  P£  and  Q£  as  ordinary  classical  dynamical  variables, 
they  satisfy  the  equations  for  a  linear  harmonic  oscillator.  Indeed,  it 
follows  from  (27.22)  and  (10.18)  that  P£  =  —  <4  Qi  and  Qg  =  P2. 
This  agrees  with  the  harmonic  time  dependence  of  the  amplitudes 
Ag,  A£. 

Each  separate  oscillator  is  characterized  by  four  integers  nv  n2.  n3, 
and  cr,  which  label  the  independent  degrees  of  freedom  of  the  electro- 
magnetic field.  Qk  are  normal  coordinates  of  the  electromagnetic 
field  [see  (7.31)]. 

Quantization  of  the  electromagnetic  field.  The  result  we  have  ob- 
tained (27.22)  is  of  fundamental  significance.  It  provides  the  most 
simple  and  vivid  method  of  applying  quantum  mechanics  to  the  electro- 
magnetic field.  Indeed,  the  equations  of  nonquantized  oscillators  are 
equivalent  to  the  electrodynamical  equations  of  a  nonquantized  electro- 
magnetic field,  the  only  difference  being  that  they  describe  the  field 
in  other  variables.  But  the  oscillator  problem  in  quantum  mechanics 
having  already  been  solved  in  Sec.  26,  quantization  can  be  performed 
in  these  variables  as  before.  Quantization  of  the  motion  of  oscillators 
representing  a  field  in  vacuo  is  just  this  quantization  of  the  equations 
of  electrodynamics  performed  in  the  appropriate  system  of  variables. 
From  (26.21),  the  energy  of  an  oscillator  in  the  Nth  quantum  state 
was 


Therefore,  with  the  aid  of  equation  (27.22),  the  energy  of  the  electro- 


276  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

g  = J^cs.^  (#w,.0  +  I)  -2>"k  KO+  Y)  •        (27-23) 

«n  «a» «».  <*  k,  o 

The  numeral  Nni>thitl3ta  gives  the  number  of  the  quantum  state  of 
the  oscillator,  classified  by  the  numbers  nv  7i2,  7i3,  and  the  polari- 
zation a. 

Quanta.  We  see  that  the  energy  of  an  oscillator  can  experience 
increments  equal  to  Ao>Ml,M2fM3.  This  quantity  of  energy  is  called 
the  energy  quantum  of  the  electromagnetic  field.  Disregarding  the 

zero  energy    *<V"*"»   for  the  time  being,  we  see  that  the  field  energy 

is  equal  to  the  sum  of  the  energies  of  its  quanta  &conitflfffv  Thus 
is  found  a  quantum  expression  for  the  energy  of  an  electromagnetic 
field.  It  will  be  shown  in  exercise  1  of  this  section  that  the  momentum 
of  a  field  is  equal  to  the  sum  of  the  momenta  of  its  quanta,  while  the 
momentum  of  each  quantum  is  found  to  be  related  to  its  energy  by  the 
expression 

p  =  Ak  =  -^|.  (27.24) 

Thus,  a  quantum  possesses  the  properties  of  a  particle  of  zero  mass. 
The  possibility  of  the  existence  of  such  particles  was  elucidated  in 
connection  with  equation  (21.16). 

Polarization  of  quanta.  A  quantum  has  one  more,  so  .to  say,  internal 
degree  of  freedom,  that  of  polarization.  This  peculiar  degree  of  freedom 
corresponds  to  the  "coordinate"  a,  taking  only  two  values  <r~l 
and  a  =  2.  The  energy  does  not  depend  upon  CT.  But,  of  course,  in  order 
to  fully  define  the  oscillation  corresponding  to  a  given  quantum,  we 
must  indicate  the  number  or  =  l,  2  as  well  as  the  three  numbers  nl9 
n2,  7i3.  We  observe  that  these  quanta  relate  only  to  the  transverse 
field  of  electromagnetic  waves  and  do  not  describe  the  Coulomb 
field. 

The  classical  approximation  ot  quanta  and  electrons.  A  quantum 
should  by  no  means  be  regarded  as  the  outcome  of  some  mathematical 
sleight  of  hand  that  led  us  to  equation  (27.23).  The  quantum  is  an 
elementary  particle  just  as  real  as  the  electron.  For  example,  when 
X-rays  are  scattered  by  electrons,  the  energy  of  each  individual  quan- 
tum Ji  to  and  its  momentum  &k  are  involved  in  the  general  law  of 
conservation  of  energy  and  momentum  in  collisions  in  the  same  way 
as  for  any  other  particle.  In  scattering,  the  frequency  of  a  quantum 
diminishes,  in  direct  proportion  to  its  energy. 

The  essential  difference  between  the  quantum  and  the  electron 
consists  in  the  fact  that  in  classical  theory  there  is  nothing  to  which  the 
quantum  corresponds;  its  energy  <?<,>= A  to  and  its  momentum  p=Ak 
tend  to  zero  when  h  tends  to  zero.  Yet  the  quantum  mechanics  of  the 
electron  admits  of  a  classical  approximation,  since  the  quantum  quan- 


Sec.  27]  QUANTIZATION    OF   THE   ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD  277 

tities  for  the  electron  become  corresponding  classical  quantities,  which 
do  not  tend  to  zero  even  when  we  take  h  ->0.  The  relation  (27.24) 
has  a  counterpart  in  classical  electrodynamics;  the  energy  density 
of  an  electromagnetic  wave  was  shown  in  Sec.  17  to  be  related  to  its 
momentum  by  means  of  the  factor  c.  In  the  limiting  transition  to 
classical  theory,  the  energy  of  each  quantum  is  regarded  as  infinitely 
small  while  their  number  JVkf  0  is  infinitely  large,  so  that  the  wave 
amplitude  remains  finite. 

Occupation  numbers.  Passing  from  Cartesian  coordinates  to  new 
independent  variables  (the  components  of  the  wave  vector  k),  wo 
renumbered  the  radiation  degrees  of  freedom,  the  quantities  Q& 
now  being  the  generalized  coordinates.  The  state  of  a  field  is  specified 
if  all  the  "occupation"  numbers  JVk,  o  are  known,  because  the  number 
Nkt  a  defines  the  quantum  state  the  given  harmonic  oscillator  is  in, 
i.e.,  the  number  of  quanta  in  the  state  k,  a.  The  numbers  Nk,a  may 
be  regarded  as  the  quantum  variables  of  an  electromagnetic  field. 
When  a  field  interacts  with  a  radiator  (for  example,  an  atom)  these 
numbers  change.  For  example,  if  the  number  N^a  has  increased  by 
unity  this  means  that  a  quantum  of  corresponding  frequency,  direction, 
and  polarization  has  been  emitted. 

The  ground  state  of  an  electromagnetic  field.  Let  us  now  examine 
expression  (27.23)  when  N^ta  =  0.  In  other  words,  let  us  determine 
the  ground  state  energy  of  the  electromagnetic  field.  According  to 
(27.23)  it  is 


MI,  «2,  W3,  O 

But  since  the  numbers  nl9  n2,  and  n3  run  through  an  infinite  set  of 
values,  the  sum  (27.25)  is  infinitely  large.  It  must  be  said  that  in  this 
case  the  theory  is  not  fundamentally  defective  because  the  zero 
energy  itself  (27.25),  does  not  appear  in  any  expression  ;  the  field  energy 
is  always  measured  from  the  ground  state. 

At  the  same  time,  the  ground  state  ^0  of  the  quantum  oscillators 
of  an  electromagnetic  field  leads  to  actually  observable  effects  because 
the  amplitude  of  a  harmonic  oscillator  in  the  ground  state  is  not  equal 
to  zero.  It  takes  on  all  possible  values,  and,  in  accordance  with  (26.22), 
the  probability  of  a  certain  value  of  Q  is  proportional  to  |  ^0  (Q)  |2. 

In  an  electromagnetic  field,  the  part  of  the  oscillator  coordinates  is 
played  by  the  generalized  coordinates  Q,  in  terms  of  which  the  field 
amplitudes  are  expressed  linearly.  Therefore,  one  can  by  no  means 
assert  that  the  field  amplitudes  are  equal  to  zero  in  the  ground  state 
of  an  electromagnetic  field  (i.e.,  in  the  absence  of  quanta).  The  prob- 
abilities of  definite  amplitude  values  are  given  by  the  harmonic- 

-  °>Qa 

oscillator  wave  functions.  These  functions  are  equal  to  e  2h  in 
coordinates. 


278  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Electron-level  shift  produced  by  the  ground  state  of  a  field.  The  ground 
state  of  an  electromagnetic  field  affects  observable  quantities.  One 
of  the  most  important  effects  of  this  type  consists  in  the  following. 

Let  an  electron  move  in  the  potential  field  of  a  nucleus.  The  value 
of  the  electromagnetic  potentials  of  a  field  acting  on  the  electron  is 

usually  chosen  as  A  =  0,  9=-'.--.  Only  the  static  Coulomb  field  has 

been  taken  into  account.  In  actual  fact,  the  potential  of  the  radiating 
field  must  be  added  to  the  static  potential,  for  example,  in  the  form 
(27.5).  As  was  indicated,  this  potential  must  not  be  considered  equal 
to  zero  even  when  there  are  no  quanta  in  the  field.  The  field  of  radiation 
affects  the  energy  eigenvalues  of  the  electrons  in  an  atom.  They 
prove  different  from  what  they  should  be  in  a  purely  Coulomb  nuclear 

field  with  A  =  0,  <p  =  — —  . 

The  solution  of  the  problem  of  finding  the  energy  eigenvalues  for  an 
atom,  with  account  taken  of  the  radiation  field,  encounters  considerable 
inherent  difficulties.  First  of  all,  this  problem  does  not  lend  itself  to 
a  precise  solution  by  means  of  mathematical  analysis.  It  becomes  neces- 
sary to  solve  it  approximately,  taking  the  correction  to  the  energy 
produced  by  the  radiating  field  as  a  small  quantity.  Til  actuality,  how- 
ever, a  direct  calculation  of  this  correction  leads  to  divergent  integrals, 
i.e.,  to  infinite  expressions. 

Nevertheless,  it  is  possible  to  redetermine  this  correction  so  that  a 
finite  expression  is  obtained.  To  do  this,  one  has  to  consider  the  anal- 
ogous correction  for  the  energy  of  a  "free"  electron  not  influenced  by 
the  external  field  of  the  nucleus,  and  consider  the  difference  of  two 
infinite  integrals.  If  in  doing  so  we  take  great  care  to  follow  the  rela- 
tivistic  invariance  of  the  expressions,  the  subtraction  turns  out  to  be 
a  completely  unique  operation  and  does  not  contain  any  indeterminate 
quantity  of  the  form  oo  —  oo.  The  final  correction  does  indeed  turn 
out  to  be  a  small  quantity  compared  with  the  binding  energy  of  the 
electron  in  the  atom  in  its  ground  state  (4  x  10  ~6  ev  for  the  hydrogen 
atom).  The  value  of  the  correction  is  in  excellent  agreement  with  mod- 
ern radiospectroscopic  data. 

Subtraction  of  infinities.  The  meaning  of  such  a  subtraction  consists 
in  the  following.  Physically,  an  electron  is  inseparable  from  its  charge, 
i.e.,  from  its  radiation  field.  When  we  talk  about  a  "free"  electron, 
we  always  imply  that  the  electron  interacts  with  a  radiation  field, 
which  cannot  be  regarded  as  equal  to  zero.  The  rest  energy  of  an  elec- 
tron is  equal  to  me2,  where  m  denotes  the  observed  value  of  the  mass. 
In  reality,  this  quantity  encompasses  the  energy  of  all  interactions 
of  the  electron,  including  interaction  with  the  field  of  radiation. 

Thus,  in  calculating  the  energy  of  an  electron  in  a  Coulomb  field, 
the  mass  of  the  electron  must  be  redefined  so  that,  in  the  absence  of 
any  static  external  field,  all  the  energy  has  a  finite  value  we2.  This 


»SCC.  27]  QUANTIZATION    OF   THE    ELECTROMAGNETIC    FIELD  279 

redefinition  operation  or,  as  it  is  called,  "renormalization"  of  mass 
allows  us  to  find  a  finite  quantity  for  the  energy  eigenvalue  of  an 
electron  in  an  atom.  Concerning  the  levels  in  a  hydrogen  atom,  see 
Sees.  31  and  38. 

The  renormalization  operation  consists  in  the  fact  that  the  mass 
which  appears  formally  in  the  equations  of  mechanics,  together  with 
the  mass  due  to  the  interaction  of  the  electron  with  radiation,  is  re- 
garded as  the  observed  finite  quantity  w  =  0.9  106  x  10~27  gm.  Only 
this  known  quantity  appears  in  the  final  result  for  any  calculated 
effect. 

Difficulties  of  the  theory.  The  appearance  of  divergent  (i.e.,  infinite) 
expressions  in  quantum  electrodynamics  is  a  defect  of  the  theory  and 
indicates  a  certain  internal  contradiction.  The  modern  form  of  the 
theory  as  given  by  J.  Schwinger,  R.  Feynman  and  F.  Dyson,  is  appar- 
ently, not  yet  final. 

It  is  all  the  more  remarkable  that  despite  this  imperfection,  quan- 
tum electrodynamics  is  capable—  with  the  aid  of  renormalization  —  of 
yielding  correct  and  unique  answers  when  calculating  concrete  quan- 
tities observed  in  experiment. 

Exercise 

Calculate  the  electromagnetic  Hold  momentum  in  a  vacuum  in  terms  of 
the  normal  field  coordinates  Q£ 
In  the  expression  (13.27) 


we  substitute  the  electric  and  magnetic  fields  from  (27.8)  and  (27.9).  After 
integration  over  the  volume  we  obtain  by  (27.13) 


k  ([Ak  I  kA°'  J]  +  [A£  [*Ak*JJ  +  [Af  I  kA|']]  +  [Af 

k,  a,  a' 

We  rearrange  the  double  vector  products: 


-"•  T^Z1  w*  (kAk  A-  k  -I-  2  kA£  A£*  +  kA£*  A'*k) 


k,  a 


The  quantities   kAk  A^_k  and  kAk*  A^!k  are  odd  functions  of  k,  and  disappear 
after  summation  over  all  k.  There  remains  only 


k,  o 

Substituting  here  the  normal  coordinates  of  the  field  from  (27.20)  and  (27.21), 
we  arrive  at  the  expression 

p  -E\  2-  <n°  +4<>  -2>*  (AV  .  +  -I) . 

k,  o  k,  o 

so  that  the  momentum  of  each  quantum  is  related  to  its  energy  by  relation 


280  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

Sec.  28.  Quasi-Classical  Approximation 

The  classical  limit  of  a  wave  function.  It  was  shown  in  Sec.  24  that 
the  limiting  transition  from  quantum  mechanics  to  classical  mechan- 
ics is  performed  by  means  of  the  substitution  of  (24.5) 


=       h 


(28.1) 


By  substituting  ip  into  (24.11)  (i.e.,  into  the  Schrodinger  equation), 

•  A 
eliminating  e    h  ,  and  formally  making  h  tend  to  zero,  we  obtained  the 

correct  classical  relation  between  energy  and  momentum.  This  limiting 
process  signifies  that  the  de  Broglie  wavelength  —  —  —  is  very  small 

compared  with  the  region  in  which  the  motion  occurs. 

It  is  sometimes  useful  not  to  carry  the  limiting  process  to  its  end, 
namely  in  those  cases  when  the  asymptotic  form  of  the  almost  classi- 
cal wave  function  is  important.  If  the  wavelength  is  small  compared 
with  the  region  in  which  motion  occurs,  then  the  wave  function  has 
many  nodes  in  this  region  and,  as  we  know  from  Sec.  25,  this  corre- 
sponds to  an  energy  eigenvalue  with  a  large  number.  Thus,  the  passage 
from  quantum  laws  of  motion  to  classical  laws  is  accomplished  through 
a  region  in  which  the  number  of  the  eigenvalue  is  large  compared  with 
unity.  If  the  energy  eigenvalue  is  determined  by  several  integers,  as 
in  the  case  with  motion  having  several  degrees  of  freedom  (cf.  the 
problem  of  the  potential  well),  then  all  these  numbers  must  be  large 
compared  with  unity  so  that  the  motion  should  be  close  to  the  classical 
limit.  The  wave  function  in  approximation  (28.1)  (where  S  is  the  classi- 
cally calculated  action)  thus  allows  us  to  determine  eigenvalues  with 
large  numbers  [see  (28.18)]. 

Solutions  with  real  values  of  the  exponent.  The  wave  function  does 
not  convert  to  zero  also  for  real  values  of  the  exponent  in  (28.1),  i.e., 
for  irnaginarjr  values  of  S.  Imaginary  values  can  only  occur  in  those 
regions  of  space  into  which  —  for  a  given  energy  —  the  trajectories  of 
classical  motion  cannot  enter,  because  the  potential  energy  would  be 
greater  in  that  case  than  the  total  energy,  corresponding  to  a  negative 
kinetic  energy  or  an  imaginary  velocity.  In  these  cases,  the  square  of 
the  modulus  of  the  wave  function  determines  the  probability  of  a 
particle  penetrating  into  a  classically  unattainable  region  of  motion. 
Naturally,  this  probability  does  not  convert  to  zero  only  anterior  to 
the  limiting  transition,  and  not  posterior  to  it,  when  h  has  already 
been  eliminated  from  the  equations.  This  is  why  approximation  (28.1) 
is  termed  quasi-classical. 

The  quasi-classical  approximation.  Let  us  write  the  equations  of 
transition  to  a  quasi-classical  approximation  in  a  one-dimensional 


Sec.  28]  QUASI-CLASSICAL   APPROXIMATION  281 

o  Cf  /I  G 

case.  From  (24.14),  by  substituting  -~^~  =  —  $  and  y  $=  -7— into  it 
(the  one-dimensional  case!),  we  have 

i7),  (28.2) 

whence  ~)  dx.  (28.3) 


Unlike  classical  mechanics,  equation  (28.3)  holds  not  only  for 
$  >  U,  when  the  root  is  extracted  from  a  positive  quantity,  but  also 
when  §  <  U,  when  the  action  is  imaginary. 

In  Sec.  25  we  investigated  a  similar  example  of  the  precise  wave  equa- 
tion for  the  problem  of  a  potential  well  of  finite  depth.  In  the  region  of 
the  well ,  the  wave  function  was  of  the  form  fy  =  sin  x  x,  while  outside  the 

well  it  approached  zero  exponentially  like  e~**.  This  resulted  precise- 
ly when  $  <  [7,  i.e.,  in  a  classically  unattainable  region.  Of  course, 
an  imaginary  velocity  signifies  that  a  particle  moving  according  to 
classical  laws  does  not  attain  the  given  position.  Therefore,  the  expres- 
sion 

±  ±JV2m"( t/^?)" dx  (28.4) 

must  not  longer  be  understood  as  action,  but  simply  as  the  exponent 
in  the  equation 

;Js_ 

fy  =  e    h  > 

extended  to  the  region  <?  <  C7,  if  there  is  such  a  region.  When  h  -^0, 
the  wave  function  will  be  damped  in  this  region  infinitely  quickly — like 
e~°° ;  and  this  denotes  the  unattainability  of  points  where  for  classical 
motion  $  <  U. 

The  potential  barrier.  In  the  potential  well  problem,  the  region  for 
which  U  >$  extended  rightward  to  infinity.  Therefore,  the  wave 
function  became  zero  at  infinity.  Considerable 
interest  is  attached  to  another  problem,  in 
which  the  potential  energy  at  a  certain  distance 
away  from  the  well  again  becomes  less  than 
the  total  energy.  This  is  shown  in  Fig.  42. 
U  >$  for  the  region  xl  ^  x  ^  x2.  Therefore, 
in  classical  mechanics  a  particle  situated  to 
the  left  of  x  =  xl  cannot  under  any  circum- 


stances attain  the  region  x  >  x2,  from  which  xi  xz       x 

it  is  separated  by  a  potential  barrier.  In  Fig.  42 

quantum  mechanics,  the  wave  function  does 

not  become  zero  between  x^  and  #2,  since  this  region  is  finite  (see 
exercise  2,  Sec.  26). 

In  the  approximation  (28.1),  the  exponent  in  the  equation  is  a  real 
quantity  when  x  <  xv  Therefore,  the  modulus  of  fy  remains  equal  to  unity : 


282  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 


On  the  other  hand,  between  xl  and  #2,  the  modulus  of  ip  decreases 
according  to  the  law 

x  \2  * 

*j  dx  -  4-  f  VSlToN^n  dx 

J    =e     *i  .      (28.5) 

At  #  =  #2,  in  comparison  with  the  point  x~xl  it  diminishes  in  the  ratio 


~~  T"       V2m(U-<f)  dx 

#=e        't  (28.6) 

after  which  it  again  stops  changing,  since  S  becomes  a  real  quantity. 

Hence,  the  square  of  the  modulus  of  the  wave  function  diminishes 
between  x^  and  x2  according  to  the  expression  determined  by  the 
quantity  B.  A  more  precise  theory  provides  a  correction  factor  for  B, 
though  fundamentally,  the  function  is  determined  by  B  alone.  B  is 
called  the  barrier  factor.  Somewhat  later,  it  will  be  explained  how  the 
B  factor  is  related  to  the  penetration  probability  through  the  barrier 
in  unit  time. 

The  quasi-classical  approximation  is  feasible  only  when  the  order 
of  magnitude  for  the  action  is  large  compared  with  h.  This  was  men- 
tioned in  Sec.  24,  when  the  conditions  for  the  limiting  transition  to 
classical  mechanics  were  being  determined.  For  this  reason,  equation 
(28.6)  may  be  used  only  when  the  exponent  is  large  compared  with 
unity.  If  it  is  comparable  with  unity,  the  penetration  probability 
through  the  barrier  must  be  evaluated  by  means  of  precise  wave  func- 
tions, 

The  Mandelshtam  analogy.  In  wave  optics  there  is  an  analogy  to 
the  passage  of  a  particle  through  a  potential  barrier.  When  a  lighl 
wave  falls  on  the  boundary  of  a  medium  of  small  refractive  index  froir 
a  medium  of  larger  refractive  index  at  an  angle  whose  sine  is  greater 
than  the  ratio  of  the  indices  of  refraction,  there  occurs  total  internal 
reflection  in  accordance  with  the  laws  of  geometrical  optics.  If  the 
problem  is  solved  in  strict  accord  with  wave  optics,  on  the  basis  of 
Maxwell's  equations  (see  exercise  2,  Sec.  17),  then  it  turns  out  that  the 
wave  penetrates  somewhat  into  the  second  medium,  but  dies  out 
exponentially  in  it.  L.  I.  Mandelshtam  took  notice  of  this  analogy 
between  quantum  mechanics  and  wave  optics.  It  can  be  applied  in  the 
following  manner. 

Let  us  imagine  two  optically  dense  media  separated  by  a  layer 
optically  less  dense.  Let  a  light  ray  fall  on  the  interface  of  the  media 
at  an  angle  to  the  normal  larger  than  the  angle  of  total  internal  re- 
flection. According  to  geometrical  optics,  the  ray  should  be  complete- 


Sec.  28]  QUASI -CLASSICAL    APPROXIMATION  283 

ly  reflected  by  the  layer,  and  it  is  absolutely  immaterial  whether  or 
not  there  is  a  denser  medium  beyond  the  layer,  or  whether  the  re- 
flection occurs  from  an  infinitely  thick,  nondense  medium.  Similarly, 
a  particle  in  classical  mechanics  is  completely  incapable  of  penetrating 
the  barrier.  According  to  the  laws  of  wave  optics,  light  penetrates 
into  a  nondense  medium,  but  dies  out  in  a  thickness  comparable  with 
the  wavelength.,  Therefore,  if  the  second  dense  medium  is  situated 
closely  enough,  part  of  the  light  "seeps"  into  it. 

The  classical  expression  for  the  amplitude  of  a  light  wave  may  be 
regarded  as  the  wave  function  in  relation  to  a  light  quantum.  The 
transition  from  quantum  theory  to  classical  electrodynamics  consists 
in  considering  the  occupation  numbers  ^k,o  as  large  (see  Sec.  28). 
Then  the  corresponding  field  amplitudes  change  to  classical  ones.  For 
this  reason  the  Mandelshtam  analogy  represents  an  example  of  quanta 
penentrating  through  a  barrier.  As  has  already  been  pointed  out,  the 
limiting  transition  for  electrons  occurs  differently;  it  corresponds  to 
the  transition  from  wave  optics  to  geometrical  optics.  Therefore,  in 
the  classical  limit,  electrons  do  not  penetrate  the  barrier. 

The  existence  of  penetrations  through  a  barrier  clearly  indicates 
that  the  concept  of  a  trajectory  is  sometimes  completely  inapplicable 
in  the  case  of  quantum  motion.  A  trajectory  extended  under  the 
barrier  would  lead  to  imaginary  velocity  values. 

Alpha  disintegration.  Passage  through  a  potential  barrier  enables  us 
to  explain  one  of  the  most  important  facts  of  nuclear  physics,  that  of 
alpha  disintegration.  The  nuclear  masses  of  heavy  elements  with  atomic 
numbers  greater  than  that  of  lead  satisfy  an  inequality  of  the  form 
(21.12): 

m  (A ,  Z)  >  m  (A  -  4,  Z  -  2)  +  m  (4,  2) .  (28.7) 

Here  A  is  the  atomic  weight  and  Z  is  the  nuclear  charge  (i.e.,  the 
atomic  number  in  the  Mendeleyev  table).  Thus,  m  (4,2  )  is  the  mass  of 
a  helium  necleus  with  atomic  weight  4  and  atomic  number  2.  Such  a 
nucleus  emitted  during  alpha  disintegration  is  called  an  alpha  particle. 
All  that  can  be  seen  from  equations  (21.12)  and  (28.7)  is  that  the 
spontaneous  decay  of  a  nucleus  of  mass  m  (A,  Z)  is  possible,  though  no 
indication  is  obtained  about  the  time  law  of  disintegration.  The 
nuclei  of  certain  elements  have  mean  decay  times  of  1010  years  while 
others  have  decay  times  of  about  10~5  sec,  which  is  a  difference  of 
23  orders  of  magnitude.  It  will  be  noted  that  the  energy  of  the  alpha 
particles  emitted  differs  here  by  a  factor  of  only  two.  From  experiment 
it  turns  out  that  the  logarithm  of  the  mean  decay  time  of  a  nucleus 
is  inversely  proportional  to  the  alpha-particle  velocity.  It  is  this 
logarithmic  law  that  corresponds  to  the  difference  of  23  magnitudes. 
It  is  accounted  for  by  the  difference  of  barrier  factors  which  depend 
exponentially  upon  the  energy. 


284  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

The  potential-energy  curve.  At  large  distances  from  a  nucleus,  an 
alpha  particle  experiences  a  repulsive  force  of  potential  energy 


[cf.  (3.4)].  At  small  distances,  attractive  forces  must  act  because, 
otherwise,  the  nucleus  (A,  Z)  could  not  exist  at  all.  We  do  not  know 
the  force  law  (i.  e.,  the  shape  of  the  potential-energy  curve  when  the 

alpha  particle  is  situated  sufficiently  close 
to  the  nucleus)  and,  therefore,  in  Fig.  43 
we  draw  it  at  will.  In  this  we  must  be 
guided  by  the  following  considerations. 
The  special  nuclear  forces  which  hold 
the  alpha  particle  in  the  nucleus  before 
emission  have  a  smalJ  radius  of  action,  so 
the  potential-energy  curve  has  the  form 
of  a  "potential  well."  Motion  inside  the 
nucleus  corresponds  to  motion  inside  such 
a  well.  The  transition  region  from  the  well 
to  the  Coulomb  curve  is  not  very  essential 
-  43  for  final  results,  i.  e.,  it  little  affects  the 

exponent  of  the  barrier  factor. 

The  barrier  factor  for  alpha  disintegration.  The  energy  of  an  alpha 
particle  is  positive  at  an  infinite  distance  from  the  nucleus.  It  is 
this  that  signifies  that  the  nucleus  is  capable  of  alpha  disintegration, 
i.e.,  the  alpha  particle  can  move  infinitely.  In  order  to  find  the  prob- 
ability for  alpha  disintegration,  we  must  calculate  the  barrier  factor 
B  in  accordance  with  (28.6).  Because  nuclear  forces  are  short-range 
forces,  the  transition  region  is  small  and  we  can  extrapolate  the 
Coulomb  law,  without  sensible  error  in  the  integral,  up  to  the  point 
r  =  r1  where  S  becomes  greater  than  U.  Point  ^  is  the  effective  nuclear 
radius  determined  from  alpha  disintegration.  Other  data  concerning 
the  nucleus  lead  to  somewhat  different  values  for  the  respectively 
determined  effective  radius.  This  is  understandable  since  rx  is  obtained 
on  the  particular  assumption  that  the  Coulomb  law  is  valid  up  to  the 
region  for  which  the  potential  energy  curve  is  taken  in  the  form  of  a 
well  with  steep  sides. 

And  so  we  determine  the  barrier  factor  according  to  the  equation 


(28.9) 
ubsti- 

2]Z_2)e2  "" ™°  *'  (28.10) 


The  integral  in  the  exponent  can  be  easily  calculated  by  the  substi- 
tution 


Sec.  28]  QUASI-CLASSICAL   APPROXIMATION  285 

Then,  after  elementary  treatment,  it  reduces  to  the  form 


(08  U) 

^'      j 


The  quantity  --r^^1     2  is  the  ratio  of  the  alpha  particle  energy  to 

the  effective  barrier  height  at  the  point  rl9  taken  according  to  equation 
(28.8).  Let  us  evaluate  this  ratio.  For  heavy  nuclei  2  (Z  —  2)^180, 
rt^  9  x  10-13  cm  ;  we  shall  take  S  to  be  equal  to  6  Mev,  e2  =  23  x  10  ~20. 
Whence 

<?>!  6.  l. 


__  _ 

2  (Z  -  2)  e*  ~~          180  •  23".  1Q-20  -        ~  5  ' 

To  a  first  approximation,  we  shall  consider  this  quantity  as  small. 
Then,  on  the  right-hand  side  of  (28.1  1),  we  obtain  the  approximation 


2\/2i 


n        g"|/        ^'^         \ 
2  '    2(Z~2)e2  ]~ 


=  .  2  (Z  -  2)  -      V^72"  ("Z^2)~  .  (28.12) 

It  is  easy  to  check  the  correctness  of  this  expansion  by  a  direct  numer- 
ical substitution. 

The  time  dependence  of  alpha  disintegration.  We  shall  now  show 
how  the  expression  for  the  barrier  factor  is  related  to  the  probability 
of  alpha  disintegration  in  unit  time.  In  exercise  2,  Sec.  25,  it  was  found 
that  the  particle  flux  passing  through  a  barrier  is  proportional  to  the 
particle  density  before  the  barrier.  It  is  easy  to  see  that  the  basic 
result  obtained  in  the  problem  of  a  rectangular  barrier  coincides, 
in  the  limit,  with  the  result  of  this  section,  if  we  go  over  to  the  quasi- 
classical  approximation.  Indeed,  we,  so  to  say,  divide  a  barrier  of 
arbitrary  shape  into  separate,  successive  rectangular  barriers.  The 

penetration  probability  for  each  of  them   is  e     h  = 

_  e-  2x  &x  5  where  A  a;  is  the  width  of  the  rectangular  barrier.  The  total 
penetration  probability  will  be  determined  by  reduction  of  the  ampli- 
tude of  the  wave  function  over  the  whole  width  of  the  barrier.  In  other 

2         _____ 

words,  it  will  be  proportional  to  the  product  II  e     h  .  This 

i      *.  t,    •        i          i       u  j.   j   vi          ""^7"T  Vam(U-tf)    Ax 

product  can,  obviously,  also  be  represented  like  e  ^-'  " 


286  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

or,  in  the  limit,  like  e     h  }       m  *  corresponding  to  (28.6).  Thus, 

for  any  potential  barrier,  we  can  assert  that  the  flux  of  transmitted 
particles  is  proportional  to  the  particle  density  before  the  barrier 
multiplied  by  the  barrier  factor. 

From  this  we  can  deduce  the  time  dependence  of  alpha  disintegra- 
tion. The  probability  of  an  alpha  particle  existing  inside  the  nucleus 
is  equal  to  the  integral  of  the  square  of  the  wave-function  modulus 
over  the  volume  of  the  nucleus,  i.e.,  over  the  region  r<rl.  As  has 
just  been  indicated,  the  alpha-particle  flux  emitted  from  the  nucleus 
is  proportional  to  the  probability  density  of  their  being  in  the  nucleus, 
the  constant  of  proportionality  being  basically  determined  by  the 
barrier  factor.  It  follows  that  the  number  of  nuclei  decaying  in  unit 
time  is  proportional  to  the  total  number  of  nuclei  present  that  have 
not  disintegrated  by  the  given  instant.  The  constant  of  proportionality 
depends  upon  the  shape  of  the  barrier  and  upon  the  state  of  the  par- 
ticles inside  the  nucleus,  but  it  cannot  be  a  function  of  time,  as  may 
be  seen,  for  example,  from  the  equations  obtained  in  exercise  2,  Sec.  25. 
Indeed,  this  constant  is  obtained  from  the  solution  of  the  wave 
equation  with  the  time  dependence  eliminated,  i.e.,  (24.22). 

For  this  reason,  the  law  for  alpha  disintegration  is  expressed  by  the 
equation 

_  rt 
^L  =  __  JL N9      N=NQe     '»",  (28.13) 

where  N  is  the  number  of  nuclei  that  have  not  disintegrated  at  the 
given  instant  of  time  and  NQ  is  the  initial  number  of  nuclei.  The 
quantity  F  has  the  dimensions  of  energy  for  convenience  of  comparison 
with  other  quantities  of  the  same  dimension.  Every  nucleus  has  the 
same  probability  of  decaying  in  unit  time,  no  matter  how  long  it 

has  been  in  existence.  This  probability  is  -=-  and  does  not  depend 

upon  time. 

Equations  (28.13)  and  (28.12)  confirm  the  experimentally  deter- 
mined law  which  yields  an  inversely  proportional  relationship  between 
the  logarithm  of  the  probability  for  alpha  disintegration  and  the 
alpha-particle  velocity  v. 

The  nuclear  wave  function  before  decay.  It  is  easy  to  obtain  a 
time  dependence  for  the  wave  function  of  a  nucleus  which  has  not 
emitted  an  alpha  particle.  It  looks  like 

^e-lr.e"'^"-  (28.14) 

The  first  factor  accounts  for  the  exponential  attenuation  of  ampli- 
r< 

tude  according  to  a  e     2/l  law  (since  the  probability,  i.e.,  the  square 


Sec.  28]  QUASI-CLASSICAL   APPROXIMATION  287 

Tt 

of  the  amplitude,  diminishes  according  to  e  h  ) ;  the  second  factor 
is  the  usual  wave-function  time  factor.  Expression  (28.14)  is  very 
similar  to  the  well-known  formula  for  damped  oscillations,  with  the 
difference  that  in  the  given  case  it  is  the  probability  amplitude 
of  the  initial  (not  yet  decayed)  state  of  the  nucleus  that  is 
damped. 

The  wave  function  (28.14)  satisfies  the  initial  condition  |<p  (0)|  =  1. 
Since  the  wave -function  equation  is  of  the  first  order  with  respect 
to  time,  it  is  absolutely  necessary  to  impose  some  initial  condition. 
It  was  assumed  that  at  the  initial  instant  of  time  an  alpha  particle 
was  definitely  situated  inside  the  nucleus.  However,  for  this  wave 
function,  the  right-hand  side  of  equation  (24.16)  does  not  become 
zero :  there  is  a  finite  flux  for  the  probability  of  a  particle  being  emitted 
from  the  nucleus.  This  is  what  leads  to  the  exponential  damping 
of  the  probability  of  the  predecay  state. 

All  nuclei  before  disintegration  are  described  by  exactly  the  same 
wave  function  (28.14),  if  at  the  instant  £  =  0  they  were  in  the  initial 
state.  Therefore,  they  all  have  a  perfectly  identical  probability  of 
decaying  in  unit  time,  and  it  is  impossible  to  predict  which  one  of 
them  will  decay  earlier  and  which  later.  In  exactly  the  same  way, 
in  the  diffraction  experiment  it  is  impossible  to  say  which  part  of 
the  photographic  plate  will  be  hit  by  a  given  electron.  The  decay 
law  is  purely  statistical,  in  the  same  way  as  the  law  for  diffraction 
pattern. 

In  this  sense,  radioactive  decay  does  not  resemble  the  falling  of 
ripe  fruit  from  a  tree — an  alpha  particle  in  a  nucleus  is  always  identi- 
cally "ripe"  for  emission.  This  is  suggested  by  the  homogeneity  of 
the  decay  law  (28.13)  with  respect  to  time. 

The  indeterminacy  of  a  nuclear  energy  level  before  decay.  The  wave 
function  (28.14)  does  not  belong  to  any  eigenvalue  of  the  energy  S, 
since  the  states  with  energy  $  have  wave  functions  which  are  time- 

-i^~ 
dependent  according  to  e       h  .  Such  states  should  exist  for  an  un- 

limitedly  long  time  because  the  amplitude  of  their  probability  does 
not  fall  off,  while  the  probability  for  an  undecayed  nuclear  state 

is  reduced  by  e  times  in  a  time  A£  ==  — .  We  can  define  the  time  interval 
•*  i 

—  as  the  characteristic  (or  mean)  attenuation  time. 

Let  us  now  suppose  that  the  wave  function  (28.14)  is  represented 
as  the  sum  of  wave  functions  of  states  whose  energies  are  determined 
accurately.  We  know  that  the  time  dependence  of  these  functions 

—  «  — 
is  given  by  the  factor  e    h  .  In  other  words,  we  have  to  represent 

__  _EL_  .  <*<>' 

the  * 'non-monochromatic"  wave  e     2h         h    as  the  sum  of  "mono- 


288  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

chromatic"  waves  f,"~l'ir*\     I*1  which  energy  interval  A<?  (by  order 

of  magnitude)  will  the  amplitude  of  these  monochromatic  waves 
differ  noticeably  from  zero  ? 

We  can  answer  this  question  by  making  use  of  relation  (18.6). 
According  to  this  relationship,  a  wave  of  duration  A£  is  represented 
by  a  group  of  monochromatic  waves  whose  frequencies  lie  in  the  inter- 
val A  <o  >  ---  ~  -~ —  .  Substituting,  in  place  of  Aco,  the  equivalent 
<"•'••'  t\t          fi  \  JP 

(in  this  case)   quantity  •-'— ,  we  arrive  at  the  following  estimate: 

A«f  A*>  27C&.  (28.15) 

This  is  the  uncertainty  relation  for  energy.  The  measure  of 
uncertainty  for  the  energy  is  the  quantity  P,  i.e.,  the  inverse  value 
for  the  probability  of  decay  in  unit  time.  (28.15)  should  be  formulated 
thus:  an  energy  of  a  state  existing  during  a  limited  time  interval  A£ 

is  determined  within  the  accuracy  of  the  order  of  — TT-  -  Only  the 

energy  of  a  state  which  exists  an  uiilimitedly  long  time  is  fully  deter- 
minate. 

The  meaning  of  the  uncertainty  relation  for  energy.  The  meaning 
of  the  uncertainty  relation  for  the  coordinate  and  the  momentum 
(23.4)  is  not  analogous  to  the  meaning  of  (28.15).  The  estimate  (23.4) 
expresses  the  fact  that  the  coordinate  and  momentum  do  not  exist 
in  the  same  state;  (28.15)  signifies  that  if  a  state  of  the  system  has 
a  finite  duration  A£,  then  its  energy  at  each  instant  of  time  within 
the  interval  A£  is  not  determined  exactly,  but  is  only  contained 
within  a  region  of  the  order  of  P. 

The  quantity  P  is  termed  the  level  width  of  the  system.  The  concept 
of  level  width  can  be  applied  to  any  states  of  finite  duration  and  not 
only  to  alpha  disintegration.  For  example,  the  energy  level  of  an 
atom  in  an  excited  state  has  a  definite  width,  since  an  excited  atom 
is  capable  of  the  spontaneous  emission  of  a  quantum. 

Explanation  of  the  level  width.  We  shall  now  show  how  the  level 
width  of  a  nucleus  capable  of  alpha  disintegration  can  be  found 
by  considering  the  wave  function  variation  under  a  potential  barrier. 

In  was  shown  in  Sec.  25  that  infinite  motion  has  a  continuous 
spectrum.  The  motion  of  a  system  with  a  potential  barrier  is  infinite 
because  an  alpha  particle  is  capable  of  going  to  infinity.  It  follows, 
strictly  speaking,  that  a  nucleus  capable  of  alpha  disintegration 
should  have  a  continuous  spectrum. 


*  A  wave  with  definite  frequency  is  termed  "monochromatic."  A  mono- 
chromatic wave  corresponds  to  a  single  colour  (chromos  is  the  Greek  for  colour). 


Ser.  28]  QUASI-CLASSICAL  APPROXIMATION  289 

Let  us  now  evaluate  the  energy  level  widths  F  for  alpha-radioactive 
nuclei.  From  (28.15)  it  follows  that  even  for  a  nucleus  with  a  very 
short  alpha-decay  time  (£~10-5sec)  F~10-22erg~0.6  x  10-10ev. 
How  is  it  possible  to  combine  a  continuous  spectrum  with  such  a 
narrow  energy  interval  ? 

The  solution  to  the  wave  equation  between  rt  and  r2  is  of  the 
following  form:, 

T 

—  y-  f  V  2m(U—#)  dr  -j-  I   V  2m(U— <f)  dr 

^  =  C,e      '  (  +  02e  l  ;[  .      (28.16) 

The  first  solution  exponentially  diminishes  with  r,  while  the  second 
exponentially  increases.  It  follows  that  if  the  barrier  extended  to 
infinity  rightwards,  a  solution  would  exist  only  for  G2  =  0.  The  ratio 
C2/Cly  determined  from  the  boundary  conditions  at  r  =  rv  is  a  function 
of  energy.  It  is  the  roots  of  equation  C2  (§}  =  0  that  give  the  possible 
energy  eigenvalues  for  finite  motion.  The  energy  of  a  particle  in  a 
well  of  finite  depth  is  obtained  in  just  this  way.  A  particle  in  a  well, 
which  was  considered  in  Sec.  25,  differs  from  a  particle  beyond  the 
barrier  in  that  the  barrier  is  of  finite  width.  Therefore,  the  second 
solution,  proportional  to  C2,  need  not  be  strictly  equal  zero,  but 
may  only  be  small  compared  with  the  first  solution  in  any  small 
interval  of  values  $  close  to  a  root  of  equation  02  ($}  =  0.  This  region 
of  values  of  &  is  what  corresponds  to  the  assumption  that  the  modulus 
of  the  wave  function  outside  the  nucleus  is  small  compared  with  the 
wave  function  inside  the  nucleus.  In  other  words,  if  the  energy  of 
the  nucleus  is  contained  in  a  given  region  of  values  F,  then  we  can 
say  that  the  alpha  particle  is  in  some  way  bound  in  the  nucleus, 
similar  to  the  way  that  a  particle  can  be  bound  in  a  real  potential 

well.  The  higher  or  broader  the  potential  barrier,  the  less  the  barrier 

•p 

factor  B  and  the  less  the  decay  probability  -T-  proportional  'to  it. 

But  then  &$  is  also  correspondingly  reduced,  i.e.,  the  continuous- 
spectrum  state  becomes  closer  to  the  discrete -spectrum  state  with 
an  exact  energy  value  <£0.  This  is  what  explains  the  meaning  of 
the  uncertainty  [±$\  it  indicates  how  close  the  state  is  to  a  bound 
one,  with  an  infinitely  long  life-time. 

The  uncertainty  of  &#  does  not  limit  the  applicability  of  the  law 
of  conservation  of  energy  in  any  way;  the  total  energy  of  a  nucleus 
and  alpha  particle  is  constant.  However,  the  state  with  a  strictly 
defined  energy  relates  simultaneously  to  disintegrated  and  non- 
disintegrated  nuclei,  while  a  nondisintegrated  nucleus  has  an  inexactly 
defined  energy. 

Any  state  capable  of  a  spontaneous  transition  to  another  state 
with  the  same  energy  possesses  a  certain  energy  width.  The  energy 


290  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

is  not  defined  exactly  in  each  of  these  states  separately,  but  a  precisely 
defined  energy  corrasponds  to  both  states  at  once. 

We  can  divide  the  total  level  width  into  partial  widths  related 
to  the  probabilities  for  various  transitions.  Thus,  strongly  excited 
nuclear  states  are  capable  of  emitting  neutrons  of  various  energies 
and  of  radiating  gamma  quanta.  Each  possibility  contributes  its 
exponential  in  the  term  characterizing  attenuation.  The  total  atten- 
uation is  determined  by  the  product  of  such  exponentials.  It  follows 
that  the  total  level  width  is  equal  to  the  sum  of  its  widths  in  relation 
to  all  possibilities  of  disintegration. 

The  Bohr  quantum  conditions.  Let  us  now  apply  the  quasi-classical 
approximation  to  the  finite  motion  of  a  particle  in  a  potential  well 
and  find  the  energy  levels.  From  (28.3)  the  wave  function  is 

X 

fy  --  sin  (~  J  dx  V  2m  (tf  —  U)'  +  y) .  (28.1 7) 

*  i 

The  real  solution  involving  the  sine  is  taken,  since,  in  accordance 
with  (24.20),  it  does  not  involve  any  particle  flux  outside  the  well, 
i.e.,  it  corresponds  to  a  stationary  state. 

Here  x1  is  the  left  edge  of  the  well  for  which  $  =  U.  In  changing 
x  to  xl  to  the  right-hand  edge  x2,  the  phase  of  the  wave  function 
can  change  by  a  whole  multiple  of  TT  together  with  a  certain  addition, 
which  we  shall  call  (3  for  the  time  being.  In  the  whole  length  of  the 
well,  the  sine  changes  its  sign  for  a  given  value  of  the  particle  energy 
by  as  many  times  as  TT  is  added  to  the  argument  of  the  sine,  i.e., 
the  wave  function  (28.17)  has  as  many  nodes.  However,  the  number 
of  nodes  is  equal  to  the  number  of  the  energy  eigenvalue  n ;  therefore, 
an  equality  is  obtained  for  the  determination  of  <&n: 

** 

-i  J  V  2m  (ffn  -  U)  dx  =  KH  +  p.  (28.18) 

*i 

If  the  edges  of  the  well  are  not  plumb  at  the  points  xl  and  x2, 
then  a  very  fine  analysis  shows  that  P  =  v  •  It  turns  out  that  (3  -  =  0 

for  plumb  edges  of  the  well,  because  the  condition  fy  (a^)—  fy  (x2)  =  0 
is  then  imposed  on  the  wave  function,  as  in  the  problem  of  an  infinitely 
deep  rectangular  well.  In  addition,  we  note  that  the  points  xl  and 
#o  are  given  by  the  result  that  &  —  U  (xj^  U  (x2),  i.e.,  x±  and  x2 
depend  upon  S. 

It  should  be  noted  that,  from  its  very  meaning,  equation  (28.18) 
holds  only  for  a  large  n,  to  a  quasi-classical  approximation.  The  integral 
is  considerably  greater  than  h  for  large  n,  and  this  signifies  that 
$  (#2)  —  S(xl)^>h,  whence,  to  a  quasi-classical  approximation,  we 
obtain  (28.17). 


Sec.  29]  OPERATORS    IN    QUANTUM    MECHANICS  291 

Equation  (28.17)  was  postulated  by  Bohr  in  1913  in  determining 
the  stationary  orbits  for  a  hydrogen  atom  (P  was  considered  to  be 
equal  to  zero).  Bohr  supposed  that  electrons  in  such  orbits  do  not 
radiate  light  and  do  not  falJ  onto  the  nucleus,  while  radiation  occurs 
only  in  the  case  of  a  transition  from  one  orbit  to  another. 

Thus,  it  turns  out  that  the  Bohr  quantum  conditions  emerge  as 
a  limiting  case,  of  quantum  mechanics  without  any  additional 
postulates. 

Exercises 

1)  Determine  the  energy  levels  for  a  linear  harmonic  oscillator  from  equation 

(28.18). 


From  this  ^  =  /&coln+—  I  which  is  fortunately  correct  for  all  n  and  not  only 

for  n  ^>  1. 

2)  Find  the  approximation  that  follows  (28.3). 
We  look  for  S  in  the  form  S  =  S0  +  hSl.  Then 


d^ 


dx* 
The  zero  approximation  gives  S0  from  (28.3).  The  first  approximation  yields 


•""  or 


so  that  ib  =     ,____  e 


3)  Find  the  factor  B  for  a  barrier  of  the  form  U  =  0  when  x  <  0,  U  *=  U0  —  oa? 
when  x>0,  #  <  U0. 


Sec.  29.  Operators  in  Quantum  Mechanics 

Momentum  eigenvalues.  In  a  number  of  cases  we  are  able  to  deter- 
mine energy  eigenvalues  from  the  wave  equation  (24.22).  However, 
it  is  very  important  to  find  the  eigenvalues  of  other  quantities  too : 
linear  momentum,  angular  momentum,  etc.  To  do  this,  it  is  con- 
venient to  proceed  from  the  form  of  ^  in  the  limiting  transition  to 
classical  mechanics: 

,A 
9  =  e    h  .  (29.1) 


292  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

7  r\ 

Let  us  apply  the  operation  —  -3—  to  both  sides  of  equation  (29.1), 

1i      G  X  j 

i.e.,  we  take  the  partial  derivative  with  respect  to  x  and  multiply  by  -4-  : 


But  in  the  classical  limit  S  becomes  the  action  of  the  particle,  while 

o  Of 

-£—  becomes  the  component  of  momentum  px  [see  (22.9)].  Therefore, 
ox 

the  equation  for  the  momentum  eigenvalues  that  yields  the  correct 
transition  to  classical  mechanics  is  of  the  following  form: 


where  px  is  the  eigenvalue  for  the  xth  momentum  projection. 

Momentum  and  energy  operators.  Let  us  compare  equation  (29.3) 
with  the  wave  equation  (24.22): 


Here,  the  symbol  I  .—  )  ty  denotes  -~  and  similarly  for  (  -^—  1  fy  , 

(0  \2  *  \^xi  ux  \vy/ 

-a-)  *• 

In  order  to  find  the  energy  and  momentum  eigenvalues  we  must 
perform  a  definite  set  of  differential  operations  and  multiplications 
by  the  function  of  coordinates  in  the  left  part  of  the  equation.  But 
these  sets  are  connected  in  a  very  curious  manner,  as  will  now  be 

shown.  We  shall  call  the  symbol  -=  —  ,  multiplied  by  -.-  ,  the  momentum 

*         /?    ft 
operator    applied    to    a   wave    function.    Instead  of  ™  y-   we  will 

symbolically  write  px.  Then,  it  will  be  necessary  to  rewrite  equation 
(29.3)  as 

M  =  pxty  .  (29.5) 

This  equation  denotes  exactly  the  same  as  (29.3),  though  the  sym- 
bolic notation  pA  should  emphasize  that  the  corresponding  operation 
is  applied  in  order  to  find  the  momentum  eigenvalues. 

The  operation  on  the  left-hand  side  of  (29.4)  we  shall  also  symbol- 
ically call^.  We  write  <&  and  not  &  because  the  energy  is  assumed  to 
be  expressed  in  terms  of  momentum,  similar  to  the  Hamiltonian  func- 
tion «#*.  Then,  in  shorter  notation,  (29.4)  appears  as 


<!f4/.  (29.6) 

is  called  the  Hamiltonian  operator,  or  the  energy  operator. 


Sec.  29]  OPERATORS   IN    QUANTUM  MECHANICS  293 

Comparing  (29.4)  and  (29.3),  we  see  that  the  momentum  and  energy 
operators  are  related  by  the  same  equations  as  the  corresponding 
quantities  : 

*)  +  U-  (29.7) 


We  have  written  U  instead  of  simply  U  in  order  to  emphasize  that 
in  this  equation  the  expression  U  is  not  regarded  as  an  independent 
quantity  but,  instead,  as  an  operator  acting  upon  <p,  i.e.,  a  multipli- 
cation operator  of  fy  by  U.  Equation  (29.7)  is  symbolic.  It  is  under- 
stood that  both  sides  are  applied  to  fy. 

The  meaning  of  operator  symbolism.  The  usefulness  of  an  abbreviat- 
ed operator  notation  in  quantum  mechanics  consists  in  the  fact  that 
the  equations  thus  become  more  expressive.  The  relation  between 
quantum  laws  of  motion  and  classical  laws,  which  are  limiting  cases 
with  respect  to  the  quantum  ones,  can  be  best  of  all  seen  in  operator 
notation. 

If  in  classical  equations  relating  mechanical  quantities  we  replace  the 
momenta  by  their  operators,  we  then  obtain  correct  operator  rela- 
tionships of  quantum  mechanics.  The  limiting  transition  to  classical 
mechanics  restores  the  usual  relationships  between  quantities.  Indeed, 

in  the  limiting  transition  (29.1),  the  operator  p=  —  y  w^  giye  P^« 

If  we  must  perform  the  limiting  transition  for  p2,  then  we  need  to 
differentiate  only  the  exponential  each  time,  because  this  yields  the 
quantum  of  action  in  the  denominator.  For  h  -^0,  only  terms  with  the 
highest  degree  of  h  in  the  denominator  remain,  and  it  is  these  very 
terms  which  are  obtained  in  replacing  the  operator  p  by  the  quantity 
VS  (i.e.,  by  the  classical  momentum  vector).  We  had  an  example  of 
such  a  transition  in  Sec.  24  [see  equations  (24.13)  and  (24.14)]. 

The  angular-momentum  operator.  It  is  now  easy  to  define  the  angu- 
lar-momentum operator.  We  shall  begin  with  one  component  Mz.  It 
is  clear  from  Sec.  5  that  the  angular  momentum  Mz  is  at  the  same  time 
a  generalized  momentum  corresponding  to  the  angle  of  rotation  about 
the  z-axis,  i.e.,  Mz  =  pcf).  Then,  from  (10.23) 

*•-•£•  <29-8> 

Therefore,  in  quantum  mechanics  the  operator  pv  must  be  of  the  form 

*.-T£-  <29-9> 

At  the  same  time,  in  accordance  with  classical  mechanics,  the  pro- 
jection Mz  is  related  to  the  momentum  projections  thus: 

Mz  =  xpy~ypx.  (29.10) 


294  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

It  follows  that  there  must  exist  an  operator  relationship 

*py--yp*.  (29.11) 


Let  us  check  to  see  that  the  definitions  (29.9)  and  (29.11)  do,  indeed, 
coincide.  Let  us  pass  to  cylindrical  coordinates: 

(29.12) 

(29.13) 
From  this  we  have 

dx        dr  dx       $9  dx 

Solving  (29.12)  and  (29.13)  with  respect  to  x  and  y,  we  have 
r  —  A/ir2  +  y2  ,      9  —  arc  tan  ~  ; 

•i/1 

-=coscp,         -g^-y-/-",—  8"1'*'; 


'  +  2/a 

y  sin  9 


Substituting  all  these  expressions  into  equalities  (29.14)  and  (29.15), 
and  substituting  the  derivatives  themselves  into  (29.11),  we  can  see 
that  both  definitions  for  Mz  (29.9)  and  (29.11)  are  identical. 

Angular-momentum  projection  eigenvalues.  Let  us  now  find  the 
eigenvalues  for  Mz.  For  this,  it  is  necessary  to  solve  the  equation 

Mzfy  =  Mzfy  ,  (29.16) 

i.e., 

IL'^L^MZ^J.  (29.1?) 

1     C/9 

This  equation  is  very  simply  integrated: 

M 

^e'-Jr--  (29-18) 

As  we  know,  a  wave  function  is  the  probability  amplitude.  Function 
(29.18)  is  the  amplitude  of  the  probability  that  the  particle  possesses 
an  azimuth  angle  9,  if  the  2th  component  of  its  angular  momentum 
is  equal  to  Mz.  It  is  essential  that  not  only  the  absolute  value  of  the 
wave  function  has  physical  significance,  but  also  its  phase;  this  is 
indicated,  for  example,  by  the  phenomenon  of  electron  diffraction. 
For  the  phase  of  the  wave  function  (29.18)  to  be  determined,  it  must 
either  not  change  at  all  or  only  by  a  multiple  of  2  n  in  rotating  the 


Sec.  29]  OPERATORS   IN   QUANTUM   MECHANICS  295 

coordinate  system  through  360°;  this  is  because  the  position  of  the 
particle  relative  to  such  a  system  rotated  through  360°  does  not 
change.  If  in  this  case  the  wave  function  were  not  returned  to  its 
initial  value,  it  could  not  uniquely  represent  the  probability  ampli- 
tude. Thus, 


i.e., 

e'        V^e'^,  <29'19> 

so  that 


a1'"*—  _!_,«**  (29.20) 

C.  -    A    --   (  , 

where  k  is  an  integer  of  any  sign  or  zero.  Whence  we  obtain  the  eigen- 
values of  Mx\ 

Mz=hk.  (29.21) 

Mz  is  called  the  orbital  angular-momentum  projection  for  a  particle. 
We  shall  see  in  Sec.  32  that  a  particle  can  have  an  angular  momentum 
connected  with  its  internal  motion,  which  is  not  described  by  the  wave 
function  (29.18).  Here,  we  have  proven  that  the  orbital  angular- 
momentum  components  can  only  assume  values  which  are  whole 
multiples  of  h. 

The  Stern-Gerlach  experiment.  The  discreteness  of  the  angular- 
momentum  spectrum  is  confirmed  by  direct  experiment.  The  idea 
of  the  experiment  consists  in  the  following:  a  direct  relationship 
exists  between  the  orbital  angular-momentum  projection  and  the 
magnetic  moment  projection  [see  (15.25)]: 


A  narrow  beam  of  vapour  of  the  substance  under  investigation 
is  passed  between  the  poles  of  an  electromagnet  in  a  strongly  inhomo- 
geneous  field  ;  to  achieve  this,  one  of  the  poles  may  be  made  tapered. 
The  particles  —  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment,  they  are  atoms  — 
enter  the  field  parallel  to  the  edge  of  the  taper,  i.e.,  they  move  in 
a  direction  perpendicular  to  the  plane  of  the  lines  of  force  of  the 
field.  The  plane  of  symmetry  of  the  field  passes  through  the  edge 
of  the  taper  and  the  initial  direction  of  motion  of  the  particle.  We 
assume  the  z-axis  to  be  perpendicular  to  the  edge  of  the  taper  and  to 
lie  in  the  plane  of  symmetry  of  the  field.  If  the  mechanical  moment 
of  the  electrons  in  the  atoms  has  only  discrete,  integral  projections 
on  the  z-axis,  then  the  magnetic  moment  of  the  atoms  is  established 
in  several  definite  ways.  The  deflecting  force  acting  on  the  magnetic 
moment  in  a  magnetic  field  is,  by  (15.40) 


(29.23) 


296  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

In  the  plane  of  symmetry  of  the  field,  H  is  directed  along  the  z-direction 
and  depends  only  upon  z. 

Since  the  angular  momentum  can  only  have  a  definite  set  of  values, 
the  deflecting  force  acting  upon  the  atoms  in  the  beam  is  also  not 
arbitrary  but  has  a  very  definite  value  for  particles  with  respective 
angular-momentum  projection  Mz=hk.  It  can  be  seen  from  (29.23) 

that  the  force  is  a  quantity  which  is  a  multiple  of  -5 ~ —  •  Therefore, 

the  particles  in  the  beam  experience  only  those  deflections  in  the 
magnetic  field  which  correspond  to  the  possible  values  of  the  force 
(29.23).  In  other  words,  the  beam  is  split  into  several  separate  beams 
and  does  not  proceed  continuously,  as  would  be  the  case  for  any 
nonintegral  projections  Mz. 

Where  the  beam  is  formed,  each  particle  was  given  a  certain  angular 
momentum.  Motion  in  the  magnetic  field  makes  it  possible  to  measure 
the  projection  of  this  angular  momentum  Mz  in  the  direction  of  the  field. 

The  impossibility  of  the  simultaneous  existence  of  two  angular- 
momentum  projections.  From  the  fact  that  the  angular-momentum 
projection  on  any  axis  is  integral,  it  follows  that  the  angular  mo- 
mentum does  not  have,  simultaneously,  projections  on  two  axes 
in  space. 

Indeed,  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment,  the  z-axis  is  absolutely 
arbitrary.  We  could  have  measured  the  angular-momentum  projection 
011  some  axis  in  space  and  then  pass  the  same  beams  through  a 
magnetic  field  making  a  very  small  angle  with  the  field  in  which 
the  first  measurement  was  performed.  Both  measurements  will  givo 
only  integral  projections  of  the  angular  momentum.  Both  one  and 
the  same  vector  cannot  simultaneously  have  integral  projections 
on  infinitely  close,  but  otherwise  arbitrary,  directions;  when  tho 
first  measurement  was  performed,  the  angular  momentum  had  a 
projection  only  on  the  first  direction  of  the  field,  and,  correspondingly, 
in  the  second  measurement,  it  had  projections  only  on  the  second 
direction  of  the  field. 

Similar  to  the  way  that  coordinate  and  momentum  do  not  exist 
simultaneously,  it  turns  out  that  two  angular-momentum  projections 
do  not  exist  in  the  same  state. 

The  simultaneous  existence  of  two  physical  quantities.  We  shall 
consider  from  a  general  point  of  view  the  question  of  which  quantities 
of  quantum  mechanics  can  exist  in  the  same  state  of  a  system.  Let 
us  suppose  that  in  a  certain  state  described  by  the  wave  function  A 
there  simultaneously  exist  two  physical  quantities  X  and  v.  This 
means  that  the  wave  function  fy  is  an  eigenfunction  of  the  two  operators 
X  and  v.  It  satisfies  two  equations 

^  =  \fy  (29.24) 

and  vij;=v^.  (29.25) 


Sec.  29]  OPERATORS    IN    QUANTUM   MECHANICS  297 

X  and  v  are,  speaking  generally,  differential  operators;  X  and  v  are 
numbers. 

Let  us  apply  the  operator  v  to  (29.24).  Since  there  is  a  number  X 
on  the  right,  it  can  be  put  on  the  left  of  the  operator  sign  v  : 

vX^  =  vXtJ>  =  Xv^  =  Xv<{>  .  (29.26a) 

In  the  last  equation  we  made  use  of  (29.25).  We  shall  now  apply 
the  operator  X  to  (29.25): 

Xv^  =  Xv<J>  =  vX^  =  vX^1  .  (29.26b) 

Let  us  subtract  (29.26b)  from  (29.26a): 

vX^  —  Xv^  =  XviJ;  —  vX^  =  0 .  (29.27) 

(29.27)  can  be  symbolically  written  as  an  equality  between  operations. 

5X  =  Xv  or  vX  —  Xv  —  0  .  (29.28) 

This  symbolic  equality  means  that  the  result  of  operating  with  v 
and  X  should  not  depend  upon  the  order  of  their  actions,  otherwise 
equations  (29.24)  and  (29.25)  cannot  have  a  general  solution. 

We  can  also  prove  the  inverse  theorem :  if  two  operators  are  com- 
mutative, i.e.,  the  result  of  their  action  does  not  depend  on  their 
order,  then  it  is  possible  to  form  a  common  eigenfunction  ty  satisfying 
equations  (29.24)  and  (29.25). 

Commutations  of  certain  operators.  Let  us  now  apply  the  obtained 
result  to  two  quantities  which  definitely  do  not  exist  in  the  same 
state:  the  coordinate  x  and  momentum  px.  We  must  calculate  the 
commutation  pxx  —  xpx. 

Changing  from  symbolic  notation  to  the  usual  one,   we  obtain 

h     8        1  //-    d$          h    j  h   dty  h    dfy        h    •        /«>o  .>Q\ 

~~*      5        X  T  "~~"  X     '     o —      ~  w  ~T~  X      ;      ~ ~-"~  X  ~~i r,       — -     r*  w  .      \  £ •) , ~j ** ) 

^    dx      T  ^    dx          *   T  ^    dx  i    dx        i   T       v  ' 

Reverting  to  symbolic  notation,  we  represent  (29.29)  in  the  following 
form :  h 

pxx  —xpx=  ~.  (29.30) 

Thus,  the  result  of  operating  with  px  and  x  depends  upon  the  order 
of  their  action;  px  and  x  are  noncommutative.  And  this  was  to  be 
expected  because  the  quantities  x  and  px  do  not  exist  simultaneously. 

The  eigenfunction  of  the  operator  x  satisfies  the  equation  (x  — x')fy  =0. 
Consequently,  it  is  equal  to  zero  over  the  whole  region  where  the 
coordinate  x  is  not  equal  to  the  chosen  eigenvalue  x'.  This  function 
differs  from  zero  only  at  one  point  x=x'.  The  eigenfunction  of  the 

momentum  operator  which  satisfies  equation  (29.30)  is  e*  h  '  it 
differs  from  zero  over  all  the  space.  This  example  shows  how  great 
is  the  difference  between  the  eigenfunctions  of  noncommuting  operators. 


298  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

The  abreviated  notation  of  (29.30)  is  a  convenient  representation 
of  (29.29).  In  the  more  complex  cases  that  will  be  examined  later 
the  convenience  of  this  abbreviated  notation  is  obvious.  It  must 
be  borne  in  mind  that  the  operator  notation  is  simply  a  rationalization 
of  mathematical  symbolism,  and  there  is  nothing  incomprehensible 
in  the  result  that  pxx  —  x  px^Q-,  such  is  the  property  of  operator 
symbols.  It  will  be  recalled  that  in  vector  algebra  there  also  exists 
noncommutative  multiplication;  and,  what  is  more,  not  of  symbols, 
but  of  quantities.  In  quantum  mechanics  the  operator  symbolism 
is  most  expedient. 

The  various  momentum  components  are  commutative: 

pxpy  —  pyp*  =  0  (29.31) 

(the  word  "operators,"  will  be  frequently  omitted  in  future  as  being 
self-evident).  The  commutative  relation  (29.31)  is  obtained  simply 
from  the  fact  that  the  result  of  applying  two  partial  derivatives 
does  not  depend  upon  the  order  of  differentiation. 
It  is  also  obvious  that 

pyx  -  xpY  =  0.  (29.32) 

We  now  calculate  the  commutation  of  any  two  angular-momentum 
components.  Let  us  take  Mx  and  My: 


My  =  zpx  —  xpz  . 

Let  us  first  of  all  w£ite  the  commutation  without  using  the  rules 
(29.30)-(29.32): 

Mx  MY  —  MyMx=(ypz  —  zpy)  (zpx  —  xpz)  —  (zpx  —  xp 


We  now  group  the  terms  here  so  that  the  order  of  coordinates  and 
corresponding  momenta  is  not  disturbed: 

MxMy  —  MyMx^-  ypx(pzz  —  zpz)  —  xpy(pzz  —  zpz)  . 

We  substitiite  the  commutation  relation  px  z  —  zpz  —  -i-  and  then  find 
the  required  result: 

Mx  My  -  My  Mx  -  ih  (xpy  -  ypx)  ^ihMz.  (29.33) 

Now  changing  the  indices  x,  y,  z  cyclically,  we  obtain  the  remaining 
commutation  relations  : 

My  Mz  —  M  x  My  =  ih  Mx  ,  (29.34) 

Mz  Mx  —  Mx  Mz=  ihMy.  (29.35^ 

All  three  commutation  relations  can  be  easily  remembered  if  we 
write  them  in  contracted  form  thus: 


Sec.  29]  OPERATORS    IN    QUANTUM   MECHANICS  299 

[MM]  =  iAM.  (29.36) 

Expanding  this  equality  in  components,  we  once  again  arrive  at 
(29.33)-(29.36). 

It  will  be  noted  that  the  vector  product  of  an  operator  by  itself 
cannot  equal  zero  unless  the  operator  components  of  the  vector 
are  noncommutating  (but,  for  example,  [pp]  =  0). 

We  have  shown  that  there  does  not  exist  a  state  in  which  a  system 
would  possess  two  angular-momentum  projections.  Angular  mo- 
mentum has  a  projection  only  on  one  axis,  in  agreement  with  the 
Stern-Gerlach  experiment.  The  only  exception  is  when  all  three 
angular-momentum  projections  are  equal  to  zero.  The  eigenfunction 
of  such  a  state  does  not  depend  upon  any  angles  at  all  [see  (29.18)]. 
Therefore,  as  a  result  of  applying  differential  operations  of  the  type 
(29.9),  where  the  differentiation  is  performed  with  respect  to  the 
angle  of  rotation  about  any  arbitrary  axis,  this  eigenfunction  is 
multiplied  by  zero.  The  action  of  the  operators  of  the  angular-mo- 
mentum components  on  such  a  function  is  commutative.  This  does 
not  contradict  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment,  because  a  vector  can 
have  a  zero  projection  on  two  infinitely  close,  though  arbitrarily 
orientated,  axes,  provided  the  vector  itself  is  equal  to  zero.  But  if 
only  one  of  the  angular-momentum  projections  is  not  equal  to  zero, 
then  the  two  others  do  not  have  definite  values  because,  otherwise, 
there  would  be  a  contradiction  in  equality  (29.36). 

The  square  of  the  angular  momentum.  Let  us  now  examine  further 
properties  of  angular  momentum.  We  shall  show  that  even  though 
two  angular-momentum  projections  do  not  exist,  a  single  angular- 
momentum  projection  exists  together  with  its  square 

M*  =  Ml  +  M*  +  M  I  .  (29.37) 

We  shall  verify  this: 


because  Mz  and  Ml  are,  of  course,  commutative.  Let  us  add  to  the 
right-hand  side  of  the  last  equality,  and  subtract  from  it  the  combi- 
nations MXMZMX  and  MyMzMy  ;  we  take  M  z  and  My  outside  the  brackets, 
once  on  the  right  and  another  time  on  the  left.  Then  we  obtain 


=  Q.  (29.38) 


Here  we  have  made  use  of  the  commutation  rules  (29.33)-(29.35). 
The  eigenvalue  of  M  2  will  be  found  in  the  following  section. 


300 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 

Exercises 


[Part   III 


1)  Find  the  commutations,  of 

MX9  px',  Mx,  py;  Mx,  pz; 

Mx,x-,    MX  ,  y  ;    MZfz; 

M*,  px;  Mz,  p*-,  M2,  x;    M2  ,  r*  . 

2)  Write  down  the  Cartesian  projections  of  momentum  in  spherical  co- 
ordinates. 

Spherical  coordinates  are  expressed  in  terms  of  Cartesian  coordinates  in 
the  following  manner  [see  (3.5),  (3,7),  (3.8)]: 


ft  =  arc  cos  - 


Whence  we  obtain  the  partial  derivatives 


&r         x 
- —  =  —  =  sin  ft  cos  9  , 

OX  T 

dr        y 

~ —  ™  ~  =  sin  $  sin  9  , 

dy         r 


or        z 

-  —  =  —  =  cos  ft  , 
GZ         r 


d  9 
dx 

3  9 
" 


dx 
80- 


cos  0  cos  © 


cos  -8-  sin  9 

— 


sin  9 
r  sin  ^   ' 


cos  9 
r  sin  if  ' 


Further, 


. 

sm  *  cos      " 


coscpcos  $    e? 


sin  9       a 

_a_  __  dr  a 

cos  9      a 


a&  a    ,  a  9    a 
-         -  = 


a  9  ' 

a       ar   a 


sin  9  cos  o-  a 
—  — 


a  a         sinft 

- —  =  cos  ft  — 


3)  Write  the  angular -momentum  projections  on  Cartesian  axes  in  terms 
of  spherical  coordinates. 


Sec.  30]  EXPANSIONS  INTO   WAVE   FUNCTIONS  301 

M*  =  ypz—zpy  *=  -j-l—Bin  <?  —  —  cot  $  cos  9  ^—\  , 

My  =  zpx  —  xpz  =  -T-  (cos  9  -gy  —  cot  £  sin  9  —  J  , 

•iTr        ^  ^         **.  *•          ho 

Mx-*pt-Vp,--rJj: 

4)  Write  the  expression  for  the  square  of  the  angular  momentum  in  spherical 
coordinates  : 

^^ 
y) 
From  exorcise  3  we  have 


Applying  Mx-M*Afy  to  MX  —  iMy,  wo  must  observe  the  order  of  the  "factors" 

o  o 

-—and  c»v,  cot  ^  and-^  —  .  We  obtain 

6*9  db 

(Mx  -f  tJ  My)  (Mx  -  1  My)  = 


COt  #  -7; 

\tf#a  c?9 

Finally, 


1  O 

This  expression  is  obviously  commutative  with  Mz  =  —  -5 — .  This  was 

1    o  9 

shown  in  the  present  section  in  another  way. 


Sec.  30.  Expansions  into  Wave  Functions 

The  superposition  principle.  One  of  the  most  fundamental  ideas 
of  quantum  mechanics  consists  in  the  fact  that  its  equations  are  linear 
with  respect  to  the  wave  function  ^.  This  result  proceeds  from  the 
whole  set  of  facts  that  confirm  the  correctness  of  quantum  mechanics, 
in  the  same  way  as  an  analogous  result  in  classical  electrodynamics 
(see  Sec.  21),  which  is  also  a  generalization  of  experience. 

For  example,  the  diffraction  of  electrons  shows  that  the  amplitudes 
of  wave  functions  are  combined  in  the  same  simple  way  as  the  ampli- 
tudes of  waves  in  optics ;  diffraction  maxima  and  minima  are  situated 
at  the  same  positions,  which  are  determined  only  by  the  phase  relation- 


302  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

ships,  independently  of  the  wave  intensities.  All  this  points  to  the 
linearity  of  wave  equations;  the  solutions  of  nonlinear  equations 
behave  in  an  entirely  different  manner. 

The  sum  of  two  solutions  of  a  linear  equation  again  satisfies  the  same 
equation.  It  follows  from  this  that  any  solution  of  a  wave  equation 
can  be  represented  in  the  form  of  a  certain  set  of  standard  solutions, 
similar  to  the  way  that,  hi  Sec.  18,  a  travelling  nonperiodic  wave 
was  represented  by  a  set  of  travelling  harmonic  waves  (18.1). 

The  statement  concerning  the  possibility  of  representing  a  single 
wave  function  in  terms  of  the  sum  of  other  wave  functions  is  called 
the  superposition  principle. 

The  Hermitian  property  of  operators.  Wave  functions  are  usually 
represented  with  the  aid  of  the  sum  of  eigenfunctions  of  certain 
quantum-mechanical  operators.  In  the  present  section  it  will  be 
shown  how  such  expansions  are  performed.  First  of  all,  however, 
it  is  necessary  to  establish  certain  general  properties  of  the  operators 
whose  eigenvalues  are  physical  quantities. 

Obviously,  these  eigenvalues  must  be  real  numbers,  although  the 
operators  themselves  may  depend  explicitly  upon  i=V—  1  [see 
(29.3),  (29.10)].  We  shall  consider  the  equations  for  the  eigenfunctions 
of  the  operator  X  and  another  equation  involving  its  conjugate: 

X^-X<];,  (30.  la) 

X*^*-X*^*.  (30.1b) 

We  must  find  the  condition  for  which  the  eigenvalues  of  the  operator 
are  real  numbers,  X*=X. 

To  do  this,  we  multiply  (30. la)  by  ^*  and  (30. Ib)  by  ^,  integrate 
over  the  whole  range  of  the  variables  x  (upon  which  the  operator  X 
depends),  and  subtract  one  from  the  other.  Then  we  obtain 

4/X*  <|;*)  dx  =  (X -  X*)  ft*  fy  dx . 

But  the  integral  of  ^*^=|^|2  cannot  be  equal  to  zero,  since  |^|2 
is  an  essentially  positive  quantity. 

The  eigenvalue  X  is,  by  definition,  real,  i.e.,  X  =  X*;  therefore  we 
arrive  at  the  relation 

* \ty  -  <|; X*  <[,*)  dx  =  0  .  (30.2) 

Equation  (30.2)  can  be  regarded  as  a  condition  imposed  upon  the 
operator  X.  In  fact,  however,  we  must  demand  that  the  operator  X 
satisfy  the  equation  (30.2)  not  only  for  its  own  eigenfunctions  fy*  (X,  x) 
and  $  (X,  #),  but  also  for  any  pair  of  functions  #*  (x)  and  ^  (x),  pro- 
vided these  functions  satisfy  the  same  conditions  of  being  finite, 
continuous,  and  single-valued  as  the  eigenfunctions  <]>  (X,  x) : 


SeC.  30]  EXPANSIONS   INTO    WAVE    FUNCTIONS  303 

J(X*  ty  ~  *  **  X*)  dx  -  0  .  (30.3) 

The  necessity  of  such  a  condition  will  be  explained  later  in  this 
section.  An  operator  for  which  equality  (30.3)  is  satisfied  is  termed 


In  equation  (30.3),  dx  is  an  abbreviated  notation  for  dV=dx  dy  dz, 
if  the  integration  is  performed  over  a  volume  (X  -^  J$)y  or  ^9,  if  X  =  Mz> 
etc. 

The  Hermitian  nature  of  the  operators  px,  Mz,  ...  is  easily  verified 
by  integrating  by  parts.  For  example, 

" 


0  0  00 

The  eigeiifunctions  of  the  operator  Mz  must  satisfy  the  requirement 
of  uniqueness  (29.19);  hence  #*  (0)=#*  (2w),  <J;  (0)=<|;  (27e)  similar 
to  the  eigenf  unctions  of  the  operator  .M*.  Therefore,  the  integrated 
quantity  becomes  zero.  The  operator  --  -  -  is  M*,  so  that 


\% 


27T 


in  accordance  with  the  general  requirement  (30.3). 

The  Hermitian  nature  of  Jif  and  M2  is  proven  by  a  double  integration 
by  parts. 

The  orthogonality  of  eigenfunctions.  An  important  property  of 
eigenf  unctions  follows  from  the  Hermitian  nature  of  operators.  Let 
us  consider  the  equations  for  two  eigenvalues  of  the  same  operator  X: 

Xip  (X,  x)  -  X<J>  (X,  x)  .  (30.4a) 

X*  ty*  (X',  x)  -  X'  ^*  (X',  x)  .  (30.4b) 

We  multiply  (30.4  a)  by  ^*  (X',  x)  and  (30.4b)  by  fy  (X,  x),  integrate 
with  respect  to  dx,  and  subtract  one  from  the  other: 


=  (X  -  X7)  JV  (X7,  x)  ty  (X,  x)  dx  .  (30.5) 

The  left-hand  side  of  this  equation  becomes  zero  in  accordance  with 
general  requirements  for  Hermitian  form  (30.3).  Therefore,  if  X'^X, 
the  following  integral  must  equal  zero 

(X',  x)  fy  (X,  x)  dx  -  0  for  X  -£  X'.  (30.6) 


304  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

This  property  was  proved  in  exercise  1,  Sec.  24,  as  applied  to  the 
eigenf  unctions  of  the  energy  operator.  It  is  called  the  property  of 
orthogonality. 

Several  quantities,  X,  v,  etc.,  may  sometimes  exist  in  the  same  state. 
For  this  it  is  necessary  that  the  operators  X,  v,.  .  .  should  be  com- 
mutative. For  example,  for  free  motion  there  exist  px,  pY,  and  pz. 
Then  we  may  form  fonctions,  which  are  eigenfunctions  with  respect 
to  all  the  operators  simultaneously: 


the  orthogonality  condition  for  such  functions  is  directly  generalized 
in  the  form 

J^*(X',v';a;)^(X,v;a:)da;  =  0,  (30.7) 

if  XV  X  or  vV  v. 

Expansion  in  eigenfunctions.  Let  us  suppose  that  the  eigenfunctions 

of  a  certain  operator  X  are  known.  These  functions  always  satisfy 
(in  addition  to  the  equation  X^=X^)  certain  requirements:  they  are 
finite,  continuous,  single-valued,  and  so  forth.  Then,  in  accordance 
with  the  superposition  principle,  any  function  <L  (x)  which  satisfies 
the  same  requirements  may  be  represented  as  the  sum  of  the  eigen- 
functions of  the  operator  X: 

*(s)=2>'<Hx'>*>-  (30.8) 

y 

We  shall  show  how  to  determine  the  expansion  coefficients  c\. 
To  do  this  we  multiply  both  sides  of  the  equation  by  ^*  (X,  %)  and 
integrate  with  respect  to  dx: 


(X,  x)  ty  (x)  dx  =         -        ft,  *)  *  (*',  a)  dx  .  (30.9) 


In  accordance  with  the  orthogonality  condition  all  the  integrals 
on  the  right-hand  side  of  the  equality  (30.9)  become  zero  except  those 
for  which  X'=X.  Consequently,  there  remains  the  equation 

,x)\*dx.     (30.10) 

We  shall  consider  that  the  eigenfunctions  fy  (X,  x)  are  normalized  to 
unity,  i.e.,    j|  <J;  |2da;  =  l   [see  (24.18)].    Then  the  expansion  coeffi- 

cient is 

cx  =  JV  (X,  x)  fy  (x)  dx  .  (30.11) 


Sec.  30]  EXPANSIONS    INTO    WAVE    FUNCTIONS  305 

s*. 

In  the  case  when  we  have  a  system  of  commutative  operators  X, 
v,  equation  (30.11)  is  directly  generalized: 

(X,v;*)4;(30d*.  (30.12) 

The  meaning  pf  the  expansion  coefficients.  We  have  seen  that  a 
state  <{/  (x)  is  represented  as  a  superposition  of  states  with  definite 
values  of  the  quantity  X.  The  component  of  the  wave  function  fy 
which  corresponds  to  this  value  of  X  is 


It  represents  the  probability  amplitude  for  the  given  value  of  the 
quantity  X  in  the  state  fy  (x).  In  order  to  find  the  probability  itself, 
w^9  of  the  occurrence  of  quantity  X,  we  must  eliminate  the  coordinate 
dependence,  since  X  and  x  do  not  exist  in  the  same  state. 

To  do  this,  let  us  integrate  the  probability  density  of  the  state  with 
a  given  X,  i.e.,  |  c\  |2  |  ^  (X,  x)2,  over  all  x.  From  the  normalization 
condition  for  eigenfunctions  we  obtain 

,  *)  |»d*  =  |  'x  i2  -  (30.13) 

The  quantities  Wx  =  I  cx  |2  have  a  basic  property  of  probability: 
their  sum  is  equal  to  unity,  provided  the  function  itself  satisfies  the 
condition  of  normalization  (24.18).  Indeed, 

1  =  Jl  *  (*)  \*d*  =  J  1  2>x  *  (*»  *)  \*dx  = 
x 

,  x)  |2  Ax  +ZZ  c*  c*'   **  <X/>  *>  *  <X>  *>  dx  • 


x  x  xvx 

But  on  the  orthogonality  condition  (30.6)  a  double  summation  is 
equal  to  zero.  From  this,  in  accordance  with  (24.18),  it  follows  that 

Ji>x|2=Ji>x  =  l.  (30.14) 

Thus,  the  coefficient  Cx  should  be  regarded  as  the  probability  ampli- 
tude, similar  to  ty  (x).  But  |  fy  (x)  |2  is  the  probability  of  detecting  a 
particle  with  coordinate  x  independently  of  X,  while  |cx|2  is  the  prob- 
ability of  finding  it  with  a  given  value  of  the  quantity  X  independently 
of  x. 

Expansion  in  angular-momentum  projection  eigenfunctions.  The 
atomic  beam  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment  is  split  into  a  certain 
number  of  separate  beams,  corresponding  to  the  number  of  angular- 
momentum  components  along  the  magnetic  field  direction  Mx=hk. 

20-0060 


306  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Let  us  denote  the  largest  eigenvalue  quantity  k  by  the  letter  I.  Then 
it  is  obvious  that 

Z  >£>-£,  (30.15) 

i.e.,  k  takes  on  21  +  1  values. 

The  eigenfunction  corresponding  to  Mz  —  hk  is 


-67T 

(the  factor  -    is  introduced  for  normalization,     f|  tp  \*d<p  —  1) . 

V   2rr  J 

o 

If  each  of  the  separate  beams  is  once  again  passed  through  a  magnet- 
ic field  parallel  to  the  z-axis,  there  is  no  further  splitting;  this  is 
because  Mz  in  these  beams  has  a  single  definite  value  and  not  the 
whole  set  of  values  in  the  range  hi  >  Mz  >  —  hi,  as  was  the  case  in 
the  initial  beam.  From  this  the  meaning  of  the  orthogonality  of 
eigenfunctions  is  very  well  seen.  If  a  particle  is  found  in  a  beam  corre- 
sponding to  a  given  value  of  fc,  then  the  probability  of  finding  it  in  a 
beam  with  a  different  value  of  the  projection  Mz  =  hk'^hk  is  equal 
to  zero.  From  the  general  rule,  the  probability  is  equal  to  the  square 
of  the  modulus  of  the  coefficient  of  the  expansion  Ck  of  the  function 
4»  (k)  in  terms  of  the  functions  ^  (&'),  i.e.,  in  accordance  with  the  gen- 
eral expression  (30.11) 


*  'i 
=  J 


From  the  orthogonality  condition  (30.6),  the  integral  is  naturally 
equal  to  zero  if  lc'  ^  k.  Therefore  the  orthogonality  condition  is  a  neces- 
sary condition  of  particles  being  found  in  states  with  definite  values 
of  Mz  or,  as  in  the  case  of  an  arbitrary  operator  X,  in  states  with  defi- 
nite values  of  X.  But  the  orthogonality  condition  follows  directly  from 
the  Hermitian  nature  of  operators  (30.3),  while  equation  (30.2), 
concerning  the  functions  with  equal  values  of  X,  is  insufficient. 

The  Hermitian  condition  implies  the  reality  of  eigenvalues  together 
with  the  possibility  of  "pure  states,"  i.e.,  states  with  definite  eigen- 
values of  quantities. 

If  the  second  magnetic  field  is  along  the  #-axis,  then  splitting  will 
again  occur  due  to  the  component  of  angular  momentum  M x,  which 
does  not  exist  simultaneously  with  Mz.  The  number  of  splitting  com- 
ponents is  again  equal  to  2  I  + 1,  since  it  is  determined  by  the  maximum 
angular-momentum  projection  I.  This  quantity  cannot  depend  upon 
the  direction  of  the  magnetic  field,  and  is  related  only  to  the  atomic 
states  in  the  original  beam. 


Sec.  30]  EXPANSIONS    INTO    WAVE    FUNCTIONS  307 

The  eigenfunctions  of  M  x  are 

",  (30.17) 


where  I  ^  fcj  ^  —  I,  and  co  is  the  angle  of  rotation  about  the  #-axis. 
Functions  (30.16)  and  (30.17)  do  not  coincide,  which  is  a  natural 
consequence  of  their  being  functions  of  noncommutative  operators. 
As  a  result  of  magnetic  splitting  in  a  field  directed  along  the  a-axis, 
a  beam  with  given  value  of  k  is  split  into  2  I  +  1  beams  with  definite 
values  &j.  Hence,  the  function  (30.16)  will  be  represented  as  the  super- 
imposition  of  functions  (30.17): 

/ 

*  (*)  =  2>i  +<*i>-  <30-18) 

I*--! 

The  square  of  the  modulus  |  ckl  |  2  is  proportional  to  the  intensity 
of  the  beam  of  the  given  projection  Mx  =  hkl  obtained  as  a  result  of 
the  secondary  splitting  of  the  beam  with  a  given  Mz. 

Averages  in  quantum  mechanics.  Let  us  now  find  the  average  of  X 
in  a  state  given  by  the  wave  function  fy  (x),  represented  in  the  form 
of  a  sum  (30.8).  By  definition  the  mean  value  is 

X-JTx^,  (30.19) 

x 

i.e.,  the  sum  of  possible  values  of  X  multiplied  by  the  corresponding 
probabilities.  Let  us  substitute  here  u\  from  (30.13)  and  cj  from  (30.11)  : 

)ty*(\x)dx.        (30.20) 

We  shall  now  replace  the  product  X^*  (X,  x)  by  X*  ^*  (X,  x)  and  we 
first  sum  and  then  integrate.  Then  we  obtain 


X  =       (*)JTcXX*  4*  (X,  x)  dx  .  (30.21) 

x 

But  the  operator  X*  does  not  depend  upon  any  definite  value  of  X 
(for  example,  if  X  =  px,  then   X*  =  --  s--g—  ). 
Therefore,  X*  stands  outside  the  sign  of  the  summation  : 

X  =  J\J,  (s)X*27<4**  (X,  x)  dx  .  (30.22) 

x 
The  sum  £c*  fy*  (X,  x)  =  <i*  (x)  ,  since  this  is  an  equation  which  is  a 

x 
conjugate  complex  of  (30.8).  Therefore, 

20* 


308  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 


X  =    <l>  (x)  X*  ty*  (x)  dx  (30.23) 

or,  from  the  Hermitian  condition  for  the  operator  X  (30.2),  (30.3), 

X  =   ^  *  (x)  X  <]>  (x)  dx  .  (30.24) 


Thus,  in  order  to  calculate  the  mean  value  of  X  in  a  state  fy  (x), 
it  is  not  necessary  to  know  the  eigenvalues  of  X,  since  it  is  sufficient 
to  calculate  the  integral  (30.24). 

The  eigenvalues  of  the  square  of  the  angular  momentum.  If  fy  (x) 
is  one  of  the  eigenfunctions  of  the  operator  X,  then  the  mean  value  X 
is  simply  reduced  to  this  eigenvalue.  Indeed,  then 

(X,  x)\*dx  =  X. 

Taking  advantage  of  the  foregoing  remark,  it  is  easy  to  calculate 
the  mean  value  of  the  square  of  the  angular  momentum. 

First  of  all  it  may  be  noted  that  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment 
the  mean  values  of  the  squares  of  all  three  angular-momentum  pro- 
jections must  be  the  same,  because  it  is  absolutely  immaterial  what 
the  notation  of  the  coordinate  axis  is  along  which  the  magnetic  field 
is  directed: 

Wx  =  Wy^~Ml.  (30.25) 


It  follows  that  the  mean  value  M 2  is  equal  to  three  times  the  mean 
value  Ml\ 

In  the  original  beam  all  values  of  Mz~hk  from  — -hi  to  hi  are  equally 
probable.  This  means  that  Jf|  is  equal  to 


whence 

l&*  =  hzl(l+  1).  (30.28) 

But  it  was  shown  in  Sec.  29  that  M2  is  commutative  with  MZl  so 
that  M 2  and  Mx  exist  in  one  and  the  same  state.  In  the  Stern-Gerlach 
experiment  the  atoms  in  the  beam  occur  predominantly  in  the  ground 
state.  This  state  is  characterized  by  a  certain  absolute  value  of  the 
angular  momentum.  Therefore,  the  mean  value  of  the  angular  momen- 
tum in  such  a  state  is  equal  to  its  eigenvalue 

Jf2  =  W^  Wl  (I  +  1) .  (30.29) 


Sec.  30]  EXPANSIONS   INTO    WAVE   FUNCTIONS  309 

The  result  (30.29)  may  appear  somewhat  surprising  because  the 
eigenvalue  of  the  square  of  the  angular  momentum  is  equal  not  to  the 
square  of  its  greatest  projection  A2/2,  but  to  some  greater  amount. 
However,  if  M  \  were  equal  to  h2  12,  i.e.,  its  greatest  value  and  M2  =  h2l2, 
then  for  the  remaining  projections  there  would  remain  an  identical 
zero.  The  other  projections  cannot  have  any  definite  values,  including 
zero  values,  at  the  same  time  as  Mz^  0.  Therefore,  the  square  of  the 
angular  momentum  is  somewhat  greater  than  the  square  of  the  maxi- 
mum value  of  any  of  its  projections.  The  only  exception  is  when  all 
three  projections  are  equal  to  zero  (see  Sec.  29). 

Composition  of  angular  momenta.  Knowing  the  absolute  value  of 
the  angular  momentum,  we  can  now  indicate  a  rule  for  the  composition 
of  the  angular  momenta  of  two  mechanical  systems.  Let  the  greatest 
angular-momentum  projection  of  one  system  equal  hl^  and  that  of 
the  other  system  AZ2;  and  also  let  l^l^.  Then  the  projection  of  the 
smaller  angular  momentum  in  the  direction  of  the  larger  one  is  con- 
tained between  hl2  and  —  &Z2,  which,  when  added  to  the  larger  angular 
momentum,  yields  values  ranging  from  A(Z1  +  /2)  to  h  (l±  —  Z2).  It 
follows  that  the  greatest  projection  of  the  resultant  angular  momentum 
upon  any  arbitrary  direction  in  space  is  equal,  in  units  of  /&,  to 

Z-Zi  +  ^2,  h  +  li—  1,  h  +  k  —  2>-.->  li~lz.         (30.30) 
The  eigenvalues  of  the  square  of  the  sum  of  the  angular  momenta  are 

+  w  (*i  +  h  +  1)  ,  A2(/x  +  z,  -  1)  &  +  y  ,  ...  , 


The  rule  for  composition  of  angular  momenta  formulated  here  agrees 
with  the  result  that  the  value  of  a  vector  sum  is  contained  between  the 
sum  and  the  difference  of  the  absolute  values  of  the  vectors. 

Quantum  equations  of  motion.  Let  us  suppose  that  a  certain  opera- 
tor X  is  given.  It  is  required  to  find  the  operator  form  of  its  total  time 
derivative,  i.e.,  X.  We  shall  first  of  all  determine  the  total  derivative 
of  the  mean  value  X.  In  accordance  with  (30.24),  for  any  state  with  wave 
function  d»,  this  derivative  is 


Let    us    substitute    here  the   derivatives  --—-  and  -~-  from  the 

ot  ot 

Schrodinger  equation  (24.11),  whose  right-hand  side  we  shall  represent 
as  &  ^,  where  &  is  the  Hamiltonian  operator  [see  (29.7)].  From  this, 


310  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

We  transform  the  first  integral  on  the  right-hand  side  in  accordance 
with  the  Hermitian  condition  for  $  ',  namely 


We  now  combine  all  three  integrals  and  obtain 

X  =  JV  (|}  +  -J-  [&  X  -  X  Jf])  <|;  dx  .  (30.31) 

If  we  now  define  the  operator  X  by  the  equality 

X  ^  (fy*i<\>dx,  (30.32) 

then  we  obtain  the  equation 

*  /)C  «  A  ~  >S          /V 

X  -  -       +       [X  X  -  X  Jf]  .  (30.33) 


The  operators  of  linear  momentum,  angular  momentum,  and  coordi- 
nate that  have  been  employed  up  till  now  do  not  depend  upon  time 
explicitly.  For  them,  only  the  second  term  of  (30.33)  remains: 


X  r  "i/P  "i  1    fy(P~\  t  Q  C\  O  A  \ 

=  -7-  LeJ^T  A  —  Ae^TJ  .  ^oU.OTcj 

h 

Thus,  if  a  given  operator  commutes  with  the  Hamiltonian  operator 
Jf7,  then  X  --=  0.  It  is  then  natural  to  call  the  quantity  X  a  quantum  inte- 
gral of  motion.  In  accordance  with  the  general  result  of  Sec.  29, 
quantum  integrals  of  motion  have  a  common  state  with  energy,  since 
their  operators  are  commutative. 

We  shall  now  find  the  equations  of  motion  for  the  x  and  px  opera- 
tors. From  (29.7),  the  energy  operator  $  is  equal  to  ~—  +  U.  Here, 

&tfY\i 

only  PX  is  noncommutative  with  x ;  for  px  we  find 

Px  X  —  X  px  =  px  X  —  px  X  PX  ~|-  px  X  px  —  X  px  — 

2h 
=  px  (pxX  —  X  px)  +  (pxX  —  X  px)  px  =  —  PX  . 

It  follows  that 


i.e.,  the  operator  x  is  related  to  the  operator  px  by  the  same  expression 
as  the  quantities  x  =  vx  and  px  in  classical  mechanics. 

Let  us  now  find  px .  px  does  not  commute  with  U.  The  commutator 
of  U  and  px  is  easily  evaluated : 


Sec.  30]  EXPANSIONS   INTO   WAVE    FUNCTIONS  311 

whence,  symbolically, 


pxU^-r  (30.36) 

Hence, 

aft 
px=-yL,  (30.37) 

which  is  completely  analogous  to  the  classical  relationship  between 
the  momentum  derivative  and  the  force. 

The  quantum  equations  of  motion  (30.34)  were  the  starting  point 
for  W.  Heisenberg,  who  arrived  at  quantum  mechanics  independently 
of  Schroclinger.  The  equivalence  of  both  approaches  was  shown  some- 
what later. 

The  wave  function  and  measurement  of  quantities.  The  probability 
amplitudes  characterize  the  properties  of  a  system  in  relation  to  the 
results  of  measuring  certain  quantities.  If  a  system  occurs  in  a  state 
with  wave  function  fy  (x),  and  the  quantity  X  is  measured,  then  the 
probability  of  obtaining  the  given  value  of  X  is  [see  (30.11),  (30.13)] 


For  example,  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment,  the  particles  in  the 
original  beam  have  all  angular-momentum  projections  between  — hi 
and  hi.  Measurement  results  yield  2  Z  +  l  beams,  each  of  them  corre- 
sponding to  the  25th  angular-momentum  projection  given  by  a  definite 
value  hk.  However,  the  same  measurement  in  a  field  directed  along  the 
#-axis  of  the  original  system  would  split  the  beam  according  to  the 
xth  angular-momentum  projections.  Both  angular-momentum  pro- 
jections do  not  exist  simultaneously,  and  the  initial  states  of  the 
particles  in  the  beam  were  identical.  It  follows  that,  as  a  result  of 
measurement,  the  particles  occur  either  with  a  definite  zth,  or  with  a 
definite  xth  angular-momentum  projection. 

A  measurement  of  a  microscopic  entity  essentially  changes  the  state 
of  the  latter.  This  is  the  fundamental  difference  between  the  concepts 
of  measurement  in  classical  and  in  quantum  physics :  a  classical  meas- 
urement has  an  infinitesimaJly  small  effect  on  the  object  being 
measured. 

As  a  result  of  measurement,  the  angular-momentum  projections  in 
the  original  beam  acquire  2  1  + 1  values,  no  matter  how  the  measure- 
ment is  performed.  The  state  of  these  particles  after  measurement  is 
essentially  different  and  depends  upon  how  the  measurement  was  per- 
formed. But  by  performing  measurements  of  a  large  number  of  iden- 
tical entities,  we  can  find  out  in  what  state  they  were  before  measure- 
ment, quite  independently  of  the  method  of  measurement.  For  this 
reason,  a  quantum  measurement  yields  physical  results  which  are 
just  as  objective  as  those  given  by  a  classical  measurement  though, 
obviously,  within  the  limits  permitted  by  the  uncertainty  principle. 


312  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Fart  III 

Thus,  in  the  Stern-Gerlach  experiment  it  appears  that  the  particles 
had  an  absolute  angular-momentum  value  M2  =  h2l  (Z  +  l),  while 
the  direction  of  the  angular  momentum  in  space  was  arbitrary  (a  non- 
polarized beam). 

The  repeated  measurement  of  the  2th  angular-momentum  projec- 
tion, in  the  beams  which  had  passed  earlier  through  a  field  directed 
along  the  z-axis,  gives  a  definite  value  of  M2=h2l  (I  + 1)  and  a  definite 
value  of  Mz  —  hk. 

Exercises 

1)  Expand     the     function     <|>  =  — ™ ,   in  an  infinitely   deep   rectangular 

\/a 

potential  well,  in  terms  of  functions  (25.12). 
a  a 

f  ,  ,    ^  V^     f    .      n(n  +  l)x 

cn  =    dub,,  d x  — I  sin dx  = 

J  a     J  a 

0  0 


2)  Find  the  energy  eigenvalues  for  a  symmetrical  quantum  top.  The  energy 
of  the  symmetrical  top  is 


Introducing  M2,  we  have 

1 


Substituting  the  eigenvalues  for  the  angular  momentum  and  its  projections, 
we  at  last  find 


Sec.  31.  Motion  in  a  Central  Field 

The  motion  of  an  electron  in  a  central  attractive  field  is  the  princi- 
pal problem  in  the  quantum  mechanics  of  the  atom.  And  it  is  not 
necessary  to  regard  the  field  as  strictly  Coulomb  in  character.  For 
example,  in  alkali-metal  atoms,  an  outer  electron  which  is  bound 
relatively  weakly  to  the  nucleus  moves  in  the  field  of  the  nucleus  and 
the  so-called  atomic  residue  (i.  e.,  all  the  other  electrons).  The  charge- 
density  distribution  for  these  electrons  possesses  spherical  symmetry 
and  therefore  produces  a  central  field.  We  shall  suppose  that  the  poten- 
tial energy  of  the  electron  is  equal  to  U  (r),  where  r  is  the  distance 
from  the  nucleus. 

The  energy  operator  and  the  angular-momentum  integral.  The  equa- 
tion for  the  energy  eigenvalues  of  an  atom  (24.22)  is,  as  usual, 

__  _ — A<J,  _j_  [7<j,  —  g^  m  (31.1) 


Sec.  31]  MOTION   IN   A   CENTRAL   FIELD  313 

Here,  m  is  the  reduced  mass  of  the  nucleus  and  the  electron,  which 
mass  is  very  close  to  the  mass  of  the  electron.  Since  the  field  is  central 
we  must  pass  to  spherical  coordinates.  The  Laplacian  operator  in 
spherical  coordinates  was  obtained  in  Sec.  11  (11.46).  Using  this 
expression,  we  rewrite  (31.1)  explicitly: 

_jfrLLLArii*.  .  _L/L   d  sina**  i      *     d^ 

2m  Lr2  dr  T     dr   ^  r*  [sin*  db  *     ^  d*  ^  sina#   292 

£<l>.  (31.2) 


The  operator  involving  angular  differentiation  is  simply  the  square 
of  the  angular  momentum  introduced  by  us  in  exercise  4,  Sec.  29. 
Therefore,  equation  (31.2)  can  also  be  rewritten  as 


It  follows  that  the  Hamiltonian  operator  <&  [see  (29.6)]  is  related  to 
the  angular-momentum  operator  in  the  following  way: 


_ 

2m 


I/  (r)  .  (31.4) 

v  '  v          7 


Reducing  to  an  ordinary  differential  equation.  The  operator  M* 
involves  only  the  angles  &  and  9  and  derivatives  with  respect  to  them. 
All  the  derivatives  with  respect  to  angles  in  the  operator  $f  are  con- 
tained in  the  one  term  If2,  while  all  the  remaining  terms  involve  only 
r  and  the  derivative  with  respect  to  r.  Consequently,  the  operators  3t? 
and  M*  are  commutative,  since  M2  commutes  with  any  function 
of  r  and,  of  course,  with  r  itself.  Commutative  operators  have  eigen- 
values in  the  same  state.  Therefore,  in  a  central  field,  the  square  of  the 
angular  momentum  and  one  of  its  projections  have  (together  with 
energy)  eigenvalues,  which,  in  accordance  with  (30.34),  are  quantum 
integrals  of  motion.  All  the  other  quantities  which  are  not  integrals 
of  motion  do  not  exist  in  the  same  energy  state  (in  classical  mechanics 
they,  naturally,  exist  but  are  not  conserved). 

Thus,  in  equations  (31.3)  and  (31.4),  we  can  substitute  in  place  of 
M2its  eigenvalue  h2l  (I  +  1)  from  (30.29).  Then  any  angular  dependence 
will  be  eliminated  from  equation  (31.3)  and,  in  place  of  the  partial 
derivative  with  respect  to  r,  we  will  get  the  total  derivative  : 


It  is  considerably  more  simple  to  solve  this  equation  than  the  partial 
differential  equation  (31.2).  The  form  of  (31.5)  corresponds  to  (5.6) 
in  classical  mechanics,  where  it  was  also  possible  to  eliminate  all 
^variables  except  r  with  the  aid  of  the  angular-momentum  integral. 


314  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

Reduction  to  one-dimensional  form.  It  is  convenient  to  reduce 
equation  (31.5)  to  a  one-dimensional  form.  To  do  this — the  treatment 
is  similar  to  that  used  in  the  problem  of  the  propagation  of  spherical 
waves  [cf.  (19.6)] — we  introduce  the  function 

y  =  ri}     tli  —  —  .  (31.6) 

t  T  y 

Without  repeating  the  computations  by  means  of  which  the  one- 
dimensional  form  (19.6)  was  obtained,  we  write  down  the  analogous 
equation  for  /: 


The  wave  function  at  large  and  small  distances  from  the  nucleus.  As 

long  as  the  form  of  U  (r)  has  not  yet  been  made  definite,  we  can  con- 
sider (31.7)  only  in  two  limiting  cases:  for  very  large  and  for  very 
small  distances  from  the  nucleus. 

The  field  of  the  atomic  residue  is  not  effective  at  very  small  dis- 
tances from  the  nucleus,  and  there  remains  only  the  Coulomb  rela- 

tionship 1  [7  =  ----  (Z  is  the  atomic  number  of  the  element). 
However,  if  r  is  very  small  then  the  term  —~  —  ^-  ty  is,  in  any  case, 

larger  than  the  term  Ufy,  which  involves  r  in  the  denominator  only 
in  the  first  degree,  and  all  the  more  greater  than  &k.  Hence,  in  direct 
proximity  to  the  nucleus,  the  wave  equation  is  of  very  simple  form  : 


In  this  form  it  is  solved  by  the  substitution 

X-r«,  (31.9) 

so  that 

a  (a  -I)  -/(/  +  !).  (31.10) 

This  equation  has  two  roots: 

a  =  /  +  1  and  a  =  -  Z  .  (31.11) 

But  the  second  root  gives  fy  =  r~l~l  from  (31.7);  at  the  point  r  =  0, 
this  function  of  ^  becomes  infinite  for  all  L  Therefore,  we  must  discard 
the  root  a  =  —  I  and  take  the  relationship  between  ^  and  r  for  small  r 
in  the  form 

^==^-  =  H*.  (31.12) 


*  The  result  (31.12)  is  true  for  I  =  0  as  well,  even  though  the  term  +a 

in  this  case  does  not  exist  at  all  and  cannot  exceed   U  (r)  fy. 


SeC.  31]  MOTION    IN   A    CENTRAL   FIELD  315 

The  greater  the  angular  momentum,  the  higher  the  order  of  the 
wave-function  zero  at  the  coordinate  origin.  Only  for  Z  =  0  does  it 
remain  finite  close  to  the  nucleus.  This  can  be  understood  by  analogy 
with  classical  mechanics:  angular  momentum  is  the  product  of  mo- 
mentum by  the  "arm,"  i.e.,  by  the  distance  from  the  origin;  Z  =  0 
corresponds  to  a  zero  "arm"  and  a  zero  angular  momentum.  There- 
fore, there  is  a  nonzero  probability  of  finding  the  electron  at  the 
origin.  In  the  old  version  of  quantum  mechanics  (due  to  Bohr),  the 
electron  orbit  with  zero  angular  momentum  passed  through  the 
nucleus.  The  larger  angular-momentum  values  correspond  to  larger 
"arms"  and,  correspondingly,  in  quantum  mechanics,  to  a  smaller 
probability  of  finding  an  electron  close  to  the  nucleus. 

The  behaviour  of  the  wave  function  close  to  the  origin  can  also  be 
explained  as  follows.  A  centrifugal  repulsive  force  acts  on  the  particle  ; 

to  this  force  there  corresponds  an  effective  potential  energy  -—^  —  ~-  . 

This  energy  limits  the  classically  possible  region  of  motion  for  small  r. 
In  quantum  mechanics  the  particle  penetrates  the  centrifugal  barrier, 
though  more  weakly  the  greater  r,  i.e.,  the  higher  the  barrier.  There 
is  no  barrier  for  I  =  0  and  there  is  nothing  to  prevent  finding  the  par- 
ticle at  the  origin. 

The  terms  —  ~  —  ^~  fy  and  Ufy  must  be  discarded  for  large  r  in  the 

wave  equation,  because  U  (r)  is  assumed  to  be  zero  at  infinity, 
U(  00)^0.  Then  the  equation  is  also  greatly  simplified: 


Its  general  solution  appears  thus: 


x  =  Cie        *          +C2e       *          .  (31.14) 

Positive  and  negative  energy  values.  We  consider  two  cases.  Let  the 
energy  be  positive,  <?>0.  Here,  x  appears  as  follows: 


X  =  (71c        h       +  C2e  h       .  (31.15) 

Both  terms  remain  finite  for  any  value  of  r.  Therefore,  two  constants, 
C:  and  <72,  must  be  retained  in  the  solution.  We  came  across  the  same 
situation  in  considering  the  solution  of  wave  equation  (25.33)  for  a 
potential  well  of  finite  depth. 

Any  general  solution  of  a  second-order  differential  equation  involves 
two  arbitrary  constants.  Let  us  suppose  that  the  solution  (31.12), 
which  holds  for  small  r  only,  is  continued  into  the  region  of  large  r, 
where  it  is  not  of  the  simple  form  r1,  but  nevertheless  satisfies  the 


316  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

precise  equation  (31.7).  A  certain  integral  curve  is  obtained  for  this 
equation.  But  any  integral  curve  can  be  represented  by  properly 
choosing  the  constants  in  the  general  solution.  As  r  tends  to  infinity 
this  solution  acquires  its  asymptotic  form  (31.15)  if  <f>0.  The  ex- 
pression (31.15)  remains  finite  when  r->oo  for  any  constants  Cl  and 
C2.  It  follows  that,  for  a  positive  energy,  the  wave  equation  always 
has  a  finite  solution  for  any  values  of  r.  Therefore,  the  values  for  $  >  0 
correspond  to  a  continuous  energy  spectrum,  since  the  wave  function 
satisfies  the  required  conditions  at  zero  and  at  infinity  for  any  S  >  0. 
In  accordance  with  (31.15),  the  probability  of  finding  an  electron  at 
infinity  for  r->oo  does  not  become  zero;  i.e.,  this  case  corresponds 
to  infinite  motion,  as  in  the  classical  problem  considered  in  Sec.  5 
(see  also  Sec.  25). 

Thus,  the  general  rule  has  been  confirmed  that  infinite  motion 
possesses  a  continuous  energy  spectrum. 

Now  let  <?<0  or  S  =  —  \  S  \  .  Then  (31.14)  must  be  represented 
thus: 


_  _ 

x  =  Cr1e""     h    "     +  C2e  "       ".  (31.16) 

Here  the  first  solution  tends  to  infinity  together  with  r  and  we  must 
therefore  put  C:  =  0,  so  that  x  will  involve  one  instead  of  two  arbitrary 
constants  : 


*  =  C2e         *         .  (31.17) 

The  condition  for  eigenvalues.  If  we  now  draw  an  integral  curve 
from  the  coordinate  origin,  proceeding  from  (31.12),  then,  as  a  rule, 
for  large  r  it  will  not  be  reduced  to  the  form  (31.17).  For  all  negative 
energy  values,  except  certain  ones,  the  integral  curve  is  represented  in 
the  form  (31.16)  at  infinity  when  <f  <0  and,  hence,  does  not  satisfy 
the  boundary  condition  imposed  on  the  wave  function.  Only  for  those 
energy  values  for  which  it  turns  out  that 

C1(<?)=0  (31.18) 

does  the  wave  equation  have  a  solution.  This  corresponds  to  a  discrete 
energy  spectrum.  At  the  same  time,  x  (<*>)  becomes  zero,  so  that  the 
finite  motion  has  a  discrete  energy  spectrum,  as  expected. 

The  Coulomb  field.  The  transition  to  atomic  units.  We  shall  now 
find  this  spectrum  for  an  electron  in  a  purely  Coulomb  field: 

U(r)  =  -•?£-.  (31.19) 

This  occurs  in  a  hydrogen  atom  (though  not  in  a  molecule!),  in 
singly  ionized  helium,  doubly  ionized  lithium,  etc.  Z,  as  usual,  denotes 
the  atomic  number  of  the  nucleus. 


Sec.  31]  MOTION    IN   A   CENTRAL   FIELD  317 

The  wave  equation  (31.7)  is  now  written  as 


__ 
2m    dr* 

We  have  straightway  taken  the  case  of  negative  energies  that  leads 
to  a  discrete  spectrum. 

It  is  convenient  here  to  change  the  units  of  length  and  energy 
similar  to  the  way  it  was  done  in  the  problem  of  the  harmonic  oscillator 
(Sec.  26).  In  place  of  the  CGS  system  (where  the  basic  units  are  the 
arbitrary  quantities  centimetre,  gram,  second)  we  take  the  following 
units  :  the  elementary  charge  e,  the  mass  of  the  electron  m,  and  the 
quantum  of  action  h.  From  these  quantities  we  form  the  unit  of  length 

h*    =5.29  17  x  10-9cm 


me2 
and  energy 


Hence,  if  we  put  e  =  l,  m  =  l,  h  =  l  in  equation  (31.20),  then  length 
and  energy  will  be  measured  in  these  units.  Let  us  call  this  length  £: 


and  energy  s: 

*  /Ql    90\ 

(31.22) 


so  that,  of  the  constants,  the  wave  equation  will  involve  only  the 
atomic  number  Z: 

(31.23) 


Solution  by  the  series-expansion  method.  We  look  for  the  solution 
of  this  equation  in  the  form  of  a  series  expansion.  We  shall  proceed 
here  from  the  solutions  obtained  for  large  and  small  values  of  i; 
(i.e.,  r). 

In  accordance  with  equations  (31.12)  and  (31.17),  we  write  /  in 
following  form: 


<SL24> 

n—  0  «=-0 

The  first  factor  determined  the  form  of  x  for  ^->0,  the  second  factor 
should  basically  correspond  to  the  form  of  x  for  large  £,  and  the  series 
interpolates,  as  it  were,  between  the  limiting  values. 


318  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Differentiating  (31.24)  twice,  we  obtain 

00 

(31.25) 

The  first  term  on  the  right  is  simply  — 2  e^.  Hence,  it  cancels  with  the 
same  term  in  (31.23).  We  group  the  remaining  terms  so  that  in  one  of 
them  the  degree  of  £  is  everywhere  less  by  unity  than  in  (31.24)  and, 
in  the  other,  less  by  two  units.  In  addition  we  eliminate  the  common 
factor  e-5^e  .  We  shall  now  have  an  equality  between  two  such 
series : 

00 

£  [1(1+  1)  -  (n  +  I  +  1)  (n  +  I)]  X^-H-'-^ 

(31.26) 


An  equality  between  series  is  possible  only  when  the  coefficients  of 
the  same  powers  of  ^  coincide.  On  the  left-hand  side  the  power  £M  +  / 
will  have  a  coefficient  involving 

Hence 


-  (n  +  /  +  iT^-TT+  2)~  '  . 

Examining  the  scries  and  the  condition  for  eigenvalues.  From  the 
relationship  (31.27),  all  the  coefficients  x«  are  determined  consecu- 
tively. We  must  neglect  the  constant  numbers  I  and  Z  in  equation 
(31.27)  when  n  are  large;  there  then  remains  the  limit 


We  met  with  a  similar  expression  in  the  problem  of  the  harmonic 
oscillator  (26.16).  In  the  case  of  large  £  it  reduces  the  whole  series  to 
an  exponential  form: 

(31.29) 


But  such  a  series  cannot  give  a  correct  solution  to  the  wave  equation 
because,  if  we  substitute  (31.29)  in  (31.24),  we  obtain  ^(oo)  =  oo 
despite  the  boundary  condition.  However,  if  all  the  coefficients  become 
zero  from  a  certain  x«+i  onwards,  the  series  (31.29)  degenerates  to  a 
polynomial.  Then,  being  multiplied  by  e-S^^r,  ^  gives  ^  (oo)  =  0, 


Sec.  31]                                            MOTION    IN   A   CENTRAL   FIELD  319 

as  expected.   It  can   be  seen  from   (31.27)   that  &,  + 1  *s  equal  to 
zero  if 

Z-  (n  + 1  + 1)  V2?  =  0,  (31.30) 


Finally,  going  over  to  conventional  units  and  taking  into  account 
the  sign  of  the  energy,  we  obtain  the  required  spectrum: 

T-  (31.32) 

Quantum  numbers.  The  number  n  is  the  degree  of  the  polynomial 
[n  (it  is  called  the  Sonin-Laguerre  polynomial).  A  more  detailed 


analysis  shows  that  this  polynomial  becomes  zero  exactly  n  times, 
corresponding  to  its  degree.  Therefore,  if  we  examine  the  dependence 
of  the  wave  function  on  radius,  it  has  n  zeros  or  "nodes/*  not  counting 
the  zero  at  r  =  oo  and  at  r  =  Q,  which  all  functions  with  Z^O  have. 
The  term  node  instead  of  zero  is  given  by  analogy  with  the  nodes  of  a 
vibrating  string  fixed  at  both  ends.  In  future  we  shah1  call  nr  the  degree 
of  the  polynomial  and  denote  by  the  letter  n  the  whole  sum 

n==ttr  +  Z+l.  (31.33) 

It  is  convenient  to  use  these  quantities  also  in  the  more  complex 
cases  of  many -electron  atoms.  Even  though  the  energy  in  such  a  case 
does  not  have  the  simple  form  (31.32),  the  numbers  n,  nr,  and  I  are 
convenient  for  classification  of  the  states. 

I  is  called  the  azimuthal  quantum  number.  As  we  know,  it  defines 
the  angular  momentum  of  an  electron.  The  following  system  of  nota- 
tion is  used  in  spectroscopy :  the  electron  state  with  I  =  0  is  called  the 
s-state  and,  corresponding  to  I  =  1,  2,  3,  we  have  the  p-,  d-  and  /-states. 
There  are  no  greater  values  of  I  in  nonexcited  atoms.  Combining  the 
angular  momenta  of  separate  electrons  according  to  the  rule  of  vector 
addition  (30.30),  we  obtain  the  angular  momentum  L  of  the  atom  as  a 
whole.  The  states  with  L  =  Q,  1,  2,  3  are  termed  S9  P,  D,  F,  while 
states  with  greater  L  are  named  by  subsequent  letters  of  the  Latin 
alphabet. 

fc,  [see  Eq.  (29.21)],  i.e.,  the  angular-momentum  projection  on  some 
axis  in  units  of  A,  is  called  the  magnetic  quantum  number,  since  the 
external  magnetic  field  is  usually  directed  along  this  axis. 

nr  is  the  number  of  wave-function  zeros  as  related  to  the  radius 
(for  r^O  and  r=^oo)  and  is  called  the  radial  quantum  number. 

Finally,  the  sum  (31.33)  is  called  the  principal  quantum  number. 
In  accordance  with  (31.32),  the  binding  energy  of  an  electron  in  a 
hydrogen  atom  is 


320  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 


An  analogous  expression  is  obtained  also  for  the  positive  helium 
ion.  Apart  from  the  difference  of  Z2  =  4  times,  there  is  a  more  subtle 
difference  due  to  the  fact  that  the  reduced  mass  of  the  helium  atom 
differs  somewhat  from  the  reduced  mass  of  a  hydrogen  atom  as  a  result 
of  a  difference  in  the  nuclear  masses. 

The  state  with  n=l  is  the  ground  state.  The  atom  cannot  emit 
light  in  this  state  because  it  is  impossible  to  make  a  transition  to  a 
lower  state.  For  more  detail  about  radiation,  see  Sec.  34. 

The  parity  of  a  state.  The  state  of  an  electron  in  an  atom  is  character- 
ized by  one  more  property,  which  (as  opposed  to  energy  and  angular 
momentum)  does  not  correspond  to  any  classical  analogue.  This  is 
the  parity  of  a  wave  function  with  respect  to  coordinates. 

To  begin  with  let  us  consider  the  wave  function  of  a  separate  electron. 
The  wave  equation  (31.1)  does  not  change  its  form  if  we  substitute 

x  =  -  of  y,  -  -  */',  z  =  -  z'.  (31.35) 

This  transformation  is  termed  inversion  :  it  transforms  a  right-handed 
coordinate  system  to  a  left-handed  one.  No  rotation  in  space  can  make 
these  systems  coincide  (like  left-hand  and  right-hand  gloves)  (see 
Sec.  16). 

The  wave  equation  (31.1)  is  linear.  Therefore,  if  it  has  not  changed 
its  form,  then  its  solution  (determined  by  the  boundary  conditions 
within  the  accuracy  of  the  constant  factor)  can  acquire  only  a  certain 
additional  factor: 

',  »',*')•  (31.36) 


But,  in  principle,  the  primed  left-handed  system  differs  in  no  way 
from  the  unprimed,  right-handed  system.  For  this  reason,  the  trans- 
formation of  inversion  must  involve  the  same  transformation  factor  C: 


x,v,z).  (31.37) 

Substituting  this  in  (31.36),  we  obtain 


whence 

C2  =  l,     G=±l.  (31.38) 

The  function  is  termed  even  for  (7  =  1  and  odd  for  C=  —  1.  The 
eigenfunctions  of  a  linear  harmonic  oscillator  possessed  an  analogous 
property;  here  the*  energy  operator  was  also  even,  jf?  (x)  =  jf?(  —  x), 
while  the  wave  functions  alternated  depending  upon  the  eigenvalue 
number  n  (i.e.,  they  were  either  even  or  odd). 

Parity  and  orbital  angular  momentum.  Let  us  now  find  out  what 
it  is  that  determines  the  parity  of  a  wave  function  in  a  central  field. 


Sec.  31]  MOTION   IN   A   CENTRAL   FIELD  321 

To  do  this,  it  is  convenient  to  utilize  its  form  near  the  coordinate 
origin: 

fy  =  rl.  (31.39) 

In  order  to  find  the  angular  dependence  of  the  wave  function  as 
well,  it  is  sufficient  to  investigate  it  to  the  approximation  that  yields 
equation  (31.39)  since  the  terms  U  and  S ,  which  do  not  depend  upon 
the  angles,  are  thereby  discarded.  The  angular  dependence  of  the 
solutions  of  the  precise  and  shortened  equation  is  the  same.  This 
shortened  equation  is,  obviously,  simply  the  Laplace  equation 

A^  =  0.  (31.40) 

Equation  (31.40)  is  satisfied  by  a  homogeneous  polynomial  in  x,  y,  z 
<p  =  xl  +  ax1-1  y  +  ...  +  bxl-k~m  yk  zm  +  . . .  (31.41) 

of  degree  I  for  certain  relationships  between  its  coefficients  a,  . .  . , 
b,  ...  .It  is  clear  that  the  degree  I  of  this  polynomial  is  equal  to  the 
degree  I  in  equation  (31.39).  But  the  degree  I  of  (31.41)  defines  the  even 
or  odd  nature  of  ^  with  respect  to  the  inversion  (31.35).  It  follows  that 
wave  functions  with  even  orbital  angular  momenta  I  are  even,  and 
those  with  odd  orbital  angular  momenta  I  are  odd.  In  a  multi-electron 
atom,  the  total  parity  of  the  wave  function  is  determined  by  the  parity 
of  all  the  wave  functions  for  the  separate  electrons  (this  by  no  means 
signifies  that  the  wave  function  of  an  atom  is  equal  to  the  product  of 
the  wave  functions  of  the  separate  electrons!).  Therefore,  the  parity 

of  the  total  wave  function  is  equal  to  the  parity  of  the  number  JE7fc 

i 

where  /,-  are  the  orbital  quantum  numbers  of  the  electrons.  As  we  know, 
the  total  angular  momentum  of  the  atom  is  equal  to  the  vector  sum 
of  the  angular  momenta  of  its  electrons. 

Parity  as  an  integral  of  motion.  We  shall  explain  the  significance  of 
the  parity  of  a  wave  function.  To  begin  with,  let  us  point  out  that  the 
inversion  (31.35)  can  be  represented  by  an  operator  G  such  that 

Gty(x9y,z)  =  ty(-x,-y,-z).  (31.42) 

Since  the  Hamiltonian  operator  in  an  atom  &  is  an  even  function  of 
coordinates,  we  can  write 

&<$  =  &.  (31.43) 

Whence  it  follows  that  the  parity  operator  is  commutative  with  the 
Hamiltonian  operator 

G3fty  =  jeG<l>.  (31.44) 

The  eigenvalues  of  the  operator  G  are  the  numbers  G  =  ±  I  (31.38), 
because 

Gfy  =  ty  (-  x,  -  y,  -  z)  =  C<Jj .  (31.45) 

21  -0060 


322  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

According  to  (.31.44)  and  (29.28)  these  numbers  exist  simultaneously 
with  the  energy  eigenvalues. 

We  shall  now  consider  what  limitations  can  be  imposed,  by  the 
law  of  conservation  of  parity,  on  possible  transitions  in  the  atom. 
Suppose  we  have  an  excited  multi-electron  atom  with  total  angular 
momentum  L  =  0,  i.  e.,  in  the  $-state.  Then  let  there  be  in  this  atom 
s-electrons  and  an  odd  number  of  p-electrons.  Consequently,  the  atom 
is  in  an  odd  state.  Let  the  excitation  energy  be  sufficient  for  the  atom 
to  emit  one  of  the  ^-electrons,  so  that  after  the  rearrangement  of  the 
electron  cloud  the  atom  remains  in  the  $-state  with  £  =  0.  Since  angu- 
lar momenta  are  combined  vectorially,  such  a  state  may  result  both 
for  an  odd  and  an  even  number  of  ^-electrons.  According  to  the  law 
of  conservation  of  total  angular  momentum,  an  electron  may  be  emitted 
only  with  an  angular  momentum  equal  to  zero  because,  according  to 
assumption,  the  angular  momentum  of  the  rest  of  the  system  is  equal 
to  zero  before  and  after  the  transition.  It  follows  that  the  electron  can 
be  emitted  only  in  an  even  s-state. 

After  the  emission  of  the  electron,  an  even  number  of  ^-electrons 
remains  in  the  ion,  and  the  emitted  electron  is  also  found  to  be  in  an 
even  state.  But  this  is  impossible  since  the  initial  state  was  odd  and 
the  final  state  was  even,  the  total  energy  being  constant.  Hence,  the 
laws  of  conservation  of  parity  and  angular  momentum  may  exclude 
transitions  which  are  permissible  energetically.  We  have  considered 
a  typical  case  of  a  transition  which  is  "forbidden"  by  parity  selection 
rules  (Z/  —  0  into  Z/  — 0  with  changed  parity). 

The  law  of  conservation  of  parity  by  no  means  follows  from  the 
law  of  conservation  of  angular  momentum,  since  parity  depends  upon 
the  arithmetic  sum  of  I  while  total  angular  momentum  depends  upon 
the  vector  sum. 

The  law  of  conservation  of  angular  momentum  in  quantum  mechan- 
ics must  always  be  used  together  with  the  law  of  conservation  of 
parity.  In  origin,  these  laws  have  a  common  basis:  they  both  follow 
from  the  invariance  of  equations  with  respect  to  the  orientation  of 
coordinate  axes  in  space.  But  all  possible  orientations  are  not  exhausted 
by  axis  rotations  alone :  an  additional  transformation  is  inversion  which 
is  not  reduced  to  any  rotation.  It  is  this  that  yields  the  parity  conser- 
vation law  in  addition  to  the  law  of  conservation  of  angular  momentum. 

In  this  form  the  parity  conservation  law  can  be  unconditionally 
applied  to  those  systems  in  which  electromagnetic  interactions  occur. 

The  considerably  weaker  interactions  which  occur  in  certain  ele- 
mentary-particle conversions  probably  satisfy  a  modified  parity  con- 
servation law  (see  Sec.  38). 

Hydrogen-like  atoms.  Alkali-metal  atoms  somewhat  resemble  the 
hydrogen  atom.  The  outer  electron  in  these  atoms  is  relatively  weakly 
bound  to  the  atomic  residue,  which  consists  of  the  nucleus  and  all  the 
remaining  electrons.  The  wave  functions  for  electrons  of  the  atomic 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  323 

residue  differ  from  zero  at  smaller  distances  from  the  nucleus  than  the 
wave  function  for  the  outer  electron,  so  that  the  residue  screens,  as  it 
were,  the  nuclear  charge.  The  field  in  which  the  outer  electron  moves 
is  approximately  Coulomb,  provided  only  that  it  is  not  situated  in 
the  region  of  the  residue.  It  is  for  this  reason  that  the  spectra  of  alkali- 
metal  atoms  resemble  the  hydrogen-atom  spectrum.  The  energy  levels 
of  these  atoms,  which  are  due  to  excitation  of  the  outer  electron,  are 
given  by  the  equation 

&  me*  1    _  /01  Aa. 

*"•'=-  W  [n  +  A  (I)]*"'  <3L46) 

where  the  correction  A  (I)  depends  upon  the  azimuthal  quantum 
number.  It  accounts  for  the  deviation  of  the  field  from  a  purely  Cou- 
lomb one  at  small  distances  from  the  nucleus. 

Thus,  the  energy  levels  in  alkali  metals  —  -like  the  energy  levels  of 
all  atoms  —  depend  upon  n  and  I.  An  exception  is  the  hydrogen  atom, 
where  the  energy  depends  only  upon  n\  this  is  a  special  property  of  a 
purely  Coulomb  field.  For  example,  when  n  =  2,  the  azimuthal  quan- 
tum number  can  take  on  two  values:  1^0  and  1  =  1,  while  the  corre- 
sponding energy  levels  of  the  hydrogen  atom  are  close  to  each  other 
(the  splitting  of  these  levels  is  due  to  relativistic  corrections  to  the  wave 
equation). 

Exorcise 

Construct  and  normalize  the  wave  functions  in  a  hydrogen  atom  with 

00 

1  =  0,  1,  2  and  w=  1,  2,  3.  Take  advantage  of  the  fact  that    j    e~*xndx  =  n  ! 


Sec.  32.  Electron  Spin 

The  insufficiency  of  three  quantum  numbers  for  the  electron  in  an 
atom.  From  equation  (31.34)  the  ground  state  of  a  hydrogen  atom  has 
a  principal  quantum  number  n  equal  to  unity.  For  n  =  1  the  azimuthal 
quantum  number  I  and  the  radial  quantum  number  nr  must  be  equal 
to  zero,  since  n  =  nr  +  l  +  1,  and  nr  and  I  can  in  no  way  be  less  than 
zero.  The  ground  state  of  a  hydrogen  atom  is  the  s-state.  The  orbital 
motion  of  an  ^-electron  does  not  produce  a  magnetic  moment  because 
the  magnetic  moment  is  proportional  to  the  mechanical  moment. 
Yet,  if  the  Stern-Gerlaeh  experiment  is  performed  for  atomic  hydro- 
gen, the  atomic  beam  will  split,  but  only  into  two  parts.  However, 
when  Z  =  0,  as  we  have  already  said,  there  should  be  no  splitting  due 
to  orbital  angular  momentum,  while  for  Z—  1,  the  beam  should  split 
into  2  I  +  1  =  3  beams  corresponding  to  the  number  of  projections  k 
of  the  angular  momentum  I  (  —  1,  0,  1). 

The  same  results  if,  instead  of  hydrogen,  we  take  an  alkali  metal. 
The  electron  cloud  of  any  alkali  metal  consists  of  an  atomic  residue  in 

21* 


324  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

an  /S-state,  i.e.,  one  lacking  an  orbital  angular  momentum  and  one 
electron  in  the  s-state.  In  this  sense,  aklali-metal  atoms  resemble  the 
hydrogen  atom.  For  this  reason,  the  state  of  the  atom  is  not  described 
by  the  three  quantum  numbers  n,  I,  and  k. 

Intrinsic  angular  momentum  or  electron  spin.  Splitting  into  two 
beams  can  be  accounted  for  only  by  an  angular  momentum  whose 
greatest  projection  is  equal  to  hj 2.  Then  it  has  only  two  projections 
h/2  and  — -h/2. 

The  Stern-Gerlach  experiment  was  given  only  as  an  example.  In 
fact,  not  only  this  experiment,  but  the  whole  enormous  aggregate  of 
knowledge  about  the  atom  indicates  that  the  electron  possesses  a 
mechanical  moment  h/2  that  is  not  related  to  its  orbital  motion.  This 
mechanical  moment  is  termed  the  spin.  It  can  be  said  that  an  electron 
is  somewhat  reminiscent  of  a  planet  which  has  an  angular  momentum 
due  not  only  to  its  revolution  about  the  sun,  but  also  to  rotation  on  its 
own  axis. 

The  analogy  with  a  planet  is  not  far-reaching  since  the  angular  mo- 
mentum of  rotating  rigid  body  can  be  made  equal  to  any  value,  while 
the  spin  of  an  electron  always  has  projections  ±  A/2  and  no  others. 
Therefore,  spin  is  a  purely  quantum  property  of  the  electron;  in  the 
limiting  transition  to  classical  mechanics  it  becomes  zero.  We  must  not 
take  the  word  "spin"  too  literally,  for  the  electron  actually  does  not 
resemble  a  rigid  body  like  a  top  or  a  spindle. 

Spin  degree  of  freedom.  The  analogy  between  an  electron  and  a  top 
consists  in  the  fact  that  their  motion  is  not  described  by  their  position 
in  space  alone,  but  possesses  an  internal  rotational  degree  of  freedom. 

There  is  a  certain  analogy  between  the  electron  and  the  light 
quantum.  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  28,  in  addition  to  its  wave  vector, 
the  state  of  a  quantum  is  described  by  a  polarization  variable  which 
takes  on  two  values.  Similarly,  the  electron  has,  in  addition  to  its 
spatial  coordinates,  a  spin  variable  a  which  assumes  two  values  (since 
spin  has  only  two  projections). 

Spin  operators.  When  we  write  ^  (#)  we  have  in  mind  the  whole  group 
of  values  of  the  wave  function  for  all  x,  i.e.,  fy  at  all  points  of  space. 
The  action  of  an  operator  on  fy  (#)  denotes  a  linear  transformation 
of  ip  in  the  whole  space,  since,  in  accordance  with  the  superposition 
principle,  all  operators  in  quantum  mechanics  are  linear.  Taking  into 
account  the  spin  variable,  one  has  to  write  fy  (x,  a),  where  or  takes  on 
only  two  values.  The  action  of  the  spin  operator  on  fy  (x,  a)  denotes 
the  replacement  of  fy  (x,  1)  by  some  linear  combination  of  ip  (x9  1) 
and  fy  (x,  2) ;  the  action  of  the  operator  on  fy  (x,  2)  is  determined  anal- 
oguously.  Linear  operators  depending  upon  a  can  denote  nothing 
other  than  a  linear  substitution  as  applied  to  a  function  of  "two 
points"  a  =  l  and  a  —  2. 

We  shall  try  to  determine,  in  explicit  form,  how  spin  angular- 
momentum  projection  operators  should  act  upon  functions  of  the 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  325 

spin  variable  a.  The  following  requirements  are  to  be  imposed 
on  them. 

1)  The  eigenvalues  of  all  three  spin  projections  must  be  equal  to 
±  fc/2. 

2)  The  same  commutation  rules   (29.33)- (29.35)   must  exist  for 
them  as  for  the  components  of  orbital  angular  momentum,  otherwise 
the  sum  of  the  orbital  and  spin  angular-momentum  operators  will  not 
possess  the  property  of  angular  momentum. 

3)  For  the  same  reason  we  must  require  that  the  spin-projection 
operators  should  be  Hermitian. 

4)  In  coordinate-system  rotations,  spin-projection  operators  must 
behave  in  the  same  way  as  vector  components  so  that  the  commuta- 
tion rules  for  these  operators,  in  a  rotated  system,  should  not  differ 
from  the  rules  of  the  original  system  in  which  the  operators  were  de- 
fined. 

Corresponding  to  these  requirements,  W.  Pauli  found  the  required 
operators,  which  we  shall  now  form. 

We  shall  write  the  group  of  functions  fy  (xy  a)  in  columns  instead  of 
rows;  the  meaning  of  fy  (x,  ci)  does  not  thereby  change,  of  course. 
In  addition,  for  brevity,  we  shall  omit  the  coordinate  dependence  con- 
tained in  the  argument  x.  Thus,  fy  (<*)  denotes  the  column 

p-  «*•» 

Here,  each  component  satisfies  Schrodinger's  coordinate  equation 
(24.22).  In  the  most  general  case  the  action  of  a  linear  operator  on  the 
function  (32.1)  reduces  it  to  the  form 


As  we  know,  one  of  the  angular-momentum  projections  can  always 
exist  together  with  the  square  of  the  total  angular  momentum,  since 
the  substitution  rules  for  spin  components  are  the  same  as  for  orbital 
angular  momentum  (condition  2).  To  be  specific,  we  shall  consider 
that  there  exists  the  2th  projection  a*.  If  the  operator  az  has  an  eigen- 
value in  the  given  state,  its  application  leads  to  the  multiplication  of 
the  function  (32.1)  by  some  number  without  mixing  of  the  components. 
This  number  is  equal  to  ±  A/2,  depending  upon  what  the  sign  of 
the  spin  projection  az  is  in  the  given  state.  Let  the  function  <p  (1) 
be  multiplied  by  +h/2  and  the  function  <p  (2)  by  — A/2,  so  that 


326  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

The  equality  sign  between  columns  denotes  a  line  by  line  equality 
of  the  expressions,  i.e.,  S*<p  (1)  =  y  ^  (1),  cz(2)  =  —  -^-fy  (2)  .  The 

form  of  the  functions  corresponding  to  various  spin  projections  can 
immediately  be  seen  :  to  the  projection  h/2  there  corresponds  a  function 

(   0  )  '  w^e  ^ne  function  I  ,  ,2\)  corresponds  to  the  projection  —  A/2. 

The  first  of  them,  if  we  substitute  it  in  (32.2),  is  entirely  multiplied 
by  A/2,  while  the  second  is  multiplied  by  —  A/2,  since  the  change  of 
sign  for  the  zero  component  of  the  function  does  not  signify  anything. 

The  operators  ax  and  <ry  cannot  have  eigenvalues  in  these  states. 
It  follows  that  they  must  in  any  case  also  interchange  the  components 
of  the  wave  function  that  we  have  defined,  and  not  merely  multiply  them 
by  numbers.  Simple  multiplication  operators  would  be  commutative 
with  GZ.  Once  the  form  GZ  is  given,  we  can  also  determine  the  operators 
for  the  other  two  components. 

Let  us  temporarily  go  over  to  atomic  units  (see  Sec.  31),  i.e.,  we 
put  A  ~  1.  We  shall  look  for  the  operator  5X  (acting  on  the  two  functions) 
in  the  most  general  possible  form*: 

(32.3) 

In  other  words,  we  suppose  that  it  replaces  <pi  by  a^  +  p^g  and 
^2  by  Y^i  +  ^2*  We  act  on  cxfy  with  a*.  Then,  by  definition  of  GZ 
(32.2),  we  must  change  the  sign  in  the  lower  row  and  divide  both 
rows  by  two  : 


If  we  act  upon  Gzfy  with  GX,  then  we  must  first  of  all  put  a  minus  sign 
in  front  of  <ji2  and  divide  both  components  by  two,  and  then  substitute 
them  in  (32.3).  This  will  yield 


From  (29.35),  the  difference  az<*x  —  <y*S*  must  be  equal  to  iay  in 
atomic  units  : 


__  y    .  (32.4) 

Thus,  the  operator  <ry  interchanges  the  functions  <pi  and  ^2  and  multi- 
plies them  by  p  and  —  y,  where  p  and  y  appeared  in  the  definition 
(32.3)  for  5x. 

*  The  argument  o  =  1  and  a  =  2  will  in  future  be  replaced  by  the  index. 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  327 

But  if  we  proceed  from  ory,  defining  it  analogously  to  (32.3),  it  will 
turn  out  that  GX  also  interchanges  functions,  i.e.,  it  does  not  contain 
the  coefficients  a  and  8.  Therefore  we  obtain 


We  now  form  the  difference  GX  <ry  —  <ry  GX.  First  acting  with  GX  upon 
Gyfy  and  then  with  <yy  upon  axfy,  we  equate  their  difference  to  i  azfy  [see 
(29.33)]: 


whence  it  follows  that 

Y=-£-  (32-5) 

Hence,  conditions  (29.33)-(29.35)  lead  to  the  following  form  for 

Gx  and  Gy  : 

r       \  -t 

(32.6) 

The  operators  £*,  ffy  and  <r*  must  be  Hermitian.  We  once  again 
deduce  the  Hermitian  condition  (30.3)  for  the  operator  GX,  insofar  as 
the  result  of  Sec.  30  related  to  a  continuous  variable  #,  while  here 
we  consider  a  discrete  variable  G.  Let  us  write  similarly  to  (30.  la) 
and  (30.  Ib),  with  spin  dependence  in  explicit  form: 


Summation  with  respect  to  a  now  corresponds  to  integration  with  re- 
spect to  x.  We  multiply  the  first  two  equations  by  <p?  andj  <];£,  respec- 
tively, and  the  second  two  by  ^  and  4>2>  sum  w^h.  respect  to  cr,  and 
equate  the  results  utilizing  the  fact  that  GX  is  a  real  number  : 


As  was  shown  in  Sec.  30,  this  condition  must  be  identically  satis- 
fied for  any  two  functions  #*  and  fy.  From  this  we  obtain 

3d*  ?*•  +  Xt*  17  *i  =  *i  P*  Xa*  +  4*2  4^1-  Xi*  •  (32.7) 

But  this  equation  can  hold  only  if 


328  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

i.e.,    B  =  -H-e'v.  There  remains  an  arbitrary  phase  factor  e'v  which 

2t 

we  choose  equal  to  unity.  Thus, 

<32-8> 


<32-9> 

We  jiote  three  operator  relations 

Gx  Gy  "  —  Gy  Gx  =  -5-  ff*  J        CF*  GTx  =  —  <7x  0^  =  ~^~  CTy  J 

.  (32.10) 

GyGz~  —  OF*  CTy  =  -g-  CT*  , 

which  are  directly  verified  by  substitution,  and  also  expressions  for 
the  squares  3£,  SJ,  and  SJ,  which  are  obtained  when  they  act  twice 
upon  4" 

1  AM       1  i 

=  =  T*' 

(32.11) 

s^  =    ^;    a;*-*. 

Hence,  in  accordance  with  condition  (1),  the  eigenvalues  of  SJ, 
SJ,  and  aj  are  -j-  .  Since  each  operator  is  commutative  with  its  square, 

we  see  that  the  eigenvalues  of  a*,  &y,  and  GZ  should  equal  the  square 
roots  of  the  eigenvalues  of  their  squares,  i.e.,  ±  1/2.  Naturally, 
these  eigenvalues  of  a*,  5y,  and  az  only  exist  separately  and  by  no 
means  simultaneously. 

The  vector  properties  of  spin  operators.  In  order  to  prove  finally 
that  the  operators  ax,  ay,  and  GZ  possess  the  properties  of  angular- 
momentum  components,  we  must  be  convinced  that  in  coordinate 
rotations  they  transform  like  vector  projections,  i.e.,  we  must  verify 
that  condition  (4)  is  satisfied. 

Let  us  suppose  that  a  rotation  occurs  around  the  z-axis  through 
an  angle  co.  Then  we  must  prove  that  the  operators 

5i  =  Sr*cosco+Sysin<o, 

A,  A  .  ,         A  lO^.l^j 

ay  —  —  a*  sin  co  +  ary  cos  co  , 

formed  by  analogy  with  the  vector  projections  on  rotated  coordinate 
axes  possess  the  same  properties  (1)  and  (2)  as  the  original  operators 
Sx  and  5y.  First  of  all  we  have 


>)  (GX cos  co  - 
=  GX  cos2  co  +  5y  sin2  co  +  (GX 5y  +  ay  GX)  sin  co  cos  co  . 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  329 

It  can  be  seen  from  (32.10)  that 

axay  +  SySx=0  (32.13) 

(and  analogously  for  any  pair  of  components).  Further,  a£  and  aj, 
operating  on  ^-functions,  act  like  numbers,  i.e.,  they  simply  multiply 

it  by  1/4.  But  then  this  also  means  that  S '  J  =  -j-  (cos2  co  +  sin2  to)  =  -7- . 

Thus,  the  first  property  of  3*  and  S'y  is  retained  under  the  rotation 
of  the  components. 

We  now  form  the  difference  axSy  —  GySx: 

GX  Gy—SyGx~  ~  <*x  COS  CO  SU1  CO  +  Sy  SHI  CO  COS  CO  +  SjcSy  COS2  CO  — 

o  4-  5£coscosinco  —  ajsincocosco  +  5xSysin2co  — 

O  —   SXSy  —  SySx  =  lSZ  .  (32.14) 

But  Sz=$z  since  the  rotation  occurs  about  the  z-axis. 

Any  rotation  in  space  may  be  obtained  by  successive  rotations 
about  three  axes.  Therefore,  it  was  sufficient  to  show  that  the  basic 
properties  of  the  operators  are  preserved  under  rotations  about  any 
one  of  the  three  axes. 

The  total  angular-momentum  operator.  If  we  now  form  the  sum 
of  the  operators 

JX  =  MX  +  SX;     jy  =  My  +  $y;     fz  =  Mz  +  3z,        (32.15) 

then  it  will  possess  all  the  properties  of  an  angular-momentum  operator. 
Naturally,  we  could  not  have  added  the  components  of  o  to  the 
components  of  M  if  they  both  did  not  transform  identically  under 
rotations  of  the  coordinate  system,  since,  otherwise,  equations  (32.15) 
would  be  noninvariant  with  respect  to  the  choice  of  the  system  of  axes. 
The  vector  j  is  called  the  total  angular  momentum  of  an  electron. 
If  the  orbital  angular  momentum  of  the  electron  has  a  greatest 

projection  I,  then  the  greatest  projection  of  j  can  equal  1  +  -^  or 

I  —  -5-    In  the  first  case,  we  say  that  the  spin  and  the  orbital  angular 
£  • 

momentum  are  parallel ;  in  the  second  case,  we  say  that  they  are 
antiparallel. 

Spin  magnetic  moment.  The  spin  of  an  electron,  similar  to  its  orbital 
angular  momentum,  is  associated  with  a  definite  magnetic  moment. 
But  experiment  shows  that  the  ratio  of  spin  magnetic  moment  to 
mechanical  moment  is  twice  as  great  as  for  orbital  angular  momentum. 
There  is  nothing  paradoxical  in  this  because  the  result  (15.25)  cannot 
be  applied  to  spin.  At  the  same  time  we  can  deduce  the  spin  magnetic 
moment  from  the  Dirac  relativistic  wave  equation  for  an  electron 
(Sec.  38);  in  agreement  with  experiment,  it  is  found  to  be 

*  =  •«•  (32-16) 


330  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Hence,  the  projection  of  jxa  on  any  axis  is 

i.  32.17 


The  quantity  JJLO  is  termed  the  Bohr  magneton.  This  is  a  natural 
unit  of  magnetic  moment. 

The  ratio  ^q^  =  —  -  is  called  the  spin  gyromagnetic  ratio.  It  was 

QZ  771  C 

first  discovered  in  determining  the  mechanical  moment  caused  by 
magnetization  of  iron  rods  (the  Einstein-de  Hass  experiment).  Spin 
was  not  known  at  that  time  and  it  appeared  strange  that  the  gyro- 

magnetic  ratio  was  not  equal  to  -^  ---  as  follows  from  (15.25).  It 

is  now  known  that  magnetism  in  iron  is  connected  with  the  spin 
of  certain  of  its  electrons. 

The  fine  structure  of  atomic  levels.  Spin  magnetic  moment  interacts 
with  the  magnetic  moment  of  orbital  motion  and  with  the  spin 
angular  momenta  or  other  electrons,  if  the  atom  is  of  the  multi- 
electron  type.  This  interaction  is  proportional  to  the  magnitude  of 
both  magnetic  moments,  i.e.,  it  involves  the  product  of  gyromagnetic 
ratios.  The  latter  is  inversely  proportional  to  c2  and,  hence,  is  an 
essentially  relativistic  effect. 

Electron  velocities  in  atoms  are  everywhere  small  compared  with 
the  velocity  of  light,  with  the  exception  of  the  internal  regions  of 
the  atoms  of  heavy  elements.  Therefore,  a  quantity  involving  c2 
in  the  denominator  is  usually  small  compared  with  other  quantities 
on  the  atomic  scale;  the  interaction  energy  for  magnetic  moments 
is  less  than  the  distance  —  due  to  electrostatic  interaction  —  between 
energy  levels.  As  a  result  of  the  interaction  between  spin  and  orbital 
angular  momenta,  the  energy  level  of  a  separate  electron  corresponding 

to  a  total  electron  angular  momentum  j  =  I  +  -^  differs  a  little  (when 
placed  in  a  central  field)  from  a  level  with  a  total  angular  momentum 
j^l  —  y*;  this  is  because  the  angular  momenta  are  parallel  in 

the  first  case  and  antiparallel  in  the  second.  But  the  energies  of 
two  parallel  and  antiparallel  angular  momenta  differ. 

The  only  scalar  quantity  which  is  linear  with  respect  to  each  of 
two  pseudovectors  ji^  and  fx2  is  \L±  (X2.  Therefore,  to  the  lowest  approxi- 
mation, the  interaction  energy  of  two  magnetic  moments  is  pro- 
portional tO  [JL1  fJL2. 

The  spacing  between  the  levels  j  =  I  +  -^  and  j  =  I  —  —  is  small 

compared  with  that  between  electron  levels  with  different  I.  Therefore, 
a  magnetic  interaction  contributes  only  a  small  splitting  of  the 


*  The  angular  momentum  is  determined  by  means  of  its  greatest  projection. 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  331 

electron  level  with  a  given  I  into  two  levels.  This  splitting  is  called 
the  fine  structure  of  the  level. 

We  note  that  such  a  simple  splitting  into  two  levels  takes  place 
for  a  separate  electron  in  a  central  field,  for  example,  for  the  outer 
electron  in  an  alkali-metal  atom. 

Isotopic  (isobaric)  spin.  The  splitting  of  an  atomic  level  into  two 
levels  with  j  =  1  +  1/2  and  j  =  l —  1/2  is  due  to  weak  magnetic  inter- 
actions between  spin  and  orbital  magnetic  moments.  Since  each 
magnetic  moment  contains  c  in  the  denominator  [see  (32.16)],  such 
interaction  is  relativistic  in  nature  and  must  vanish  if  the  electrostatic 
forces  alone  are  taken  into  account.  This  means  that  the  energies 
of  two  states  with  spins  parallel  and  antiparallel  to  the  magnetic 
moment  coincide  if  magnetic  forces  are  completely  neglected. 

An  analogous  situation  exists  in  the  domain  of  nuclear  interaction. 
The  nuclear  forces  which  hold  nuclear  particles  (neutrons  and  protons) 
together  are  not  of  electromagnetic  origin.  At  least  we  have  no  in- 
dications that  both  types  of  force — nuclear  and  electromagnetic — can 
be  deduced  in  a  unique  manner  from  some  first  principle.  As  yet, 
no  experiment  suggests  that  such  derivation  is  at  all  possible.  On 
the  contrary,  there  are  many  facts  proving  that  nuclear  interactions 
are  independent  of  the  electrical  properties  of  particles. 

First,  we  have  the  so-called  mirror  nuclei.  These  are  pairs  of  nuclei 
which  have  all  the  neutrons  interchanged  with  all  the  protons,  and 
vice  versa.  For  example,  H3  consists  of  one  proton  and  two  neutrons, 
and  He8,  of  two  protons  and  one  neutron.  All  the  main  properties 
of  such  nuclei  are  similar  both  qualitatively  and  quantitatively, 
and  the  small  differences  that  still  do  exist  can  readily  be  explained 
by  the  difference  in  charge  and  magnetic  moment  of  the  neutron 
and  proton.  We  can  therefore  say  that  the  substitution,  in  a  nucleus, 
of  all  protons  by  neutrons  and  all  neutrons  by  protons  leaves  the 
nuclear  interactions  invariant,  i.e.,  the  nuclear  interaction  between 
two  protons  and  two  neutrons  is  the  same  if  we  neglect  electro- 
magnetic forces. 

Second,  the  scattering  of  neutrons  and  protons  on  protons  indi- 
cates that  the  elementary  nuclear  interactions  neutron-proton  and 
proton-proton  are  also  the  same.  This  is  a  stronger  statement  than 
the  previous  one,  because  the  interaction  between  two  unlike  particles 
is  also  taken  into  account. 

Comparing  this  situation  with  that  in  the  atom,  we  can  say  that 
there  is  no  splitting  of  nuclear  states  if  the  strongest  interactions 
alone  are  considered;  the  actual  splitting  is  due  to  the  much  weaker 
electromagnetic  interactions. 

Let  us,  therefore,  neglect  for  a  time  the  weakest  interactions. 
We  can  then  consider  the  neutron  and  the  proton  as  two  states  of 
a  single  particle — the  nucleon.  These  states  do  not  differ  in  energy 
like  those  of  an  electron  with  two  different  spin  projections  in  the 


332  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

absence  of  a  magnetic  field.  If  such  a  field  is  switched  off,  both  states  of 
the  electron  fall  together  in  energy ;  if  all  the  electromagnetic  interactions 
are  switched  off,  certain  states  of  nucleon  pairs  fall  together,  too. 

We  have  said  that  the  spin  can  be  considered  as  an  internal  degree 
of  freedom  of  the  electron.  It  is  reasonable  to  say  that  the  electric 
charge  is  the  internal  degree  of  freedom  in  the  nucleon.  Both  degrees 
of  freedom  assume  only  two  values  with  a  dichotomic  variable  cor- 
responding to  them.  It  will  be  shown  that  there  exists  a  far-reaching 
formal  analogy  between  these  degrees  of  freedom.  Let  us  say  that 
the  nucleon  possesses  (besides  its  usual,  nucleon,  spin)  another  "spin" 
variable,  which  defines  its  "charge  state."  Like  mechanical  spin, 
this  variable  assumes  only  two  values.  It  is  called  the  isotopic  spin 
(sometimes,  and  more  consistently,  the  isobaric  spin).  We  shall  say 
that  the  projection  on  some  imaginable  axis  of  isotopic  spin  is  equal 
to  +1/2  which  corresponds  to  a  proton,  the  opposite  projection 
corresponding  to  a  neutron.  Some  years  ago,  the  reverse  convention 
was  used,  but  this  is  immaterial.  Now  let  us  consider  three  nucleon 
pairs :  proton-proton,  neutron-proton,  and  neutron-neutron.  According 
to  what  we  have  already  said,  the  first  pair  corresponds  to  a  resultant 
projection  1  of  the  isotopic  spin,  the  second  pair  to  a  projection  0, 
and  the  third,  to  — 1.  In  the  absence  of  electromagnetic  forces,  none 
of  the  three  projections  split  in  energy. 

But  if  these  states  coincide  in  energy  they  can  be  considered  as 
having  a  resultant  spin  1  and  differing  in  then:  projections  only. 
Spin  angular  momentum  1  can  assume  just  three  projections;  and 
here  we  can  say  that  the  resultant  isotopic  spin  angular  momentum  1 
has  three  different  projections  on  some  imaginable  z-axis.  In  the 
absence  of  electromagnetic  forces,  the  physical  choice  of  such  a 
"z-axis"  is  unimportant.  Note,  for  comparison,  that  if  no  magnetic 
field  is  applied  to  the  electron,  any  direction  in  space  is  preferred 
(for  example,  the  z-axis). 

Changes  in  projections  of  ordinary  spin  can  be  due  simply  to  ro- 
tations of  the  coordinate  frame.  If  no  preferred  directions  in  space 
exist,  such  rotations  are  unlimited.  Now  we  can  consider  different 
isotopic  spin  projection  as  due  to  "rotation"  of  some  frame  also. 
But  this  rotation  is  purely  formal  in  nature  and  has  nothing  in  common 
with  the  rotation  of  geometrical  space,  except  their  mathematical 

expressions.  If  the  isotopic  spin  vector^?  with  components  T*,  Ty,  T* 
is  introduced,  then  its  rotations  are  described  exactly  by  the  same 
formulae  as  (32.12).  The  corresponding  angle  of  rotation  has  no  more 
geometrical  meaning  than  the  axes  which  rotate. 

The  formulae  for  isotopic  spin  rotation  are  deducible  from  the 
dichotomic  nature  of  that  variable  and  from  the  similarity  of  three 
different  two-nucleon  states,  so  there  is  no  reason  to  abolish  the 
vivid  geometrical  terminology  of  "projections"  and  "rotations." 


Sec.  32]  ELECTRON  SPIN  333 

Let  us  now  formulate  the  situation  in  a  quantum-mechanical 
fashion.  For  several  nucleons,  it  is  possible  to  define  their  resulting 
isotopic  spin  operator. 

T=JT£<  (32.18) 

i 

Its  different  components  do  not  commute.  But  its  square,  T  2,  commutes 
with  one  projection,  say  T*,  which  defines  the  resulting  charge  of  the 
given  system.  The  Hamiltonian  of  the  nuclear  interactions  (with 
electromagnetic  interactions  neglected)  commutes  with  both  T2  and 
f  z,  just  like  the  Hamiltonian  for  an  electron  in  a  central  field 
commutes  (to  a  nonrelativistic  approximation)  with  £2  and  [iz.  It 
follows  that  T2  and  T*  exist  in  nuclear  states  with  a  given  energy. 
In  other  words,  nuclear  states  can  be  distinguished  by  their  T2  and 
T*  values.  This  ascribing  of  T2,  T*  to  nuclear  levels  is  approximate, 
like  the  distinguishing  of  atomic  levels  by  n,  I,  k,  the  difference  being 
that  no  account  is  taken  of  the  magnetic  properties  of  spin. 

In  heavy  nuclei,  electrostatic  interactions  are  very  important 
because  they  increase  in  proportion  to  the  square  of  the  atomic 
number.  Nuclear  interactions  increase  linearly  with  the  number  of 
nucleons,  as  the  mass  defect  of  nuclei  does.  So  in  heavy  nuclei  both 
types  of  interaction  are  of  an  equal  order  of  magnitude  and  the  neglect 
of  electrical  interaction  has  no  meaning.  No  definite  isotopic  spin 
values  can  be  attributed  even  approximately  to  the  levels  of  heavy 
nuclei. 

The  isotopic  spin  variables  are  very  important  in  the  classifying 
of  elementary  particles. 

Exercises 

1)  Write  down  the  transformation  of  ax,  ay,  az  for  any  arbitrary  rotation 
in  space  and  prove  that  the  properties  of  the  operators  do  not  change. 

The  general  expression  for  the  transformation  of  vector  component  is 
the  following  (see  Sec.  9): 


*ik  =  cos  (  Z.  x 
where  the  coefficients  a^  satisfy  the  conditions 

f 


where,  according  to  the  summation  convention,  n  runs  from  1  to  3. 

2)  Find  the  eigenvalues  of  the  scalar  product  <jia«  of  two  electrons  with 
rallel  an  r 


parallel  and  antiparallel  spins. 
We  begin  with  the  equation 


a  =  a|  +  af  +  2a1o2  . 

o 


But   aj  =  o|  =  ax  +  ay  -f-  a*=  —   [see   (32.11)];  the  maximum  projection  of 
ax  +  <*2  is  equal  to  zero  for  antiparallel  spins,  and  is  equal  to  unity  for  parallel 


334  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

spins.  From  this,  (c^  -f  a2)2  —  0  in  the  first  case  and  is  equal  to  1-2  =  2  in  the 
second  case.  This  gives 

°-T  3 

o1o2  =  -  ~  -  =  —  T  ( 


_____        ^ 
GI  02  =  -  -  _        (parallel  spins)  . 

_5  -b 

3)  Write  down  the  eigenfunctions  for  a*,  ay,  and  az- 

for  <%  =  -!.  +  =  (J),  for  a,=  --i-,  *-(_}). 

for  Oy  -  -J-,  *  -  (J).  for  «,,  -  _  -J-,  + 

for«.=-i-,*  =  (J),  for«,=  -l,4, 

Thus,  the  eigenfunctions  of  all  three  noncommutative  operators  differ. 

4)  Express  the  scalar  product  jlt  ya  in  terms  of  the  resultant  angular  mo- 
mentum 7,  /j,  and  ?2. 

By  definition  j2  —  j\  ~\-  j\  4-  2y"1</2.  Substituting  here  the  squares  of  the 
angular  momenta,  wo  obtain 

Ji  J2  -  y  0  °*  •*'  1}  "  jl  (jl  +  l)~  J2  (jz  +  1)}* 

Sec.  33.  Many-Electron  Systems 

The  Mendeleyev  periodic  law.  Long  before  the  atom  became  an 
object  of  physical  study  its  properties  were  investigated  in  chemistry. 
And  chemistry  discovered  and  studied  such  properties  of  the  atom 
as  were  utterly  alien  to  prequantum  physics.  In  this  category  belongs, 
first  of  all,  valency  or  the  chemical  affinity  of  atoms.  On  the  basis  of 
a  vast  quantity  of  experimental  material  accumulated  in  chemistry, 
Mendeleyev  constructed  a  generalizing  and  systematic  periodic  law. 
This  was  a  new  law  that  allowed  Mendeleyev  to  predict  the  existence 
of  many  elements,  which  were  discovered  later.  And  what  is  more, 
the  basic  chemical  and  many  physical  properties  of  these  elements 
were  correctly  predicted.  At  the  present  time,  too,  the  Mendeleyev 
law  guides  scientific  investigation  into  the  study  of  the  periodic 
structure  of  nuclear  shells.* 

The  Fauli  principle.  The  wave  equation  for  a  single  particle  is  in 
adequate  for  an  explanation  of  Mendeleyev's  periodic  law.  It  is  ne- 

*  We  have  in  mind  the  quantum-mechanical  theory  of  nuclear  shells, 
and  not  the  rather  widespread  speculative  constructions  which  are  mainly 
based  on  the  arithmetic  relationships  between  the  atomic  numbers  and  atomic 
weights  of  the  elements. 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON   SYSTEMS  335 

cessary  to  introduce  a  new  principle  concerning  many-electron 
systems  —  the  so-called  Pauli  principle.  We  shall  first  of  all  formulate 
it  in  such  a  way  that  it  can  be  conveniently  used  to  investigate  the 
electron  shells  of  an  atom,  to  wit,  an  atom  cannot  have  more  than  one 
electron  with  a  given  group  of  four  quantum  numbers  :  the  principal 
quantum  number  .n,  the  azimuthal  quantum  number  I,  the  magnetic 
quantum  number  ki  and  the  spin  quantum  number  ka.  The  spin 
quantum  number  is  a  measure  of  the  spin  projection  onto  the  same 
axis  onto  which  the  orbital  angular  momentum  is  projected. 

The  Pauli  principle  is  substantiated  by  relativistic  quantum  mechan- 
ics (see  Sec.  38).  Here  we  shall  simply  use  it  as  a  supplementary 
principle  of  quantum  mechanics. 

The  addition  of  angular  momenta  of  two  electrons  with  identical  n 
and  /.  We  shall  first  of  all  show  how  the  Pauli  principle  is  applied  in 
adding  the  angular  momenta  of  two  electrons  for  which  the  principal 
and  azimuthal  quantum  numbers  are  the  same.  The  accepted  practice 
is  to  say  that  these  electrons  belong  to  the  same  shell.  Usually  (though 
not  always)  electrons  in  different  shells  possess  quite  different  ener- 
gies —  a  fact  which  justifies  the  classification  by  shells. 

Let  us  take  the  simplest  case  when  n  =  \.  Then,  in  accordance  with 
the  definition  of  n  (31.33),  1  =  0.  But,  for  I  equal  to  zero,  the  magnetic 
quantum  number  ki  is  also  equal  to  zero.  Hence,  three  quantum 
numbers  are  the  same  for  the  electrons  and,  according  to  the  Pauli 
principle,  the  fourth  number  ka  must  differ.  However,  ka  can  only 

have  two  values,  +  y  and  —  y  ,  and  each  of  its  values  can  only  have 

one  electron  for  given  n,  I,  and  &/.  Thus,  an  atom  can  have  only  two 
electrons  with  n~l.  Their  spins  are  antiparallel  and  therefore  the 
resultant  spin  S  is  equal  to  zero.  The  resultant  orbital  angular  momen- 
tum L  is  also  equal  to  zero. 

Let  us  now  take  two  electrons  in  the  ^p-state,  i.e.,  with  I  =  I  and  with 
the  same  principal  quantum  numbers.  Either  the  magnetic  or  the  spin 
quantum  numbers,  or  both,  must  differ.  The  ^-electron  can  be  in  six 
states,  which  we  list  writing  the  magnetic  quantum  number  firsthand 
the  spin  projection  second: 


It  follows  that  two  electrons  can  occupy  any  two  different  states  of 
the  six.  As  is  known,  the  number  of  combinations  of  six  things,  two 

6x5 
at  a  time,  is  equal  to  Cl=  —  ^  —  =  15-  These  fifteen  states  differ  by 

the  total  orbital  angular  momentum  L  and  the  total  spin  8,  as  well  as 
by  their  projections.  The  latter  depend  upon  the  choice  of  coordinate 
axes  and  will  interest  us  only  insofar  as  they  characterize  the  relative 
directions  of  L  and  S. 


336  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

We  shall  first  of  all  find  those  states  which  correspond  to  the  greatest 
projections  of  L  and  S,  because  they  determine  the  possible  eigen- 
values of  L  and  S.  In  any  case,  of  the  fifteen  states  only  those  must  be 
taken,  for  which  the  total  spin  projections  and  orbital  angular  mo- 
mentum are  non-negative,  since  it  is  obvious  that  negative  projections 
cannot  be  greatest  in  relative  value.  The  states  with  positive  pro- 
jections number  eight  out  of  fifteen,  and  from  these  eight  we  take 
only  those  which  possess  the  greatest  projections.  We  rewrite  all  eight 
states  : 

AD:  2,  0;  BD:  1,  0;  CD:  0,  0;  AB:  1,  1]  AC:  0,  1;  AE:  1,  0;  BE:  0,  0; 
AF:  0,  0. 

The  state  with  maximum  orbital  angular-momentum  projection  is 
AD.  Hence,  a  state  exists  for  which  the  orbital  angular  momentum  is 
equal  to  two  and  the  spin  angular  momentum  is  zero  (here,  and  in 
future,  the  angular  momentum  is  characterized  by  the  greatest  pro- 
jection). The  indicated  state  also  yields  projections  1,  0  and  0,  0. 
Such  states  are,  for  example,  the  BD  and  CD  states;  therefore  they 
need  not  be  considered,  since  they  do  not  define  the  vector  sum.  The 
AB  state  has  the  maximum  spin  angular  momentum.  It  follows  that 
a  state  exists  for  which  the  orbital  and  spin  angular  momenta  are 
equal  to  unity.  Their  projection  can  be  1,  0;  0,  1;  and  0,  0.  These  are 
AC,  AE,  and  BE,  which,  like  BD  and  CD,  no  longer  interest  us.  There 
remains  one  more  state  with  projections  0,  0. 
Thus,  only  three  states  are  possible: 


Composition  of  angular  momenta  for  three  electrons  with  identical 
n  and  /.  For  three  ^-electrons  we  obtain  the  following  seven  states 
with  positive  projections: 

,±;  ACE:0,±-  ;  ABD:2,±  ;  ABE:  1,|  ; 


The  maximum  spin  projection  is  3/2  for  a  zero  orbital  angular-mo- 
mentum projection.  The  maximum  orbital  angular-momentum  pro- 

jection is  2  with  a  spin  projection  -^  .  These  two  states,  together  with 
their  projections,  are  listed  in  order  from  ABC  to  ABF.  ACD  and 
A  BE  remain,  to  which  there  correspond  L  —  1  and  S  —  -^  .  In  all,  we 
have  L  =  Q,  S  =  3/2;  L  =  2,  S  =  ~]  L  =  l,  8  =  ~. 

Normal  coupling.  States  with  different  values  of  the  total  orbital 
and  spin  angular  momenta  L  and  S,  and  with  the  same  principal 


Sec.  33]  MANV-KLECTKON    SYSTEMS  337 

quantum  numbers  for  the  electrons,  differ  in  energy.  This  difference 
occurs  as  a  result  of  the  electrostatic,  and  not  magnetic,  interaction 
between  electrons.  In  order  to  explain  why  the  resultant  orbital  angu- 
lar momentum  affects  the  interaction  energy,  we  examine  two  ^-elec- 
trons. The  sum  of  their  orbital  angular  momenta  can  yield  two,  unity 
or  zero.  If  two  is  obtained,  then  the  angular  dependence  for  the  wave 
functions  of  both  electrons  is  the  same  (not  only  do  the  azimuthal 
quantum  numbers  coincide,  but  also  the  magnetic  quantum  numbers, 
that  is  why  at  least  the  spin  projections  must  differ).  We  shall  call  the 
wave  functions  of  both  electrons  d^,  t  (i\)  and  fyl9  x  (r2),  where  rx  and  r2 
are  the  radius  vectors  of  both  electrons  and  the  indices  refer  to  the 
quantum  numbers  I  and  kv 

The  interaction  energy  between  electrons  is  approximately 


because  e  \  fyl9  x  (rx)!2  and  e  |d/t,  l  (r2)|2  represent  the  densities  of  the 
charge  distribution.  The  approximation  consists  in  the  fact  that  the 
effect  of  the  interaction  on  the  wave  functions  and  the  so-called 
"exchange"  [see  (33.32)]  has  not  been  taken  into  account. 

If  the  resultant  moment  is  unity,  we  correspondingly  obtain  the 
other  estimation: 


Here  the  magnetic  quantum  numbers  are  equal  to  zero  or 
unity. 

This  integral  is  clearly  different  from  the  previous  one.  Thus,  there 
appears  to  be  interaction  between  the  orbital  angular  momenta  when 
they  are  to  form  the  total  angular  momentum;  this  interaction  does 
not  involve  c2  in  the  denominator,  i.e.,  it  is  electrostatic  in 
character. 

In  multi-electron  atoms,  Pauli's  principle  imposes  definite  conditions 
on  the  choice  of  spatial  wave  functions  for  given  spins.  As  an  example, 
let  us  consider  the  state  with  spin  3/2,  which,  as  was  just  established, 
is  possible  in  a  system  with  three  ^-electrons.  In  accordance  with  the 
Pauli  principle,  three  different  spatial  wave  functions  for  the  separate 
electrons  having  ki  =  1,  0  and  — 1  correspond  to  this  state.  The  corre- 
sponding electron  densities  coincide  in  space  less  than,  for  example, 
in  a  state  with  magnetic  quantum  numbers  1,  1,  0,  to  which,  according 

to  the  Pauli  principle,  there  must  correspond  spin  projections  -^  , —  ^  , 

-0-  in  order  that  all  three  pairs  of  &/,  ka  should  be  different.  But  the  less 

& 

the  electron  wave  functions  coincide  in  space,  the  less  the  Coulomb 
repulsion  energy  between  the  electrons,  because  the  mean  distance 
between  like  charges  is  greater.  For  this  reason,  the  state  to  which  the 

22  -  0060 


338  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Pauli  principle  assigns  the  greatest  possible  spin  possesses  the  least 
repulsion  energy. 

There  are  three  ^-electrons  in  the  ground  state  of  nitrogen.  As  was 
just  indicated,  the  state  with  the  least  energy  occurs  when  all  three 
spins  are  parallel.  The  next  state,  for  which  the  orbital  angular  mo- 
mentum is  equal  to  2  and  the  'spin  is  equal  to  - ,  lies  approximately 
2.2  ev  higher,  while  the  state  with  orbital  angular  momentum  1  and 
spin  T>  lies  3.8  ev  higher. 

We  can  explain  why  a  lesser  energy  corresponds  to  a  greater  result- 
ant orbital  angular  momentum.  Wave  functions,  for  which  the 
orbital  angular-momentum  projections  differ  only  in  sign,  are  closer 
to  each  other  than  functions  for  which  the  angular-momentum  pro- 
jections differ  in  absolute  value.  But  those  functions  which  correspond 
to  a  closer  spatial  electron  density  distribution  lead  to  a  larger  repul- 
sion energy,  while  angular  momenta  in  opposite  directions,  when 
summed,  yield  a  lesser  resultant  angular  momentum  than  the  angular 
momenta  whose  projections  differ  in  magnitude  also.  Thus,  the  state 
with  the  greatest  spin  possesses  the  least  energy  and,  for  a  given  spin, 
it  is  the  state  with  the  greatest  orbital  angular  momentum  that  has 
the  least  energy  (Hund's  first  rule). 

This  is  the  way  the  orbital  and  spin  angular  momenta  are  com- 
bined. In  calculating  the  electrostatic  energy  only,  the  state  of  the 
atom  is  defined  by  the  absolute  values  of  L  and  S.  But  a  magnetic 
interaction  takes  place  between  the  resultant  orbital  angular  mo- 
mentum and  the  resultant  spin  angular  momentum  of  a  system  of 
electrons,  analogous  to  that  of  a  separate  electron  (see  Sec.  32).  To  a 
first  approximation,  this  interaction  is  described  by  the  scalar  product 
A\LL  |x*,  where  JJLL  and  JJL,  are  the  magnetic  moments  for  the  orbital 
and  spin  motion  of  the  system,  and  A  is  a  factor  of  proportion- 
ality. 

The  scalar  product  of  two  angular  momenta  assumes  as  many 
values  as  are  possessed  by  the  resultant  angular  momentum  for  a 
given  absolute  value  of  the  component  angular  momenta  (see  exercise 
4,  Sec.  32).  This  is  clearly  shown  with  the  aid  of  a  so-called  vector 
model:  a  triangle  is  constructed  on  the  vectors  L,  S  and  J  =  L+S. 
In  accordance  with  the  law  of  composition  of  angular  momenta 
(30.30),  the  side  J  can  equal  L  +  S,  L  +  S — 1,  .  .  .,  |  L— S  \  .  The 
energy  level  of  an  atom  with  given  values  of  L  and  8  is  split  into  as 
many  fine  structure  levels  as  can  be  assumed  by  J,  i.e.,  2  8  + 1  levels 
if  S  is  less  than  L,  and  2  L  + 1  levels  if  L  is  less  than  S. 

The  system  of  levels  described  here  occurs  with  the  so-called  Russel- 
Saunders  normal  coupling  (of  orbital  and  spin  angular  momenta): 
the  energy  states  with  different  L  and  8  differ  considerably  more  than 
the  energy  states  with  given  L  and  8  but  different  J.  The  group  of 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON   SYSTEMS  339 

energy  levels  differing  only  in  total  angular  momentum  J  is  termed  a 
multiplet. 

In  heavy  elements,  where  the  spin-orbital  interaction  for  separate 
electrons  is  great,  the  spin  of  each  electron  in  a  shell  is  combined  with 
its  orbital  angular  momentum  to  form  a  resultant  angular  momentum 
j  [see  (32.15)];  only  then  do  the  angular  momenta  j  of  separate  elec- 
trons combine.  This  may  be  accounted  for  by  the  fact  that,  the 
relativistic  effect  of  magnetic-moment  interactions  is  not  small  com- 
pared with  the  energy  of  electrostatic  repulsion  between  electrons  in 
the  inner  regions  of  the  atoms  of  heavy  elements,  where  the  electron 
velocity  is  close  to  the  velocity  of  light.  The  type  of  coupling  which 
occurs  when  the  j  of  separate  electrons  are  added,  is  termed  j-j 
coupling,  j-j  coupling  also  occurs  between  nuclear  particles  as  a 
result  of  the  large  spin-orbital  interaction  characteristic  of  nuclear 
forces. 

The  spcctroscopic  notation  for  levels.  In  general  form,  the  spectro- 
scopic  notation  for  the  resultant  state  of  an  atom  is  written  thus  : 

2S  +  l]jg,u  t 

The  main  symbol  is  L,  i.e.,  the  letters  S,  P,  Z),  F,  etc.,  depending 
upon  what  L  is  equal  to:  0,  1,  2,  3,  ....  As  a  left  superscript  we  put 
2  S  +  1.  As  a  right  subscript  we  put  J,  i.e.,  the  vector  sum  of  L  and 
S  from  the  number  of  the  fine-structure  components.  Finally,  the 
right  superscripts  denote  an  odd  (u)  or  even  (g)  state,  respec- 
tively. 

For  example,  the  ground  state  of  a  nitrogen  atom  has  L  =  0,  $  =  3/2 
and  is  formed  by  three  ^-electrons.  Hence,  its  spectroscopic  designation 
is  4$?/8  because  the  total  angular  momentum  can  only  equal  the 
spin  angular  momentum  (L  =  0),  and  JT*Z  =  3  is  an  odd  number. 

The  notations  for  the  next  two  states  of  nitrogen  are 

2D"  and  2P", 

or,  if  the  multiplet  splitting  is  taken  into  account,  then 

or  2D»   and  2Pj    or 


depending  upon  the  resultant  angular  momentum  J. 

If  the  ground  state  of  the  atom  has  L  and  S  not  equal  to  zero,  the 
resultant  angular  momentum  is  determined  by  Hund's  second  (empir- 
ical) rule  :  when  there  are  less  than  half  the  possible  number  of  elec- 
trons in  a  shell,  the  least  energy  corresponds  to  a  multiplet  level  for 
which  J=\L  —  S  |,  and  to  that  of  J  =  L  +  S  when  there  is  more 
than  half  the  possible  number.  Since  the  electron  angular-momentum 
Z  can  have  21  +  1  projections,  and  there  are  two  values  ka  for  each 

22' 


340  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

projection  &/,  then  there  can  be  in  all  2  (2  l  +  l)  electrons  in  a  shell 
with  given  values  of  I  and  n.  The  total  number  of  electrons  in  an 
atom  with  a  given  principal  quantum  number  n  is 

H-l 

l)~~=2n*.  (33.1) 


The  electron  configuration  corresponding  to  the  least  energy  occurs 
in  the  ground  state.  It  is  determined  by  Hund's  first  and  second 
rules. 

The  dependence  of  energy  on  the  azimuthal  quantum  number. 

Before  we  can  go  over  to  a  description  of  the  Mendeleyev  periodic 
system  we  have  to  remark  on  the  dependence  of  the  energy  of  an  elec- 
tron on  the  azimuthal  quantum  number.  The  energy  of  an  electron 
in  all  atoms,  except  the  hydrogen  atom,  depends  upon  /  as  well  as 
upon  n.  For  large  /  the  electron  is  situated  comparatively  far  away  from 
the  nucleus;  in  other  words,  it  is  more  weakly  bound  to  the  nucleus 
than  for  small  L  For  a  given  n,  the  energy  of  an  electron  is  greater,  the 
larger  I.  When  the  field  greatly  differs  from  a  Coulomb  field,  the  de- 
pendence of  energy  upon  I  is  so  strong  that  an  increase  in  the  princi- 
pal quantum  number  n,  with  a  simultaneous  decrease  in  I,  leads  to  a 
smaller  energy  increase  than  the  increase  of  I  for  a  given  n.  In  other 
words,  the  state  with  quantum  numbers  n  +  l,  0  can  have  a  lower 
energy  than  the  state  with  quantum  numbers  n,  I.  This  will  become 
clear  in  the  later  examples. 

Filling  the  first  shells.  As  was  mentioned,  the  shell  with  n  =  l  is 
filled  by  two  electrons  in  the  Is-state  (the  1  in  front  denotes  the  quan- 
tity n).  Hydrogen  has  one  electron  in  this  shell  and  helium  has  two. 
The  helium  shell  is  completely  filled  and  has  a  1S$  state.  The  electron 
configuration  for  the  ground  state  of  a  helium  atom  is  so  stable  that 
if  any  other  atom  approaches  close  to  it  the  total  energy  can  only 
increase,  so  that  repulsion  forces  are  produced.  Helium  is  completely 
inert  chemically.  The  forces  between  helium  atoms  are  small  as  a 
result  of  the  symmetry  and  stability  of  their  electron  shells.  Therefore, 
helium  gas  is  liquified  at  an  extremely  low  temperature.* 

After  helium,  the  shell  structure  with  n  =  2  begins.  The  first  electron 
of  this  shell,  i.e.,  a  2  ^-electron,  appears  in  lithium.  The  two  inner 
Is-electrons  occurring  in  the  helium  configuration  strongly  screen 
the  nuclear  charge  and,  consequently,  the  outer  electron  is  weakly 


*  The  condensation  of  helium  into  a  liquid  at  low  temperatures  is  due 
to  the  so-called  Van  der  Waals  forces,  which  arise  out  of  the  mutual  electro- 
static polarization  of  approaching  atoms.  These  forces  act  at  larger  distances 
than  the  forces  of  chemical  affinity,  and  are  very  small  compared  with  them. 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON   SYSTEMS  341 

bound.  Such  is  the  alkali-metal  electron  configuration  in  the  case 
of  lithium,  and  analogous  electron  configurations  subsequently  result 
each  time  (Na,  K,  Rb,  Cs)  from  the  addition  of  an  ^-electron  to  a  nucleus 
surrounded  by  a  noble-gas  electronic  cloud.  The  next  2  ^-electron 
has  an  energy  which  is  comparatively  close  to  the  energy  of  a 
2  ^-electron :  the  energy  of  the  electron  is  still  weakly  dependent  on  the 
azimuthal  quantum  number  since  the  field  is  approximately  Coulomb. 
A  large  energy  is  needed  for  an  electron  to  go  from  a  1  s-shell  to  a 
2  5-  or  a  2  p-shell,  while  a  small  energy  is  needed  for  the  transition 
from  a  2  s-  to  a  2  ^-shell.  For  this  reason,  the  beryllium  electronic 
configuration,  having  two  2  s-electroiis,  is  not  very  stable  with  respect 
to  an  electron  transition  to  the  2  p-shell.  In  other  words,  filling  the 
2  s-shell  does  not  give  the  electron  configuration  of  a  noble  gas.  Indeed, 
as  we  know,  beryllium  is  a  metal. 

After  beryllium,  the  2  p-shell  fills  up,  and  is  completely  filled  for  the 
noble  gas  neon.  Neon  follows  fluorine,  which  requires  one  electron  for 
the  shell  to  be  filled.  The  energy  required  for  an  electron  to  be  added 
to  the  fluorine  2  p-shell,  to  fill  the  shell  of  neon,  is  large.  This  explains 
the  chemical  activity  of  fluorine  and  the  other  halogens,  which  are 
similarly  situated  with  respect  to  the  noble  gases. 

There  can  be  eight  electrons  in  a  shell  for  which  n  =  2.  This  is  the 
first  group  of  the  Mendeleyev  system.  The  shell  with  n  =  3  is  then 
filled,  though  initially  only  the  first  two  subshclls :  3  s  and  3  p.  The 
elements  of  the  second  group  have  an  outer  electron-shell  structure 
similar  to  the  elements  of  the  first  group.  The  chemical  properties  of 
atoms  are  basically  determined  by  the  outer  shells.  This  explains  the 
similarity  of  chemical  properties,  on  the  basis  of  which  Mendeleyev 
formulated  his  law.  Argon  has  a  filled  shell,  i.e.,  still  another  group 
of  eight  elements  is  completed.  The  noble-gas  configuration  is  obtained 
for  argon  because  the  3  ^-state,  on  the  one  hand,  and  the  3  d  and  4  s 
states,  on  the  other  hand,  differ  considerably  in  energy. 

By  considering  the  possible  states  of  shells  which ,  to  be  filled,  lack 
less  than  half  the  possible  number  of  electrons,  we  can  consider  that 
unfilled  states  behave  like  electrons.  For  example,  if  there  are  two  of 
the  six  electrons  wanting  in  a  2  p-shell,  then  we  can  combine  the 
states  of  the  two  "holes,"  similar  to  the  way  that  the  states  of  two 
2  p-electrons  were  combined  at  the  beginning  of  this  section.  In  doing 
so,  correct  results  are  always  obtained,  provided  that  Hund's  second 
rule  is  used  in  finding  the  total  angular  momentum  J  of  the  ground 
state,  i.e.,  that  we  take  J  =  L  +  S.  It  is  easy  to  see  that  four  electrons 
in  the  shell  are  equivalent  to  two  holes  by  applying  the  Pauli  principle 
first  to  an  electron  and  then  to  a  "hole,"  (see  exercise  2). 

Let  us  now  give,  in  one  table,  the  scheme  for  building  up  the  first 
eighteen  places  in  the  periodic  system  of  elements ;  this  table  shows 
the  number  of  electrons  having  given  quantum  numbers. 


342 


QUANTUM   MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


Element 

n  =  1, 
J  -  0 

n  =  2, 
/  -0 

n  =2, 
/  =  1 

n  =  3, 
J  =  0 

n  =  3, 
I  =  1 

Ground 
state 

H 

1 

•8fh 

He 

2 

*so 

Li 

2 

1 

*S!/t 

Bo 

2 

2 

ls$ 

B 

2 

2 

1 

n 

C 

2 

2 

0 

0 

N    *%« 

2 

2 

3 

4^M/a 

() 

2 

2 

4 

3pf 

F 

2 

2 

5 

2JP"/I 

No 

2 

2 

6 

ls%* 

Na 

2 

2 

6 

1 

2sf/t 

Mg 

2 

2 

(5 

2 

ls{ 

Al 

2 

2 

6 

2 

1 

2jP"/a 

Si 

2 

2 

6 

2 

2 

3jpo 

P 

2 

2 

6 

2 

3 

*S"lt 

S 

2 

2 

f» 

2 

4 

*P% 

C'l 

2 

o 

0 

2 

5 

2p" 

/a 

AT 

2 

2 

(i 

2 

(3 

*^0 

The  filling  order  after  the  3/i-shell.  After  argon,  the  4s-shell  begins 
to  fill  instead  of  the  3rf-shell.  The  new  group  begins  with  the  alkali 
metal,  potassium.  The  sum  n  +  l  is  the  same  for  the  3p-  and  46l-shells 
and  is  equal  to  4,  while  it  is  already  greater  by  unity  in  the  3d-shell. 
The  4^}-shell  is  filled  after  the  3rf-shell,  with  the  same  value  of  the 
sum  n  +Z  =  5,  and  then  the  5s-shell.  It  is  seen  that  this  rule  is  observed 
later  on,  too;  the  filling  of  the  shells  with  the  same  sum  n-\-l 
proceeds  in  order  of  increasing  ?i.  But  there  are  certain  deviations 
from  this  rule  during  the  filling  of  the  d-  and  /-shells. 

In  the  shells  with  n=l,  2,  3,  there  are  altogether  2.12  +  2.22  + 
+  2.32  =  2  +  8  +  18  =  28  electrons.  There  are  a  further  eight  electrons 
in  the  4s-  and  4p-states,  and  another  two  electrons  in  the  5s-state. 
The  55-state  is  followed  by  electrons  with  n  +  Z  — 6,  where  we  begin 
with  the  least  n,  i.e.,  witli  4d.  There  are  2  (4  +  1)  —10  more  of  these 
electrons.  The  4d-electrons  are  followed  by  5£>-electrons,  of  which 
there  are  six,  and  then  by  the  same  simple  rule  we  get  the  6s-state. 

Hare-earth  elements.  The  next  value  of  n  +  l  =  7,  the  least  being 
7i  =  4.  Hence,  beginning  with  the  57th  place  (in  actuality,  with  the 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON    SYSTEMS  343 

58th  place)  the  4/-shell  can  begin  to  fill  acquiring  at  once  two  4/- 
electrons.  This  shell  is  already  inside  the  atom  as  a  result  of  the 
form  of  the  potential  distribution  within  the  atom.  The  screening 
of  the  nuclear  charge  by  atomic  electrons  leads,  at  large  distances 

away  from  the  nucleus,  to  the  potential  decreasing  like  -.-  instead 

1  r 

of  —  (see  Sec.  44).  If  we  combine  the  potential  energy  of  an  electron, 

calculated  with  allowance  for  screening  with  the  centrifugal  energy, 
it  turns  out  that  the  d-  and  /-states  possess  a  minimum  resultant 
effective  potential  energy  deep  inside  the  atom  (see  Sec.  5,  footnote 
to  p.  45).  Indeed,  the  centrifugal  energy  is  greater  than  the  potential 
energy  both  close  to  the  nucleus  (with  allowance  made  for  screening) 
as  well  as  far  away  from  the  nucleus.  Therefore,  the  effective  poten- 
tial energy  UM  is  positive  for  large  r  as  well  as  for  small  r.  In  other 
words,  for  the  d-  and  /-states,  the  UM  curve  goes  higher  for  large  r 
than  for  the  s-  and  ^-states,  and  it  turns  out  that  the  effective  poten- 
tial well  for  d-  and  /-electrons  is  situated  closer  to  the  nucleus  than 
to  the  boundaries  of  the  s-  and  p-electron  shells.  Thus,  the  d-  and 
/-shells  are,  as  it  were,  filled  inside  the  atom.  But  the  chemical  prop- 
erties of  atoms  depend  mainly  upon  the  outer  electrons  which, 
in  filling  the  4/-shell,  change  very  little.  This  is  how  the  group  of 
2  (2*3  +  1)  =14  chemically  similar  elements,  termed  rare-earth 
elements,  originates. 

It  should  be  pointed  out  that  the  d-  and  /-shells  arc  not  filled 
successively  as  a  result  of  "competition"  with  outer  shells  :  for  example, 
there  are  throe  d-electroiis  and  two  ^-electrons  in  F23,  five  rf-electroiis 
and  one  s-electron  in  the  next  element  O24,  while  Mn25  also  has  five 
d-olectrons  but  two  .^-electrons. 

The  statistical  theory  of  the  atom,  which  will  be  set  out  in  Sec.  44, 
permits  us,  in  rough  outline,  to  find  the  potential  distribution  inside 
an  atom.  It  becomes  possible,  from  this  distribution,  to  predict 
rather  accurately  the  places  in.  the  periodic  system  where  elements 
with  I  —  2  and  3  appear. 

The  5  /-shell  fills  up  (beginning  with  thorium)  in  a  whole  group 
of  elements  similar  to  the  rare  earths.  A  large  part  of  this  group 
consists  of  the  artificially  produced  transuranium  elements. 

The  wave  equation  of  a  two-electron  system.  We  shall  now  formulate 
Pauli's  principle  using  wave  functions.  The  simplest  way  to  do  this 
is  to  consider  a  two-electron  system.  The  wave  equation  for  two 
electrons  may  be  written  thus: 


=    -  ~a  AI-  ¥     A*  =  U  <fi'  r*>  *  =  **  •  (33-2) 

Here  AJ  and  A2  are  the  Laplacian  operators  with  respect  to  variables 
of  the  first  and  second  electrons,  U(rly  r2)  is  the  potential  energy 


344  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [P&Ft    III 

of  their  interaction  with  the  external  field  and  with  each  other. 
For  example,  in  a  helium  atom 

9/>2  0/>2  ,,2 

U  (rl5  r.)  -  -  4'-  -  -  -7-  +  -      '-—  .  (33.3) 

rl  r2  I  Fl  ~  F2  I 

The  wave  function  depends  upon  the  spatial  and  spin  variables 
of  both  particles: 

fc-OO-^ir^).  (33.4) 

The  interaction  of  spin  magnetic  moment  with  orbital  motion 
is  weak.  Therefore,  to  a  first  approximation,  the  spin-orbital  inter- 
action can  be  neglected  in  the  potential  energy  operator.  This  cor- 
responds to  U  (FH  r2)  in  equation  (33.3).  Tf  the  effect  of  spin  motion 
upon  orbital  motion  is  small  then  the  probability  of  a  certain  value 
of  spin  and  coordinate  is  equal  to  the  product  of  the  probabilities 
of  both  values,  and  the  probability  amplitude  <£  also  divides  into 
a  product  of  amplitudes 


(D  (rl5  al  ;  r2,  a2)  -  T  (r1?  r2)  x  (a,,  cr2).  (33.5) 

The  probability  amplitude  of  orbital  motion  satisfies  equation 
(33.2),  provided  it  does  not  involve  the  spin  operator.  But  even 
when  the  system  is  placed  in  an  external  homogeneous  magnetic 
field  II,  the  following  operator  is  added  to  fjfr 


where  it  is  taken  that  the  z-axis  coincides  with  the  direction  of  the 
field  (the  minus  sign  is  replaced  by  a  plus  sign  because  the  electronic 
charge  is  negative).  The  action  of  the  operator  Szl  -\-  SZ2  on  the 
spin  function  simply  gives  the  total  spin  projection  of  the  system. 
For  this  reason,  in  the  presence  of  an  external  homogeneous  magnetic 
field,  UmdK  is  replaced  by  a  number  which  is  added  to  the  total  energy 
of  the  system. 

The  symmetry  of  the  &  operator  with  respect  to  particle  inter- 
change. When  examining  the  jfe  operator  in  (33.2)  we  see  that  it  is 
completely  symmetrical  with  respect  to  a  coordinate  interchange 
for  both  particles,  i.e.,  it  does  not  change  its  form  if  the  first  electron 
is  called  the  second,  and  the  second  electron  the  first: 

JT  (r1?  ^  ;  r2,  o2)  -  3?  (ra,  a2  ;  r^  aj.  (33.7) 

But  equation  (33.2)  is  linear.  Therefore,  if  the  form  does  not  change 
due  to  operation  (33.7),  then  the  wave  function  can  only  be  multiplied 
by  some  constant  number  P: 

$  (rlf  aj;  P8,  cr8)  -  PO  (r8J  a2;  rlf  at).  (33.8) 


SeC.  33]  MANY-KLKCTRON    SYSTEMS  345 

Because  rx,  G!  and  r2,  <r2  are  involved  in  the  saino  way  in  all  the 
equations,  we  can  interchange  them  in  (33.8)  obtaining 

O  (r2,  <j2;  r1?  aj  -  PO  (rx,  cv,  r2,  cr2).  (33.9) 

Substituting  (33.9)  in  (33.8),  we  shall  have 


or 

pa=l,     P=±l.  (33.10) 

In  this  comparatively  simple  case,  when  there  are  only  two  par- 
ticles, the  transformation  is  similar  to  the  symmetry  transformation 
for  a  wave  function  under  reflection  [see  (31.38)]. 

The   commutative   operator   for   coordinates    and   spin   variables. 

We   can  define   a   coordinate   commutative   operator   for   electrons 
PT  such  that 

r1).  (33.11) 


If  the  wave  equation  is  symmetrical  with  respect  to  interchange 
of  rx  and  r2  (without  interchanging  the  spin  variables  vl  and  <r2) 
then,  by  repeating  the  foregoing  argument,  we  see  that  the  eigen- 
values of  Pr  for  two  electrons  are  equal  to  ±  1. 

An  analogous  operator  is  also  defined  for  spin 


where  the  eigenvalues  of  Pa  are  likewise  equal  to   -h  1. 

We  denote  the  set  of  orbital  quantum  numbers  of  the  first  electron 
by  the  letter  n±  (in  place  of  nl9  l±,  k/t),  and  those  of  the  second  elec- 
tron by  the  letter  n2.  Then  the  orbital  wave  function  XF  is  written  in 
more  detail  as 


It  follows  from  requirement  (33.10)  that 

PrxF  (14,  rx  ;  na,  ra)  -  T  (nl9  r2  ;  n2,  rx)  -  ±  T  (nl9  rx  ;  na,  ra)  .  (33.13) 


The  function  in  (33.13)  with  an  upper  sign  is  termed  symmetric; 
with  a  lower  sign,  antisymmetric. 

The  wave  function  of  a  two-electron  system.  Introducing,  in  ad- 
dition, the  spin  quantum  numbers  kai  and  &02,  which  determine 
the  form  of  the  spin  wave  functions  (see  exercise  3,  Sec.  32),  we  write 
the  total  wave  function  of  a  two-electron  system  as 


340  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   111 

The  total  permutation  of  spin  and  spatial  coordinates  in  this 
function  occurs  as  a  result  of  the  action  of  the  P  operator,  which  is 

P=PrPa.  (33.14) 

Operating  with  (33.14)  on  the  function  O,  we  have 
PO  (WJL,  fc0l,  T19  d, ;  n2,  k<,2,  ra>  a2)  --  O  (wx,  A0l,  r2,  cr2:  w2,  fr0a,  rl5  orj  .  (33.15) 

According  to  (33.10)  this  function  is  also  either  symmetric  or 
antisymmetric.  But  it  can  now  be  seen  immediately  that  only  the 
antisymmetric  function  satisfies  the  Pauli  principle.  Indeed,  let 
the  states  of  both  electrons  be  identical,  i.e.,  n^^n^  kai  —  kat.  Then, 
if  the  function  O  is  antisymmetric,  we  obtain 

PcD  (Wl,  40l>  rx,  (jj;  nv  fc0l,  r2,  d2)  -=  O  (nl9  fc0l,  ra»  ^i  ?h>  ^  r^  aL)  -= 

=  —  O  (nl9  kai9  rl5  <7i ;  nx,  fc0l,  ra,  cr2)  — 
=^  O  (nl5  fe0l,  r1?  ^ ;  nl9  kai,  r2,  cr2) . 

(33.16) 

"By  definition,  the  operator  P  interchanges  only  the  variables  r 
and  or,  and  by  no  means  the  quantum  numbers  ?i,  ka.  The  first 
equation  of  (33.16)  denotes  the  result  of  a  P  operation,  the  second 
takes  into  account  the  antisymmetry  of  the  wave  function,  while 
the  third  is  obtained  from  the  first  by  permutation  of  all  four 
arguments  relating  to  the  electrons.  The  possibility  of  such  a  per- 
mutation for  any  function  is  obvious,  since  it  does  not  matter  which 
particle  is  considered  first  and  which  second  when  writing  down 
the  wave  function;  the  interchange  of  the  four  values  nx,  &0l,  rl  c^ 
and  nt,  k0l,  r2,  <72  m  tnc  ^ast  equality  of  (33.16)  simply  does  not 
denote  anything:  it  is  immaterial  which  arguments  are  written 
first — those  relating  to  the  first  electron,  i.e.,  n^  k0^  rt,  <rt,  or  those 
relating  to  the  second  electron  w±,  k0l,  r2,  o-2.  Hence,  the  function 
*  (MI*  ^<v  ri»  ai>  ni*  ^i»  r2>  ^2)  is  equal  to  itself  with  the  sign  reversed, 
i.e.,  it  becomes  zero  identically. 

This  property  is  possessed  only  by  an  antisymmetric  function 
and  not  by  a  symmetric  function ;  the  latter  would  become  identically 
equal  to  itself.  But  if  the  antisymmetric  wave  function  of  two  elec- 
trons occurring  in  identical  states  is  identically  equal  to  zero,  the 
probability  amplitude  of  this  state  of  a  system  of  two  electrons 
is  equal  to  zero  for  any  values  of  the  variables  rt,  r2,  c^,  a2.  Only 
an  antisymmetric  function  is  compatible  with  the  Pauli  principle. 

The  same  applies  to  the  wave  function  for  a  many-electron  system : 
it  is  antisymmetric  with  respect  to  a  simultaneous  permutation  of 
spatial  and  spin  variables  for  any  electron  pair.  This  is  the  generalized 
formulation  of  the  Pauli  principle. 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON   SYSTEMS  347 

Particles  with  half-integral  spin.  Experiment  shows  that  all  ele- 
mentary particles  with  half -integral  spin  obey  the  Pauli  principle: 
protons,  neutrons,  electrons,  and  positrons.  Complex  particles, 
consisting  of  an  even  number  of  elementary  particles  with  half-integral 
spin,  have  a  symmetric  wave  function  because,  for  a  complete  inter- 
change of  all  variables  relating  to  such  a  complex  particle,  we  must 
make  an  even  number  of  permutations  of  the  elementary  particle 
variables  it  consists  of.  But  by  changing  the  sign  an  even  number 
of  times  we  do  not  change  it  at  all.  For  this  reason,  nuclei  with  even 
atomic  weights  (for  example,  D2,  He4,  N14,  O16,  etc.)  and,  therefore, 
having  symmetric  wave  functions  arc  not  subject  as  units  to  the 
Pauli  principle,  while  He3,  Li7,  etc.,  have  an  antisymmetric  wave 
function,  that  is  to  say,  they  are  subject  to  the  Pauli  principle. 

Elementary  particles  not  subject  to  the  Pauli  principle.  Light  quanta 
do  not  obey  the  Pauli  principle  since  there  can  be  an  unlimited 
number  of  quanta  in  a  state  with  a  given  wave  vector  k  and  given 
polarization.  All  particles  with  integral  spin  possess  a  wave  function 
which  is  symmetric  with  respect  to  a  complete  permutation  of  the 
variables  relating  to  any  pair  of  particles. 

The  Pauli  principle  and  the  limiting  transition  to  classical  theory. 
The  Pauli  principle  enables  us  to  understand  why  the  wave  prop- 
erties of  light  quanta  are  conserved  in  the  limiting  transition  to 
classical  theory,  while  the  wave  properties  of  electrons  are 
not. 

We  shall  consider  quanta  in  definite  states,  i.e.,  having  a  certain 
polarization  and  wave  vector.  The  number  of  such  quanta  can  be 
infinitely  large,  since  quanta  are  not  subject  to  the  Pauli  principle. 
We  note  that  this  was  not  introduced  as  a  supplementary  hypothesis 
concerning  the  properties  of  light  quanta,  but  was  directly  obtained 
in  Sec.  27  in  the  quantization  of  electromagnetic  field  equations: 
the  number  of  quanta  in  a  state  Nkt  0  is  the  quantum  number  for 
the  corresponding  oscillator.  If  this  quantum  number  is  large  then 
the  motion  of  the  oscillator  becomes  classical,  and,  as  we  know, 
its  oscillation  amplitude  is  proportional  to  the  amplitude  of  a  field 
with  a  given  polarization  and  wave  vector.  Thus,  the  limiting  transi- 
tion yields  a  classical  wave  pattern. 

In  accordance  with  the  Pauli  principle,  there  cannot  be  more 
than  one  electron  in  each  state.  Therefore,  the  probability-amplitude 
absolute  values  are  always  limited  by  the  normalization  to  unity 
and,  consequently,  do  not  pass  to  wave  amplitudes  which  can  be 
defined  classically.  f 

The  ortho-  and  para-states  of  two  electrons.  Let  us  now  return 
to  the  case  for  which  the  wave  function  can  be  represented  in  the 
form  (33.5).  Since  the  whole  product  is  antisymmetric,  one  of  its 
factors  must  be  symmetric  and  the  other  antisymmetric.  This  simple 
result  refers  only  to  the  two-electron  problem. 


348  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Let  us  consider  the  wave  function  for  two  electrons.  Since  the 
spin  of  each  electron  is  equal  to  --(in  atomic  units),  the  resultant 

2i 

spin  can  only  be  equal  to  zero  or  unity.  Both  these  states  of  a  system 
of  two  electrons  have  special  names.  The  state  with  spin  unity  is 
termed  the  ortho-state,  while  that  with  spin  equal  to  zero  is  called 
the  para-state. 

As  has  already  been  said,  the  magnetic  interaction  of  spins  is 
small.  If  we  can  neglect  it,  then  it  is  easy  to  write  down  the  spin 
wave  functions  for  the  ortho-  and  para-states.  Let  x  (^a^  <*i)  be  a 
function  of  the  spin  variable  for  the  first  particle  c^,  assuming,  as 
we  know,  only  two  values  at  =  1  and  (j1  =  2.  &CTI  denotes  the  eigen- 
value of  the  spin  projection.  Depending  upon  whether  fc0l  is  equal 

to  -r  or  —  -,-  ,  the  function  ^  has  the  form  shown  in  exercise  3,  Sec.  32. 

Z  Zi 

Without  assigning  a  definite  form  to  x»  we  write  down  the  spin 
wave  function  for  two  particles  which  do  not  have  a  spin  magnetic 
interaction  : 

CTI)  •  X  (*oa,  *a)  <  (33.17) 


i.e.,  the  probability  amplitude  for  both  particles  breaks  up  into  the 
product  of  the  amplitudes  for  each  particle  separately.  However, 
it  must  be  taken  into  account  that  this  function  must  be  either 
symmetric  or  antisymmetric.  If  &ai  —  A;^,  then  (33.17)  is  symmetric 
by  itself: 

x!>  ^ixf*  ><*2> 

(33.18) 


/       I        \     /      i        \ 

|x(-2  »*i)x(-2  'CT2/' 


For  kai^k<,z  we  must  form  either  a  symmetric  or  an  antisymmetric 
combination  of  ^: 

frvm  -     ,19   [x  (  1  >  CTi)  X  (~  \  >  ^a)  -I-  X  (  2  »  ^2)  X  (-  2  '  ^j]  '  (33.19) 

(33.20) 


---  is  introduced  for  normalization. 
V2 

The  magnitude  of  the  spin  projection,  i.e.,  0,  1  or  —  1,  depends 
upon  the  choice  of  the  z-axis.  But  the  symmetry  or  antisymmetry 
of  a  wave  function  is  an  internal  property  and  cannot  depend  upon 
the  choice  of  coordinate  axes.  Therefore,  the  state  (33.19)  must  be 
regarded  as  one  state  together  with  (33.18),  if  we  judge  by  the  total 
spin  value.  They  are  distinguished  by  the  spin  projections,  and  the 
total  number  of  these  states  is  three,  as  is  required  for  a  total  spin 
equal  to  1.  The  upper  line  of  (33.18),  as  is  evident,  corresponds  to 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON    SYSTEMS  349 

a  total  projection  1,  the  lower  line  to  a  projection  —  1,  and  (33.19) 
to  a  projection  0.  (33.20)  corresponds  to  a  total  spin  of  zero.  In  the 
accepted  terminology,  the  state  with  unity  spin  is  to  be  regarded 
as  the  ortho-state  while  that  with  zero  spin,  the  para-state. 
This  definition  of  ortho-  and  para-states  from  the  symmetry  of 

the  spin  wave  function  also  holds  for  particles  with  spin  other  than  -0-  . 

But  the  resultant  spin  in  the  ortho-  and  para-states  turns  out,  in 
this  case,  to  be  ambiguously  related  to  the  symmetry  of  the  function. 
The  example  of  deuterons  with  spin  1  will  be  examined  in 
Sec.  41. 

Ortho-  and  para-states  of  helium.  The  two  electrons  in  the  helium 
atom  can  occur  either  in  the  ortho-state  or  the  para-state.  In  the 
first  case,  the  atom  has  spin  unity,  in  the  second  case,  zero.  The 
symmetric  and  antisymmetric  spin  functions  are  the  eigenfunctions 
of  the  spin-commutation  operator  Pa:  when  operated  upon  by 
the  operator  P0  they  give  fcl,  i.e.,  the  eigenvalues  of  P0.  To  the 
approximation  (33.2)-(33.3),  the  Hamiltonian*  is  commutative 
with  P0,  so  that  Pa  is  an  integral  of  motion.  Therefore,  transitions 
between  the  ortho-  and  para-states,  during  which  the  total  spin 
is  not  conserved,  are  far  less  probable  than  transitions  with  conser- 
vation of  spin. 

Only  when  spin-orbital  interaction  is  taken  into  account,  when 
the  wave  function  cannot  be  expressed  as  a  product  of  the  form 
(33.5),  is  Pa  not  an  independent  integral  of  motion.  But  the  cor- 
responding terms  in  the  Hamiltonian,**  which  describe  the  spin- 
orbit  interaction,  are  inversely  proportional  to  c2.  To  this  approxi- 
mation, it  is  only  the  total  permutation  operator  of  the  spin  and 
spatial  variables  for  both  electrons  P  that  is  an  integral  of  motion, 
because  the  total  wave  function  of  the  two  electrons  is  always 
antisymmetric  in  accordance  with  the  Pauli  principle. 

The  eigenfunction  of  a  hydrogen  molecule  in  a  zero  approximation. 

Concluding  this  section  we  shall  consider  the  quantum  mechanical 
explanation  for  the  homopolar  chemical  bond.  Such  a  bond  occurs, 
for  example,  between  the  two  atoms  in  a  hydrogen  molecule.  It 
was  first  considered  by  Heitler  and  London. 

We  assume  that  the  atoms  are  independent  in  the  zero  approx- 
imation. Each  electron  is  situated  close  to  its  own  nucleus.  We 
shall  denote  the  nuclei  by  the  letters  a  and  6,  and  the  electrons  by 
the  numbers  1  and  2.  In  the  initial  approximation,  the  interaction 


*  The  Hamiltonian  means  the  Hamiltonian  operator. 

**  See  A.I.  Akhiezer  and  V.  B.  Berestetsky,  Quantum  Electrodynamics, 
GTTI,  1953,  equation  (37.10).  [English  translation  by  Consultants  Bureau, 
Inc.  New  York,  N.  Y.,  1957.] 


350  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

between  atoms  is  not  taken  into  account.  But  this  does  not  mean 
that  the  wave  functions  of  two  electrons  can  be  taken  in  the  form 


because  this  function  is  neither  symmetric  nor  antisymmetric  with 
respect  to  the  interchange  of  the  electron  coordinates.  Neglecting 
the  spin-orbital  interaction,  we  must  write  the  spatial  wave  function 
in  one  of  the  two  forms: 


or 


t-^(ra^(rb,)+^(ra2)^(rhl),  (33.21) 

1  =  *  (rai)  *  (r^)  -  4/  (rat)  ty  (rbl) ,  (33.22) 

assuming  that  the  total  wave  function  O  is  obtained  by  multiplication 
of  the  spatial  function  by  the  spin  function  of  opposite  symmetry. 
In  this  form  the  wave  functions  arc  compatible  with  Pauli's  principle. 

We  write  rai  and  r/,2  in  scalar  form  because  the  wave  functions 
of  a  hydrogen  atom  in  the  ground  state  do  not  depend  upon  the 
angle. 

The  wave  equation  for  a  hydrogen  molecule  has  the  following 
form : 

h*     .    __  _h*_  .    _  _h*_  .    __    h*    .    _    e*_  _   e*   _ 
2mp  2rnp  2m  2m  T^        ^bt 

(33.23) 


The  first  two  terms  describe  the  motion  of  the  nuclei  of  the  molecule. 
They  involve  the  mass  of  the  proton  mp  in  the  denominator,  and  are 
therefore  exceedingly  small  compared  with  the  terms  describing 
the  motion  of  the  electrons.  Physically,  this  means  that  the  nuclei 
move  considerably  slower  than  the  electrons,  so  that  we  can  find 
the  electron  wave  function  for  a  fixed  distance  between  the  nuclei. 
Then  $  is  a  function  of  the  distance  between  the  nuclei.  If  this  func- 
tion has  a  minimum,  corresponding  to  a  stable  equilibrium  for  a 
given  electronic  state,  then  it  becomes  possible  for  atoms  to  form 
a  molecule.  We  shall  not  in  future  write  the  terms  corresponding  to 
the  nuclear  kinetic  energy:  they  must  be  taken  into  account  when 
we  consider  the  vibrational,  rotational  or  translational  motion  of 
molecules,  though  the  very  position  of  stable  equilibrium,  which 
is  determined  by  the  electronic  motion,  can  be  found  without  allow- 

r             h*    A         j           W    A 
ance  for  —  -= A*  and    —  -^ A& . 

2mp  2mp 

The  terms  of  the  Hamiltonian  appearing  in  the  first  line  of  (33.23) 
refer  to  separated  atoms.  We  shall  call  this  part  (without  —  -^~  Aa 
and  —  -^-Abj  J^0,  where  the  index  0  indicates  the  degree  of 
the  approximation.  The  second  line  involves  terms  due  to  atomic 


Sec.  33]  MANY-ELECTRON   SYSTEMS  351 

interactions:  the  attraction  of  electrons  to  *  'alien"  nuclei,  and  the 
Coulomb  repulsion  between  electrons  and  nuclei.  We  shall  call  this 
part  c/i^  and  consider  it  a  perturbation  :  this  is  true,  strictly  speaking, 
only  in  a  qualitative  sense. 

Perturbation  method.  Using  the  notation  3JfQ  and  J^,  the  wave 
equation  is  written  as 

^  T  -  (t^0  +  Jf^)  XF  =  £  *F.  (33.24) 

The  energy  eigenvalue  can  be  expanded  as  the  sum  of  the  energies 
of  the  noiiinteracting  hydrogen  atoms  [from  (31.34)]  and  the  inter- 
action energy  of  the  atoms: 

«f  =  «?0  +  «?i.  (33.25) 

We  consider  the  operator  ^fl  and  the  energy  £±  as  corrections.  Ac- 
cordingly, we  separate  the  wave  function  into  a  zero  approximation 
function  given  by  one  of  the  expressions  (33.21)  or  (33.22),  and  a 
correction  T1: 

T-TO  +  T!.  (33.26) 

We  shall  neglect  the  quantities  3F±  ^¥l  and  ff^  XFX  because,  in  our 
approximation,  they  can  be  considered  as  being  of  the  second  order 
of  magnitude. 

Substituting  (33.  25)  and  (33.26)  in  (33.24)  and  omitting  these  small 
terms,  we  obtain 


(33.27) 


But  from  the  definition  of  XF0  we  have 


^o%  =  «?<>%>  (33.28) 

since  £  '0  is  the  zero  approximation  energy  and  YQ  is  an  eigenfunction 
of  &0. 

We  multiply  the  remaining  terms  by  TO  and  integrate  over  the 
volume  dV1  dV2  of  both  electrons*: 


=  ^  JT02  d  VidV*  +  tfojV^dVidVz.        (33.29) 

We  can  transform  the  first  term  on  the  left  making  use  of  the 
fact  that  J^Q  is  an  Hermitian  operator  (XF0  is  a  real  wave  function)  : 

oY1dF1iF,>      (33.30) 


*  For  simplicity,  we  consider  here  the  real  Hamiltonian  and  the  real  wave 
functions;  in  the  more  general  case,  we  must  multiply  the  left  by  *FJ. 


3/52  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

so  that  it  cancels  with  the  last  term  ou  the  left,  in  accordance  with 
(33.28).  The  same  could  have  been  proved  by  using  a  definite  form 

for  J#"0  in  the  given  case. 

Finally,  from  (33.20)  we  obtain 


(33.31) 


The  denominator  of  this  expression  is  the  square  of  the  normaliza- 
tion factor  of  the  function  XF0,  which  square  appears  because  the 
expressions  (33.21)  and  (33.22)  are  not  normalized  to  unity.  Chang- 
ing to  a  normalized  wave  function, 


we  represent  the  energy  correction  to  a  first  approximation  in  the 
form 

,?1==    >;JVF;dMF2.  (33.31  a) 


This  expression  is  equal  to  the  average  of  the  perturbation  energy 
over  nonperturbed  motion  [see  (30.24)]. 

It  can  be  seen  from  the  very  deduction  of  equation  (33.32),  in 
which  only  the  general  Herinitian  property  for  operators  is  used, 
that  the  result  is  of  a  general  nature. 

Hound  stale  of  hydrogen  molecule.  From  (33.21)  or  (33.22),  we  can 
substitute  either  a  symmetric  or  an  antisymmetric  coordinate  func- 
tion in  the  formula  for  the  energy  of  a  hydrogen  molecule.  Evaluating 
the  integral  shows  that  £  l  (ritb)  has  a  minimum  for  the  symmetric 
form  of  the  spatial  wave  function  only.  The  depth  of  this  minimum 
corresponds  approximately  to  the  binding  energy  of  a  hydrogen 
molecule.  We  cannot  expect  very  good  agreement  with  experiment 
here,  since  the  approximation  used  was  more  qualitative  than  quanti- 
tative in  nature. 

In  calculating  the  energy,  the  following  integral  is  of  essential 
importance 

*2  fy  (r*i)  *  (r*,)  ~  *  (r«,)  }  (rbl)  d  V,  d  V,  ,  (33.32) 

J  ^12 

and  is  termed  the  exchange  integral.  It  cannot  be  correlated  with 
any  classical  quantity  because  it  involves  only  probability  ampli- 
tudes and  not  densities. 

We  note  that  the  antisymmetric  spatial  function  (33.22)  possesses 
a  nodal  surface  between  the  nuclei  because  it  changes  sign  when 
the  places  of  the  nuclei  a  uiid  6  are  exchanged.  A  symmetric  func- 


See.  34]  TITK  QUANTUM  THEORY  OF  R  UHATIOX  353 

tion  does  not  have  nodes  and  therefore  corresponds  to  a  smaller 
total  energy,  i.e.,  a  more  stable  state.  This  function  is  multiplied 
by  an  antisymmetric  spin  function  so  that  a  stable  molecular  state 
has  a  zero  resultant  spin.  Thus,  the  homopolar  bond  of  two  hydrogen 
atoms  forming  a  molecule  is  related  to  a  "saturation,13  as  it  were, 
of  spins.  There  is  "no  longer  a  stable  equilibrium  position  for  a  third 
hydrogen  atom  near  a  hydrogen  molecule. 

The  tendency  towards  spin  saturation  of  electron  pairs  is  pro- 
nounced in  homopolar  bonds. 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  possible  states  of  a  system  of  two  ^-electrons  with  the  same 
principal   quantum  numbers. 

Each  electron  can  occur  in  ten  states: 

A  -  9         •  7?  •  i         •  r*  •  c\         •/)•        i         •   //  •       9         .   JF  .  o  •  fj  •  i  • 

'  ~2~  '          '  2  ~  2  2~  '       '   ~       2   '         "'  --  2   '  ~~  2'  ' 


The  states  with   positive  projections  of  spin  and  orbital   moment  are 

AB:  3,1;  AC:  2,1;  AD:  1,1;  AE:  0,1;  AFi  4,0;  Alii  3,0;  AH:  2,0; 
AI:  1,0;  AJ:  0,0;  7?C7:  1,1;  BD\  0,1;  /*F:  2,0;  /*<7:  2,0;  /*//  :  1,0;  7*7:  0,0; 
CFi  2,0;  C'tf:  1,0;  CH  :  0,0;  7>7<T:  1,0;  DO:  0,0;  #7<T:  0,0. 

Choosing  the  states  with  maximum  angular-momentum  projections,  wo 
obtain  three  resultant  states  with  zero  spin  : 

1S,1D,  1G  or  'AS*,  ^,  1G$, 
and  two  states  with  unity  spin: 

3P,  3F  or  3Pf  ,  3Pf  ,  3Pg  and  3i^f  ,  3J^,  3Ff  . 

2)  Show  that,  in  a  system  of  four  p-electrons  with  the  same  principal  num- 
bers, the  states  are  the  same  as  in  a  system  of  two  ^-electrons  ;  in  other  words, 
that  two  electrons  have  the  same  states  as  two  '"holes." 

Sec.   34.   The   Quantum  Theory  of  Radiation 

In  this  section  we  shall  find  the  probability  of  an  excited  atom 
emitting  a  light  quantum  in  unit  time,  and  we  shall  compare  the 
probabilities  of  such  radiation  transitions  as  correspond  to  various 
changes  in  the  atomic  states.  But  lirst  we  must  deduce  a  general 
formula  for  the  probability  of  quantum  transitions  (this  formula 
will  also  be  used  in  Sec.  37). 

Transitions  between  states  with  the  same  energy.  Let  us  suppose 
that  a  system  has  two  states  corresponding  to  the  same  energy  but 
different  in  some  other  respect.  For  examj>le,  in  this  section  we 

23  -  0060 


354  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

will  consider  an  excited  atom  having  energy  excess  ff:  —  £  0  above 
the  ground  state.  This  atom  is  capable  of  emitting  a  light  quantum 
with  energy  A  CD  =ffi  —  <?0,  in  which  case  the  atom  will  go  to  the 
ground  state.  Strictly  speaking,  there  is  only  one  state  consisting 
of  an  atom  and  electromagnetic  field  with  a  certain  energy  (fx  (if 
there  are  no  other  quanta  in  the  field).  The  energy  of  such  a  system 
is  rigorously  determined,  though  the  state  is  not  defined  in  more 
detail. 

Also  possible  is  the  following  approach  to  the  problem.  Let  an 
atom  at  the  initial  instant  of  time  be  in  an  excited  state  but  capable 
of  the  spontaneous  emission  of  a  quantum.  Then  the  energy  of  the 
atom  is  no  longer  specified  with  full  rigour,  but  lies  in  some  narrow 

interval  A  (^,  where  A  $  ~  ~r  an(l  ^  ^  ^ie  mean  lifetime  of  the 


atom  in  the  excited  state  before  radiation  [see  (28.15)].  If  the  mean 
lifetime  of  the  atom  in  the  excited  state  A£  is  such  that  —  -^—  is  con- 

A£ 

siderably  less  than  the  energy  level  spacing  of  the  atom,  then  the 
energy  uncertainty  can  be  neglected  to  a  first  approximation, 
assuming  that  the  atom  initially  occurred  in  a  state  with  an  accurate 
energy  value  S^\  it  is  also  necessary  to  calculate  the  probability 
that,  in  a  certain  interval  of  time  £,  the  atom  will  go  to  the  ground 
state,  and  a  quantum  with  energy  h  CD  =ff:  —  <^0  will  appear  in  the 
electromagnetic  field. 

The  reason  for  the  transition  is  interaction  with  the  electromagnetic 
field.  Here  the  lifetime  of  the  atom  in  the  excited  state  A  £  is  so  great 
that  &<§><^6\  —  <?0.  For  this  reason,  the  interaction  of  the  atom 
with  the  electromagnetic  field  can  be  interpreted  as  a  small  pertur- 
bation superimposed  on  the  excited  atom  with  energy  £±. 

The  same  type  of  problem  concerning  the  transition  probability 
due  to  a  perturbation  can  also  be  formulated  for  other  transitions. 
For  example,  if  the  total  excitation  energy  of  an  atom  is  greater 
than  its  ionization  energy,  it  is  possible  for  an  electron  to  be  emitted 
from  the  atom  without  radiation.  In  this  case  the  excited  state  of 
the  atom  and  the  ion  +  electron  state  belong  to  the  same  energy. 
Each  of  them  separately  does  not  have  a  strictly  defined  energy. 

Transition  probability.  A  radiation  transition  with  the  emission 
of  a  quantum  is  caused  by  interaction  between  an  atom  and  an 
electromagnetic  field.  We  shall  suppose  for  the  time  being  that  this 
interaction  is  "switched  off";  then  the  energy  of  the  atom  and  field 
separately  becomes  an  exact  integral  of  motion.  We  shall  call  its 
eigenvalue  in  the  initial  state  S^.  Then,  if  the  interaction  is  "turned 
on,"  a  finite  probability  exists  of  the  system  making  a  transition 
to  some  state  which,  energetically,  is  very  close  to  &19  but  otherwise 
very  different  from  the  initial  state;  for  example,  the  atomlwas 
excited  in  the  initial  state  and  there  were  no  quanta  in  the  field, 


SeC.  34]  THE    QUANTUM   THEORY    OF    RADIATION  355 

while  iii  the  final  state  the  atom  went  to  the  ground  state  and  a 
quantum  appeared  in  the  field. 

Let  us  divide  the  Hamiltonian  of  the  system  into  two  terms: 
je=  <&w  +J&M  ,  where  jfW  corresponds  to  the  separated  atom  and 
field  while  «^(1)  describes  the  interaction.  We  then  deduce  a  general 
formula  for  the  transition  probability,  and  apply  it  to  a  radiation. 
We  shall  therefore  call  3t?w>  the  Hamiltonian  of  the  unperturbed 
system,  and  regard  3?®)  as  a  small  perturbation  causing  the  transition. 
The  eigcnfunctions  and  eigenvalues  of  the  operator  30*^  are  deter- 
mined from  the  equation 


Allowing  for  perturbation,  the  wave  function  satisfies  the  equation 


.  .  (34.2) 

Considering  that  Jff^  is  a  small  perturbation,  we  represent  the  wave 
function  in  the  form 

(34.3) 


the  "product"  &*&  ij/1*  will  be  neglected  as  being  of  the  second  order. 
Then,  for  tp(1)  we  obtain  the  nonhomogeneous  equation 


>  (34.4) 


We  shall  look  for  i]/1*  in  the  form  of  an  eigenfunction  expansion 
of  the  operator  t]/°): 

*(1)=27c»W*2>,  (34.5) 

m 

each  of  the  functions  3$  satisfying  the  homogeneous  equation  (34.1). 
Substituting  the  series  (34.5)  in  the  nonhomogeneous  equation  and 
using  the  indicated  property  of  the  function  fy®\  we  arrive  at  the 
following  equality: 

W-  (34>6) 


The  coefficients  cm  can  be  determined  therefrom  by  taking  advantage 
of  the  orthogonality  property  of  the  eigenfunctions  fy$  (30.6).  For 
this  it  is  necessary  to  multiply  both  sides  of  (34.6)  by  ^n0)*  and  integrate 
over  a  volume.  Then  only  the  term  --  -  —=~  remains  on  the  left, 

while  on  the  right  a  certain  integral  is  obtained  which  is  characteristic 
of  the  perturbation  method  set  out  here: 

23' 


356  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

<34-7) 


In  order  to  integrate  this  equation  we  must  determine  the  time 
dependence  of  the  right-hand  side.  It  involves  wave  functions  [that 
satisfy  equation  (34.1)]  together  with  their  time  factor  in  the  form 
(24.21).  It  is  assumed  that  the  operator  J^(1>  does  not  depend  ex- 
plicitly on  time.  Then 

F  =  P""'  ~  '  *    "    tf$*jf™  WF,         (34.8) 


where  the  integral  multiplied  by  the  exponent  does  not  depend 
upon  time.  We  have  supposed  that  at  the  initial  instant  of  time 
the  system  was  in  a  state  with  energy  ff±\  in  other  words,  that 
Iq  (0)  |  =  1,  cW7ti  (0)—  0.  Therefore,  equation  (34.7)  is  integrated  thus: 


(34.9) 

or,  once  again  introducing  the  exponential  factor  under  the  integral 
sign,  i.e.,  reverting  to  the  functions  ^,(,0)* ,  ^i0)  we  obtain 

Cn(t)=l~~*       h          U^tfW^dV.  (34.10) 


Consequently,  the  probability  that  at  the  instant  of  time  t  the 
system  will  be  in  a  state  with  wave  function  d>,(,0)  is,  from  (30.13), 
equal  to 


Matrix  elements.  We  shall  be  concerned  with  the  expression  (34.11) 
somewhat  later.  First  of  all  let  us  introduce  a  system  of  notation 
which,  in  general,  is  very  convenient  in  quantum  mechanics.  The 
integral  (34.7)  for  any  pair  of  eigenfunctions  d»w,  AJ  and  for  an  arbitrar}7 
operator  X  is  denoted  thus: 

X^MdF,  (34.12) 


Sec.  34]  THE   QUANTUM  THEORY   OF   RADIATION  357 

where  the  integration  is  performed  over  all  the  independent  variables 

involved  in  the  Hamiltonian  C/C. 

The  quantities  X«k  form  a  square  table  so  that  the  index  n  will 
designate  the  rows,  and  k  the  columns: 


»      22  » 


.............  (34.13) 

Such  a  table  is  termed  a  matrix  in  mathematics,  while  the  separate 
quantities  X«fc  are  called  matrix  elements.  The  right-hand  side  of 
(34.7)  contains  the  matrix  element  3f^. 

We  note  an  important  property  of  the  matrix  elements  of  Her  mitian 
operators.  In  accordance  with  the  Hermitian  condition  (30.3) 

,  (34.14) 

where  the  conjugate  sign*  on  the  right  refers  to  the  whole  integral. 
Proceeding  now  from  the  definition  (34.12),  we  write: 

X^-Xfe,,.  (34.15) 

A  matrix  whose  elements  satisfy  equation  (34.15)  is  termed  Hermitian. 
The  relationship  between  matrix  elements  of  different  quantities. 

Let  us  take  the  matrix  elements  of  both  sides  of  the  operator  equalities 
(30.35)  and  (30.37),  and  put  the  time  derivative  before  the  integral: 

~dt  Xnk  ^  P"k'  (34.16) 


The  time  dependence  of  the  matrix  elements  was  found  in  equation 
(34.8),  namely 


Therefore, 

~  Xnk  =  I  ~k  "--"-  Xnk  ,  (34.18) 


358  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   111 

Thus,  matrix  elements  depend  harmonically  upon  time. 
The  energy  difference  A  —  Sn  can  be   conveniently  represented 
by  means  of  the  Bohr  frequency  condition  (see  beginning  of  Sec.  23): 

'*-*"   m*kn.  (34.20) 


Therefore,  the  operator  relationships  (34.16)  and  (34.17),  rewritten 
for  matrix  elements,  appear  thus: 


pnk  =  imuknXnk,  (34.21) 

*•  (34-22> 


The  matrix  form  of  the  equations  of  quantum  mechanics  was 
found  by  Heisenberg. 

The  probability  for  transition  to  a  continuous  spectrum.  Let  us  now 
investigate  the  expression  for  the  transition  probability  (34.11), 
rewriting  it  in  matrix  notation: 


«,  («)  -  4  sin*  <&=LpLL  .  .  (34.23) 

4  tl  (GI  —  <5  n) 

In  the  examples  dealing  with  radiation  and  ioiiizatiou  that  we 
have  mentioned,  the  final  state  of  the  system  belonged  to  a  continuous 
energy  spectrum.  Indeed,  the  energy  spectrum  of  an  electromagnetic 
field  is  continuous  since  the  field  can  contain  quanta  of  any  frequency 
o).  In  the  ionization  example,  the  spectrum  of  the  electron  emitted 
from  the  atom  was  continuous  because  the  motion  of  the  electron 
was  infinite. 

If  the  state  n  belongs  to  a  continuous  spectrum,  it  is  more  interesting 
to  determine  the  total  probability  of  transition  to  any  of  the  states 
with  energy  Sn,  i.e.,  to  find  the  integral  of  (34.23)  with  respect  to 
dSn.  Now  it  is  not  advisable  to  state  the  final  energy  ffn  since  it 
varies  continuously;  it  is  better  simply  to  write  £.  Then  there  are 
dN  (ff)  states  contained  within  the  energy  interval  between  $  and 
ff-\-d£.  The  example  of  dN  (£)  was  given  in  Sec.  25,  equation  (25.25). 
(The  transition  to  a  continuous  spectrum  in  Sec.  25  is  achieved 
simply  by  means  of  an  infinite  increase  in  the  box  dimensions,  which 
are  not  contained  in  any  physical  result.  The  distance  between  neigh- 
bouring levels  is  then  infinitely  reduced.) 
So  let 

dN(g)=z(g)d£.  (34.24) 

The  total  probability  of  transition  to  the  continuous  spectrum  is 


r  r A  •  *(*- *i> * 

I  /    48m     2* 

= J  w  (/, ,  t)  dN  (t)  =  J  — w-~^ 


(34.25) 


Sec.  34]  THE    QUANTUM   THEORY    OF    RADIATION  350 


For  clarity  in  notation  we  shall  put  the  indices  <£\,  $  of  JlfM  in 
brackets  and  not  as  subscripts,  treating  them  as  the  arguments 

of  the  function,  which  in  fact  they  are  with  respect  to 
We  shall  denote  the  argument  of  the  sine  by  the  letter 


2h        "s* 
Passing  to  the  integration  variable  £  we  obtain 


(34.26) 

The  function   ^  ^   has  a  principal  maximum  for  £  =  0.  Its  next 

maximum  is  already  twenty  times  smaller.  For  this  reason,  in  the 
integral  (34.26),  the  main  part  is  played  by  the  values  of  £  of  the 
order  unity.  But  then  the  instant  of  time  t  can  always  be  chosen 

2/t  y 
so  that  —  "-  is  considerably  less  than.  tf\.  Fn  other  words,  it  is  per- 

missible, in  the  arguments  of  the  functions  ,^(i)  ($v  $  )  and  z  (<?'), 
to  replace  g  simply  by  <£\  and  to  take  out  tho  functions  |  ,#"CI)  (c^, 
^*—  ^j)!2  and  2(^=^1)  from  under  the  integral  sign.  It  is  shown 
thereby  that  if  the  time  t  is  sufficiently  long,  the  energies  of  the  initial 
and  final  states  £±  and  S  arc  defined  so  accurately  that  they  can  be 
considered  simply  equal  to  one  another,  in  accordance  with  the  Jaw 
of  conservation  of  energy  in  the  transition.  Naturally,  tho  law  of 
conservation  of  energy  holds  always,  but,  for  sufficiently  small 
values  of  t,  it  is  impossible  to  determine  tho  energy  of  the  final  state, 
for  the  uncertainty  relation  (28.15)  for  the  given  case  is  of  the  form 
($  —  $i)  £^2  TcA.  Hence,  if  t  tends  to  infinity,  the  precise  equality 
ff=ffli  is  obtained. 

Since  the  function  —  ~-  decreases  rapidly  with  increasing  5,  the 

integration  should  be  extended  from  —  oo  to  oo.  Since  the  remaining 
values  have  been  taken  out  from  under  the  integral  sign,  the  integral 
itself  can  be  evaluated.  It  is 


~dZ  =  n.  (34.27) 

—  00 

From  this 

W^  AlL  I  jjf  (i)  (^l)^==  ^t)  12 2  (<£>  j  .  tt  (34.28) 

/i 

Then  the  transition  probability  in  unit  time  is 


300  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

We  write  the  second  argument  S'=^>1  to  emphasize  that  the  state 
fy  (S )  coincides  with  <p  (I x)  only  with  respect  to  energy.  The  formula 
(34.29)  has  very  many  applications. 

The  matrix  clement  corresponding  to  the  emission  of  a  quantum. 

With  the  aid  of  expression  (34.29)  it  is  possible  to  obtain  rigorously  an 
expression  for  radiation  intensity.  This  result  is  based  on  quantization 
of  the  electromagnetic  field  performed  in  Sec.  27.  We  shall  not  give 
the  other,  less  rigorous,  result  based  on  the  analogy  between  classical 
equations  and  the  equations  for  matrix  elements. 

In  order  to  simplify  subsequent  computations,  we  shall,  from  the 
start,  take  advantage  of  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy  for  radiation. 
In  considering  transitions  of  an  atom  from  a  state  with  energy  ^>1 
to  a  state  with  energy  *f  0,  we  take  only  those  quanta  which  satisfy 
the  energy  conservation  law  in  accordance  with  the  Bohr  frequency 
condition  S\ — ^0--=Aco.  Further,  we  shall  first  of  all  consider  quanta 
with  a  definite  direction  of  the  wave  vector  k,  and  a  definite  polari- 
zation a.  In  addition,  we  assume  that  there  Avere  no  quanta  of  this 
type  in  the  field  initially,  i.e.,  in  the  initial  state  N^a  =  0. 

In  this  case  the  perturbation  energy  operator  is  the  product  of  two 
operators : 

(vA).  (34.30) 


c 


This  expression  is  obtained  from  (15.32),  if  the  term  that  is  linear  in  A 
is  retained  in  the  equation,  and  if  we  put  cp  —  0. 

The  wave  function  of  the  atom  and  the  field  in  a  nonperturbed 
state,  i.e.,  with  the  interaction  between  them  "switched  off,"  is 
expressed  as  the  product  of  the  wave  functions  of  the  atom  and  the 
field.  The  wave  function  of  the  field  is  represented  as  the  product  of 
the  wave  functions  of  separate  oscillators  with  different  k,  o.  All 
these  functions  are  orthogonal  and  normalized.  Therefore,  in  calculat- 
ing the  matrix  element  of  the  quantity  Ag  or  of  the  coordinate  of 
the  oscillator  with  given  k,  cr,  we  must  take  the  wave  functions 
corresponding  to  the  given  oscillator.  In  accordance  with  the  nor- 
malization condition,  the  integral  over  all  the  remaining  coordinates 
of  the  field  gives  unity. 

In  the  vector  potential  we  take  the  term  relating  to  k  and  a : 

(34-31) 

where  we  have  used  equations  (27.20)  and  (27.21)  that  express  the 
field  amplitudes  in  terms  of  real  variables. 

We  must  calculate  the  matrix  element  describing  the  transition 
between  two  states,  with  no  quantum  described  by  wave  vector  k 
and  polarization  a  in  the  first  one,  and  with  only  one  such  quantum 


See.  34]  THE  QUANTUM  THEOUY  OF  RADIATION  3(51 

in  the  second  one.  We  shall  write  these  states  with  subscripts  0  and  1. 
Then,  from  (34.21), 

(Pg)oi  =  ico10  (eg)01  -  i<ok  (#g)ol  ,  (34.32) 


since  o>10  is  equal  to  the  energy  difference  between  the  initial  and 
final  states  of  the1  field  divided  by  h,  i.e.,  just  equal  to  the  frequency 
of  the  emitted  quantum  cot.  Substituting  this  into  the  expression  for 
the  matrix  element  (A£)01  we  find  that 

'  (34.33) 

since  the  coefficient  of  eikr  becomes  zero. 

For  simplicity  we  shall  temporarily  omit  the  indices  k  and  o. 
We  must  evaluate  the  integral 

(34.34) 


Here,  the  field-oscillator  wave  functions  are  denoted  by  90  ami  9i 
in  order  not  to  confuse  them  with  the  atom  wave  functions. 

We  know  the  functions  90  and  9,  from  Sec.  26.  From  equations 
(26.22)  and  (26.23)  we  have 

1     u>  Q2  -.  i 

<34'35) 


The  coefficients  gQ  and  gl  are  found  from  the  normalization  condition 
exercise  1,  Sec.  26): 


(e  -  -"?-)'  -  ,:  f  A  Jrf  *r   *-  -  »:  ]/'-  ;  ,.  =  f  ,:  "  ; 


We  note  that  the  product  Q<pQ  is  proportional  to  9^  Hence,  the 
integral  (34.34)  would  have  vanished  due  to  the  orthogonality  con- 
dition, if  any  other  function,  92,  <p3,  .  .  .  ,  9,,.  had  been  substituted,  in 
place  9X,  into  the  integral.  Therefore,  only  one  quantum  can  be 
emitted  with  a  given  frequency,  direction,  and  polarization.  The 
same  can  also  be  shown  for  any  arbitrary  initial  stage  of  the  field. 
Absorption  of  quanta  also  occurs  singly.  For  Qol  we  have 

:-        (34-36) 


3012                                                                QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    III 

The  dipolo  approximation.  It  is  now  necessary  to  calculate  the 
matrix  element  given  by  two  atomic  states: 

^    -*o  (v  A01)  ^dV.  (34.37) 


Substituting  A01  from  (34.33)  and  (34.36),  we  reduce  this  matrix  ele- 
ment to  the  form 

dV  .  (34.38) 

The  wave  function  of  the  discrete  spectrum  of  an  atom  differs  from 
zero  in  the  region  near  10~8  cm,  i.e.,  of  the  order  of  atomic  dimensions. 
The  wavelength  of  visible  light  is  about  0.5  x  10~4  cm,  i.e.,  several 
thousand  times  greater.  Therefore,  we  can  consider  that  the  phase 
of  a  wave  changes  very  little  in  the  region  of  the  atom,  and  we  remove 
the  exponential  factor  from  the  integration,  taking  it  at  some  mean 
point  (for  example,  the  nucleus). 

This  corresponds  to  a  dipole  approximation  defined  in  Sec.  19, 
the  wavelength  being  considerably  greater  than  the  dimensions  of 
the  radiating  system.  The  other  condition  concerning  the  applicability 
of  the  dipole  approximation  is  that  the  electron  velocity  must  be 
considerably  less  than  the  velocity  of  light  —  a  thing  that  occurs 
in  atoms  of  small  and  medium  atomic  weight. 

To  the  dipole  approximation  we  have 

V  .  (34.39) 

From  (34.18)  the  velocity  matrix  element  is  directly  expressed 
in  terms  of  the  coordinate  matrix  element 

VIG  =  ^01  rio  =  -  *cok  r10  ,  (34.40) 

a>     _   jp 

because,  according  to  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy,  co10  =  ---  v  —  — 

is  equal  to  the  frequency  of  the  radiated  light. 

The  square  of  the  modulus  of  the  matrix  element  is 


12  —  f  .    . 

I     —  e          y        lekrlol     •  104.4IJ 

We  shall  now  take  into  account  the  fact  that  an  emitted  quantum 
can  have  two  different  polarizations.  If  we  are  not  specially  interested 
in  the  probability  of  quantum  emission  with  a  given  polarization,  then 
the  probability  must  be  summed  over  the  polarizations,  i.e.,  over  o. 
To  begin  with,  let  us  assume  the  vector  k  to  be  in  the  direction  of  the 
z-axis.  Then  the  unit  vector  ek  can  have  two  directions:  along  the 
#-axis  and  along  the  y-axis.  Accordingly, 


Sec.  34J 


THJS    QUANTUM   THEORY    OF    RADIATION 

2  =1*.  J24-U/.J2 


Let  us  find  the  average  of  this  expression  over  all  possible  directions 
of  quantum  emission.  It  is  then  obvious  that 


(34.43) 


By  performing  this  averaging  after  summation  with  respect  to  cr, 
we  obtain 


In  order  to  find  the  probability  of  emission  of  a  quantum  in  unit 

t) 

time,  we  must  multiply  (34.44)   by  -V-z  (£).  z  (S1)   is  found   from 

equation  (25.24),  where  we  must   put  k~  --°- : 

c 

c°)     _.        °2  /•jy*    4rt\ 


Finally,   from  equation   (34.29),   we  find  the  expression  for  the 
probability  to  a  dipole  approximation: 


dir 

~dt~ 


4      co3 

y^ca~ 


(34.46) 


We  can  write  the  product  er10  as  d10,  i.e.,  as  the  dipole  moment 
matrix  element. 

The  intensity  of  radiation  is  equal  to  the  radiation  probability  in 
unit  time  multiplied  by  the  energy  of  the  quantum: 


This  equation  greatly  resembles  the  classical  formula  (19.28).  How- 
ever, we  have  the  square  of  the  modulus  co4  |  d10  |2  in  place  of  the 
square  of  the  second  derivative  of  dipole  moment  d2.  The  correspond- 
ence between  classical  and  quantum  theory  displayed  here  may  be 
demonstrated  by  means  of  the  matrix  equations  (34.16)  and  (34.17) 
too.  Directly  applied  to  electrodynamics,  it  leads  to  equation  (34.47). 
We  have  given  a  more  rigorous  deduction,  based  on  the  quantization 
of  electrodynamical  equations,  in  order  to  illustrate  the  generality  of 
the  methods  of  quantum  theory. 

Compared  with  the  classical  formula  (19.28),  the  quantum  expression 
contains  an  extra  factor  of  two  (4/3  instead  of  2/3).  This  is  explained 


364  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [  L'cirt    111 

in  the  following  way.  We  represent  a  classical  dipole  moment,  varying 
harmonically,  in  the  following  manner: 

(1  =  dx  e"')f  +  d}  e"''<°'  ,    d  =  —  co2  (dx  f"'M'  +  d}  e~/wf)  -         (34.48) 

The  terms  dx  e/w/  and  dj  e~'wf  depend  upon  time  like  the  matrix 

elements  d10  and  d01.  Let  us  form  the  time  average  of  (d)2.  The  terms 

involving  e2'"'  and  e~2iwr  drop  out  in  averaging,  and  there  remains 


But  it  is  the  quantum  formula  which  corresponds  to  the  mean 
radiation  intensity  I  Aco  •  '-.—  1  ,  so  that  the  factor  of  two  is  due  to  the 

time  averaging  of  the  square  of  the  dipole  moment,  given  in  the 
form  (34.48). 

The  expression  (34.47)  confirms  what  was  said  in  Sec.  22  about  an 
atom  being  stable  in  quantum  theory:  radiation  is  always  associated 
with  a  transition  of  the  atom  from  one  state  to  another.  But  no 
atomic  state  exists  for  which  the  energy  is  less  than  the  energy  of  the 
ground  state,  that  is  why  the  atom  can  exist  in  the  ground  state  for 
an  indefinitely,  long  time. 

The  selection  rules  lor  the  magnetic  quantum  number.  It  follows 
from  equation  (34.41)  that,  if  r10  =  0,  the  intensity  is  equal  to  zero, 
at  any  rate  to  a  dipole  approximation.  We  shall  now  find  the  con- 
ditions for  which  r10  differs  from  zero.  First  of  all  we  notice  that  if 
the  vector  defining  the  polarization  direction  is  equal  to  e£  then,  to 
a  dipole  approximation,  radiation  of  such  a  quantum  is  possible 
provided  the  matrix  element  for  the  projection  of  the  electron  radius 
vector  along  the  direction  of  quantum  polarization  differs  from  zero. 
Let  us  assume  that  the  quantum  polarisation  is  along  the  z-axis. 
Let  the  magnetic  quantum  number  of  the  electron  be  equal  to  k 
before  the  transition,  and  kf  after  the  transition.  Then  the  dependence 
of  the  wave  function  upon  azimuth  ^  is  given  by  the  equations 

<I>i-  Mr,  »•)«**,     *;=/;(r,&)e-^, 

because  eik*  and  etk'v  are  eigeiifuuctions  of  the  angular-  momentum 
z  -projection.  Hence 

27t 

z10  =  J/J  (r,  ft)  r  cos  ft  -  f1  (rb)  r2  sin  9-  dr  dftjV*  (k  ~  fc'>  d  9  ; 

o 

a--*'),/0-  ei*(k'   fc/)  I""-  I     °  for  &^fc'' 
d(?-  ~i  II  -  k'}  \     -  \  2  TT  for  fc  =  k'  . 

0  |0 

2  ~r  cos  ft  in  polar  coordinates  and,  therefore,  does  not  depend 
upon  9.  For  this  reason,  the  matrix  element  z10  differs  from  zero 
only  when  k'  =  k. 


Sec'.  34]  THE    QUANTUM    THEORY    OF    RADIATION  365 

Instead  of  considering  plane  polarized  radiation  along  x  or  y,  let 
us  take  circularly  polarized  radiation  in  the  #y-plane.  In  such  radiation 
there  is  a  constant  phase  shift  between  the  xtii  and  the  yth  components 

equal  to  -^  (see  sec.  17,  Fig.  25).  Consequently,  we  must  determine  the 
matrix  elements  of  the  quantities 

.    TC 

(x-\-e    *  2  y)lQ  =  (x  {-  iy)1Q  =  (r  sin&e  ±  <<%  . 


Substituting  the  expressions  for  the  wave  functions  involving  9 
explicitly,  we  find 


27T 


|V<fc-fc':t  D<Pd9  -^'i'^r  -  0,  if  jfc'  ^  fc  ±  1  .         (34.49) 

o  ~^ 

Hence,  radiation  which  is  circularly  polarized  in  the  #?/-plane  can 
only  be  emitted  if  the  magnetic  quantum  number  changes  by  ±  1. 

The  rules  that  determine  what  change  of  quantum  number  governs 
the  emission  of  a  given  radiation  are  called  selection  rules. 

The  selection  rules  for  dipole  radiation  with  respect  to  the  magnetic 
quantum  number  forbid  the  changing  of  k  by  more  than  unity. 

The  selection  rules  for  the  azimuthal  quantum  number  and  parity. 
The  magnetic  quantum  number  is  the  angular-momentum  projection. 
Since  the  angular-momentum  projection  does  not  change  by  more 
than  unity,  the  angular  momentum  itself  (i.e.,  the  azimuthal  quantum 
number)  cannot  change  by  more  than  unity. 

But  I  for  a  separate  electron  cannot  remain  unchanged,  because 
then  the  functions  d^  and  A0  must  have  the  same  parity.  Here,  the 
product  fy*Q  z  fyi  will  turn  out  to  be  an  odd  function  while  its  integral, 

i.e.,  the  matrix  element  j  ^zfy^dV,  will  become  identically  zero. 
In  exactly  the  same  way  f  Jj;J  x^  d  V  and  \  tybyfyidV  will  also  become 

zero.  This  is  why,  for  a  dipole  transition  of  one  electron  in  the  atom, 
the  azimuthal  quantum  number  changes  by  ±  1. 

Angular  momentum  and  parity  of  a  light  quantum.  As  was  indicated 
in  Sec.  13,  an  electromagnetic  field  possesses  angular  momentum.  If 
from  equation  (13.28)  we  determine  the  angular  momentum  of  a 
quantum  emitted  during  dipole  radiation,  it  comes  out  equal  to  unity. 
And  the  state  of  the  quantum  is  odd  because  it  is  determined  by  the 
parity  of  the  dipole-moment  vector  components  d,  which,  obviously, 
change  sign  for  the  interchange  x->  —  x,  y->  —  y,  z->  —  z.  Hence,  the 
selection  rules  for  the  azimuthal  quantum  number  and  parity  of  the 
state  of  the  atom  must  be  interpreted  as  the  conservation  laws  of 
total  angular  momentum  and  total  parity  of  the  atom  +  quantum 
system  in  radiation.  Clearly,  if  the  angular  momentum  of  a  quantum 


306  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

is  equal  to  unity,  the  angular  momentum  of  the  atom  cannot  change 
by  greater  than  unity  during  radiation. 

The  selection  rules  for  spin  and  total  angular  momentum.  If  the  spin 
is  in  no  way  related  to  the  orbital  motion,  the  spin  functions  for  the 
initial  and  final  states  must  be  the  same,  otherwise  the  transition 
dipole  moment  is  equal  to  zero  due  to  the  orthogonality  of  spin  func- 
tions that  correspond  to  different  spin  eigenvalues. 

This  selection  rule  is  approximate  in  character  and  is  valid  for  light 
atoms.  Taking  into  account  the  spin-orbital  interaction,  we  must 
consider  the  selection  rules  for  the  total  angular  momentum  j  =M±a 
[see  (22.15)].  Since  the  angular  momentum  of  a  dipole  quantum  is 
equal  to  unity,  we  obtain  the  condition  for  j' — j:  j'=j  or  j'=j±l. 
Here,  the  parity  of  the  state  must  change.  However,  since  the  parity 
is  not  directly  related  to  j  but  only  to  Z,  the  transition  j' =j  is  also 
possible.  But  the  transition  from  j  =  0  to  j'  —  0  is  forbidden,  because 
in  this  transition  the  quantum  cannot  acquire  the  angular  momentum. 
It  is  necessary  to  note  that  the  angular  momenta  for  quanta  of  higher 
multipole  order  than  dipole  can  only  be  greater  than  unity,  so  that  the 
transition  from  j  =  0  to  j'  =  0  is  forbidden  for  all  approximations,  and 
not  only  to  the  dipole  approximation. 

The  selection  rules  for  many-electron  atoms.  By  considering  a  light 
quantum  as  a  particle  with  unity  angular  momentum,  it  is  easy  to 
obtain  the  selection  rules  also  for  cases  when  the  states  of  more  than 
one  electron  change.  Neglecting  the  spin-orbital  interaction,  the 
selection  rules  are  the  following:  8'  =S,  L'  —  L  or  L'==JD±1  and  the 
parity  is  reversed.  The  transition  L'  —L  is  possible  here,  because,  in 
a  many-electron  system,  parity  is  not  related  to  total  angular  momen- 
tum. 

Magnetic  dipole  radiation.  A  system  of  charges  may  radiate  as  a 
magnetic  dipole  as  well  as  an  electric  dipole.  Magnetic  dipole  radiation 
is  usually  related  to  a  change  of  spin  projection  ka.  Since  the  spin  of 
an  electron  is  one-half,  the  angular  momentum  of  an  atom  changes 
by  unity  for  a  "flip"  of  the  spin  of  an  electron  and  for  an  unchanged 
orbital  angular  momentum.  The  moment  of  a  magnetic  dipole  quantum 
is  equal  to  unity  just  like  the  moment  of  an  electric  dipole  quantum. 
But  the  parities  of  the  electric  and  magnetic  quanta  are  reversed. 
Indeed,  the  components  of  electric  dipole  moment  change  signs  in  an 
inversion  of  the  coordinate  system  (31.35),  while  the  magnetic-moment 
components  do  not  change  signs  because  the  magnetic  moment,  like 
the  angular  momentum,  is  a  pseudovector  (see  Sec.  16). 

As  was  pointed  out  in  Sec.  19,  the  intensity  of  magnetic  dipole  ra- 
diation is  less  than  the  intensity  of  electric  dipole  radiation,  their 

ratio  being  l~-\  ,  where  v  is  the  charge  velocity  and  c  is  the  velocity 
of  light.  This  ratio  is  about  10*5  for  light  elements. 


Sec.  34]  THE  QUANTUM  THEORY  OF  RADIATION  367 

Quadrupole  radiation.  In  Sec.  19  it  was  shown  that  radiation  is 
possible  due  to  the  change  of  quadrupole  moment  for  the  system. 
Here,  electric  quadrupole  quanta  occurring  in  an  even  state  are  radiat- 
ed because  the  electric  quadrupole  moment  is  an  even  coordinate 
function.  The  angular  momentum  of  a  quadrupole  quantum  is  equal 
to  two. 

Quadrupole  radiation  can  occur  when  dipole  radiation  is  forbidden 
by  the  selection  rules.  From  Sec.  19,  quadrupole  radiation  is  obtained 
when  taking  into  account  the  retardation  inside  the  system.  The  order 
of  magnitude  of  this  retardation  is  determined  by  the  ratio  of  the  di- 
mensions of  the  system  to  the  wavelength  of  the  emitted  light.  There- 
fore, the  probability  of  quadrupole  radiation  is  less  than  the  proba- 
bility of  dipole  radiation  in  the  ratio  I—I  ,  where  r  is  the  size  of  the 

system. 

X~0.5x  10~4cm  for  visible  light  while  the  atomic  dimensions  are 
r~0.5x  10~8cm.  Therefore,  in  order  of  magnitude,  the  probability 
of  a  quadrupole  transition  is  1C8  times  less  than  the  probability  of  a 
dipole  transition. 

Metastable  atoms.  If  an  atom  can  go  from  an  excited  state  to  the 
ground  state  only  by  means  of  a  transition  which  is  forbidden  in  dipole 
radiation,  it  remains  excited  considerably  longer  than  for  a  dipole 
transition.  For  a  strong  forbiddence  it  may  remain  excited  for  a  very 
long  time  (even  on  the  ordinary  scale,  and  not  the  atomic  scale). 
Such  an  atom  is  termed  metastable.  Usually,  in  gases  which  are  not 
highly  rarefied  a  metastable  atom  gives  up  its  excitation  energy  to 
other  atoms  in  collisions  and  not  by  means  of  radiation.  Radiation  will 
then  not  be  observed.  But  in  highly  rarefied  matter,  for  example  in 
the  solar  corona  or  in  a  gaseous  nebula,  the  spectral  lines  due  to  the 
de-excitation  of  metastable  atoms  are  very  bright.  For  example,  in 
the  spectra  of  nebulae,  there  occurs  an  intense  magnetic  dipole  line 
of  doubly-ionized  oxygen  atoms. 

Nuclear  isomerism.  Transitions  with  very  large  A;  (up  to  5)  are 
observed  in  nuclei.  For  small  excitation  energies,  of  the  order  of  several 
tens  of  kilovolts,  metastable  nuclei  have  very  large  de-excitation 
times — days  or  months.  Such  nuclei  are  called  isomers  with  respect 
to  the  basic  unexcited  state  of  the  nucleus.  The  phenomenon  of  nuclear 
isomerism  in  artificially  radioactive  nuclei  was  first  discovered  by 
I.  V.  Kurchatov  and  L.  I.  Rusinov  (in  Br80). 

The  totally  forbidden  transition.  The  transition  from  j  =  0  to  j'  =  0, 
with  an  energy  of  1,414  kev  is  observed  in  the  RaC  nucleus.  Since  the 
radiation  in  this  case  is  completely  forbidden,  the  nucleus  simply 
ejects  an  electron  from  the  inner  atomic  shell  by  means  of  an  electro- 
static interaction;  this  may  be  explained  as  follows. 

If  an  internal  nuclear  rearrangement  occurs,  the  charge  distribution 
inside  it  somehow  changes.  For  a  0->0 — transition,  one  spherically 


308  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

symmetrical  charge  distribution  is  rearranged  into  another,  which  is 
also  symmetrical,  but  with  a  different  radial  dependence.  Therefore, 
in  accordance  with  Gauss'  theorem,  only  the  electric  field  inside  the 
nucleus  is  changed.  The  field  outside  the  nucleus  cannot  change;  for 
instance,  it  cannot  radiate  quanta.  The  wave  functions  of  the  ^-states 
of  the  electrons  differ  from  zero  in  the  nucleus.  It  follows  that  a  change 
of  field  inside  the  nucleus  is  capable  of  influencing  an  electron  and  im- 
parting to  it  an  energy  sufficient  for  ejection  from  the  atom.  In  accord- 
ance with  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy,  the  electron,  upon 
ejection  from  the  atom,  will  have  an  energy  equal  to  the  energy  differ- 
ence of  both  spherically  symmetrical  states  of  the  nucleus  minus 
the  binding  energy  in  the  atom. 

It  may  be  stated  generally  that  the  ejection  of  electrons  from  an 
atom  shortens  the  lifetime  of  metastable  isometric  nuclei,  since  it 
makes  transitions  more  possible. 

Sec.  35.  The  Atom  in  a  Constant  External  Field 

A  classical  analogue.  In  considering  the  behaviour  of  a  system  of 
charges  situated  in  an  external  magnetic  field,  it  is  very  convenient 
to  proceed  from  the  idea  of  the  Larmor  precession  of  magnetic  moment 
around  the  field.  The  only  component  of  the  angular  momentum  con- 
served in  such  precession  is  that  directed  along  the  field,  both  trans- 
versal components  averaged  over  the  precessional  motion  being 
zero. 

The  situation  in  quantum  mechanics  is  analogous,  with  the  differ- 
ence that  the  projections  perpendicular  to  the  field  do  not  exist  as 
physical  quantities.  In  this  way  a  simple  correspondence  is  established 
between  the  integrals  of  classical  and  quantum  mechanics.  The  angu- 
lar-momentum projection  on  the  magnetic  field  is  such  a  corresponding 
quantity;  it  can  be  called  a  quantum  integral  of  motion. 
*-  An  external  magnetic  field  superimposed  on  an  atom  perturbs  its 
state  in  a  definite  way.  The  Hamiltonian  operator  for  such  an  atom 
may  be  divided  into  the  operator  Jf^  for  the  unperturbed  atom  and 
the  perturbation  operator  J6  (1)  due  to  the  magnetic  field. 

Addition  of  magnetic  moments.  Let  us  first  of  all  write  down  the 
operator  JT(1)  explicitly.  It  was  shown  in  Sec.  32  that  spin  motion  does 
not  produce  the  same  magnetic  motion  as  orbital  motion,  namely,  the 
magnetic  moment  for  orbital  motion  is 


and   the  spin  magnetic  moment 

(35.2) 

\          ) 


Sec.  35]  THK    ATOM   IN  A   CONSTANT   EXTEHNAL  tflKLl)  309 

Therefore  the  total  magnetic  moment  is 

(35.3) 


Hence,  the  magnetic  moments  are  not  combined  according  to  the 
same  law  as  mechanical  moments: 

J-L  +  8.  (35.4) 

Comparing  (35.3)  and  (35.4),  we  see  that  the  magnetic  moment  of  an 
atom  is  not  proportional  to  its  mechanical  moment. 

In  accordance  with  (15.35),  the  perturbation  energy  caused  by  the 
magnetic  field  is  equal  to  (the  moments  are  expressed  in  h  units) 


=  (L  f  28)  =  tioH(J  +  8)  .  (35.5) 

Here  |X0  =  -j-^—  is   the   Bohr   magneton.   The  plus   sign  resulted 

because  the  charge  of  the  electron  is  —  e.  We  note  that  the  magnetic 
energy  in  expression  (15.35)  was  defined  as  a  correction  to  the  Hamil- 
tonian,  i.e.,  to  the  energy  expressed  in  terms  of  momenta.  Therefore, 
in  quantum  theory  it  is  directly  interpreted  in  terms  of  operators. 

The  vector  model  of  the  atom.  To  a  first  approximation,  the  energy 
correction  is  equal  to  the  mean  value  of  the  perturbing  energy  taken 
over  unperturbed  motion  [see  (33.31)].  Therefore,  we  first  find  the 
unperturbed  state  of  the  atom  without  the  superimposition  of  a  magnetic 
field.  Let  us  suppose  that  a  normal  coupling  exists  in  the  atom 
between  the  total  spin  and  the  total  orbital  angular  momentum 
(see  Sec.  33),  i.e.,  all  the  orbital  angular  momenta  of  the  electrons  are 
combined  in  one  resultant  orbital  angular  momentum  L,  and  all  the 
spin  angular  momenta  are  combined  in  one  resultant  spin  angular 
momentum  8.  Examples  of  such  orbital  and  spin  angular-momentum 
composition  were  given  in  Sec.  33  (in  the  text  and  in  the  exercises). 
For  example,  in  combining  the  angular  momenta  of  two  r&p-electrons, 
the  following  states  are  obtained:  1Z),  3P,  and  1S.  All  these  states  are 
formed  in  accordance  with  the  Pauli  principle,  and  possess  spatial 
wave  functions  of  different  forms.  For  this  reason,  in  all  three  states, 
the  energy  for  purely  electrostatic  electron  interactions  differs  by 
magnitudes  of  the  order  of  an  atomic  unit,  i.e.,  by  several  electron- 
volts. 

Let  us  choose  the  ground  state  of  these  states.  In  accordance  with 
Hund's  first  rule,  this  is  the  3P  state.  We  have  not  written  the  sub- 
script J  here  because  it  can  have  three  values:  J  =  2,  J=  1,  and  «/  =  0. 
Accordingly,  we  have  written  3  on  the  upper  left.  The  states  which 
differ  only  in  J,  for  identical  L  and  S,  are  considerably  closer  to  each 
other  than  the  three  states  with  differing  8  or  L  listed  above. 

Let  us  estimate  the  order  of  magnitude  for  multiplet  level  splitting, 
i.e.,  the  spacing  of  levels  with  different  J.  A  magnetic  field  of  moment 


370  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

(x  is  of  the  order  -~ ,  so  that  the  interaction  energy  of  two  moments  is 

2  ^* 

— 3- .  To  evaluate  the  order  of  magnitude  we  put  one  Bohr  magneton 

in  place  of  JJL,  i.e.,  10~20,  and  r^0.5  x  10~8.  This  results  in  an  inter- 
action energy  of  the  order  1Q-15,  i.e.,  thousandths  of  an  electron-volt 
(in  practice,  greater  multiplet  splitting  is  observed  due  to  larger  [i 
and  smaller  effective  radius  values).  In  any  case,  the  levels  3P2,  3P1? 
and  3P0,  which  are  comparatively  different  from  the  other  two  levels 
1D  and  1S9  occur  close  to  one  another.  The  3P  level  is  split  into  three 
fine-structure  levels  which,  in  the  given  case,  corresponds  to  the  super- 
script 3.  If  L<S,  the  number  of  components  of  the  multiplet  splitting 
is  determined  by  L. 

Each  of  the  levels  with  a  given  J  corresponds  to  a  definite  configu- 
ration of  the  vectors  L  and  S.  In  classical  theory,  we  would  say  that 
L  and  S  are  parallel  in  the  state  with  J  =  2,  antiparallel  for  J  =  0, 
and  perpendicular  for  J—1.  Of  course,  the  latter  one  is  not  at  all 
meaningful  in  quantum  theory  because  only  one  angular-momentum 
projection  exists.  The  projection  of  S  on  L  is  equal  to  zero  for  J  =  1, 
and  the  other  projections  do  not  exist. 

At  the  beginning  of  this  section  we  indicated  that,  in  the  classical 
analogy,  those  components  which  are  not  conserved  are,  in  some  way, 
averaged  over  the  Larmor  precession  of  angular  momenta  and  yield 
zero.  In  this  case,  we  are  not  concerned  with  precession  in  an  external 
magnetic  field,  but  with  that  in  the  internal  field  of  the  magnetic 
moments  themselves.  Since  J  is  an  exact  integral  of  motion  we  can,  in 
a  visual  demonstration,  consider  that  the  direction  of  J  is  fixed  in  space, 
while  the  triangle  consisting  of  the  vectors  L,  S,  and  J  processes  about 
J  in  space.  In  the  cases  for  which  J  =  2  and  J  —  0  the  triangle  degen- 
erates to  a  straight  line.  Thus,  to  each  of  the  multiplet  levels  there 
corresponds  a  definite  vector  model  given  by  L, 
S,  and  J.  We  note  that  this  refers  to  normal 
coupling. 

An  external  magnetic  field  H  causes  the 
vectors  L,  S  to  precess  about  its  direction.  It 
is  most  simple  here  to  consider  the  two  opposing 
limiting  cases.  We  shall  examine  them. 

A  weak  external  field.  Let  the  external  field 
be  weak  compared  with  the  effective  internal 
field  that  the  multiplet  level  splitting  is  due  to. 
Fig.  44  Since  the  Larmor  precession  frequency  is  propor- 

tional to  the  magnetic  field,  the  triangle  LS  J  in 

this  case  rotates  about  the  side  J  considerably  faster  than  the  precession 
about  H.  During  the  time  of  one  rotation  about  H,  the  triangle  can 
rotate  very  many  times  about  J.  Therefore,  the  coupling  of  the  vectors 
L,  8,  and  J  in  the  triangle  is  not  disrupted,  as  it  were,  due  to  the 
internal  magnetic  forces  forming  the  triangle  being  large  compared 


Sec.  35]  THE    ATOM   IN   A   CONSTANT  EXTERNAL   FIELD  371 

with  the  external  magnetic  force.  We  have  shown  this  idea  in 
Fig.  44. 

Let  us  now  find  the  correction  due  to  the  magnetic  field.  In  calculat- 
ing the  mean  value  of  the  perturbation  energy  from  the  unperturbed 
motion,  it  is  convenient  to  make  use  of  the  Larmor  precession  model. 
In  this  case,  two  forms  of  precession  must  be  considered:  the  triangle 
LSJ  about  i  and  the  precession  of  J  about  the  magnetic  field. 

Equation  (35.5)  involves  the  vectors  J  and  S.  It  is  very  simple  to 
average  J:  we  must  take  its  projection  on  the  magnetic  field  Jz.  We 
shall  consider  that  the  2-axis  coincides  with  the  direction  of  H.  The 
projection  of  8  upon  H  is  not  meaningful  because  the  vector  S  together 
with  the  triangle  LSJ  rotates  considerably  more  rapidly  about  J 
than  about  H.  The  component  S,  perpendicular  to  J,  is  averaged  by 
the  precession  in  motion  unperturbed  by  the  external  field.  There 
remains  the  projection  parallel  to  J  and  equal  to 

(35.6) 

/O  J\ 

Obviously,  the  projection  of  this  vector  upon  H  is  equal  to  Jx        '  . 


Thus,  the  mean  value  of  JdfM  is  proportional  to  Jx  and  is  equal  to 

.  (35.7) 


It  is  now  necessary  to  give  a  quantum  meaning  to  the  product 
(SJ).  From  the  definition  of  J  (35.4)  we  have 

L  =  J-S.  (35.8) 

Squaring  this  equation,  we  get 

(35.9) 


Expressing  the  square  of  the  angular  momentum  in  h  units,  in  accord- 
ance with  (30.29),  we  have 


Let  us  make  similar  substitutions  for  J2  and  S2.  Therefore 

(SJ) 
-~~ 


Substituting  (35.10)  in  (35.7)  we  obtain  finally 

.      (35.11) 


Thus,  the  fine-structure  level  with  a  given  J  is  split  into  as  many 
levels  as  there  are  different  projections  of  J  on  the  magnetic  field, 


372  (JUANTTM    MECHANIC'S  [l^U't    III 

i.e.,  2J  +  1  levels.  For  given  L  and  8,  the  following  definite  factor 
corresponds  to  each  value  of  J: 


,,_!    t 

g  ,„    1   -h 

It  is  called  the  Lande  factor. 

For  example,  for  L~-/Sy  —  J  =  l,  we  obtain 


Analogously,  for  «/-=2,  8~L  =  l 

7==1+  i  «-»:?.- 2.  =  :< 

^       X   1     2  6  2  ' 

Tho  level  with  J^O  does  not  split. 

Splitting  in  a  strong  field.  Tho  representation  of  splitting  set  out 
here  corresponds  to  reality  only  as  long  as  the  magnetic  field  is  so 
weak  that  the  spacing  between  the  2  J  +  l  levels  of  [LQyHJz  in  the 
magnetic  field  is  small  compared  with  that  between  the  unsplit  multi- 
plet levels  themselves  with  differing  J.  When  the  splitting  in  the  mag- 
netic field  is  comparable  with  that  of  the  multiplet  itself,  or  is  somewhat 
greater,  the  pattern  becomes  more  complicated,  but  in  a  strong  field  it 
once  again  becomes  very  simple. 

Therefore  we  shall  consider  the  opposite  extreme  case,  when  the 
external  field  is  strong  compared  with  the  internal  field,  so  that 
the  coupling  between  the  vectors  L,  S,  3  in  the  triangle  is  disrupted. 
The  necessity  for  this  disruption  in  a  sufficiently  strong  magnetic 
field  can  bo  explained  by  the  fact  that  S  processes  twice  as  fast  as  L. 
Then,  from  the  classical  analogy,  each  of  the  vectors  S  and  L  processes 
independently  about  the  magnetic  field,  so  that  the  correction  to 
the  energy  is  given  by  a  different  expression  from  (35.11): 

«?U)  =  jff(V  =  ^eH(Lz  +  2SZ) .  (35.13) 

Here  Lz  is  the  projection  of  the  orbital  angular  momentum  upon 
the  z-axis,  and  Sz  is  the  total-spin  projection  of  the  atom  upon  the 
same  axis  (in  h  units).  Naturally,  the  total  values  of  L  and  S  are  not 
changed  by  the  magnetic  field,  though  the  distribution  of  levels 
in  a  strong  magnetic  field  is  not  related  to  the  multiplet  structure, 
as  was  the  case  in  a  weak  field,  but  only  with  the  possible  projections 
of  L  and  S  on  the  magnetic  field.  The  vectors  L  and  8  precess  about 
the  field  far  more  rapidly  than  they  precess  about  3  without  the 
field.  This  is  why  the  coupling  in  the  triangle  is  disrupted. 

The  projections  Sz  and  Lz  are  changed  by  unity,  therefore  all 
the  levels  #W  in  expression  (35.13)  are  equidistant.  Of  course,  certain 
values  of  gM  may  be  repeated  several  times  if  the  sum  LZ  +  2SZ 
assumes  the  same  value  in  several  ways.  For  example,  if  L  =  1,  #==  1, 


tSec.  35]  THE    ATOM   IN    A    CONSTANT    KXTEHNAL    F1KLD  373 

then  we  get  the  following  range  of  values  of  the  sum :  1+2  =  3, 
0  +  2-2,  1+0  =  1,  —  1+2  =  1,0  +  0  =  0,  —  1+0=  —  1,1  —  2=— 1, 
0  —  2  — —  2,  — 1  —  2=  —  3;  there  are  in  all  seven  equidistant 
values,  and  1  and  —  1  are  obtained  in  two  ways  (i.e.,  each  of  them 
from  the  confluence  of  two  levels),  so  that  there  are  nine  states  in 
all.  We  note  that  in  a  weak  field  the  same  multiplet  split  thus :  J  =  2 
into  5  levels,  J  =  l  into  3  levels  and  J  =  0  did  not  split.  As  was  to 
be  expected,  the  total  number  of  different  states  in  the  strong  and 
weak  fields  is  the  same. 

The  radiation  spectrum  for  level  splitting  in  a  strong  field.  Let  us 

now  see  what  spectral  lines  appear  when  light  is  emitted  from  an 
atom  situated  in  a  magnetic  field.  To  begin  with,  let  us  consider  a 
strong  field,  because  the  pattern  of  the  splitting  of  spectral  lines  is 
simpler  in  this  case  than  in  that  of  a  weak  field.  Both  levels,  upper 
and  lower,  resulting  from  two  multiple ts  are  split  into  a  certain 
number  of  equidistant  levels  in  accordance  with  formula  (35.13). 
Let  the  radiation  be  observed  in  a  direction  perpendicular  to  the 
magnetic  field.  The  radiation  polarization  vector  is  perpendicular 
to  the  direction  of  propagation,  i.e.,  it  is  either  directed  along  the 
magnetic  field  or  in  a  third  perpendicular  direction,  say  along  the 
a:-axis  (the  magnetic  field  is  along  the  z-axis).  The  selection  rules 
for  radiation  polarized  along  z  and  along  x  are  different.  For  polari- 
zation along  the  z-axis,  the  orbital  magnetic  quantum  number  must 
be  conserved.  Sz  is  also  conserved  for  all  polarization  in.  which  the 
spin-orbital  interaction  is  neglected.  Therefore,  all  Hues  polarized 
along  the  z-axis,  i.e.,  along  the  magnetic  field,  have  the  same  frequency, 
which  corresponds  to  the  energy  difference  of  the  two  initial  levels 
<^i  —  <^o  prior  to  splitting  in  the  magnetic  field:  the  correction  (35.13) 
is  cancelled  in  calculating  the  difference  <?W  —  ^j,n.  A  wave  pol- 
arized along  the  #-axis  can  be  represented  as  the  sum  of  two  waves 
circularly  polarized  with  opposite  directions  of  polarization.  Tho 
selection  rule  for  these  lines  is  that  k  can  change  only  by  -_L  1.  Con- 
sequently, the  radiation  polarized  along  the  #-axis  has  a  frequency 

that  differs  from  the  initial  frequency  by   db  -£ — .  In  observing 

the  spectral  lines  emitted  perpendicularly  to  a  strong  magnetic  field, 
the  original  line  is  thus  split  into  three  lines  separated  by  an  interval 
which  is  equal  to  the  Larmor  frequency  for  the  given  field. 

If  we  drill  a  hole  in  the  shoe  of  an  electromagnet  it  is  possible  to 
observe  radiation  propagated  along  the  magnetic  field.  It  is  circularly 
polarized  in  the  #y-plane.  The  selection  rules  for  right-  and  left-hand 
circular  polarization  correspond  to  a  change  of  k  by  ±  1,  so  that 

there  will  be  observed  two  lines  spaced  from  the  centre  by  ±  ~ — . 

£<  fY\i  C 

Thus,  when  the  field  is  switched  on,  the  original  line  will  split  into 
two  Ijnes  separated  by  an  interval  equal  to  twice  the  Larmor  frequency. 


374  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part    III 

Exactly  the  same  picture  is  found  in  the  classical  oscillatory  motion 
of  a  charge  situated  in  a  magnetic  field.  This  problem  was  considered 
in  exercise  6,  Sec.  21. 

The  effect  of  the  splitting  of  spectral  lines  in  a  magnetic  field 
was  discovered  by  Zeeman  before  the  quantum  theory  of  the  atom 
appeared.  Therefore,  the  then  accepted  theoretical  explanation  of 
the  Zeeman  effect  corresponded  to  the  classical  problem,  where  it 
was  considered  that  the  charge  performs  an  oscillatory  motion. 

However,  in  observing  spectra,  this  classical  picture  applies  only 
in  strong  magnetic  fields  such  that  the  splitting  of  lines  obtained 
is  considerably  greater  than  the  spacing  between  multiplet  levels. 
Under  these  conditions  the  Zeeman  effect  is  termed  normal,  because 
outwardly  it  corresponds  to  the  theoretical  ideas  of  the  time  at  which 
it  was  discovered.  It  may  be  noticed  that  a  field  which  is  strong 
for  one  multiplet  can  still  be  weak  for  another. 

Spectral-line  splitting  in  a  weak  magnetic  field.  The  Zeeman  effect 
in  a  weak  magnetic  field  is  termed  anomalous.  A  spectral  pattern 
is  obtained  which  is  entirely  different  from  the  classical.  First  of  all, 
the  number  of  splitting  components  can  differ  from  the  normal. 
The  distances  between  them  are  also  quite  different. 

As  an  example  let  us  consider  the  anomalous  Zeeman  effect  in 
the  so-called  D-line  doublet  of  sodium.  This  line  is  double  without 
an  external  magnetic  field.  It  corresponds  to  the  two  transitions 
2Pi->2$t  and2Pa->2$i.  The  2P  level  has  an  orbital  angular  momen- 

2"  2  1    ~2  2~ 

turn  1  and  spin  -^  .  Therefore,  the  resultant  value  of  the  total  angular 

13  11 

momentum  J  can  be  1  +  -^  =  -0-  and  1  --  ~  —  -5-  .  This  is  where  we 

2t          2i  2i  Zt 

get  the  fine  doublet  structure  of  the  2P  level  in  the  absence  of  an 
external  field.  The  2$  level  cannot  split  without  a  field  because  it 
has  an  orbital  angular  momentum  of  zero.  The  double  Z)-liiie  in  the 
sodium  spectrum  arises  in  the  transition  from  the  doublet  level 
to  the  single.  According  to  our  rough  estimate  of  the  fine-structure 
splitting,  the  difference  in  frequency  between  its  components  amounts 
to  about  one  thousandth  of  the  mean  frequency  of  the  doublet. 
The  2Px  level  is  lower  than  the  2P^  level. 

2  2 

Let  us  now  calculate  the  Lande  factor  for  three  levels. 


JL  V*  •  Vi  +  V*  •  V.  -  i  il  _  _* 

2      •  ~»7,  •••/,•*  ~       3 


2) 


Sec.  36  J  THE    ATOM   IN   A    CONSTANT   EXTERNAL   FIELD  375 

3)  «&,,:     J  =  1lt,     i  =  0,     5  =  Vi. 

rt-14.    J     Vt-Vi  +  Vl-Vl    _0 

(7-1  +  T  ---  i^  -----  2. 

In  accordance  with  equation  (35.11),  we  have  an  expression  for 
the  energy  of  the  2P_a_  state  in  a  magnetic  field.  For  conciseness  we 

shall  denote  the  quantity  [LQH  by  the  single  letter  p.  Then 


But  Jz  takes  on  four  values:  3/2,  1/2,  —  1/2,  —  3/2.  Hence,  in  a  field, 
the  *P±  level  splits  into  four  levels,  whose  energy  differences  from 

the  central,  unperturbed,  state  are 


respectively. 

We   obtain  two  energy  values  for   the   2Pj^  fine-structure  level: 


2 

V2)  =      P  • 


And,  finally,  for  the  lower  2S±  level,  we  get 


2 


Let  us  now  find  the  spectral  pattern.  We  start  with  the  2P_^  ->  2S± 

transitions.  The  oscillations  polarized  along  the  field  obey  the  se- 
lection rule  AJ*  —  0.  Hence,  their  frequencies  are  shifted  relative 
to  the  central  position  by 


and  by 

/,  ,  V2)  -      P  ~  P  =  - 


Unlike  the  normal  Zeeman  effect,  a  double  line  has  been  obtained 
also  for  radiation  polarized  along  the  magnetic  field. 
For  perpendicular  polarizations  we  have 

•/.)  =  — J-P-P- -4e 


--          *  - 


-J-  P  +  P  =  4 


376 


QUANTUM    MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


Let  us  take  the  transition  2Pjr-*2&±*  If  the  oscillation  is   polarized 

2  2 

along  the  field  we  once  again  have,  of  course,  two  lines,  though  with 
other  spacing: 


V.) 


,,,  ,   _  i/a)  =  -  3-  p  +  p  =  y  p  , 

>  Vi)  =  --  P  -  P  -  -     P  - 


We  have,  for  both  circular  polarizations: 


These  are  the  results  for  right-handed  polarization.  The  corresponding 

rj 

splitting  for  left-handed  polarization  is  p  and  ^  p. 

Thus,  one  component  of  the  ZMine  is  split  into  six  Zeemaii  compo- 
nents, and  the  other  into  four. 

In  the  given  case,  the  Zeeman  effect  remains  anomalous  as  long 
as  p  is  negligibly  small  compared  with  one  thousandth  of  a  volt, 

or  the  magnetic  field  is  very  much 
*A  loss  than  5,000  CGSE  units. 

A  diagram  of  the  splitting  is  shown 
in  Fig.  45. 

The    atom    in    an    electric    field 
(Stark  effect).  The  multiplet  levels 

*/fe       ,_,,_ . %  f°r  a  certain  total  angular  momen- 

~J/z  turn  J  split  in  an  electric  field,  too. 

tt>U)  We   shall  consider   first  of  all  the 

a/o!)  '    '    '   J    case  of  a  weak  field,  when  the  level 
*P% — *~*Si£  shift  caused  by  the  field  is  small 
compared    with    natural    multiplet 
splitting. 

First   of  all,    we   must    bear    in 
t  mind  that  the  angular-momentum 
projection   on   the  electric   field   is 
determined  only  within  the  accuracy 
Fig.  45  of  the    sign,   because    the    angular 

momentum  is  a  pseudovector  while 

the  electric  field  is  a  real  vector.  In  reversing  all  the  coordinate  signs, 
the  angular-momentum  components  change  sign  while  the  electric- 
field  components  do  not  change  sign.  But  since  the  choice  of  right- 
handed  or  left-handed  coordinate  system  is  arbitrary,  the  projections 
of  the  angular  momenta  on  the  electric  field  are  physically  deter- 
mined only  to  the  accuracy  of  the  sign.  If  J  is  an  integer,  the  number 


~& 


Sec.  35J  THE    ATOM    IN    A    CONSTANT    JSXTKRNAL    FIELD  377 

of  its  projections  which  differ  in  absolute  value  is  equal  to  J+l 
(0,  1,  ...,«/),  while  if  J  is  a  half-integral  number  then  the  total  number 

of  projections  is  :  J  -f  y  ly  ,  y  ,  .  .  .  ,  Jl  .  For  example,  if  J  =  y,  there 
is  only  one  nonnegative  projection.  Therefore,  the  state  with  angular 
momentum  -^  is  not  split  by  an  electric  field,  at  any  rate  as  long 
as  the  coupling  between  L  and  S  is  not  disrupted.  For  comparison 
we  note  that  the  magnetic  field  splits  the  state  witli  J~-  9  into  two 

states  because  the  magnetic  field,  like  the  angular  momentum,  is 
a  pseudovector. 

In  a  stronger  electric  field  the  coupling  between  L  and  8  is  disrupted. 
In  this  case  the  scheme  of  splitting  is  the  following.  The  vector  L 
is  integral.  It  has  L  +  l  projections  on  the  electric  field.  We  must 
project  8  onto  its  projection.  But  since  L  and  S  are  both  pseudovectors, 
the  number  of  projections  of  S  upon  L  is  already  equal  to  2$  +  l. 
The  only  exception  is  when  the  projection  of  L  upon  the  field  is  equal 

to  zero.  This  level  splits  into  $  +  1  or  $+-£-  levels  according  to  8. 

The  square-law  Stark  effect.  The  amount  of  splitting  is  determined 
by  the  relative  shift  of  neighbouring  levels.  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  33 
(33.  31  a),  the  shift  of  an  energy  level  is  equal  to  the  average  of  the 
perturbation  energy  for  unperturbed  motion.  Proceeding  from  (14.28), 
we  have  the  following  expression  for  the  perturbation  energy  in 
a  homogeneous  electric  field 


(35.14) 

But  it  is  easy  to  see  that  the  average  of  this  quantity  is  equal  to 
zero.  Indeed,  the  wave  function  of  an  atomic  state  with  given  / 
is  always  odd  or  even  (with  the  exception  of  hydrogen,  see  below). 
Therefore,  the  product  t^y  fyj  must  be  even.  From  (30.24),  the  average 
of  ^f^  is  equal  to 

(35.15) 


But  the  integrand  is  an  odd  function,  so  that  its  integral  is  identically 
equal  to  zero. 

Level  splitting  is  obtained  only  to  a  second  approximation,  if 
into  (35.15)  we  substitute  wave  functions  which  have  already  been 
perturbed  by  the  external  field.  This  splitting  is  governed  by  a  square- 
law  field  dependence. 

The  linear  Stark  effect.  In  a  hydrogen  atom  the  electron  energy 
depends  only  upon  the  principal  quantum  number  n  and  does  not 
depend  upon  L  Therefore,  the  state  with  <?=<fn  is  represented  as 
a  superposition  of  states  with  I  varying  from  0  to  n  —  1.  But  the  wave 
function  is  even  for  even  /,  and  odd  for  odd  L  Hence,  the  function 


378  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

with  $  =  & n  does  not  have  a  definite  parity,  so  that  the  integral 
(35.15)  does  not  become  zero.  Therefore,  in  the  hydrogen  atom  we 
observe  line  splitting  which  depends  linearly  upon  the  electric  field.  * 

Highly  excited  atomic  states  always  more  or  less  resemble  hydrogen- 
atom  states,  because  the  nucleus  and  the  atomic  residue  act  upon 
an  electron,  which  has  receded  far  from  the  nucleus,  in  a  way  similar 
to  a  point  charge.  The  energies  of  these  states  depend  upon  I  in  ac- 
cordance with  the  expression  (31.46).  These  states  give  a  linear 
Stark  effect  if  the  perturbation  produced  by  the  field  shifts  the  levels 
more  strongly  than  they  are  split  in  I. 

lonization  of  the  atom  by  a  constant  field.  A  constant  electric  field 
not  only  shifts  the  energy  levels  of  an  atom,  but  also  qualitatively 
changes  its  whole  state. 

Let  us  write  down  the  potential  energy  of  an  electron  in  an  atom 
situated  in  an  external  electric  field  E  which  is  directed  along  the 
z-axis : 

U  =  UQ(r)+eEz.  (35.16) 

For  a  sufficiently  large  and  negative  z  the  potential  energy  far  away 
from  the  atom  is  less  than  in  the  atom.  The  potential  well  in  the  atom 
is  separated  from  the  region  of  large  negative  z  (where  the  potential 
energy  can  be  still  less)  by  a  potential  barrier.  But  there  is  always 
the  probability  of  a  spontaneous  electron  transition  through  the 
potential  barrier  into  the  free  state.  Transitions  of  this  type  were 
considered  in  Sec.  28  as  applied  to  alpha  disintegration. 

Any  state  of  an  atom  put  in  a  constant  electric  field  may  be  ionized, 
but,  naturally,  if  the  field  is  weak  the  probability  of  ioiiization  be- 
comes vanishingly  small.  In  a  strong  field  the  potential  barrier  be- 
comes transparent,  especially  for  highly  excited  atomic  states.  If 
the  time  for  the  spontaneous  ejection  of  an  electron  in  such  a  state 
turns  out  to  be  less  than  the  radiation  time,  the  corresponding  line 
in  the  spectrum  disappears. 

Thus,  a  weak  perturbation  inside  an  atom  (the  atomic  unit  of  field 

intensity  E  =  ^4—  —  5.13- 109  v/cm,   so  that  the  external  field  is 

always  small  compared  with  the  atomic  field)  essentially  affects 
the  state  since  the  conditions  at  infinity  change.  But  if  the  broadening 
of  the  atomic  levels  is  still  small  compared  with  the  distance  between 
them,  they  can  be  regarded,  as  before,  as  discrete. 

Exercise 

Construct  a  diagram  for  the  splitting  of  the  multiplet  3JP->3£  and  the 
transitions  in  a  strong  and  weak  magnetic  field. 


*  The  relativistic  expression  (38.28)  for  the  energy  of  a  hydrogen  atom 
involves  n  and  /.  The  orbital  angular  momentum  I  =  /  ±  */2  for  a  given  /, 
so  that  a  state  with  given  n  and  /  (in  the  same  way  as  to  a  nonrelativistic 
approximation)  does  not  have  definite  parity  and  yields  a  linear  Stark  effect. 


Sec.  36]  QUANTUM   THEORY    OF    DISPERSION  379 

Sec.  36.  Quantum  Theory  of  Dispersion 

The  classical  theory  of  dispersion,  a  brief  outline  of  which  was 
given  in  exercise  19,  Sec.  16,  proceeds  from  the  concept  of  a  charge 
elastically  bound  in  an  atom.  The  forced  oscillations  of  these  charges 
under  the  action  of  a  sinusoidally  varying  field  lead  to  an  electrical 
polarization  of  the  medium  proportional  to  the  field.  Whence  the 
dielectric  constant  can  be  easily  calculated  as  a  function  of  the  fre- 
quency. 

The  classical  theory  of  dispersion  is  in  good  agreement  with  ex- 
periment. Yet,  at  the  present  time  it  is  well  known  that  the  charges 
in  atoms  are  by  no  means  bound  by  elastic  forces.  For  this  reason, 
the  success  of  classical  dispersion  theory  may  appear  incomprehensible. 

Even  though  the  charges  are  not  bound  by  elastic  forces,  there  exist 
quantities,  relating  to  the  motion  of  the  charges,  which  vary  har- 
monically with  time:  these  are  the  coordinate  matrix  elements 
[see  (34.18)].  Similar  harmonic  oscillations  occur,  as  is  well  known, 
in  the  classical  mechanics  of  elastically  bound  particles.  The  dipole 
moment  of  an  atom,  induced  by  an  external  alternating  field,  is 
expressed  in  terms  of  the  dipole-moment  matrix  elements  directly 
related  to  the  coordinate  matrix  elements.  In  the  present  section, 
a  quantum  theory  of  dispersion  will  be  formulated  which  will  lead 
to  the  same  expression  for  dielectric  constant  as  classical  theory; 
it  will  also  indicate  which  quantities  should  correspond  to  each 
other  in  both  theories. 

The  wave  equation  for  an  atom  in  a  given  field  of  radiation.  In 

order  to  calculate  the  dipole  moment  induced  by  a  field,  we  must 
first  of  all  determine  the  wave  function  of  the  atom  in  the  external 
field.  In  contrast  to  the  previous  section,  where  the  behaviour  of 
an  atom  in  a  constant  external  field  was  studied,  we  shall  here  con- 
sider the  interaction  of  an  atom  with  an  alternating  external  field 
which  varies  according  to  the  law 

E:=E0cosco*.  (36.1) 

It  turns  out  to  be  more  convenient  here  to  write  down  the  field, 
straightway  in  real  form  instead  of  taking  the  real  part  of  the  final 
result  in  order  to  have  a  real  Hamiltonian. 

The  wavelength  of  a  light  ray  is  rightly  considered  large  compared 
with  atomic  dimensions  (this  was  confirmed  by  the  estimate  in  Sec.  34), 
so  that  the  field  E  may  be  considered  homogeneous:  its  phase  is 
constant  over  the  whole  atom. 

We  determined  the  energy  for  a  system  of  charges  in  an  external 
homogeneous  field  in  Sec.  14  [see  (14.28)  and  (35.14)].  The  correction 
to  the  Hamiltonian — due  to  a  homogeneous  electric  field — looks  like 

—  (dE).  (36.2) 


380  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  |  Part    III 


If  we  call  the  Hamiltonian  of  an  unperturbed  system    fW,  then 
Schrodinger's  equation  will  be  of  the  form 


Separating  the  wave  function  into  an  unperturbed  part  ^<°)  and 
a  perturbation  ^<1)>  and  regarding  the  perturbation  as  relatively 
small,  we  obtain  an  equation  which  we  have  already  used  in  Sec.  34: 


_     -         - 

%  (j  t 

Expansion  in  eigenfunctions.  We  seek  the  unknown  function  i]/l> 
in  the  form  of  a  wave  function  expansion  with  time-dependent  co- 
efficients : 

«j,a>=2>»^0).  (36.5) 

n 

We  obtained  an  equation  in  (34.7),  Sec.  34,  for  the  expansion 
coefficients 

-**£=  f  W&^dV.  (36.6) 

The  right-hand  side  of  this  equation  depends  upon  time  in  a  different 
way  from  that  in  equation  (34.7),  because  the  perturbation  operator 
jfrM  involves  time  explicitly  [see  (36.1)].  Let  us  consider  that  the 
unperturbed  state  of  the  atom  is  its  ground  state,  which  we  shall 
write  with  a  subscript  0,  i.e.,  ^0<°>.  Then  there  will  simply  be  the 
matrix  element  dofl  on  the  right-hand  side  of  (36.6)  multiplied  by 
—  E0  cos  w£.  The  time  dependence  for  the  matrix  element  was  found 
in  Sec.  34.  Using  the  notation  (34.20)  we  can  write 

dow^e'^iiod'oi,.  (36.7) 

The  representation  of  a  matrix  element  together  with  its  time  de- 
pendence is  termed  the  Heisenberg  representation,  and  that  without 
the  dependence,  in  the  form  d'0«,  is  the  Schrodinger  representation. 
Substituting  (36.7)  in  (36.6)  we  obtain 

-  TlfiT  =  ~  Y  (e'(M  +  Wfld>/  +  C'(W|I°"  w)0  (Eod'on)  .         (36.8) 

In  order  to  integrate  this  equation  we  must  impose  a  certain  initial 
condition  upon  c«.  It  is  natural  to  suppose  that  the  external  field 
acts  for  a  sufficiently  long  time  so  that  ail  the  transition  processes 
related  to  turning  on  the  field  do  not  affect  the  states.  We  can  assume, 
for  example,  that  the  external  field  depends  upon  time  according 
to  the  law: 


Sec.  ,'J()J  QUANTUM   THEORY   OF   D  [Sl'KItSlOM  381 

cos6>£     for     £<0, 


, 
E-Eocoseo*         for     *^0,  (        ' 

i.e.,  the  amplitude  gradually  rises  with  time  to  the  value  E0.  This 
law  for  the  change  of  the  field  must  be  substituted  into  (36.8),  inte- 
gration performed  from  —  oo  to  any  t,  and  a  must  tend  to  zero. 
After  this,  at  each  instant  of  time  (t  <  0  or  £>  0)  there  will  be  a  single 
dependence  of  cn  upon  t: 

i    /  P  l  (a)*jO  ~  °)  ' 

Cn  =  ™     ~-   --  h 
2h   \     w/iO~  w 

Induced  dipole  moment.  The  mean  value  of  the  dipole  moment 
is  calculated  according  to  the  general  formula  (30.24)  for  mean  values: 


=  J 


(36.11) 


The  quadratic  term  in  <J/l>  must,  of  course,  be  discarded,  since 
the  calculations  are  performed  to  the  accuracy  of  terms  proportional 

to  E  in  the  first  degree.  In  addition,  the  term    j^(o)*d<J/0)^F   does 

not  depend  at  all  upon  E  and,  therefore,  is  irrelevant  to  the  problem 
of  polarization  produced  b>  an  external  field.  Also,  this  term  is  usually 
equal  to  zero,  as  indicated  in  the  previous  section  in  connection  with 
the  expression  (35.15).  Hence,  the  mean  dipole  moment  responsible 
for  dispersion  is 

d  =  J  (4/<>)*  d^1)  +  ^(1>*d^(°))dF.  (36.12) 

We  shall  substitute  here  the  expansion  (36.5)  and  integrate  the 
series  term  by  term: 

a  = 

The  integrals  involved  here  are  once  again  dipole  -moment  matrix 
elements.  Substituting  their  expressions  from  (36.7),  we  write  the 
mean  dipole  moment  as 

d~  -  J£W  "to*'  d',l0  +  c*e-"1>0"'  d'0,,)  .  (36.14) 

n 

With  the  aid  of  expression  (36.10),  we  finally  obtain  for  cn: 


(36.15) 

w/,0  *}-  eo 


Here  we  could  already  have  written  d«0  in  place  of  d^0,  because  the 
time  factors  of  d,,0  and  d0/J  cancel. 


382  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Polarization.  In  order  to  calculate  the  polarization  of  atoms  by 
a  light-wave  field,  it  is  sufficient  to  know  only  the  dipole  moment 
projection  on  the  field.  If,  for  example,  the  electric  field  of  an  incident 
wave  is  directed  along  the  #-axis,  then  the  expression  (36.15)  involves 
only  angular-momentum  transition  components  directed  along  the 
cc-axis,  i.e.,  the  matrix  elements  of  x: 


-'l  £[(-±± 

2h  *-*  \\  co,,o  — 


-  --      - 

2h  *-*  \\  co,,o  —  o>  coM0  4-  co 

n 


(36.16) 


We  have  made  use  of  the  Hermitian  nature  of  matrix  elements 
expressed  by  the  relationship  (34.15).  In  other  words,  we  have  put 
|%,  |2  in  place  of  xQnxnQ. 

Now,  by  performing  a  simple  algebraical  transformation  and 
introducing  the  electric  field  E  itself  instead  of  its  amplitude  7£0, 
we  have: 

^        yt  2coM0e2|a?OM|  2  v  /Q«17\ 

d  =  L    *«-«')    E  '  (36J7) 

n 

The  dispersion  formula.  Let  us  consider  the  polarization  of  a  medium 
P  =  N&,  where  N  is  the  number  of  atoms  in  unit  volume.*  The  electric 
induction  is  related  to  the  electric  field  and  polarization  by  the  relation- 
ship (16.23)  which,  in  the  given  case,  is  of  the  form 


D  =  E  +  47UP  =    l  +  JTyE  -         <36-18) 

n 

But    D—  sE   from  the  definition  of  dielectric   constant,   so  that 

c  =  i  +  I^JT  2y^ia  .  (36.19) 

h       WMO 

We  note  that  this  expression  is  correct  only  when  the  frequency 
of  the  incident  radiation  is  not  close  to  one  of  the  natural  frequencies 
of  the  atom  <o,,0.  Otherwise  the  denominator  in  (36.19),  and  cor- 
respondingly in  all  the  previous  equations  up  to  (36.10),  can  become 
zero  ;  in  any  case,  it  becomes  small.  But  then  the  perturbation  caused 
by  the  field  is  large,  and  it  cannot  be  regarded  as  weak,  utilizing 
the  expansion  ^^^(oj+^d)  and  neglecting  |  ^  |2.  Physically,  this 
means  that  if  the  frequency  of  the  incident  light  is  close  to  the  fre- 
quency of  one  of  the  absorption  lines  (or,  what  is  just  the  same, 
the  emission  lines),  we  must  take  into  account  the  damping  in  the 
amplitude  of  the  excited  atomic  states  due  to  radiation.  In  other 


*  Such  additivity  of  dipole  moments  is  true  only  for  gases. 


See.  36J  QUANTUM   THEORY   OF   DISPKRSION  383 

words,  the  amplitudes  of  the  excited  atomic  states  must  not  be  taken 
with  a  purely  imaginary  time  dependence,  but  of  the  form  (28.14): 

>  =    -  •§£-<•¥-  (36.20) 


The  quantum  evaluation  of  F«  for  radiation  damping  is  rather 
complicated,  and  we  shall  not  deal  with  it. 

A  comparison  of  classical  and  quantum  dispersion  formulae.  We 
shall  now  go  over  to  a  comparison  of  the  quantum  formula  of  dispersion 
(36.19)  and  the  classical  formula.  We  shall  write  the  latter  for  the  case 
when  there  are  many  types  of  oscillation  whose  frequencies  are  tono 
(instead  of  a  single  frequency  co0).  We  shall  separate  the  total  number 
of  oscillators  N  into  parts  corresponding  to  each  separate  frequency  cono  : 

N  =ZNn  .  (36.21) 

n 

If  we  introduce  the  relative  fractions  of  each  oscillation  by  the  formula 

fn^%',  (36.22) 

then  it  is  obvious  that 

1  •  (36.23) 


Let  us  suppose  that  the  frequency  of  the  incident  radiation  is 
not  close  to  any  one  of  the  natural  frequencies  COMO.  Then  the  classical 
dispersion  formula  is  generalized  to  the  case  of  many  frequencies 
in  the  following  way: 

' 


e  =  1  +     7  zfn     a  .  (36.24) 

1  vn.         ^-J     /.\2     —   ,.v2  \  ' 


m 


Comparing  it  with  the  quantum  formula  of  dispersion  (36.19), 
we  see  that  both  formulae  become  identical  if  we  put 

|2.  (36.25) 

But  to  make  this  equation  meaningful  we  must,  in  accordance 
with  (36.23),  impose  upon  the  right-hand  side  of  (36.25)  the  condition 

=  1-  <36-26> 

« 

Let  us  prove  that  this  is  actually  what  occurs.  To  do  so  we  write 
the  commutation  relation  between  px  and  x  [see  (29.3)] 

.  (36.27) 


384:  QUANTUM    MECHANICS  [Part  HI 

We  multiply  it  by  ^5  on  the  left  and  ^0  on  the  right  (we  omit  the 
upper  index  0)  and  integrate  over  the  whole  volume.  We  can  take 
advantage  of  the  normalization  condition  on  the  right-hand  side 

of  the  equality,  i.e.,  of  the  fact  that  (|  <p0  1  2  ^  ^  ^  1: 

J  ftpxxhd  V  -  J  ^Qxp^d  V  -  \  .  (36.28) 


We  expand  the  products  x^Q  and  ^x  in  an  eigenf  unction  series 
according  to  the  general  formula  (30.8): 


(36.29) 

The  expansion  coefficients  are  determined  from  (30.11): 

an  -  J  <K#<M  V  ;  a:  =  |  foxtynd  V  .  (36.30) 


In  other  words,  they  are  equal  to  the  matrix  elements  a?0«.  Now, 
substituting  the  expansion  (36.29)  into  (36.28),  we  obtain 

*  .  (36.31) 

But  this  expression  contains  the  momentum  matrix  elements,  which 
can  be  replaced  by  coordinate  matrix  elements  by  equation  (34.21): 


J   fyoPxfynd  V  ^  (px)nQ  =  i 
J   fynP*fyod  V  =  (px)Qn 


After  this  substitution,  equality  (36.31)  can  be  easily  reduced  to 
the  required  form  (36.26)  if  we  take  advantage  of  the  fact  that  xno  =xon 
and  o)0«  =  —  6)«0. 

We  note  that  the  oscillator  fractions  /»  (they  are  also  called  '  'oscilla- 
tor forces")  are  proportional  to  the  same  matrix  elements  as  are  involved 
in  the  probabilities  of  radiation  or  absorption  of  the  appropriate 
quanta.  Therefore,  the  dispersion  properties  of  a  substance  may  be 
associated  with  the  intensity  of  the  spectral  lines  emitted  by  it. 

Incoherent  scattering.  In  addition  to  the  dipole  moment  d  deter- 
mined by  equation  (36.11),  we  can  also  calculate  the  transition 
moments  corresponding  to  radiation  with  a  frequency  which  is  less 
than  that  of  the  incident  light.  In  other  words,  we  can  calculate  the 
intensity  of  light  scattering  with  a  change  of  frequency.  Such  scattering 
is  termed  incoherent. 

A  very  important  case  is  when  the  radiation  energy,  which  remains 
in  the  substance  upon  incoherent  scattering,  contributes  to  exciting 


See.  37]  QUANTUM  THEORY  OF  SCATTERING  385 

the  oscillatory  motion  of  the  molecules.  This  phenomenon  was  dis- 
covered by  L.  1.  Mandelshtam  together  with  G.  S.  Landsberg  and, 
independently,  by  Raman.  It  is  frequently  accompanied  by  the  exci- 
tation of  oscillations  which  do  not  manifest  themselves  in  the  direct 
absorption  of  quanta  as  a  result  of  the  appropriate  selection  rules  for 
molecular  oscillations.  In  this  case,  incoherent  scattering  yields  im- 
portant information  concerning  the  molecular  structure  of  substances. 

Sec.  37.  Quantum  Theory  of  Scattering 

The  effective  cross-section  concept  in  quantum  theory.  The  concept 
of  an  effective  scattering  cross -section  of  particles,  which  was  denned 
in  Sec.  6  in  terms  of  classical  mechanics,  is  directly  extended  to 
quantum  mechanics.  Indeed,  the  differential  effective  scattering 
cross-section  of  the  particles  inside  a  given  solid  angle  is  the  ratio 
of  the  number  of  scattered  particles  in  this  element  of  angle  to  the 
flux  density  of  the  incident  particles.  Since  flux  and  flux  density 
can  be  defined  quantum-mechanically,  the  effective  cross-section  has 
the  same  sense  in  quantum  theory  as  it  has  in  classical  theory. 

In  practice,  however,  it  is  very  difficult  to  calculate  the  effective 
cross-section.  Therefore,  we  shall  consider  certain  special  cases  in 
which  the  solution  to  the  problem  is  comparatively  simple. 

The  Born  approximation.  Let  us  suppose  that  a  particle  witli 
energy  $  is  scattered  in  a  given  potential  field  U.  We  shall  first 
consider  the  case  of  $  >  U.  Then,  the  change  in  the  wave  vector 
of  the  particle  in  the  field  is  of  the  order 


-  U) 


If  the  dimensions  of  the  region  in  which  the  field  acts  are  of  the 
order  a  then  the  total  phase  change  of  the  wave  function  in  the 
scattering  field  is  estimated  as 


L_  JZ5L 

€     h    ' 

This  quantity  must  be  considerably  smaller  than  unity  in  order 
that  the  perturbation  produced  by  the  field  may  be  regarded  as 
weak.  In  the  case  when  l]^>$,  the  wave  number  is  estimated  as 


!/_..._  ^>  |/_  *   —  .  it  follows  then  that  the  criterion  of  smallness 
y       ti  \       ti  .— - 

for  a  phase  change  is-^-y™ —  <^  1  (upper  estimate). 

Under  these  conditions  the  action  of  the  field  U  must  be  regarded 
as  a  weak  perturbation  imposed  upon  the  wave  function. 

We  shall  proceed  from  the  general  formula  (34.29)  for  the  transition 
probability.  Let  the  initial  momentum  of  the  incident  particle  equal  p 

25  -  0060 


386  QUANTUM   MBCHANirs  [Part   III 

prior  to  scattering  in  a  eentre-of-inass  system  (see  Sec.  6),  and  p' 
after  scattering.  We  consider  the  scattering  to  be  elastic,  so  that 
p  —  pf.  To  a  zero  approximation  we  choose  the  wave  functions  <]/°>  (p) 
and  <J/0)  (p')  in  the  form  of  plane  waves,  which  corresponds  to  free 
motion.  We  write  them  as 

4,(o>  (p)  =  y  e^T-  .  <|/o).  (p/)  =  ^y  e-  -*--  .          (37Bl) 

These  functions  are  normalized  to  unity  in  the  volume  V  (which, 
of  course,  falls  out  of  the  final  result).  The  approximation  (37.1) 
for  <|/°>  (p),  <|/°>*  (p')  is  called  a  Born  approximation. 

The  function  <J^°>  (p)  corresponds  to  a  flux  density  ^  ;  this  is  im- 
mediately seen  from  (24.20): 


Ve-eVe  =  -~      -       .        (37.2) 

*  V  \  )        mV         V  v         ' 


From  (37.1),  the  matrix  element  for  the  transition  probability  that 
appears  in  (34.29)  is 

~7>~~  U(t)dV.  (37.3) 


In  order  to  find  the  scattering  probability,  we  must  multiply  the 
square  modulus  of  (37.3)  by-~-  ,  by  the  number  of  finite  states  z  ($) 

in  a  unit  energy  interval,  and  by  the  element  of  solid  angle  d£i. 
This  number  can  be  determined  directly  from  (25.25)  if  we  take 
into  account  that  the  fraction  of  the  states  corresponding  to  a  solid 

angle  element  dii  is-^—  . 
Therefore, 

(37.4) 


The  differential  effective  scattering  cross-section  inside  a  solid-angle 
element  d  ii  is  equal  to  the  scattering  probability  in  unit  time  [defined 

from  (34.29)],  divided  by  the  incident  flux-^-  =  -4  p^  •  Therefore, 


V 


J 


(p— 


U(t)dV 


2 


m* 


dSl  .  (37.5) 


The  integral  appearing  here  is  the  matrix  element  calculated  for 
two  functions  <j/°>  (p),  <J/°>*  (p')  with  normalization  over  unit  volume, 

F  =  l.  Therefore,  introducing  k^=  J-,   k'=  -—-,   we  A\Tite 


Sen.  37 J  QUANTUM  THEORY  OF  SCATTERING  387 

Uw  =  je< (k-k'> '  U  (r)  d  V,  (37.6) 


'kk' 


(37.7) 


Scattering  by  a  central  field.  Simplifications  appear  in  expression 
(37.5)  if  the  field  U  is  central,  i.e.,  if  it  depends  only  upon  r.  Let 
us  calculate  C7kk'  for  this  case.  In  defining  the  polar  angle  &  we  choose 
the  direction  of  the  vector  k  —  k'  as  the  polar  axis.  Then 

.    (37.8) 


Bearing  in  mind  that  sin  fr  d$=  —  d  cos  ft,  we  can  integrate  with 
respect  to  &  immediately,  obtaining 

°!  ,  p/|k-k'|r_    _i|k  — k'|r 

TT  rt         I      O    J        T  J  I     \    I    "J  ^^  ^ 

11..*    •     V  7"f  I  4**  //  "f*  /  /    I  •/•  1   I  -         

l_x  IrV *j/tl/       Iv/l/l/ll  •it  1/1 

J  v  '  \  »  |  k  —  k'  |  r 

o 

oo 

=  Tb-4-Vr  fr  17  (r)  sin  ( I  k  -  k'  I  r)  d  r .  (37.9) 

|k-k|J 

As  we  have  already  said,  k~k'.  Therefore,  the  vector  difference 
is  easily  expressed  in  terms  of  the  deflection  angle  0  for  the  particle : 


|k  —  k'12^  2fc2-  2(kk')  =  2A;2(1  -cos 6)  =  4 A;2 sin2  ^  .       (37.10) 

1  '  Jt 

This  can  also  be  seen  from  a  geometrical  construction.  We  have 

oo 

-— ~  CrU(r)am(2krsm~\dr.  (37.11) 

Uw=  *sin|.  J  \  2/ 

o 

Thus,  a  calculation  of  U^^  reduces  to  calculation  of  a  single  integral 
(37.11). 

Rutherford's  formula.  For  the  case  of  a  Coulomb  field,    U  =  ±  -—  . 
The  integral   E/kk'  is  found  in  the  following  artificial  manner.  We 

00 

define  the  integral  (sin x dx  thus 
o 

oo 

lim  I  e~~ a*  sin  x  dx  =  lim   ~2~~i  ~  1  • 

<,~>l)J  .-.O^-i-1 


25* 


388  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Then 

CO 

f  •  1 

J  ~~   a 

0 

and,  finally, 

tfkk-  =  ±  2nZe~    I  sin(2A;rsm^-)dr  =  ±      TC"P"     •        (37.12) 


Substituting  this  in  (37.7),  we  obtain  a  final  expression  for  the 
differential  effective  scattering  cross-section: 


4  m2  y4  sin4  -  - 

where  we  have  taken  advantage  of  the  fact  that  p~hk~mv.  This 
result  curiously  agrees  with  the  precise  classical  Rutherford  formula 
(6.19). 

It  turns  out  that  the  result  (37.13)  is  also  obtained  from  a  precise 
solution  of  the  wave  equation  for  the  case  of  a  Coulomb  field.  Thus, 
Rutherford's  formula  is  extended  to  quantum  mechanics  unchanged. 

The  Born  approximation  in  the  theory  of  scattering  by  a  Coulomb 
field  can  be  regarded  as  a  series  expansion  in  square  powers  of  the 
charge,  or,  more  precisely,  Ze2.  But  since  the  precise  formula  does 
not  involve  powers  higher  than  (Ze2)2,  the  result  of  the  Born  approxi- 
mation coincided  with  the  precise  result. 

We  shall  now  estimate  the  limits  of  applicability  of  the  method 
under  consideration  for  the  Coulomb  field.  To  do  this,  we  make  use 
of  the  first  criterion  established  at  the  beginning  of  the  section  for 
the  applicability  of  this  method.  Since  the  product  Ua  in  this  case 
is  equal  to  Ze2,  we  arrive  at  the  following  condition: 

(37.14) 

The  quantity  e2/hc  =  1/137.  Therefore,  we  write  (37.14)  otherwise 
thus: 

w-H1-  <37-15) 

But  Z~90  for  heavy  elements,  so  that  (37.15)  is  not  satisfied  in 
general.  Of  course,  Rutherford's  formula  is  applicable  to  nonrela- 
tivistic  particles  in  this  case  too,  because  it  is  exact ;  but  in  calculating 
a  correction,  for  example,  arising  from  a  distortion  of  the  nuclear 
field  by  the  field  of  atomic  electrons,  the  Born  approximation  yields 
an  incorrect  result. 


Sec.  37J  QUANTUM   THEORY   OF   SCATTERING  389 

With  the  condition  (37.15),  formula  (37.13)  is  applicable  also  to  the 
scattering  of  relativistic  particles  at  small  angles  provided  m  is  re- 

placed   by  -rJ==r  . 


The  collision  parameter  (aiming  distance)  and  angular  momentum. 

The  Born  approximation  cannot  be  used  when  large  forces  act  upon 
a  particle,  even  if  they  are  concentrated  in  a  small  region.  First  of  all 
let  us  define  what  is  meant  by  a  "small"  region. 

It  is  convenient  here  to  compare  the  classical  aiming  distance  of  p 
(see  Sec.  6)  with  the  angular-momentum  eigenvalue  in  quantum 
mechanics.  For  large  angular-momentum  eigenvalues,  when  the  quasi 
classical  approximation  is  applicable,  we  can  give  the  following  esti- 
mate : 

hl~mvp.  (37.16) 

Whence 

p~-hl    ---•   0X/   ,  (37.17) 

r         m»          2r>    '  v  ' 

Avhere  X  is  the  de  Broglie  wavelength. 

It  can  be  seen  from  here  that  to  a  change  in  the  angular  momentum 

by  unity  there  corresponds  an  increment  of  -  —  ,  in  the  aiming 
distance.  Accordingly,  the  smallest  collision  parameter  is  given  by 
/==0  and  p  ^-£  --  -  .  Here  the  particle  is  scattered  iu  the  s-state. 

Let  us  consider  the  case  when  the  radius  of  action  of  the  forces  is 
less  than  —  -  .  Then  a  particle  with  an  angular  momentum  other 

than  zero  hardly  at  all  experiences  scattering.  We  have  shown  [see 
(31.12)]  that  the  wave  function  for  a  particle  with  angular  momentum 
I  becomes  zero,  like  rl,  at  the  origin.  Therefore,  the  probability  of 
finding  a  particle  with  /  >  0  in  the  region  of  action  of  the  forces  is 

very  small  if  the  radius  of  action  of  the  forces  is  much  less  than  -y—  . 

ZTC 

Separating  the  wave  function  with  zero  angular  momentum.  Let 

iis  take  the  term,  corresponding  to  £  =  0,  out  of  the  wave  function. 
To  do  this,  it  is  necessary  to  expand  the  function  (37.1),  i.e.,  a  plane 
wave,  in  a  series  of  eigenfunctions  of  the  operator  M2.  The  function 
corresponding  to  1  =  0  is  especially  simple:  it  does  not  depend  upon 
the  angle.  Indeed,  the  operator  M2  involves  only  angular  derivatives. 
Operating  upon  a  function  which  does  not  depend  on  the  angle  is 
equivalent  to  multiplying  the  function  by  zero.  Normalizing  the  angu- 
lar function  of  the  s-state  to  unity,  we  find 


f 
then  J  |cp0|2dQ  = 


390  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  HI 

The  expansion  coefficient  for  this  function  is,  according  to  the  gen- 
eral formula  (30.11), 


c(r)  = 

_ 

«  —  |^-  fe'fercos  *  sin  0  db  =  2  1/jT  ^£L^L  .  (37.18) 

V47TFJ  r    F       kr 

0 

c  (r)  satisfies  the  radial  wave  equation  for  a  free  particle  (31.5), 
if  we  put  C7  =  0,  I  —  0  in  it.  In  actual  fact,  equation  (31.7),  which  is 

obtained  from  (31.5)  by  substituting  <I*  =  y-  wnen  &  =  0,  £7  =  0,  has 
the  solution  _ 

__    .     <\/2m& 
X  —  sm       ^       r  • 

But  --  -  J^  —  ~  k,  so  that  the  function  ^=^rc  (r). 

c  (r)  tends  to  a  finite  limit  when  r  —  0.  This  corresponds  to  the 

boundary  condition  for  a  radial  ^-function  at  the  coordinate  origin. 

Let  there  now  be,  close  to  the  origin,  a  scattering  field  U  (r),  which 

diminishes  so  rapidly  with  distance  that  U  (r)  =  0  when  r  ~--  —  .  Then, 
in  its  radial  dependence,  the  s  -state  wave  function  satisfies,  as  before, 
equations  (31.  5)  -(31.7)  for  T>-^-9  because  no  forces  act  upon  the 

particle  in  this  region.  The  solution  to  (31.5),  which  is  more  general 
than  (37.18),  is 

-.  (37.19) 

where  8  is  some  phase  shift  depending  upon  the  definite  form  of  the 
potential  U  (r).  Naturally,  the  solution  (31.19)  cannot  be  extended 

to  r  <  -5—  •  ,  because  the  particle  in  this  region  is  no  longer  free  from  the 

action  of  forces. 

We  shall  show  that  the  effective  scattering  cross-section  is  expressed 
in  terms  of  S.  An  example  of  determining  S  is  given  in  exercises 
2  and  3. 

Determining  the  scattered  wave.  Let  us  suppose  that,  in  some  way, 
an  exact  solution  <|/  of  the  wave  equation  (31.12)  has  become  known 
in  a  given  scattering  field  U  (r).  This  solution  must  satisfy  the  same 
conditions  at  infinity  as  a  plane  wave,  because  these  conditions  corre- 
spond to  the  particle  scattering  problem.  We  represent  the  function 
<|/  in  the  form  of  the  sum 

*'  =  *°(P)  +  ***  (37.20) 


Sec.  37]  QUANTUM  THEORY   OF   SCATTERING  391 

This  equation  separates  the  function  tb°  (p),  which  corresponds  to 
the  incident  wave,  from  the  complete  solution  of  the  wave  equation. 
The  second  term  ^scat=^' — ^°  (p)  describes  the  scattered  particles. 

If  we  now  expand  ^'  and  <J>°  (p)  in  a  series  of  eigenfunctions  of  the 
square  of  the  angular  momentum,  it  turns  out  that  a  short-range  force 
field  distorts  only  the  term  <]/,  which  corresponds  to  1  =  0.  All  the 
remaining  terms  of  both  functions  are  the  same.  As  a  result,  when 

r  >  -0—  we  obtain 

47t 

i              r//\           /  \T             nl/~rc    [Aain(kr  +  B) —  amkr]       *  /orroix 

<kcat  -  [c' (r)  —  c  (r)]  90  =  2  |/T  |_       —^ J  -^j=-  .  (37.21) 


But  for  large  r  the  scattered  particles  can  move  only  away  from  the 
scatterer.  This  means  that  ^at  involves  only  the  function and 

does  not  contain  the  function .  Indeed,  if  we  put  i  = in 

r  •*•         •  r 

(24.20),  then  the  flux  j  will  acquire  a  positive  sign,  while  if  we  substi- 
tute -'-  --  the  flux  will  be  negative,  i.e.,  incoming. 
We  write  d>scat  in  complex  form: 


<J,scat  =  -  --  ----  [A  (e''<*'  +  *>  -  e—  '<*'  -«-«)  -  (eikf  -  e~ik')]  .       (37.22) 

2i  v  V  '  kr 

To  exclude  the  incoming  wave  e~ikr,  we  put  4e~'8~l,  whence 

4-e'5,  (37.23) 

(e2i8-1)eI'kr-  (37-24) 


The  effective  scattering  cross-section.  From  (24.20),  the  flux  density 
of  the  scattered  particles  at  infinity  is 

7  =  Ti/irr  I  e»'«  -  1  1  »  —  .  (37.25) 

1       4Vk2r2  '  '      m  v  ; 


The  total  effective  scattering  cross-section  or  is  equal  to  the  whole 
flux  4Tcr2;  divided  by  the  flux  density  of  the  incident   particles 

v    _    hk 
'V  ~~  ~mV   '' 

(jz=-^.|e2»«~  1|2.  (37.26) 

K 

Passing  to  real  quantities  we  write 

|  e2i«  _  1  1  2  =  (e2i«_  i)  (e-a»«—  1)  =  2  -  2  cos  2S  =  4  sin2  8, 
so  that 

(37.27) 


392  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

It  can  be  seen  from  here  that  the  greatest  value  of  cr  is  for  the  scatter- 
ing of  particles  in  the  s-state  -—- .  This  formula  has  many  applications 

in  nuclear  physics  since  nuclear  forces  are  large  and  short-range. 

Since  scattered  particles  occur  in  the  s-state,  their  distribution  in 
a  centre-of-mass  system  is  isotropic,  i.e.,  it  does  not  depend  upon  the 
scattering  angle.  This  agrees  with  the  statement  made  at  the  end  of 
Sec.  6. 

Exercises 

I)  Find  the  effective  scattering  cross-section  of  fast  particles  by  hydrogen 
atoms  in  the  ground  state. 

The  wave  function  for  the  ground  state  of  a  hydrogen  atom  with  n  =  1, 
I  --  0  is 


because,  of  the  polynomial  x  there  remains  only  the  first  term,  which  does 
not  depend  upon  £,  while  \/2e0  ~  !•  The  coefficient  It  is  found  from  the  nor- 
malization condition 


0 
whence 


•-R-RJT- 

The  potential  interaction  energy  of  the  charge  c  with  the  atom  is 


The  first  term  of  the  integral  f/kk'  was  found  in  the  text.  It  is 

Wo  integrate  the  second  term  in  the  following  way: 

CJG  dV  j  ""fT^rT"  " 

-    2f      2     >     i<k-lOr'  ,•  c'(k-k')(r-r') 

J     °  J        |  r  —  r'  | 

In  the  last  integral  it  is  necessary  to  take  the  origin  at  the  point  r',  so 
that  it  reduces  to  the  same  form  as   (37.12): 

J  f  0 

Hence, 


Sec.  37 J  QUANTUM   THEORY    OF    SCATTERING  393 

The  quantity  inside  tho  brackets  is  callod  the  screening  factor.  Evaluating 
it  in  the  same  manner  as   (37.8),  we  obtain 


f  /     i(k-lOr"       r,  2rr        f  ,  L       ,    .      0\ 

The  integral  reduces  to  the  form 

OO  CO 

J  X Sm  **  e      C  *l  ~  ~~  0V  J  Sm  " **  P/          '*       ~~  0V  < 


2nb 


Here,  a  =  2  k  sin  —  ,     6  =        ~      ,   so   that  the  screening  factor  is 


1  /  w  e2  \       2  r 

~~   r:\li*  r/""7    . 
- 


~ 

0    07.  sin  °      2wrS 

-  •  -  ^  sin  o~  '      h*  I 

0        .,    .   0  o  2we2Ma  ""      ""  I  .        h*  k2'  7"  "  01» 


A*  sin 

1         .  . 

hV\*    ,'     2    °    I'"     ' 

It  was  assumed  in  tho  last  transformation  that  tho  scattered  particle  is  an. 
electron.  Then,  strictly  speaking,  we  should  have  formed  a  function  which 
is  antisymmetrieal  together  with  the  function  of  the  atomic  electron;  this 
we  did  not  do.  The  final  formula  for  the  effective  scattering  cross-section 
differs  from  (37.13)  by  the  square  of  the  screening  factor.  We  note  that  this 
factor  is  correctly  obtained  only  in  the  Born  approximation,  hi  contrast  to 
Rutherford's  formula  (37.13),  which  is  exact. 

For  0—0,  the  effective  cross-section  turns  out  to  bo  finite,  because  0^0 
corresponds  to  large  aiming  distances,  when  tho  nuclear  charge  is  screened 
by  the  charge  of  an  electron. 

2)  Calculate  the  effective  scattering  cross-section  for  a  particle  by  an  im- 
permeable sphere  of  radius  a,  which  is  very  much  less  than -7: —  ~  -,  . 

Z  TC  K 

In  accordance  with  (25.1),  the  wave  function  at  the  surface  of  tho  imper- 
meable sphere  becomes  zero.  Hence,  the  solution  (37.19)  has  tho  form 


k  (r  —  a) 
kr 


From  this,   8  ==  —  ka,  while 


But  ka  <^    1  from  the  conditions,  so  that  sin  ka  ~  ka. 

Finally,  a  —  4  TT  a2,  i.e.,  the  effective  scattering  radius  is  twice  tho  radius 
of  the  sphere.  In  classical  theory  or  =  jra2  (see  exercise  1,  Sec.  6). 

3)  Examine  the  scattering  of  particles  with  energy  &  in  the  s-state  by  a 
spherical  potential  well  of  constant  depth  |  UQ\  and  radius  a;  consider  that 
there  exist  the  following  relations: 


394  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part    111 

(see  Sec.  25).  For  e  >  0,  there  exists  in  the  well  a  bound  state  of  a  particle 
of  energy  <f0  close  to  the  upper  boundary  of  the  well.  Unlike  Fig.  38,  it  is 
assumed  here  that  U  becomes  zero  for  r  >  a.  Express  the  cross -sect  ion  in 
terms  of  the  energy  level  ^0. 

The  conjugation  condition  for  the  wave  functions  with  r  =  a  is  of  tho  form 

x  cos  xa 


sin  (fco-f  8) 


where   x  =  ~ — r — ' — ~—  ,    k  =  — — =- •    Neglecting    ka,    wo    obtain 

fi  n 

an  expression  for  the  effective  cross-section: 

4* 
a  =  TV- 


~k*  (1  +  cot8  8)         k2  +  x2  cot2  xa 

In  accordance  with  the  conditions  imposed  upon  E/  \U0\  wo  have,  approx- 
imately, 

cot  xa££  -   -  . 
4 

From  (25.41)  the  condition  for  finding  the  level  *?0  is  of  the  form 

x0  cot  x0  a  ~  —  x 


Supposing    that 


e ,  we  obtain 


^0 

assumption    concerning    the    order    of    smallnoss 
the  cross -section  we  finally  have 

4* 


This     confirms     the 


,  since  V  e  ^  e  •   For 


__ 

where  k0  —  —  --  ^^  —  ?-'—  •  We    note    that    the  formula   obtained   also   holds 

for  e  <  0,  when  in  actuality  there  is  no  level  at  all  in  the  well.  In  this  case 
we  talk  about  a  "virtual"  level.  The  straight  line  in  Fig.  39  intersects  the 

first  half-cycle   of  the   sinusoid  just  before   x  a  ==  -~  . 

A  similar  case  occurs  when  neutrons  are  scattered  by  protons  with  anti- 
parallel  particle  spins. 

Sec.  38.  Tho  Belativistic  Wave  Equation  for  an  Electron 

The  equation  for  a  spinless  particle.  Schrodinger's  equation  (24.11) 
is  formed  on  the  basis  of  the  nonrelativistic  relationship  between 
energy  and  momentum 


Therefore,  it  can  be  applied  only  to  electrons  whose  velocity  is  consid- 
erably less  than  that  of  light,  and  whose  kinetic  energy  is  considerably 
less  than  the  rest  energy: 


Sec.  38J  THE  BELAT1VISTIC   WAVE  EQUATION  395 

T=  2 


Immediately  after  Schrodinger  obtained  the  nonrelativistic  equa- 
tion, the  first  attempts  were  made  to  build  a  relativistic  wave  equation 
(Fock,  Klein,  Gordon).  In  formula  (21.30) 


-  e?)2  =  c2  (p  -  ~  A)"  + 


wa 

\m         c      / 

~  ~dt  was  substituted  in  place  of  Jff,  as  is  usual  in  quantum  mechan- 
ics, and  in  place  of  p,  the  operator  4- V.  In  this  way  a  wave  equation 
was  obtained  in  relativistically  invariant  form 

8 


-|-m2c4^,  (38.1) 

which  equation,  however,  is  not  applicable  to  electrons.  The  fact  of 
the  matter  is  that  equation  (38.1)  does  not  take  into  account  the  spin 
of  the  electron,  because  it  involves  only  a  single  wave  function.  Yet 
in  Sec.  32  we  saw  that  a  particle  with  spin  1/2  must  be  described  by 
at  least  two  wave  functions.  These  two  functions  could  be  introduced 
into  the  nonrelativistic  equation  purely  formally,  assuming  that  each 
of  them  satisfies  it.  But  the  interaction  of  spin  and  orbit  is  a  relativ- 
istic effect;  therefore,  a  correct  equation  for  fast  electrons  must  take 
it  into  account  automatically,  without  any  additional  hypotheses 
concerning  spin  magnetic  moment.  This  equation  must  involve  op- 
erators which  act  upon  the  spin  degree  of  freedom. 

The  inapplicability  of  equation  (38.1)  to  the  electron  was  very 
quickly  seen:  the  fine  structure  of  the  levels  of  the  hydrogen  atom 
obtained  from  this  equation  was  incorrect.  A  nonspin  equation  cannot 
explain,  first  of  all,  the  number  of  splitting  components;  this  is  deci- 
sively against  it. 

Charged  particles  without  spin — mesons — take  part  in  nuclear 
interactions.  Equation  (38.1)  can  be  applied  to  them,  at  least  if  it  is 
shown  that  such  mesons  can  be  regarded,  to  some  sort  of  approxi- 
mation, separately  from  protons  and  neutrons. 

But  for  electrons  one  has  to  form  a  relativistic  wave  equation  that 
takes  spin  into  account.  Such  an  equation  was  obtained  by  Dirac. 

The  Dirac  equation.  Following  the  line  of  Dirac 's  argument,  we 
begin  with  the  equation  for  a  free  electron.  The  starting  relationship  is 

ff  =  Vc2  (pi  +  p$  +  pi)  +  m2  c* .  (38.2) 


390  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

Instead  of  £  and  p  we  must  substitute  the  derivatives  —  ^-j-  and 

j  l>     G  t 

-.-V.  However,  to  do  this  it  is  necessary  to  define  the  meaning  of  the 

square  root  of  an  operator.  Dirac  supposed  that,  in  the  operator  sense, 
a  root  is  equal  to  an  expression  like 


Vc2(p  +  £*  +  pz)  +  w2c4  -  c  (*xpx  +  5iypY  +  azpz) 

(38.3) 

where  <xx,  ay,  a*,  and  p  act  on  the  internal  degrees  of  freedom  of  the 
electron  such  as,  for  example,  the  spin  degree  of  freedom. 
Let  us  square  both  sides  of  the  equation  and  attempt  to  choose  the 

operators  a*,  ay,  a*,  and  p  in  such  a  way  as  to  obtain  an  identity,  i.e., 
so  as  to  eliminate  terms  of  the  type  px  py,  .  .  .  ,  me3  px,  .  .  .  : 

c2  (pi  +  P2Y  +  pi)  +  m*c*  -  c2  (alpl  +  a  JfiJ  +  Upl)  +  P8wac*  + 
+  r,a(axay  +  S.yS.x)pxpy  -|-  r,2(a.va^  -|-  SizS.x)pxps  + 
+  c2(aya^   f-  $.zS.y)pypz  +  wc3(a.xp  +  Pa.x)  /)*  4- 
•h  ?wcs(ayp  -f  Pay)  py  +  mc3(a^p  +  $$.*}$?. 

Hence,  the  operators  must  be  subject  to  the  conditions 


--    .X.Z  -\-  a-a.v  = 

=  a^p  +  PCX^-^  ayp  +  pay  =  a?p  +  pdt^  =  0  .  (38.4) 

These  operator  equalities  greatly  resemble  the  spin  operator  relation- 
ships (32.10),  (32.11).  It  can  already  be  seen  from  this  that  the  oper- 
ators S.x,  ay,  a*,  and  p  at  least  act  upon  the  spin  degree  of  freedom  of 
an  electron.  To  the  accuracy  of  the  factor  1/4,  the  relations  (38.4)  agree 
with  (34.11)  and  (32.13)  for  Sx,  5y,  and  Sz. 

But  the  operators  a  and  o  are  not  identical.  This  can  easily  be  seen 
by  proceeding  from  the  opposite  :  assume  that  £.X  =  GX,  6cy^5y,  S.Z  =  SZ. 
In  order  to  obtain  the  wave  equation  we  must  equate  the  right-hand 

rot 

side  of  (38.3)  to  --  ""•=T*  -^ow  ^  us  Perf°rm  an  inversion  of  the 
coordinate  system.  All  momentum  components  will  change  sign  so 
that  the  sign  of  pz  will  also  change.  But  the  operator  6c^  in  front  of  pz, 
if  it  equals  Sz,  should  not  interchange  the  wave-function  components. 
Therefore,  the  equality  between  the  left-  and  right-hand  sides  of  the 
wave  equation  breaks  down  when  the  coordinate  system  is  inverted; 
but  this  should  not  be.  Therefore,  a  7^  a. 

The  necessity  for  a  four-component  wave  function.  We  shall  be 
confronted  with  the  same  difficulty  if  we  consider  that  the  operators 
a*,  ay,  a*  act  upon  the  same  wave  functions  as  those  appearing  with 


Sec.  38]  THE    KELATIVJSTIC    WAVE    EQUATION  397 

l 


--  ~~dT°n  ^e  °^ier  S^e  °f  the  equation.  Therefore,  we  must  assume 
that  coordinate  differentiation,  on  the  one  hand,  and  time  differentia- 
tion, on  the  other,  are  applied  to  different  pairs  of  functions,  of  which 
one  pair  changes  sign  in  inversion  of  the  coordinate  system  while  the 
other  does  not.  This  is  sufficient  to  ensure  invariance  of  the  equation 
with  respect  to  inversion. 

Thus,  we  shall  say  that  the  wave  functions  depend  not  only  upon 
the  spin  variable  a,,  but  also  upon  some  other  internal  variable  p, 
which  also  takes  on  two  values. 

Let  us  define  the  operators  which  are  completely  analogous  to  spin 
operators  and  which  act  upon  the  variable  a  and  upon  the  variable  p. 
Bearing  in  mind  that  the  factor  1/2,  with  which  the  spin  operators 
were  multiplied  by  in  Sec.  32,  is  no  longer  needed,  we  shall  write 
61?  o2,  63  and,  correspondingly,  px,  p2,  and  p3  for  the  variable  p.  These 
operate  upon  the  wave  function  analogously: 


<*2 

\y  v~,  p;/      v     <  y  il>  pyy 

f'     Ji  n   o\\ 

(38.5) 


Pi 

^3\if  '2n~\  —  ib  C  '2^)'  (38.6) 

From  formulae  (32.10)  and  (32.11)  we  find  the  basic  relations  for  the 
operators  a  and  p : 


iSl\  1 
f 

J 


and  similarly  for  p. 

All  the  operators  o  are  commutative  with  all  the  operators  p 
because  they  operate  upon  different  variables.  In  order  that  the 
operators  a*,  ay,  SLZ  together  should  satisfy  the  "anticommutative" 
relations  with  the  operator  (§,  as  in  the  third  line  of  (38.4),  we  arrange 
that  all  three  components  of  a  are  proportional  to  one  operator  of  the 
components  of  p,  for  example,  px  and  p  is  simply  p3.  We  notice  that 
px  interchanges  the  functions  while  p3  does  not.  To  have  the  operators 
a*,  ay,  and  SLZ  anticommutative,  as  in  the  second  line  of  (38.4),  we 
put  them  proportional  to  av  o2,  63,  respectively.  Thus, 

a^^p^a,  P  =  p3.  (38.8) 


398 


QUANTUM    MECHANICS 


[Part  III 


It  is  obvious  that,  as  a  result  of  the  commutative  nature  of  p  and  a 
and  of  the  definition  of  the  operators  (38.5)  and  (38.6),  all  the  opera- 
tors formed  in  (38.8)  satisfy  the  conditions  (38.4). 

Thus,  the  wave  function  in  the  Dirac  equation  has  four  components, 
according  to  the  number  of  values  for  o  and  p  (a  —  1,  2;  p  =  l,  2). 
For  convenience  in  future  we  shall  number  the  symbols  a,  p  from  one 
to  four,  putting 


It  is  convenient  to  write  the  functions  tyl9  i];2,  ^3,  ^4  in  columns,  as  in 
Sec.  32.  Now  using  (38.5)  and  (38.6),  we  find  out  how  the  operators 
and  p  act  upon  the  four-component  wave  function 

*  (1,1)1 


ay,  a* 


(2,  2) 


=  Pi 


(2,  2) 


-*4 

-I; 


—  V, 


(38.9) 


The  choice  of  operators  (38.8)  and  (38.9)  is  not  unique.  It  is  possible 
to  form  other  operators  with  the  same  properties.  For  example,  one 
could  have  chosen  p2  instead  of  px.  We  shall  examine  below  (exercise  4) 
the  implications  of  this  fact. 

The  Dirac  equation  in  expanded  form.  Summarizing,  according  to 
(38.2),  (38.3)  and  (38.8)  Dirac's  equation  can  be  written  as 


(38.10) 

In  accordance  with  (38.9),  this  equation  must  be  understood  as  a 
system  of  four  equations,  which  we  shall  write  explicitly,  first  of  all 

T          p     |  I 

replacing  --  ~~^7^J  &$  (because  fy  is  proportional   to  the  factor 


iEt  \ 

e'~  *  )  : 


=  c  (px 

=  c  (px 

=  C  (P* 
=  C  (px 


4-  pz 


(38.11) 


h 


As  usual,  here  px,  py,  pz  are  the  components  of  the  vector —  V,   i.e., 
.  ^^7 .  The  system  of  equations  (38.11)  is  applied  to  a 


7-  "FT 


~-~  •)""  » 


Seo.  38] 


THE    BELATIVISTIC    WAVJ5    EQUATION 


300 


free  electron  since  it  does  not  involve  the  scalar  potential  and  compo- 
nents of  the  vector  potential.  Therefore,  the  coordinate  dependence  of 
the  wave  function  is  determined  by  the  factor 


so  that  the  whole  group  of  four  fy  has  the  form 


JH- 


(38.12) 


where  the  amplitudes  al9  a2,  «3,  and  a4  do  not  depend  upon  coordinates. 
The  action  of  the  operators  pX9  py,  pz  on  this  group  of  four  fy  leads 
simply  to  a  multiplication  of  its  components  by  pX9  pY9  px.  Conse- 
quently, the  differential  equation  (38.10)  for  a  free  electron  leads 
to  the  algebraic  equation 

+  wc2pa,  (38.13) 


where  by  a  is  understood  the  whole  column 


a  = 


Here,  operator  properties  are  preserved  only  by  a*,  ay,  a*,  and  p, 
which  rearrange  the  amplitudes  a  in  the  same  way  as  the  functions  <{/. 
In  other  words,  the  amplitudes  depend  upon  the  internal  variables  a 
and  p. 
Energy  eigenvalues.  We  apply  the  operator 

$  =  c2  (ocp)  +  mc^  p  (38.14) 

to  both  sides  of  equality  (38.13).  As  a  result  of  the  anti-commutation 
properties  of  the  Dirac  operators  (38.4),  only  their  squares,  equal  to 
unity,  remain  on  the  right.  Hence,  the  following  equation  will  result : 


W2c4a. 


(38.16) 


Here,  the  components  of  a  are  no  longer  interchanged  because  there 
are  numbers  in  front  of  a,  and  not  operators.  All  four  equations  (38.15) 
have  the  same  form  <?2  ax  =  c2  p2  at  +  w2  c2  al9  etc.  For  these  equalities 
to  be  satisfied  we  must  subject  the  energy  to  the  usual  relativistic 
relationship,  i.e.,  we  cancel  ax: 

(38.16) 


400  QUANTUM    MT3PHANICS  [Part   III 

The  last  equality  refers  simply  to  magnitudes.  Thus  the  energy 
eigenvalue  for  a  free  electron,  determined  from  the  Dirae  equation,  is 


cM7^2  .  (38.  1  7) 

The  two  signs  in  the  equality  correspond  to  the  internal  degree 
of  freedom  which  an  electron  possesses  in  addition  to  spin.  Only  the 
plus  sign  is  taken  in  classical  mechanics,  since  free  electrons  do  not 
have  negative  energy.  The  square  root  in  (38.17)  is  not  less  than 
me2  in  absolute  value,  so  that  a  region  of  width  2  me2  exists  in  which 
the  energy  cannot  occur.  But  all  the  quantities  in  classical  equations 
vary  continuously;  therefore,  once  the  energy  has  been  defined  with 
a  positive  sign,  it  cannot  jump  across  this  forbidden  region  of  width 
2  me2,  and  remains  positive  all  the  time.  In  other  words,  energy  which 
is  defined  as  positive  in  the  initial  conditions  remains  positive  from  the 
equations  of  motion. 

Negative  kinetic  energies  in  the  Dirae  theory.  In  quantum  theory  it 
is  shown  that  discontinuous  transitions,  too,  are  possible  between 
different  states.  For  example,  an  electron  with  energy  greater  than 
we2  could  emit  a  light  quantum  and  remain  with  an  energy  less  than 
—  me2.  But  such  electrons  with  negative  energy  and  mass  are  not 
observed  in  nature.  Their  properties  would  be  very  strange:  upon 
radiating  light,  they  would  each  time  reduce  their  energy  and,  as  it 
were,  drop  into  a  state  with  «?  =  —  oo.  All  the  electrons  in  the  universe 
would  rather  quickly  fall  into  this  state  ;  but,  as  we  see,  this  has  not 
happened  ! 

Thus,  Dirac's  equation  admits  of  the  possibility  of  states,  which 
cannot  simply  be  excluded,  because  electrons  may  transfer  to  them 
from  other  observable  states.  But,  on  the  other  hand,  there  are  no 
electrons  in  nature  with  negative  energy  &  —  —  Vm2  c4+c2  p2.  At  the 
same  time,  the  Dirae  equation  describes  quite  correctly  a  great  assem- 
blage of  electron  properties  :  as  we  shall  soon  see,  it  yields  a  relationship 
between  the  spin  and  magnetic  moment  of  an  electron  that  agrees  with 
experiment,  it  leads  to  an  accurate  formula  for  the  fine-structure  levels 
of  the  hydrogen  atom,  etc.  In  addition,  mathematical  investigations 
show  that  there  is  110  essentially  different  relativistically  invariant 
wave  equation  for  a  particle  with  spin  one  half  and  mass  differing  from 
zero.  Therefore,  one  should  not  simply  reject  the  Dirae  equation:  it 
is  better  to  attempt  to  supplement  it  with  some  kind  of  hypothesis. 

Vacuum  in  the  Dirae  theory.  Dirae  suggested  that  vacuum  should  be 
redefined.  Earlier,  vacuum  was  understood  as  being  a  state  of  matter 
in  which  there  are  no  charges,  say  electrons.  A  vacuum  must  now  be 
called  that  state  in  which  all  negative  energy  levels  are  occupied  by 
electrons.  That  this  redefinition  is  not  verbal  but  has  a  physical  mean- 
ing will  be  seen  very  soon  from  what  follows. 


Sec.  38]  THE   RELATIVISTIO   WAVE   EQUATION  401 

If  all  the  negative  energy  levels  are  occupied,  then,  in  accordance 
with  the  Pauli  principle,  no  electrons  can  transfer  to  them  from  positive 
energy  states.  Thus,  the  Pauli  principle  is  necessary  for  relativistic 
quantum  theory  to  be  able,  in  general,  to  describe  the  properties  of 
electrons.  This  is  the  basic  reason  why  the  Pauli  principle  is  necessary 
as  an  element  of  quantum  mechanics.  In  order  to  avoid  misunder- 
standing we  shall  give  a  somewhat  fuller  definition  of  a  "vacuum" 
in  field  theory,  which  has  a  rather  different  meaning  from  that  in 
experimental  physics.  In  field  theory,  vacuum  signifies  the  ground 
state  of  the  field;  for  an  electromagnetic  field,  for  example,  it  is  the 
state  of  the  field  in  which  there  are  no  quanta.  We  saw  in  Sec.  27  that 
this  state  is  endowed  with  observable  physical  properties. 

In  exactly  the  same  way,  if  all  the  negative  energy  states  are  occu- 
pied, then  all  the  remaining  electrons  can  no  longer  reduce  their  energy 
by  making  a  transition  to  negative  states.  When  there  are  no  electrons 
with  positive  energy,  electrons  can  no  longer  reduce  their  energy  in 
any  way  if  all  the  negative  energy  states  are  occupied.  This  explains 
the  definition  of  vacuum  as  a  ground  state. 

Pair  production.  All  observed  phenomena  occur,  so  to  speak,  on  the 
background  of  a  state  in  which  the  negative  kinetic-energy  levels  are 
filled. 

However,  this  "background"  can  manifest  its  existence  in  a  real 
physical  process.  Close  to  a  nucleus,  a  quantum  with  energy  greater 
than  me*  is  capable  of  effecting  the  emission  of  an  electron  from  a  nega- 
tive-energy to  a  positive-energy  state.  Proximity  to  the  nucleus  is 
necessary  so  as  to  satisfy  the  law  of  conservation  of  momentum.  For 
the  proof  of  this  simple  statement,  see  exercise  1. 

But  after  an  electron  has  been  removed  from  a  negative  energy 
state  there  will  remain  a  "hole,"  i.e.,  an  unoccupied  level.  In  an  elec- 
tric field,  electrons  with  negative  mass  (mass  has  the  same  sign  as 
energy)  do  not  move  against  the  field,  towards  the  anode,  but  along 
the  field,  to  the  cathode,  against  the  applied  force.  And  with  them 
moves  the  hole  which  thus  behaves  like  an  electron  of  positive  charge 
and  mass. 

Experiment  will  show  that  as  a  result  of  the  ejection  of  an  electron 
from  a  negative  energy  state,  two  charges  have  appeared:  negative 
and  positive.  Such  a  positive  electron,  or  positron,  was  discovered  by 
Anderson  after  Dirac  had  formulated  his  theory  of  the  background. 
The  attitude  towards  the  Dirac  equation  was  somewhat  suspicious 
before  the  discovery  of  the  positron,  while  the  idea  of  background  was 
considered  far-fetched  and  intended  only  to  hide  the  defects  of  the 
theory. 

In  actual  fact  Dirac 's  theory  is  an  unusual  example  of  scientific 
foresight.  The  discovery  of  the  "antiproton"  (i.e.,  a  proton  with 
negative  charge)  by  Segrfc  once  again  confirmed  the  generality  of 
Dirac  Js  conceptions  concerning  particles  with  spin  1/2. 

26  -  0060 


402  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

Pair  annihilation.  When  a  positron  and  electron  meet  they  can 
annihilate  each  other  if  the  electron  transfers  to  an  unoccupied  level 
belonging  to  a  negative  energy  state.  Its  energy  will  be  imparted  to 
electromagnetic  radiation  in  the  form  of  two  or  three  quanta.  A  single 
quantum  cannot  result  when  annihilation  occurs  in  free  space  because, 
in  this  case,  momentum  is  not  conserved,  in  the  same  way  that  a  single 
quantum  cannot  form  a  pair  in  free  space.  Single-quantum  annihi- 
lation, too,  is  possible  in  a  nuclear  field. 

The  Dirac  equation  and  quantum  electrodynamics.  Modern  quantum 
electrodynamics  is  based  upon  the  quantum  theory  of  the  electro- 
magnetic field  (Sec,  27)  and  the  Dirac  electron  theory,  with  account 
taken  of  direct  and  reverse  transitions  from  negative  energy  to  posi- 
tive energy.  It  actually  describes  an  electron  and  a  positron  in  a  com- 
pletely symmetrical  way:  the  nonsymmetry  of  the  charge  that  has 
appeared  in  our  terminology  as  a  result  of  the  fact  that  the  positron 
was  defined  as  a  "hole,"  is  only  apparent.  The  background  of  elec- 
trons with  negative  energy  may  be,  as  it  were,  subtracted  from  the 
equations  without  altering  the  physical  content  of  the  theory,  and  so 
the  equations  become  symmetrical  with  respect  to  the  sign  of  the 
charge.  The  concept  of  particles  and  antiparticles  is  extended  also  to 
particles  without  spin  (for  example,  TC+-  and  7r"-mesons). 

It  is  characteristic  that  the  relativistic  quantum  theory  describes 
change  in  the  number  of  particles:  electrodynamics  treats  of  ab- 
sorption and  emission  of  quanta,  electron  theory  is  concerned  with 
the  creation  and  annihilation  of  pairs. 

The  electron-positron-photon  field.  Electrons  together  with  a  field 
form  a  sort  of  unified  electron-positron-electromagnetic  field.  Insofar 
as  interaction  exists  between  electrons  and  positrons,  on  the  one 
hand,  and  quanta,  on  the  other,  the  division  of  a  unified  field  into 
charges  and  quanta  becomes,  in  a  certain  sense,  artificial  and,  in  any 
case,  approximate.  The  strength  of  interaction  between  field  and 
charge  is  determined  by  the  dimensionless  parameter 

e2  _    1 
he  ~"  137  ' 

Since  this  parameter  is  a  rather  small  number,  the  approximation 
arising  from  the  separated  charges  and  field  seems  satisfactory. 

As  was  mentioned  in  Sec.  27,  the  theory  still  has  certain  difficulties. 
The  most  difficult  problem — even  the  approach  to  which  is  not 

known — consists  in  an  explanation  of  the  number  -r«=-  :  since  it  is  an 

abstract  number,  the  theory  shbuld,  in  principle,  derive  it  from  certain 
general  physical  principles.  But  these  principles  have  not  yet  been 
formulated. 

Nevertheless,  all  problems  in  which  quantum  electrodynamics  is 
used  in  calculating  experimental  quantities  have  complete  and  unique 


Sec.  38]  THE   BELATIVISTIC   WAVE  EQUATION  403 

solutions.  Therefore,  despite  certain  imperfections,  the  quantum  theo- 
ry of  the  electromagnetic  field  possesses  the  essential  features  of  a 
correct  theory:  agreement  with  experiment  and  a  very  specific  mecha- 
nism for  calculation. 

The  quantum  theory  for  other  fields  is  quite  a  different  matter. 
The  only  other  comparatively  satisfactory  situation  is  in  the  theory  of 
the  field  responsible  for  the  beta  disintegration  of  nuclei  and  other 
so-called  "weak  interactions,"  like  Tu-pL-meson  decay,  etc.  (see  below). 

As  regards  the  theory  of  nuclear  forces,  all  that  is  known  from  a 
series  of  unsuccessful  attempts  is  what  form  the  theory  cannot  have. 
However,  there  are  many  experimental  facts  that  permit  of  a  con- 
clusion concerning  the  physical  nature  of  nuclear  forces.  These  forces 
are  undoubtedly  related,  at  least  in  part,  with  the  so-called  7c-mesons — 
particles  with  mass  273  times  that  of  the  electron  mass.  These  mesons 
play  the  part  of  quanta  in  the  field  of  nuclear  forces.  But  they  interact 
with  nucleons  (i.e.,  with  protons  and  neutrons)  so  intensely  that  it  is 
doubtful  whether  there  is  any  sense  in  a  separate  consideration  of 
nucleons  and  7r-mesons  as  opposed  to  electrodynamics,  where,  to  an 
initial  approximation,  electrons  and  quanta  may  be  considered  sepa- 
rately. 

In  addition  to  re-mesons ,  there  are  heavy  jfiT-mesons,  which  dis- 
integrate into  three,  and  sometimes  only  into  two,  7u-mesons. 

Upon  decay,  Ti-mesons  give  fA-mesons,  which  interact  weakly  with 
nuclei.  The  role  played  by  such  weakly  interacting  particles  in  the 
general  scheme  of  nuclear  forces  is  mysterious  in  the  extreme. 

An  analysis  of  experimental  data  shows  that  the  three  basic  types 
of  elementary  interactions  differ  essentially  as  to  their  strength: 

1 )  The  strongest  are  nuclear  interactions.  These  include,  for  example, 
interactions  between  7u-mesons  and  nucleons. 

2)  Electromagnetic  interactions  between  quanta  and  charged  ele- 
mentary particles  are  approximately  one  hundred  times  weaker  than 
nuclear  interactions. 

3)  Interactions  which  are  related  to  beta  disintegration  or,  for 
example,  to  the  decay  of  heavy  mesons  of  mass  960  electron  masses 
into  2  or  3  7u-mesons  are  weaker  than  nuclear  interactions  by  a  factor 
of  1011. 

Landau,  and  also  Lee  and  Yang,  have  shown  that  the  laws  for  weak 
interactions  cannot  be  invariant  with  respect  to  a  simple  transfor- 
mation from  a  right-handed  to  a  left-handed  coordinate  system  (in- 
version). For  the  interaction  to  remain  invariant,  it  is  necessary, 
simultaneously  with  inversion,  to  transfer  from  particles  to  antipar- 
ticles,  i.e.,  from  electrons  to  positrons,  from  protons  to  antiprotons, 
from  TC+-  to  7c~-mesons,  etc. 

Thus,  the  simple  law  of  conservation  of  parity,  which  obtains  for 
nuclear  and  electromagnetic  interactions,  changes  its  form  for  weak 
interactions.  Starting  with  the  principle  of  "combined  parity," 

26* 


404  QUANTUM   MECHANICS  [Part   III 

R.  Feynman  and  R.  Gell-Mann  (and,  independently,  R.  Marshak 
and  Snolarshan)  have  succeeded  in  constructing  a  universal  Hamil- 
tonian  for  all  the  weak  interactions.  The  original  form  was  suggested 
by  Fermi.  It  contains  a  new  universal  constant  of  the  order  of 
10-49erg-cm3. 

Classification  o!  elementary  particles.  It  is  rather  difficult  to  define 
exactly  just  what  an  "elementary"  particle  is.  At  the  beginning  of 
this  century,  the  atoms  of  elements  were  considered  to  be  elementary 
particles,  since  they  were  thought  to  be  indivisible.  Now  we  know 
that  atoms  consist  of  electrons,  protons,  and  neutrons,  and  we  are 
quite  sure  that  these  latter  do  not  consist  of  still  other  particles  of  a 
more  "elementary"  nature  in  the  same  sense  as  atoms  do. 

Several  elementary  particles  transform  into  one  another.  In  some 
cases  we  can  precalculate  the  laws  of  such  transformations,  for  in- 
stance, for  electrons,  positrons,  and  photons,  or,  to  a  less  extent,  for 
beta  transformations;  but  we  know  very  little  about  strong  nuclear 
interactions,  which  are  undoubtedly  also  connected  with  some  con- 
version of  elementary  particles. 

To  visualize  this  situation  better  let  us  consider  the  following  proc- 
ess: a  neutron  emits  a  negative  7r-meson,  and  a  proton  absorbs  it. 
The  neutron  converts  into  a  proton,  and  the  proton  into  a  neutron, 
and  the  whole  process  of  emission  and  reabsorption  can  be  treated 
as  an  "exchange"  interaction.  This  sort  of  interaction  is  to  some 
extent  analogous  to  electromagnetic  interaction,  where  a  photon  is 
emitted  by  one  electron  and  absorbed  by  another,  but  unlike  the  elec- 
tromagnetic forces,  we  can  describe  the  mechanism  of  nuclear  forces 
only  in  words.  All  attempts  to  do  more  have  as  yet  failed. 

Despite  the  lack  of  a  theory  of  elementary  particles,  it  is  now  possible 
to  bring  them  into  some  order.  This  classification  is  due  to  R.  Gell- 
Mann. 

We  shall  not  describe  the  experimental  proofs  of  the  existence  of  all 
the  elementary  particles  listed  below;  such  proof  can  be  found  else- 
where. Let  us  be  satisfied  in  stating  that  their  actual  existence  is  quite 
definite,  in  contrast  to  the  "existence"  of  the  ephemeral  elementary 
particles  which  disappear  from  the  pages  of  scientific  papers  after  a 
careful  investigation. 

The  Gell-Mann  classification  is  based  primarily  on  particle  inter- 
action. First,  a  particle  exists  which  is  capable  of  electromagnetic 
interaction  only.  This  is  the  photon,  or  the  quantum  of  electromagnetic 
radiation.  Another  group  of  particles  is  not  capable  of  strong  nuclear 
interactions:  the  (ji-meson,  the  electron,  and  the  neutrino — the  so- 
called  "leptons"  (light  particles).  Still  another  group  of  particles, 
consisting  of  TT-  and  ^T-mesons,  is  capable  of  nuclear  interactions.  The 
masses  of  these  particles  are  intermediate  between  those  of  nucleons 
and  leptons.  TT-  and  IT-mesons  can  appear  and  disappear  in  the  nuclear 
transformations  of  other  highly  energetic  particles;  no  conservation 


Sec.  38]  THE   RELATIVISTIC   WAVE   EQUATION  405 

law  for  their  number  exists,  but  the  charge  conservation  law  is  never 
violated.  The  name  baryon  (heavy  particles)  has  been  given  to  a 
fourth  group  of  elementary  particles.  This  group  consists  of  stable 

nucleons  (neutron  and  proton),  and  unstable  hyperons:  A,  JT^andS, 

which  transform  spontaneously  into  nucleons.  A  conservation  law 
concerning  the  baryon  number  exists,  and  is  as  strong  as  the  charge 
conservation  law. 

All  the  particles  listed  above,  except  the  photon  and  the  7u°-meson 
have  counterparts  —  antiparticles.  It  is  very  important  that  a  particle 
need  not  to  be  electrically  charged  to  be  able  to  have  an  aiitiparticle, 
as  witness  the  antineutron.  The  process  of  particle-antiparticle  inter- 
action is  one  of  annihilation  ;  thus,  the  antineutron  and  the  neutron 
are  mutually  annihilated,  and  in  the  process  create  7r-mesons.  True 
neutral  particles  are  only  those  that  do  not  possess  antiparticles,  or, 
in  other  words,  such  that  physically  coincide  with  them  in  a  trans- 
formation from  the  ordinary  world  into  the  "antiworld."  This  means 
a  mathematical  transformation  of  all  the  wave  equations  interchang- 
ing positrons  and  electrons,  negative  antiprotons  and  protons,  etc. 
(some  think  that  antinebulae  actually  exist  in  the  universe). 

If  the  physical  laws  governing  the  antiworld  are  the  same  as  those 
that  govern  our  ordinary  world,  then  the  Hamiltonian  of  electro- 
magnetic interaction  must  be  invariant  under  transformation  from 
one  to  the  other.  The  sign  of  the  charge  evidently  changes  in  such  a 
transformation,  and  the  charge  enters  the  Hamiltonian  multiplied 
by  the  amplitude  of  the  electromagnetic  field,  the  vector  potential  A, 
so  the  latter  must  change  its  sign  simultaneously.  We  conclude  that 
the  amplitude  of  the  photon  is  odd  with  respect  to  a  transformation 
from  the  ordinary  world  to  the  antiworld.  The  7c°-meson  decays  into 
two  photons;  consequently  its  amplitude  must  be  even. 

Such  parity  of  true  neutral  particles  is  one  of  their  very  important 
characteristics. 

We  now  pass  to  a  iiontrivial  point  in  the  Gell-Mann  classification. 
We  first  consider  the  decay  of  the  electrically  neutral  A  particle 

A-  >7t°+n    or  A->TC~  +  P 


(both  are  possible).  The  mean  time  of  such  decay  is  of  the  order  of 
10~10  sec,  but  the  A  particle  itself  was  created  in  a  nuclear  collision 
which  lasted  less  than  10~21  sec.  It  appears  rather  puzzling  that  a 
particle  that  can  be  created  so  quickly  should  disappear  so  slowly. 
It  seems  to  contradict  the  general  reversibility  of  physical  laws  in 
time.  This  was  why  the  A  particle  came  to  be  called  "strange."  The 
only  explanation  is  that  both  processes  are  of  a  totally  different  na- 
ture. The  generation  of  a  particle  is  due  to  a  strong  interaction,  and 
the  decay,  to  a  weak  interaction.  It  is  enough  to  suppose  that  the 
A  particle  is  always  created  from  a  nucleon  accompanied  by  a 


406  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

jff-meson.  This  has  been  verified  experimentally,  though  indirectly.  Such 
a  process  does  not  violate  the  baryon  conservation  law.  If  A  and  K 
particles  take  part  in  the  interaction  simultaneously,  it  is  strong, 
and  if  only  one  of  them  transforms  into  something  else,  the  interaction 
is  weak. 

To  distinguish  between  these  two  types  of  interaction,  Gell-Mann 
introduced  a  new  characteristic  of  mesons  and  of  baryons  —  their 
"strangeness,"  S.  It  is  defined  as  follows: 


.  - 

e         2  ^    *    '     2  ' 

Here,  Q  is  the  charge  of  the  baryon,  e  is  the  magnitude  of  the  elemen- 
tary charge,  n  is  the  difference  between  the  number  of  baryons  and 
antibaryons  (1  for  baryons,  —  1  for  antibaryons,  and  0  for  mesons), 
and  T*  is  the  z-component  of  the  isotopic  spin  (see  Sec.  32).  As  all  the 
heavy  particles  take  part  in  strong  interactions,  a  definite  value  of  T* 
can  be  ascribed  to  each  one  of  them,  n  must  be  taken  equal  to  1  for 

each  baryon.  For  nucleons,  T*  is  +  y,  as  they  can  have  only  two  values 
of  charge:  1  and  0.  A  has  no  charge  and  can  have  only  Tg  =  0.  JT1  has 

three  values  of  charge:  1,  0,  —  1,  and  equal  values  of  T*.  Lastly,  S  is 
either  neutral  (r*=l/2)  or  negative  (T*  —  —  1/2).  Substituting  these 
values  of  charge  and  T*  into  the  definition  of  strangeness,  we  find  that 

nucleons  have  /S^=0,  A  and  ^7  hyperons  have  8==  —  1  and  S  has 

8^  —  2.  It  is  noteworthy  that^+  andJT^  are  not  particle  and  anti- 

particle,  as  both  have  w~l.  Each  of  them  has  an  antibaryon,  for 
which  n  —  —  1. 
For  K-  and  Ti-mesons,  n  =  0,  since  they  are  not  baryons.  This  gives 

8  =0  for  re-mesons  and  S  —  1  for  .fiT-  mesons.  Unlike  J7=fc,  TC*  are  related 

as  particle  and  antiparticle. 

Then  a  selection  rule  is  defined:  the  given  interaction  is  strong 
only  when  the  resulting  strangeness  of  all  particles  entering  into  the 
reaction  is  conserved.  For  instance,  every  interaction  of  nucleons  and 
7r-mesons  only  is  strong  (if  it  does  not  violate  any  other  conservation 
laws,  except  strangeness). 

The  simultaneous  creation  of  A  and  K  particles  belongs  to  strong 
interactions  also,  since  one  of  them  has  /S  =  l,  and  the  other  S  =  —  1. 
But  the  spontaneous  decay  of  the  A  particle  into  a  nucleon  and  a 
7r-meson  is  due  to  a  weak  interaction,  because,  here,  the  strangeness 
is  not  conserved. 

Transitions  with  AS  =  2  are  forbidden  more  strongly  than  with 

=  1.  That  is  why  the  S  particle  must  decay  first  into  a  A  orJT* 


SeC.  38]  THE   RELATIVISTIC   WAVE   EQUATION  407 

particle,  which  in  turn  decays  intoTnucleons  and  7u-mesons.  These 
statements  agree  with  the  cascade  nature  of  S  decay. 

There  is  no  reason  as  yet  to  attribute  definite  values  of  T*  and  8 
to  leptons,  since  they  do  not  take  part  in  strong  interactions. 

The  transition  to  the  nonrelativistic  wave  equation.  It  is  instructive, 
in  comparing  the  relativistic  wave  equation  with  Schrodinger's  equa- 
tion, to  perform  the  limiting  transition.  We  shall  consider  that  the 
energy  of  the  electron  is  positive  and  that  its  velocity  v  is  considerably 
less  than  the  velocity  of  light.  Then  <?  differs  from  me2  by  a  small 

quantity-^-.  If  we  take  mc2^  and  mc2$2  to  the  left-hand  side  in  the 
first  and  second  equations  (38.11),  the  components  ^  and  ^2  are  mul- 
tiplied by  the  quantity  S — we2,  i.e.,  by  -y~.  The  wave-function 

components  ^3  and  ip4  appear  on  the  right,  multiplied  by  cpx  or  by 
cpy.  It  follows  that,  for  a  positive  energy,  the  components  i[/3  and  ^4 

are  less  than  ^  and  tp2  in  the  ratio  -^-.The  same  follows  from  the  second 

two  equations  (38.11):  the  components  ^3  and  ^  appearjon  the  right 
multiplied  by  ~2  me2,  and  ^  and  ip2  are  on  the  left  with  a  factor  of 
the  order  cp. 

For  negative  energies  the  components  ^3  and  ip4  are  large,  while 

^l  and  <p2  are  less  in  the  ratio  ~ . 

Consequently,  in  the  nonrelativistic  limit  Dirac's  equation  is  re- 
duced to  two-component  form  (as  is  required  according  to^Sec.  32)  for 

a  description  of  particles  with  spin  -^- . 

Spin  magnetic  moment.  We  shall  now  show  how  spin  magnetic  mo- 
ment is  obtained.  It  is  first  of  all  necessary  to  write  down  the  Dirac 
equation  in  an  electromagnetic  field.  We  know  that  for  a  transition 
from  the  equation  for  a  free  particle  to  an  equation  for  a  particle  in  a 

field  it  is  necessary  to  replace  the  momentum  p  by  p  —  —  A,  where  A 

is  the  vector  potential,  and  the  energy  <?  by  S — e<p  (see  Sec.  21). 
Thus,  the  Dirac  equation  in  the  presence  of  an  electromagnetic  field 
isof  the  form 

^+pmc2^.  (38.18) 

As  was  pointed  out,  the  relations  between  the  wave-function  com- 
ponents in  the  nonrelativistic  limit  without  field  appear  as 

[(P*  -  ipd  ^2  +  P*  W  > 


408  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part   III 

It  is  convenient  to  write  down  these  relations,  according  to  Sec.  32, 
with  the  aid  of  the  operators  o,  the  definition  of  which  involves  the 

factor     [see  (32.2),  (32.8),  (32.9)]: 

(38'20) 

Here,  the  two  small  wave-function  components  ^3  and  ^4  are  for  short 
denoted  by  <j/,  and  the  two  large  components  ^i  and  ^2  are  called  fy. 

In  addition,  the  momentum  p  is  replaced  by  p A. 

c 

We  shall  also  call  £  -^mc* -\-$' ,  where  $'  is  the  energy  value  which 
appears  in  the  nonrelativistic  theory.    Then,   after  replacing  p  by 

p A,  we  obtain  from  the  first  two  equations  of  (38.11) 

(38.21) 

We  can  now  eliminate  <{/  from  the  equations,  so  that  only  the  rela- 
tions for  the  large  components  ty  remain. 

Substituting  $'  in  (38.21)  from  (38.20),  we  shall  have 

(f     e<p)<|/-- a,p-Aa,p---A*.  (38.22) 


(e      \ 
o,p -A  we  must  take  into  account 

C  '  ~ 

the  commutation  relations  between  the  components  of  o  and  also 
between  p  and  A.  Taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that  6£  —  ay  —  a*  —  —  , 

and  calling  px — —AX---PX...,   and  analoguously  for   Py  and   Pz, 

c 

we  shall  first  of  all  have 

($'  —  69)^  —    -g —  (p A 1  +  - —  (Sx  ay  Px  Py  -\~  oy  ax Py  Px)  +  . . .  I  ^ . 

(38.23) 
•% 
Further,  we  utilize  the  fact  that  6*6y=- — Oya*^^  [see  (32.13)], 

and  also  the  commutation  relations  of  the  form 


PX   Py   —   Py  PX  —  ~   ~  (pXAy  +  Ax  fry  —  fry  A 


c 

(38.24) 


—     e^    (  ®^X    _     ^^*  \    —  ek 

~~cT\~ay         dx~)  ~~~i^ 


[cf.  (30.36)].  Substituting  this  in  (38.23),  we  obtain  an  equation  for 
the  components 


Sec.  38]  THE  RE:LATIVISTIC  WAVE  EQUATION  409 

(f  -  e<p)  *  =--  [~  (p  -  -J  A)2  -  £  (5,  #*  +  S,£T,  +  S,ff,)]  *  . 

Going  over  to  vector  notation,  we  arrive  at  the  iionrelativistic 
wave  equation 


Compared  with  the  Hamiltonian  operator  for  a  spinless  particle, 
the  Hamiltonian  of  an  electron  involves  an  additional  term: 

^o  =  -^(5H)s-(|i0H).  (38.26) 

But  since  6  is  an  additional  mechanical  moment,  we  see  that  the  elec- 
tron has  an  additional  magnetic  moment 

Ao=^S  (38.27) 

in  accordance  with  what  was  affirmed  in  (32.17)  (a  here  is  a  dimension- 
less  operator).  Spin  differs  from  orbital  angular  momentum  in  that 
its  magnetic  moment  does  not  contain  a  factor  2  in  the  denominator. 
Thus,  the  so-called  spin  magnetic  anomaly  follows  naturally  from  the 
Dirac  equation. 

The  radiation-field  correction  to  the  magnetic  moment.  Equation 
(38.27)  is,  of  course,  correct  only  in  the  nonrelativistic  limit.  But  even 
in  this  limit  it  is  not  completely  exact.  As  was  indicated  in  Sec.  27, 
the  state  of  an  electromagnetic  field  in  which  there  are  no  quanta 
interacts  with  charged  particles.  Strictly  speaking,  insofar  as  there 
is  an  interaction  between  the  charges  and  the  field,  the  state  of  each 
separately  cannot  be  defined  with  complete  precision.  It  is  therefore 
not  surprising  that  any  state  of  a  field  is  in  some  way  perturbed  by  the 
presence  of  charges,  and  any  state  of  the  charges  is  perturbed  by  the 
field.  As  a  result  of  this,  the  magnetic  moment  of  an  electron,  as  is 
shown  by  the  rather  exact  calculations  of  Schwinger  and  others,  is 
greater  than  one  magneton  by  a  very  small  quantity,  whose  relative 

yj2 

fraction  is  -^  —  r—  .  This  result  is  in  complete  agreement  with  experi- 

ment. 

The  magnetic  moments  of  the  proton  and  neutron  do  not  at  all 
agree  with  the  Dirac  theory.  For  instance,  on  Dirac's  theory,  a  neutral 
particle  (the  neutron)  should  not  have  a  magnetic  moment  at  all. 
In  actual  fact,  the  neutron  possesses  a  magnetic  moment  directed 
opposite  to  the  spin. 

This  is  usually  explained  by  the  strong  interaction  between  the 
nucleoii  and  the  nuclear  force  field  or,  as  it  is  sometimes  called,  the 
meson  field.  There  is  a  certain  analogy  here  with  the  correction  to 


410  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part  III 

the  magnetic  moment  of  the  electron.  This  correction  is  small  because 


the  interaction  constant  -r—  is  small.  Nuclear  interaction  is  very  strong, 

he 

and  so  the  result  is  a  large  "correction,"  if  one  can  use  that  expression 
for  a  quantity  which,  in  the  case  of  a  proton,  is  twice  as  great  as  the 
basic  magnetic  moment  given  by  the  Dirac  theory. 

At  the  present  time  we  are  unable  to  calculate  the  magnetic  moment 
of  a  nucleon,  since  no  theory  of  nuclear  forces  exists. 

Nevertheless,  the  nucleon  is  undoubtedly  to  some  extend  a  Dirac 
particle,  as  confirmed  by  the  existence  of  the  antiproton. 

Energy  eigenvalues  of  a  hydrogen  atom.  In  accordance  with  the 
Dirac  equation,  the  energy  eigenvalues  of  a  hydrogen  atom,  or  of 
any  single-electron  atom,  are  calculated  in  the  following  way: 


-1,       (38.28) 


+ 


where  n  is  the  principal  quantum  number,  j  =  l±-^,i.e.,  j  is  the  total 
electron  angular  momentum,  a  =  -|^-  =  -y^- .  If  we  regard  ocZ  as  small 

compared  with  unity,  then  the  nonrelativistic  formula  (31.34)  results. 
It  follows  from  formula  (38.28)  that  the  states  2^/2  and  2si/a,  with 

the  same  n  ~  2  and  j~^-,  have  the  same  energy.  In  practice,  these 

states  of  the  atom  are  somewhat  split  as  a  result  of  the  interaction 
of  light  quanta  with  the  ground  state  of  the  field.  The  calculated 
splitting  agrees  with  experiment  with  considerable  accuracy. 

Exercises 

1)  Prove  that  a  quantum  cannot  give  rise  to  an  electron -positron  pair 
in  free  space  in  the  absence  of  an  additional  external  field. 

The  conservation  laws  in  the  absence  of  a  field  are  written  thus: 


—  V™2  c*  -f-  ca  pa  4  h  <o  =  V™2  c4  -f  c2  pi ,    p-f n  ^pj. 

c 

Here,  p  is  the  electron  momentum  in  a  negative  energy  state,  n  is  a  unit 
vector  in  the  direction  of  the  quantum  momentum,  pt  is  the  electron  momentum 
in  a  positive  energy  state.  Substituting  Pj  in  the  first  equality  and  squaring 
the  left-  and  right-hand  sides,  it  is  easy  to  see  that  this  equation  is  not  satis- 
fied. 

Another  method  of  proof  is  based  on  simple  reasoning.  A  transition  to 
another  inertia!  system  can  always  make  the  energy  of  a  quantum  less  than 
2  me2.  A  quantum  cannot  give  rise  to  a  pair  in  such  a  system,  simply  because 
it  has  insufficient  energy.  But  what  is  impossible  in  one  reference  system 
is  impossible  in  all  systems,  because  the  possibility  or  impossibility  of  an 
event  does  not  depend  upon  the  choice  of  the  reference  system. 


Sec.  38]  THE   BELATTVISTIO   WAVE   EQUATION  411 

The  preceding  argument  no  longer  holds  if  pair  production  is  considered 
close  to  a  nucleus.  Here,  the  nucleus  is  at  rest  in  one  reference  system  and 
in  motion  in  another.  Where  the  energy  of  the  quantum  is  less  than  2  me2, 
the  moving  nucleus  will  "help"  it  to  give  rise  to  a  pair.  Naturally,  it  is  in  no 
way  possible  for  a  quantum  to  give  rise  to  a  pair  if  its  energy  in  the  rest  system 
of  the  nucleus  is  less  than  2  me*. 

2)  Obtain  the  solution  to  the  Dirac  equation  for  a  free  electron. 

Let  us  equate  ^  to  zero.  Then  the  first  equation  of  (38.11)  is  satisfied  if 
we  take  ^3  -^  Ac  (px  —  ipy),  <J>4  ~  —Ac  pz.  The  second  equation  of  (38.11) 
gives 


Y2 


—  me2 


The  third  equation  of  (38.11)  reduces  to  the  identity 

(<T  J  me2)  ^3  =  Ac  (&  -f-  me2)  (px  —  ipy)  =  c(px  —  ipy)  <j;a  =  Ac  (px  -  ipy)  (&  -\-  me2)  . 

The  fourth  equation  of  (38.11)  also  reduces  to  an  identity.  The  number  A 
is  determined  from  the  normalization  condition 


A*  [(*  +  we2)2  +  c*p*x  -f- 


-I-  me2) 

The  components  ^3  and  4>4  are  small  compared  with  ^2  if  v  <£  c.  Therefore 
the  solution  corresponds  to  positive  energy.  Another  solution  with  positive 
energy  is  obtained  if  we  take  <|;2  =  0.  Negative  energy  solutions  are  obtained 
if  we  choose  ^3  —  0  or  ^4  =  0. 

3)  Show  that  from  Dirac's  equation  there  follows  a  charge-conservation 
equation  which  is  analogous  to  (24.16): 


whore  |  *  |2  =  |  <K  |2  +  K*  |a  +  Ks  I2  +  |  h  |2- 

Write  down  equation  (38.18)  and  its  complex  conjugate;  multiply  the 
first  by  4>*  and  the  second  by  fy;  subtract  the  second  from  the  first  and  utilize 
the  Hermitian  nature  of  the  operators  a  and  p. 

4)  Show  that  if  ^  is  a  solution  with  positive  energy  <f  ,  then  p2  <]>  is  a  solution 
with  negative  energy  —  ^. 

The  equation  for  <J>  is 


+  me2  (3  < 
Whence 


This  proves  that  a  negative  energy  solution  cannot  be  avoided. 
5)  Prove  that  the  operators 


acting  upon  four-component  functions,  are  spin  operators. 


412  QUANTUM  MECHANICS  [Part   III 

We  have 

.2  A2  ....         h*  .2        h* 

ax  ~  —  —  j-  «y  a  ^  oty  oijjr  —  —  -  —  ay  =  —r-  , 

..  ft«    ____  A2   _  .  &   ~ 

CTA.   ay  =  ---  -  ay  a.z  a.z  ax  =  --  —  a.y  <x.x  —  1  -jr  <*z9 


so  that  the  spin  operators  determined  here  possess  all  the  required  properties 
(see  See.  32).  This  can  also  be  seen  from  the  definition  of  d  in  terms  of  o  and 
p.  Wo  notice  that  the  spin  operators  do  not  permute  functions  of  the  first 
pair  4>i»  ^2  and  of  the  second  pair  <|>3,  <^4»  but  make  permutations  only  inside 
each  pair. 

(>)  Show  that  according  to  the  Dirac  equation  only  the  sum  of  the  orbital 
and  spin  angular  momenta  and  not  each  angular  momentum  separately  satis- 
fies the  angular-momentum  conservation  law. 

Tho  total  angular  momentum  is  defined  as 


ypx  +  -g-r-  a*  ay. 
We  calculate  the  commutator  with  the  Hamiltonian: 

-ypx   |    -A_ 


he 


y)    -  —?-  (axpy  —  ay  px  -\-  px  ay  -  py  avV) 


The  Hamiltonian  is  commutative  also  with  the  square  of  the  total  angular 
momentum  J2  -  -•  jj  +  «7y  +  J  J  .  Tho  integrals  of  motion  are  J2  and  Jz,  and 
not  Mz,  o2  and  JVf^-,  3^  separately. 


PART  IV 
STATISTICAL  PHYSICS 

lee.  39.  The  Equilibrium  Distribution  of  Molecules  in  an  Ideal  Gas 

The  subject  of  statistical  physics.  The  methods  of  quantum  mechanics 
et  out  in  the  third  part  make  it  possible,  in  principle,  to  describe 
ny  assembly  of  electrons,  atoms,  and  molecules  comprising  a  macro - 
copic  body. 

In  practice,  however,  even  the  problem  of  an  atom  with  two  elec- 
rons  presents  such  great  mathematical  difficulties  that  nobody,  so 
ar,  has  solved  it  completely.  It  is  all  the  more  impossible  not  only 
o  solve  but  even  to  write  down  the  wave  equation  for  a  macroscopic 
>ody  consisting,  for  example,  of  1023  atoms  with  their  electrons. 

Yet  in  large  systems,  we  encounter  certain  general  laws  of  motion 
or  which  it  is  not  necessary  to  know  the  wave  function  of  the  system 
o  describe  them.  Let  us  give  one  very  simple  example  of  such  a  law. 
Ve  shall  suppose  that  there  is  only  one  molecule  contained  in  a  large, 
ompletely  empty  vessel.  If  the  motion  of  this  molecule  is  not  defined 
Beforehand,  the  probability  of  finding  it  in  any  half  of  the  vessel  is 
qual  to  1/2.  If  there  are  two  molecules  in  the  same  vessel,  the  prob- 
,bility  of  finding  them  in  the  same  half  of  the  vessel  simultaneously 

3  equal  to  \-~\  =  1/4.  The  probability  of  finding  all  of  a  gas,  consisting 

>f  N  particles,  in  the  same  half  of  the  vessel  (if  the  vessel  is  filled  with 
;as)  is  (1/2)N,  i.e.,  an  unimaginably  small  number.  On  the  average, 
here  will  always  be  an  approximately  equal  number  of  molecules  in 
>ach  half  of  the  vessel.  The  greater  the  number  of  molecules  forming 
he  gas,  the  closer  to  unity  will  be  the  ratio  of  the  number  of  molecules 
n  both  halves  of  the  vessel,  no  matter  at  what  time  they  are 
>bserved. 

This  approximate  equality  for  the  number  of  molecules  in  equal 
volumes  of  the  same  vessel  gives  an  almost  obvious  example  of  a  sta- 
istical  law  applicable  only  to  a  large  assembly  of  objects.  In  addition 
-o  a  spatial  distribution,  molecules  possess  a  definite  velocity  distri- 


414  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

bution,  which,  however,  can  in  no  way  be  uniform  (if  only  because  the 
probability  of  an  infinitely  large  velocity  is  equal  to  zero). 

Statistical  physics  studies  the  laws  governing  the  motion  of  large 
assemblies  of  electrons,  atoms,  quanta,  molecules,  etc.  The  problem 
of  the  velocity  distribution  of  gas  molecules  is  one  of  the  simplest 
that  is  solved  by  the  methods  of  statistical  physics. 

Statistical  physics  introduces  a  series  of  new  quantities,  which  can- 
not be  defined  in  terms  of  single-body  dynamics  or  the  dynamics  of  a 
small  number  of  bodies.  An  example  of  such  a  statistical  quantity  is 
temperature,  which  turns  out  to  be  closely  related  to  the  mean  energy 
of  a  gas  molecule.  If  a  gas  is  confined  only  to  one  half  of  a  vessel,  and  the 
barrier  dividing  the  vessel  is  then  removed,  the  gas  will  itself  uniformly 
fill  both  halves.  Similarly,  if  the  velocity  distribution  of  the  molecules 
is  disturbed  in  some  way,  then,  as  a  result  of  collisions  between  the 
molecules  there  will  be  established  a  very  definite  statistical  distri- 
bution, which,  for  constant  external  conditions,  will  be  maintained 
approximately  for  an  indefinitely  long  time.  This  example  involving 
collisions  shows  that  regularity  in  statistics  arises  not  only  because  a 
large  assembly  of  objects  is  taken,  but  also  because  they  interact. 

The  statistical  law  in  quantum  mechanics.  Quantum  mechanics  also 
describes  statistical  regularities,  but  relating  to  a  separate  object. 
Here,  the  statistical  regularity  manifests  itself  in  a  very  large  number 
of  identical  experiments  with  identical  objects,  and  is  in  no  way  relat- 
ed to  the  interaction  of  these  objects.  For  example,  the  electrons  in  a 
diffraction  experiment  may  pass  through  a  crystal  with  arbitrary  time 
intervals  and  nevertheless  give  exactly  the  same  statistical  picture 
for  the  blackening  of  a  photographic  plate  as  if  they  had  passed  through 
the  crystal  simultaneously. 

Regularities  in  alpha  disintegration  cannot  be  accounted  for  by  the 
fact  that  there  are  a  very  large  number  of  nuclei:  since  there  is  practi- 
cally no  interaction  between  nuclei  inducing  the  process,  the  statisti- 
cal character  predicted  by  quantum  mechanics  is  only  manifested 
for  a  large  number  of  identical  objects ;  it  is  by  no  means  due  to  their 
number.  In  this  connection,  a  description  of  phenomena  in  quantum 
mechanics  involves  the  concept  of  probability  phase,  similar  to  the 
concept  of  the  phase  of  a  light  wave. 

In  principle,  the  wave  equation  can  also  be  applied  to  systems  con- 
sisting of  a  large  number  of  particles.  The  solution  of  such  an  equation 
represents  a  detailed  quantum-mechanical  description  of  the  state 
of  the  system.  Let  us  suppose  that  as  a  result  of  the  solution  of  the 
wave  equation  we  have  obtained  a  certain  spectrum  of  energy  eigen- 
values of  the  system 

*  =  *Q, *!,**,  .••>£»,  ...  (39.1) 

in  states  with  wave  functions 


Sec.  39]  THE  EQUILIBRIUM  DISTRIBUTION   OF  MOLECULES  415 

Then  the  wave  function  for  any  state,  as  was  shown  in  Sec.  30,  can 
be  represented  in  the  form  of  a  sum  of  ^-functions  of  states  with  defi- 
nite energy  values: 

(39.2) 


The  square  of  the  modulus 

Wn  =  \Cn\2  (39.3) 

gives  the  probability  (when  the  energy  of  a  system  in  the  state  fy  is 
measured)  that  the  result  will  be  the  nth  value. 

The  expansion  (39.2)  makes  it  possible  to  determine  not  only  ampli- 
tudes, but  also  relative  probability  phases  corresponding  to  a  detailed 
quantum-mechanical  description  of  the  system. 

The  methods  of  statistical  physics  make  it  possible  straightway 
to  determine  approximately  the  quantities  wn=  |cM|2,  i.e.,  the  prob- 
abilities themselves  omitting  their  phases.  For  this  reason,  the 
wave  function  of  the  system  cannot  be  determined  from  them,  al- 
though it  is  possible  to  find  the  practically  important  mean  values 
of  quantities  that  characterize  macroscopic  bodies  (for  example, 
their  mean  energy). 

In  this  section  we  shall  consider  how  to  calculate  the  probability 
wn  as  applied  to  an  ideal  gas. 

Ideal  gases.  An  ideal  gas  is  a  system  of  particles  whose  interaction 
can  be  neglected.  The  interaction  resulting  from  collisions  between 
molecules  is  essential  only  when  the  statistical  distribution  wn  is  in 
the  process  of  being  established.  When  this  distribution  becomes 
established  the  effect  of  interaction  is  very  slight. 

As  regards  condensed  (i.e.,  solid  and  liquid)  bodies,  the  molecules 
are  all  the  time  in  vigorous  interaction,  so  that  the  statistical  distri- 
bution depends  essentially  upon  the  forces  acting  between  the  bodies. 

But  even  in  a  gas  the  particles  must  not  be  regarded  as  absolutely 
independent.  For  example,  Pauli's  principle  imposes  essential  limi- 
tations on  the  possible  quantum  states  of  a  gas.  We  shall  take  these 
limitations  into  account  when  calculating  probabilities. 

The  states  of  separate  particles  ol  a  gas.  In  order  to  distinguish 
the  states  of  separate  particles  from  the  state  of  the  gas  as  a  whole 
we  shall  denote  their  energies  by  the  letter  e  and  the  energy  of  the 
whole  gas  by  S.  Thus,  for  example,  if  the  gas  is  contained  in  a  rec- 
tangular potential  well  (see  Sec.  25),  then  the  energy  values  for  each 
particle  are  calculated  according  to  equation  (25.19). 

Let  e  take  on  the  following  series  of  values: 

6  =  60,6!,  e2,...,efe,...,  (39.4) 

where  there  are  nQ  particles  in  the  state  with  energy  e0  and  in  general 
there  are  nk  particles  with  energy  g*  in  the  gas.  Then  the  total 
energy  of  the  gas  is 


416  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

(39.5) 


By  giving  different  combinations  of  numbers  Uk,  we  will  obtain 
the  total  energy  values  forming  the  series  (39.1). 

We  have  repeatedly  seen  that  the  energy  value  Zk  does  not  yet 
define  the  particle  states.  For  example,  the  energy  of  a  hydrogen 
atom  depends  only  upon  the  principal  quantum  number  n,*  so 
that  the  atom  can  have  2n2  states  for  a  given  energy  [see  (33.1)]. 
This  number,  2n2,  is  called  the  weight  of  the  state  with  energy  e,,. 
But  it  is  also  possible  to  place  the  system  under  such  conditions  that 
the  energy  value  defines  the  energy  in  principle  uniquely.  We  note, 
first  of  all,  that  in  all  atoms  except  hydrogen  the  energy  depends 
not  only  on  n,  but  on  I  also,  i.e.,  on  the  azimuthal  quantum  number. 
Further,  account  of  the  interaction  between  spin  and  orbit  shows 
that  there  is  a  dependence  of  the  energy  upon  the  total  angular- 
momentum  j  and,  finally,  if  the  atom  is  placed  in  an  external  magnetic 
field,  the  energy  also  depends  upon  the  projection  of  angular  momen- 
tum on  the  magnetic  field.  Thus,  one  energy  value  mutually  corre- 
sponds uniquely  to  one  state  of  the  atom. 

In  a  magnetic  field  all  the  2n2  states  with  the  same  principal 
quantum  number  are  split.  We  now  consider  how  the  states  of  a 
gas  in  a  closed  vessel  are  split.  We  shall  suppose  that  the  vessel  is 
of  the  form  of  a  box  with  incommensurable  squares  of  the  sides 
#i>  #!>  #!•  Then,  in  accordance  with  equation  (25.19),  the  energy 

of  the  particles  is  proportional  to  the   quantity     -—-  +  •—  +  ~ 

where  nv  n&  na  are  positive  integers.  Any  combination  of  these 
integers  gives  one  and  only  one  number  for  the  incommensurable  values 
af,  a|,  a|.  Therefore,  specification  of  the  energy  defines  all  three 
integers  nlt  n&  n$.  If  the  particles  possess  an  intrinsic  angular  mo- 
mentum, we  can,  so  to  speak,  remove  the  degeneracy  by  placing 
the  gas  in  a  magnetic  field  (an  energy  eigenvalue  to  which  there  cor- 
respond several  states  of  a  system  is  termed  degenerate).  We  shall 
first  consider  only  completely  removed  degeneracy. 

States  of  an  ideally  closed  system.  We  shall  now  consider  the  energy 
spectrum  of  a  gas  completely  isolated  from  possible  external  influences 
and  consisting  of  absolutely  noninteracting  particles.  For  simplic- 
ity, we  shall  assume  that  one  value  of  energy  corresponds  to  each 
state  of  the  system  as  a  whole,  and,  conversely,  one  state  corresponds 
to  each  energy  value.  This  assumption  is  true  if  all  the  energy  eigen- 
values for  each  particle  are  incommensurable  numbers).*  We  shall 

*  Not  to  be  confused  with  nfc! 

*  In  a  rectangular  box  the  state  e  (nlf  n2,  n3)  has  an  energy  which  is  com- 
mensurable with  the  energy  of  state  e  (2%,  2  n2,  2  n3).  Therefore,  the  energy 
of  all  states  can  be  incommensurable  only  in  a  box  of  more  complex  form  than 
rectangular. 


Sec.  39]  THE   EQUILIBRIUM  DISTRIBUTION   OF   MOLECULES  417 

call  these  numbers  £fe.  Then,  if  there  are  nk  particles  in  the  &-th 
state,  the  total  energy  of  the  gas  is  equal  to  $  =£nk£k  .  But,  for 


incommensurable  £fe,  it  is  possible  in  principle  to  determine  all 
nk  from  this  equation,  provided  <£  is  precisely  specified.  It  is  clear, 
however,  that  the  energy  of  a  gas  consisting  of  a  sufficiently  large 
number  of  particles  must  be  specified  with  trully  exceptional  ac- 
curacy for  it  bo  be  possible  to  really  find  all  nk  from  ff. 

It  is  not  a  question  of  determining  the  state  of  an  individual  par- 
ticle from  its  energy  <f  ,  but  of  finding  the  state  of  the  whole  gas 
from  the  sum  of  the  energies  of  all  of  its  particles.  Every  interval 
of  values  d  ff,  oven  very  small  (though  not  infinitely  small),  will 
include  very  many  eigenvalues  <f  .  Each  of  them  corresponds  to  its 
own  set  of  values  nk,  i.e.,  to  a  definite  state  of  the  system  as  a  whole. 

States  of  a  nonidoally  closed  system.  Energy  is  an  exact  integral 
of  motion  only  in  an  ideally  closed  system.  The  state  of  such  a  system 
is  maintained  for  an  indefinitely  long  time,  and  the  conservation 
of  the  quantity  $  provides  for  the  constancy  of  all  Uk.  But  nature 
does  not  (and  cannot)  have  ideally  closed  systems.  Every  system 
interacts  in  some  way  with  the  surrounding  medium.  We  will  regard 
this  interaction  as  weak  and  will  determine  how  it  affects  the  be- 
haviour of  the  system. 

Let  us  assume  that  the  interaction  with  the  medium  does  not 
noticeably  disturb  the  quantum  levels  of  separate  particles.  Never- 
theless, every  level  efe  ceases  being  a  precise  number  and  receives 
a  small,  though  finite,  width  A^.  This  is  sufficient  for  the  moaning 

of  the  equation  ff—£nkZk\>v  change  in  a  most  radical  way:  in  a 


system  consisting  of  a  large  number  of  particles,  the  equation  con- 
taining approximate  quantities  £k  no  longer  defines  the  number  Uk. 

In  other  words,  an  interaction  with  the  surrounding  medium, 
no  matter  how  weak,  makes  impossible  an  accurate  determination 
of  the  state  from  the  total  energy  <f  . 

Transitions  between  close-energy  states.  In  an  ideally  closed  system, 
transitions  were  forbidden  for  all  states  corresponding  to  an  energy 
interval  d  <?  because  the  energy  conservation  law  held  strictly.  For 
weak  interaction  with  the  medium,  all  transitions  that  do  not  change 
the  total  energy  of  the  gas  as  a  whole  are  possible  to  an  accuracy 
which  is,  in  general,  compatible  with  the  determination  of  the  energy 
of  a  nonideally  closed  system. 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  interaction  with  the  medium  is  so  weak 
that,  for  some  small  interval  of  time,  it  is  possible,  in  principle,  to 
determine  all  the  quantities  nk  and  thus  to  give  the  total  energy  of 

the  gas  $  =JT'wfe£fe.  But  over  a  large  interval  of  time  the  state  of 


27-0060 


418  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

the  gas  can  now  vary  within  the  limits  of  that  interval  of  total  energy 
which  is  given  by  the  inaccuracy  in  the  energy  of  separate  states 
Ae*.  Ah1  transitions  will  occur  that  are  compatible  with  the  approx- 
imate equation  £  =  57  nk  (£fe  ±  A  efe) ,  Naturally ,  the  state  in  which 

k 

all  Ae*  are  of  one  sign  is  extremely  improbable;  this  is  why  the 
double  symbol  ±  is  written.  We  must  find  the  state  that  is  formed 
as  a  result  of  all  possible  transitions  in  the  interval  dS . 

The  probabilities  of  direct  and  reverse  transitions.  A  very  important 
relation  exists  between  the  probabilities  for  a  direct  and  reverse  tran- 
sition. Let  us  first  of  all  consider  this  relation  on  the  basis  of  equation 
(34.29),  which  is  obtained  as  a  first  approximation  in  perturbation 
theory.  Let  there  be  two  states  A  and  B  in  the  system,  with  wave 
functions  <{M  and  ^B-  The  same  value  of  energy  corresponds  to 
these  states,  within  the  limits  of  inaccuracy  d$  given  by  the  inter- 
action of  the  system  with  the  medium.  In  the  interval  dS,  both 
states  may  be  regarded  as  belonging  to  a  continuous  spectrum. 
Then,  from  (34.29),  the  probability  of  a  transition  from  A  to  B  in 


unit  time  is  equal  to 
where 


27C 


\ ,  and  from  B  to  A, 


27T 


(the  weights  of  the  states  are  denoted  by  QA,  gu).  But,  if  gA  =  QB, 
then  the  probabilities  for  direct  and  reverse  transitions,  which  we 
shall  call  WAD  and  WBA>  are  equal  because  |  J^AB\2  =  \  <%?BA  |2.  Natu- 
rally, the  transition  is  only  possible  because  the  energies  &A  and 
SB  are  not  defined  with  complete  accuracy,  and  a  small  interval 
dff  is  given  in  which  the  energy  spectrum  is  continuous.  In  an  ideally 
closed  system  we  would  have  SA  ^  <£B. 

The  relationship  we  have  found  only  holds  to  a  first  approximation 
in  the  perturbation  method.  However,  there  is  also  an  accurate 
relationship  that  can  be  deduced  from  the  general  principles  of 
quantum  mechanics.  In  accordance  with  the  accurate  relationship, 
the  probabilities  for  transitions  from  A  to  B  and  from  B*  to  A* 
are  equal;  here  A*  and  B*  differ  from  A  and  B  in  the  signs  of  all 
the  linear-  and  angular-momentum  components. 

The  equal  probability  for  states  with  the  same  energy.  We  have 
seen  that,  due  to  interaction  with  the  medium,  transitions  will  occur, 
in  the  system,  between  all  kinds  of  states  A,  B,  C, .  .  .,  belonging 
to  the  same  energy  interval  d$.  If  we  wait  long  enough  the  system 
will  pass  equal  intervals  of  time  in  the  states  A,  B,  C, .  . ..  This  is 
most  easily  proven  indirectly,  supposing  first  of  all  that  the  probabil- 


Sec.  39]  THE    EQUILIBRIUM  DISTRIBUTION   OF   MOLECULES  419 


ities  for  direct  and  reverse  transitions  are  simply  equal: 

The  refinement  WAB  =  WB*A*  does  not  make  any  essential  change. 

For  simplicity  we  shall  consider  only  two  states  such  that  WAB  =  WBA. 
We  at  first  assume  that  IA  is  greater  than  ts,  so  that  the  system 
will  more  frequently  change  from  A  to  B  than  from  B  to  A.  But 
this  cannot  continue  over  an  indefinitely  long  time,  because  if  the 
ratio  IA:  ts  increases,  the  system  will  finally  be  constantly  in  A  de- 
spite the  fact  that  a  transition  is  possible  from  A  to  B.  Only  the 
equality  tA=tB  can  hold  for  an  indefinite  time  (on  the  average) 
on  account  of  the  fact  that  direct  and  reverse  transitions  occur  on 
the  average  with  equal  frequency.  The  same  argument  shows  that 
if  there  are  many  states  for  which  direct  and  reverse  transitions 
are  equally  probable,  then  over  a  sufficiently  long  period  of  time 
the  system  will,  on  the  average,  spend  the  same  time  in  each  state. 

We  can  suppose  that  fo=  ^*,  because  the  states  A  and  A*  differ 
only  in  the  signs  of  all  linear  and  angular  momenta  (and  also  the 
sign  of  the  external  magnetic  field,  which  must  also  be  changed  so 
that  the  magnetic  energy  of  all  particles  is  the  same  in  states  A 
and  A*).  If  we  proceed  from  the  natural  assumption  that  IA=  t^*, 
then  all  the  precinged  argument  can  be  extended  to  the  case  when 


We  have  thus  seen  that  the  system  spends  the  same  time  in  all 
states  (with  the  same  weight)  that  belong  to  the  same  total  energy 
interval  d  $. 

The  probability  o!  a  separate  state.  We  will  call  the  limit  of  the 
ratio  tA/t,  when  t  increases  indefinitely,  the  probability  of  the  state  qA  . 
The  equality  of  all  IA  implies  that  corresponding  states  are  equally 
probable.  But  this  allows  us  to  define  the  probability  of  each  state 

p 

directly.    Indeed,  if  there   are    P   states,   then     T^^=l,  because 

£  ^' 

2^i  U  =  t.  But  since  the  states  are,  as  proven,  equiprobable,  we  find 


that  qA  =  l/P.  Similarly,  the  probability  that  a  tossed  coin  will 
fall  heads  is  equal  to  1/2,  since  the  occurrence  of  heads  or  tails  is 
practically  equiprobable. 

Hence,  the  problem  of  finding  probability  is  reduced  to  that  of 
combinatorial  analysis.  But  in  order  to  use  this  analysis  we  must 
determine  which  states  of  the  system  can  be  regarded  as  physically 
different.  When  computing  the  total  number  P  we  must  take  each 
such  state  once. 

Specification  of  gas  states  in  statistics.  If  a  gas  consists  of  identical 
particles,  for  example,  electrons,  helium  atoms,  etc.,  then  its  state 
is  precisely  given  if  we  know  how  many  particles  occur  in  each  one 
of  the  states.  It  is  not  meaningful  to  ask  which  particles  occur  in  a 
certain  state,  since  identical  particles  cannot,  in  principle,  be  distin- 

27' 


420  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

guished  from  one  another.  If  the  spin  of  the  particles  is  half-integral 
then  Pauli's  exclusion  principle  must  hold  and  in  each  state  there 
will  occur  either  one  particle  or  none  at  all. 

As  an  illustration  for  calculating  the  number  of  states  of  a  system 
as  a  whole,  let  us  suppose  that  there  are  only  two  particles  and  that 
each  particle  can  have  only  two  states  a  and  b  (ea=e&),  each  with 
weight  unity.  In  all,  three  different  states  of  the  system  are  con- 
ceivable : 

1)  both  particles  in  state  a;  state  b  is  unoccupied; 

2)  the  same  in  state  6;  a  is  unoccupied; 

3)  one  particle  in  each  state. 

In  view  of  the  indistinguishability  of  the  particles,  state  (3)  must 
be  counted  once  because  the  interchange  of  identical  particles  between 
states  does  not  have  meaning.  If,  in  addition,  the  particles  are  subject 
to  the  exclusion  principle,  then  only  the  third  state  is  possible. 

Thus,  if  the  exclusion  principle  is  applicable  to  the  particles  then 
the  system  can  have  only  one  state  and,  if  it  is  not,  then  three  states 
are  possible.  Pauli  exclusion  greatly  reduces  the  number  of  possible 
states  of  a  system.  A  system  of  two  different  particles,  for  example, 
an  electron  and  proton,  would  have  four  states  because  these  particles 
can  obviously  be  distinguished. 

Let  us  further  consider  the  example  of  three  particles  occupying 
three  states.  If  Pauli  exclusion  is  operative,  then  one,  and  only  one, 
state  of  the  system  as  a  whole  is  possible ;  one  particle  occurs  in  each 
separate  state.  If  there  is  no  exclusion,  then  the  indistinguishable 
particles  can  be  distributed  thus:  one  in  each  quantum  state,  or 
two  particles  in  one  state  and  the  third  in  one  of  the  two  remaining 
states  (this  gives  six  states  for  the  system  as  a  whole),  and  all  three 
particles  in  any  quantum  state.  Thus  we  have  obtained  1  +  3  +  6  =  10 
states  for  the  system  as  a  whole. 

If  these  three  particles  differed,  for  example,  if  they  were  TU+-, 
TU°-,  and  7r--mesons  of  zero  spin,  then  each  of  them  could  have  any 
one  of  three  states  independently  of  the  others.  Consequently,  a 
system  of  three  such  particles  could,  as  a  whole,  have  33  =  27  states. 
Later  on  we  shall  derive  a  general  formula  for  calculating  the  mimber 
of  states. 

Particles  not  subject  to  the  Pauli  exclusion  principle.  There  is  no 
sense,  for  future  deductions,  in  considering  that  each  state  of  a  par- 
ticle of  given  energy  has  unit  weight.  We  shall  denote  the  weight 
of  a  state  with  energy  e*  by  the  letter  gk.  In  other  words,  gk  different 
states  of  a  particle  have  the  same  energy  ei*.  For  every  particle 
these  states  are  equally  probable. 

Let  us  assume  that  Uk  particles  have  energy  efe  and  are  not  subject 
to  Pauli  exclusion.  It  is  required  to  calculate  the  number  of  ways 
that  these  nk  particles  can  be  distributed  in  gk  states.  We  shall 


Sec.  39]  THE   EQUILIBRIUM   DISTRIBUTION   OP    MOLECULES  421 

call  this  number   Pgknk.  In  accordance  with  what  we  have  proved 
above,  the  probability  for  each  arrangement  as  a  whole  is 


In  order  to  calculate  Pgknk  we  will,  as  is  usual  in  combinatorial 
analysis,  call  the  state  a  "box"  and  the  particle  a  "ball."  The  problem 
is  :  how  many  ways  are  there  of  placing  Uk  balls  in  gk  boxes  without 
numbering  the  balls,  i.e.,  without  desiring  to  know  which  ball  lies 
in  which  box.  If  the  particles  are  not  subject  to  the  Pauli  exclusion 
principle  then  we  must  suppose  that  each  box  can  accommodate 
any  number  of  balls. 

Let  us  mix  up  all  the  boxes  and  all  the  balls  so  that  we  obtain 
nk  +  gk  objects.  From  these  objects  we  take  any  box  and  put  it 
aside.  The  nk+gk  —  1  objects  which  remain  are  then  randomly 
taken  from  the  common  pile,  irrespective  of  whether  they  are  box 
or  ball,  and  placed  in  one  row  with  this  box  from  left  to  right.  The 
following  series  may  be  obtained: 
bx,  bl,  bl,  bx,  bx,  bl,  bl,  bl,  bx,  bl,  bx,  bl,  bl,  bx,  bx,  bx. 

Since  a  box  must  appear  on  the  left,  the  remaining  objects  can  be 
distributed  among  themselves  (nk  +  gk  —  1)!  ways. 

We  now  throw  each  ball  into  the  closest  box  on  the  left.  In  the 
distribution  we  have  used  there  will  be  two  balls  in  the  first  box, 
none  in  the  second  box,  'three  in  the  third,  one  in  the  fourth,  and 
so  on.  There  are  (nk  +  gk  —  1)!  distributions  in  all,  but  they  are 
not  all  distinguishable.  Indeed,  if  we  place  the  second  ball  in  the 
position  of  the  first  or  any  other  one,  nothing  will  change  in  the 
series  shown.  There  are  nk\  permutations  between  the  balls.  In 
exactly  the  same  way  the  boxes  can  be  interchanged  with  the  boxes 
because  it  does  not  matter  in  which  order  these  boxes  appear.  Only 
we  must  not  touch  the  first  box,  because  it  always  appears  on  the 
left  by  convention.  In  all,  there  are  (gk  —  1)!  permutations  of  the 
boxes.  It  follows  that,  of  all  the  possible  (nk  +  gk  —  1)!  arrangements 
in  the  series,  only  the  following  set  of  arrangements  is  different: 

p       __    (nk  +  gfc  —  1)  I  XOQAX 

- 


If,    for    example,    nk=3,   <7*=3    then  P^«t  =  -«-j--=  10,  which  is 


what  we  have  already  seen  from  direct  computation. 

Particles  subject  to  Pauli  exclusion.  In  the  case  of  particles  subject 
to  Pauli  exclusion  the  calculation  of  P&knk  is  still  simpler.  Indeed, 
here  we  always  have  the  inequality  nk  ^  gk,  because  not  more  than 
one  particle  occurs  in  each  state.  Therefore,  of  the  total  number  of 
gk  states  nk  are  occupied. 

The  number  of  ways  in  which  we  can  choose  nk  states  is  equal 
to  the  combination  of  gk  things  nk  at  a  time  : 


422  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

(39'7) 


There  are  as  many  possible  different  states  in  the  case  of  nk^gu, 
and  there  is  one  particle  or  none  at  all  in  any  of  the  gk  states. 

The  most  probable  distribution  of  particles  among  states.  The 
numbers  gk  and  Uk  refer  to  a  single  definite  energy.  The  total  number 
of  states  of  a  gas  is  equal  to  the  product  of  the  numbers  Pgk  njt  for 
all  the  states  separately: 


So  far  we  have  only  used  combinatorial  analysis.  And  besides  it  has 
been  shown  that  all  separate  states  taken  separately  are  equally 
probable.  The  quantity  P  depends  upon  the  distribution  of  particles 
among  the  states.  It  can  be  seen  that,  in  fact,  a  gas  is  always  close 
to  a  state  where  the  distribution  of  separate  particles  among  the 
states  corresponds  to  the  maximum  value  of  P  possible  for  a  given 
total  energy  £  and  for  a  given  total  number  of  particles. 

We  shall  explain  this  statement  by  a  simple  example  from  gambling, 
as  is  usually  done  in  probability  theory  (most  easily  seen  here  is  the 
manifestation  of  large-number  laws  in  a  game  of  chance).  Let  a  coin 
be  tossed  N  times.  The  probability  that  it  will  fall  heads  once  is 
equal  to  1/2.  The  probability  that  it  will  fall  heads  all  N  times  is 
equal  to  (1/2)N.  The  probability  that  it  will  fall  N  —  1  times  heads, 
and  once  tails,  is  equal  to  (1/2)N~1  x  1/2  x  N,  because  this  single 
occasion  can  turn  out  to  be  anyone,  from  the  first  to  the  last,  and 
the  probabilities  for  mutually  exclusive  events  are  additive.  The 

probability  for  a  double  tails  is  equal  to   (yj    —  L_r_A  - 

The  last  factor  shows  how  many  ways  two  events  can  be  chosen  from 
the  total  number  N  (the  number  of  combinations  of  N  two  at  a  time). 
In  general,  the  probability  that  the  coin  will  fall  tails  k  times  is 


_  /  j_w-^  mfe 

\2/       \2/   ~k\( 


N\ 


\(N-k)\~' 
The  sum  of  all  probabilities  is,  of  course,  unity: 


because  the  sum  of  binomial  coefficients  is  equal  to  2N. 

Considering  the  series  qk,  we  can  see  that  qk  increases  up  to  the 
middle  of  the  sum,  i.e.,  as  far  as  k~N/'2,  and  then  decreases  sym- 
metrically with  respect  to  the  middle  of  the  sum.  Indeed,  the  kth 


Sec.  39]  THE   EQUILIBRIUM   DISTRIBUTION   OF   MOLECULES  423 

term  is  obtained  from  the  (k — l)th  term  multiplied  by — — 


so  that  the  terms  increase  as  long  as  N/2>k. 

Every  separate  series  for  tails  appearing  is  in  every  way  equally 
probable  with  all  other  series.  The  probability  for  any  given  series 
is  equal  to  (1/2)N.  But  if  we  are  not  interested  in  the  sequence  of 
heads  and  tails,  but  only  in  their  total  number,  then  the  probabilities 
will  be  equal  to  the  numbers  qk.  For  N^>  1,  the  function  qk  has  a 
very  sharp  maximum  at  k  =  N/2  and  rapidly  falls  away  on  both 
sides  of  N/2.  If  we  call  the  total  number  of  N  tosses  a  "game,"  then 
in  the  overwhelming  majority  of  games,  heads  will  be  obtained  ap- 
proximately N/2  times  (if  N  is  large).  The  probability  maximum 
will  be  sharper,  the  greater  N  is.  We  will  not,  here,  refine  this  as 
applied  to  the  game  of  pitch  and  toss  (see  exercise  1),  but  will  return 
to  the  calculation  of  the  number  of  states  of  a  gas. 

On  the  basis  of  the  equal  probability  for  the  direct  and  reverse 
processes  between  any  pair  of  states,  we  have  shown  that  any  pre- 
viously defined  distribution  of  particles  among  states  has  the  same 
probability  of  being  established  for  a  given  total  energy.  In  the 
same  way,  every  separate  sequence  of  heads  and  tails  in  each  separate 
game  is  of  equal  probability.  But,  if  we  do  not  specify  the  states 
of  a  gas  by  denoting  which  of  the  gk  states  with  a  given  energy 
are  filled,  and  give  only  the  total  number  of  particles  in  a  state  with 
energy  £fe,  then  we  obtain  a  probability  distribution  with  a  maxi- 
mum similar  to  the  probability  distribution  of  games  according  to 
the  total  number  of  occurrences  of  tails  irrespective  of  their  sequence. 
The  only  difference  is  that  in  the  example  of  pitch  and  toss  the 
probability  depends  upon  one  parameter  &,  and  the  probability 
for  the  distribution  of  gas  particles  among  states  depends  upon 
all  ttfe. 

Our  problem  is  to  find  this  distribution  for  particles  with  integral 
and  half -integral  spins. 

It  is  most  convenient  to  look  for  the  maximum  of  the  logarithm 
of  P  rather  than  P  itself.  In  P  is  a  monotonic  function  of  the  argument 
and  assumes  a  maximum  value  at  the  same  time  as  the  argument  P. 

Stirling's  formula.  In  calculations  we  shall  require  logarithms 
of  factorials.  For  the  factorials  of  large  numbers,  there  is  a  con- 
venient approximate  formula  which  we  shall  deduce  here. 

It  is  obvious  that 

n 

lnn\  =  In  (1*2* 3*4 ...  n)  =  JPln  k . 

The  logarithms  of  large  numbers  vary  rather  slowly  since  the  difference 
ln(n  +  l) —  Inn  is  inversely  proportional  to  n.  Therefore,  the  sum 
can  be  replaced  by  an  integral: 


424  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 


Inn!  ~  J^ln&  ^  J  In  kdk  =  nlnn  —  n  =  rain  ™.        (39.9) 
*»i  b 

This  is  the  well-known  mathematical  formula  of  Stirling  in  somewhat 
simplified  form.  It  becomes  more  accurate  the  greater  n  is. 

Additional  maximum  conditions.  And  so  we  must  look  for  the  values 
of  the  numbers  n*  for  which  the  quantity 

8  =  hi  P  =  hi  PI  ^*«*  (39.10) 

k 

is  a  maximum  at  a  given  total  energy 

&  =  £nkzk  (39.11) 

k 

And  for  a  given  total  number  of  particles 

N  =  £nk-  (39.12) 

k 

This  kind  of  extremal  condition  is  termed  bound,  because  addi- 
tional conditions  (39.11)  and  (39.12)  are  imposed  upon  it. 

We  shall  first  of  all  find  nk  for  particles  which  are  not  subject 
to  Pauli  exclusion,  i.e.,  those  with  integral  spin.  To  do  this  we  must 
substitute  the  expression  for  P  from  (39.6)  in  (39.10),  take  the  dif- 
ferential dS  with  respect  to  all  n^  and  equate  it  to  zero.  We  have 


k  k  (39.13) 

We    substitute    here    the    expression    for    factorials    according   to 
Stirling's  formula  (39.9): 


(39.14) 

Since  gr*  is  a  large  number,  unity  can  naturally  be  neglected  every- 
where. We  must,  of  course,  differentiate  with  respect  to  nk  in  formula 
(39.14),  because  jr*  is  the  given  number  of  all  states.  Then 


nk)  -  Inn*]  =  ^dnk\n^^-  =0  . 
*  *  (39.15) 

It  must  not  be  concluded  from  this  equation  that  the  coefficients 
of  every  dnk  are  equal  to  zero,  because  nk  are  dependent  quantities. 


Sec.  39]  THE   EQUILIBRIUM   DISTRIBUTION    OF   MOLECULES  42f 

The  relationship  between  them  is  given  by  the  two  equations  (39.  IT 
and  (39.12)  and,  in  differential  form,  are  as  follows: 


Q>  (39.16; 

k 

dN  =       dnk  =  0.  (39.17; 


From  these  equations,  we  could  eliminate  any  two  of  the  numbers 
drik,  substitute  them  in  (39.15),  and  afterwards  regard  the  remaining 
dnk  as  independent  quantities.  Then  their  coefficients  may  be  regarded 
as  equal  to  zero. 

The  method  of  undetermined  coefficients.  The  elimination  of  de- 
pendent quantities  is  most  conveniently  achieved  by  the  method 
of  undetermined  coefficients.  This  makes  it  possible  to  preserve 
the  symmetry  between  all  Uk.  Let  us  multiply  equation  (39.16; 
by  an  indefinite  coefficient  which  we  denote  by  1/0;  the  meaning 
of  this  notation  will  be  explained  later.  We  multiply  the  second 
equation  (39.17)  by  a  coefficient  which  we  denote  (j,/0,  so  that  we 
have  introduced,  as  is  required  from  the  number  of  supplementary 
conditions,  two  quantities,  0  and  pi.  After  this  we  combine  all  three 
equations  (39.15)-(39.17)  and  regard  all  dnk  as  independent,  and 
6,  and  (JL  as  unknown  values  which  should  be  determined  from  equations 
(39.11)  and  (39.12).  The  maximum  condition  is  now  written  as 

dS-    **.  +  ±**L  =  o.  (39.18; 


We    look    for   the   extremum    of   one  quantity  S  --  —  +  -^  —  >  anc 

then  choose  0  and  \L  so  that  the  energy  and  number  of  particles 
equal  the  given  values.  But  if  the  extremum  is  determined  foi 
one  function  without  conditions,  then  all  its  arguments  become 
mutually  independent,  and  we  are  entitled  to  equate  any  differential 

to  zero  regardless  of  the  other  differentials. 
Equation  (39.18),  written  in  terms  of  dnk,  has  the  following  form: 


Bose-Einstein  distribution.  Let  us  now  put  all  the  differentials 
except  dnk  equal  to  zero.  According  to  what  we  have  just  said  this 
is  justified.  Then,  for  equation  (39.19)  to  hold,  we  must  put  the 
coefficient  of  dnk  equal  to  zero: 

A-Jt^o.  (39.20) 

x  ' 


426  STATISTICAL   PHYSICS  [Part   TV 

Naturally,  this  equation  holds  for  all  1c.  Solving  it  with  respect 
to  rife,  we  arrive  at  the  required  most  probable  distribution  of  the 
number  of  particles  according  to  state: 


.e*r^          '  (39.21) 

e  —  1 

This  formula  is  called  the  Bose-Einstein  distribution.  As  to  particles 
for  which  this  distribution  is  applicable,  they  are  said  to  obey  Bose- 
Einstein  statistics  or,  for  short,  Bose  statistics.  They  have  either 
integral  or  zero  spin.  The  unknown  quantities  0  and  [JL,  i.e.,  the  para- 
meters in  the  distribution,  are  given  by  equations  as  functions  of 
N  and  S\ 


<*-*  '  (39.22) 

k      6—  _! 

y  __   0fc    —  =AT 

^       cfe-*  '  (39.23) 

"      .""--I 

so  that  the  problem  posed  of  finding  the  most  probable  values  of 
Tife  is,  in  principle,  solved. 

Fermi-Dirac  distribution.  We  shall  now  find  the  quantities  rik 
for  the  case  when  the  particles  are  subject  to  Pauli  exclusion.  In 
accordance  with  (39.7)  and  Stirling's  formula  we  have  for  the 
quantity  8: 

fl  =  In  PI  -77^—77  = 

1  •  n!        —  w! 

09.24) 


k 

Differentiating  $  and  substituting  into  equation  (39.18),  we  obtain 


k 

whence,  by  the  same  method,  we  arrive  at  the  extremum  condition: 


and  the  required  distribution  appears  thus: 

«fc  =  -^gr  —  •  (39-26) 

e      *      +1 


Sec.  39]  TBOB   EQUILIBRIUM  DISTRIBUTION   OF   MOLECULES  427 

Here,  nk  <  gk  as  is  the  case  for  particles  subject  to  Pauli  exclusion. 
For  such  particles,  formula  (29.36)  is  called  a  Fermi-Dirac  distri- 
bution. The  parameters  9  and  fji  are  determined  analogously  to  (39.22) 
and  (39.23): 

—  =  <f  ,  (39.27) 


(39.28) 


Concerning  the  parameters  6  and  p.  The  parameter  0  is  an  essentially 
positive  quantity,  because  otherwise  it  would  be  impossible  to  satisfy 
equations  (39.22),  (39.23)  and  (39.27),  (39.28).  Indeed,  there  is  no 
upper  limit  to  the  energy  spectrum  of  gas  particles.  For  an  infinitely 

-1*. 

large  e  and  0  <  0,  we  would  obtain  e  e  =  0 ,  so  that,  by  itself,  a  Bose 

distribution  would  lead  to  the  absurd  result  nk  <  0.  In  (39.23), 
on  the  left,  we  would  have  the  negative  infinite  quantity^  —£yk, 

which  can  in  no  way  equal  N.  Similarly,  a  Fermi  distribution  would 
lead  to  infinite  positive  quantities  on  the  left-hand  sides  of  (39.27) 
and  (39.28);  and  this  is  impossible  for  finite  N  and  8  on  the  right. 
Therefore, 

0>0.  (39.29) 

In  the  following  section  it  will  be  shown  that  the  quantity  0  is  pro- 
portional to  the  absolute  temperature  of  the  gas. 

The  quantity  \i  is  very  important  in  the  theory  of  chemical  and 
phase  equilibria.  These  applications  will  be  considered  later  (see 
the  end  of  Sec.  46  and  the  succeeding  sections  of  the  book). 

The  weight  of  a  state.  Here  we  give  a  few  more  formulae  for  the 
weight  of  a  state  of  an  ideal  gas  particle.  The  weight  of  a  state  with 
energy  between  e  and  s  +  de  is  given  by  the  formula  (25.25),  whose 
left-hand  side  we  shall  denote  now  by  dg  (e).  In  addition  we  assume 
that  the  particles  have  an  eigenmoment  j,  so  that  we  must  take 
into  account  the  number  of  possible  projections  of  j,  equal  to  2j+l: 

-.  (39.30) 

For  electrons  ?  =  l/2,  so  that  2; +  1=2. 

For  light  quanta  we  must  use  formula  (25.24),  replacing  K  in 
it  by  co/c  and  multiplying  by  two,  according  to  the  number  of  possible 
polarizations  of  the  quantum: 

(39.31) 


428  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV" 

It  is  also  useful  to  know  the  weight  of  a  state  whose  linear  momen- 
tum is  between  px  and  px  +  dpx,  pY  and  py  +  dpy,  p*  and  pz  +  dpz. 
It  is  determined  in  accordance  with  (25.23),  also  with  account  taken 
of  the  factor  2;  +  l.  Thus,  for  electrons,  we  obtain 

.  (39.32) 


Exercises 

1)  Write  clown  the  formula  for  the  probability  that  heads  are  obtained  k 
times  for  largo  N,  whore  k  is  close  to  the  maximum  (jk> 
Tho  general  formula  for  probability  is  of  the  form: 

Nl  _      N 
'#-   (N--k)lkl          ' 

Wo  shall  consider  the  numbers  N  and  k  us  largo.  It  is  more,  convenient  hero 
to  use,  Stirling's  formula  in  a  somewhat  more  exact  form  than  (39.9),  namely: 

Nln  N~  +  ~lni2KN. 
c          2 

N  N 

Wo  put  k  ~  -_--  -f  *^»  N  —  k  =  -    —  .»*  ,  where  x  is  a  quantity  small  com- 

^  LJ 

N 
pared  with     0    .  Then,  in  the  correction  terms  of  Stirling's  formula  1/2  In  '2-xk 

and  1/2  In  2  K  (N  —  -  £),  the  quantity  jr  win  bo  neglected.  Wo  expand  the,  denom- 
inator in  a  series  up  to  xz: 


11,  1        /  N        ,         \  ,  ^     1          ^        ,  1         ^V        ,        ^        ,         l     1        O          ^ 

Infc!  -In  I  -g^  +  ^l!  =  -0~  m  ^<T  +  J?  In  --  -  +  ^  'I-  y  ln  2^-^-. 


Tho  corrootion  terms  aro 


Substituting   this    in  the  expression  for  qk  and  taking  antilogarithms  we 
arrive  at  the  required  formula: 

_  __  2.x* 

]/    2  N 

*  M  ra-  e 

g  has  a  maximum  at  x  —  0  and  dies  away  on  both  sides,  q  is  reduced  e  times 

1  /~y~ 
in    the    interval  av  =  I  -—-  »  characterizing    the   sharpness    of  the   maximum. 

Compared  with  the  whole  interval  of  variation  x,  the  interval  xe   comprises 

Xe         ir"2~ 
—  —  =  I/-  -  -  .  por  example,  for  N  ~  1,000,  the  maximum  is   approximately 

equal  to  1/40.  The  ratio  -'-  is  about  2%  so  that,  basically,  the  heads  fall  between 

475  to  525  times.  Tho  probability  that  heads  (or  tails)  will  fall  400  times  out 

'      2  ' 


_ 
of  a  thousand  is  equal  to  1/40-e        lt000     —  l/40e~20.   In   other  words,  it  is 


SeC.  39]  THE    EQUILIBRIUM   DISTRIBUTION    OF    MOLECULES  429 

e+2°,  i.e.,  several  hundreds   of  millions  of  times  less  than  the  probability  for 
heads  appearing  five  hundred  times. 

2)  Verify  that  the  probability  q  has  been  normalized,  i.e.,  that  \q  (x)  dx  =  1  . 

Since  the  probability  decreases  vory  rapidly  with  increase  in  the  absolute 
value  of  x,  the  integration  can  bo  extended  from  —  eo  to  oo  without  notice- 
able error.  Then 


Wo  shall  now  show  that  the  integral  appearing  hero  is  indeed  equal  to  \/  re 
We  shall  call  it  /: 


Squaring,  we  get 

-5'd5  jV^  -  J 

The  integration  spreads  over  tho  w'lolo  ^/j-plano.  Let  us  go  over  to  polar  coor- 
dinates : 

£  =  p  cos  9  ,   7)  =  p  sin  9  . 

Instead  of  d^d-ri  we  must   put    p</p  dy,  as  is   usual   for   polar   coordinates. 
Then, 

27T 


=     f  p6-PI,/p     f 


or 

so  that 

00 


3)  Find  the  mean  square  deviation,  for  the  occurrence  of  heads,  from  the 
most  probable  number,  i.e.,  x2. 
We  have 

00  00  0^2 

—  2  _     I    ~,'ln  {~\  f?r  —     /  (    vIp  N~  <7'r  —         -          

X      ~~~     I    •*'    (J  {•*'/  U"*'  —  I/  -^y"      I    •*'    t>  z*      Ct-«t/  —  -  — • 


In  order  to  calculate  the  integral  we  make  use  of  the  result  of  exorcise  2, 
writing  £2  a  in  the  exponent  instead  of  ^2. 


(v-rds-y* . 

J  Va 


430  STATISTICAL,  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Wo  differentiate  both  sideH  of  this  equation  with  respect  to   a: 


2a'' 

—  oo 

Putting  a  —  1  we  arrive  at  the  required  formula: 


Wo  notice,  incidentally,  that 


and   in  general 


For  xa,  we  obtain 


Expressing  JV  in  terms  of  x'2,  wo  can  write  down  the  probability-distribution 
law  : 

__*L 
q(x)dx=  -—    -—  ~         ^ 

V  2- 


Thus,  the  width  of  the  distribution  is  very  simply  related  to  the  mean 
square  deviation  of  the  quantity  from  its  most  probable  value*: 

».     _  .  A/  O  ^2 
j.  g  —  •    v    i*  *L     . 

Of  courso,  this  relationship  holds  only  for  an  exponential  distribution  of  the 
typo  obtained  in  exorcise   1. 

See.  40.  Boltzmaim  Statistics 
(Traiislutional  Motion  ot  a  Molecule.  Gas  in  an  External  Field) 

Boltzmann  distribution.  Long  before  the  Bose  and  Fermi  quantum 
distribution  formulae  (39.21)  and  (39.20)  had  been  obtained,  Boltz- 
maim derive  J  a  elassical  energy  distribution  law  for  the  molecules 
of  an  ideal  gas.  This  law  is  obtained  from  both  quantum  laws  by 
means  of  a  limiting  process.  We  shall  perform  this  transition  purely 
formally  at  first,  and.  then  decide  which  real  conditions  it  corresponds  to. 

*  For  .r  =  a\>,  the  probability  q  (.r)  decreases  e  times  compared  with  q  (0); 
it  is  for  this  reason  that  .i>  characterizes  tho  width  of  the  distribution. 


OC.  40]  BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS  431 

Let  e  be  measured  from  zero,  and  let  the  ratio  (ji/0  be  large  in  absolute 
alue  and  negative.  Then 


\  considerably  greater  thftii  unity  for  all  e.  Here,  unity  in  the  deiiom- 
lator  of  both  distribution  formulae  can  be  neglected  as  compared 
'ith  the  exponent,  and  both  the  Bose  and  Fermi  formulae  take 
n  the  same  limiting  form 


Wfc  =  <7*«'     °       .  (40.1) 

'his  is  the  Boltzmanii  distribution.  Let  us  now  determine  the  constant 
from  the  normalization  condition  for  the  distribution  : 

JTwfc=iV.  (40.2) 

k 

Let  us  suppose  that  the  gas  molecules  possess  some  internal  degrees 
f  freedom  (in  addition  to  the  external  transport  degrees  of  freedom) 
lat  may  be  related  to  electron  excitation,  the  vibration  of  nuclei 
dth  respect  to  each  other,  and  the  rotation  of  the  molecule  in  space. 
'ho  energy  of  all  these  degrees  of  freedom  is  quantized.  Without 
efiiiing  it  more  exactly  for  the  time  being,  we  can  write  the  total 
tiergy  of  a  molecule  e  in  the  form  of  a  sum  of  the  energies  of  trans- 
itional and  internal  motion: 


Accordingly,  the  weight  of  a  state  of  given  energy  is  also  represented 
3  the  product  of  two  weights:  one  relates  to  translation  al  motion 
tid  is  given  by  the  formula  (39.32),  while  the  other  we  denote  simply 
y  </(/)  (we  also  agree  to  include  in  it  the  factor  2^  +  1): 


8  ----  <!<•>• 
herefore,  formula  (40.2)  can  be  written  thus: 


(40.5) 


2 


-I  I 

Expanding    the    translational- motion    energy    into    V*  +  PY  ~*~  P*  ^ 

o  see  that  the  momentum  integral  is  represented  as  the  product 
f  three  integrals  of  the  form 


2mO 


dpx 


432  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

These  integrals  are  easily  calculated  from  the  second  formula 
of  exercise  3,  Sec.  31).  Each  of  them  is  equal  to  \/27rw6,  so  that  con- 
dition (40.5)  reduces  to  the  form 

l*Z<l&e"r-  (40.6) 

t 

If  the  gas  is  monatomic  then  the  quantities  £(1)  refer  to  electron 
excitations.  Therefore,  if  sW  >  0,  then,  actually,  only  the  zero  term 
appears  in  the  summation  over  the  states*.  But  since  the  energy 
is  measured  from  ^  as  from  zero,  the  whole  summation,  actually, 
reduces  only  to  the;  zero  term  #(<>).  It  is  of  the  order  of  unity.  For 
example,  when  the  ground  state*  has  angular  momentum  1/2,  g^0)=^2. 
We  then  obtain  the  condition  for  the  applicability  of  Boltzmaim 
statistics  in  the  form 


For  the  inequality  (40.7)  to  be  satisfied,  it  is  sufficient  to  satisfy 
one  of  two  conditions: 

1)  the  density  of  the  gas  is  very  small,  i.e.,  the  volume  occupied 
by  the  gas  at  a  given  temperature  0  is  large; 

2)  the  temperature  0  for  a  given  volume  V  is  very  high. 

In  the  case  when  the  gas  is  nob  monatomic,  these  conditions  are 

__.i(l! 
quantitatively   changed  somewhat   because  £(J(i)e      °    is  also  some 

i 

function  of  0.    But  qualitatively,  the   conditions  of  applicability  of 
Bolt'/mann  statistics  still  hold. 

Classical  and  quantum  statistics.  We  have  seen  that  for  small 
densities  or  high  temperatures  the-  quantum  distribution  laws  for 
a  gas  pass  into  the  classical  Boltzmaim  law.  From  now  on  we  shall 
agree  to  call  the  Bose  and  Fermi  statistics  quant  am  statistics  and 
the  Boltzmann  statistics,  classical,  regardless  of  wheather  the  energy 
spectrum  is  discrete  or  continuous.  Those  statistics  will  be  termed 
quantum  for  which  the  indistinguishability  of  separate  particles  is 
taken  into  account.  In  other  words,  a  quantum  definition  of  the  state 
of  a  system  lies  at  the  basis  of  quantum  statistics:  the  number  of 
particles  in  all  quantum  states  must  be  given.  The  classical  definition 
of  the  state  of  a  system  indicates  which  particles  are  found  in  the 
given  states.  The  Boltzmann  formula  (40.1)  can  be  obtained  from 
this  classical  definition. 

Maxwell  distribution.  In  this  section  we  will  not  be  concerned  with 
the  statistics  of  the  internal  motion  of  molecules,  and  will  consider 

*  Tho  relation  between   0  and  temperature  is  given  by  formula  (40.25). 


Sec.  40] 


BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS 


433 


only  their  traiislational  motion.  In  accordance  with  (40.3),  the  energy 
of  the  traiislational  motion  of  molecules  is  separable  from  their 
internal  energy.  Therefore,  the  Boltzmann  distribution  breaks  up 
into  the  product  of  two  factors.  We  are  not  interested  in  the  first 
of  the  two  factors,  but  the  second,  relating  to  traiislational  motion, 
is  of  the  form 

p% 

f>~  ^tnQ 


The  weight  of  a  state  relating  to  a  given  absolute  value  p  is  obtained 
by  changing  to  polar  coordinates  in  formula  (39.32): 

dg(p)  Vff*  (40.8) 

[cf.   (25.24)]. 

Thus,  the  distribution  according  to  the  kinetic  energies  of  transla- 
tional motion  is  written  in  the  form: 


dn(p)  = 


(40.0) 


It  is  applicable  both  to  monatomic  and  polyatomic  gases  if  m  is  the 
mass  of  a  molecule  as  a  whole. 

The  constant  A  is  found  from  the  normalization  condition 


00 

f    --p-'- 

I  p*e     *m*dp  =  N. 


(40.10) 


The  value  of  the  integral  was  found  in  exercise  3,  Sec.  30.  From  this 
vve  obtain 

-.         (40.11) 


,  !n  place  of  the  momentum  distribu- 
*.i  n-.i  of  molecules,  it  is  sometimes  useful 
:,  ',ave  their  velocity  distribution.  For 
i,ti;~  it  is  sufficient  to  substitute  p  =  mv 


i?-e  distribution  (40.9): 


(40.12) 


Fig.  46 


distribution  had  already  been  deduced  by  Maxwell,   before 
,  and  for  this  reason  it  is  called  the  Maxwell  distribution. 

).?<  Tig.  46  we  have  plotted  the  ratio  -^^-  on  the  ordinate.  For 

w  O/D 

,  this  quantity  is  close  to  zero  because  of  the  factor  v2  in  the 

-  0360 


434  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  I\ 

equation  for  the  weight  of  a  state  ;  after  the  zero  point  it  reaches  a 
maximum  and  exponentially  decreases  to  zero  again  for  large  velocities, 
We  thus  sec  that  a  gas  contains  molecules  with  every  possible  velocity 
value. 

The  velocities  of  gas  molecules.  The  greatest  number  of  molecules 
have  a  velocity  corresponding  to  the  maximum  of  the  distribution 
curve  shown  in  Fig.  46.  This  maximum  is  determined  from  equatior 
(40.12).  The  corresponding  velocity  is  termed  the  most  probable; 
it  is 

(40.13; 

We  find  the  mean  velocity  by  calculating  the  integral  (we  omit 
the  factor  N,  because  the  mean  value  of  velocity  relates  to  a  single 
molecule)  : 


^ 

0 

The  mean  square  velocity  is  also  interesting 


:=J^-.        (40.15 
m  v 

(the  result  of  exercise  3,  Sec.  39  is  used  in  the  derivation). 
The  ratio  Vv*~:v:  vm.p.  =  VT :  I/  —  :  VT. 

r      TT 

The  mean  energy  of  a  single  molecule  is  equal  to 

£  =  ~-  =  |G,  (40.16; 

and  the  mean  energy  for  the  whole  gas  is  N  times  greater:  / 

—  3  f 

<?  =  Nz  =  Y^e-  (40.F7 

This  result  relates  to  the  energy  of  translational  motion  of  the  mole- 
cules. Numerical  evaluations  of  velocity  will  be  performed  below. 

The  relationship  between  energy  density  and  pressure.  We  fshal 
now  derive  a  very  important  relationship  between  the  density  o: 
kinetic  energy  of  a  gas  and  its  pressure.  This  relationship  holds  for  an} 
statistics  and  depends  only  upon  the  form  of  the  expression  for  eiaergj 
in  terms  of  momentum. 

The  pressure  of  a  gas  is  defined  as  the  force  with  which  the  gas  act? 
upon  unit  area  perpendicular  to  its  direction.  This  force  is  eqi  al  tc 
the  normal  (to  the  surface)  component  of  momentum  transmitted  by  the 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  435 

gas  molecules  in  unit  time.  Let  the  direction  of  the  normal  to  the  sur- 
face coincide  with  the  #-axis.  We  first  choose  those  molecules  which 
have  a  velocity  component  along  the  #-axis  equal  to  vx.  They  will 
reach  the  surface  of  a  volume  in  unit  time  if  they  initially  were  situated 
in  a  layer  of  width  vx.  Let  us  cut  out  a  cylinder  from  this  layer  with 
base  of  unit  area  and  height  equal  to  vx.  The  volume  of  this  cylinder 
is  vx.  If  dn  (vx)  is  now  the  number  of  molecules  whose  velocity  compo- 
nent normal  to  the  surface  is  vx,  then  the  density  of  these  molecules 


is  —~-.  There  are  vx    n-  such  molecules  in  a  cylinder  of  volume  vx. 

Each  of  them,  upon  elastically  colliding  with  a  wall,  will  reverse  its 
normal  velocity  component,  and  the  wall  will  receive  a  momentum 

mvx  —  (—  mvx)  =  2mvx.  (40.18) 

Thus,  all  the  gas  molecules  having  a  velocity  vx,  transfer  to  the  wall 
in  unit  time  a  momentum 

(40.19) 


In  order  to  obtain  the  gas  pressure  on  the  wall  we  must  integrate 
(40.19)  over  all  vx  from  0  to  oo,  and  not  from  —  oo  to  oo,  because 
molecules  moving  away  from  the  wall  will  not  strike  it.  Thus,  the  pres- 
sure of  the  gas  on  the  wall  is 


(40.20) 


0  —oo 

On  the  other  hand,  the  mean  kinetic  energy  of  the  gas  is 

CO  OO  '  OO 

~f  =  -f-  J  vldn  (»«)  +  -f-  J  v$dn  (»,)  +  -f-  J  t£  d  n  (v,)  = 


),  (40.21) 

because  the  mean  values  of  the  squares  of  all  the  velocity  components 
are  identical. 

Comparing  now  (40.20)  and  (40.21)  we  find  that  the  gas  pressure  is 
equal  to  two  thirds  of  the  density  of  its  kinetic,  energy  : 

?  =  !—'-•  (40.22) 

This  result  was  published  by  D.  Bernoulli,  as  early  as  1738,  a  century 
and  a  half  before  statistical  physics  began  to  develop  as  an  independ- 
ent science. 


28* 


436  STATISTICAL,  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Only  two  assumptions  have  been  used  in  the  derivation  of  (40.22): 
identical  values  of  the  three  velocity  projections  are  equiprobable 

and  the  kinetic  energy  is  equal  to  —»~ .     The  concrete  form  of  the 

distribution  function  is  not  essential. 

The  Clapeyron  equation.  If  a  gas  is  subject  to  Boltzmann  statistics, 
then,  in  accordance  with  (40.17),  the  mean  kinetic  energy  <?is  equal 
to  — 2"  •  Substituting  this  in  (40.22)  we  obtain 

pV  =  NQ.  (40.23) 

But  from  the  definition  of  absolute  temperature 

pV  =  RT.  (40.24) 

From  this  we  obtain  the  relationship  between  ''statistical"  temper- 
ature 0,  measured  in  ergs,  and  the  temperature  T,  measured  in 
degrees  Centigrade: 

fi  _  J?_  T  —  -'*—  x  10?  T -  —  1  38  y  10- 16  T  (40  25} 

N  6.024  x  1023     ™  L'm  X  1U       -1   '  {w.AO) 

7? 

The  ratio  k=-^-is  called  Boltzmann's  constant.    It  is  equal  to 

1.38  x!0~16.  The  temperature  can  also  be  measured  in  electron-volts, 
one  electron-volt  being  equal  to  1.59  x  10~12  erg.  Translating  ergs  into 
degrees  with  the  aid  of  Boltzmann's  constant,  we  find  that  1  ev~ 
-=11,600°. 
As  is  known,  the  specific  heat  of  an  ideal  inonatomic  gas  is  equal 

O  £ 

to  -' -  jR,  thus  corresponding  to  an  energy  '  -  RT.  Replacing   RT  by 
NQ,  we  find  ~g'  =  ~NQ   in  agreement  with  (40.17). 

JL 

The  relationship  (40.25)  allows  us  to  calculate  the  mean  velocity 
of  gas  molecules  without  using  the  Avogadro  number  N.  Indeed, 


where  M  is  the  molecular  weight  of  the  gas.  For  example,  the  mean 
velocity  of  hydrogen  molecules  at  a  temperature  of  300°  K  is 


This  value  is  comparable  with  the  exit  velocity  of  a  gas  into  a 
vacuum  or  with  the  velocity  of  sound  [see  (47.30)]. 

The  thermonuclear  reaction.  When  nuclei  collide  reactions  are  pos- 
sible between  them  that  proceed  with  the  release  of  energy.  For  exam- 
ple, in  a  deuteron-deuteron  collision  one  of  two  reactions  can  occur 
(besides  elastic  scattering): 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS  437 


Here  //*  is  tritium  and  nl0  a  neutron.  Another  example  is 


In  order  that  charged  nuclei  may  be  able  effectively  to  collide,  they 
must  overcome  the  potential  barrier  of  Coulomb  repulsion,  which  was 
considered  in  Sec.  28.  The  dependence  upon  energy  for  the  probability 
of  passing  through  the  potential  barrier  is  basicaUy  determined  by  the 
barrier  factor  [see  the  first  term  on  the  right  in  (28.12)]: 

_   2  TC  Zj  Zt  e* 

e         ''"H       .  (40.26) 

Here,  Z:e  and  Z2e  are  the  charges  of  the  colliding  nuclei  and  v\\  is  the 
relative  velocity  along  their  joining  line  [recall  that  (28.12)  refers  to 
one-dimensional  motion]. 

The  reaction  can  be  produced  by  accelerating  the  particles  in  a  dis- 
charge tube.  But  charged  particles,  striking  a  substance,  mainly 
spend  their  energy  on  ioiiization  and  excitation  of  the  atoms.  And 
since,  according  to  (40.26),  the  probability  of  the  reaction  at  small 
energy  is  vanishingly  small,  the  majority  of  incident  particles  do  not 
cause  a  reaction.  Of  the  total  number  of  particles  it  turns  out  that 
10~5  —  10~6  are  effective.  Therefore,  the  energy  yield  of  the  reaction 
is  considerably  less  than  the  total  energy  spent  in  accelerating  the 
beam  of  particles. 

The  situation  is  different  if  the  substance  used  for  the  reaction  is 
at  a  very  high  temperature,  of  the  order  of  107  degrees.  At  this  tem- 
perature, the  nuclei  of  the  heated  substance  already  react  at  a  suffi- 
ciently high  rate,  and  transmission  of  energy  to  electrons  does  not 
occur  because  their  mean  energy  is  the  same  as  that  of  the  nuclei. 

Let  us  calculate  the  rate  of  a  nuclear  reaction  occurring  under  such 
conditions.  It  is  termed  thermonuclear. 

Let  the  effective  cross-section  for  the  reaction  between  nuclei  with 
relative  velocity  v\\  be  <r  (VH).  We  assume  that  different  nuclei  react: 
we  shall  call  them  1  and  2.  Let  us  construct  on  each  nucleus  2  a  cylinder 
with  base  area  a  (v\\)  and  height  numerically  equal  to  v\\.  Then,  by 
definition  of  a  (v\\),  all  those  nuclei  1  which  occur  in  the  volume  of 
these  cylinders  and  which  have  velocity  v\\  relative  to  nuclei  2  will 
be  involved  in  the  reaction  in  unit  time. 

The  number  of  such  events  in  unit  volume  and  unit  time  is  equal 
to  the  product  of 

(40.27) 


where  nx  and  n2  are  the  numbers  of  nuclei  1  and  2  in  unit  volume,  and 
dq  (v\\)  is  the  probability  that  the  relative  velocity  is  equal  to  v\\. 


438  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Indeed,  a  cylinder  of  volume  v\\  G  (v\\)  can  be  constructed  on  each 
nucleus  2,  and  there  will  be  n±  a  (v\\)  v\\  nuclei  1  in  each  cylinder.  The 
velocity  distribution  of  the  nuclei  is  taken  into  account  by  multiplying 
by  dq  (VH).  If  1  and  2  are  identical  nuclei,  then  expression  (40.27) 
must  be  halved  so  that  each  reaction  is  not  taken  into  account  twice. 
We  indicate  this  by  the  factor  (2)  in  the  denominator  of  expression 
(40.28). 

Let  us  now  determine  the  probability  factor  dq  (v\\).  The  absolute- 
velocity  distribution  is  given  by  the  product  of  two  Maxwellian  fac- 
tors of  the  form 

r^v*1^. 

In  the  exponent  of  this  expression  is  the  sum  of  the  energies  of  both 
nuclei.  In  accordance  with  formula  (3.17),  it  can  be  split  into  the  kine- 
tic energy  of  the  motion  of  the  centre  of  mass  of  the  nuclei  and  the 
kinetic  energy  of  their  relative  motion.  Hence,  in  the  product  a  factor 
is  separated  that  gives  the  relative-velocity  distribution: 


mvl 
~ 


20  26  26 


where      m  ==  —  i-^-     [see  (3.20)]  ,     v2  ===  v\  +  vl  . 

ml  4-  m2       L         v         /J  n   •      a. 

Normalizing  the  distribution  over  v\\  to  unity  and  passing  to  the  re- 
duced mass  m,  we  obtain  an  expression  for  the  probability  that  the  value 
of  relative  velocity  along  the  line  joining  the  nuclei  will  be  v\\. 


20 


The  barrier  factor  (40.26)  depends  upon  v,,. 

Thus,  the  overall  rate  of  a  thermonuclear  reaction  is 


%n2   f 

=  -&-  J 


events 


Taking  into  account  the  barrier  factor,  we  write  the  dependence  of 
effective  cross-section  upon  the  rate  as 


"" 


The  factor  a0  here  depends  considerably  less  upon  the  rate  than  the 
exponential  function. 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  439 

The  integral  in  (40.28)  now  reduces  to  the  form: 


I  d0  (v{\)  v\\  e          hv]{  20  dvl{.  (40.29) 

o 

It  can  be  calculated,  to  a  good  approximation  in  the  case  when  the 
temperature  is  so  low,  that  the  greater  part  of  the  reaction  proceeds 
at  the  "tail"  of  the  Maxwellian  distribution  at  a  rate  greater  than  the 
mean.  Let  us  show  how  this  calculation  is  done. 

We  denote  the  argument  of  the  exponential  in  the  integrand  thus : 

'2e2    ,     w*V||  __   «     ,     *>  Mt 


._,  S_. 

We  find  the  minimum  of  the  function  /  (v\\)  from  the  condition 

-&-  =  -  -4-  +  6»«  =  0;      Vj|  =  j/|T .  (40.30) 

av\\  v\\  1   b 

We  shall  see  that  the  basic  contribution  to  the  integral  is  given  by 
values  of  v\\  close  to  v\.  Near  the  minimum,  /  (v\\)  can  be  represented 
in  the  form 


-0?,)2,  (40.31) 

and  the  integral  (40.29)  is  written  as 

""    ""   dv,,.  (40.32) 

The  minimum  of  /  (v\\)  corresponds  to  the  rate  v*\  at  which  the 
greatest  number  of  reactions  occur.  The  ratio  of  the  rate  vjj  to  the 
mean  relative  rate  |  v\\  \  is,  according  to  (40.30), 

V||  I/  w   a  /—  8  /7-       /Jl 

J=T=   \~2  VaVb  =\2 
bill         v  *  x 

since 


o 

o 

v\\ 


We  shall  call  the  temperature  low  if  the  ratio          •  is  several  times 

I  «ll  I 
greater  than  unity.  Then  the  maximum  of  the  integrand  of  (40.32) 


440  STATISTICAL,  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

is  very  sharp  at  the  point  v\\  =  v\,  because  it  decreases  e,  times  when 
v\\  deviates  from  i?J  by  an  amount  \/-^r  ,  which  is  considerably  less 

than  vjj. 

It  was  therefore  justifiable  to  terminate  the  expansion  in  (40.31) 
with  the  second  term.  In  addition,  the  quantities  <TO  (v\\)  and  v\\ 
can  be  taken  outside  the  integral  sign  when  v\\  =  v*\.  The  error  in 

both  approximations  is  of  the  order  J  —  ^-  .The  integration  can  be  taken 

F|1 
from  —  oo  to  oo  because  the  integrand  rapidly  decreases  as  v\\  re- 

cedes from  v\\9  so  that  the  error  is  exponentially  small. 
Thus, 


.  , 

Ja(t;,,)t;,,c 
o 


°°  >   ,  Ovo 

r  "~~2"(t/ii~~l'ii) 
J  e     2 


(40.34) 


Substituting  the  values  a  and  6  and  using  (40.28),  we  find  the 
expression  for  the  rate  of  a  thermonuclear  reaction 


(40.35) 


The  exponential  factor  depends  very  strongly  upon  the  temperature. 
For  example,  for  a  reaction  in  deuterium,  this  factor  changes  3,600 
times  when  the  temperature  is  increased  from  100  to  200  ev. 

Thermonuclear  reactions  are  the  source  of  stellar  energy  and 
for  this  reason  play  as  important  a  part  in  our  life  as  chemical 
reactions  ! 

Ideal  gas  in  an  external  field.  We  shall  now  consider  an  ideal  gas 
acted  upon  by  an  external  field  with  potential  U.  The  potential  ener- 
gy can  depend  both  upon  the  position  of  the  molecules  in  space  as  well 
as  their  orientation  (if  the  gas  is  not  mon  atomic). 

The  total  energy  of  a  molecule  is 

e  =  -    +  e(0  +  u  •  (4°-36) 


If  U  depends  upon  the  position  of  a  molecule  in  space,  i.e., 
U=U  (#,  y,  z),  then  we  must  pass  from  a  finite  volume  F,  in  the  weight 
factor  (40.4),  to  an  infinitely  small  volume  dV  —  dxdy  dz.  Then  part  of 
the  distribution  function  that  depends  upon  coordinates  x,  y,  z  can  be 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  441 

separated,  and  a  formula  is  obtained  defining  the  dependence  of  gas 
density  upon  coordinates: 


dn(x9y,z)  =  nQe  dxdydz.  (40.37) 

Here,  the  potential  energy  calibration  is  U  (0,  0,  0)  =  0,  and  the  gas 
density  at  this  point  is  equal  to  n0.  For  example,  in  a  gravitational 
field,  U  =  mgz,  so  that 

dn(z)  =  n0e      °    dz .  (40.38) 

It  should  be  noted  that  in  the  earth's  atmosphere  the  "barometric" 
formula  (40.38)  is  rather  more  applicable  qualitatively  because  air 
temperature  is  not  constant  with  height. 

In  addition,  the  "barometric"  formula  indicates  that  the  composition 
of  the  air  must  vary  with  height  as  a  result  of  the  different  molecular 
weights  of  nitrogen,  oxygen,  and  other  gases.  Actually,  the  air  com- 
position is  almost  uniform  vertically  because  of  vigourous  mixing 
processes. 

The  nonequilibrium  state  of  planetary  atmospheres.  In  place  of  the 
approximate  expression  for  the  potential  energy  in  a  gravitational 
field,  let  us  substitute  its  exact  expression  (3.4).  Let  us  first  of  all 
express  the  constant  a  in  formula  (3.4)  in  terms  of  more  convenient 
quantities.  The  force  of  gravity  at  the  earth's  surface  is  — mg  and, 

from  the  general  gravitational  law,  it  is  equal  to c\ ,  where  r0  is  the 


m   r 
radius  of  the  earth.  From  thisa  =  ragrr§,sotliat  J7=  —  mffr°-.  Therefore, 

the  gas  density  must  vary  with  height  according  to  the  law 


n^n^e  2r°  .  (40.39) 

This  quantity  remains  finite  even  at  an  infinite  distance  from  the 
earth,  and  since  the  exponent  is  equal  to  unity  at  infinity  we  have 
called  the  proportionality  factor  n^  . 

Near  the  earth,  where  r  =  rQ,  the  density  is  greater  than  n^  by  as 
many  times  as  the  quantity 


is  greater  than  unity. 

The  radius  of  the  earth  r0  &  6.4  x  108  cm,  g  &  103  cm/sec2.  From 
this  we  obtain  for  oxygen 

82  •  10*  •  6.4.10* 

' 


RT    =     8.3  •  10'  •  300 


442  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

In  actual  fact  the  density  of  the  earth's  atmosphere  at  infinity  is 
equaJ  to  zero.  Therefore,  it  follows  from  formula  (40.39)  that  the 
atmosphere  cannot  arrive  at  the  most  probable  state  when  in  the 
earth's  gravitational  field,  and  is  gradually  dispersed  into  space. 
The  most  probable  state  of  a  gas  is  called  statistical  equilibrium 
(see  Sec.  45).  The  equilibrium  density  of  the  atmosphere  at  infinity 
is  e800  times  less  than  at  the  earth's  surface.  Therefore  the  present 
state  of  the  atmosphere  is  very  close  to  equilibrium.  For  the  nioon, 
equilibrium  has  been  reached:  its  atmosphere  has  completely 
escaped  ! 

A  kinetic  interpretation  of  the  dispersion  of  planetary  atmospheres. 
It  is  easy  to  understand  the  reason  for  the  recession  of  gases  to  infinity. 
Any  particle  whose  velocity  exceeds  11.5  km/sec  is  capable  of  over- 
coming the  earth's  attraction:  its  motion  is  infinite.  In  accordance 
with  the  Maxwell  distribution  (40.12)  a  gas  will  always  have  molecules 
with  every  possible  velocity.  In  literal  notation,  the  velocity  of  mole- 
cules capable  of  going  to  infinity  is  defined  by  the  equation 

(40.40) 


Taking  v2  from  this  equation  and  substituting  into  the  Maxwell 

_   WtfTO^ 

distribution,  we  once  again  obtain  the  exponential  e  Q  for  the 
fraction  of  molecules  capable  of  leaving  the  atmosphere.  It  is  easy 
to  estimate  the  number  of  such  molecules  in  the  atmosphere  at  any 
instant  of  time.  The  earth's  surface  is  5xl018  cm2.  There  is  about 
1,030  gm  of  air  above  every  square  centimetre,  i.e.,  about  35  mo]es. 
Hence,  the  total  number  of  molecules  in  the  atmosphere  is  5  x  1018  x 
X  35  x  6  x  1023  =  1044,  and  the  fraction  of  molecules  of  velocity  greater 
than  11.5  km/sec  is  e~800~10~344.  Therefore  the  mean  number  of  mole- 
cules capable  of  leaving  the  earth  at  each  instant  is  only  10~300.  Of 
course,  those  molecules  close  to  the  earth's  surface  will  not  be  able  to 
"carry"  their  energy  to  the  upper  layers  of  the  atmosphere  because 
of  collisions  with  other  molecules. 

The  dielectric  constant  of  a  gas.  We  shall  now  consider  a  gas  whose 
molecules  have  a  constant  dipole  moment  in  a  constant  and  uniform 
electric  field.  Those  molecules  can  have  characteristic  dipole  moments 
for  which  there  is  some  preferred  direction:  NO,  CO,  H2O  (along  the 
altitude  of  the  triangle  passing  through  0),  NH3  (along  the  axis  of 
symmetry  of  a  three-sided  pyramid).  The  more  symmetrical  mole- 
cules do  not  possess  moments:  H2,  O2>  CH3  (tetrahedron),  CO2  (this 
proves  that  the  C02  molecule  has  the  form  of  a  rod  with  the  C  atom 
in  the  centre). 

Rotational  motion  is  quantized.  In  the  next  section  it  will  be  shown 
that  for  all  gases  except  hydrogen,  at  a  temperature  of  several  tens  of 
degrees  (from  absolute  zero),  the  states  with  large  quantum  numbers 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS  443 

are  already  excited.  In  these  states  the  motion  may  be  rega  ded  as 
classical.  Then  the  total  rotational  energy  of  a  molecule  simply  breaks 
down  into  the  kinetic  energy  of  rotation  (see  Sec.  9)  and  potential 
energy,  which  depends  upon  the  orientation  of  the  dipole  moment 
relative  to  the  external  electric  field: 


[see  (14.28)].  In  classical  motion,  the  potential  and  kinetic  energies 
may  be  regarded  as  quantities  instead  of  operators.  Therefore,  in  the 
Boltzmann  distribution  the  factor  that  depends  only  upon  potential 
energy  is  split  off: 

d  •  E  cos  & 


dn(b)  =Ae     «      sin&d&.  (40.41) 

Here,  sin  -ft  d$  is  proportional  to  the  element  of  solid  angle  in  which  the 
vector  d  lies  [cf.  (6.15)]. 

Let  us  now  determine  the  electric  polarization  of  a  gas  in  an  external 
field.  For  this  we  must  calculate  the  mean  projection  of  the  dipole 
moment  upon  the  electric  field,  i.e., 


'•/ 


e 
0 


n  d-EcosQ- 

/.— 

0 


(40.42) 


It  turns  out  that  it  is  sufficient  merely  to  find  an  expression  for 
the  integral  in  the  denominator,  because  equation  (40.42)  can  be 
rewritten  thus: 


(40.43) 


Indeed,  differentiating  the  integral  with  respect  to  the  parameter  E, 
we  revert  to  (40.42).  The  integral  can  be  calculated  using  the  fact  that 
sin  &  d&  =  —  d  (cos  -9-)  : 


/• 


.        *  /  At\      A    A\ 

=  -sr7Sinh-7r.       (40.44) 


The  integral  in  formula  (40.43)  is  called  a  statistical  integral.  For 
quantized  energy  levels,  it  is  replaced  in  the  general  case  by  a  statisti- 
cal sum.  The  expression  for  the  summation  and  integral  will  be  met 
with  many  times  again.  It  is  very  convenient  in  calculating  mean 


values. 


444  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Substituting  (40.44)  in  (40.43),  we  obtain  an  expression  for  the  mean 
projection  of  the  dipole  moment  on  the  electric  field 


(//'  /I  A    \ 

coth----^-).  (40.45) 

This  expression  was  obtained  by  Langevin.  Let  us  investigate  the 
right-hand  side  in  two  limiting  cases:  E<^  -7-  (weak  field)  and  E^>  -j 

(strong  field). 

If  the  field  is  weak  then  we  can  use  the  expansion  of  coth  x  in  terms 
of  x: 

1    ,    x 


X 

whence 


-SIT  •  (4°'46) 

The  polarization  of  the  gas  is 

P  =  Nd  •  cos  &  =  -— «^—  ,  (40.47) 

and  the  dielectric  constant  is  calculated  from  the  definitions  of  induc- 
tion (16.23)  and  (16.29): 


D  =  E  +  47r  P  =  #l  +  -  =  *E.  (40.48) 


In  a  strong  field  coth  -^-  tends  to  unity  and  -^-y  tends  to  zero. 

Therefore,  cos  £  tends  to  unity.  This  means  that  all  the  dipoles  are 
orientated  along  the  external  field  and  saturation  sets  in.  Then 
D  =  E  +  4nNd.  We  notice  that,  for  J7  =  300°K,  this  case  would 
correspond  to  a  field  E  >  107  v/cm,  which  is  considerably  greater  than 
the  breakdown  potential. 

Paramagnetism  of  gases.  We  shall  now  find  how  the  magnetic  per- 
meability x  is  calculated.  Here  we  must  take  into  account  the  fact  that 
the  magnetic  moment  is  related  to  the  mechanical  moment  of  electrons, 
and  the  latter  is  a  quantized  quantity,  i.e.,  it  takes  on  a  discrete 
series  of  values.  Usually  an  electronic  mechanical  moment  does  not 
have  a  value  greater  than  several  units,  so  that  the  limiting  transition 
to  classical  theory  cannot  be  performed.  An  atom  can  also  have  a 
magnetic  moment  (as  opposed  to  an  electric  dipole  moment).  There- 
fore, let  us  determine  the  magnetic  susceptibility  arising  from  the 
orientation  of  atomic  magnetic  moments  in  an  external  field  H. 

Let  us  suppose  that  an  atom  in  the  ground  state  possesses  an  orbi- 
tal angular  momentum  L,  a  spin  angular  momentum  S  and  a  total 
angular  momentum  J.  In  other  words,  the  ground  state  is  a  multiplet 
state.  Let  the  multiplet  splitting  (fine  structure)  be  defined  by  the 


Sec.  40]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  445 

energy  interval  A,  so  that  the  level  with  the  closest  value  J  ±  I  differs 
from  the  ground  level  by  the  quantity  A.  If  the  energy  of  the  ground 
level  is  e0,  then  the  closest  level  has  an  energy  e0  +  A.  The  ratio  of  the 
number  of  atoms  in  the  ground  state  to  the  number  of  atoms  in  the 
closest  state,  belonging1  to  the  given  multiplet,  is,  according  to  (40.1) 


2J+1  (40.49) 


1)4-1 


Thus,  if  the  multiplet  splitting  A  is  considerably  greater  than  0, 
the  majority  of  the  atoms  are  in  the  ground  state.  If  they  are  placed 
in  an  external  magnetic  field  then  each  of  the  multiplet  levels  is 
split  into  2  J-\-  1  levels,  corresponding  to  its  value  of  J.  Suppose  that 
the  field  corresponds  to  the  anomalous  Zeeman  effect  in  the  sense 
that  the  splitting  of  each  multiplet  level  in  the  magnetic  field  is  con- 
siderably less  than  the  fine-structure  splitting  A  as  defined  in  Sec.  35. 
Then,  from  (35.11),  the  energy  of  an  atom  in  the  ground  state  is 


where  gL  is  the  Lande  factor  [see  (35.12)]  and  [JLO  is  the  Bohr  magneton. 
The  number  of  such  atoms  is  given  by  the  Boltzmann  distribution 


n(Jz)=Ae         e      .  (40.51) 

We  must  again  determine  the  mean  value  of  the  magnetic  moment 
projection  on  the  field: 


t^H/,1 
*        • 


We  have  put  the  minus  sign  on  the  left  because  the  electronic  charge 
is  negative.  Formula  (40.52)  involves  a  statistical  sum.  The  summation 
is  performed  only  over  those  levels  which  are  obtained  when  the  ground 
state  of  the  multiplet  is  split  in  the  magnetic  field,  since  the  number  of 
atoms  in  an  excited  state  is  small. 

Summing  the  geometric  progression,  it  is  not  difficult  here  to  obtain 
a  general  formula  similar  to  the  Langevin  formula  (40.45).  But  we 
shall  confine  ourselves  to  the  case  of  a  weak  field,  when  the  exponen- 
tial function  is  expanded  in  a  series.  The  expansion  must  be  taken 


446  STATISTICAL.  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

up  to  the  second  term  inclusive  because  the  sum  of  the  terms  which 
are  linear  in  Jz  is  equal  to  zero : 


— j 


We  calculated  the  sum  of  J*2  in  Sec.  30  [see  (30.27)].  Using  the  value 
for  the  sum  then  obtained,  we  write  the  required  mean  moment 
thus : 

i  _•_  l    v-foLH*J(J+ 1)  (2J+1)\  _ 
i-t-y Q2  j- 

!-,  (40.53) 


where  we  have  once  again  neglected  terms  of  higher  order  in  H. 

Formula  (40.53)  is  completely  analogous  to  (40.46)  for  the  electric 
moment  of  dipole  molecules  produced  by  a  field.  The  characteristic 
magnetic  moment  is  represented  by  the  quantity  [LQ  gL  VJ  ( J  +  1) 
so  that  the  Lande  factor  gL  takes  into  account  the  spin  magnetic 
anomaly.  Thus,  magnetic  susceptibility  can  be  calculated  from  data 
obtained  from  spectroscopic  observations. 

Paramagnetisin  of  rare  earths.  There  are  almost  no  elements  for 
which  we  can  completely  verify  formula  (40.53)  as  applied  to  the 
gaseous  state.  But  in  rare  earths  the  moment  of  the  electronic  cloud 
is  due  to  the  4  /-shell,  which  occurs,  as  mentioned  in  Sec.  33,  deep 
inside  the  atom.  When  such  an  atom  is  part  of  a  crystal  lattice,  the 
4  /-shell  is  but  slightly  subjected  to  the  action  of  the  electric  field 
of  the  neighbouring  atoms  so  that  its  state  may  be  regarded  as  being 
almost  the  same  as  for  a  free  atom  of  a  rare-earth  element.  Therefore, 
(40.53)  is  applicable  to  those  chemical  compounds  of  rare-earth  ele- 
ments where  other  elements  do  not  possess  a  characteristic  magnetic 
moment.  Its  agreement  with  experiment  is  very  satisfactory  for  almost 
all  the  elements  of  the  rare -earth  group. 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  mean  relative  velocity  of  two  molecules  of  different  gases  occur- 
ring in  a  mixture. 

Tho  relative  velocity  distribution  is  given  by  a  formula  similar  to  the  t>u 
distribution  but  written  for  all  three  velocity  components.  This  formula  is 

similar   to    (40.12),   but   it   involves   the  reduced  mass  m  = — - — instead 

rax  -f-  m2 

of  the  mass  of  a  single  molecule.  Hence,  like  (40.14),  the  mean  relative  velocity 
turns  out  equal  to 


Sec.  41]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  447 


TCW 


If  the  molecules  are  identical,  their  mean  relative  velocity  is  \/2  times  the 
mean  absolute  velocity. 

2)  Calculate  the  velocity  of  a  bimolecular  reaction  r't  if  the  effective  cross- 
section  depends  upon  the  velocity  component  (along  the  lino  joining  the  nuclei) 
in  the  following  way: 


Then,  from  the  general  formula  (40.28),  we  find 


_  A 

The  decisive  quantity  in  this  result  is  the  exponential  factor  e  °  .  The 
quantity  A  is  called  the  activation  energy.  It  is  equal  to  the  height  of  the  poten- 
tial barrier  over  which  the  colliding  particles  must  pass  in  order  that  the  reaction 
may  occur.  Unlike  a  thermonuclear  reaction,  it  is  assumed  here  that  the  motion 
Df  the  reacting  particles  is  classical.  Transitions  below  the  barrier  make  a  vanish  - 
ingly  small  contribution  in  chemical  reactions. 


Sec.  41.  Boltzmann  Statistics 
(Yibrational  and  Rotational  Molecular  Motion) 

Molecular  energy  levels.  In  order  to  apply  statistics  to  gases  consist- 
ing of  molecules,  we  must  classify  the  energy  levels  of  the  molecules. 
The  fact  that  a  nucleus  is  considerably  heavier  than  an  electron,  and, 
therefore,  moves  much  slower,  is  very  helpful  here.  We  have  used  this 
in  Sec.  33,  when  considering  the  question  of  the  binding  energy  of 
two  hydrogen  atoms  in  a  hydrogen  molecule.  The  eigenf unction 
can  be  found  for  any  relative  positions  of  the  nuclei.  In  a  diatomic 
molecule  the  position  of  the  nuclei  is  defined  by  a  single  parameter — 
the  distance  between  them.  The  energy  eigenvalue  of  the  electrons 
depends  upon  this  distance.  Adding  the  energy  of  Coulomb  repulsion  of 
the  nuclei  to  the  electron  energy,  we  obtain,  for  a  given  electron  wave- 
function,  the  energy  of  the  molecule  as  a  function  of  the  distance  be- 
tween the  nuclei.  For  example,  in  a  hydrogen  molecule,  the  curves  for 
this  relationship  are  of  different  form  in  the  case  of  parallel  and  anti- 
parallel  spin  orientations  (Fig.  47).  The  lower  curve  refers  to  the  state 
with  a  symmetric  spatial  wave  function  and  antiparallel  spins,  while 
the  upper  curve  relates  to  the  states  with  an  antisymmetric  spatial 


448  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

function  and  parallel  spins.  The  lower  curve  has  a  minimum  at  r  =  re, 
so  that  hydrogen  atoms  may  form  a  molecule  only  in  a  definite  elec- 
tron state. 

In  the  general  case,  several  different  electronic  states  can  have  a 
minimum.  The  distances  between  corresponding  potentional  curves 
are  defined  from  a  wave  equation  of  the  type  (33.23).  In  this  equation 
we  can  neglect  terms  involving  the  masses  of  the  nuclei  in  the  denomi- 
nator. Therefore,  the  energy  scale  separating  different  electronic  states 
of  the  molecules  is  the  same  as  for  an  atom,  i.e.,  from  one  to  ten  elec- 
tron-volts. 

Close  to  the  minimum  of  potential  energy,  nuclei  may  perform  small 
oscillations.  To  a  first  approximation,  these  oscillations  are  harmonic 
so  that  their  energy  is  given  by  the  general  formula  (26.21): 

(41.1) 

Here,  v  is  called  the  vibrational  quantum  number  of  the  molecule. 
This  number  is,  naturally,  integral.  Fig.  47  shows  a  more  general 
dependence  of  energy  upon  v,  taking  into  account  that  the  potential 
energy  curve  is  not  a  parabola  as  in  Fig.  41.  However,  practically,  the 
deviations  from  formula  (41.1)  affect  but  little  the  statistical 
quantities,  because  dissociation  occurs  when  oscillations  with 
large  v  are  excited  (see  Sec.  51). 

The   frequency   to  depends  upon  the  electronic  state   in 
nuclear    oscillations  occur.    In  accordance  with    the 
general  formulae  for  frequency  (7. 10)- (7. 12), 

co  =    / — \-7r-*-]        9    so  that  the  fre- 

\  m  \  d  rz  lr  =  re  ' 

queiicy  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square 
root  of  the  reduced  mass  of  the  nuclei.  There- 
fore, the  vibrational  quantum  is  considerably 
less  than  the  distance  between  electronic  lev- 
Fig.  47  els,  which  is  independent  of  the  nuclear  mass. 
It  is  of  the  order  of  tenths  of  an  electron-volt. 

In  addition  to  vibrational  motion,  a  molecule  with  two  atoms  may 
also  perform  rotational  motion,  flotation  is  most  simply  taken  into 
account  when  the  resultant  spin  of  the  electrons  is  equal  to  zero  and 
the  total  orbital  angular-momentum  projection  of  the  electrons  on 
a  line  joining  the  nuclei  is  also  equal  to  zero.  These  conditions  are  satis- 
fied in  the  electronic  ground  state  for  nearly  all  molecules,  with  the 
exception  of  02,  the  resultant  spin  of  which  is  equal  to  unity  (but  the 
projection  of  the  electronic  moment  on  the  axis  is  zero),  and  NO, 
where  the  spin  is  one  half  (and  the  orbital  angular-momentum  pro- 
jection of  the  electrons  on  the  axis  is  zero).  Disregarding  these  excep- 
tions, we  may  consider  a  molecule  of  two  atoms  as  a  solid  rotator, 
i.e.,  a  system  of  two  point  masses  at  a  fixed  distance  re  corresponding 


SOC.  41]  BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS  449 

to  the  minimum  of  the  lower  potential  curve  in  Fig.  47  (see  exercise  2, 
Sec.  30);  (our  case  corresponds  to  J3  —  0  and  k  =  Q,  so  that  the  closest 
excited  level  hi  k  with  k  ==•  1  is  moved  to  infinity.  The  rotational 
moment  of  the  rotator  is  perpendicular  to  the  line  joining  the  nuclei 
since  its  projection  on  this  line  is  equal  to  zero). 

As  we  know  from  Sec.  5  [see  (5.6)]  the  rotational  energy  of  two 
particles  is 


where  m  is  the  reduced  mass  and  mr*  is  equal  to  the  moment  of  inertia 
of  the  rotator  «/1.  Going  over  to  the  quantum  formula,  we  substitute) 
the  angular-momentum  eigenvalue.  It  is  usual  to  denote  it  by  the 
letter  K,  so  that 


This  formula  corresponds  to  the  energy  of  a  symmetric  top  with 
£•-=0  (cf.  exercise  2,  Sec.  30).  It  involves  the  mass  of  the  nuclei  in  the 
denominator.  Therefore,  the  distances  between  neighbouring  rotation- 
al levels  are  of  the  order  of  a  thousandth  of  an  electron- volt  and  less. 

Thus,  to  a  good  approximation,  the  total  energy  of  a  two-atom 
molecule  can  be  written  in  the  form  of  a  sum  with  three  terms : 

,    /      /      ,     l\    t    hzK(K-\-\)  ,t.  ox 

s  =  et  +  ev   \-  zr  ---  se  +  &<o  iv  +    A  +  -     -.,       ^        ,  (41.3) 

where  se  ~—-  (i.e.,  it  is  independent  of  the  nuclear  mass  w),  e^^ , 

ni  '  ifYi  \i  ' 

Zi^-* 

m 

The  excitation  of  electronic  levels.  If  we  substitute  the  expression 
(41.3)  in  the  Boltzmann  distribution,  the  latter  separates  into  the  prod- 
uct of  three  distributions  involving  electronic,  rotational,  and  vibra- 
tional states.  Let  us  suppose  that  a  gas  is  considered  with  temperature 
not  exceeding  several  thousand  degrees,  for  example,  2,000-3,000°. 
Then  if  the  energy  of  electronic  excitation  is  several  electron-volts 
(1  ev  =  l  1,600°,  since  the  temperature  can  be  defined  in  energy  units), 
the  fraction  of  molecules  in  excited  electronic  states  is  a  very  small 

£t' 

number:  e  e  .  In  those  cases  when  there  are  very  low  electron  levels, 
the  Boltzmann  factor  may  also  be  other  than  a  small  quantity.  But, 
as  a  rule,  dissociation  of  the  molecules  sets  in  earlier  than  excitation 
of  then-  electronic  levels  (see  Sec.  51). 

Excitation  ol  vibrational  levels.  Let  us  examine  the  vibrational  states. 
For  generality  we  may  consider  not  only  molecules  with  two  atoms, 
but  also  polyatomic  molecules.  If  the  oscillations  of  such  molecules 
are  harmonic,  we  can  make  the  transition  to  normal  coordinates,  as 
was  shown  in  Sec.  7.  Then  the  vibrational  energy  assumes  the  form  of 

29  -  0060 


450  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

a  sum  of  the  energies  of  independent  harmonic  oscillators.  The  energy 
levels  for  each  such  harmonic  oscillator  are  given  by  a  formula  of  the 
form  (41.1)  with  a  frequency  co  corresponding  to  a  given  normal  oscilla- 
tion. 

Molecular  oscillations  are  basically  divided  into  two  types:  "valent," 
in  which  the  distances  between  neighbouring  nuclei  mutually  change, 
and  "deformational,"  where  only  the  angles  between  the  "valence 
directions"  change.  For  example,  in  a  C02  molecule,  having  a  straight- 
line  equilibrium  form  0  =  0  =  0,  valent  oscillations  alter  the  distance 
between  the  carbon  nucleus  and  the  oxygen  nuclei,  while  deformation- 
al oscillations  move  the  C  nucleus  out  of  the  straight-line  configura- 
tion. The  frequencies  of  deformational  vibrations  are  several  times 
less  than  those  of  valent  oscillations.  The  estimation  7&co~0.1ev 
related  to  valent  oscillations. 

In  any  case,  if  the  vibrational  energy  breaks  up  into  the  sum  of 
energies  of  separate  independent  oscillations,  then  the  distribution 
function  also  splits  into  the  product  of  distribution  functions  for  each 
separate  oscillation. 

Let  us  calculate  the  mean  energy  for  one  normal  oscillation: 


(41.4) 


here  we  have  used  the  same  transformation  as  in  the  derivation  of 
(40.43)  and  (40.52).  Formula  (41.4)  involves  the  statistical  sum  for  a 
harmonic  oscillator.  The  sum  of  the  geometric  progression  inside  the 
logarithm  sign  is  very  easily  calculated.  Indeed, 


=  e    «  2,{e 

i—O 


l-e 


Substituting  this  in  (41.4)  and  differentiating,  we  get 


—  l 


The  first  term  in  (41.6)  simply  denotes  the  zero  energy  of  an  oscilla- 
tion of  given  frequency.  The  oscillation  possesses  this  energy  at  abso- 
lute zero  because  then  the  second  term  in  (41.6)  does  not  contribute 


Sec.  41]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  451 

anything.  The  second  term  has  a  very  simple  meaning.  If  we  write 
the  mean  energy  in  terms  of  the  mean  vibrational  quantum  number  ~v 


(41.7) 
then  it  is  obvious  that 

"=-J—    •  (41-8) 


(ftw          \-l 
e  °  —  i)      signifies  the  mean  number  of 

quanta  possessed  by  a  vibration  at  a  temperature  Q  =  kT.  At  a  low 
temperature,!;  is  close  to  zero.  For  example,  for  oxygen  and  nitrogen, 
/ico  is  about  0.2  ev,  or  2,000-3,000°.  Therefore,  at  room  temperature 
oxygen  and  nitrogen  occur  in  the  ground  vibratioual  state.  In  the 
case  of  hydrogen  the  reduced  mass  of  a  molecule  is  14  times  less  than 
that  of  nitrogen.  Its  vibrational  quantum  is  close  to  6,000°.  In  poly- 
atomic molecules,  where  deformational  vibrations  occur,  such  oscilla- 
tions can  be  excited  at  temperatures  of  the  order  of  .300-600°. 
Yibrational  energy  at  high  temperatures.  If  the  temperature  is  very 

/i6> 

high  compared  with  h  to,  then  e  e    can  be  replaced  by  the  expansion 
1  +  --".  Substituting  this  in  (41.6),  we  obtain 


The  first  term  does  not  relate  to  thermal  excitation.  Besides,  it  is 
considerably  less  than  0.  Thus  it  turns  out  that  at  a  sufficiently  high 
temperature  the  mean  energy  per  oscillation  is  equal  to  6,  irrespective 
of  the  frequency.  The  same  can  be  obtained  by  proceeding  from  the 
noiiquantized  expression  for  the  energy  of  a  harmonic  oscillator: 

p2      ,    ra<o2  q2  ,  A~    irk. 

e«^      +  —  -  •  <4L10> 


Substituting  this  in  the  Boltzmann  distribution  and  calculating  the 
mean  energy,  we  have 


<x>  co  ea 

0 


£(«j6 

'      CO  00 


J    dp j    dq 

-^_-~_ .^  ._  =  62-^-ln|  J  dp  j 

j  dp  j  dqe 


—  CO  -     OO 


—  oo        --  oo 


The  statistical  integral  inside  the  logarithm  is  calculated  in  the  usual 
way: 

29* 


452  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  i  [Part  IV 

- 


__  _  _     __  .  - 

f  e    8«»dp     e      *«    d?  =  V27u»e.y-^=  —  6.  (41.12) 

J  Z       J  K     W<0*  to 

-  oo  —  oo 

Whence  ew=0.  Then  the  total  vibrational  energy  of  a  gas  occurring 
at  a  frequency  G>  is 

''kT,  (41.13) 


and  its  contribution  to  the  specific  heat  is  correspondingly  equal  to  R 
[see  (40.17)].  Thus,  at  a  high  temperature  the  specific  heat  due  to 
vibrational  degrees  of  freedom  tends  to  a  constant  limit. 

The  excitation  of  rotational  levels.*  Let  us  now  consider  rotational 
energy.  The  weight  of  a  state  with  a  given  value  of  moment  K  is, 
as  usual,  equal  to  2  K  +  1,  in  accordance  with  the  number  of  possible 
projections  of  K  '  .  Especially  interesting  is  the  case  when  a  diatomic 
molecule  consists  of  two  identical  nuclei.  In  classifying  the  states  of 
such  a  molecule  it  is  necessary  to  take  nuclear  spin  into  account. 
Indeed,  the  wave  equation  for  a  molecule  consisting  of  identical  atoms 
does  not  change  form  when  the  nuclei  are  interchanged.  Therefore, 
if  the  nuclei  have  half-integral  spin,  the  wave  function  must  be  anti- 
symmetric with  respect  to  the  interchange  of  both  nuclei,  while  if 
they  have  integral  spin  it  must  be  symmetric.  The  symmetry  of  the 
eigenfu  notion  of  a  molecule  is  determined  by  the  symmetry  of  its 
factors  fin  the  approximation  (41.3)  it  is  separated  into  factors]: 
electronic,  vibrational,  rotational,  and  nuclear  spin.  The  electronic 
term  of  most  molecules  does  not  change  when  the  nuclei  are  inter- 
changed. The  vibrational  function  depends  only  upon  the  absolute 
value  of  the  distance  between  the  nuclei  and  therefore  does  not  change 
either.  The  rotational  eigenfunctioii  is  even  with  respect  to  this 
permutation  in  the  case  of  even  K,  and  odd  for  odd  K  .  Therefore,  if 
the  nuclear  spin  is  half-integral,  then  the  spin  function  must  be  anti- 
symmetric for  even  K  and  symmetric  for  odd  K  ,  so  that  the  resultant 
wave  function  may  always  be  antisymmetric.  If  the  nuclear  spin  is 
integral,  the  position  is  reversed,  and  if  it  is  equal  to  zero,  then  odd  K 
are  in  general  excluded  because  then  the  spin  factor  simply  does  not 
exist. 

Rotational  energy  of  para-  and  ortho-hydrogen.  We  shall  now  consider 
the  rotational  states  of  a  hydrogen  molecule.  The  total  nuclear  spin 
for  hydrogen  can  equal  unity  (the  ortho-state)  and  zero  (the  para- 
state).  The  weight  of  a  state  with  spin  1  is  3  and  that  with  spin  0  is  1. 
The  state  with  K  —  0  is  even  in  the  rotational  wave  function.  Hence, 
it  must  be  odd  in  the  spin  function,  i.e.,  it  must  have  spin  0,  (see 
Sec.  33).  But  the  state  with  zero  moment  possesses  the  least  rotational 


*  The  hypothesis  that  the  rotation  of  molecules  participates  in  the  thermal 
motion  of  a  gas  was  put  forward  by  M.  V.  Lomoriosov  as  far  back  as  1745. 


Sec.  41]  .  BOLTZMANN    STATISTICS  453 

energy.  Therefore,  only  para-hydrogen  is  stable  close  to  absolute 
zero. 

At  a  temperature  other  than  zero  all  those  states,  for  which  the 

„  fra  K  (K  -I-  1) 

" 


„ 

Boltzmann  factor  e      2"mfle     is  of  the  order  unity,  are  excited.  Taking 
the  moment  of  inertia  of  a  hydrogen  molecule  to  be  equal  to  0.45  x 
X  lO"40,  we  can  see  that  already  at  ?7^300°  K  the  summation  over 
all  odd  moments 

h*K(K  (  1) 

'  "    *""° 


differs  from  the  summation  over  even  moments  by  several  thousandths. 
But  since  the  states  with  even  moments  are,  for  hydrogen,  nuclear- 
spiii  ortho-states,  each  state  with  even  moment  has  an  additional 
weight  factor  3  according  to  the  number  of  projections  of  spin  1. 
Thus,  at  room  temperature,  3/4  of  hydrogen  is  ortho-hydrogen  and 
1/4  para-hydrogen.  If  hydrogen  is  rapidly  cooled  the  ratio  3:1  is 
retained  for  a  long  time  because  the  ortho-para-transition  proceeds 
slowly.  Such  a  state  is  obviously  iionequilibrium  since  all  the  hydro- 
gen in  an  equilibrium  state,  at  a  temperature  close  to  absolute  zero, 
must  be  in  the  para-state. 

One  of  the  methods  of  obtaining  pure  para-hydrogen  is  to  adsorb 
hydrogen  onto  any  substance  that  disrupts  the  molecular  bonds 
during  adsorption,  for  example,  activated  carbon.  When  desorbing 
the  hydrogen  by  pressure  reduction  at  low  temperature,  the  change  is 
that  to  the  para-state.  If  the  hydrogen  is  then  heated  to  room  temper- 
ature it  stays  in  the  para-state  for  quite  a  long  time. 

Let  us  now  write  down  the  formulae  for  the  mean  rotational  energy 
of  ortho-  and  para-hydrogen.  For  simplicity  we  shall  denote  the 

70  * 

factor      — 3-  in  the  rotational  energy  by  the  letter  B.  Then 

B 


l)e  -BK(K  +  ] 

K>0,2,4...  _____ 

__j?i 

Y1  (?.  W4-n  «    ° 

K-O.2,4,   .. 


K-0,2,4, 


The  difference  between  "i"  ortho  and  ¥  para  is  that  the  summation  is 
performed  over  odd  K.  For  a  mixture  at  room  temperature 

1  —  3 

£r~~  "4  £para+  -4  "Sorlho-  (41.15) 


454  STATISTICAL   PHYSICS  [Part    IV 

At  very  low  temperature,  it  is  sufficient  to  retain  only  the  term  with 
K  —  2  in  the  summation  (41.14),  so  that 


L  +  5e    o  |^30jSe    «  .  (41.16) 

For  ortho-hydrogen  we  obtain 

2B 

"  °~~  +  7e~ 

2tf  12  7J 

6  "T"  ,    S4       e™  /  _i??\ 

^  # ±_^     ^2J3\1  -f  14 e     °  /.          (41.17) 

3e~e 

The  determination  of  nuclear  spins  from  rotational  specific  heat. 

The  rotational  specific  heat  of  hydrogen  makes  it  possible  to  determine 
the  spin  of  a  proton.  Let  us  consider  formula  (41.17).  In  it,  the  first 
term  is  a  constant.  It  is  due  to  the  fact  that  a  molecule  of  ortho- 
hydrogen  would  have  a  rotational  energy  2  B  even  at  absolute  zero. 
This  energy  does  not  contribute  to  the  specific  heat  because  it  does 
not  depend  upon  the  temperature.  Defining  specific  heat  as  the  deriv- 
ative T^r ,  we  see  that  for  a  sufficiently  low  temperature  the  ratio  of 
the  specific  heats  of  ortho-  to  para-hydrogen  tends  to  zero  as 

\B 


Therefore,  if  ordinary  hydrogen  is  rapidly  cooled  to  a  low  temperature, 
its  rotational  specific  heat  will  be  determined  by  a  quarter  of  its  mole- 
cules in  the  para-state.  It  will  be  four  times  less  than  the  rotational 
specific  heat  of  pure  para-hydrogen  at  the  same  temperature. 

Thus,  by  measuring  the  specific  heat  of  the  equilibrium  state  of 
hydrogen  at  low  temperature  (i.e.,  the  para-state)  and  of  rapidly 
cooled  hydrogen,  we  can  determine  the  spin  of  a  proton  or,  knowing 
the  spin  from  other  data,  we  can  show  that  protons  are  subject  to 
Pauli  exclusion  because  they  possess  an  antisymmetric  wave  function. 

The  rotational  specific  heat  of  molecules  consisting  of  different  atoms. 
Diatomic  molecules  that  do  not  consist  of  identical  atoms  possess 
equal  nuclear-spin  weights  for  states  with  odd  and  even  K.  Therefore, 
their  mean  rotational  energy  is  expressed  thus: 

±1)1 

(41.18) 

The  sum  inside  the  logarithm  cannot  be  written  in  finite  form,  but 
it  is  easily  tabulated.  Let  us  evaluate  the  temperature  at  which  use 


8ec.  41]  BOLTZMANN   STATISTICS  455 

of  an  integral  as  a  substitute  for  the  summation  is  justified.  Thus, 
for  hydrogen 

B  _  J^_ 1.11- 10-" !  2  .  10-i4erg 

^  "  2mr?  =  1. 67- 10-24  (0.74)2- 10-"  "~  1'-    1U       erg) 

which  corresponds  to  a  temperature  of  87°  K. 

Here,  m  is  the  reduced  mass  of  two  protons,  equal  to  half  the  proton 
mass;  re  ^0.74 x  10~8  cm  (where  we  obtained  the  moment  of  inertia 
used  above).  For  other  gases  B  is  of  the  order  of  several  degrees  so 
that  for  all  temperatures  at  which  these  gases  are  not  in  the  liquid 
state  the  ratio  J5/0  is  a  small  quantity.  To  a  good  approximation,  the 
summation  in  (41.18)  may  be  replaced  by  an  integral.  If  we  take 

K(K+  1)  =  *, 
then 

(2K+  })dK-=  2K+  1  =dx     (dK^  1) 
and 

BK(Kf  1)       °°    _B* 

JT(2/v  +  l)e    "~  e       ^je     Qdx=~.  (41.19) 

o 

Substituting  this  in  (41.18),  we  have  an  expression  for  the  rotational 
energy  of  a  diatomic  molecule  or  any  linear  molecule 

/?T 
-e,-e  =  -^-.  (41.20) 

We  note  that  the  concepts  of  "high"  temperature  for  vibrations  and 
rotations  do  not  coincide  in  the  least.  With  respect  to  the  rotational 
specific  heat  of  oxygen,  the  temperature  must  be  higher  than  10°  K 
to  be  regarded  as  high,  while  with  respect  to  vibrational  specific  heat, 
it  must  be  above  2,000°  K.  Therefore,  in  a  very  wide  range  of  temper- 
atures, in  particular  at  room  temperature,  the  specific  heats  of  diatom - 

3 
ic  gases  are  constant,  and  consist  of  a  translational  part  -^  R  and 

re 

a  rotational  part  equal  to  B,  so  that  the  total  specific  heat  is  -5-  E. 

It  may  be  seen  by  numerical  computation  that  the  rotational  specif- 
ic heat  does  not  tend  to  a  constant  limit  monotonically,  but  passes 
through  a  maximum  at  6  =  0.81  J3,  equal  to  1.1  R. 

The  rotational  energy  for  a  polyatomic  molecule  will  be  calculated 
in  Sec.  47. 

Exercise 

Find  the  rotational  energy  of  para-  and  ortho -deuterium. 

Particles  with  integral  spin  have  a  symmetric  wave  function.  Let  us  now 
consider  a  system  of  two  particles  with  integral  spin,  for  example,  a  deuterium 
molecule.  For  comparison  we  shall  also  take  two  particles  with  spin  zero.  The 
spin  function  of  the  latter  is  identically  equal  to  unity;  therefore  their  orbital 


456  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

wave  function  can  bo  only  symmetrical.  With  respect  to  the  rotational  function, 
interchange  of  the  nuclei  is  equivalent  to  a  reflection  at  the  coordinate  origin. 
Hence,  if  the  spin  of  a  dautoroii  were  zero  then  the  spectrum  of  molecular  deute- 
rium would  show  the  linos,  corresponding  to  odd  rotational  quantum  numbers, 
to  bo  absent.  In  actual  fact  they  exist  in  the  deuterium  spectrum,  and  the  weight 
of  states  with  even  K  is  twice  as  great  as  for  those  with  odd  K.  This  is  seen  from 
the  relative  intensity  of  spectral  lines  that  correspond  to  transitions  from  the 
appropriate  states. 

We  shall  show  that  for  a  douteron  spin  of  unity,  the  weight  of  the  ortho- 
states  turns  out  twice  the  weight  of  the  para-states.  A  spin  projection  of  unity 
takes  on  three  values:  1,  0,  —  1.  We  denote  the  spin  wave  functions  (of  both 
deuterons)  that  correspond  to  these  projections  as  ^  (1),  ^  (0),  ^i  (  —  1)  and 
^2  (1)»  ^2  (0)»  4*2  (—1)-  Let  us  form  all  the  spin  wave  functions  of  deuterium  that 
correspond  to  a  total  spin  projection  0;  wo  shall  only  take  symmetric  and  anti- 
symmetric combinations  : 

Symmetric  functions  Antisymmetric  f  'unctions 

<!/,  (1)  ^  ("  1)  -!    *i  (-  1)  *a  (!)  >  *i  (1)  *2  (-  1)  ~  *i  (-  1)  ^2  (1)  - 


For  the  total  spin  projection  J:  1,  we  obtain 

*i  (I)  *a  (0)  -I-  *,  (0)  *a  (1)  ,  4>i  (1)  *2  (0)  -  *!  (0)  +a  (1)  , 

*i  (-  1)  *a  (0)  +  *i  (0)  42  ("  1)  ,  *i  (-  1)  *i  (<>)  -  *,  (-  1)  +!  (0)  . 

And  for  a  total  projection   ±  2  wo  have 


The  symmetric  state  has  a  maximum  spin  projection  of  two.  Hence,  the 
state  for  which  the  spins  are  parallel  is  symmetric.  But  there  are  six  symmetric 
spin  wave  -function  projections  in  all,  and.  spin  2  has  2-2  +  1  =  5  projections. 
Hence,  of  the  functions  with  zero  resultant  projection,  we  can  construct  one 
function  corresponding  to  a  zero  projection  of  spin  2.  The  other  function  with 
zero  resultant  projection  corresponds  to  a  resultant  spin  0. 

In  all,  deuterium  has  six  ortho-states  with  a  syrnmotric  spin  wave  function. 
A  spin  unity  has  states  given  by  an  antisymmetric  spin  function  because  the 
maximum  spin  projection  in  these  states  is  equal  to  unity.  Thus,  there  are  three 
para-states.  An  even  rotational  function  of  a  deuterium  molecule  corresponds 
to  the  ortho-states,  and  an  odd  rotational  function  corresponds  to  the  para- 
states.  Then  the  total  function  is  symmetric,  as  the  case  should  be  for  integral 
particle  spins.  The  weight  (duo  to  spin)  for  the  ortho-states  is  six  and  for  the 
para-states  it  is  three.  Therefore,  the  statistical  sum  of  ortho  -deuterium  is 

BK(K+l) 


K-  0,2,4,... 
and  for  para-douterium  it  is  equal  to 

3^  (2^+1) 
K  =1,3,5,... 


Sec.  42]  THE    APPLICATION    OF    STATISTICS  457 

Here  the  equilibrium  state  at  absolute  zero  is  the  ortho-state.  The  energies 
of  both  states  [see  (41.16)  and  (41.17)]  are 

_  6? 

"o"  . 


Compared  witli  hydrogen,  the  ortho-  and  para-states  are  interchanged  here. 
(-lose  to  absolute  zero,  the  basic  contribution  to  the  specific  heat  is  given  only 
by  the  ortho-state.  Two  thirds  of  all  the  molecules  in  equilibrium  deuterium 
occur  in  this  state  at  room  temperature.  Therefore,  the  rotational  specific  heat 
of  rapidly  cooled  deuterium  is  less  than  that  of  equilibrium  deuterium  at  the 
same  temperature  in  the  ratio  2/3.  Thus,  by  measuring  this  ratio  we  can  show 
that  the  spin  of  a  deuteron  is  equal  to  unity  and  not  zero. 


Sec.  42.  The  Application  of  Statistics  to  the  Electromagnetic  Field 
and  to  Crystalline  Bodies 

The  statistical  equilibrium  o£  matter  and  radiation.  In  this  section 
we  shall  first  of  all  consider  radiation  in  a  state  of  statistical  equilibrium 
with  matter.  The  conditions  for  such  equilibrium  are  achieved  inside 
a  closed  cavity  in  an  opaque  body.  The  walls  of  the  opaque  cavity 
absorb  radiation  of  all  frequencies  and  hence  they  also  radiate  all 
frequencies:  if  a  direct  quantum  transition  is  permissible,  then  the 
reverse  transition  is  also  permissible.  Therefore,  radiation  arrives 
at  a  statistical  equilibrium  with  matter,  that  is,  in  unit  time  there 
is  an  equal  amount  of  absorbed  and  emitted  energy  of  electromagnetic 
radiation  per  unit  surface  of  the  cavity  for  every  direction,  frequency, 
and  polarization. 

An  equilibrium  density  of  radiation  energy  is  thus  set  up  in  the 
cavity.  It  can  be  shown  that  in  this  case  temperature  of  radiation 
is  equal  to  the  temperature  of  the  walls.  The  necessity  of  this  will 
be  especially  clearly  seen  in  the  sections  dealing  with  the  fundamentals 
of  thermodynamics  (Sec.  45  and  46);  for  the  time  being  we  shall 
merely  note  that  it  is  natural  to  regard  the  temperatures  of  systems 
in  equilibrium  as  identical. 

The  absolutely  black  body.  Equilibrium  radiation  can  be  experi- 
mentally studied  by  making  a  small  aperture  in  the  wall  of  the  cavity : 
if  it  is  of  sufficiently  small  dimensions  the  equilibrium  state  will  not 
be  noticeably  changed.  Radiation  incident  on  such  an  aperture 
from  outside  the  cavity  is  absorbed  in  it  and  does  not  get  outside. 
In  this  sense  the  aperture  resembles  a  black  body  which  does  not 
reflect  light  rays.  For  this  reason  it  is  called  an  "absolute  black  body'' 
and  the  equilibrium  radiation  coming  from  the  aperture  is  called 
"black-body  radiation." 


468  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

This  term  is  somewhat  paradoxical  since  it  contradicts  the  obvious 
picture.  Indeed,  an  absolutely  black  body  in  equilibrium  radiates 
more  than  a  nonblack  body  because  it  absorbs  more,  and  in  equilib- 
rium the  radiation  and  absorption  are  equal.  If  a  body  having  a 
cavity  and  aperture  is  brought  to  an  incandescent  state,  the  aperture 
will  exhibit  the  brightest  glow. 

The  statistics  of  an  oscillator  field  representation.  Planck's  formula. 
In  this  section  we  shall  consider  the  application  of  statistics  to 
equilibrium  radiation.  For  this  it  is  necessary  to  quantize  the  radiation. 
Unlike  the  statistics  of  a  gas,  the  statistics  of  radiation  does  not 
permit  a  limiting  transition  to  equations,  with  the  quantum  of  ac- 
tion being  eliminated  entirely.  This  will  become  clear  a  little  later. 

In  quantizing  the  field,  a  double  approach  is  possible.  Firstly, 
a  field  may  be  represented  as  a  set  of  linear  harmonic  oscillators 
by  characterizing  each  oscillator  with  a  definite  wave  vector  k  and 
polarization  a  (or~l,  2).  It  is  obvious  that  all  these  oscillators  are 
different  (as  to  their  k  and  cy).  The  quantum  properties  of  such  os- 
cillators are  not  apparent  in  calculating  the  number  of  states  of  the 
field;  their  only  manifestation  is  that  the  energy  of  each  of  them 
cannot  be  equated  to  an  arbitrary  number,  but  belongs  to  an  oscil- 

lator-energy spectrum;  i.e.,  equal  toAco  \n  +  -^-1  where  n  is  an  integer. 

When  an  oscillator  is  in  thermal  equilibrium,  the  mean  number 
of  its  vibrational  quanta  is  given  by  a  formula  similar  to  (41.8): 


h  to 

~6~ 


(42.1) 

v  ' 


The  energy  of  each  quantum  is  equal  to  Aco  and  the  number  of  oscil- 
lations with  frequency  o>  is,  according  to  (25.24), 

(42-2) 

Here,  in  contrast  to  formula  (25.24),  both  possible  polarizations 
of  oscillation  with  a  given  frequency  are  taken  into  account,  and 
K  =  co/c  has  been  substituted.  Hence  the  energy  of  an  electromagnetic 
field  in  the  frequency  interval  dco  is 


\  C0         o>  t  AC\    e*\ 

to)  =  -  j-g-  -  r  .  (42.3) 


The  radiation  spectrum  of  the  sun  is  close  to  this  frequency  distri- 
bution. 

The  statistics  of  light  quanta.  Let  us  now  approach  formula  (42.1) 
from  another  direction.  We  have  said  that  the  electromagnetic 
field  is  viewed  as  an  assemblage  of  elementary  particles — light  quanta. 


Sec.  42]  THE   APPLICATION   OP   STATISTICS  459 

Quanta  of  the  same  frequency,  direction,  and  polarization  are  in- 
distinguishable from  one  another.  Therefore  quantum  statistics 
are  applicable  to  them  as  to  particles.  At  the  same  time  quanta 
have  integral  angular  momenta;  this  was  mentioned  in  Sec.  34. 
Therefore  they  are  not  subject  to  Pauli  exclusion,  and  possess  a  Bose 
and  not  Fermi  distribution.  But,  as  opposed  to  gas  molecules,  which 
are  subject  to  a  Bose  distribution,  the  number  of  quanta  is  not  a 
constant  quantity,  since  quanta  may  be  absorbed  and  radiated. 
This  is  why  the  supplementary  condition  (39.12)  does  not  apply 
to  quanta. 

It  is  easy  to  pass  from  the  general  Bose  distribution  to  a  special 
case,  when  condition  (39.12)  is  not  imposed;  for  this  it  is  sufficient 
to  put  equal  to  zero  the  parameter  (JL,  by  which  equation  (39.12) 
is  multiplied  ((ji  was  introduced  to  satisfy  the1  condition  N  =  const). 
Then  the  Bose  distribution  is  simplified: 

(42.4) 


Taking  into  account  that  for  a  quantum  s  =  Aa>,  we  once  again 
obtain  (42.1).  Thus,  formula  (42.1)  denotes  either  the  mean  vibra- 
tional  quantum  number  of  an  oscillator  in  an  assembly  subject 
to  Boltzmann  statistics,  or  the  mean  number  of  light  quanta  subject 
to  Bose  statistics.  As  we  have  already  said,  certain  oscillators  obey 
Boltzmann  statistics:  they  are  differentiated  by  the  numbers  nl9 
n2>  n&  CT  (see  Sec.  27),  while  the  statistics  of  distinguishable  particles 
is  nonquantum.  Let  it  be  recalled  that  we  differentiate  between 
quantum  and  nonquantum  statistics  according  as  the  particles  are 
distinguishable  or  not. 

The  impossibility  of  the  limiting  transition  h  ->  0  in  the  statistics 
o!  the  electromagnetic  field.  Let  us  now  turn,  for  a  time,  to  the  oscil- 
lator picture.  On  classical  theory,  the  mean  energy  of  an  oscillator 
is  equal  to  0  [see  (41.11)-(41.13)].  If  we  multiply  it  by  dg  (co),  the 
classical  Ray leigh- Jeans  formula  for  the  energy  of  equilibrium 
radiation  results. 

^(coUss==^~-0.  (42.5) 

But  this  formula  is  obviously  inadequate  for  large  frequencies: 
upon  integration  with  respect  to  co  it  gives  an  infinite  total  energy. 
It  was  precisely  here,  in  statistics,  that  the  classical  representations 
first  so  obviously  failed.  Therefore,  in  1900,  Planck  proposed  for- 
mula (42.3):  it  was  here  that  the  quantum  of  action  appeared  for  the 
first  time  in  physics. 

Formula  (42.5)  is  correct  only  for  frequencies  that  satisfy  the 
inequality 


460  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  total  energy  of  equilibrium  radiation.  It  is  easy  to  find  the 
total  energy  of  equilibrium  electromagnetic  radiation  from  formula 
(42.3).  Integrating  with  respect  to  co,  we  obtain 

CO  CO 

Vh       /"    co3rf<o  Vh 


h       I"    w3 
^   I     /,<•> 

J    e'' 


*L  (  *•*£.  (42  6) 

/**  J   e*-l  '  (          > 


The  integral  in  (42.6)  is  merely  an  abstract  number,  equal  to-pr 

(see  Appendix,  p.  586),  so  that  the  required  energy  is  proportional 
to  the  fourth  power  of  the  absolute  temperature  (the  Stefan- Boltz- 
mann  law). 

Radiation  from  an  absolutely  black  body.  The  result  (42.6)  can 
be  verified  from  the  emissivity  of  an  "absolutely  black  body."  It 
is  easy  to  relate  it  to  the  energy  S\  For  this  it  is  sufficient  to  calculate 
how  many  quanta  fall  from  inside  in  unit  time  upon  unit  surface 
of  a  cavity,  normal  to  the  surface.  We  have  indicated  that  if  we 
take  away  a  small  section  of  the  wall,  radiation  will  pass  through 
the  aperture  with  the  same  composition  as  that  falling  on  the  wall. 

The  velocity  of  each  quantum  is  c,  so  that  its  normal  component 
is  equal  to  c  cos  ft,  where  ft  is  the  angle  with  the  normal.  In  unit 
time  these  quanta  will  strike  a  square  centimetre  of  the  wall  from 
the  whole  volume  of  a  cylinder  with  base  1  cm2  and  height  c  cos  ft. 

The  energy  included  in  the  volume  of  this  cylinder  is  equal  to  -^r  •  c  cos  ft . 
The  fraction  of  quanta  flying  in  unit  solid  angle  is  equal  to  -~ , 

so  that  the  total  energy  falling  on  a  square  centimetre  of  the  wall 
in  unit  time  is 


27T  2 

P4.     (42.7) 


0  0 

The  constant  in  front  of  T4  is  equal  to  5.67  x  10~5  erg/cm2  sec  •  deg4. 
Formula  (42.7)  cannot  be  directly  applied  to  an  incandescent 
solid  body  without  ascertaining  to  what  extent  it  may  be  regarded 
as  black. 

Due  to  the  fact  that  the  sun's  luminous  shell  (chromosphere)  is 
nearly  opaque  to  radiation,  the  spectrum  it  emits  is  close  to  the 
equilibrium  spectrum  (42.3),  even  though  it  does  not  exactly  coin- 
cide with  it.  The  temperature  of  the  chromosphere,  as  determined 
from  (42.3),  is  approximately  5,700°. 

The  pressure  of  equilibrium  radiation.  It  is  also  easy  to  calculate 
the  pressure  of  equilibrium  radiation.  It  is  convenient  in  doing  so 
to  apply  the  same  reasoning  that  led  to  formula  (42.7).  Now,  however, 


Sec.  42]  THE    APPLICATION    OF    STATISTICS  461 

instead  of  calculating  the  number  of  quanta,  it  is  necessary  to  cal- 
culate their  normal  component  of  momentum  transmitted  through 
a  square  centimetre  of  surface.  This  component  is  equal  to  the  quan- 
tum energy  Aco  divided  by  c  and  multiplied  by  cos  ft.  Therefore, 
unlike  formula  (42.7),  we  must  integrate  cos2&  instead  of  cos  fr. 
In  addition,  for  every  incident  quantum  in  the  equilibrium  state 
there  is  a  similar  quantum  radiated  in  the  reverse  direction,  so  that 
the  transferred  momentum  is  doubled.  Whence  the  pressure  is 

2rc       7t/2 

=  w  •  (42-8) 


i.e.,  one  third  of  the  energy  density.  The  same  would  be  obtained 
from  the  derivation  of  equation  (40.22)  if  the  momentum  were  put 
equal  to  s/c  instead  of  mv.  We  note  that  in  Lebedev's  experiments, 
where  the  pressure  of  a  directed  beam  was  measured,  and  not  of 
iight  arriving  uniformly  from  all  directions,  p  =  <g'/V'9  the  pressure 
of  the  directed  beam  is  equal  to  the  energy  density  without  the 
factor  1/3  (see  Sec.  17). 

From  (42.8)  and  (42.6),  the  pressure  of  electromagnetic  radiation 
increases  in  proportion  to  the  fourth  power  of  the  temperature  while 
the  gas  pressure  is  proportional  to  the  first  power.  Therefore,  radiation 
pressure  will  always  predominate  at  a  sufficiently  high  temperature. 

At  high  temperatures  the  pressure  of  a  substance  can  always  be 
calculated  from  the  ideal  -gas  formula,  because  the  interaction  energy 
between  particles  becomes  small  compared  with  their  kinetic  energy. 
Hence, 

JVO 


By  considering  that  atoms  are  dissociated  into  nuclei  and  electrons, 
it  is  easy  to  express  the  ratio  N/  V  in  terms  of  the  mass  density.  Let 
us  suppose  that  the  substance  consists  of  hydrogen.  Then  for  every 
proton  there  is  one  electron.  If  the  density  of  the  substance  is  p, 
then  the  ratio  N/V  is  2p/m,  where  m  is  the  mass  of  a  proton  and 
the  factor  2  takes  into  account  the  electron.  This  gives 


(42.9) 


From  (42.8)  and  (42.6),  the  radiation  pressure  pr  is 


From  this  we  obtain  the  relationship  between  density  and  tem- 
perature when  the  radiation  pressure  becomes  equal  to  the  gas  pres- 
sure: 


462 


STATISTICAL   PHYSICS 


[Part  IV 


63=1.5xlO-23T3. 


r~~  90      (he)- 

For  example,  for  a  density  p  -=  1  gm/cm3,  both  pressures  become 
equal  if  the  temperature  is  equal  to  4  x  107  deg.  Radiation  pressure 
is  important  in  the  interiors  of  certain  classes  of  stars. 

The  frequency  corresponding  to  the  maximum  radiation-energy 
density  in  a  spectral  interval  rfco.  The  maximum  energy  in  the  distri- 
bution occurs  at  a  frequency  determined  from  the  equation 

(42.11) 


Performing  the  differentiation,  we  have 


1-e     °  - 


30 


This  equation  has  a  single  solution  with  respect  to  -~ 


=  2.822. 


(42.12) 


(42.13) 


16 
14 


W\ 
18 


0.4 


Thus,  the  frequency  corresponding  to  maximum  energy  in  the  spec- 
trum of  black-body  radiation  is  directly  proportional  to  the  absolute 
temperature  (Wien's  law): 

Wo==jypl.  (42.14) 

We  notice  that  the  numerical  coefficient  in 
the  formula  would  have  been  different  if  we 
had  considered  the  wavelength  distribution 
instead  of  frequency  distribution  (see  exer- 
cise 1).    Tt  is  interesting  to  note   that  the 
corresponding   wavelength   X0  in  the   solar 
spectrum  is  very  close  to  that  for  the  maxi- 
mum  sensitivity   of  the   human 
eye.  The  curve  of  the  distribution 


_ 
h  co 


1234      5678 


Fig.  48 


e  e  — 1  is  shown  in  Fig.  48. 

Spontaneous  and  forced  emis- 
sion of  quanta.  At  the  beginning 
of  this  section  we  pointed  out 
that  thermal  equilibrium  between 

atoms  and  radiation  is  attained  in  a  closed  cavity.  The  presence 
of  atoms  capable  of  radiation  and  absorption  is  necessary  in  general 
in  order  that  the  radiation  may  arrive  at  equilibrium ;  this  is  because 


Sec.  42]  THE   APPLICATION   OP   STATISTICS  463 

separate  oscillators,  corresponding  to  normal  oscillations  of  the 
electromagnetic  field,  are  completely  independent  of  one  another, 
and  any  initial  nonequilibrium  distribution  is  maintained  until 
there  is  an  exchange  of  quanta  via  absorbing  atoms. 

In  Sec.  34  we  derived  an  expression  for  the  probability  of  light 
emission  by  an  atom.  According  to  (34.46),  the  radiation  probability 
in  unit  time  is 


We  shall  now  consider  atoms  whicli  are  in  thermal  equilibrium  with 
matter.  Let  the  frequency  co10  satisfy  the  relationship  Aco10  —  et  —  e0, 
where  sx  and  e0  are  the  energies  of  two  atomic  states.  In  equilibrium, 
atoms  with  energy  ex  radiate  as  many  quanta  with  frequency  co10 
as  are  absorbed  by  atoms  with  energy  e0. 

In  accordance  with  the  principle  of  detailed  balance,  the  probabili- 
ties for  direct  and  reverse  transitions  are  connected  by  the  following 
relation  : 

.  (42.16) 


Indeed,  the  first-approximation  formula  of  perturbation  theory 
(34.29)  is  applicable  to  radiation  and  absorption  processes,  since  the 
interaction  of  matter  with  radiation  may  be  regarded  as  weak.  From 
this  formula,  the  probabilities  for  the  transitions  I  >0  and  0  ~>1 
are,  respectively, 

!2f/o;  WQl  =  2jL\J#>ol\*gi.  (42.17) 


But  according  to  the  Hermitian  condition  (34.15),  the  squares  of 
the  moduli  of  the  matrix  elements  |  ^Oi  I2  an(^  I  ^10  I2  are  ^e  same  s° 
that  if  we  multiply  expressions  (42.17)  by  the  weights  of  the  initial 
states,  the  result  will  be  equation  (42.16). 

The  formula  for  the  probability  of  absorption  related  to  the  case 
when  a  single  quantum  of  frequency  co10  existed  in  the  field  before 
absorption.  If  there  were  n  (co10)  such  quanta  before  absorption,  then 
it  is  natural  to  assume  that  the  probability  of  absorbing  one  of  them 
in  unit  time  is  n  (<o10)  times  greater.  This  assumption  is  justified  in 
electromagnetic  -field  quantum  theory. 

We  shall  therefore  assume  the  probability  of  absorbing  in  unit  time 
one  of  the  n  (co10)  identical  quanta  in  the  field  to  be  equal  to  n  (co10) 
{/o^oi-  ^n  accordance  with  the  principle  of  detailed  balance  we  must 
have  the  same  probability  for  the  reverse  transition,  i.  e.,  the  emission 
of  a  quantum  by  an  atom  occurring  in  state  1  when  there  are  n  (o>10)  —  1 
such  quanta  in  the  field  ;  this  is  because  the  transition  is  reversed  with 
respect  to  the  one  just  considered.  We  represent  both  transitions 
thus: 


464  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 


1st  state  of  the  system: 
atom  with  energy  e0 
n  quanta  with  frequency 

WIG 

quantum 
absorption 

quantum 
radiation 

2nd  state  of  the  system  : 
atom  with  energy  cx 
n-  —  1  quanta  with 
frequency  co10 

Thus,  in  accordance  with  the  principle  of  detailed  balance,  the  prob- 
ability of  emission  of  a  quantum  must  likewise  be  ng^V^,  which  can 
also  be  represented  as  [(n — 1 )  +  1]  g^ IF10.  Because  of  equation  (42.16) 
the  probabilities  for  both  direct  and  reverse  transitions  will  be  equal. 
Hence,  if  n-  -1  quanta  exist  in  the  field,  then  the  probability  of  emis- 
sion is  proportional  to  n,  i.e.,  to  the  number  of  quanta  increased  by 
unity.  If,  for  example,  there  were  no  quanta  in  the  field  before  emission, 
this  factor  of  proportionality  is  equal  to  unity.  In  this  case  the  emis- 
sion is  termed  spontaneous.  But  when  there  are  quanta  in  the  field, 
they  stimulate,  as  it  were,  further  emission  of  quanta  with  the  same 
frequency,  direction  of  propagation,  and  polarization.  The  emission 
produced  by  them  is  called  forced.  The  existence  of  forced  emission 
can  also  be  proved  by  means  of  quantum  field  theory,  just  as  the  pro- 
portionality factor  n  in  the  absorption  probability.  The  idea  of  forced 
emission  was  introduced  by  Einstein. 

The  derivation  of  Planck's  formula  from  the  relationship  between 
the  quantum  emission  and  absorption  probabilities.  Let  us  now  consider 
atoms  in  thermal  equilibrium  with  an  electromagnetic  iield.  Let  the 
quantity  n  (o>10)  denote  the  equilibrium  number  of  quanta.  The  condi- 
tion of  statistical  equilibrium  is  that  atoms  occurring  in  state  0  absorb 
as  many  quanta  with  frequency  colo  in  unit  time  as  are  emitted  by  atoms 
in  state  1.  Then  the  number  n  (co10)  does  not  change  with  time,  i.e., 
equilibrium  is  attained. 

The  number  of  acts  of  absorption  by  all  the  atoms  in  unit  time  (from 
state  0  in  which  there  are  N0  atoms)  is  equal  to 

iV0)F01n(co10).  (42.18a) 

The  number  of  acts  of  emission  by  all  atoms  in  state  1  in  unit  time  is 
^i^iohKoJ  +  l],  (42.18b) 

because,  as  we  have  seen,  it  involves  the  number  of  quanta  increased 
by  unity,  i.e.,  n  (co10)  +  l- 

Naturally,  expressions  (42. 18 a)  and  (42.18b)  no  longer  denote  the 
probabilities  for  direct  and  reverse  transitions,  but  the  probabilities 
for  transitions  from  a  state  with  the  same  number  of  quanta  n  (<o10), 
which  probabilities  lead  to  a  reduction  or  to  an  increase  by  unity  of 
the  same  number.  The  condition  for  thermal  equilibrium  is  that  these 
probabilities  are  equal: 

iV9  Wol  n  («10)  =  N,  Wlo  [n  («10)  +  1] .  (42. 1 9) 


Sec.  42]  THE    APPLICATION    OF   STATISTICS  465 

Here,  we  substitute  N0  and  Nl  from  the  Boltzmann  distribution 
(40.1): 


<Jo  Wn  n  (o>10)  =         ~  </,  W10  [»  (co10)  +  1  ]  .          (42.20) 

We  now  take  advantage  of  the  fact  that  7i<o10—  ex  —  e0,  and  also 
of  the  relationship  (42.16).  Then  there  remains  an  equation  for  the 
equilibrium  number  of  quanta  n  (fc>10) 


•n(o>10)=»(o>10)H-  1.  (42.21) 

AVhence  Planck's  formula  is  immediately  obtained 

w(«io)  =  -7r,-—  •  (42-22) 


Thus,  the  idea  of  forced  emission  leads  to  a  correct  frequency  distri- 
bution of  quanta.  Note  that  the  part  of  forced  emission  is  the  more 
important  the  greater  n  is  compared  with  unity.  But  large  n  corre- 
spond to  the  classical  limit ;  it  follows  that  forced  or  induced  emission 
is  by  nature  classical  and  spontaneous  emission  is  a  quantum  effect. 

We  notice  that  the  theory  of  a  field  consisting  of  Boso  particles 
always  leads  to  the  concept  of  forced  emission,  provided  the  principle 
of  detailed  balance  is  used. 

The  probability  of  the  appearance  in  the  field,  of  the  (n  +  l)th  par- 
ticle is  proportional  to  n+l,  while  the  probability  of  the  particle  dis- 
appearing is  proportional  to  n.  Naturally,  if  the  Bose  particles  are 
charged  (as,  for  example,  Ti-mesons)  then  only  those  transitions  are 
possible  which  are  compatible  with  the  conservation  of  total  charge 
of  the  system. 

As  regards  Fermi  particles,  we  must  bear  in  mind  that  a  transition 
to  a  filled  level  is  impossible.  Therefore,  if  the  probability  that  a  level 
is  filled  is  /,  then  the  number  of  transitions  to  this  level  in  unit  time  is 
proportional  to  1 — /. 

The  oscillation  spectrum  for  the  lattice  of  a  solid  body.  Let  us  now 
apply  statistics  to  the  crystal  lattice  of  a  solid  body.  As  applied  to 
the  crystal  lattice,  statistics  is  in  many  ways  similar  to  the  theory  of 
equilibrium  radiation. 

The  vibrations  of  atoms  in  a  lattice  may  be  described  in  normal 
coordinates,  after  which  their  energy  is  reduced  to  approximately 
the  same  form  as  (27.22) :  it  consists  of  the  sum  of  the  energies  of  sepa- 
rate oscillators.  To  each  oscillator,  there  corresponds  a  travelling  wave 
(hi  the  lattice)  of  the  displacements  of  atoms  from  their  equilibrium 
positions.  An  example  of  such  a  wave,  travelling  along  a  chain  of 
atoms,  will  be  given  in  exercise  4. 

30-0060 


4(5(5  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

However,  there  exist  the  following  differences  between  the  set  of 
oscillators  for  an  electromagnetic  field  and  those  for  a  solid  crystalline 
body. 

1)  The  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  for  an  electromagnetic  field 
is  infinite,  so  that  it  always  contains  all  frequencies  from  zero  to  oo. 
A  solid  body  has  a  finite  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  equal  to  3AT, 
where  N  is  the  number  of  atoms.  Therefore,  the  range  of  vibrational 
frequencies  extends  from  zero  to  some  maximum  frequency  comax. 

2)  The  dependence  of  frequency  upon  the  wave  vector  of  an  electro- 
magnetic field  is  defined  by  the  simple  law  G>=^C/C.  In  the  oscillations 
of  a  solid  body,  the  frequency  depends  upon  the  wave  vector  in  a  very 
complex  manner.  Only  in  the  limit  do  the  atomic  vibrations  become 
elastic  vibrations  of  a  continuous  medium  for  very  long  waves  (i.e.,  for 
small  k),  so  that  the  atomic  structure  of  the  crystal  can  be  ignored. 

In  a  continuous  medium  the  frequency  is  proportional  to  the  wave 
vector  co  ^=ua  Ic,  where  the  index  a  must  denote  that  the  wave  velocity 
u  depends  upon  its  polarization.  Here,  as  opposed  to  the  electromagnet- 
ic field  in  an  elastic  body,  there  are  three  wave  polarizations  for  each  h 
(when  taking  into  account  the  atomic  structure  of  a  crystal,  waves  of 
another  type  besides  elastic  sometimes  occur:  see  Fig.  49).  The  direc- 
tions of  polarization  depend  upon  the  elastic  properties  of  crystals 
and  upon  k. 

In  an  isotropic  elastic  body  two  of  these  polarizations  are  transverse, 
for  which  the  velocity  is  equal  to  ut,  and  one  is  longitudinal  with  velo- 
city ui,  so  that  a  ranges  through  three  values  as  in  the  crystal. 

The  number  of  oscillations  occurring  in  a  given  interval  of  values  k 
can  be  obtained,  as  usual,  by  proceeding  from  the  relationship  between 
the  oscillation  number  and  the  wave  vector.  Each  oscillation  is  defined 
by  three  integers  (%,  n2,  n3)  and  cr.  The  wave  vector  has  components 
proportional  to  nv  n2,  n^: 

;       k,  =  1^-  ;       tt  ~  1^  (42.23) 

*  V  ' 


(av  a2,  a3  are  the  crystal  dimensions).  From  this, 

7  j        7        7  a*a.,(t*dkTdkudk,  Vdkxdkudkf  ,*~^j* 

rftfk  =  dn1dnad»3=     l-      (27r)3     -       =  ---  (i«)«        '      (42>24) 

Comparing  this  formula  with  (25.22),  we  notice  that  now  the  denom- 
inator is  (2  7u)3,  while  before  it  was  simply  7r3.  The  difference  is  due 
to  the  fact  that  here  the  numbers  nl9  n2,  n3  are  found  from  the  peri- 
odicity condition,  as  for  an  electromagnetic  field  [see  (27.4)],  and  the 
expansion  is  performed  for  travelling  waves  instead  of  standing  waves. 
For  this  reason,  an  additional  factor  23  appears  in  the  denominator 
of  (42.24)  as  compared  with  (25.18).  But  here  the  numbers  nlt  ra2,  n3 
range  through  all  values  from  —  oo  to  oo,  while  in  Sec.  25  they  varied 


Sec.  42]  THE    APPLICATION    OF    STATISTICS  467 

only  from  zero  to  oo,  filling  one  octant.  Thus,  the  total  number  of 
states  turns  out  to  be  the  same,  irrespective  of  the  method  used  to 
count  them — by  travelling  waves  or  by  standing  waves.  And  this  is 
the  way  it  should  be  [cf.  (25.23)]. 

The  energy  of  a  solid  body.  It  is  now  easy  to  write  down  an  expression 
for  the  energy  for  an  interval  dkx,  dkY,  dkz  and  for  a  given  polarization 
of  oscillations  cr.  Like  in  (42.3)  we  have 

d£  (k,  a)  -    ™*,dk.dlc,dlc.  (42>25) 

V      '       /  ,      htoa  v  V  ' 

S^\e    °     -l) 

In  order  to  find  the  total  crystal  energy,  we  must  integrate  this 
expression  over  all  dkx  dky  dkz  and  sum  over  CT.  Unlike  the  case  of  an 
electromagnetic  field,  here  the  integration  must  not  be  performed  to 
infinity,  but  only  between  limits  such  that  the  total  number  of  oscil- 
lations equals  the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  3iV  (because  there 
are  N  atoms  in  the  lattice  and  each  one  lias  three  vibrational  degrees 
of  freedom) : 


In  order  to  find  out  what  is  meant  here  by  summation  over  a,  let  us 
consider  the  possible  types  of  vibration  of  a  crystal  lattice  composed 
of  atoms. 

Two  types  of  lattice  vibration.  If  we  confine  ourselves  only  to  crystal 
lattices  of  elements  where  there  is  only  a  single  atom  in  an  elementary 
cell,  then  the  index  a  will  indeed  range  in  value  from  1  to  3.  In  reality, 
lattices  are  sometimes  of  more  complex  form,  and  the  possible  types 
of  vibration  become  correspondingly  more  complicated.  This  can  be 
illustrated  by  a  simple  example.  Let  there  be  two  atoms  in  a  cell, 
as  shown  in  Fig.  49  by  solid  and  open  circles.  The  length  d  corresponds 
to  one  constant  of  the  lattice.  Let  us  imagine  a  vibration  of  some 
definite  wavelength  X.  In  Fig.  49  X  =  4  d  (a  single  half -wave  is  shown). 
This  vibration  may  be  effected  in  two  ways:  both  atoms  in  the  ele- 
mentary cell  are  either  displaced  to  one  side  (Fig.  49a),  or  in  opposite 

directions  (Fig.  49b).  The 
second   vibration    corre- 
^       sponds  to  a  greater  fre- 
quency for  a  given  wave- 
length than  the  first  be- 
oJ  6)  cause  the  restoring  force 

Fig.  49  for  the  second  vibration 

is  greater. 

If  there  are  i  atoms  in  an  elementary  cell  then  3  i  types  of  vibration 
exist  in  the  three-dimensional  case.  Three  types  correspond  to  the 
case  (a)  in  Fig.  49,  when  all  the  i  atoms  are  displaced  in  the  same  direc- 

30* 


468  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

tion,  and,  in  the  limiting  case  of  long  wavelengths,  the  whole  lattice 
vibrates  like  a  continuous  medium. 

The  total  number  of  crystal  vibrations  is  equal  to  3  iN'  —  3  A7,  where 
Nr  is  the  number  of  elementary  cells.  Obviously,  the  number  of  vibra- 
tions is  equal  to  the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom,  i.e.,  three  times 
the  number  of  atoms  in  the  lattice. 

Calculating  the  energy  of  a  crystal  lattice.  (42.25)  cannot  be  integrat- 
ed in  general  form  because  the  dependence  of  frequency  upon  k 
and  (j  is  different  for  different  lattices  and  for  different  types  of  vibra- 
tion. We  must  therefore  coniine  ourselves  to  two  cases. 

a)  The  temperature  0  is  considerably  greater  than  the  limiting-fre- 
quency quantum  7&6)max.  It  is  then  all  the  more  so  greater  than  the 
other  quanta,  so  that  we  can  neglect  all  terms,  except  the  first,  in  the 
exponential  series 

h  co  a 

e    °     -  1  =- 


Substituting  this  in  (42.25),  we  obtain  a  simple  expression  for  the  lat- 
tice energy: 

£'----  KOJT  f  I  I  </A*</MA>   _  3  ,yo  =  3  RT  (4L>.27) 

o 

Here  we  have  made  use  of  the  fact  that  the  total  number  of  lattice  vibra- 
tions is  equal  to  the  number  of  its  degrees  of  freedom  3iY.  Hence, 
the  specific  heat  of  the  lattice  is  equal  to  37?  and  is  the  same  for  all 
elements  in  molar  units.  This  law  is  well  satisfied  for  very  many  ele- 
ments already  at  room  temperature  (the  Dulong  and  Petit  law). 
Exceptions  are,  for  example,  diamond  and  beryllium,  for  which  the 

large  frequency  <omax  is  due  to  a  relatively  small  atomic  weight,  since 

_  i 

frequency  is  proportional  to  M     -  . 

Expression  (42.27)  fits  the  general  law  for  the  temperature  dependence 
of  vibrational  energy  at  high  temperatures  (41.13). 

Very  frequently,  in  a  crystal  lattice  we  can  distinguish  the  molecules 
of  the  substance  of  which  it  is  formed.  We  cannot,  of  course,  draw  a 
really  strict  distinction  between  atomic  and  molecular  crystals  but, 
qualitatively,  this  distinction  is  fully  meaningful.  In  molecular  crystals 
we  can  separately  consider  the  motion  of  atoms  inside  molecules 
(purely  vibrational,  in  the  given  case)  and  the  motion  of  molecules 
as  a  whole  relative  to  their  equilibrium  positions  in  the  crystal.  The 
latter  correspond  not  only  to  definite  centre-of-mass  coordinates  of 
the  molecules  in  the  lattice,  but  also  to  certain  distinct  orientations 
in  space.  Usually  all  the  degrees  of  freedom  of  the  motion  of  molecules 
in  a  crystal  are  vibrational.  Solid  hydrogen  forms  an  exception  where 
the  molecules  rotate  almost  freely  (this  rotation  is  similar  to  the  rota- 
tion of  a  pendulum  if  its  total  energy  is  sufficient  for  transition  through 


Sec.  42]  THE    APPLICATION    OF    STATISTICS  469 

its  upper  position).  The  frequency  spectrum  for  all  vibrations,  trans-' 
lational  and  rotational,  consists  of  very  man}7'  dispersion  curves  with 
different  cr  (according  to  the  number  of  modes  of  vibration)  and  with 
its  frequency  dependent  upon  the  wave  vector.  This  spectrum  is 
complicated  by  the  vibrations  of  atoms  inside  molecules,  similar  to 
case  (b)  in  Fig.  49.  Since  all  the  possible  vibrations  are  excited  by 
temperature  increases,  the  dependence  of  specific  heat  upon  tempera- 
ture is  of  very  complex  form  in  molecular  crystals. 

b)  The  temperature  is  considerably  less  than  Acomax>  Then  the  factor 


/    /lwmax          \ 
\€       °       -I/ 


is  so  small  that  integration  can  be  taken  to  infinity  without  any  essen- 
tial error,  because  only  the  small  frequencies,  for  which  the  quantum 
is  of  the  order  0,  contribute  noticeably,  i.e.,  Aco  ~6.  For  large  fre- 
quencies, the  Planck  factor  \e  °  —  1;  cancels  the  contributions  of 
the  corresponding  vibrations. 

However,  in  the  case  of  small  frequencies  the  lattice  vibrations  pass 
into  the  vibrations  of  a  continuous  medium,  for  which  vibrations  the 
frequency  is  related  to  the  wave  vector  by  the  simple  formula 

7')'fc-  (42.28) 

The  propagation  velocity  of  such  waves  depends  upon  the  direction 
of  propagation  and  upon  polarization,  but  does  not  depend  upon  the 
absolute  value  of  k.  The  remaining  types  of  vibration,  whose  frequency 
does  not  become  zero  for  small  k,  are  not  excited  at  low  temperature 
since  the  corresponding  quanta  are  comparable  with  A(oraax. 

It  is  expedient  to  transform  the  volume  element  dkxdkvdkz  to  spheri- 
cal coordinates,  i.e.,  to  replace  it  by  the  expression  kzdk  d£l,  where 
dQ,  is  an  element  of  solid  angle  for  the  directions  k.  Here,  in  accordance 
with  what  has  just  been  said,  the  integration  with  respect  to  k  must 
be  taken  to  infinity. 

Thus,  we  obtain  a  formula  for  the  total  crystal  energy  at  low  tem- 
perature 


The  inner  integral  is  taken  in  the  same  way  as  in  the  formula  for  the 
energy  of  an  electromagnetic  field  (42.6),  so  that 


470  STATISTICAL   PHYSICS  [Part    IV 

Thus  the  energy  of  a  crystal  lattice  is  proportional  to  the  fourth  power 
of  the  absolute  temperature,  while  the  specific  heat  is  proportional  to 
the  third  power.  This  refers  to  temperatures  considerably  smaller 
than  /z-comax. 

The  Debye  interpolation  formula.  P.  Debye  —  -the  author  of  the  theory 
of  crystal  specific  heats  at  low  temperatures  which  is  set  out  here  — 
proposed  an  interpolation  formula  for  intermediate  temperatures 
when  the  results  (42.30)  and  (42.28)  do  not  hold.  The  Debye  formula 
reduces  to  both  these  formulae  in  the  limiting  cases  of  high  and  low 
temperatures.  The  intermediate  interval  is  described  qualitatively, 
but  in  certain  agreement  with  experiment.  In  order  to  obtain  the 
Debye  formula,  we  suppose  that  the  law 


holds  for  all  k,  where  u0  is  the  usual  propagation  velocity  of  elastic 
waves.  We  may  even  take  Ui  =  uz  ---Ut,  u^--=ui9  where  Ut  and  u\  are 
the  velocities  of  transverse  and  longitudinal  waves  in  a  given  substance 
in  the  polycrystallirie  state,  which  velocities  are  independent  of  the 
direction  of  propagation  of  the  wave.  We  define  the  upper  frequency 
limit  comax  from  the  condition  that  the  total  number  of  vibrations  is 
equal  to  3^.  For  this  we  must  go  over  to  spherical  coordinates  in 
(46.26): 


(42.31) 

a          0 


or,  changing  to  ui,  iir,  we  have 

lS7T2Ar  V/ 


(42.32) 

^(--V  +  -» 


Condition  (42.31)  is  selected  so  that  at  high  temperatures  the  correct 
law  <£  =  3NQ  is  automatically  obtained.  At  medium  temperatures 
0  ^  h  comax ;  k=  -^-x-is  substituted  as  the  upper  limit  in  the  integral 
(42.29)  in  place  of  oo,  so  that  the  energy  expression  has  the  form 

2    ,    i  \  Tr^do  (42  33) 

e   w  -  1 

Changing  to  the  integration  variable  x  =  -~-  and  denoting 
^60,  we  can  rewrite  the  lattice  energy  thus: 


See.  42]  THE   APPLICATION  OF   STATISTICS  471 


r  /j     M**.!. 

2Ka  \  u]         u*.  I  h*  J  ex—  1 


At  low  temperature  OD  >  6,  so  that  the  upper  limit  in  the  integral  is 
replaced  by  infinity.  Then  the  integral  is  equal  to  -jg-  ,  and  for  the 
energy  we  have 

2       , 


The  exact  formula  (42.30)  assumes  the  same  form  if  we  replace  ua 
in  it  by  ut  and  m,  which  are  independent  of  direction. 

We  shall  now  show  how  to  determine  0D  from  experimental  data  on 
specific  heat  and,  independently,  from  elastic  constants.  The  following 
values  of  specific  heat  G  are  known  for  tungsten  (from  the  data  of 
F.  F.  Lange)  :  T  -  26.2°K,  C  -  0.21  cal/mol  -  deg.  ;  T  =  3S.9°K, 
C  =  0.75  cal/mol  •  deg.  The  cube  of  the  temperature  ratio  is  equal  to 
3.37,  and  the  ratio  of  specific  heats  is  3.58.  We  may  assume  that  in 
the  given  temperature  range  the  T3  law  for  specific  heat  holds.  Substi- 
tuting OD  =  A  (Omax  in  formula  (42.35),  we  determine  o)max  with  the  aid 
of  (42.32).  This  gives 


Converting  this  to  heat  units,  we  write 


Here  R  =  1.96  cal/mol  •  deg.  Substituting  the  specific  heat  at  the  lowest 
temperature,  we  find  TD  —  340°. 

We  now  determine  TD  by  proceeding  from  the  elastic  constants  for 
tungsten.  We  have  to  give,  without  derivation,  the  formulae  which 
connect  ut  and  u\  with  the  shear  modulus  and  the  bulk  modulus  for 
tungsten  (see  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits,  The  Mechanics  of 
Continuous  Media,  Gostekhizdat,  1953,  p.  744  or  A.  Love.  A  Treatise 
on  the  Mathematical  Theory  of  Elasticity,  Oh.  XIII,  Cambridge,  1927). 


Ut' 


F?. 


Here,  K  is  the  bulk  modulus,  which,  for  tungsten,  is  about  3.14  x  1012 
dyne/cm2  at  low  temperature.  O  is  the  shear  modulus  equal  to 
1.35xl012  dyne/cm2.  The  density  of  tungsten  is  p  =  19.3  gm/cm2. 
Hence,  ui  =  6  x  105  cm/sec,  ut  =  2.64  x  105  cm/sec.  For  tungsten  the  ratio 
is  equal  to  0.635  x  1023.  Whence,  if  we  calculate  it  from  (42.32), 

ix     A  *i        1AM  i       Am          4.61  X  1013  X  1.05  X  10~27       Oeo0 

equal  to  4. 61  x  1013sec~1andTD= 7-^3 — npie =^352°. 


472  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  agreement  with  what  was  obtained  from  specific  heat  turns 
out  to  be  even  better  than  could  have  been  expected,  because  the 
elastic  constants  do  not  strictly  refer  to  the  temperature  at  which 
the  specific  heat  was  determined,  and  also  because  tungsten  is  a 
crystalline  substance  and  its  elastic  properties  are  characterized  by 
three  moduli  of  elasticity  instead  of  two  (see  Landau  and  Lifshits, 
loc.  cit.,  p.  675).  For  a  number  of  substances  we  have  the  following 
values  of  Debye  temperature  TD:  Pb  —  88°,  Na  —  172°,  Cu  —  315°, 
Fe  —  453°,  Be—  1,000°,  diamond  —  J,860°  (all  from  absolute  zero). 
At  high  temperature,  0  >  OD,  we  must  put  ?.*  —  •  1  p^  x9  so  that 


which  is  what  we  demanded. 

For  0  «*  OD,  formula  (42.34)  agrees  with  experiment  qualitatively. 
We  note  that  we  must  not  expect  complete  agreement,  because  the 
initial  assumptions  made  in  deriving  this  formula  are  not  quantitative 
in  character.  It  is  not  worth  the  attempt  to  make  formula  (42.34) 
more  accurate,  without  taking  into  account  the  exact  form  of  the 
dependence  of  co  upon  k.  The  attempts  at  correcting  this  formula, 
which  are  sometimes  made,  are  simply  in  the  nature  of  adjustments. 

Exercises 

1)  Write  down  the  formula  for  the  wavelength  distribution  of  black-body 
radiation  energy.  Proceeding  from  the  fact  that  co  --  -  .       ,  wo  have 


'    '  /     -2nhc 

X'U  X0"-l 
The  maximum  is  defined  by  the  equation 


'2)  Show  that  if  Hose  particles  interact  with  a  Boltzmann  gas  the  probability 
of  a  particle  appearing  in  a  certain  state  is  proportional  to  n  -j-  1,  where  n  is  the 
number  of  particles  already  in  that  state,  arid  the  probability  of  a  particle 
disappearing  is  n. 

Let  the  energy  of  a  Boltzmann  particle  be  e  and  that  of  a  Bose  particle,  t\. 
Lot  us  consider  the  process  in  which  there  occurs  the  transition 

e  -f  Y)  ->  e'  -f  YJ' 

i.e.,  the  interaction  of  these  particles  changes  their  initial  state  with  energies 
e,  Y)  to  a  state  with  energies  e'  and  r{ '.  In  statistical  equilibrium  we  must  observe 
the  balance 

JTree'  Ne  >jr,  (1  +  «„')  ==  TfV.AY  (1  -I-  7iYi)HYj'. 

where  Wit'  is  the  probability  of  direct  transition  and  Wt't  is  the  reverse- 
transition  probability.  Putting 


Sec.  42]  THK    APPLICATION    OF    STATISTICS  473 

It-  e  H-e' 


^        \-i  /  -n'  -M.X        \-i 

-I/      ,  HV  =  U     °     -I/      » 


wo  see  that  tho  balance  equation  is  satisfied  if  We,  &'  —  W&'  e.  For  simplicity 
wo  have  put  gs  —  ge.'.  The  presence  of  spontaneous  emission  is  duo  to  the  Bose 
distribution. 

3)  Find  the  total  number  of  quanta  in  black-body  radiation  at  a  given 
temperature 

oo  on 

AT  /       C0          *** *  /      ^         _ 

9       T"       I  I  ~~          «>   T"'»      •*      I       ~    v         ^1       * 

TT 4 c**    I     «_<•>  IT"/?.  cj  I    ex — I 

./  e  »"-  1  J 

0  0 

Further  (see  Appendix), 


Hence, 

CO  CO        00  OO 

-r  -27  /•-«-'  -Z1  - 

0  «=10  «=1         0  M-  1 

The  sum  is  approximately  1.2,  so  that 

_2.4     FO3 

7T2      "/>C3     ' 

4)  The  atoms  are  situated  in  tho  form  of  a  linear  chain.  We  shall  denote 
the  displacement  of  the  nth  atom  by  an.  Tho  force  acting  between  the  nth 
and  (n  +  l)th  atoms  is  equal  to  a  (an  +  l  —  ««).  Find  the  equations  for  tho  vibra- 
tions of  tho  chain.  Ignore  the  interaction  between  the  more  distant  neighbours. 

The  vibration  equation  for  the  nth  atom  is 

mdn  -  a  (an  +  i  -f  ««-!  — 
We  look  for  an  in  the  form 


Substituting  this  in  the  initial  equation,  we  find,  after  cancelling  e^n 

ml  (t)  =  a&  (t)  (e{f+  e~^  —  2)  -  2  a6  (t)  (cos  /  —  1)  -  —  4  a  sin2  -£-  -  6  (t)  , 

& 

so  that  the  oscillation  frequency  for  a  given  value  of  /  is 


sin 


If  the  distance  between  the  atoms  is  d  then  n  —  —r  ,  where  x  is  the  equilib- 
rium position  of  the  nth  atom.  Putting  -j  =k,wQ  have  eifn  =  eikx,  so  that  /  can 

be  called  the  wave  vector,  considering  that  tho  length  is  measured  in  units 
of  d.  For  small  /,  as  was  asserted,  the  frequency  is  proportional  to  /  : 


474  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Sec.  43.  Bose  Distribution 

The  choice  ol  sign  of  JJL.  The  Bose  distribution  has  very  peculiar 
properties  at  low  temperatures.  We  shall  suppose  that  the  atoms 
do  not  have  spin;  such,  for  example,  are  helium  atoms  with  atomic 
weight  4.  Both  the  electrons  in  the  cloud  of  the  helium  atom  and  the 
protons  and  neutrons  in  the  helium  nucleus  are  in  the  Is-state.  They 
all  go  in  pairs  and  by  the  Pauli  principle  the  spins  are  antiparallel. 
Therefore,  the  resultant  spin  is  zero. 

From  (39.30),  the  weight  of  the  state  of  a  spinless  particle  is 


The  normalization  condition  (39.23)  looks  like 

Vm'l, 


.    „„. 
-  (          ' 

•"'"-I 

0 

This  condition  can  be  satisfied  only  for  negative  (ju  Indeed,  if  we 
suppose  that  (JL  is  greater  than  zero,  then  the  denominator  of  the 

s-  tx 


integrand  will  be  negative  for  s  <  (JL  because  then  e  e  <  1  .  But 
this  is  impossible  because  the  distribution  function  is,  by  its  very 
meaning,  a  positive  quantity. 

Hence,  fji<0.  At  high  temperatures  the  Bose  distribution  passes 
into  the  Boltzmann  distribution  in  accord  with  (40.6). 

The  sign  ol  ~  .  As  the  temperature  diminishes,   [i  decreases   in 

absolute  value.  This  can  be  shown  generally  with  the  aid  of  (43.2). 
Differentiating  this  equation  as  an  implicit  function  we  have 


CO  OO 

/r 
_j£rf?  _         / 
-r-  / 

e     e     -1  J 


8      §         •ye  </e  j      e-  -  (x 

sir 


00' 


5 

The  integrands  in  (43.3)  are  essentially  positive  quantities  [(e  —  p.)  >  0, 
because  (Ji<0],  and  therefore  ^~  <0.  Hence,  as  0  decreases,  the 
absolute  value  |[JL|  diminishes  monotonically  since  JJL  must  increase. 


Sec.  43]  BOSE  DISTRIBUTION  475 

We  shall  now  show  that  (JL  becomes  zero  at  a  temperature  other 
than  zero.  To  do  this  we  put  [x  =  0  in  (43.2)  and  find  the  corresponding 
value  0=00: 


The  integral  simply  represents  an  abstract  quantity:  it  is  equal 
to  &  2.31  (see  Appendix).  Therefore  equation  (43.4)  is  satisfied  by 
a  value  of  60  that  is  different  from  zero. 

Bose  condensation.  What  will  happen  when  the  temperature  is 
reduced  further  ?  (ji  cannot  go  from  negative  to  positive  values  since, 
as  we  have  shown  at  the  beginning  of  the  section,  this  would  lead 
to  negative  probability  values.  (JL  cannot  become  negative  once  again, 

because  -  y  is  always  less  than  zero  so  that  (JL  varies  only  monotonically, 

if  it  is  at  all  capable  of  varying.  Therefore,  the  only  possibility  is 
for  |JL  to  remain  equal  to  zero  after  it  has  once  attained  its  zero  value. 
But  then  equation  (43.2)  is  no  longer  satisfied  if  the  temperature 
is  less  than  60,  and  N  does  not  change.  On  the  contrary,  it  can  be 
seen  from  (43.4)  that  if  we  define  the  number  of  particles  as 


for  0<00,  it  decreases  with  the  temperature  in  proportion  to  0*/a. 
What  happens  to  the  remaining  particles  which  number  N  —  N"i 
As  opposed  to  light  quanta  these  particles  cannot  be  absorbed. 
Therefore,  they  will  pass  into  a  state  which  is  not  taken  into  account 
in  the  normalizing  integral  (43.2).  The  only  state  of  this  kind  possesses 
an  energy  equal  to  zero:  due  to  factor  A/e  it  does  not  contribute 
anything  to  the  integral  (43.4).  In  normalization  we  can  isolate  the 
particles  occurring  in  the  zero  state  in  a  separate  term.  If  a  finite 
number  of  particles  go  to  the  zero-energy  state,  they  will  naturally 
fall  out  of  the  integral.  N'  particles  remain  continuously  distributed, 
but  with  the  value  \i  =  Q.  Thus,  at  a  temperature  0<00,  the  whole 
distribution  consists  of  an  infinitely  narrow  "peak"  at  e  =  0  and  of 

/  _L        \-i 

particles  distributed  according  a  \e  e  —  I/  law.  At  absolute  zero 
all  the  particles  are  in  a  zero  state :  this  state  of  a  Bose  gas  is  obviously 
defined  uniquely.  It  will  be  noted  that  a  BoJtzmann  gas  would  behave 
in  an  entirely  different  way  when  the  temperature  tended  to  zero. 


476  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Liquid  helium.  Helium  with  atomic  weight  4  obeys  Bose  statistics 
since  the  spin  of  its  nuclei  and  of  the  electronic  shells  is  equal  to  zero. 
It  is  therefore  interesting  to  see  whether  anything  like  this  "Bose 
condensation"  is  observed  in  helium. 

It  is  difficult  to  give  a  unique  answer  because  at  low  temperature 
helium  is  a  liquid,  and  the  Bose  distribution,  which  relates  to  an  ideal 
gas,  does  not  apply.  Nevertheless  the  qualitative  aspect  of  the  result 
obtained  for  a  gas  may  still  hold.  Namely,  it  may  be  supposed  that 
at  a  certain  temperature  part  of  the  gas  will  pass  into  a  zero  energy 
state  and,  accordingly,  will  not  contribute  to  the  specific  heat. 

Liquid  helium  does,  in  fact,  experience  a  peculiar  change  of  state 
at  a  temperature  of  2.10°K  (at  atmospheric  pressure).  Speaking  of 
a  monatomic  liquid,  which  is  what  liquid  helium  is,  it  is  difficult 
to  imagine  any  change  of  state  related  to  a  rearrangement  of  the 
atoms  in  space.  Therefore,  it  is  interesting  to  compare  the  actual 
temperature  of  transition  in  liquid  helium  with  the  temperature  at 
which  Bose  condensation  would  occur  in  gaseous  helium  of  the  same 
density. 

The  density  of  liquid  helium  is  equal  to  0.12  gm/cm3.   Whence 

the  ratio  y  —  ' 4  -  X  6  x  1023  =  0. 1 8  x  1023.  Consequently,  according  to 
(43.4)  the  temperature  00  is 

0.18  -  1023  •  9.8G  •  1.41  -  1.18  -  10  8I  W,       0  0,.    .  „    lf. 
2.31.17.1.10-  ) /J- 3.86- 10-1*; 

„,     _   3.8(^10   '«    _         0 
0   ~   1.38  ."10  »«         ^'       ' 

which  is  close  to  the  transition  temperature.  At  the  transition,  the 
specific  heat  of  helium  experiences  a  discontinuity.  In  the  case  of 
a  Bose  gas,  only  the  derivative  of  the  specific  heat  with  respect  to 
temperature  has  a  discontinuity. 

Superfluidity.  P.  L.  Kapitsa  discovered  that  below  the  temperature 
of  phase  transition,  liquid  helium  possesses  a  most  remarkable  prop- 
erty:  it  is  capable  of  passing  through  the  finest  slit  without  exhibiting 
any  signs  of  viscosity.  This  property  was  called  superfluidity. 

L.  D.  Landau  developed  a  theory  of  superfluidity  proceeding  from 
the  supposed  quantum-level  spectrum  for  a  liquid.  On  the  basis 
of  this  theory  he  built  the  hydrodynamics  of  a  superfluid,  which 
differs  from  conventional  hydrodynamics  in  that  each  point  possesses 
two  velocities  instead  of  one :  a  normal  and  a  superfluid  component. 
The  occurrence  of  two  velocities  means  that  in  a  superfluid  two  types 
of  sound  vibrations  may  be  propagated:  ordinary  sound,  in  which 
pressure  and  density  oscillate,  and  "second  sound/'  which  is  connected 
with  the  relative  motion  of  the  normal  and  superfluid  components. 
The  second  sound  was  demonstrated  in  an  experiment  carried  out 
by  V.  P.  Peshkov  using  a  method  proposed  by  E.  M.  Lifshits.  The 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  477 

experimentally  found  velocity  of  second  sound  (which  is  small  com- 
pared with  the  velocity  of  conventional  sound)  is  in  excellent  agree- 
ment with  Landau's  theory. 

The  question  of  th$  relationship  between  superfluidity  and  Bose 
condensation  cannot  be  considered  fully  resolved.  It  may  be  suggested 
that  the  superfiuid  component  corresponds  to  that  part  of  the  helium 
which  has  passed  to  the  zero  state.  This  hypothesis  is  strongly  sup- 
ported by  the  fact  that  the  liquid  isotope  of  helium  with  atomic 

weight  3  is  not  superfiuid :  the  nuclear  spin  of  helium  3  is  equal  to  -5- , 

so  that  its  atoms  are  subject  to  the  statistics  of  Fermi  and  not  Bose. 
Accordingly,  they  cannot  all  pass  into  the  zero  state  together:  the 
Pauli  principle  does  not  permit  this. 

N.  N.  Bogolyubov  showed  that  a  gas  which  is  close  to  an  ideal 
gas  and  consists  of  Bose  particles  possesses  an  energy  spectrum  which, 
according  to  Landau's  theory,  a  superfiuid  liquid  should  have.  How- 
ever, no  one  has  so  far  succeeded  in  proving  theoretically  that  it  is 
precisely  liquid  helium  below  the  transition  point  that  should  possess 
such  a  spectrum. 

Exercise 

Calculate1  the  energy  and  pressure  of  a  Bose  gas  below  the  transition  point. 
For  the  energy  we  have 

oo 

Vml*      5,   C  x*l*d-.c          1.78  \7m*l*tflt 
g  =  4>1  -  0   3-  0  /a    — —      ^  — 

6 

(see   Appendix).   The   pressure   is   determined  from  the   general  relationship 

(40.22): 

2     0 


Thus,  the  pressure  of  a  Bose  gas  below  the  transition  point  is  independent  of 
volume  and  depends  only  upon  the  temperature.  Jf  we  compress  such  a  Boso  gas 
its  particles  will  go  to  the  zero-energy  state.  Conversely,  upon  expansion  the 
particles  will  come  out  of  the  zero -energy  state  until  there  are  none  left.  If  expan- 
sion continues  the  pressure  will  begin  to  decrease. 

Sec.  44.  Fermi  Distribution 

The  form  of  the  Fermi-distribution  curve  and  its  interpretation. 

The  criterion  for  the  transition  from  quantum  statistics  to  classical 
statistics  is  that  [see  (40.7)] 

N      ^    #(0)  /  w 


If  the  inequality  is  reversed,  then  essentially  quantum  properties 
of  the  statistical  distribution  appear.  In  this  section  we  shall  consider 


478  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

the  properties  of  the  Fermi  distribution  when  the  inverse  inequality 

T-"  $(£•)*  <"•" 

or  an  equivalent  inequality 

£  >  1  (44.2) 

is  satisfied. 

From  (39.26)  and  (39.30),  the  Fermi-distribution  curve  is  of  the 
following  form: 

J»</e  1  M  i  Q\ 

~         ,  .  (44.3) 


Here,  a  weight  factor  2  is  introduced,  since  we  have  put  j '  —  -^  .  The 

first  factor  in  (44.3)  represents  the  total  number  of  states  between 
£  and  £-(  rf£,  while  the  second  factor  represents  the  probability  that 
these  states  are  occupied.  We  can  interpret  the  function 

/W=     Y--V  -  («.4) 

e    °       i    1 

as  a  probability  and  as  the  mean  number  of  particles,  because  /  (e) 
is  contained  between  zero  and  unity.  A  similar  function  in  the  Bose 
distribution  could  only  denote  the  mean  number  of  particles  in  one 
of  the  quantum  states  with  a  given  energy,  because  the  Bose-distri- 

/  «-•*         \    l 

bution  function  \e  °  —  I/  is  sometimes  even  greater  than  unity 
and  must  not  be  interpreted  as  a  probability. 

Let  us  see  how  the  curve  /  (E)  behaves  when  -|-  g>  1.  When  £  =  0 
we  obtain 


JL 

T+i 


because  e     e   is  a  small  number.  The  quantity  e    e     is  also  a  small 
number  as  long  as  e  remains  smaller  than  [JL,  while  /  (e)  is  close  to 

e-n 

unity,  like  /  (0).  Only  when  e  —  [i  is  comparable  with  6,  is  e    Q      of 
the  order  of  unity,  so  that  /  (s)  begins  to  decrease  noticeably  with 

further  increase  of  e.  For  e  =  (Ji,  /  (fi)  decreases  toy: 

J_  —  L 

"  -eo+  1  "   2  • 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  479 

For  still  greater  values  of  e,  /  (e)  decreases  exponentially  because 
unity  can  then  be  neglected  in  the  denominator,  and,  for  e  >  ji,  /  (e) 
becomes  the  Boltzmann  distribution 


The  Bose  distribution  also  has  the  same  limiting  form.  The  curve 
/  (z)  is  roughly  shown  in  Fig.  50.  The  region  e,  where  /  (s)   changes 

from  unity  to  zero,  has  a  width  of  the  order  6,  since  g-  —  is  comparable 

with  unity  only  if  e-  -ji^O:  for  smaller  s  the  exponential  is  con- 
siderably smaller  than  unity,  while  for  larger  e  the  exponential  is 
considerably  greater  than  unity. 

Fermi  distribution  at  absolute  zero.  We  shall  call  the  region  of 
transition  of  /  from  unity  to  zero  the  spread  region  of  Fermi  distri- 
bution. As  the  temperature  decreases  the  spread 
region  narrows  and,  at  absolute  zero,  becomes  a 
sharp   discontinuity   /,   so   that   the   distribution 
function  takes  the  form  of  a  right  angle.  Fig.  50 
shows  this  step  by  a  broken  line.  The  value  of  (JL 
at  absolute  zero  is  called  [JLO.  Hence, 
=  0,   all   states  with   energy   less 
than  [JLO  arc  occupied  with  unity  prob- 


F.  ability     (i.e.,    with    certcainty),    while 

lg'  those  with  energy  greater  than  [JLO  are 

empty,  also  with  certainty. 

This  result  can  likewise  be  obtained  directly  from  Pauli's  principle 
without  resorting  to  statistics.  From  (39.32),  a  definite  interval  of 
momentum-component  values  kpx,  kpy,  &pz  corresponds  to  one  state 
of  particle  motion.  If  the  particle  is  contained  in  a  box  with  sides 
%,  a2,  a3,  then  it  follows  from  the  uncertainty  relation  (23.4)  that 


since  these  quantities  show  by  how  much  the  momentum  components 
of  two  particles  must  differ  in  order  that  the  particles  may  be  regarded 
as  occurring  in  different  states  of  motion. 

This  follows  not  only  from  the  uncertainty  relation,  but  can  also 
be  seen  strictly  when  computing  the  states  leading  to  formulae 
(25.23)  and  (39.32).  Here,  each  state  must  be  identified  not  with 
the  volume  of  the  parallelepiped,  but  with  one  of  its  vertices  whose 
coordinates  are  given  by  the  three  integers  nl9  w2,  n3.  The  coefficient  2  it 
in  the  uncertainty  relations  is  taken  so  that  both  definitions  for  the 
number  of  states  agree. 

If  we  plot  px,  py,  pz  on  coordinate  axes,  then  to  each  state  of  spatial 
motion  of  the  electron  there  correspond  three  quantum  numbers 


480 


STATISTICAL   PHYSICS 


[Part  IV 


nly  n%,  n%.  These  quantum  numbers  specify  the  number  of  the  parallele- 
piped with  sides  ApXy  &py,  A^.  It  is  shown  in  Fig.  51.  All  the  space 
in  which  the  axes  pXy  py,  pz  are  drawn  can  be 
filled  with  such  boxes.  Since  three  quantum 
numbers  correspond  to  a  single  box  and,  in 
addition,  the  state  is  also  given  by  the  spin,  there 

may  be  two  particles  with  spin  -^  having  momen- 
tum projections  in  the  same  interval  Ap*,  A^y, 

~    A£>*.  The  spins  of  these  two  particles  are  anti- 

*     parallel. 

Thus,  the  space  pxy  py,  pz  may  be  divided 
into  boxes  or  cells  with  dimensions 


Fig.  51 


(44.5) 


where  there  are  no  more  than  two  particles  in  each  cell. 

The  closer  the  cell  to  the  coordinate  origin,  the  less  the  energy  it 

1 


possesses,  because  the  energy  is    equal  to   e 


(pl  +  K 


In  other  words,  it  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the  distance  of 
the  cell  from  the  origin. 

Let  us  now  consider  the  state  of  a  gas  at  the  absolute  zero  of  temper- 
ature. If  the  gas  consisted  of  only  two  particles,  then  at  absolute  zero 
the  states  of  both  particles  would  fill  the  cell  closest  to  the  origin. 
In  accordance  with  the  Pauli  jmnciple,  the  next  two  particles  cannot 
enter  the  same  cell :  they  are  forced  to  take  up  positions  further 
from  the  origin.  As  the  number  of  particles  increases,  cells  are  filled 
which  are  situated  further  and  further  from  the  origin;  but  each 
time  two  particles  are  added  they  fall  into  a  free  cell  closest  to  the 
origin,  because,  by  definition,  absolute  zero  corresponds  to  the  least 
possible  energy  of  the  gas  as  a  whole. 

If  there  are  very  many  particles,  their  cells  will  densely  fill  a  sphere 
whose  centre  is  the  coordinate  origin.  All  states  inside  the  sphere 
are  filled  with  unity  probability,  while  those  outside  the  sphere  are 
free — also  with  certainty. 

The  limiting  energy  of  Fermi  distribution.  If  we  denote  the  energy 
corresponding  to  the  boundary  of  the  sphere  by  e0,  then  it  can  be 
seen  from  Fig.  50  that  £Q  =  \JLO.  [iQ  is  the  limiting  energy  of  a  particle 
at  absolute  zero.  It  is  very  easy  to  calculate  e0  or  [JLO.  Since  at  absolute 
zero  the  function  /  (e)  is  equal  to  unity  for  all  s  <  [LQJ  the  total  number 
of  particles  N  is,  from  (44.3), 


N  =  — ^  " V-- 


F(2m)3/2e03/2 


(44.6) 


Sec.  44]  FERMI    DISTRIBUTION  481 

whence 


The  same  can  be  seen  without  the  aid  of  /  (s).  Indeed,  the  radius 
of  the  sphere  of  greatest  energy  is 


Its  volume  is 


But  this  same  quantity  is  equal  to  the  number  of  filled  elementary 
cells  (with  two  particles  per  cell)  multiplied  by  the  volume  of  a  single 

cell  ~rc          Consequently, 

4       /rt  v»y  N    (2nh)*  /AA   a\ 

y7r:(2m£0)^-  -;T"-j/—  >  (44-8) 

whence  equation  (44.7)  is  again  obtained. 

At  absolute  zero  the  state  of  a  Fermi  gas  as  a  whole  is  defined 
uniquely:  in  quantum  statistics  it  is  necessary  to  indicate  which 
states  are  occupied  by  separate  particles,  but  it  is  impossible  to  deter- 
mine by  which  particles  they  are  filled.  In  the  given  case  all  the 
states  inside  the  sphere  with  limiting  energy  s0  are  filled  by  particles. 

The  criterion  for  the  closeness  of  the  Fermi  distribution  to  the 
distribution  at  absolute  zero  (based  on  the  form  of  the  distribution). 
At  a  temperature  close  to  absolute  zero  thermal  excitation  can  be 
imparted  only  to  those  particles  whose  energy  is  close  to  e0  —  pL0. 
Indeed,  as  long  as  6<^s0,  a  thermal  excitation  of  the  order  6  cannot 
be  imparted  to  a  particle  whose  cell  lies  deep  beneath  the  surface 
e  =  e0,  because  the  states  between  the  surface  and  the  given  cell 
are  occupied,  and  the  energy  0  is  insufficient  to  remove  the  particle 
beyond  the  limits  of  the  surface  boundary.  Therefore,  only  those 
particles  whose  energy  differs  from  e0  by  an  amount  of  the  order 
of  0  can  take  up  free  places.  Deeper  states  will  remain  densely  filled 
as  before.  Thus,  the  filling  probability  will  be  almost  equal  to  unity 
for  all  energies  £<e0>  an^  will  fall  to  zero  in  a  region  of  the  order 
of  0  close  to  £^£0,  as  shown  in  Fig.  50. 

The  criterion  that  the  curve  is  close  to  the  step  is  the  inequality 

6  <  £0  >  (44.9) 

and  this  agrees  with  (44.1)  within  the  accuracy  of  the  numerical 
factor.  As  we  shall  soon  see,  the  concept  of  '  'closeness"  of  temperature 
to  .absolute  zero,  according  to  the  criterion  (44.9),  differs  greatly 
from  conventional. 

31  -0060 


482  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Electrons  conducting  electricity  in  metals  are  usually  considered 
as  an  ideal  gas.  The  main  basis  for  this  is  the  fact  that  we  as  yet 
have  no  better  theoretical  model.  It  has  not  been  possible  to  consider 
electrostatic  interactions  between  electrons  sufficiently  fully  to  obtain 
quantitative  results  that  might  compare  with  experiment.  This  is 
why  the  phrase  "electron  gas"  in  metals  is  used.  In  many  cases  the 
conclusions  from  such  a  model  are  in  good  agreement  with  experiment. 

Without  considering  the  electron  theory  of  metals,  we  shall  take 
the  electron  gas  only  as  an  example  in  which  condition  (44.9)  is 
satisfied.  Let  us  suppose  that  there  is  one  conduction  electron  for 
each  atom.  This  assumption  appears  to  be  satisfied  for  alkali  metals, 
in  which  the  outer  electron  is  weakly  bound  and  is  separated  from 
the  atom  in  a  lattice. 

Let  us  find  e0  for  the  electron  gas  in  metallic  sodium.  The  density 
of  sodium  is  0.97  and  atomic  weight  23.  Hence,  unit  volume  contains 

°;,?7-  •  6.02  -  1023  =  0.25  •  1023 

Z*j 

atoms   and   as   many   conduction   electrons.   Whence,   from    (44.7), 

1    19      10— 5 t 

e0  =-=  2.1 .  4.6  Y 8  .'10_ 27    •  0.08  - 10-16  =  4.8  -  10-« 

[the  sequence  of  the  numbers  is  the  same  as  in  (44.7)].  In  degrees  e0 
is  34,800.  Hence,  at  all  temperatures  for  which  we  can  speak  of 
sodium  as  a  metal,  the  electron  gas  in  it  is  close  to  a  Fermi  gas  at 
absolute  zero.  Similar  results  are  also  obtained  for  non-alkali  metals, 
though  with  a  less  reliable  value  of  electron  density. 

The  compressibility  of  alkali  metals.  Let  us  derive  a  formula  for 
the  compressibility  of  a  Fermi  gas  at  absolute  zero.  From  (44.6), 
the  energy  at  absolute  zero  is 


-e0'/..  (44.10) 

In  accordance  with  the  Bernoulli  equation  (40.22),  the  pressure 
is  equal  to  two  thirds  the  energy  density,  i.e., 

7)  =  -?-  (2m) /2  e  »/«  =  Ali!L(i  A3  l*L\ /3  (44  1 1) 

^         15     :T2/i3      °  5       m  \F/  v     •     ; 

Whence 
-  -ay-  =>|,  ^-SrS^)"''  =°-273  X  1027(^)~/3bai-i.      (44.12) 

Ya.  I.   Frenkel  noted  that  the   compressibility  of  alkali  metals 
is  close  to  the  compressibility  of  an  electron  gas. 


Sec.  44] 


FERMI    DISTRIBUTION 


483 


Indeed,  expressing  N/V  in  terms  of  atomic  weight  and  density, 
we  obtain  the  following  table: 


Li 

Na 

K 

Kb 

Cs 

1    dV 

-   -     -  -  x  108  from  equation  (44.12) 

4.7 

13 

37 

52 

79 

\     op 

I    dV 

—  —  -  -^—  x  106  from  experimental  data 

S 

15 

32 

40 

61 

In  a  crystal  lattice  there  are,  of  course,  not  only  forces  of  repulsion 
between  particles,  but  also  cohesive  forces.  The  equilibrium  of  these 
forces  with  the  forces  of  repulsion  determines  the  characteristic  vol- 
ume which  every  condensed  body,  solid,  or  liquid  has  in  the  absence  of 
external  pressure.  Ordinary  atmospheric  pressure  gives  a  force  which 
is  negligibly  small  compared  with  these  tremendous  forces  that  keep 
bodies  in  their  volumes.  In  order  to  change  the  volume  of  a  body  by 
only  one  per  cent,  pressures  are  required  in  the  order  of  tons  of  thou- 
sands of  atmospheres. 

The  coincidence  of  theoretical  and  experimental  data  indicates  that 
when  alkali  metals  are  compressed  the  cohesive  forces  change  insignif- 
icantly compared  with  the  forces  of  repulsion.  It  is  even  conceivable 
that  the  state  of  the  valence  electrons  in  alkali  metals  is  perturbed  to  a 
comparatively  small  degree  by  the  atomic  residues,  and,  to  some  ex- 
tent, is  close  to  an  electron  gas.  Compression  affects  but  little  the 
electronic  shells  of  the  atomic  residues,  and  therefore  the  compressi- 
bility of  alkali  metals  is  close  to  the  compressibility  of  an  ideal  Fermi 
gas.  That  this  should  bo  so  is,  of  course,  not  at  all  obvious  beforehand. 

Paramagrietisni  of  alkali  metals.  According  to  Pauli,  the  paramagne- 
tism  of  alkali  metals  can  also  be  exp  lamed  on  the  basis  of  the  concept 
of  a  free  electron  gas. 

If  we  place  a  Fermi  gas  (consisting  of  electrons)  in  a  magnetic  field, 
the  energy  of  the  electrons,  whose  spins  are  parallel  to  the  field,  will 
be  equal  to  —  $H,  while  the  energy  of  electrons  with  opposite  direc- 
tion of  spin  will  be  equal  to  p//*.  Therefore,  if  those  electrons  whose 
spin  is  antiparallel  to  the  field  reverse  their  spin  directions,  then  the 
energy  of  the  gas  must  decrease.  But  all  the  places  inside  the  limiting- 
energy  sphere  are  occupied  ;  so  for  an  electron  to  change  its  spin  direc- 
tion it  must  come  out  of  the  sphere  into  a  free  cell.  But  this  increases 
its  kinetic  energy.  Equilibrium  is  established  between  electrons  with 
spins  parallel  and  antiparallel  to  the  field  when  their  total  energies 
become  equal.  Indeed,  if  there  occurred  a  further  transition  of  elec- 
trons into  a  state  with  spin  parallel  to  the  field,  the  increase  in  their 


*  Here  the  Bohr  magneton  is  denoted  by 
confusion  with  the  distribution  parameter  ^. 


instead  of  n,  so  as  to  avoid 


31* 


484  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

kinetic  energy  could  not  be  compensated  by  a  reduction  in  magnetic 
energy. 

Let  there  be  n  electrons  which  have  changed  their  spin  directions. 

N 
Then  there  remain  -  --  n  electrons  with  spin  antiparallel  to  the  field, 

N 
while  —  +n  have  spins  parallel  to  the  field.  The  limiting  energies  are 

determined  from  formula  (44.8),  where  we  must  put-^-  ±  n  instead 

N 
of  -g-  .  Whence  we  obtain  the  following  expression  for  the  limiting 

kinetic  energy  of  both  types  of  electrons  : 


and  the  equation  for  the  total  limiting  energies  is 
/   3   \'/.  (2  */,,) 

~ 


Since n<^ -5-,  the  binomials  can  be  expanded  in  a  series  as  follows: 

z 

IN    .      \'/3 


3JV  * 

Substituting  this  in  (44.14),  we  find  the  number  of  electrons  which 
change  their  spin  directions  in  the  magnetic  field : 

(44.15) 


Each  of  these  electrons  contributes  a  term  2  p  to  the  total  magnetic 
moment  of  the  whole  gas,  because  its  moment  projection  on  the  magnet- 
ic field  has  changed  from  —  (J  to  p.  The  magnetic  polarization  (that 
is,  the  magnetic  moment  of  unit  volume)  turns  out  equal  to 


while  the  magnetic  polarizability  a,  defined  as  the  coefficient  of  H 
on  the  right-hand  side  of  this  formula,  depends  only  upon  the  density 
of  the  electron  gas  and  not  its  temperature  : 


Indeed,  alkali  metals  have  a  paramagnetism  independent  of  tempe- 
rature. Let  it  be  recalled  that  in  accordance  with  the  results  of  Sec.  40 
[see  (40.53)]  atomic  paramagnetism  gives  a  magnetic  polarizability 
which  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  temperature.  Formula  (44.17) 
agrees  satisfactorily  with  experiment. 


Sec.  44] 


FERMI  DISTRIBUTION 


485 


Diamagnetism  of  electrons.  L.  D.  Landau  has  shown  that  the  quan- 
tized motion  of  electrons  in  a  magnetic  field  —  this  motion  is  similar 
to  their  classical  motion  in  a  spiral  —  leads,  in  a  weak  field,  to  the  appear- 
ance of  a  magnetic  moment  equal  to  1/3  of  expression  (44.16),  and  of 
opposite  sign.  The  nature  of  this  effect  is  purely  quantum  :  if  we  regard 
the  motion  of  electrons  as  classical  then  the  additional  magnetic 
moment  becomes  identically  zero  (see  Sec.  46,  exercise  13). 

If  $H  is  of  the  order  of  0,  then  the  polarizability  does  not  depend 
monotonically  upon  the  field  and  exhibits  much  oscillation  as  the  field 
increases.  The  oscillatory  variation  of  magnetic  properties  is,  in  fact, 
observed  in  very  many  metals. 

The  potential  distribution  in  an  atom.  We  shall  now  show  how  to  find 
the  general  form  for  the  electron-density  distribution  in  atoms  via 
the  notion  of  a  Fermi  gas.  To  a  certain  approximation,  the  electrons 
in  heavy  atoms  resemble  a  Fermi  gas.  However,  it  must  be  noted  that 
each  electron  occurs  in  the  inhomogeneous  electric  field  formed  by  the 
nucleus  and  the  entire  configuration  of  the  remaining  electrons. 

Let  us  first  of  all  consider  a  Fermi  gas  at  absolute  zero  in  a  potential 
field  of  the  form  shown  in  Fig.  52. 


=  0  for  0  <x  <a,  C7=  C70  for 


17 


Fig.  52 


Fig.  53 


a  <  x  <  b,  U=U1foTX>b.  Then  the  limiting  energy  of  the  electrons  e0 
must  be  the  same  for  0<#  <a  and  for  a<#  <6,  because  otherwise 
the  electrons  will  pass  into  a  region  of  lesser  limiting  energy  according, 
as  it  were,  to  the  law  of  communicating  vessels.  Of  course,  as  a  result 
of  this  the  total  energy  will  diminish.  But  the  energy  of  a  gas  at 
absolute  zero  is  the  least  possible,  so  that  the  limiting  energy  must  be 
the  same  in  any  part  of  the  gas. 

The  potential  energy  distribution  in  an  atom  is  approximately  as 
shown  in  Fig.  53.  The  potential  energy  is  everywhere  negative  because 
we  have  taken  it  to  be  zero  at  infinity. 

The  limiting  energy  of  electrons  must  not  be  positive  anywhere, 
because  electrons  with  a  positive  total  energy  could  leave  the  atom  for 
infinity.  The  limiting  energy  cannot  anywhere  be  less  than  the  poten- 
tial energy.  We  shall  show  that  it  must  be  equal  to  zero.  If,  for  exam- 


486  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

pie,  it  corresponded  to  the  dashed  line  in  Fig.  53,  the  electron  density 
would  become  zero  at  the  point  r  —  rQ.  But  then  the  electric  field  would 
be  zero  for  all  values  r>rQ,  because  in  the  case  of  spherical  symmetric- 
al charge  distribution  the  action  of  all  the  electrons  of  a  neutral  atom 
balances  the  action  of  the  nucleus.  Accordingly,  the  potential  would 
also  be  zero  when  r  =  r0,  because  potential  is  the  field  integral: 

r 

9  =  |  E  dr,  i.e.,  the  integral  with  integrand  equal  to  zero  at 

CO 

Thus,  the  following  three  conditions  would  be  satisfied  at  the  point 
r~r0:  r&(r0)  =  0.  9  (FO)~(),  j-1?  J  ==0|n  -~  ~~-,i.c.,  the  electron  den- 

sity). The  density  is  proportional  to  the  3/2  power  of  the  kinetic 
energy  [see  (44.8)],  n^^Q  +  ey)*1*  .  Here,  ff0  =  e<r"e<P»  i-e->  the 
limiting  total  energy  must  be  a  constant  quantity.  But,  applying  this 
equation  at  the  point  r0,  we  see  that  <3*0  must  equal  zero.  It  only  re- 
mains to  show  that  the  point  r0  cannot  occur  at  a  finite  distance  away 
from  the  nucleus.  As  we  shall  see  later,  this  follows  from  the  equation 
for  the  distribution  of  potential. 
Thus,  putting  <^0  =  0  we  obtain 

-7*.'/.-=e0   -=r<p.  (44.18) 


Here,  from  formula  (44.7),  e0  is  expressed  in  terms  of  density,  i.e., 
the  charge  density  is  related  to  potential. 

The  equation  for  a  self-consistent  field.  A  second  relationship  be- 
tween potential  and  density  is  given  by  the  electrostatic  equation 
(14.7).  Since  the  electronic  charge  is  negative,  this  equation  should  be 
written  with  a  plus  sign  on  the  right-hand  side: 

l>  -r-r°  {l?  -"  47crw.  (44.10) 

r"    d  r         dr  v  ' 

The  density  n~~~fy~  must  be  eliminated  from  (44. 18)  and  69  inserted 
in  place  of  e0.  Then  we  obtain 


r/rp  2'/a    'tn  I*     5/      3,  ...  rt_. 

-  /  —  -  ~  ------  -7-=-  e  /a  9  /j  .  (44.20) 

3  r  v  ' 


-  -  -  -  ,    r   - 

r2    dr        dr 

We  transform  this  equation  like  (19.6).  For  this,  we  substitute  9 
in  the  form 

9  ^~*t.  (44.21) 

The  function  ^  is  nondimensioiial  since  —  has  the  dimensions  of 

potential.  In  immediate  proximity  to  the  nucleus,  9  is  determined  only 
by  the  nucleus  because  the  potential  of  the  nucleus  tends  to  infinity 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  487 

like  —  ,  while  the  potential  of  the  spatially  distributed  charge  of  the 

electrons  remains  finite. 

Therefore,  close  to  the  nucleus  (i.e.,  when  r  =  Q)  <|;=1.  At  large 
distances  from  the  nucleus,  its  charge  is  completely  screened  by  the 
electron  charge  of  opposite  sign,  so  that  the  potential  of  an  atom  must 

tend  to  zero  more  rapidly  than  —  .  This  shows  that  fy  (oo)  =^0. 
Substituting  (44.21)  in  (44.20),  we  have  an  equation  for  fy: 


—  /->-   =  —  0  -  •  *        7  .7—  ,.  -.  ::. 

dr*  3rc  h*  rlk  v  ' 

It  is  convenient  to  get  rid  of  the  dimensional  factor  on  the  right- 
hand  side.  To  do  this,  we  must  introduce  a  new  unit  of  length  similar 
to  the  atomic  unit  [see  (31.21)]: 

f=<3?>>i      '''..*.  (44.23) 

27/s      %  la  we2  v  ' 

This  unit  differs  from  the  atomic  unit  by  the  factor  —  ^,—  .  After  the 

£i  la 

introduction  of  a  nondimersional  variable  xy  equation  (44.22)  reduces 
to  standard  form  (the  Thomas-Fermi  equation): 

-r-t-4.  (44-24) 

f/.t2  .r/2  V  ' 

Now  it  does  not  involve  atomic  number.  Both  boundary  conditions 
for  ip  (^(0)  —  1  and  <p  (oo)  =  0)  are  also  the  same  for  all  atoms.  There- 
fore, it  is  sufficient  to  integrate  equation  (44.24)  once  with  these  bound- 
ary conditions. 

If  we  return  to  the  dimensional  radius  r,  the  function  tp  (x)  gives  the 
potential  distribution  for  each  Z: 


If  the  distance  from  the  nucleus  is  expressed  in  terms  of  x,  the  elec- 
tron density  distribution  is  the  same  for  all  atoms  to  which  the  statis- 
tical method  is  applicable,  i.e.,  for  all  elements  of  large  and  medium 
atomic  weight.  But  the  same  x  denotes  a  geometrical  distance  inversely 
proportional  to  Zll*  ,  as  can  be  seen  from  (44.23).  Therefore,  in  heavy 
atoms,  the  main  part  of  the  electrons  is  concentrated  closer  to  the  nu- 
cleus than  in  the  lighter  atoms. 

The  accuracy  of  the  Thomas-Fermi  equation  (44.24)  is  determined 
by  the  quantity  Z~tf»,  as  can  be  shown  from  a  strictly  quantum- 
mechanical  derivation  by  using  a  quasi-classical  approximation.  There- 
fore, equation  (44.24)  cannot,  of  course,  be  applied  to  the  very  lightest 
atoms  that  contain  few  electrons. 


488  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Substantiation  of  the  boundary  conditions  for  equation  (44.24).  The 

integral  curves  of  equation  (44.24)  begin  at  the  point  ^  =  1  for  #  =  0, 
and  fall  with  increasing  x,  accounting  thereby  for  the  screening  effect, 
i.e.,  weakening  of  the  nuclear  field  by  the  atomic  electrons.  The  dimin- 
ishing function  may  either  pass  through  a  minimum,  without  attain- 
ing fy  =  0,  and  then  begin  to  increase,  or  it  may  intersect  the  #-axis  at 
a  certain  point  #  =  a?0,  or  it  may  tend  to  this  axis  asymptotically. 
The  first  possibility  must  be  rejected  at  once,  because  it  results 

00 

in  an  infinite  total  number  of  electrons  proportional  to  I  <J//a  xlf*  dx, 

o 

see  (44.18)  and  (44.21)  (if  we  take  <J>  (oo)>0).  It  is  impossible  to  cut 
off  the  integration  at  some  x0  when  fy  >  0,  since  this  would  correspond 
to  a  limiting  total  energy  <^0  not  equal  to  zero. 

If  we  take  the  second  possibility,  then  the  total  number  of  electrons 

*0 

has  a  finite  value  and  will  be  proportional  to  f  <|//a  x*1*  dx.  The  electron 

o 

density  and,  hence,  the  electric  field  of  a  neutral  atom  also,  must,  by 
definition,  become  zero  at  the  point  x  =  x0,  since  the  nuclear  charge 
in  it  is  completely  screened  by  electrons.  In  accordance  with  (44.21) 
the  electric  field  will  be  determined  by  the  expression 


But  the  condition  -~  =  0  is  satisfied  where  E  =  0  and  fy  =  0.  There- 

fore, the  point  X  =  XQ  must  correspond  to  tangency  of  the  integral 
curve  with  the  ar-axis,  and  not  to  intersection.  In  the  general  case,  the 
integral  curve  close  to  the  point  of  tangency  has  the  following  form  : 


where  k  is  a  positive  number.  Terms  with  large  values  of  k  are  denoted 
by  the  dots.  Substituting  this  expansion  in  equation  (44.20),  we  have 

O  jL 

(2  +  *)(!+  k)a(x-x0)*  =  -^(x-x0)*+^, 

whence  it  follows  that  k=  —  6,  in  spite  of  the  assumption  that 
k^O.  Hence,  tangency  of  the  integral  curve  with  the  #-axis  is  impos- 
sible at  a  finite  distance  from  the  origin,  and  asymptotic  tangency 

must  be  assumed.  And  the  condition  -—-  =  0  is  automatically  satisfied 

at  infinity. 

The  charge  distribution  in  positive  ions.  In  positive  ions,  the  charge 
of  all  the  electrons  does  not  completely  screen  the  nuclear  charge, 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  489 

because,    at  the  point  where   fy  =  Q,   the   condition  --  ^  =  0   should 

not  be  satisfied.  The  electron  density  distribution  in  an  ion  is  given 
by  the  integral  curves  intersecting  the  #-axis.  The  point  of  inter- 
section determines  the  radius  of  the  ion  x0. 

The  order  for  filling  the  electron  shells.  From  the  potential  distri- 
bution in  an  atom,  we  can  determine  the  values  of  Z  for  which  d- 
aiid  /-electrons  first  appear  in  the  atom. 

We  first  of  all  note  that  the  electron  density  distribution  in  an 
atom  must  be  associated  with  the  angular-momentum  distribution 
of  the  electrons.  As  we  have  already  indicated,  the  limiting  momentum 
of  electrons  is  proportional  to  the  */a  power  of  the  electron  density. 
Therefore,  close  to  the  nucleus,  where  the  electron  density  is  great, 
the  limiting  momentum  is  also  great,  while  at  large  distances  from 
the  nucleus,  the  limiting  momentum  is  small.  But  the  angular  mo- 
mentum of  an  electron  is  determined  by  the  product  of  the  momentum 
by  the  distance  to  the  nucleus,  and  close  to  the  nucleus  it  is  small 
despite  the  large  limiting  momentum.  At  large  distances  from  the 
nucleus  the  angular  momentum  becomes  small  —  this  time  as  a  result 
of  the  smallness  of  the  limiting  momentum.  Hence,  somewhere 
at  medium  distances,  the  angular  momentum  attains  a  maximum 
which  is  larger,  the  greater  the  electron  density.  Therefore,  in  heavy 
atoms  with  a  large  electron  density,  we  find  larger  values  of  angular 
momentum.  In  order  to  find  the  greatest  values  of  angular  momentum 
that  are  possible  for  a  given  Z,  we  shall  proceed  from  the  classical 
expression  for  energy  in  a  central  field  [see  (5.7)] 


- 

-  2m 

We  must  put  <^  =  0  for  the  boundary  energy,  in  accordance  with 
the  basic  assumption  (44.18).  Then,  for  the  radial  component  of 
momentum  we  obtain  the  expression 


We  can  substitute  h2l(l  + 1)  in  place  of  M2.  But  since  formula 
(44.26)  is  written  to  a  quasi-classical  approximation,  a  better  result 
is  obtained  if  we  also  take  the  quasi-classical  approximation  for  M2. 
It  can  be  calculated  using  the  same  methods  as  those  for  determining 
the  energy  eigenvalues  from  formula  (29.18).  To  this  approximation 

M 2  =  h2  (l  +  y)2-  We  notice  that  (l  +  ~)2  differs  from  1(1  +  1)  only  by 

a  quarter. 

We  write  (44.27)  in  the  following  form: 


490  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 


<44-28> 

Lot  us  now  express  the  factor  r  in  the  radicand  in  terms  of  the 
nondimensional  quantity  x  according  to  formula  (44.23).  Then  pr 
will  be 

Pr  -  y  1/1.778^/3^^-  (i  -;-  I)2.  (44.29) 

For  pr  to  be  a  real  quantity,  the  radicand  must  remain  positive 
in  a  certain  interval  of  values  x.  But  since  x  fy  =  0  when  x  =  0  and 
#^=00  this  interval  is  finite  and  contains  the  maximum  point  of  the 
function  x  fy.  The  maximum  is  equal  to  0.488.  Thus,  the  whole  inter- 
val in  which  pr  is  a  real  quantity  is  contracted  into  a  point  for  the 
value  of  Z  at  which 

1 .778  -  0.488  -  £a/3-  ll  -1-  y)2,  (44.30) 

the  curve  y   =1.778  Z*l*  xfy  being  tangential  to  the  constant  straight 

,.  /,    ,      1\2 

line  y=-.  \l-\- -%)  . 

It  follows  that  a  given  value  of  I  in  an  atom  may  occur  when  Z 
satisfies  the  condition 

Z  ^  0.155  (2 M-  I)3.  (44.31) 

According  to  this  equation,  electrons  having  Z  — 2  will  occur  for 
#==19,  while  /-electrons  (£  —  3)  will  occur  when  2  —  53.  There  will 
be  better  agreement  if  we  take  the  coefficient  0.17  instead  of 
0.155. 

Using  the  numerical  form  of  the  function  fy(x),  it  can  be  shown 
that  the  d-  and  /-shells  are  formed  mainly  deep  inside  the  atom, 
as  was  shown  in  Sec.  33. 

The  approximate  integral  formula  for  the  Fermi  distribution.  In 
conclusion,  let  us  consider  a  Fermi  gas  not  at  absolute  zero,  but 
at  a  temperature  other  than  zero  yet  satisfying  the  inequality 
(44.9). 

It  is  convenient  first  to  derive  a  general  formula  for  the  integral 
of  the  Fermi  distribution  that  holds  for  0  <^  e0. 

Let  us  take  the  integral 


(44.32) 


where  y  (e)  is  some  power  function,  for  example  Ve ,  Vg?~,  etc. 
We  integrate  (44.32)  by  parts: 


Sec.  44]  FERMI   DISTRIBUTION  491 

Y(e) 


OO  00 


/  —       Y(S)  / 

^  -  -r-jt  I 

e    «""+!   !        J 


v 

IT  w  -57  %--,,----- 

~e      f-l 


0        0 


Let  us  write  the  second  factor  in  the  integrand  thus: 

T^"      U    =     /._-*          //.I-.      'I     '  <44'34) 

(e    e~"+l)  (/  °":    l)  («~~°"~«    l) 

The  denominator  of  this  expression  is  large  both  for  e-  :;/,  and  for 

p.  -    e  e  -  -  n 

s  >  |ji .  The  exponential  e  e  is  large  in  the  first  case,  while  e  °  is  large 
in  the  second  case.  Therefore,  the  whole  expression  differs  noticeably 
from  zero  only  in  a  narrow  range  of  values  s,  different  from  \L  by 
an  amount  of  the  order  of  0.  Let  us  expand  the  function  y(s)  within 
this  range  and  let  us  terminate  the  expansion  with  the  second  term. 


We  substitute  this  expansion  in  (44.33).  Taking  into  account  that 
the  second  factor  in  the  integrand  is  very  small  for  e^O,  we  can 
perform  the  integration  to  e=  —  oo  without  making  any  perceivable 

v- 

error.  In  addition,  we  shall  neglect  the  quantity  (>,  e  in  the  integrated 
term  of  (44.33).  From  this  we  obtain 


+1 


IJL  —  e          \     * 

r^-f  i) 


(44.36) 


492  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  first  integral  is  calculated  immediately;  it  is 

CO  OO 

1  *  (44.37) 


We  change  the  integration  variable  in  the  second  and  third  integrals, 
assuming 


o      -• 
Then  the  second  integral  reduces  to  the  form: 


because  the  integrand  is  an  odd  function.  Finally,  the  third  integral 
(see  Appendix)  is 


/'  _  (ir_!i)!*  ______  =  Q3 

/    /  5.TL*       \  /  •*-«       \  /  ( 

J    (e    •    +  l)  (e    0    +  l)  J 


Thus,  the  required  integral  appears  in  the  form  of  the  following 
expansion  : 

I  =  YM  -  Y(0)  +  -~6«Y'  ((x)  ={Y'(e)<Zs  +  -j-e«Y'(l*).    (44.40) 

0 

The  zero  term  in  this  expansion  corresponds  to  the  form  that  the 
Fermi  distribution  has  at  absolute  zero;  indeed,  if  /==!  for  O<S<(JL, 

n 

then  /  will  just  equal    |  y'  (e)  dz.  The  first  term,  which  is  linear  in 

o 

6,  drops  out  of  the  expansion.  This  is  clearly  evident  from  the  follow- 
ing. The  electrons  which  escape  the  limiting-energy  sphere  leave 
behind  unoccupied  levels,  so-called  "holes."  To  a  first  approxi- 
mation, these  holes  are  symmetrically  distributed  with  respect  to 
the  occupied  levels  lying  above  the  limiting  energy.  In  Fig.  50  this 
can  be  seen  from  the  fact  that  the  shaded  areas  are  approximately 
equal. 

Finally,  the  quadiatic  term  contributes  the  desired  correction  to 
the  integral  /. 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  493 

The  specific  heat  ol  a  Ferini  gas.  We  shall  now  apply  the  result  (44.40) 
to  calculation  of  specific  heat.  To  do  this  we  write  down  the  expres- 
sions for  the  energy  and  the  total  number  of  particles: 

*-.  <«•«) 


N -**£!-  I -j^-.  (^.42) 

6  -f-  1 


0 

We  apply  formula  (44.40)  and  obtain 


because  the  function  y'(e)  equalled   eJ/«  for   the   first   integral   and 
s1'*  for  the  second  integral. 

Using  these  formulae  let  us  find  the  specific  heat.  From  the  defini- 
tion of  specific  heat  we  have 


We  calculate  the  derivative  ~~-  from  the  second  equation,  differen- 
tiating it  as  an  implicit  function: 


"W" 


We  have  both  times  omitted  differentiating  the  coefficient  of  0, 
because  0  is  regarded  as  small.  Substituting  (44.46)  in  (44.45),  we  write 
the  specific  heat  as 


Finally,  in  place  of  \L  we  must  substitute  the  expression  for  the 
limiting  energy  (44.7).  Then  the  specific  heat  will  be  expressed  in 
terms  of  the  gas  density  and  temperature: 

'^s-       <41-481 


494  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

A 

Thus,  the  specific  heat  per  electron  is  approximately  5 — ,  which, 

^0 

according  to  (44.9),  is  a  very  small  quantity.  For  example,  we  esti- 
mated that  for  sodium  e0^  34,800°,  so  that  — ~0.01  at  room  temper- 

eo 

ature.  The  specific  heat  of  a  Fermi  gas  per  electron  at  room  tempera- 
ture is  0.05.  This  must  be  compared  with  the  specific  heat  for  a  Boltz- 
mann  gas,  equal  to  1.5  from  Sec.  40  (if  0  is  expressed  in  ergs,  the 
specific  heat  C  is  an  abstract  quantity). 

It  is  easy  to  see  why  the  specific  heat  of  a  Fermi  gas  is  considerably 
less  than  the  specific  heat  of  a  Boltzmann  gas :  not  all  the  electrons  in 
a  Fermi  distribution  are  capable  of  being  thermally  excited,  but  only 
those  whose  energy  is  close  to  the  critical  energy.  This  is  why  the 

specific  heat  of  a  Fermi  gas  turns  out  equal  to  a  few  per  cent  of  N. 

3 
A  specific  heat  -'-  N  is  obtained  only  when  all  the  electrons  are  capable 

of  being  thermally  excited. 

Difficulties  in  the  classical  electron  theory  of  metals.  Considerable 
difficulty  was  experienced  in  the  prequaiitum  theory  of  metals  because 
the  electron  gas  in  a  metal  does  not  have  an  experimentally  noticeable 
specific  heat  at  room  temperature.  The  specific  heat  of  a  metal  does  not 
exceed  the  value  3  per  atom  [see  (42.32)].  Yet  if  the  number  of  elec- 
trons present  equalled  the  number  of  atoms,  then,  according  to  classic- 
al statistics,  the  metal  would  have  a  specific  heat  3  -(-3/2  ==9/2  per 
atom,  which  is  never  observed. 

If  we  apply  Fermi  statistics  to  electrons,  then,  as  we  have  just 
seen,  the  difficulty  with  specific  heat  is  removed. 

At  low  temperature  the  specific  heat  of  the  crystal  lattice  of  a  metal 
is  proportional  to  O3  [see  (42.35)].  Therefore,  if  the  temperature  is 
sufficiently  low,  the  electronic  specific  heat  begins  to  predominate 
and  can  be  measured.  Measurements  show  that  at  very  low  tempera- 
tures the  specific  hoat  of  metals  is  indeed  proportional  to  6.  As  can  be 
seen  from  (44.48),  if  we  know  the  specific  heat  we  can  also  determine 
the  number  of  electrons  per  atom.  It  is  a  curious  fact  that  bismuth, 
which  in  many  respects  is  not  a  typical  metal,  has  a  very  small  number 
of  conduction  electrons. 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  equilibrium  concentration  of  electrons  arid  positrons  in  some 
volume  not  containing  charges  at  low  temperature. 

In  place  of  the  conservation  of  the  number  of  particles  we  must  take  into 
account  the  conservation  of  charge  in  the  formation  and  annihilation  of  elec- 
tron-positron pail's.  Denoting  the  number  of  electrons  in  a  given  quantum  state 
by  the  letter  /,  and  the  number  of  positrons  by  the  letter  /',  we  have,  in  place 
of  (39.23),  the  following  supplementary  condition: 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  495 

Determining  /  and  /',  which  give  the  maximum  of  the  function  S  =  hi  P 
with  the  supplementary  condition  indicated,  we  obtain  the  distribution  func- 
tions for  electrons  and  positrons: 

,  =  _  L___        /-  ....  __L_. 

5"  V  '  e  +  P. 


e    °     h  1  e    °     I   1 

where  the  constant  [i  is  the  same.  The  total  number  of  electrons  must  equal 
the  total  number  of  positrons,  i.e., 


CO  .  «) 

/"     Vet/s  /"     \/s"r/e 

I       £ _-  \L  ~      I       e   I    M- 

J   c""°"    .   1       J    e    e"-h  1 

0  0 


This  equation  has  a  solution  only  for  ^  —  0.  Hcnco,  tho  total  number  of  elec- 
trons in  unit  volume  is 


2.- 1*    /'   p-<lp 
(•2-li)3  I       e 

J    c»|-l 


Let  us  calculate  this  integral  when  0  <|  me2.   Wo  can  take  tho  iioiirolati- 
vistic  approximation  for  the  energy  and  represent  tho  distribution  function  in 

e 

tho  form  c     °  . 

Whence  we  have  the  equilibrium  electron  density 


1          ijn<;  \3/     0     \8/a 
2V^8/2  '     ^/    \W"'2/ 


This  quantity  is  equal  to  I/cm3  for  0      —--    ^  8  kov.  The  onorgy  of  tho  electro- 

UTC 

magnetic  field  per  unit  volume  at  the  same  tempera tures  is  0.6  x  1018  ergs, 
while  only  1.6  x  10~6  org  is  released  in  pair  annihilation.  Tho  energy  of  electrons 
and  positrons  will  be  close  to  the  electromagnetic  field  onorgy  only  when  0  is 
of  the  order  of  me2. 

2)  Find  the  limiting  energy  of  a  superdonse  electron  gas,  for  which  the  de- 
pendence of  energy  upon  momentum  is  in  the  main  extremely  relativistic : 
e^cp.  Determine  the  density  at  which  the  gas  may  bo  regarded  as  ultrarola- 
tivistic. 

In  place  of  equation  (44.8),  we  have 

T~  c8  "  2~     V~  ' 

so  that 

3 


The  rest  energy  can  be  neglected  if 


496  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

so  that  the  condition  for  the  density  is  written  in  the  form 

N          1     /wc\3 

~rr  ^  o    «•  (— i— I    ^  1030  electrons/cm3. 
V         ore2  \  h  I 

Since  e0  involves  \—rf\    >  the  inequality  must  bo  great.  The  energy  of  such 
an  ultrarolativistic  gas  is  given  by  the  expression 


V        C 

7C2/12C3      / 


3)  Find  the  number  of  electrons  passing  through  the  surface  of  a  metal 
in  unit  time  if  only  those  electrons  can  cross  tho  surface  for  which  the  velocity 
component  normal  to  the  wall  is  greater  than  vox.  This  quantity  satisfies  the 
inequality 


In  other  words,  the  energy  of  the  emerging  electrons  differs  from  the  limiting 
energy  by  an  amount  considerably  greater  than  0  (thermionic  omission). 

The  number  of  electrons  with  velocity  vx  falling  on  a  square  centimetre  ol 
surface  in  one  second  is 

vxdn(vx)t 

whore  d)i  (vx)  is  the  density  of  electrons  having  a  given  value  of  velocity  projec- 
tion vx.  Like  (44.3),  wo  write  dn  (vx)  in  the  form 


...        _,,J  dvx  dvY  dvz 
dn  (vx)  = —,--,^ 


Hrl 


whore  e—  -    -  (vx-\-  yj-|  r?r).  Tho  surface  of  a  motal  is  crossed  only  by  those  elec- 
2i 

irons  for  which  the  difference  e  —  \i  is  considerably  greater  than  0,  so  that  we 
are  justified  in  passing  from  a  Fermi  distribution  to  a  distribution  of  the  Boltz- 
maim  type,  but  with  the  same  value  of  [x  as  in  the  Fermi  distribution.  In  othei 
words,  wo  take  only  the  "tail"  of  the  Fermi  curve  where  e  —  \L  >  0.  Whorico3 
the  required  electron  flux  is 


2m3      ff 
-----e     I    v 


_    m"*2 

4i../7ji..  />         20       I    /^/ji   ^         26      I   /7^i_  /> 

(2TT/03  ./ 


xdoxe       20     I  dvye       29     /  dvze 


—  oo 


2m3      T    0          nn^OY 


(27t/i)3          m 

If  we  apply  an  electric  field  to  the  metal,  the  maximum  current  that  can  be 
extracted  at  a  given  temperature  (saturation  current)  is  determined  by  this 
formula.  Since  it  relates  to  electrons  in  a  motal,  the  quantity  \i  is  close  to  JJLO 
(i.e.,  to  the  limiting  energy  at  absolute  zero)  and  does  not  depend  upon  temper- 
ature. 


Sec.  44]  FERMI  DISTRIBUTION  497 

It  will  be  noticed  that  if  we  apply  a  very  strong  electric  field  to  the  metal, 
electrons  will  emerge  from  it  overcoming  the  potential  barrier  which  appears 
at  the  boundary  under  such  conditions  (cold  emission).  But  this  requires  very 
large  fields.  Cold  emission  is  analogous  to  the  ionization  of  atoms  in  the  Stark 
effect  (see  Sec.  35). 

4)  Calculate  the  total  energy  of  the  electrons  in  an  atom  in  accordance  with 
the  Thomas-Fermi  statistical  model. 

From  (44.10),  the  kinetic  energy  of  the  electrons  is 

-  (2m)3/*  f  .       .  (2m)'/i 


*  f  .,      .       9  ,         (2m)'/i        f        . 

j  eo3  •  4  *  r  dr  ~  V^V  4  *]  (e?)  a  r  dr> 


0  0 

because  the  limiting  kinetic  energy  of  the  electrons  is  e<p. 

We  substitute  — — —  instead  of  efy  and  go  to  non  dimensional  variables 
(44.23).  Then  for  <£kin  we  obtain 

12  /    2    W>,,7f    tne«  7,.,    dx 


The  potential  energy  is  divided  into  two  parts :  the  interaction  energy  of  the 
electrons  with  the  nucleus,  equal  to 


where  the  electron  density  is  determined  from  (44.18),  and  the  interaction  energy 
between  the  electrons  themselves, 


£h  =   _  , 

r 
0 

The  factor  -^-  takes  into  account  that  each  electron  should  be  counted  once. 
Combining  both  parts  of  the  potential  energy,  we  have 


Substituting  the  quantity  n,  we  arrive  at  the  following  expression  for  the 
potential  energy: 

00 

y7/   me4 


The  integrals  appearing  in  the  energy  expression  are  easily  calculated  using 
equation  (44.24).  Namely, 


498  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

because  fy'  (oo)  -0.  The  second  integral  is  transformed  by  parts: 


o 

(V/2  dx  --    2\/x<^l 

J      vV 


00  0 

CO  CO 


0  0  0 

since  the  integrated  expressions  are  equal  to  zero.  Further, 


0  00 

since  ^  (0)  =-  1.  Hence, 


0  ' 

Substituting  these  integral  values  in  the  expressions  for  <^kin  an(i  <^pot* 
wo  notice  that  <^pot  =  —  2  <^kin>  8O  that  the  total  energy  is  —  ^klu  (this  result 
is  also  obtained  in  the  exact  theory,  and  not  only  in  the  statistical  model). 
The  quantity  <j/  (0)  is  equal  to  —1.589,  whence  we  obtain  the  following 
formula  for  the  total  binding  energy  of  all  the  electrons  in  an  atom : 

^  -  -  0.769  -^-  -  £7/3  =  -  20.94  Z'ltev 
/I 

For  example,  for  uranium  #=  — 8  x  105  ev,  or  — 1.6  me2. 

A  relationship  of  the  form  Z7/$  is  also  easy  to  obtain,  without  calculation, 
in  the  following  way.  Coulomb  forces  fall  off  slowly  with  distance.  Therefore, 
all  the  electrons  interact  with  each  other  in  pairs,  so  that  there  are  about  Z2 
pairs.  From  (44.23),  the  mean  distance  between  the  electrons  decreases  like 
Zlt*.  This  is  what  yields  Z1/*.  We  notice  that  in  the  case  of  nuclei  the  total  bind- 
ing energy  is  proportional  to  the  first  power  of  the  number  of  particles  (within 
wide  limits).  This  points  to  the  short-range  character  of  nuclear  forces:  each 
nucleon  (i.e.,  proton  or  neutron)  does  not  interact  with  all  the  other  nucleons, 
but  only  with  the  "nearest." 

Sec.  45.  Gibbs  Statistics 

In  this  section  we  shall  consider  the  general  statistical  method  of 
Gibbs  applied  to  any  system  consisting  of  a  sufficiently  large  number 
of  particles,  irrespective  of  whether  these  systems  are  solid,  liquid, 
or  gaseous.  It  is  very  difficult  to  treat  this  method  rigorously  by  pro- 
ceeding only  from  the  equations  of  quantum  mechanics ;  it  is  probably 
still  more  difficult  to  do  so  classically,  since  the  concept  of  probability 
does  not  exist  in  classical  mechanics  (to  say  nothing  of  the  fact  that 
the  application  of  classical  mechanics  to  the  motion  of  microparticles 
is  by  no  means  always  justified).  The  derivation  of  the  basic  principles 
of  Gibbs  statistics  is  somewhat  intuitive  in  character  and  is  justified 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  499 

by  the  fact  that  the  statistics  agree  with  a  vast  quantity  of  experi- 
mental facts. 

Of  course,  in  principle,  it  would  be  well  to  substantiate  the  statistical 
method  in  such  a  way  as  to  be  certain  beforehand  of  its  agreement 
with  experiment,  proceeding  from  the  sole  fact  that  quantum  mechan- 
ics agrees  with  experiment ;  but,  as  yet,  we  have  no  such  quantitative 
treatment  at  our  disposal. 

The  quasi- closed  system.  Fundamental  to  statistics  is  the  concept 
of  a  qiiasi-closed  system,  i.e.,  a  system  occurring  in  weak  interaction 
with  the  surrounding  medium.  This  interaction  does  not  essentiaDy 
destroy  the  structure  of  the  system,  but  governs  transitions  between 
those  of  its  states  which  correspond  to  close  separate  energy  levels  of 
the  closed  system.  In  a  system  consisting  of  a  sufficiently  large  number 
of  particles,  an  energy  interval  dtf  (due  to  the  quasi-closed  nature  of 
the  system)  contains  an  exceptionally  large  number  of  separate  energy 
levels  or,  more  exactly,  states  corresponding  to  separate,  exceptionally 
close,  energy  levels  of  an  ideal  closed  system.  It  is  this  that  makes  the 
application  of  statistics  possible. 

Statistical  equilibrium.  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  39,  all  these  separate 
states  are  equally  probable,  in  other  words,  the  system  spends  the 
same  amount  of  time  in  each  of  them.  If  a  study  is  being  made  of  the 
behaviour  of  a  macroscopic  system,  the  essential  thing  to  know  is  not 
its  detailed  state  (characterized  by  a  certain  wave  function),  but  a 
large  group  of  states  to  which  the  state  of  the  system  belongs  most  of 
the  time. 

For  example,  let  us  consider  N  particles  of  an  ideal  monatomic  gas 
that  possess  a  total  kinetic  energy  ^. 

The  separate  states  of  the  gas  are  equiprobable ;  in  other  words, 
the  state,  where  a  single  particle  has  all  the  energy «?  and  the  remaining 

particles  have  zero  kinetic  energy,  is  as  probable  as  that  where  all  the 

a 

particles  have  an  equal  energy  -^  and  a  strictly  identical  direction  of 

momentum  along  a  chosen  axis  (for  the  time  being,  we  ignore  the 
possibility  of  Pauli  exclusion).  But  for  the  greater  part  of  the  time 
the  gas  occurs  in  a  state  which  is  incomparably  closer  to  the  equilibrium 
distribution  of  energy  than  to  the  exceptional  state  where  a  single 
particle  has  obtained  all  the  energy.  Most  probable  is  the  state  which  is 
described  sufficiently  well  by  a  Bose,  or  a  Fermi,  distribution,  depend- 
ing upon  whether  the  gas  particles  have  integral  or  half -integral  spin. 
If  the  gas  particles  are  close  to  the  most  probable  distribution,  for 
constant  interaction  conditions  with  the  external  medium,  then  its 
state  will  all  the  time  be  close  to  the  most  probable  state.  Any  signif- 
icant deviation  from  the  most  probable  state  is  of  vanishingly  small 
probability. 

The  whole  group  of  equally  probable  microscopic  states  in  which  a 
system  exists  for  the  greater  part  of  the  time  is  called  the  statistical 


500  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

equilibrium  state  of  the  system.  It  is  defined  in  far  less  detail  than  in 
the  case  of  the  states  in  quantum  mechanics,  but  fully  enough  for  a 
description  of  the  macroscopic  system  as  a  whole. 

The  concept  of  statistical  equilibrium  can  be  applied  to  any  suffi- 
ciently large  system  of  particles,  irrespective  of  whether  they  interact 
as  weakly  as  the  particles  of  an  ideal  gas,  or  as  strongly  as  the  particles 
in  a  solid  or  liquid  body.  It  will  be  recalled  that  in  proving  the  equi- 
probability  of  microstates  (Sec.  39)  it  was  not  assumed  that  the  system 
consisted  of  noninteracting  particles.  The  greater  the  number  of 
microstates  of  a  system,  the  more  probable  its  state.  Here,  only  those 
microstates  are  taken  into  account  which  are  compatible  with  the  law 
of  conservation  of  energy,  i.e.,  those  belonging  to  the  energy  interval 
dff  of  a  quasi-closed  system. 

Probability  distribution  in  subsystems.  Instead  of  considering  a 
quasi-closed  system  in  an  external  medium,  it  is  more  convenient  to 
proceed  from  a  large  ideally  closed  system  and  divide  it  into  individual 
quasi-closed  subsystems.  The  quasi-closed  nature  of  subsystems  mani- 
fests itself  when  the  surface  layer  of  each  subsystem,  through  which 
interaction  with  the  surrounding  subsystems  is  effected,  produces 
but  a  small  effect  on  the  processes  taking  place  inside  the  volume. 
Interaction  between  subsystems  leads  to  the  establishment  of  statis- 
tical equilibrium  over  the  whole  large  system,  Avhile  equilibrium  in  a 
subsystem  is  established  by  its  internal  interactions. 

Let  us  suppose  that  equilibrium  has  been  established  inside  a  sub- 
system. What  is  the  probability  that  its  energy  is  between  $  and 
<f+d<^?  To  this  interval  there  correspond  (/(<?)  equally  probable 
microstates.  As  we  know,  g  ($)  is  called  the  weight  of  a  state  with  a 
given  energy  <?. 

Since  all  the  separate  microstates  are  equally  probable,  the  proba- 
bility of  P  (ff)  states  is  directly  proportional  to  g  ($)  : 

P(*)  =  P(*)0W,  (45.1) 

where  p  (S  )  is  a  function  which  we  have  got  to  determine  in  the  present 
section. 

Separate  quasi-independent  subsystems  may  be  regarded  as  very 
large  molecules  of  a  Boltzmann  gas.  It  is  natural  to  consider  that 
such  a  "gas"  is  subject  to  Boltzmann  statistics  since  macroscopic 
subsystems  differ  from  one  another.  It  follows  from  this  that  the  dis- 
tribution function  must  be  of  Boltzmann  form: 


This  result  is  preliminary  and  intuitive.  A  more  strict  derivation 
is  given  below  based  on  the  properties  of  the  function  p  ((?),  which 
will  now  be  established. 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  501 

Liouville's  theorem.  We  shall  prove  that  the  function  p  (<$)  is  con- 
stant during  the  interval  of  time  within  which  a  quasi-closed  system 
may  be  regarded  as  closed,  i.e.,  the  remaining  subsystems  do  not 
noticeably  affect  its  state. 

The  weight  of  a  state  g  (£)  is  defined  by  the  number  of  microstates 
whose  energy  is  between  £  and  tf  +  dS*.  Each  of  these  microstates  is 
characterized  by  a  definite  set  of  integrals  of  motion  (for  example,  for 
a  monatomic  ideal  gas,  the  group  of  momenta  of  the  separate  systems). 
Therefore,  g  ($)  is  a  constant  quantity. 

The  probability  P  ($)  is  defined  as  lim  -- --  — ,  when  t  tends  to  in- 
finity (see  Sec.  39).  Here,  t  denotes  the  observation  time  for  the  whole 
closed  system,  which  includes  the  given  quasi-closed  subsystem.  There- 
fore, by  its  very  meaning,  P  ($)  cannot  depend  upon  time,  because 
this  is  a  resultant  average  quantity  for  large  intervals  of  time.  But 
if  P  (ff)  is  a  constant  quantity  and  g  (<f ),  as  a  function  of  the  integrals 
of  motion,  is  also  constant,  then  p  ($)  is  also  independent  of  time  and 
is  an  integral  of  motion.  But  since  all  the  integrals  of  motion  are,  in 
principle,  known  from  mechanics,  p  must  be  their  function.  In  other 
words,  p  cannot  depend  upon  quantities  that  vary  with  time,  and, 
apart  from  £',  depends  only  upon  the  integrals  of  motion.  More  exactly, 
p  remains  constant  over  intervals  of  time  for  which  the  quasi-closed 
subsystem  may  be  regarded  as  closed.  The  statement  concerning  the 
constancy  of  p  (<£)  is  known  as  Liouville's  theorem.  At  the  end  of  this 
section,  a  classical  fornwlation  of  Liouville's  theorem  will  be  given 
that  is  more  vivid  than  a  quantum  formulation. 

The  theorem  of  multiplication  of  probabilities.  Over  a  certain  interval 
of  time,  quasi-closed  subsystems  may  be  regarded  as  independent. 
Then  the  well-known  theorem  of  probability  multiplication  can  be 
applied :  the  probability  that  one  of  the  subsystems  is  in  a  state  A  and 
another  in  a  state  B  is  equal  to  the  product  of  the  probabilities  corre- 
sponding to  states  A  and  B. 

PAB  =  PAPB-  (45.2) 

The  statistical  weights  of  the  states,  gA  and  gB,  are  of  course  multi- 
plied because  they  relate  to  different  subsystems: 

9AB  =  <JA'<JS'  (45.3) 

Thus, 

PA*  =  PA  PB  =  V A*  '  PAB  =  9 A  PA  '  9*  P*- 

It  follows  from  formulae  (45.2)  and  (45.3)  that 

PAB  =  PA-PB'  (45.4) 

In  other  words,  the  probability  density  for  two  quasi-independent 
subsystems  is  a  multiplicative  function,  i.e.,  it  is  obtained  by  multi- 
plying the  separate  p  functions. 


502  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Gibbs  distribution.  The  logarithm  of  probability  density  is  an  addi- 
tive quantity,  i.e.,  it  is  equal  to  the  sum  of  the  logarithms  of  this 
quantity  for  each  subsystem  separately: 

In  p^  =  In  p^  +  In  p,,.  (45.5) 

We  know  from  Liouville's  theorem  that)  In  p  is,  in  addition,  an  in- 
tegral of  motion.  Hence,  In  p  is  an  additive  integral  of  motion. 

In  Sec.  4  of  Part  One  we  listed  the  additive  integrals  of  motion: 
energy,  linear  momentum,  and  angular  momentum.  For  In  p  to  be  an 
additive  integral  of  motion,  it  must  depend  linearly  upon  energy, 
linear  momentum,  and  angular  momentum.  If  we  choose  a  reference 
system  in  which  the  subsystem  as  a  whole  does  not  move,  then  the 
linear  momentum  and  angular  momentum  will  be  equal  to  zero  and 
the  logarithm  of  the  probability  density  will  turn  out  to  be  a  linear 
function  only  of  energy. 

In  other  words,  the  following  relationship  results: 

lnp  =  a«?-ft.  (45.6) 

The  coefficient  a  must  be  the  same  for  all  subsystems  of  the  large 
system  because,  otherwise,  In  p  will  not  have  the  properties  of  an 
additive  function.  If  a  is  the  same  for  two  subsystems,  then  these 
two  subsystems  yield 

In  ?AM  =  In  p^  +  In  p*  -  a  (ffA  +  SB)  +  (bA  +  bB)  = 

=  a#A*  +  1>A,9  (45.7) 

whence  the  additivity  of  In  p  can  be  seen. 

The  probability  of  an  infinitely  large  energy  must  be  infinitely  small 
because  a<0. 

We  shall  write 

(45.8) 

The  meaning  of  the  quantity  6  is  the  same  as  in  the  previous  sections  : 
it  is  the  temperature  multiplied  by  the  Boltzmann  constant.  Indeed, 
for  an  ideal  gas,  a  single  molecule  can  be  regarded  as  a  separate  sub- 
system, and  then  the  Gibbs  distribution  of  the  form 


e        =  e 
becomes  the  Boltzmann  distribution 


e 
In  addition,  we  denote 


(45.9) 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  503 

Finally,  the  required  distribution  function  is 

F~<f 

p(<f)=e  "e~~.  (45.10) 

The  normalization  condition.  The  following  condition  is  imposed 
upon  the  function  p  (<^)  : 


since  JT*  t  (<^)~  t.  This  simply  means  that  the  probability  of  finding  a 

subsystem  in  any  of  the  possible  states  compatible  with  the  conser- 
vation laws  is  equal  to  unity.  With  the  aid  of  the  normalization  con- 
ditions (45.11)  we  can  express  the  quantity  F  as  a  function  of  0. 
It  is  sufficient  for  this  to  substitute  the  Gibbs  distribution  (45.10) 
into  (45.11)  and  perform  summation  over  all  possible  states.  The 

L 

factor  ee,  as  a  constant  quantity,  is  taken  outside  the  summation. 
Hence,  we  have  the  following  equation  for  finding  F: 

"~¥->~'W).  (45.12) 


As  we  know,  the  expression  on  the  right-hand  side  is  called  a  statis- 
tical sum. 

The  mean  energy  of  a  subsystem.  The  mean  values  of  quantities  in 
statistics  are  determined  in  the  following  way.  Let  the  quantity  / 
assume  a  value  ]A  in  any  state  A.  Then,  if  the  probability  of  this  state 
is  equal  to  PA,  the  mean  value  will  be  defined  as 


P*.  (45.13) 

A 

For  example, 


(45.14) 

$ 
because 


Let  us  substitute  the  Gibbs  distribution  in  (45.14).  Then  we  obtain 
an  expression  for  the  mean  energy: 


(45.15) 


604  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Energy  fluctuations.  Generally,  the  state  of  a  subsystem  is,  to  a 
certain  extent,  characterized  by  the  mean  quantity.  For  this  purpose, 
any  statistics,  and  not  only  physical  statistics,  makes  use  of  mean 
quantities:  a  constant  mean  quantity  makes  it  possible  to  estimate 
the  order  of  magnitude  of  a  variable. 

However,  if  a  variable  quantity  exhibits  a  wide  scatter,  the  mean 
does  not  describe  it  sufficiently  well. 

Therefore,  in  addition  to  the  mean  value  of  the  energy  in  a  sub- 
system, it  is  interesting  to  know  its  mean  dispersion.  These  two  mean 
quantities  define  the  state  of  a  subsystem  considerably  better  than 

ff  by  itself.  But  if  we  average  the  quantity 

A  (?=<?- "if,  (45.16) 

the  result  is  identical  zero.  Indeed,  a  second  averaging  of  the  constant 

quantity  ~$  in  no  way  changes  it :  the  mean  of  $  is  again  equal  to  £ . 
Whence 

~l^g  =11 -~~S  =  §.  (45.17) 


It  is  therefore  expedient  to  average  the  quantity 
Since  it  is  essentially  positive,  a  deviation  of  &  from  the  mean  value 
(to  either  side)  makes  a  contribution.  The  desired  mean  quantity  may 
be  written  somewhat  differently: 


<f2~=  (f-2-^,  (45.18) 

where  we  have  taken  advantage  of  the  fact  that  the  mean  of  a  con- 
stant quantity  (f 2  is  equal  to  itself,  and  also  that  the  constant  factor 
can  be  taken  outside  the  averaging  symbol: 


[  (A'if  )2  is  called  the  absolute  fluctuation  of  the  energy.  This  quantity 
characterizes  the  average  extent  to  which  the  energy  deviates  from 

its  mean  value.  The  ratio  of  the  absolute  fluctuation  |  (A«f)2  to  the 
modulus  I  $  |  is  called  the  relative  fluctuation  of  the  energy.  It  is  a 
measure  of  the  relative  fraction  of  the  energy  deviation  from  its  mean 
value. 

Naturally,  the  definitions  of  absolute  and  relative  fluctuation  retain 
their  meaning  also  for  other  quantities  that  describe  a  subsystem,  and 
not  only  for  energy. 

Calculating  the  energy  fluctuation  from  the  Gibbs  distribution.  We 
now  apply  the  Gibbs  distribution  to  the  calculation  of  energy  fluctua- 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  505 

bion  in  a  subsystem.  To  do  this,  we  differentiate,  with  respect  to  0, 
the  following  two  identities  from  which  F  and  $  are  determined: 


This  expresses  the  normalization  condition  (45.11),  and  the  definition 
of  mean  energy  (45.15) 


§  and  y  ($)  are  purely  mechanical  quantities  and  do  not  depend  upon 
the  Gibbs  distribution  parameter  0.  Therefore,  only  F,  $,  and,  of 
course,  0  itse]f  need  be  differentiated  with  respect  to  0.  We  thus 
obtain 


From  (45.19)  we  have 

,    ^^       ^         F-*  ,  F-ff 


Substituting  this  in  (45.20)  we  find 


-zr.          F-6 


__      _ 

o2  e2       o1, 

=  -^ZV*  ~  **)  ^~  0  (*)  -  (45.21) 

3 

As  a  constant,  the  quantity  &  may  be  taken  outside  the  averaging 
sign.  In  accordance  with  (45.18),  this  gives 


(45.22) 
Whence  the  relative  fluctuation  is 


<«••»> 


506  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

But  this  quantity  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square  root  of  the 
number  of  particles  in  the  subsystem,  because  the  energy,  as  an 
addjtive  quantity,  is  proportional  to  the  number  of  particles. 
Let  us  illustrate  this  in  the  case  of  an  ideal  gas.  From  (40.17) 

ff---3NQ.  Hence,  the   relative   fluctuation   is    yyKr»   ^or  example, 

N  ----2.1  x  1019  for  1  cm3  of  a  gas  under  normal  conditions,  so  that  the 
relative  energy  fluctuation  is  a  few  parts  in  1010. 

For  the  greater  part  of  its  time,  the  energy  of  1  cm3  of  gas  differs 
from  its  mean  value  by  this  small  fraction.  Nevertheless,  in  the  later 
statistical  development  it  is  more  convenient  to  regard  the  energy  of 
a  subsystem  as  only  slightly  fluctuating,  and  not  strictly  constant,  as 
in  an  absolutely  closed  system. 

Naturally,  the  relative  fluctuation  for  a  separate  gas  molecule  is 
not  a  small  quantity.  Thus,  from  (40.14)  and  (40.15),  the  fluctuation 
in  the  velocity  of  a  molecule  is 

/  :5  o       8  o 


'"        "'»    =1/14?.  =  0.42. 

80  '       S 

TTM 


Thus,  we  have  shown  that  the  probability  of  a  given  value  of  sub- 
system energy  S  has  a  very  sharp  maximum  close  to  S  ~-S.  This 
maximum  becomes  sharper,  the  larger  the  subsystem. 

Entropy.  Proceeding  from  the  probability  density  for  a  subsystem, 
we  can  form  an  analogous  function  for  a  closed  system.  Utilizing  the 
fact  that  probabilities  are  multiplicative  quantities  we  obtain 

p  ~n  p<  •=  n  p.*  =np-  -ru         <45-24) 


We  now  make  use  of  the  explicit  form  of  the  Gibbs  distribution  (45.10). 
Then  for  the  product  of  all  the  functions  p,-  we  obtain 


HP-       H'      °          e"°      ~  =  e     •      . 

I  i 

But  if  the  large  system  is  closed,  £  <^»  =  &  =  const  and,   hence, 

[~]  pi  —  const  also.  Thus,  the  probability  of  a  state  is  proportional  to 
i 
the  statistical  weight  of  that  state 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  507 

And  all  states  of  the  system  with  the  same  energy  are  equally  prob- 
able :  the  probability  of  0  ($)  states  is  proportional  to  the  number 
3  (S)  (see  Sec.  39). 

As  has  already  been  repeatedly  pointed  out,  ideally  closed  systems 
do  not  exist  in  nature.  Speaking  of  a  "closed"  system,  we  mean  that 
equilibrium  for  its  subsystems  is  established  more  rapidly  than  the 
entire  large  system  attains  equilibrium  with  the  surrounding  medium. 
During  the  time  that  it  takes  for  equilibrium  to  be  established  be- 
tween the  subsystems,  the  additive  integrals  of  the  large  system  do 
not  have  time  to  change  noticeably.  Hence,  we  can  distinguish  be- 
tween the  concept  of  statistical  equilibrium  in  the  whole  system  and  in 
ts  subsystems. 

It  is  obvious  that  statistical  equilibrium  in  the  large  system  is 
maintained  for  a  longer  period  than  the  equilibrium  established  inside 
the  subsystems  alone.  Therefore,  the  probability  of  the  fuller  equilib- 
rium is,  simply  by  definition,  greater  than  the  probability  of  the  less 
full  equilibrium.  From  (45.25),  a  measure  of  the  probability  for  a 
large  system  is  the  statistical  weight  of  its  state.  Therefore,  the  closer 
a  system  is  to  statistical  equilibrium,  the  greater  the  statistical  weight 
of  the  state  of  a  closed  system,  so  that  O  (&)  is  a  measure  of  the  close- 
ness of  a  large  system  to  equilibrium.  In  this  way  we  may  also  regard 
the  quantity  g\  (<$}  of  each  ith  subsystem  as  a  measure  of  its  closeness 
bo  equilibrium  (internally)  for  those  time  intervals  during  which  the 
subsystem  may  be  regarded  as  quasi-closed. 

For  any,  not  too  small,  interval  of  time  we  can  indicate  systems 
which  remain  almost  closed  during  this  interval.  For  them  the  quan- 
tity O  is  a  measure  of  the  equilibrium  of  their  states :  the  larger  O  is, 
the  closer  the  subsystems  of  a  given  "nlosed"  system  are  to  equilibrium. 

It  is  more  convenient,  as  a  measure  of  the  closeness  of  a  system  to 
statistical  equilibrium,  to  use  In  G  instead  of  the  statistical  weight  O 
itself,  since  it  possesses  the  property  of  additivity.  In  G  is  called  the 
zntropy  of  a  system  and  is  denoted  by  the  letter  8: 

S^hiG.  (45.26) 

It  was  shown  in  the  previous  section  that  the  state  of  a  Fermi  gas 
at  absolute  zero  is  defined  uniquely:  G=l.  Hence,  the  entropy  of  a 
Fermi  gas  at  0  —  0  is  In  1—0.  At  absolute  zero,  a  Bose  gas  occurs 
completely  in  a  zero  energy  state  (see  Sec.  43).  Hence,  its  state  is  also 
uniquely  defined,  i.e.,  $==0. 

The  entropy  ol  a  subsystem.  By  definition  entropy  is  an  additive 
quantity,  so  that 

£&.  (45.27) 

i 

It  is  seen  from  this  equation  that  it  is  natural  to  call  In  gi  =  S{  the 
entropy  of  a  subsystem.  In  order  to  calculate  it,  it  is  convenient  to 


508  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

make  use  of  the  Gibbs  distribution  function  for  a  subsystem.  As  was 
shown  in  this  section,  the  energy  of  quasi-closed  subsystem  is  very 
close  to  a  constant  value,  namely,  to  its  average  value  <£*,•,  but  is  not 
strictly  equal  to  it.  Therefore,  the  formula  for  the  entropy  of  a  sub- 
system can  be  successfully  applied  also  to  a  "closed"  system,  whose 
energy  is  strictly  constant.  The  error  here  is  determined  by  the  relative 
fluctuation  of  quantities  in  the  subsystem,  i.e.,  it  is  negligibly 
small. 

The  entropy  of  a  quasi-closed  subsystem,  equal  to  In  gi  (8 ,-),  should 

be  represented  as  In  (/,-  (ffi),  where  £{  is  the  mean  value  of  the  energy 
in  a  given  subsystem  in  the  case  of  "frozen"  interaction  with  other 
subsystems.  In  other  words,  in  finding  this  value  Si  it  is  taken  that 
the  subsystems  do  not  arrive  at  a  more  complete  equilibrium  during 
the  time  considered. 

We  now  take  advantage  of  the  fact  that  the  energy  fluctuations 
are  small,  and  can  replace  the  normalization  condition  (45.11)  by  the 
following  simple  relationship: 

P.  (fi)  9i  (ffl)  =  1  •  (45.28) 


Substituting  gi  (6ai)  into  the  definition  for  the  entropy  of  a  sub- 
system, we  find 


But  since  a  logarithm  is  a  slowly  varying  function,  we  can  replace 
the  logarithm  of  the  mean  value  p,  (Si)  by  the  mean  value  of  the 

logarithm  In  —  ~  : 


Si  =  ln— .  (45.30) 

The  resultant  error  is  the  smaller,  the  larger  the  subsystem,  because 

the  relative  fluctuations  tend  to  zero  as  the  subsystem  increases. 

Substituting  p,-  from   the  Gibbs  distribution  (45.10)  into  (45.30), 

we  find  the  following  expression  for  entropy  (omitting  the  index  i): 


•    )  =  -*^L.  (45.31) 

> 

Comparing  this  with  (45.21),  we  obtain 

*=-To--  <45'32) 

Replacing  F  by  S  —  6  8  in  this  equation,  we  find,  after  differentiation 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  509 

•  0$)  d&     .    ,-Y    .    A  dS 


Here,  differentiation  occurs  with  respect  to  6  under  constant  external 
conditions,  of  which  $  and  F  can  also  be  a  function.  Eliminating  d  0 
we  find 

0--  (45-33) 


Phase  space.  In  conclusion  wo  givo  a  classical  formulation  of  Liouville's 
theorem.  In  classical  mechanics  particle  coordinates  and  momenta  exist  simul- 
taneously. A  system  of  N  particles  is  characterized  by  a  set  of  3  N  coordinates  qi 
and  3  N  momenta  pi.  As  was  shown  in  Sec.  10,  these  variables  may  bo  regarded 
as  independent.  In  order  to  make  the  sot  of  0  N  variables  more  vivid,  wo  shall 
plot  them  on  the  axes  of  a  6  .^-dimensional  coordinate  system.  This  does  not 
introduce  anything  fundamentally  new  but  it  somewhat  simplifies  the  considera- 
tion duo  to  associations  with  two-  and  three  -dimensional  space  which  are  in- 
herent in  geometrical  modes  of  expression.  Such  an  imaginary  6  A^-dimonsional 
space  is  termed  a  phase  space  in  mechanics.  A  single  point  in  phase  space  speci- 
fies the  state  of  a  whole  mechanical  system,  because  the  point  is  defined 
by  all  3  N  coordinates  and  3  N  momenta.  As  time  passes  the  momenta  and  coordi- 
nates vary  in  accordance  with  Hamilton's  equations  (10.18): 

dq,   _  SH   .       dpi  _  _  8H 
~  ~  " 


A  point  describing  the  state  of  a  system  moves  in  phase  space  describing  a 
path  in  phase  space.  As  an  example,  let  us  find  the  phase  trajectory  of  a  system 
with  one  degree  of  freedom  —  the  linear  harmonic  oscillator.  It  is  obtained  from 
the  energy  conservation  law 


_        ,         rt    —  =  JET  =  <£*  —  const. 
2m  2 

This  is  the  equation  of  an  ellipse  with  semiaxos    v   „      

F    mco2 

Classical  Liouville's  theorem.  We  shall  now  consider  a  set  of  systems  with 
the  same  Hamiltonian,  but  with  somewhat  different  initial  conditions.  Those 
systems  will  move  along  different  phase  paths.  Let  us  suppose  that  the  initial 
points  densely  fill  some  volume  element  in  phase  space.  As  each  point  moves, 
this  volume  element  will  be  displaced  similar  to  the  volume  of  a  flowing  liquid. 
We  shall  prove  that  the  magnitude  of  the  volume  remains  unchanged  when  the 
points  move,  so  that  the  motion  resembles  the  flow  of  an  incompressible  liquid. 

A  volume  element  of  phase  space  is  expressed  analogously  to  a  three-dimen- 
sional volume  element: 

dY  s  dpi . .  .dp^dq^ . . 'dq^N •  (45.35) 

We  assume  that  at  the  initial  instant  of  time  there  are  dn  phase  points  in  this 
volume  element,  i.e.,  the  initial  coordinates  and  momenta  of  the  dn  systems 
with  the  same  Hamiltonian  are  contained  between  p1  and  pl  -f-  dplt  p2  and 
p2 -f  dpz,  etc.  The  density  of  the  systems  in  phase  space  is  determined  by  the 
isual  equation 

dn  =  pdT.  (45.36) 

Wo  shall  now  prove  that  the  density  p  does  not  change  in  the  case  of  motion 
of  the  phase  points.  For  simplicity  in  notation,  we  shall  consider  a  two-dimension- 
al space,  though  all  the  reasoning  can  be  directly  extended  to  a  6  JV-dimensional 


510 


STATISTICAL    PHYSICS 


[Part  IV 


space.  We  shall  proceed  from  the  fact  that  the  total  number  of  points  dn  is 
conserved  in  motion.  Therefore,  a  decrease  in  the  number  of  points  inside  some 
fixed  volume  dT  in  unit  time  is  equal  to  their  flux  across  the  surface  bounding 
the  volume.  In  the  case  of  a  two-dimensional  region  d  T  =  dp  dq,  the  flux  across 
the  side  dp  is  equal  to  p  (q)  q  (q)  dp  (see  Fig.  54),  and  the  flux  across  the  opposite 
side  is  p  (q  -f-  dq)  q  (q  f-  dq)  dp.  The  total  flux  across  all  four  sides  is 

P('/   \-dq)q(q   \   dq)dp    -p(q)q(q)dp   |-  p(p  -\-  dp)  p  (p   [-dp)  dq  —  p(p)  p  (p)  dq  - 

r, 


[r,  S\ 

-tq-(f*>  ;    aiT 


where  the  same  expansions  have  been  used  as  in  the  derivation  of  the  Gauss- 
Ostrogradsky  theorem  (Sec.  11).  The  resulting  flux  must  be  equated  to  the 

decrease  of  particles   in  the  volume,     i.e.,   to  the  quantity  —  •-«—  dr.  As    a 

result,  the  same  equation  is  obtained  as  that  of  charge  conservation  in  electro- 
dynamics [see  (12.18)]: 


dp 
ill 


dq 


(P7) 


dp 

- 


dq 


dp 


dp 


(45.37) 


But  from  Hamilton's  equations  (45.2) 


<d)d\    ' 

\ 

^ 

d  

dp 

(bp*bjb 

fM 

\ 

(dp+d)d\ 

Fig.  54 

..  -  - 

~dq  dp        dp  dq 

so  that  equation  (45.5)  may  be  rewritten  as 


dt 


1-3 


dp_ 

dq 


P 


dp        dp 


cp 


dt 


(45.38) 


In  other  words,  the  density  of  phase  points  is  an 
integral  of  motion.  This  is  Liouville's  theorem  in 
classical  formulation. 

Strictly  speaking,  the  classical  density  function  p  defined  here  has  a  meaning 
other  than  the  quantum  probability  density  in  formula  (45.1).  We  shall  now 
show  in  what  way  these  concepts  are  closely  related. 

If  wo  observe  the  same  quasi  -closed  subsystem  very  many  times,  taking 
different  instants  of  time  as  origins,  the  result  will  be  something  in  the  nature 
of  a  set  of  identical  systems  with  differing  initial  conditions.  The  definition  of 
phase  point  density  (45.36)  is  analogous  to  the  definition  of  probability  density 
(45.1),  because,  to  the  classical  approximation,  statistical  weight  is  written  in 
the  following  manner: 


[cf.  (39.32)],  putting  dV  =  dxdydz,  i.e.,  for  an  infinitely  small  volume. 

The  difference  in  the  two  definitions  of  density  is  that  the  probability  of 

•     /Vj«V 

a  state  in  quantum  mechanics  can  be  determined  directly  as  limit  —  -  —  -  . 

t 

while  in  classical  mechanics  we  are  to  understand  by  probability  the  limit 
-  ,  whore  n  (&)  denotes  the  number  of  times  that  a  phase  point  appears  in 

the  region  of  the  state  under  consideration  with  given  energy  ef  ,  and  n  is  the 
total  number  of  observations.  All  the  individual  results  of  observations  are  re- 
garded as  equally  probable.  But  the  proof  of  this  equiprobability  is  the  basic 
difficulty  in  a  nonquantum  version  of  statistics. 


Sec.  45]  GIBBS  STATISTICS  511 

Closed  and  quasi-closed  systems.  We  have  seen  that  two  methods 
of  statistical  construction  are  possible. 

1)  Proceeding  from  an  ideally  closed  system,  in  which  the  energy 
is  strictly  conserved,  the  problem  is  to  determine  the  entropy  as 
hi  0  ($).  The  state  for  'which  the  entropy  is  maximum  is  the  equilib- 

rium state.    The  temperature  is  then  determined  as  0  =  -^  . 

2)  Proceeding  from  a  quasi-closed  system,  introduce  temperature 
from  the  Gibbs  distribution.  Then  entropy  is  calculated  from  the 

formula  In  — 

p 

Both  methods  are,  of  course,  equivalent,  but  it  is  far  more  con- 
venient to  use  the  Gibbs  distribution  in  various  applications. 

Exercises 

1)  Verify  Liouville's  theorem  in  the  case  of  four  points  in  a  gravitational 
field.  At  the  initial  instant  of  time,  the  points  form  a  rectangle  with  sides 
A  z  and  &pz  in  a  two-dimensional  phase  plane. 

Two  points  possessing  larger  initial  momenta  will  fall  faster.  Therefore,  in 
the  motion  of  the  phase  points,  the  rectangle  becomes  a  parallelogram.  Its  height 
will  equal  kpz  and  its  base  A  z,  so  that  its  area  will  remain  equal  to  the  initial 
area  of  the  rectangle.  Conservation  of  phase  volume  is  equivalent  to  conserva- 
tion of  phase  density,  i.e.,  to  Liouville's  theorem. 

2)  Verify  Liouvillo's  theorem  for  the  three  harmonic  oscillators: 


pl  ~  \^2m(^  sin  at-,     pz  =  \/2m  ($  4-  A<f  )  sin  co£; 


,  , 

~  •  —  *  cos  w  *  ;  *T2  r    /  —  ~T     cos  <°  *  ;  - 

2  *  2 


The  area  of  the  triangle  is  expressed  in  terms  of  the  coordinates  of  its  vertices 
in  the  following  way: 

F       l 
^  =  T 

whence,  substituting  coordinates  and  momenta,  the  statement  is  proved. 

3)  Find  how  the  entropy  of  an  ideal  Boltzrnann  gas,  consisting  of  N  separate 
atoms,  depends  upon  energy  and  volume. 

We  proceed  from  the  definitions  (45.39)  and  (45.26) : 


o      , 
6  =  I 


,     f 
In  J 


where  dtp  —  dpxdpydpz  for  a  separate  atom. 

It  is  convenient,  first  of  all,  to  evaluate  the  integral  for  all  states  in  which 
the  energy  of  the  gas  is  less  than  the  given  value  <^.  The  momenta  of  the  atoms 
for  all  states  with  energy  less  than  &  satisfy  the  inequality 

Pit  +  Pyi  +  rfi  +  Pi,  +  Pto  +  pi,  +  -  +  piN  +  PyN  +  PZN  <  2m# 

(the  momenta  of  the  atoms  are  numbered,  corresponding  to  non  quantum 
statistics).  The  3  ^-dimensional  space  region  over  which  the  integration  is  per- 


512  STATISTICAL   PHYSICS  [Part    IV 

formed  is  analogous  to  a  sphere  in  a  three-dimensional  space.  The  coordinates 
of  the  points  inside  the  sphere  satisfy  the  inequality 


where  K  is  the  radius  of  the  sphere.  Tho  radius  of  the  3  ^-dimensional  sphere  is 
.  Therefore,  it  is  clear  from  the  dimensionality  that  the  volume  in  a 


3  ^-dimensional  space  is  proportional  to  (\/2ra<f  )3N  just  as  in  three  dimensions 
it  is  proportional  to  KA  (the  TV-dependent  coefficient  in  this  exercise  will  not  be 
determined).  Tho  number  of  states  between  &  and  <f  -}-d#  is  proportional  to 


Tho  entropy  is  equal  to  the  logarithm  of  tho  statistical  weight,  so  that  it  involves 
the  term  I—  -  --  llln  <f.  Neglecting  unity  compared   with-^—  ,  wo  obtain  a 

\      Z  /  6 

formula  expressing  entropy  in  terms  of  tho  energy  and  volume  of  tho  gas  : 

+  N\nV  +  const. 


Sec.  46.  Thermodynamic  Quantities 

Statistics  and  thermodynamics.  The  results  of  the  previous  section 
may  appear  somewhat  abstract  if  they  are  not  related  to  the  real, 
measurable  properties  of  macroscopic  bodies,  for  example,  specific 
heat,  thermal  expansion,  compressibility  under  pressure,  <^ibc.  In 
turn,  these  properties  are  determined  as  derivatives  of  ener^^  and 
volume  with  respect  to  temperature,  of  volume  with  respect  to  pres- 
sure, and,  in  general,  as  derivatives  of  various  mean  values  and  para- 
meters in  the  Gibbs  distribution  with  respect  to  other  quantities. 

A  quantity  such  as  0  (called  the  distribution  modulus)  is  essentially 
defined  by  the  way  that  it  appears  in  the  Gibbs  distribution,  since, 
in  calculating  mean  values,  0  appears  under  the  summation  or  integral 
sign  as  a  parameter.  Therefore  0  is  one  of  the  quantities  specifying 
the  macroscopic  state  of  a  system,  since  the  mean  values  characteriz- 
ing this  state  are  related  to  it. 

The  properties  of  the  mean  macroscopic  quantities  defining  the 
state  of  a  body  form  the  subject  of  thermodynamics.  These  properties 
are  expressed  in  the  form  of  a  series  of  relationships — differential 
and  integral — which  will  be  obtained  and  interpreted  in  the  present 
section. 

Historically,  thermodynamics  appeared  before  statistics.  It  was 
usual  to  base  it  upon  two  postulates  or  laws  (see  below)  which  were 
supported  by  a  vast  quantity  of  experimental  facts.  The  "laws"  are 
now  no  longer  postulates,  since  they  are  based  on  statistical  methods. 

It  must  not  be  thought  that  with  the  advent  of  statistics  thermo- 
dynamics lost  its  importance.  Thermodynamics  shows  how  real, 


Sec.  46]  THKBMODYNAMIO    QUANTITIES  513 

experimentally  observed  macroscopic  quantities  defining  the  thermal, 
chemical,  etc.,  properties  of  macroscopic  bodies  are  interrelated. 
In  those  cases  where  it  is  impossible  to  calculate  some  quantity 
by  statistical  methods  (due  to  a  lack  of  knowledge  of  the  elementary 
laws  of  force  interaction,  or  because  of  great  mathematical  com- 
plexity), thermodynamics  shows  how  this  quantity  may  be  found, 
directly  or  indirectly,  from  measurement. 

But  statistics  is  not  only  the  basis  of  thermodynamics.  Above 
all,  statistics  indicates  the  way  that  therniodynamic  quantities 
can  be  calculated  from  the  microscopic  structure  of  bodies.  In  addition, 
statistics  makes  it  possible  to  calculate  in  advance  by  how  much 
the  actual  values  differ  from  then*  mean  values.  As  we  have  seen, 
this  type  of  deviation  is  measured  by  the  fluctuations  of  the  quanti- 
ties [see  (45.22)].  Under  certain  conditions,  fluctuations  manifest 
themselves  in  such  a  way  that  they  can  be  recorded  experimentally 
(see  Sec.  48). 

Thermodynamics  is  one  of  the  most  important  chapters  of  statistical 
physics.  Therefore,  we  shall  describe  it  on  the  basis  of  statistics, 
preferring  a  systematic  to  an  historical  account. 

Quantity  of  heat.  A  quasi-closed  macroscopic  system  spends  the 
greater  part  of  its  time  in  a  state  of  statistical  equilibrium.  In  this 
state,  the  actual  values  of  quantities  are  almost  constant,  and  are 
close  to  their  mean  values. 

The  closeness  to  the  equilibrium  in  a  system  is  defined  by  the 
total  entropy  of  all  its  subsystems,  on  the  assumption  that  inter- 
action of  the  system  with  the  surrounding  medium  occurs  considerably 
more  slowly  than  interaction  between  its  subsystems. 

We  shall  now  consider  in  what  way  interaction  between  subsystems 
affects  the  macroscopic  quantities  characterizing  their  states. 

Let  two  bodies  be  brought  into  contact  in  such  a  way  that  the 
external  conditions  and  the  number  of  particles  in  each  of  them 
remain  unchanged.  Then,  in  accordance  with  the  differential  equation 
(45.33),  the  mean  energy  increment  of  each  subsystem  is  proportional 
to  its  entropy  increment: 

d$  =  QdS,  (46.1) 

where,  after  the  stipulations  concerning  the  constancy  of  external 
conditions  and  the  dimensions  of  the  bodies  have  been  made,  the 
partial  differentials  are  replaced  by  total  differentials. 

The  total  energy  increment  for  two  bodies  isolated  from  external 
action  is  equal  to  zero: 

dft  +  d&t^O.  (46.2) 

The  total  entropy  increment  is  positive  or  equal  to  zero,  because, 
as  a  result  of  interaction,  the  bodies  will  arrive  at  statistical  equilib- 

33-0060 


614  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

rium  between  themselves,  and  this  equilibrium  is,  of  course,  more 
complete  than  the  equilibrium  inside  each  of  them.  Hence, 

d^  +  dS2  ^  0.  (46.3) 

Using  (46.1)  and  (46.2),  we  obtain 

0-  {46-4) 


If  6l>02,  then  d$i<Q,  i.e.,  the  first  system  transmits  energy 
to  the  second.  The  transmission  of  energy  is  entirely  due  to  contact 
interaction,  i.e.,  to  the  microscopic  forces  between  molecules.  The 
energy  transferred  in  this  mariner  is  termed  heat,  so  that  heat  is  not 
"a  form  of  energy*'  but  a  mode  of  energy  transmission  (we  shall  ex- 
amine this  question  in  more  detail  further  on). 

In  formula  (46.4),  Ot  and  62  are  parameters  in  the  Gibbs  distri- 
bution for  each  of  the  subsystems  separately.  As  long  as  these  para- 
meters differ,  the  subsystems  cannot  occur  as  a  unit  in  a  state  of 
statistical  equilibrium.  Approximation  to  equilibrium  occurs  as  a 
result  of  heat  transfer,  with  the  heat  always  going  to  the  subsystem 
in  which  the  parameter  0  is  least.  Only  then  are  Oj.  and  02  the  same, 
the  macroscopic  quantities  of  heat  are  no  longer  transferred,  and  the 
energy  of  each  subsystem  exhibits  only  small  fluctuations  in  the 
vicinity  of  its  equilibrium  value.  If  one  of  the  systems  is  an  ideal 
Boltzmann  gas,  then,  as  we  know,  0  is  proportional  to  the  absolute 
temperature,  since  the  Gibbs  distribution  for  a  gas  as  a  whole  leads 
to  a  Boltzmann  distribution  for  the  individual  molecules  with  the 
same  parameter  6.  The  absolute  temperature  of  a  gas  can  be  deter- 
mined from  independent  (not  thermal)  measurements  in  the  Clapeyron 
equation  pV  —  RT.  It  is  natural  to  consider  that  the  quantity  6, 
for  any  system  other  than  an  ideal  gas,  is  also  nothing  other  than 
temperature.  If  a  system  is  in  equilibrium  with  an  ideal  gas,  then 
its  value  0  is  proportional  to  the  absolute  temperature  of  the  gas. 
Thus,  6  is  the  temperature  measured  in  absolute  units  (ergs)  if  the 
ideal  gas  is  taken  as  a  tliermometric  substance.  A  little  later  in  this 
section  a  definition  of  temperature  will  be  given  which  does  not 
depend  upon  the  choice  of  the  tliermometric  substance. 

A  Gibbs  distribution  occurs  for  any  group  of  quasi-independent 
subsystems,  including  those  that  have  not  arrived  at  a  state  of  mutual 
statistical  equilibrium.  Even  though  the  quantity  6  in  this  case, 
too,  is,  by  definition,  the  same  for  all  subsystems  —  which  follows 
from  the  multiplicativity  of  the  distribution  function  p  (£)  [see 
(45.4)-(45.8)]  —  it  must  not  be  regarded  as  equal  to  the  temperature 
of  the  large  system,  which,  generally  speaking,  cannot  be  defined 
for  a  system  not  in  equilibrium.  If  the  subsystems  in  this  case  are 
in  internal  equilibrium,  they  are  characterized  by  their  own  Gibbs 


Sec.  46]  THERMODYNAMIC   QUANTITIES  515 

distribution,  which  cannot  be  represented  by  a  factor  involved  in 
the  Gibbs  distribution  of  the  large  system  because  the  parameters  6 
of  both  distributions  are  different.  Thus,  the  distribution  modulus  6 
of  an  equilibrium  system  is  a  measure  of  its  temperature. 

Taking  the  example -of  temperature,  it  can  be  seen  that  quantities 
which  are  defined  statistically  can  be  identified  with  actually  measured 
thermodynamic  quantities.  Any  statistical  quantity  can  be  regarded 
as  defined  when,  and  only  when,  there  is  given  a  unique  group  of 
operations  (of  measurement  and  calculation)  relating  this  quantity 
to  real  macroscopic  quantities  or  to  the  microscopic  parameters 
of  a  system  which  are  found  (or  can  be  found)  from  experiment. 

Work.  The  Hamiltonian  function  of  a  system  usually  depends 
not  only  upon  generalized  coordinates  and  momenta  that  vary 
according  to  dynamical  laws,  but  also  upon  certain  arbitrarily  chosen 
parameters.  The  intensity  of  the  external  field,  for  example,  may 
be  such  a  parameter.  The  energy  spectrum  of  the  system,  and  hence 
the  mean  energy  $  also,  depends  upon  the  parameters  appearing 
in  the  Hamiltonian. 

These  parameters,  transformed  according  to  a  given  law,  are 
termed  the  external  parameters  of  the  system.  We  denote  them  by 
the  letter  X,  where  X  may  mean  any  quantity  of  this  type.  As  X  varies, 
the  moan  energy  of  the  system  also  varies.  It  is  obvious  that  it  can 
only  vary  at  the  expense  of  some  external  source  of  energy.  Since  X 
is  a  mechanical  and  not  statistical  quantity  (X  is  involved  in  the 
Hamiltonian!),  the  variation  in  X  is  due  to  certain  external  mechanical 
work  performed  on  the  system,  for  example,  a  falling  weight  or  a 
rotating  motor. 

The  mechanical  work  performed  with  changing  X  can  be  represented 
as 

dA=Ad\  (46.5) 

where  it  is  natural  to  call  the  quantity  A  the  generalized  force  (since 
work  is  equal  to  the  product  of  "force"  A  and  "distance"  d  X).  If 
the  entire  energy  change  is  due  only  to  change  in  the  external  para- 
meter X,  then 

d£  =  ^d\.  (46.6) 

In  formula  (46.5),  dA  is  the  work  performed  on  an  external  object 
due  to  a  decrease  in  the  energy  of  the  system,  so  that  dA  =  —  d  $ . 

Comparing  (46.6)  and  (46.5),  we  see  that  the  mean  quantity  -r-~ 
is  equal  to  the  generalized  force  taken  with  opposite  sign: 

A  =  -.  (46.7) 


616  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  most  frequent  external  parameter  of  a  system  is  the  volume 
that  it  occupies.  In  mechanical  terms,  this  may  be  visualized  by 
considering  that  the  potential  energy  of  any  particle  included  in 
the  given  system  is  equal  to  infinity  beyond  the  boundaries  of  the 
volume,  i.e.,  an  infinite  amount  of  work  is  required  even  to  remove 
a  single  particle  from  the  volume.  This  is  how  the  volume  appears 
in  the  Harniltonian  of  a  system. 

We  shall  consider  that  a  system  occupies  the  volume  of  some  cylin- 
der with  a  movable  piston.  The  force  acting  on  unit  area  of  the  piston 
is  called  the  pressure  and  is  denoted  by  the  letter  p.  Then,  if  the 
whole  area  of  the  piston  is  /,  the  force  acting  on  it  is  pf.  When  the 
piston  is  displaced  through  a  distance  do;,  a  quantity  of  work  dA  =  pf 
dx  is  performed  on  it.  But  the  product  fdx  is  equal  to  the  vol- 
ume increment  dV  of  the  system.  Hence,  the  change  in  energy 
for  the  system  is 

dJ=-pdV  (46.8) 

This  type  of  energy  change,  produced  by  a  change  in  the  external 
parameters,  is  called  work  performed  on  a  system. 

It  can  bo  seen  from  formula  (46.8)  that  pressure  is  a  generalized 
force  A  related  to  a  volume  increment  dV. 

The  first  law  of  thermodynamics.  It  has  already  been  pointed  out 
that  energy  can  be  transmitted  from  one  body  to  another  by  purely 
contact  interaction,  without  any  change  in  the  macroscopic  para- 
meters or  in  particle  interchange.  This  type  of  energy  transfer  is 
called  heat  transfer.  It  can  be  seen  from  this  definition  that  the  total 
energy  increment  of  a  bod}'-  is  made  up  of  the  work  dA,  performed 
by  the  body,  and  the  quantity  of  heat  dQ  transmitted  to  the  body: 

d£  =  dQ-dA.  (46.9) 

The  sign  in  front  of  dA  denotes  that,  if  the  body  performs  work, 
its  energy  diminishes. 

The  statement  (46.9)  looks  like  an  identity  from  which  the  quantity 
of  heat  dQ  is  defined.  Indeed,  proceeding  from  a  statistical  inter- 
pretation of  thermodynamics,  we  can  be  sure  beforehand  that  the 
law  of  conservation  of  energy  is  applicable  to  thermal  processes. 
Any  energy  imparted  to  a  system  without  change  of  its  external 
parameters  must  be  transmitted  by  a  contact.  It  is  this  energy  that 
we  have  called  the  quantity  of  heat. 

But  thermodynamics  appeared  before  statistics.  Equation  (46.9), 
interpreted  thermodynamically,  signifies  that  a  quantity  of  heat 
can  be  measured  in  units  of  mechanical  work,  or  that  work  can  be 
measured  in  heat-quantity  units.  In  other  words,  equation  (46.9) 
extends  the  law  of  conservation  of  energy  to  thermal  phenomena. 
Therefore,  the  establishment  of  the  mechanical  equivalent  of  heat 


Sec.  46]  THBBMODYNAMIC    QUANTITIES  517 

by  Mayer,  Joule  and  Helmholtz  signified  a  whole  stage  in  the  devel- 
opment of  physical  knowledge.  Even  though  the  earlier  views  on 
heat,  as  the  disguised  motion  of  molecules,  were  close  to  the  modern 
statistical  interpretation  of  thermal  phenomena,  they  did  not  as 
yet  contain  any  quantitative  relationships.  Therefore,  the  theory 
of  heat  could  develop  only  after  the  relationship  between  thermal 
and  mechanical  quantities  had  been  experimentally  demonstrated. 
After  the  basic  principles  of  thermodynamics  had  already  been 
formulated,  statistics  began  to  develop  as  a  physical,  quantitative, 
theory. 

Equation  (46.9)  can  be  reduced  to  another  form.  For  this  we  must 
note  that  the  energy  of  a  body  is  a  unique  function  of  its  state.  Imagine 
a  certain  periodic  process  in  which  heat  is  delivered  to  a  body  and 
work  is  taken  from  it;  this  occurs  in  heat  engines.  We  integrate 
equation  (46.9)  over  one  work  cycle: 

fd£=jdQ-jdA.  (46.10) 

The  energy  has  the  same  value  at  the  beginning  and  at  the  end  of  the 
cycle,  thus  producing  the  periodicity  condition.  Therefore,  the  total 

energy  change  in  one  cycle   \d$  is  equal  to  zero.  Hence, 


jdQ=jdA.  (46.11) 


The  work  performed  by  a  heat  engine  in  one  cycle  is  equal  to  the  heat 
delivered  to  the  engine  in  that  cycle.  It  is  impossible  to  construct  an 
engine  which  would  work  without  an  external  supply  of  energy  (heat). 
This  statement  is  called  "the  first  law  of  thermodynamics."  An  imagi- 
nary engine,  performing  work  without  an  external  source  of  energy, 
is  called  a  perpetual  motion  engine  of  the  first  kind.  The  inevitable 
lack  of  success  of  all  attempts  to  build  such  an  engine  finally  led  to 
the  negative  postulate  called  the  first  law  of  thermodynamics.  Of 
course,  if  a  statistical  consideration  lies  at  the  basis  of  thermodynam- 
ics, then  the  first  law  emerges  from  the  purely  mechanical  law  of 
conservation  of  energy. 

Neither  work  nor  quantity  of  heat,  taken  separately,  characterize 
the  state  of  the  body  to  which  they  are  transmitted.  In  accordance 
with  equation  (46.11),  a  body  may  perform  any  number  of  work 
cycles,  returning  each  time  to  the  initial  state.  In  doing  so  it  obtains 
any  amount  of  heat  and  performs  any  amount  of  work  equal  to  this 
quantity  of  heat.  Therefore,  it  is  not  correct  to  speak  of  the  "heat 
reserve"  that  a  body  possesses.  It  only  possesses  an  energy  reserve 
which  varies  due  to  heat  transfer  and  performance  of  work.  Work  and 
heat  are  not  "forms  of  energy,"  but  modes — macroscopic  and  micro- 
scopic— of  energy  transfer.  This  can  be  seen  mathematically  from  the 


518  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

fact  that  dA  and  dQ  are  not  total  differentials  of  any  quantities. 
For  example,  dA  =  —  pdV.  But  pressure  is  a  function  not  only  of 

volume,  but  also  of  temperature.  Thus,  for  an  ideal  gas  P  =  -y-,  so 
that  dA=  --  -~dV.  This  equation  cannot  be  integrated  until  we 

know  how  the  temperature  0  varies  with  volume  V  in  the  given 
process.  And  so  the  quantity  of  heat  and  work  characterize  a  process 
performed  by  a  body  and  do  not  characterize  the  state  of  the  body. 
In  certain  cases  the  quantity  of  heat  transferred  in  a  process  can 
be  expressed  very  simply.  If,  for  example,  the  volume  of  a  body  does 
not  vary  (an  isochoric  process)  then  dA=0.  In  general,  dA  =  Q  if 
the  external  parameters  X  are  constant,  the  quantity  of  heat  being 
equal  to  the  change  in  energy  of  the  body: 

dQ  =  dtf,  Q=  A/(F-  const).  (46.12) 

If  the  pressure  does  not  change  (an  isobaric  process),  dA=  —  pdV  = 
=—d(pV).  Then 


dQ  =  dW+  d  (pV)  =  d  (£  +  pV)  . 
The  quantity 

g  +  pV~I,  (46.13) 

like  energy,  is  a  unique  function  of  the  state  of  the  body.  It  is  called 
the  heat  function,  or  the  enthalpy,  of  a  body  and  is  denoted  by  the 
letter  /.  Thus,  the  quantity  of  heat  in  an  isobaric  process  is  equal  to 
the  change  of  enthalpy  of  the  body 

dQ  =  dI,  e  =  A/(p  =  const).  (46.14) 

Reversible  processes,  A  definite  state  of  statistical  equilibrium  corre- 
sponds to  each  value  of  the  external  parameters  X  that  describe  a  sub- 
system of  any  closed  system.  We  can,  for  example,  visualize  a  sub- 
stance under  a  piston  in  a  nonthermally  isolated  cylinder.  In  this 
case  the  substance  and  its  external  medium  should  be  regarded  as  a 
single  system.  The  external  parameter  defining  the  state  of  the  system 
is,  in  this  case,  the  volume  V  occupied  by  the  substance. 

For  every  value  of  the  volume,  a  state  of  statistical  equilibrium  is 
established  between  the  substance  and  its  surrounding  medium  when 
the  temperature  of  the  substance  and  the  medium  is  the  same,  and 
the  total  entropy  has  a  maximum  corresponding  to  a  given  value  of 
the  total  energy  of  the  whole  system  and  to  the  volume  V  under  the 
piston. 

Let  us  now  suppose  that  the  external  parameter  of  the  subsystem 
X  varies  so  slowly  that  for  every  value  of  X  a  total  equilibrium  inside 
the  system  has  time  to  build  up.  In  other  words,  the  state  of  the  system 


Sec.  46]  THERMODYNAMIO   QUANTITIES  519 

depends  only  upon  the  value  of  X  at  the  given  instant.  Maximum  en- 
tropy corresponds  to  this  value  of  X,  so  that  the  system  is  all  the  time 
in  a  state  of  statistical  equilibrium.  But  this  means  that  in  such  a 
process  the  system  never  approaches  a  more  complete  statistical 
equilibrium,  because  it  is  not  brought  out  of  equilibrium.  And  since 
entropy  iy  a  measure  of  the  fullness  of  the  equilibrium,  it  does  not 
vary  with  X. 

The  constancy  of  entropy  for  slow  variations  in  X  can  be  explained 
in  the  following  way.  Entropy  is  the  logarithm  of  the  number  of 
equiprobable  states  of  a  system  in  a  certain  range  of  energy  values 
close  to  $ .  If  X  varies  infinitely  slowly,  the  entire  large  system  may  be 
considered  at  each  instant  as  conservative  so  that  all  its  states  remain 
equally  probable  (a  rapid  variation  may  stimulate  transitions  in  some 
definite  direction  and,  in  this  way,  destroy  the  equiprobable  nature 
of  the  states  that  follows  from  the  principle  of  detailed  equilibrium). 
The  total  number  of  states  is  conserved  for  slow  variations  of  X. 
The  most  probable  range  of  states  having  an  equal  probability  of 
occurrence  is,  in  principle,  determined  (over  all  states,  if  they  are 
known),  purely  by  combinatorial  analysis,  and  cannot  therefore  depend 
upon  the  particular  value  of  X  for  which  the  states  are  taken.  For 
this  reason,  the  number  of  states  in  the  most  probable  region,  and 
hence  the  entropy  also,  are  conserved. 

Thus,  to  each  value  of  X  there  corresponds  a  completely  defined 
state  of  the  system,  quite  independently  of  the  way  in  which  the 
value  of  X  varied  prior  to  this,  provided  it  varied  slowly  enough.  Let 
X  change  first  from  \  to  X2?  and  then  from  X2  to  X^  Then,  when  X 
varies  in  the  reverse  direction,  the  system  goes  through  .the  same 
series  of  values  that  it  passed  through  in  the  direct  variation.  This  is 
why  the  process  is  termed  reversible. 

We  can  imagine  the  following  two  limiting  cases. 

1)  The  subsystem  and  the  surrounding  medium  are  all  the  time  in 
statistical  equilibrium,  so  that  their  temperature  is  the  same.  If  the 
external  medium  is  sufficiently  large,  its  temperature  does  not  change 
at  all,  and,  hence,  the  temperature  of  the  subsystem  also  remains 
unchanged  in  the  process.  Such  a  reversible  process  is  termed  isother- 
mal. In.  an  isothermal  process,  the  total  entropy  of  the  whole  system 
is  conserved  while  the  entropy  of  the  subsystem,  and,  hence,  of  the 
medium  also,  varies. 

2)  Thevparameter  X  varies  so  rapidly  that  an  approach  to  statistical 
equilibrium  between  the  medium  and  subsystem  does  not  have  time 
to  occur,  but  at  the  same  time  the  variation  is  so  slow  that  the  equi- 
librium inside  the  subsystem  is  not  affected.  Such  a  process  would 
occur  if  the  system  were  separated  from  the  medium  by  an  ideal  ther- 
mally insulating  barrier.  Since  the  thermal  transfer  process  is,  in 
general,  rather  slow,  we  can  easily  imagine  such  rapid  variations  in 


520  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

the  parameter  X  that  there  is  not  time  enough  for  the  heat  to  be  trans- 
ferred. In  this  process,  the  entropy  of  the  subsystem  and  medium  is 
conserved  separately.  For  this  reason,  it  is  termed  isentropic  (or 
adiabatic). 

Later  we  shall  also  consider  some  irreversible  processes. 

The  second  law  of  thermodynamics.  Let  us  find  an  expression  for 
the  quantity  of  heat  received  by  a  system  in  a  reversible  process.  As 
usual,  we  shall  consider  the  given  system  to  be  a  subsystem  of  some 
large  closed  system.  The  state  of  such  a  quasi-equilibrium  subsystem 
is  corrvpletely  determined  at  each  instant  by  its  entropy  and  external 
parameters.  According  to  (46.1)  and  (46.6),  the  energy  increment, 
for  a  constant  number  of  particles,  is  expressed  in  terms  of  the  entropy 
increment  in  the  following  way: 

dl,  (46.15) 


which,  from  (46.6)  and  (46.7),  can  be  also  written  as 

d1  =  QdS-  Ad\  =  QdS-dA,  (46.16) 

whence  it  follows  that  __ 

df  +  dA.  (46.17) 


But  the  right-hand  side  of  the  last  equation  is  nothing  other  than 
the  quantity  of  heat  d  Q  received  by  the  system.  Hence,  in  a  reversible 
process 

(46.18) 


This  is  one  of  the  most  important  equations  in  thermodynamics.  It 
determines  the  entropy  increment  of  a  system  in  terms  of  the  quantity 
of  heat  directly  measured  from  experiment.  It  is  significant  that  the 
quantity  of  heat  obtained  by  a  system  in  a  process  depends  upon  the 
development  of  the  process,  while  the  entropy  increment  is  determined 
only  by  the  initial  and  final  states  of  the  system.  The  quotient  ob- 
tained from  the  division  of  an  infinitely  small  quantity  of  heat  (received 
by  the  subsystem  in  a  reversible  process)  by  the  temperature  is  the 
total  differential 

*Q  =  dS.  (46.19) 

o 

If  an  irreversible  process  occurs  inside  the  system,  equation  (46.19) 
may  not  hold.  Indeed,  let  the  system  consist  of  two  subsystems  at 
different  temperatures.  In  the  process  of  temperature  equalization, 
such  a  system  approaches  statistical  equilibrium  and  its  entropy 
increases.  But  no  heat  reaches  the  system  from  outside,  so  that  dQ 
for  the  whole  system  is  equal  to  zero  and  d$>0. 

Let  us  consider  another  example  of  an  irreversible  process.  Let  a 
gas  expand  into  a  vacuum.  The  phase  volume  AT  [see  (45.35),  (45.39)] 


Sec.  46]  THEBMODYNAMIC    QUANTITIES  521 

naturally  increases,  since  the  geometrical  volume  increases.  But  this 
means  that  the  entropy  also  increases.  When  expanding  into  a  vacuum, 
the  gas  does  not  perform  work  (since  there  are  no  opposition  forces) 
and  does  not  receive  heat.  In  other  words,  it  may  he  regarded  as  a 
closed  system  whose  entropy  increases  as  statistical  equilibrium  is 
approached  (when  a  gas  expands  isothermally  in  a  cylinder  situated 
in  an  external  medium,  the  entropy  of  the  gas  also  increases,  but  the 
entropy  of  the  medium  decreases  to  the  same  extent).  Consequently, 
the  entropy  increment  in  the  case  of  an  irreversible  expansion  of  a  gas 
into  a  vacuum  is  positive,  and  the  quantity  of  heat  transferred  is 
equal  to  zero. 

The  two  foregoing  examples  show  that  if  an  irreversible  process 
occurs  inside  a  system,  then 

^-<dS,  (46.20) 

since  entropy  increases  without  any  heat  transfer. 

But  if  the  given  system  irreversibly  exchanges  heat  with  other 
systems,  and  no  irreversible  processes  occur  inside  it,  then  equation 
(46.19)  is  applicable. 

Let  us  now  determine,  with  the  aid  of  equation  (46.18),  the  amount 
of  work  that  can  be  performed  by  a  heat  engine.  By  this  term  we 
understand  a  machine  which  periodically  obtains  heat  from  some  ther- 
mal reservoir  and,  at  the  expense  of  this  heat,  performs  work.  Accord- 
ing to  the  first  law  of  thermodynamics,  the  total  work  performed  by 
the  engine  in  a  single  work  cycle  is  equal  to  the  quantity  of  heat 
received  in  that  cycle  (46.10).  If  the  engine  operates  reversibly,  then 
the  quantity  of  heat  is  expressed  in  accordance  with  (46.18).  Therefore 

(46.21) 

It  follows  from  this  that  if  the  temperature  of  the  working  substance 
remains  constant  over  one  working  cycle,  the  work  is  identically  zero  : 


jdA  = 


(46.22) 


since  the  initial  state  in  a  periodic  process  coincides  with  the  final 
state,  and  the  entropy  is  a  single-valued  function  of  the  state,  so  that 

jdS  =  Q.  dQ<QdS  in  irreversible  processes,  so  that  jdA^Q  if  the 

temperature  is  constant.  By  keeping  the  temperature  constant,  we 
can  obtain  a  periodic  process  only  at  the  expense  of  external  work. 
It  follows  from  equation  (46.22)  that  a  heat  engine  cannot  work 
using  heat  received  from  the  surrounding  medium,  because  by  def- 
inition the  medium  is  at  a  constant  temperature.  The  statement 
formulated  here  is  known  as  the  second  law  of  thermodynamics. 


522  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

An  imaginary  engine  operating  from  heat  obtained  from  the  sur- 
rounding medium  is  called  a  perpetual  motion  engine  of  the  second  kind. 
In  an  axiomatic  account  of  thermodynamics,  the  impossibility  of 
constructing  such  an  engine  is  postulated  (naturally  on  the  basis  of 
numerous  failures  to  make  a  perpetual  motion  engine  of  the  second 
kind),  and  the  subsequent  proofs  are  indirect:  first  it  is  assumed  that 
the  statement  to  be  proved  is  false,  and  then  the  feasibility  of  such  a 
perpetual  motion  engine  is  derived  therefrom  (see  exercise  5). 

A  perpetual  motion  engine  must  not  be  confused  with  the  so- 
called  free  engine,  like  the  wind  engine,  which  gets  its  energy  from  the 
sun  heating  up  the  earth. 

Efficiency.  For  a  heat  engine  to  work,  it  is  necessary  to  have  the 
working  cycle  at  two  temperatures  at  least.  The  higher  temperature 
Oj  is  usually  called  the  source  temperature,  while  the  lower  tempera- 
ture 02  is  the  sink  temperature.  The  work  in  one  cycle  is  equal  to 


dA  =  QidS  -h  02d#,  (46.23) 


J 

a  b 

where  the  limit  a  refers  to  the  initial  and  final  state,  and  the  limit  b 

b  a 

refers  to  the  intermediate  state.  But    )d!$  =  —  \dS  so  that  the  work 

a  b 

in  one  cycle  is 

b 

JdA  =  (0!  -  02)  jdS.  (46.24) 

a 

b 

The  total  quantity  of  heat  given  up  by  the  source  is    \dQ  =  Ql  \dS. 

a 

The  efficiency  of  an  engine  is  the  term  used  for  the  ratio  of  the  work 
obtained  from  it  to  the  quantity  of  heat  taken  from  the  source,  since 
the  principal  losses  are  associated  with  obtaining  this  heat.  From 
(46.24),  the  efficiency  of  a  reversible  engine  (denoted  by  E)  is 


This  equation  shows  that  the  efficiency  of  a  reversible  engine  depends 
only  upon  the  temperatures  of  the  source  and  sink,  and  nothing  else. 
Actually,  02  is  either  the  temperature  of  the  surrounding  medium  or 
a  somewhat  higher  temperature.  To  increase  E  we  must  increase  0^ 
Equation  (46.25)  shows  that  the  efficiency  of  a  reversible  engine 
can  be  taken  to  determine  the  absolute  thermodynamic  scale  of 
temperature,  independent  of  a  thermometric  substance.  This  scale 
coincides  with  the  gas  thermometer  scale. 


SeC.  46]  THEBMODYNAMIO   QUANTITIES  523 

The  efficiency  of  an  irreversible  engine  is  less  than  the  efficiency  of  a 
reversible  engine  operating  at  the  same  temperature  difference  and  at  a 
given  source  temperature.  Indeed,  when  (46.20)  is  taken  into  account, 

equation  (46.24)  is  replaced  by  the  inequality  I  dA^  (0L  —  02)  (8a  —  Sb). 

This  is  why,  given  the  same  quantity  of  heat  taken  from  the 
source,  the  work  done  by  an  irreversible  engine  is  less  than  that  of  a 
reversible  engine. 

In  axiomatic  thermodynamics  this  statement  is  proved  indirectly 
(see  exercise  5).  The  efficiency  of  an  irreversible  engine  is  less  because 
part  of  the  heat  obtained  from  the  source  is  not  spent  in  useful  work, 
but  in  overcoming  frictional  forces  or  it  is  dissipated  into  the  ambient 
medium  in  the  engine  itself,  through  the  walls  of  the  working  cylinder, 
for  example. 

It  should  be  noted  that  an  ideally  reversible  engine  would  have  to 
operate  infinitely  slowly,  for  otherwise  finite  deviations  from  statistical 
equilibrium  would  arise  in  it.  Approximation  to  statistical  equilibrium 
is  always  an  irreversible  process. 

Thermodynamic  identities  for  energy  and  enthalpy.  Proceeding  from 
the  general  equation  (46.9),  we  can  write  down  a  general  equation 
for  the  differential  of  the  mean  energy  of  a  system  in  the  case  of  a 
constant  number  of  particles,  if  we  take  the  volume  as  an  external 
parameter 

-pdV.  (46.26) 


dS  in  this  formula  denotes  the  entropy  increment,  which  is  due  to  the 
reversible  process  in  the  system  and  the  interaction  with  the  surround- 
ing medium.  The  state  of  a  homogeneous  system  with  a  constant 
number  of  particles  is  defined  by  two  quantities  :  volume  and  entropy. 
This  can  be  seen  from  the  number  of  independent  parameters  appearing 
in  the  Gibbs  distribution  :  8  and  X  =  V  can  be  taken  instead  of  0  and 
X  =  V  ;  the  energy  of  such  a  system  is  a  single-valued  function  of  entropy 
and  volume.  Let  us  take  the  total  differential  of  the  function  $  (S,  V)  : 

v>  <46-27> 

where  the  index  of  the  derivative  denotes  which  quantity  is  kept 
constant  during  differentiation.  Comparing  (46.26)  and  (46.27),  we 
have 


Differentiating  0  with  respect  to  F,  and  p  with  respect  to  S,  we  obtain 
an  equation  between  the  cross  derivatives: 


_ 
8Vls          \9S 


524  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  enthalpy  or  heat  function  /  is  connected  with  the  energy  by  the 
relationship  _ 

g  =  I-PV 

[see  (46.13)].  Whence  an  expression  follows  for  the  total  differential 

of  enthalpy 

(46.30) 


which  gives  a  series  of  differential  relations 


Equations  (46.26)  and  (46.30)  are  known  as  thermodyuamic  identities. 
These  identities  permit  expressing  certain  thermodynamic  quantities 
in  terms  of  others. 

Free  energy.  If  an  irreversible  process  occurs  in  a  system,  then, 
from  (46.20),  dQ^QdS.  Substituting  this  inequality  into  the  equation 
of  the  first  law  (46.9),  we  have 

df*£QdS-dA.  (46.32) 

Thus,  the  work  performed  by  the  system  will  always  satisfy  the  ine- 
quality __ 

(46.33) 


Let  the  process  occur  at  a  constant  temperature.  Then  (46.33)  can 
be  written  as  a  relationship  between  total  differentials 


(46.34a) 

If  the  system  performs  positive  work,  dA>0.  Reversing  the  sign  of 
the  inequality,  we  get 

dA^-d(f-Q8).  (46.34  b) 

The  quantity  ___ 

£^QS  =  F  (46.35) 

[cf.  (45.31)]  'appears  in  the  Gibbs  distribution  (45.10);  it  is  called  the 
free  energy  of  the  system. 

It  follows  from  the  inequality  (46.34  b)  that  the  greatest  amount 
of  work  that  can  be  performed  by  a  system  at  constant  temperature 
is  equal  to  the  change  in  F,  taken  with  opposite  sign: 


Thus  the  work  is  equal  to  its  maximum  value  in  a  reversible  process. 

The  inequality  (46.34a)  has  a  somewhat  different  meaning:  it  deter- 
mines the  least  amount  of  work  which  must  be  performed  on  the  system 
in  order  to  produce  the  given  change  of  state  in  it: 


Sec.  46]  THEBMODYNAMIC   QUANTITIES  525 

Anta^Fi-Ft.  (46.37) 

The  entropy  of  the  system  and  the  surrounding  medium  (taken 
together)  is  conserved  in  these  processes,  and  the  inequality  (46.32) 
becomes  an  equality. 

Consider  the  following  example.  Let  an  ideal  gas  expand  into  a 
vacuum.  No  work  is  performed  so  that  energy  is  conserved.  But  the 
energy  of  an  ideal  gas  depends  only  upon  its  temperature  (see  Sec.  40), 
and  not  upon  volume.  Therefore,  the  temperature  does  not  change 
during  expansion  into  a  vacuum.  As  we  have  seen,  the  entropy  of 
the  gas  increases.  Then  the  minimum  work  required  to  return  the  gas 
to  its  original  volume  at  the  same  temperature  is  equal  to  the  change 
in  its  free  energy  during  expansion.  The  entropy  of  the  gas  will  de- 
crease in  such  a  reversible  compression,  but  on  the  other  hand  the 
entropy  of  the  surrounding  medium  will  increase  to  the  same  extent. 

It  is  easy  to  obtain  a  thermodynamic  identity  for  free  energy. 
Differentiating  the  relationship  between  total  and  free  energy,  and 
substituting  the  identity  (46.26),  we  obtain 

dF  =  -  SdQ  -  pdV,  (46.38) 

whence  it  is  easy  to  find  an  expression  for  the  entropy  and  pressure, 
and  also  an  equation  between  the  cross  derivatives 

*--(£).-  s- -(£),-  (£),-(»•).•  «"•» 

The  relations  (46.39)  are  convenient  in  that  the  independent  variables 
are  volume  and  temperature,  which  can  be  directly  measured  experi- 
mentally. Yet  the  thermodynamic  identity  for  energy  (46.26)  involves 
entropy  as  an  independent  variable.  But  the  entropy  itself  must  be 
calculated,  for  example,  by  integration  of  (46.19). 

From  (45.12),  the  free  energy  F  is  expressed  in  terms  of  a  statistical 
sum 

_£_ 

.F=-01nJTe    e.  (46.40) 

The  right-hand  side  of  this  equation  is  expressed  in  terms  of  the 
temperature  0  and  the  external  parameters  involved  in  the  character- 
istic values  of  S.  But  0  and  X  are  those  very  independent  variables 
which  are  chosen  in  the  identity  (46.38).  Therefore,  for  a  determination 
of  all  the  thermodynamic  quantities  it  is  sufficient  to  calculate  the 

_£ 

statistical  sumj^e    e  .  The  actual  calculation  of  this  sum  for  an 

arbitrary  system  entails  enormous  mathematical  difficulties.  Actually, 
it  is  calculated  only  for  ideal  gases  and  crystals,  and  also  for  systems 
which  deviate  but  little  from  ideal.  It  should  be  noted  that  even  if  it 
were  possible  to  evaluate  the  statistical  sum  for  some  actual  substance, 


526  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

say  liquid  water,  the  thermodynamic  laws  obtained  with  such  very 
great  difficulty  would  apply  only  to  water  and  not  to  liquids  generally. 
But  the  properties  of  ideal  gases  and  crystals  follow  from  statistics 
in  a  very  general  way. 

Thermodynamic  potential.  Let  us  now  determine  the  maximum 
work  that  can  be  performed  by  a  system  at  constant  temperature  and 
pressure,  equal  to  the  temperature  and  pressure  of  the  external  me- 
dium. We  note  that  in  a  homogeneous  system  with  a  constant  number 
of  particles,  where  there  are  no  phase  or  chemical  transitions,  the 
state  is  completely  defined  by  the  temperature  and  pressure,  since 
the  thermodynamic  identities  for  such  systems  involve  two  independent 
variables.  In  this  case  the  specification  of  two  quantities  determines 
all  the  rest.  But  if  a  system  consists  of  two  phases  of  the  same  sub- 
stance, for  example,  a  liquid  and  its  vapour,  then  the  relationship 
between  the  fractions  of  liquid  and  gaseous  substances  may  be  quite 
arbitrary  for  a  given  temperature  and  pressure. 

Work  is  performed  in  increasing  the  volume  of  a  system.  We  can 
imagine,  for  example,  a  system  in  a  cylinder  under  a  piston,  and  the 
piston  rod  connected  with  some  object  capable  of  changing  only 
its  mechanical  energy:  by  means  of  a  flywheel  or  load.  In  addition, 
on  expansion  of  the  system  work  is  done  on  the  external  medium. 
If  we  call  the  work  on  the  object  A,  then  the  total  work  performed 
is  equal  to  —  A  —  p  A  F=  —  (A+ApV),  Here,  p  is  the  pressure 
in  the  external  medium,  which  pressure  in  the  process  considered 
is  equal  to  the  pressure  in  the  system.  Since,  by  convention,  the 
temperature  of  the  system  docs  not  change,  we  have,  from  (46.33), 

-  (A  +A^J7)>A[<f-6£) 
or 

-  A  >  A  (?-  0,9  +  pV)  .  (46.41) 


The  quantity  S—  QS  +  pV  is,  obviously,  a  function  of  the  state  of 

the  system.  It  is  called  the  thermodynamic  potential  and  is  denoted 
by  the  letter  <I>  : 

O-^-OS  +  pF.  (46.42) 

Thus,  the  maximum  work  which  a  system  can  perform  at  constant 
temperature  and  pressure  is  equal  to  the  change  in  its  thermodynamic 
potential  (with  reversed  sign) 

^inax  =  $1~-02.  (46.43) 

This  work  is  performed  in  a  reversible  process. 

When  equilibrium  is  established  in  a  system,  work  cannot  be 
performed.  Then  O  attains  a  minimum,  because,  according  to  (46.43), 
the  work  is  performed  at  the  expense  of  a  decrease  in  O.  When 


Sec.  46]  THERMODYNAMIC   QUANTITIES  527 

^max  =  0,  <E>  cannot  decrease  further.  It  has  already  been  pointed 
out  that  the  process  can  occur  at  constant  temperature  and  pressure 
with  a  phase  transition  or  chemical  transformation;  hence,  the 
equilibrium  condition  here  is  that  O  should  be  minimum. 

Let  us  now  find  the  thermodynamic  relationships  for   <I>.  From 
(46.42) 

O=.F+pF.  (46.44) 

Differentiating  this  equation  and  substituting  dF  from  (46.38),  we 
obtain 

d^  =  dF+pdV  +  Vdp^  —  8db  —  pdV+pdV  +  Vdp  = 

=  -SdQ  +  Vdy.  (40.45) 

Whence  it  follows,  in  familiar  fashion,  that 


The  thermodynamic  potential  depends  only  upon  quantities 
that  characterize  the  state  of  a  body:  its  temperature  and  pressure. 
At  the  same  time  O  is,  of  course,  an  additive  quantity:  if  two  equal 
volumes  of  the  same  substance  are  joined  at  the  same  temperature 
and  pressure,  the  common  thermodynamic  potential  will  be  twice 
as  great  as  it  was  for  each  part  separately.  Therefore,  we  can  write 

O  =  JV>(p,6).  (46.47) 

Here,  [L  is  the  thermodynamic  potential  related  to  a  single  molecule 
of  the  substance,  (x  is  also  called  the  chemical  potential.  We  shall 
show  later  on  that  for  ideal  gases  it  is  identical  to  the  parameter  (ji 
in  the  distribution  function  (see  Sec.  39).  It  is  obvious  that 


If  the  system  consists  of  several  types  of  molecule,  for  example, 
a  solution  of  one  substance  in  another  or  a  mixture  of  gases,  then 
the  state  is  determined  not  only  by  the  temperature  and  pressure, 
but  also  by  the  concentrations  of  the  substances.  The  concentration 
of  the  fth  substance  in  a  mixture  is 


The  chemical  potential  of  the  ith  substance  in  a  mixture  is  natur- 
ally expressed  by  analogy  with  (46.48): 


528  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

where  [/,/  depends  upon  p,  0  and  all   the  concentrations  :  c1?  c2,  •  •  •  , 
d,  ---- 

Regarding  N{  as  variables,  we  can  write  the  total  differential 
of  O  in  the  following  way: 

d$  =  -  SdQ  +  Vdp  +  £v*dNi-  (46.51) 

i 

This  equation  generalizes  (46.45)  for  the  case  of  a  variable  number 
of  particles. 

Since  the  transition  from  §  to  F  and  <J>  does  not  involve  the  number 
of  particles  NI,  we  can  similarly  generalize  the  differential  relations 
(46.26)  and  (46.38): 


(46.52) 

dF  ==-  SdQ  -  <pdV  +  £  \LidNi.  (46.53) 

i 

For  a  constant  volume  and  for  one  type  of  molecule,  (46.52)  reduces 
to  the  form 

(46.54) 


But  this  equation  coincides  with  (30.18),  whence  it  can  be  seen  that 
the  quantity  S  introduced  in  Sec.  39  is  the  entropy  of  a  gas  and  JJL 
is  its  chemical  potential. 

Entropy  in  classical  and  quantum  statistics.  Let  us  compare  the 
definition  of  entropy  based  on  classical  and  on  quantum  laws  of 
motion.  In  the  latter  case,  entropy  is  defined  as  the  logarithm  of 
the  number  of  states  of  a  system  for  a  certain  energy  value.  When 
passing  to  a  quasi-classical  approximation,  the  number  of  states 
of  the  system  is  equal  to  the  phase  volume  A  F  it  occupies  divided 
by  (2  TC  h)n,  where  n  is  the  number  of  degrees  of  freedom  [see  (45.39)]. 
The  logarithm  of  this  ratio  represents  the  entropy  in  the  corresponding 
approximation.  But  statistics  appeared  before  quantum  mechanics. 
Therefore,  entropy  was  originally  defined  in  statistics  as  the  logarithm 
of  the  denominate  number  A  F.  In  this  definition,  entropy  depends 
upon  the  choice  of  units:  if,  for  example,  the  unit  of  mass  is  changed 
by  a  factor  two,  then  n  In  2  must  be  added  to  the  entropy.  But  since 
the  units  of  measurement  are  arbitrary,  it  follows  from  this  that  in 
classical  statistics  entropy  was  defined  only  within  the  accuracy 
of  an  arbitrary  additive  constant.  Only  the  change  of  entropy  had 
strict  meaning. 

In  quantum  statistics,  entropy  is  defined  as  the  logarithm  of  an 
abstract  number,  and  therefore  does  not  depend  upon  the  choice  of 
units  of  measurement. 


Sec.  46]  THEBMODYNAMIC   QUANTITIES  529 

The  temperature  of  a  system  is  equal  to  absolute  zero  when  the 
system  is  in  the  ground  state,  i.e.,  when  it  has  the  least  possible  energy. 
This  state  has  a  weight  equal  to  unity,  so  that  the  entropy,  or  log- 
arithm of  the  weight,  becomes  zero  at  the  absolute  zero  of  temperature. 
This  statement  is  known  as  Nernst's  theorem,  which  is  sometimes 
called  the  third  law  of  thermodynamics.  Certain  consequences  of 
Nernst's  theorem  will  be  considered  below  (see  exercise  6). 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  ratio  between  the  specific  heats  at  constant  volume  and  at 
constant  pressure. 

With  the  aid  of  (46.18),  wo  find,  from  the  definition  of  specific  heat, 


The  derivatives  can  be  rewritten  in  the  folio  wing  way: 

\ 

0  IS 


idp\ 

\dSlQ 


from  the  formulae  for  the  derivatives  of  implicit  functions.  The  partial  deriv- 
atives with  the  same  subscript  may  bo  cancelled  like  fractions,  since  the 
differentials  in  them  have  the  same  sense.  This  gives 


c, 


p 


Gy       ldp\         ldV\    ' 
\dV/Q       \dpls 

so  that  specific  heats  are  related  in  the  way  that  isothermal  compressibility 
relates  to   isentropic   compressibility.   It  is  sufficient  to   measure   only  throe 

of  the  four  quantities  Cp,  Cy,  (-5-—)  ,    (-^ — 1  . 

\  &P  /6      \  vp  JS 

(O  jn  v 
~^W\    • 
dV  /o 

We   substitute   &  =F-\-Q8;    and,    according    to    (46.39),    transform   the 
derivatives 


If  the  pressure  is  known  as  a  function  of  temperature  and  volume,  the  energy 
can  be  calculated  only  to  the  accuracy  of  an  arbitrary  temperature  function 


Therefore,  it  must  always  be  remembered  that  a  determination  of  the  relation- 
ship p  —  p  ( F,  0)  does  not  yield  complete  information  about  the  therrno- 
dynamic  properties  of  a  substance.  In  addition,  any  pressure  term  depending 


34  -  0060 


530  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

linearly  upon  temperature  will  not  affect  the  energy,  since  it  is  eliminated 

2\fQ 

from  the  equation  obtained.  For  example,  in  all  ideal  gases  p  =  —y~ ,  and  the 

energy  depends  upon  the  temperature  in  a  rather  complicated  way  if  discrete 
quantum  levels  must  be  taken  in  the  statistical  summations. 


4)  Find  the  difference  between  the  specific  heats  at  constant  volume  and 
at  constant  pressure. 

The  quantity  of  heat  at  constant  pressure  is  equal  to  dl,  and  at  constant 
volume,  to  d&  [see  (46.14)  and  (46.12)]: 

C   -I*** 
OP  —  \~,--^r 

We  transform  CP: 


Further,  representing  energy  as  &  =  8  [0,  V  (p9  6)],  we  write   the  derivative 

in  tho 


8op 

Whence 


(£V  \ 
-^-~  I  is  transformed 
vQ  Ip 

thus : 


Whence  it  follows  that 


IdpY 
\8G~lv 


It  will  later  bo  shown  rigorously  that  1-^lr  I    <  0,  i.e.,  the  pressure  can  only 

increase  with  decrease  in  volume  (otherwise  the  state  of  the  system  is  dynam  - 
ically  unstable,  which  is  obvious  as  it  is).  Therefore  CP  >  Gv  always,  and  also 

'dp\        ldp\       -n      .,                  /  8p\         N      ldp\             NQ 
-^y  I  >  (•or/ I    •  F°r  ideal  &aseB(^Q"l  ,—  ~JFT>  \~dVi  ~ F2" ' 

so  thatCp—  Cv  =  AT. 

6)  Accepting  the  second  law  of  thermodynamics  as  a  postulate,  prove 
that  the  efficiency  of  a  reversible  engine  is  always  greater  than  the  efficiency 
for  an  irreversible  engine,  working  with  the  same  temperature  difference 
between  source  and  sink. 


Sec.  46]  THBKMODYNAMIO   QUANTITIES  531 

The  proof  is  indirect.  Let  a  reversible  engine  and  an  irreversible  engine 
obtain  the  same  quantity  of  heat  Q1  from  a  source,  but  let  the  irreversible 
engine  give  a  smaller  quantity  of  heat  Q%'  to  the  sink  than  the  reversible  engine. 
The  reversible  engine  may  be  made  to  work  as  a  refrigerator,  i.e.,  to  take 
heat  from  a  cold  reservoir  and  to  deliver  it  to  a  hot  reservoir  at  the  expense 
of  external  work.  In  order  to  return  a  quantity  of  heat  Qt  to  the  hot  reservoir, 
in  accordance  with  our  assumption,  the  reversible  engine  must  take  a  larger 
quantity  of  heat  from  the  cold  reservoir  than  the  irreversible  engine  delivered. 
But  it  will  then  turn  out  that  the  hot  reservoir  does  not  deliver  heat  at  all, 
and  the  cold  reservoir  delivers  a  quantity  of  heat  Q2  —  Q>/t  at  the  expense 
of  which  useful  work  is  performed  equal  to  the  difference  between  the  work 
of  the  irreversible  engine  and  the  work  of  the  reversible  engine  operating 
as  a  refrigerator.  The  surrounding  medium  can  be  taken  as  the  cold  reservoir,  so 
that  useful  work  will  be  performed  at  the  expense  of  heat  obtained  from  the 
surrounding  medium;  this  contradicts  the  second  law  of  thermodynamics. 

6)  Prove  that  the  specific  heat  of  a  system  tends  to  zero  when  the  tem- 
perature tends  to  absolute  zero.  Do  the  same  for 

l?Y_\ 

I  98V 
The  entropy  is  related  to  tho  specific  heat  C  by  the  relation 


where  the  lower  limit  of  the  integral  is  put  equal  to  zero  from  Nernst's  theorem. 
For  the  integral  to  have  meaning,  we  must  demand  that  lim  G  ~  0.  In  addition 

(dJS\  e~>0 

~~  l~5  —  I    9  an(i  the  limit  of  tho  last  derivative  is  also  equal  to  zero 


as  0  tends  to  zero,  because  lim  S  =  0  in  the  case  of  an  arbitrary  pressure. 

o->e 

7)  Show  that  the  sum  of  the  enthalpy  and  kinetic  energy  is  conserved  in 
the  motion  of  a  substance  without  any  internal  heat  exchange  and  without 
exchange  of  heat  with  the  external  medium. 

Let  a  certain  mass  of  substance  be  transferred  from  a  volume  Vx>  pressure 
pl9  and  energy  ffl  to  V2,  pz,  and  ^2,  respectively.  In  order  to  displace  this  mass 
from  the  volume  V1  at  a  pressure  plt  an  amount  of  work  pl  Vl  must  be  done. 
Therefore,  in  going  to  p%,  V2,  a  work  pl  V^  —  p2  V2  is  done.  The  total  change 
of  energy  of  the  given  mass,  in  a  reference  system  fixed  in  it,  is  equal  to 

&i  —  <^2  +  Pi  VL  —  Pz  V*  —  I\  —  ^2-  Since  there    is  no  heat  exchange,  this 
quantity  can  be  equal  only  to  the  change  in  kinetic  energy 


Hence, 


In  future  we  shall  relate  this  equation  to  unit  mass  of  the  substance,  and  write 
it  in  the  form: 

va 
/  H — jT-  *=  const , 

where  /  is  the  enthalpy  of  unit  mass. 

34* 


632  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

8)  Find  the  propagation  velocity  of  small  ison tropic  disturbances  in  an 
isotropic  medium  [in  other  words,  neglecting  heat  transmission  and  considering 
that  p  =  p  (p)]. 

If  the  initial  position  of  a  particle  is  described  by  a  single  coordinate  a, 
and  the  displaced  position  by  the  coordinate  x,  measured  in  the  same  direction, 
then  the  equation  of  conservation  of  mass  is  the  following: 

P0  da  =  p  dx 
(p  is  the  density,  p0  is  the  initial  density).  Whence 

P_  _  tda\ 
Po        \dxh' 
The  force  acting  on  an  element  of  mass  p  dx  is 

-p  (x  +  dx)  +  p  (x)  =  -  (-I,-)  dx. 


According  to  Newton *s  Second  Law,  this  force  is  equal  to  the  product  of  mass 
and  acceleration,  i.e., 

/< 


d*x\  dp\ 

-H  =  —   -----    dx, 
JP   a  \dx  t 


whence  wo  have 


Po   V«  Po 


Considering  the  displacements  small,  wo  see  that  tlie  derivative  I  ^  —  I    is  close 

to  unity,  so  that  the  second  derivative  is  a  small  quantity.  The  result,  therefore, 
is  the  approximate  equation 


_ 

da*       ldp\ 
9  IS 


B*x_ 

~        ~     ' 


It  coincides  with  the  wave  equation  of  the  form  (17.4),  which  describes  the 
propagation  of  disturbances  with  velocity  c.  In  the  given  case,  the  propagation 
velocity  of  the  process  is  nothing  other  than  the  velocity  of  sound.  It  is  equal 

to  u  - 

9)  A  substance  flows  in  a  tube  of  constant  cross  -section  without  heat 
exchange,  but  with  internal  friction.  Show  that  the  maximum  entropy  is 
attained  where  the  flow  rate  is  equal  to  the  velocity  of  sound. 

The  following  conservation  laws  apply: 

p  v  —  j  ~  const, 

v* 
I  H  —  5- 


Sec.  46]  THERMODYNAMIC   QUANTITIES  633 

Substituting  the  velocity  from  the  first  equation,  wo  obt-ain 


Close    to    the   entropy   maximum    dS  =  0,    the    derivative  I  — — I 

\dpls 

so  that 

o2    . 


Let  us  differentiate  this  equation,  considering  that  the  enthalphy  is  expressed 
in  terms  of  the  independent  variables  8  and  p: 


V  =  — 


3  P  Ids  -  0      p2 

For  constant  entropy  I -^p- 1   =  w2,  so  that  v*=u*  at  maximum  entropy. 

If  there  is  a  flux  in  the  tube  for  which  v  <  u  ("subsonic  flow"),  the  value 
v  =  u  can  only  bo  attained  at  the  tube  outlet  because,  otherwise,  the  entropy, 
on  reaching  a  maximum  somewhere  in  the  tube,  would  have  to  decrease  in 
the  subsequent  flow,  which  is  impossible. 

10)  A  substance  flows  without  heat  exchange  or  friction,  i.e.,  isentropically, 
in  a  tube  of  continuously  variable  cross-section  /.  Show  that  the  velocity  in 
subsonic  flow  increases  with  decrease  in  cross-section,  but  in  supersonic  flow, 
it  increases  with  /.  The  flow  is  considered  as  one-dimensional  because  of  the 
smooth  variation  of  /. 

From  the  law  of  conservation  of  mass 

/  p  v  =  const , 
whence  it  follows  that 

dl  _i_  dp   _i_  dv  -ft 

-      f-  -f-          —  \j , 

Taking  into  account  that  entropy  is  constant,  wo  can  write: 

P          P  \dpls  P    uz  ' 

v2 
Differentiating  the  equation  /  -f-  ~n~  =   const  at  constant  entropy,  we  have 

(— — |    dp  -f  vdv  ==  —  -f  vdv  =  0  . 
\op1s  p 

Whence  it  follows  that 

dp  _      vdv 

and  finally 


which  proves  the  statement.  In  order  to  obtain  flow  with  supersonic  velocity 
at  the  outlet  of  the  tube,  we  must  pass  it  through  a  Laval  nozzle,  i.e.,  along 
a  tube  whoso  aperture  first  decreases,  so  that  v  —  u  at  the  narrowest  place, 
after  which  v  becomes  greater  than  u  and  continues  to  increase. 


534  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

11)  A  piston  is  in  movement  with  constant  velocity  v9  into  a  cylinder  with 
cross-section  /,  filled  with  a  substance  with  initial  pressure  pQ  and  initial  density 
P0.  The  enthalpy  /  per  unit  mass  is  regarded  as  a  known  function  of  p  and  p. 
Formulate  a  system  of  equations,  from  which  it  is  possible  to  determine  the 
displacement  velocity  of  the  boundary  between  the  compressed  and  non- 
cornpreeaed  substance,  and  also  the  density  and  pressure  of  the  compressed 
substance. 

The  compressed  substance  moves  with  velocity  v  equal  to  the  piston  veloc- 
ity. The  boundary  between  the  compressed  and  noncompressed  substance 
has  a  certain  velocity  D.  The  compressed  substance  has  a  velocity  v  —  D 
relative  to  this  boundary,  and  the  noncompressed  substance  has  velocity  D. 

Let  us  pass  to  a  reference  system  moving  together  with  the  interface. 
Then  the  mass  conservation  law  is  expressed  as  follows: 


We  shall  consider  a  cylindrical  volume  of  the  substance  passing  through 
the  boundary  in  unit  time.  The  length  of  this  cylinder  in  tho  compressed  sub- 
stance is  equal  to  D  —  v,  while  its  mass  is  /  p  (D  —  v),  so  that  its  momentum 
is  equal  to  /  p  (D  —  v)a.  The  momentum  in  the  noncompressed  substance 
equalled  /  p0''^a«  A  resultant  force  (pQ  —  p)  f  acted  on  this  cylinder,  whence 
the  conservation  equation 


/  (Po  +  Po#2)  -  flP  +  P  (D  -  v)*].  (••) 

The  third  equation  expresses  the  absence   of  heat  exchange  (see  exercise  7) 


At  the  interface,  a  discontinuous  change  occurs  in  the  density,  pressure,  and 
velocity  of  the  substance.  This  surface  is  called  a  shock  wave.  We  can  deter- 
mine D,  p,  and  p  from  the  three  conservation  laws,  if  the  form  of  the  function 
1  (p,  p)  is  known.  Those  quantities  will  be  determined  specifically  in  exer- 
cise 7,  Sec.  47,  where  it  will  also  be  shown  that  the  compression  process  in  a 
shock  wave  is  irreversible. 

12)  Show  that  the  classical  expression  for  a  statistical  sum  does  not  depend 
upon  the  constant  magnetic  field  in  which  the  system  is  situated. 

The  classical  expression  for  the  statistical  sum  (or  more  exactly,  for  the  inte- 
gral) is 


Z 


J 


When  the  system  is  placed  in  a  magnetic  field  the  momenta  of  the  particles 
change  according  to  the  formula  p  ->  p  --  A  =*  P.  Passing  (for  the  phase- 

volume  element)  from  drp  to  rfrp,  we  find  that  the  statistical  sura  appears 
the  same  as  in  the  absence  of  field  because  the  new  notation  for  the  integration 
variable  does  not  change  anything: 


•  I 


PN'»ri»r«»  •• 


Thus,  classical  mechanics  cannot  describe  the  magnetic  properties  of  a  sub- 
stance. 


Sec.  47]  THE  THERMODYNAMIO  PROPERTIES  OF  IDEAL  GASES  535 

13)  Express  the  entropy  of  an  ideal  gas  in  terms  of  the  occupation   nk 
for  all  three  statistics  (0k  =  1  everywhere). 

Using  the  expressions  for  S  in  equations  (39.14)  and  (39.25),  we  find: 
Bose  statistics: 

8  =£l(Hk  +  !)  to  (*fc  +  1)  ~  »fc  In  nk] ; 

k 
Fornii  statistics: 

S  =  — JT  [(1  -  nk)  In  (1  -  nk)  +  nfc  In  n*] ; 

fe 
Boltzmann  statistics  corresponding  to   nk  <  1 : 


If  the  weight  is  not  equal  to  unity,  then,  introducing  tik  5=  gk  fk*  we  obtain 
for  all  three  statistics: 

<  yV[(/fc+l)ln(/fc  +  l)-/fcln/fc], 


~  J£V  [(1  -  /fc)  In  (1  -  fk)  + 
fe 

^Boltzmanu  =»  —  ^/fl^fe  /fc  In  —  . 


Sec.  47.  The  Thermodynauiic  Properties  of  Ideal  Gases  in  Boltzmann 

Statistics 

In  this  section  we  shall  consider  certain  consequences  that  follow 
from  the  general  principles  of  thermodynamics  as  applied  to  ideal 
gases.  We  shall  suppose  that  the  gas  density  is  sufficiently  small 
for  Boltzmann  statistics  to  be  applied  to  its  molecules.  This  does 
not  mean  that  the  motion  of  the  molecules  should  be  regarded  as 
nonquantum;  the  quantization  of  rotational,  vibrational  (and  all 
the  more  so,  electronic)  levels  of  a  molecule  must  be  taken  into 
account  in  all  cases  when  the  spacing  between  neighbouring  levels 
is  comparable  with  6  (i.e.,  kT)  or  greater  than  6.  Even  when  the  level 
spacing  is  sufficiently  small  compared  with  6,  as  is  the  case  of  trans- 
lational  motion,  the  quantum  of  action  should  be  left  in  the  formula 
for  the  statistical  weight  of  the  states,  since  it  would  be  impossible 
otherwise  to  obtain  a  unique  expression  for  entropy. 

Deviations  from  Boltzmann  statistics  that  occur  in  gases  at  low 
temperatures  or  high  densities  are  sometimes  called  "degeneracies." 
One  should  differentiate  between  deviations  from  the  characteristic 


536  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

ideal  gas  state,  due  to  the  interaction  between  molecules,  arid  quantum 
deviations  from  classical  >statistics.  Of  course,  there  also  arise  correc- 
tions which  are  due  to  the  effect  of  both  factors  together. 

Free  energy  of  an  ideal  gas.  As  was  indicated  in  the  preceding 
section,  it  is  convenient,  when  calculating  thermodyiiamic  quantities, 
to  proceed  from  the  expression  for  free  energy. 

We  shall  start  with  formula  (46.40),  reducing  the  statistical  sum 
to  the  form  that  it  takes  for  a  Boltzmann  gas.  For  this  it  is  necessary 
to  take  into  account  that,  by  definition,  a  statistical  sum  is  calculated 
over  all  the  physically  different  states  of  a  gas.  But  the  state  of  the 
gas  does  not  change  if  all  possible  molecular  permutations  are  per- 
formed over  the  individual  states;  in  nonquantum  statistics  such  a 
permutation  can  be  defined.  The  number  of  permutations  of  N 
molecules  is  equal  to  N\. 

The  total  energy  of  an  ideal  gas  separates  into  the  sum  of  the 
energies  of  all  of  its  molecules: 


where  k  is  the  number  of  the  quantum  state. 

Substituting  the  expression  for  £  into  the  statistical  sum  (46.40), 
and  dividing  this  sum  by  the  number  of  permutations  of  the  mole- 
cules, we  obtain 

N 
-4-V"1*  N 


The  second  summation  over  (k)  relates  to  all  possible  combinations 
of  the  energy  of  the  separate  molecules  s^.  Here,  we  have  made 
use  of  the  fact  that  the  energy  spectrum  is  the  same  for  all  molecules 
(if  the  gas  consists  of  molecules  of  one  type).  The  summation  in 
(47.1)  is  performed  over  the  spectrum  of  a  single  molecule.  Replacing 
N\  by  its  expression  in  Stirling's  formula,  we  arrive  at  a  general 
formula  for  the  free  energy  of  an  ideal  gas  under  Boltzmann  statistics. 

,00 


(47.2) 


Summation  over  translational  degrees  of  freedom.  It  is  expedient, 
in  the  statistical  summation  over  the  states  of  a  separate  molecule, 
to  separate  the  translational  degrees  of  freedom  and  represent  the 
energy  in  the  form 


Sec.  47]  THE  THERMOD  YNAMIC  PROPERTIES  OF  IDEAL  OASES  537 


It  is  taken  here  that  the  energy  does  not  depend  upon  the  coordinates 
of  the  centre  of  mass  of  the  molecule. 
The  statistical  weight  of  a  state  with  momentum  p  is  equal  to 


gM  denotes  the  weight  referring  to  an  energy  level  e^.  Integration 
over  x,  y,  z  contributes  the  factor  dx,  dy,  dz=V  to  the  statistical 
sum.  The  integration  over  momenta  is  performed  in  a  familiar  manner  : 

f  __^c2  ___ 

Je    *m'*dpx=V2nmQ.  (47.5) 

—  00 

Thus,  the  free  energy  for  an  ideal  gas  reduces  to  the  following 
form  : 

(47.6) 


A  relationship  is  obtained  here  between  free  energy  and  volume. 
The  function  /  (6)  depends  upon  the  molecular  structure. 

Thcrmodynamic  quantities  of  an  ideal  gas.  It  is  easy  to  determine 
pressure  from  formula  (47.6).  From  (46.39)  we  obtain 

p--J£_:™.  (47.7) 

i.e.,  the  well-known  Clapeyron  equation.  The  thermodynamic  potential 
is 


but  here  it  is  expressed  in  terms  of  volume.  To  be  able  to  use  identity 

V         0 
(46.45)  we  must,  in  addition,  replace  -^  by  —  ,  whence  a  final  formula 

is  obtained  for  the  thermodynamic  potential  of  an  ideal  gas: 

O=  -tfeinl/^L.  (47.8) 

p  v        ' 

We  find  the  chemical  potential  with  the  aid  of  (46.47)  or  (46.48): 

(Jl=_01n-^-.  (47.9) 

The  entropy  of  an  ideal  gas  is 

(47.10) 


538  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

This  expression  does  not  agree  with  Nernst's  theorem.  In  actual 
fact,  of  course,  we  must  apply  to  a  gas  at  very  low  temperatures, 
not  Boltzmann   statistics  but  quantum  statistics,  even  neglecting 
the  fact  that  at  low  temperatures  the  gas  actually  condenses. 
The  energy  is  equal  to  &  =  F  +  6  8,  or 

(47.11) 


Thus,  the  energy  of  an  ideal  Boltzmann  gas,  expressed  in  terms 
of  temperature,   does  not  depend  upon  volume  at  all.  The  mean 

energy  of  a  single  molecule  "i  =  -^r  depends  only  upon  the  temperature 

of  the  gas.  This  is  not  only  because  there  is  no  force  interaction 
between  the  gas  molecules,  but  also  because  the  properties  of  the  gas 
are  described  by  classical  statistics.  In  the  quantum  statistics  of 
ideal  gases,  the  energy  of  a  molecule  depends  both  upon  volume 
and  temperature.  It  should  be  noted  that  the  variables  in  formula 
(47.11)  do  not  correspond  to  the  identity  (46.26).  In  order  to  make 
use  of  this  identity,  temperature  must  be  eliminated  from  (47.10) 
and  substituted  in  (47.11),  but  this  is  very  difficult  to  do  in  the  general 
form. 

The  enthalpy  of  an  ideal  gas  is 

(47.12) 


Like  energy,  it  depends  only  on  the  temperature. 

A  mixture  of  ideal  gases.  Since  the  molecules  of  ideal  gases  do  not 
interact,  the  free  energy  of  a  mixture  is  additive  and  reduces  to  the 
sum  of  the  free  energies  of  all  the  components: 


.  (47.13) 

i 

The  pressure  of  tho  mixture  is  calculated  in  the  usual  way: 


p^  _.?_£_.  ___! /4714) 

V  dV  V  V**'1*; 

If  we  introduce  the  partial  pressure  of  the  ith  component  of  the 
mixture,  i.e.,  its  contribution  pf  to  the  total  gas  pressure  p,  then 

(47.16) 


k 
so  that  the  total  pressure  appears  as  the  sum  of  partial  pressures. 


Sec.  47]  THE  THERMODYNAMIC  PROPEBTIBS  OF  IDEAL  GASES  539 

This,  of  course,  refers  only  to  ideal  gases.  The  thermodynamic  poten- 
tial of  a  mixture  is 

-  .  (47.16) 


The  chemical  potential  of  the  ^th  component  is  determined  from 
formula  (46.50).  It  turns  out  to  be  equal  to 

(47.17) 


These  formulae  are  very  important  in  the  theory  of  chemical  equilibria 
in  gases. 

Rotational  energy  of  a  gas.  Let  us  now  calculate  the  statistical  sum 
over  the  rotational  degrees  of  freedom  of  molecules.  Since  we  wish 
to  obtain  simple  thermodynamic  formulae,  in  this  section  we  shall 
confine  ourselves  to  the  case  of  nonquantum  rotational  motion  (the 
quantized  case  was  considered  in  Sec.  41).  This  means  that  the  tem- 
perature satisfies  the  condition 

6>-|J-.  (47.18) 

Here,  J  is  the  molecular  moment  of  inertia.  At  room  temperatures, 
the  condition  (47.18)  is  satisfied  for  all  gases,  including  hydrogen. 

The  expression  for  the  mean  energy  of  a  molecule  (47.11)  involves 
only  the  logarithmic  derivative  of  the  statistical  sum,  so  that  the 
constant  factors  in  this  sum  are  not  essential.  But  the  value  of  the 
sum  as  such  is  important  in  many  statistical  applications  (chemical 
equilibria).  In  order  to  calculate  this  value  we  must  take  into  account 
that  the  summation  is  taken  over  the  physically  different  rotational 
states.  For  example,  diatomic  molecules  of  H2  or  O2  take  on  coincident 
positions  when  rotated  through  180°  about  an  axis  perpendicular  to 
the  line  joining  the  nuclei.  The  position  of  a  diatomic  molecule  in 
space  is  given  by  two  angles,  the  azimuthal  and  polar  angles,  and  can 
be  represented  by  a  single  point  on  the  surface  of  a  sphere  of  unit 
radius.  But  the  physically  different  molecular  orientations  corre- 
spond only  to  half  of  this  sphere. 

The  position  of  a  nonlinear  molecule  in  space  is  given  with  the  aid 
of  the  Eulerian  angles  (see  Sec.  9).  If  the  molecule  possesses  any 
form  of  symmetry,  then  the  statistical  summation  over  all  possible 
orientations  should  be  divided  by  the  number  of  rotations  leaving 
the  molecule  invariant.  For  example,  the  ammonia  molecule  NH3 
has  the  form  of  a  pyramid  with  a  regular  triangular  base.  Its  rotational 
statistical  sum,  taken  over  all  rotations  in  space,  must  be  divided  by  3. 
The  benzene  molecule  C6H6  has  a  regular  hexagonal  form.  A  hexagon 
does  not  only  coincide  with  itself  for  60°  rotation  in  its  plane,  but  also 


540  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

for  180°  rotation  about  an  axis  joining  opposite  vertices.  Hence,  its 
statistical  sum  is  taken  over  1/2-6  =  1/12  part  of  all  orientations. 
It  is  now  easy  to  write  down  a  classical  expression  for  the  rotational 
statistical  sum  of  a  diatomic  (or,  in  general,  linear)  molecule: 


the  4jc  factor  takes  into  account  all  orientations  in  space.  If  the 
diatomic  molecule  consists  of  different  atoms,  <r  —  1 ;  if  it  consists  of 
identical  atoms,  <T  — 2.  The  quantum  statistical  sum  for  an  oxygen 
molecule,  whose  nuclei  do  not  have  spin,  is  taken  only  over  even 
rotational  states  (see  Sec.  41).  In  the  classical  limit,  this  is  taken  into 
account  by  the  factor  1/2.  When  the  nuclei  of  a  molecule  possess 
spins  we  must  multiply  the  statistical  sum  by  the  quantities  2s +  1, 
taken  for  all  the  nuclei.  In  the  linear  triatomic  molecule  CO2  (0  =  0  =  0), 
we  must  also  put  a  =  2.  Thus,  for  a  linear  molecule 

y_  4.    2*JO    __    2 JO 

Z,  -"(2*70"    ~~    a)*'    '  14/.-U) 

rot 

The  position  of  a  nonlinear  molecule  in  space  is  given  by  the  orien- 
tation of  its  arbitrary  axis  and  the  rotation  angle  about  this  axis. 
Consequently,  all  rotations  in  space  introduce  the  factor  47c-27c~87i2 
into  the  statistical  sum  for  a  nonlinear  molecule,  and  the  result  is 
the  following  expression: 


Thus,  the  contribution  of  the  rotational  energy  to  the  total  energy 
d  In  Jf 

of  the  gas — equal  to  N  6  — 7-^- amounts  to  NQ  in  the  case  of  a  linear 

o  d  in  Q 

molecule,  andy^O  in  the  case  of  a  nonlinear  molecule. 

The  vibrational  energy  of  a  molecule.  The  energy  of  a  molecule 
performing  small  oscillations  can  be  represented,  according  to  Sec.  8, 
in  the  form 

n 

evib  -  ^Z(p*  +  <°«  Q$  +  u<»  <47-22) 

where  Q*  are  the  normal  oscillation  coordinates,   P«  are  the  corre- 
sponding momenta,  UQ  is  the  potential  energy  in  the  equilibrium  posi- 


SeC.  47]  THE  THERMODYNAMIC  PROPERTIES  OF  IDEAL  GASES  541 


tion  (including  the  energy  of  the  vibratioiial  ground  state).  If  /ia>a<^  6, 
then  the  vibrational  summation  may  be  taken  for  iionquantized 
motion  : 


-n  ff -w(p«+"«Q«) 

-1  \JJ  e         ' 


(2nh)» 
vib        a-1 


-1 


The  vibrational  motion  makes  a  contribution  NnQ  —  NU0  to  the 

hz 

mean  energy  of  the  molecule.  Usually  li  <oa^>  -  j-  so  that  a  temperature 
region  exists  that  satisfies  the  two  inequalities 

/j2 

7icoa>0>-V.  (47.24) 

t/ 

The  vibrational  quanta  of  the  molecules  are  not  yet  excited  at  these 
temperatures,  while  the  rotational  specific  heat  is  already  constant. 
Thus,  in  the  case  of  nitrogen  and  oxygen  the  total  specific  heat  amounts 

toy  N  +  N  =  -^-  N   for   temperatures   from   several   tens   to   many 

hundreds  of  degrees.  TJnder  these  conditions,  gases  (for  instance,  air) 
are  subject  to  the  equipartition  law  with  a  reduced  number  of  degrees 
of  freedom.  The  last  expression  means  that  each  dynamical  variable 
coordinate  or  momentum  entering  into  the  Hamiltonian  quadratically 

NO 
gives,  in  the  classical  limit,  an  amount  —  2—  in  the  mean  energy  of 

the  gas. 

The  energy  of  the  higher  vibrational  states  is  not  governed  by  the 
simple  formula  (47.22).  This  can  be  seen  from  Pig.  47,  where  the  lower 
curve  is  close  to  a  parabola  (harmonic  oscillations)  near  the  equilibrium 
position,  and  very  different  from  a  parabola  (anharmoriic  oscillations) 
close  to  the  dissociation  limit.  If  the  temperature  is  so  high  that 
oscillations  (with  large  quantum  numbers)  close  to  the  dissociation 
limit  are  excited,  then  the  greater  part  of  the  molecules  will  have 
separated  into  atoms.  At  lower  temperatures,  the  anharmonic  nature 
of  the  oscillations  affects  but  little  the  value  of  the  statistical  sum. 

Thermodynamic  quantities  for  a  gas  governed  by  the  equipartition 
law.  The  specific  heat  of  a  gas  governed  by  the  principle  of  equiparti- 
tion of  energy  is  constant  over  a  wide  range  of  temperatures.  Hence, 
the  ratio  of  specific  heats 


is  also  constant. 


542  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

It  will  be  convenient,  in  certain  further  applications,  to  express 
the  thermodynamic  quantities  in  terms  of  y.  The  function  /  (6)  is 


proportional  to  0  N  e     e=0Y"1e     e  ' 

Whence  we  obtain  an  expression  for  the  energy  of  a  gas,  which  energy 
we  shall  write  here  to  the  accuracy  of  the  constant  term  JV£/0: 

/=  CVO  -  -^°T  =  -f^  (47.26) 

The  enthalpy  is  equal  to 

/  =  ~S  +  pV  =  -^~ .  (47.27) 

To  the  accuracy  of  the  constant  term,  the  entropy  is 

N  N 

8  =  Nln  V  +  — -T-  hi  0  ^  — — -  In  pF*.  (47.28) 

Y—  1  Y  — 1 

Whence  we  get  an  equation  for  an  adiabatic  process  in  a  gas  governed 
by  the  equipartition  principle: 

pFY=  const.  (47.29) 

Y  is  often  called  the  adiabatic  index.  From  exercise  9  of  the  preceding 
section  we  find  an  expression  for  the  velocity  of  sound 

«=l/f-ri-ri  —ffW.  <«.30> 


•ti 

where  V  is  the  volume  of  unit  mass. 

Let  us  bring  together  the  laws  from  which  the  specific  heat  of  a  gas 
subject  to  the  equipartition  principle  is  calculated.  At  a  sufficiently 

N 
high  temperature  there  is  a  specific  heat  -j-  per  rotational   degree 

of  freedom,  and  also  per  translational  degree  of  freedom,  since  each 
such  degree  of  freedom  contributes  one  squared  term  to  the  energy 

expression  of  the  form  -|~-  or  ^-^-  . 

zm        Jt/! 

Hence,  the  integral  of  the  distribution  function  acquires  either 

.  /\ 

a  factor  v  2n  m  6  or  V2rc  J±Q ;  this  yields  the  term  y  when  calculating 

the  energy.  If  we  can  replace  the  summation  by  an  integral,  the 
vibrational  degree  of  freedom  contains  two  variables  appearing 
quadratically  in  the  energy  [see  (47.22)],  thus  yielding  the  mean 
energy  0. 

To  summarize,  at  a  sufficiently  high  temperature,  each  vibrational 
degree  of  freedom,  if  it  is  strongly  excited,  makes  a  contribution  N 
to  the  specific  heat.  If  we  apply  the  equipartition  principle,  then  the 
specific  heat  of  a  molecule  consisting  of  i  atoms,  which  are  not  in 


Sec.  47]  THE  THEBMODYNAMIC  PROPERTIES  OF  IDEAL  GASES  543 

one  line  (i>2),  is  equal  to[3i  —  ~)  N,  and  if  the  atoms  form  a  line 

in  the  equilibrium  position,  it  is  (3  i  —  3)  N. 

Thus,  for  a  triatomic  molecule  of  triangular  form  (for  example 
H20),  a  specific  heat  6  N  is  obtained  for  full  excitation  of  all  the  degrees 
of  freedom  (besides  electronic),  and  the  ratio  CplCy^l/Q.  If  the  vi- 
brations are  not  yet  excited,  then  Cv=  3  N  and  Cp/CV  =  4/3.  At  the 

lowest  temperature,  only  the  translational  degrees  of  freedom  remain, 

2 
as  in  the  case  of  a  monatomic  gas,  which  gives  Cv  —  -^N  and  Cp/GV  —5/3. 

If  the  atoms  of  a  triatomic  molecule  form  a  line  (for  example  C02), 

13 
then  the  maximum  specific  heat  GV™  —  JV  and  (7P/GY=  15/13,   i.e., 

Cv  is  greater  for  a  linear  molecule  than  for  a  triangular  molecule. 

rj 

But  if  vibrations  are  not  excited  then  Cv~^N,  which  is  now  less 

than  for  a  triangular  molecule.  Such  an  intersection  of  the  specific 
heat  curves  of  C02  and  H20  with  change  of  temperature  is  actually 
observed. 

Adiabatic  demagnetization.  Of  great  interest  is  the  process  of 
isentropic  (adiabatic)  demagnetization.  In  Sec.  40  we  considered  the 
paramagnetism  of  the  salts  of  rare-earth  elements  due  to  the  free 
rotation  of  the  magnetic  moments  of  unfilled  shells.  Such  moments 
may  be  interpreted  as  a  "gas." 

Let  us  suppose  that  a  salt  is  magnetized  to  saturation  at  low  temper- 
ature and  is  then  suddenly  demagnetized.  Its  entropy  does  not  have 
time  to  change.  But  if  all  the  moments  are  orientated  in  one  direction, 
the  entropy  is  small  because  this  state  is  obtained  in  a  small  number 
of  ways  (in  one  way,  in  the  limit).  When  the  field  is  rapidly  removed, 
the  entropy  will  remain  small  only  due  to  a  big  drop  in  the  temperature. 
This  method  has  been  used  to  obtain  temperatures  of  several  thou- 
sandths of  a  degree  above  absolute  zero. 

Exercises 

1)  Find  the  work  and  tho  quantity  of  heat  obtained  by  a  gas  in  an  isothermal 
process. 

The  work  is  equal  to  tho  change  in  free  energy: 


The  quantity  of  heat  is  expressed  in  terms  of  entropy  change: 


A  and  Q  are  equal  and  opposite  in  sign,  because  energy  remains  unchanged 
at  constant  temperature. 

2)  Two  portions  of  different  gases  occurring  at  the  same  temperature  and 
pressure  are  mixed.  Find  the  increase  in  entropy. 


544  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 


Pi  Pi  P  P 

whore  pl  and  p2  are  tho  partial  pressures  of  both  gases  after  mixing.  Whence 


Pi  Pi  JVl  ^2 

If  two  portions  of  tho  same  gas  aro  mixed  under  the  same  conditions,  the 
entropy  will  equal  (Nl  -f  N2)  m  ~ — ~  >  after  mixing,  so  that  A  S  —  0  as  it  should 

be.  This  would  not  havo  occurred  if  the  factor  Nl  in  the  statistical  sum  had 
not  been  introduced  into  the  expression  for  free  energy.  Due  to  this  factor, 
only  tho  summation  over  physically  different  states  of  a  gas  appears  in  the 
free  energy,  and  the  entropy  cannot  change  when  two  portions  of  the  same 
gas  are  combined  at  the  same  temperature  and  at  equal  pressure. 

3)  Calculate  the  free  energy  of  a  gas  in  a  centrifuge,  of  radius  R  and  length  I, 
rotating  with  angular  velocity  o>.  Find  the  mean  square  distance  of  the  particle 
from  the  axis. 

Tho  centrifugal  force  is  equal  to  mw2  r,  which  corresponds  to  an  effective 

potential  energy   U  = —     m<>>2rdr  =  - 


-  -  . 
Whence  we  obtain  an  expression   for  the  free  energy 


o 


to'K*         \1 

*r_l  I 

'I 


Tho     free    energy     satisfies    tho     general     relation    d  F  =  —  S  d  0  —  ArfX 
[cf.  (46.38),  where  X  =  V]. 

Regarding  o>2  as  an.  external  parameter  X,  we  determine  the  mean  square 
distance  of  the  particle  from  tho  axis: 

7*, 2__!£_,   f       l  20 

Nm    d  ( to2) 


1  -  e 


20 


because,  if  w2=  X,  then  -=  ~-  =  -     r"  ^  A  Ccf-  (4C-7)]- 

Z  C/CQ  O  X 

JJ2 

At  very  largo  angular  velocities  r2  ->  R2,  and  at  small  velocities  r2  —  -—r- . 

% 

4)  Find  the  velocity  of  stationary  exit  of  a  gas  in  vacuum,  considering  the 
adiabatic  index  as  constant 


5)  Find  the  maximum  flux  density  of  a  gas  for  an  adiabatic  transition  from  a 
pressure  p0  and  specific  volume  V0  to  a  pressure  p. 
From  the  adiabatio  equation, 


P 
Whence  we  find  tho  final  enthalpy  : 


See.  47]  THE  THERMODYNAMIC  PROPERTIES  OF  IDEAL  GASES  545 

The  flux  density  is 


Denoting  P^^pjp^  ^Te  obtain 

-    _L  1  /  i      * 

Hence,  the  maximum  flux  density  is  obtained  at 


P  max  — 


6)  Show  that  the  flux  density  is  maximum  when  the  flow  velocity  is  equal 
to  the  velocity  of  sound  at  the  given  point. 

Note.  If  the  pressure  at  the  output  is  made  less  than  p0  Pmax»  the  exit  velocity 
will  no  longer  vary  and  will  remain  equal  to  the  local  value  of  the  velocity  of 
sound.  Any  disturbance  occurring  in  the  flow  is  propagated  with  the  velocity  of 
sound.  When  the  flow  velocity  is  equal  to  the  velocity  of  sound,  the  disturbance 
is  carried  away  by  the  flow.  Therefore,  if  the  external  pressure  pl  is  less  than 
Po  ^maxj  it  will  no  longer  affect  the  exit.  In  order  to  obtain  supersonic  exit,  a 
Laval  nozzle  must  be  iised  (see  exercise  10  of  the  previous  section)  for  the  flow 
velocity  to  equal  the  local  velocity  of  sound  at  the  narrowest  part  of  the  nozzle. 

7)  Derive  a  relationship  between  pressure  and  density  in  a  shock  wave  prop- 
agated in  an  ideal  gas  of  constant  specific  heat,  and  also  find  the  sudden  entropy 
change  in  the  shock  wave  (see  exercise  11,  Sec.  46). 

From  equation  (*)  in  the  exorcise  mentioned,  p.  534,  we  have  a  relationship 
between  v  and  D: 

v          P  —  Po 
D         "  "P       ' 

Whence,  from  equation  (**),  wo  obtain 

*          (P-PO)(P—PO)  2  P.?  -  PO 


PPo  Po  P  —  Po 

V 

We  now  substitute  the  expressions  for  v2  and——,  and  also  /  from  (47.27),  into 

equation  (***),  and  find  a  relation  between  density  and  pressure  for  shock 
compression 

JP_  =    (Y  +  1)  P  -  (Y  ~  1)  Po 

Po          (Y  +  ifpo  -  (Y  -  1)  P  " 

It  must  not  be  thought  that  for  a  shock  compression  from  p0  to  p,  the  pressure 
actually  follows  this  equation,  passing  through  the  entire  intermediate  series 
of  values  corresponding  to  the  intermediate  values  of  p.  The  relationship 
obtained  shows  what  final  values  of  p  may  be  obtained  when  the  gas  is  com- 
pressed with  given  initial  pQ  and  p0  in  the  shock  wave.  The  greatest  density 

increase   (for  p/pQ  ->  oo)  corresponds   to  —  = —  ,  i.e.,  the  density  in  the 

Po         Y  —  1 

Y  ~4~  1 
shock  wave  cannot  be  increased  by  more  than =-  times.  For  example,  when 

Y  * 
Y  ==  7/5,  the  quantity  p/p0  <  6.  Using  the  formula  (47.28)  for  entropy,  we  find 

35-0060 


546  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part   IV 


Y  -  i  \  Y        Y  +     PO  -  Y  -     p 

If  the  density  does  not  change  significantly,  we  can  expand  this  expression 
in  a  series  in  powers  of  e  =  ~  --  1.  It  then  turns  out  that 


Hence,  A  S  is  third  order  with  respect  to  e  or,  what  is  just  the  same,  with 
respect  to  the  gas  -compression  velocity  v.  Therefore,  we  can  neglect  the  change 
in  entropy  for  a  slow  gas  compression,  and  consider  that  the  gas  is  compressed 
reversibly. 

To  the  same  approximation,  the  shock  wave  velocity  assumes  the  following 
form: 


which  coincides  with  the  velocity  of  sound  in  an  ideal  gas.  Thus,  a  weak  shock 
wave  degenerates  to  a  sound  wave.  This  holds  for  any  substance. 

A  compression  sound  wave  sent  behind  another  sound  wave  in  a  substance 
will  overtake  it,  because  it  will  be  moving  in  a  substance  having  a  certain 
velocity  and,  in  addition,  initially  compressed  by  the  first  wave.  A  sufficiently 
large  number  of  such  waves,  sent  one  after  another,  must  finally  merge  to 
form  a  shock  wave  (of  finite  amplitude)  propagated  in  the  substance  faster 
than  sound. 

Sec.  48.  Fluctuations 

The  reversibility  of  mechanical  equations  with  respect  to  time. 

The  initial  and  final  states  of  a  system  in  classical  mechanics  are 
uniquely  interrelated:  one  of  them  completely  determines  the  other. 
This  is  expressed  mathematically  by  the  fact  that  if  the  signs  of  all 
the  velocities  are  reversed,  the  entire  motion  of  the  system  will  be 
in  the  reverse  direction.  Changing  the  sign  of  the  velocities  is  formally 
equivalent  to  changing  the  sign  of  the  time.  But  if  the  sign  of  the 
time  is  changed,  the  form  of  Lagrange's  equations  will  not  change. 
It  is  still  easier  to  see  the  invariance  of  the  equations  of  Newton's 
Second  Law  with  respect  to  a  change  of  t  to  — t:  these  equations 
involve  only  second  derivatives  with  respect  to  time,  which  preserve 
their  sign  in  such  a  change. 

In  order  to  perform  the  same  transition  in  electrodynamical 
equations,  we  must  first  of  all  change  the  signs  of  all  the  currents. 
In  order  that  Maxwell's  equations  (12.24) -(12.27)  should  not  change, 
we  must  also  change  the  sign  of  the  magnetic  field  together  with 
the  current,  and  leave  the  sign  of  the  electric  current  unchanged. 
Since  the  magnetic  field  is  an  axial  vector,  or  a  pseudovector  (see 
Sec.  16),  the  choice  of  sign  is  a  matter  of  pure  convenience. 

Quantum  mechanical  equations  also  preserve  their  form  when  t 
is  changed  to  — t .  In  the  simplest  case,  when  the  Hamiltonian  operator 
is  real  (i.e.,  when  it  does  not  involve  i),  the  transition  £-> — t  simply 


Sec.  48]  FLUCTUATIONS  547 

denotes  the  simultaneous  transition  ip-^*,  which  can  be  directly 
seen  from  Schrodinger's  equation  (24.11).  But  the  function  <J>*  is 
completely  equivalent  to  ^  (no  matter  which  of  them  is  regarded 
as  conjugate).  In  more  complicated  cases,  when  the  operator  &  is 
complex,  we  can  likewise  always  pass  from  the  function  fy  to  another 
(physically  fully  equivalent  to  it)  together  with  the  transition  from 
5  to  —  t. 

Statistics  and  reversibility  in  time.  We  shall  now  examine  the  way 
that  the  laws  of  statistical  mechanics  relate  to  time  inversion. 
Statistical  mechanics  states  that  if  at  some  initial  instant  of  time 
a,  system  is  deviated  from  statistical  equilibrium,  then,  in  the  over- 
whelming majority  of  cases,  it  will  subsequently  approach  equilibrium. 
A  system  which  is  already  in  equilibrium  will  remain  in  equilibrium, 
no  matter  what  imaginable  changes  in  the  sign  of  time  are  performed 
in  the  mechanical  equations  describing  the  detailed  microscopic  state 
of  the  system.  Therefore,  a  situation  arises  that  is  rather  paradoxical 
at  first  sight :  statistical  laws,  which  appear  noninvariant  with  respect 
to  time  inversion,  are  derived  from  the  equations  of  mechanics! 

The  problem  stated  in  classical  mechanics  and  statistics.  Let  us 

examine  this  paradox  in  the  limits  of  the  classical  laws  of  motion. 
First  take  the  following  example.  Let  a  gas  occupy  one  half  of  a  vessel 
divided  by  a  partition.  After  this  partition  is  removed  the  gas  will 
occupy  the  whole  vessel.  Let  us  follow  the  motion  of  each  molecule 
of  the  gas  in  this  irreversible  process  (in  classical  mechanics  this  is, 
in  principle,  possible).  The  motion  of  all  the  molecules  is  represented 
in  phase  space  by  the  displacement  of  a  single  point  along  a  phase 
trajectory.  If  in  the  state  of  statistical  equilibrium  we  mentally  change 
the  signs  of  all  the  velocities,  the  phase  point  in  its  imaginary  move- 
ment will  be  displaced  in  the  reverse  direction,  and  all  the  gas  will 
collect  in  one  half  of  the  vessel.  Since  any  equilibrium  state  of  the  gas 
is  attainable  from  a  nonequilibrium  state,  and  both  velocity  signs 
are,  a  priori,  equiprobable,  the  gas  must  come  out  of  the  statistical 
equilibrium  state  as  often  as  it  enters  it — which,  it  would  appear, 
is  never  observed. 

In  actual  fact,  in  statistics,  equilibrium  is  not  just  any  strictly 
defined  state,  but  a  whole  range  of  states  in  which  a  closed  system 
spends  the  greater  part  of  its  time.  The  phase  point  roams  about  in 
the  equilibrium  range  for  an  extremely  long  time  before  spontaneously 
leaving  it  for  any  considerable  distance.  Through  the  vast  majority 
of  phase  points  in  the  statistical  equilibrium  region  there  pass  trajec- 
tories which  almost  never  enter  regions  that  correspond  noticeably 
to  nonequilibrium  states. 

If  we  choose  a  certain  section  of  the  equilibrium  range,  we  may  say 
that  the  system  emerges  from  it  just  as  frequently  as  it  returns  to  it, 
but  that  in  the  vast  majority  of  cases  it  does  not  go  "far." 


548  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Therefore,  the  apparent  irreversibility  of  statistics  is  due  to  the 
way  the  problem  is  stated  in  it:  the  system  does  not  remain  for  long 
in  nonequilibrium  states,  and  therefore  rapidly  enters  equilibrium 
states;  it  remains  for  a  very  long  time  in  equilibrium  states,  so  that 
the  probability  of  spontaneously  leaving  these  states  can,  in  the 
majority  of  cases,  be  neglected. 

Quantum  mechanics  and  the  irreversibility  of  transitions.  The 
principle  of  detailed  balance  (see  Sec.  39)  is  fundamental  to  quantum 
statistics.  In  accordance  with  this  principle,  the  probabilities  of  direct 
and  inverse  transitions  are  equal  between  two  states  having  the  same 
statistical  weight.  However,  it  by  no  means  follows  from  this  prin- 
ciple that  the  probability  of  transition  from  an  equilibrium  to  a  non- 
equilibrium  state  is  the  same  as  for  a  transition  from  a  nonequilibrium 
to  an  equilibrium  state.  A  statistically  equilibrium  state  includes  very 
many  equiprobable  microstates,  while  a  nonequilibrium  state  con- 
tains a  comparatively  small  number  of  microstates  :  the  reason  why 
the  system  spends  the  greater  part  of  its  time  in  equilibrium  is  that 
there  are  incomparably  more  equilibrium  states  than  nonequilibrium 
states.  Each  given  microstate,  belonging  to  the  set  of  statistical  equilib- 
rium states,  passes  to  another  state  from  the  same  range  with  over- 
whelming probability,  while  to  a  nonequilibrium  state  it  passes  with 
a  negligible  probability.  A  nonequilibrium  state  passes  preferentially 
to  an  equilibrium  state  because  the  transition  to  a  state  of  less  equilib- 
rium can  occur  in  an  incomparably  smaller  number  of  equally  prob- 
able ways.  It  is  for  this  reason  that  a  system  "tends,"  as  it  were,  to 
equilibrium,  despite  the  identical  probability  for  direct  and  inverse 
transitions  between  any  two  initially  equiprobable  microstates. 

Poisson's  formula.  The  spontaneous  transition  of  a  system  from  an 
equilibrium  state  to  a  noticeably  nonequilibrium  state  is  of  very 
small  probability,  but  is  not  completely  impossible.  Deviations  of 
actual  values  from  their  averages  are  more  probable,  the  smaller  the 
system  in  which  they  occur.  If,  for  example,  gas  molecules  are  ob- 
served in  a  cube  with  a  side  10~6  cm,  then,  under  normal  conditions 
(0°  C,  760  mm  Hg)  the  mean  number  of  molecules  is  in  all  27.  The 
molecules  may  leave  for  neighbouring  portions,  so  that  their  actual 
number  in  a  certain  volume  will  exhibit  a  very  noticeable  deviation 
from  the  number  27. 

It  is  very  easy  to  determine  the  probability  that  there  will  be  N 
molecules  in  a  given  volume  F,  if  there  are  N0  molecules  contained 
in  the  total  volume  F0.  The  probability  of  finding  a  single  molecule 

in  the  volume  V  is  obviously  equal  to  -~-  .  Therefore,  the  probability 

of  finding  N  molecules  in  the  volume  F,  and  JV0  —  N  molecules  in  the 
remaining  portion  of  the  volume,  is  equal  to 


(N,-N)\N\ 


I  F\N/|  __ 
\VJ   I 


Sec.  48]  FLUCTUATIONS  549 

An  analogous  formula  was  derived  in  Sec.  39  for  the  probability  of 
obtaining  tails  k  times. 

Let  the  total  number  of  molecules  N0  be  arbitrarily  large  and  let 
N  be  any  number,  though  considerably  less  than  JV^.  We  replace  the 
factorial  ratio  thus: 

<  =  N9(N9-l)(N9-2)  ...  (N0~N)  = 


We  represent  the  quantities  1-^-1  and  (1 


where  N ^  ^  -by  definition  of  N.  Substituting  all  the  obtained  ex- 

'  0 

pressions  into  the  initial  formula,  we  find  the  required  probability 

(48.2) 

(Poisson's  formula).  It  will  be  shown  in  exercise  1  that  at  large  N 
the  distribution  (48.2)  has  a  very  sharp  maximum  at  N  —  N. 

Fluctuation  probability.  Here,  we  shall  obtain  a  general  formula 
for  fluctuation  probability  in  a  subsystem  of  a  large  system.  The  small 
volume  of  gas  just  considered  may  be  taken  as  a  special  case  of  such 
a  subsystem. 

Let  it  be  that  a  certain  deviation  from  statistical  equilibrium  has 
occurred  in  the  subsystem.  The  entire  large  system  will  thus  have 
deviated  somewhat  from  equilibrium.  The  ratio  of  the  probabilities 
for  the  equilibrium  and  nonequilibrium  states  of  the  large  system  is 
equal  to  the  ratio  of  the  statistical  weights  of  the  states 

w         G 
~w»  =  ~G~Q  '  (48.3) 

where  w  and  G  refer  to  the  large  system.  The  index  0  denotes  the 
equilibrium  value. 

Expressing  the  statistical  weight  in  terms  of  entropy  (S  =  \nG), 
we  obtain 

-^-=es-s*.  (48.4) 

Formula  (48.4)  can  be  given  a  somewhat  different  form.  Since  the 
large  system  is  closed,  its  energy  remains  unchanged  for  fluctuation 


550  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

in  the  subsystem:  <?  =  <£V  But  the  total  energy  and  the  free  energy 
F  are  related  thus:  F  =  £  —  0$,  jF0=<?0  —  8£0.  I*  follows  from  these 
equations  that  the  change  in  entropy  of  a  system  undergoing  fluc- 
tuation is  equal  to  the  change  in  free  energy,  taken  with  opposite 
sign,  divided  by  the  temperature: 


S-S0  =  =_pH  .  (48.5) 

The  change  in  free  energy  is  expressed,  in  accordance  with  (46.37), 
in  terms  of  the  minimum  work. 

Here,  Amin  is  the  minimum  external  work  which  must  be  performed 
on  the  system  in  order  to  produce  this  fluctuation  reversibly,  i.e., 
without  change  in  entropy. 

Thus,  the  fluctuation  probability  is  defined  by  the  following  formula 
derived  by  Einstein: 

_  jjnin 

w~e       e    .  (48.6) 

It  must  be  borne  in  mind  that  fluctuation  occurs  spontaneously,  with- 
out expending  any  external  work.  This  was  taken  into  account  by 
the  equation  <^=<f0.  The  same  deviation  of  actual  values  from 
equilibrium  values  in  the  subsystem  can  be  produced  without  expecting 
a  fluctuation  in  it  —  by  performing  work  Am\n  reversibly. 

Fluctuations  of  thermodynamic  quantities.  The  minimum  work 
expression  may  be  reduced  to  a  more  convenient  form  for  actual 
calculations.  We  shall  consider  that  the  large  system  has  been  divided 
into  two  parts:  a  small  part,  in  which  a  fluctuation  occurs  and  sta- 
tistical equilibrium  is  spontaneously  disrupted,  and  the  remaining 
part,  in  which  the  variation  of  quantities  is  reversible.  In  other  words, 
the  fluctuation  has  produced  a  deviation  from  equilibrium  only  in  a 
small  part  of  the  system.  The  quantities  referring  to  this  part  will  be 
written  without  any  indices,  while  those  relating  to  the  entire  remain- 
ing part  will  be  primed,  and  equilibrium  quantities  will  be  written 
with  0  index. 

By  definition,  the  minimum  work  is  calculated  in  the  case  of  constant 
entropy  of  the  whole  system;  i.e.,  as  if  instead  of  a  fluctuation  occur- 
ring there  is  some  change  in  the  quantities  at  the  expense  of  external 
action  which  does  not  destroy  the  statistical  equilibrium.  Given 
external  action,  the  work  is  equal  to  the  change  in  the  energy  of  the 
system  : 

4niln=A7+AJf'.  (48.7) 

The  work  here  is  equal  to  the  energy  change  taken  with  positive 
sign  (48.7)  because,  by  definition,  Am\n  is  performed  on  the  system. 


Sec.  48]  FLUCTUATIONS  551 

The  changes  in  the  quantities  in  the  large  system  are  very  small, 
being  less  the  larger  the  system,  so  that  A  $'  may  be  replaced  from  the 
thermodynamic  identity  (46.26): 

A^'=00A,S'  —  PQ&V.  (48.8) 

As  already  pointed  out,  -4min  is  calculated  in  the  case  of  reversible 
process.  Therefore,  AS'  =  —  A£  and,  in  addition,  AF'  =  —  AF,  of 
course.  Hence, 

"  (48.9) 


Large  fluctuations  are  highly  improbable.  Therefore,  the  quantities 
A$  and  AF  should  be  regarded  as  small  in  the  subsystem  also;  but 
it  is  now  necessary,  here,  to  make  a  series  expansion  up  to  second 
order  quantities  since,  otherwise,  J.rain  would  be  identically  equal  to 
zero  (close  to  the  maximum,  the  entropy  expansion  can  begin  only 
with  quadratic  terms): 


But  1^-1  =  60,  \-fiy     =  —  Po,  so  that  only  quadratic  terms  remain 

in  the  expression  for  Ami^  =  (&&  +  &#'  ).  These  terms  may  be  repre- 
sented in  somewhat  different  form.  Taking  advantage  of  the  fact  that 


\dV*!s 
we  write  ^4min  as 


_  _  idp\  m  t&*][\  __  /ae\   .    a2^  _  _  idp\  ___  i  ae 

~~       \8VIs'    \dSz!v~~  \8Slv'    dVVS  ~       \8SJv  "" 


+  T  *8  [(If).  AF  +  (S).  AS]  =  T<Ae  A^  -  ^  AF>  '          <48'10) 

And  so  Einstein's  formula  for  fluctuation  probability  is  transformed 
thus: 


-  A8A5) 

w  =  e  , 


where  the  0  index  is  omitted  from  0. 

Let  us  find  the  probability  for  volume  and  temperature  fluctuations. 
To  do  this  we  replace  Ap  and  A$  by  their  expressions  in  terms  of 
volume  and  temperature: 


652  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 


But  according  to  (46.39)  ho?-)    =  (ifp)  >  so  *^a*  ^10  right-hand  side 

of  equation  (48.11)  is  represented  as  the  product  of  two  factors  de- 
pendent only  upon  AF  and  A6: 

(48.12) 


It  is  now  easy  to  determine  the  mean  square  fluctuations  (A  V)2 
and  (AOJ2.  For  the  time  being  we  write 

).—-  <48-13> 

Then  the  square  of  the  volume  fluctuation  is  easily  written  in  the 
form 


=  -  -%-  In  f  e->  <AI/>*  d  (  A  I')  =  -  -£-  In  V-  =  7>l   .       (48.  14) 

<?a        J  v         '  da          r    a  2a  v  7 

—  00 

The  integration  was  justifiably  extended  from  —  oo  to  oo,  because 
the  integrand  is  very  small  for  large  A  V. 
We  finally  arrive  at  the  formula 


(48'15) 


It  must  be  remembered  that  this  is  not  a  volume  fluctuation,  generally, 
but  only  at  constant  temperature.  At  constant  entropy,  for  example, 
the  expression  would  have  been  different.  The  square  of  the  tempera- 
ture fluctuation,  too,  is  found  analogously: 


This  fluctuation  is  calculated  for  constant  volume. 

We  notice  that  the  square  of  the  fluctuation  of  volume  is  directly 

proportional  to  the  first  power  of  the  additive  quantity  (-^  —  1  since 
volume  is  an  additive  quantity.  Hence,  the  relative  volume  fluctuation 

|/(AF)2  /V  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square  root  of  the  dimen- 
sions of  the  system.  This  statement,  as  applied  to  energy,  was  ex- 

pressed in  Sec.  45.  The  temperature  fluctuation   (/  (A0)2  is  inversely 
proportional  to  the  square  root  of  the  specific  heat  and,  for  this  reason, 


Sec.  48]  FLUCTUATIONS  553 

naturally,  also  decreases  together  with  the  dimensions  of  the  sub- 
system. 

The  quantity  6  is  the  modulus  of  the  Gibbs  distribution  for  the  entire 
large  system.  When  a  fluctuation  occurs  in  the  subsystem,  0,  naturally, 
does  not  coincide  with  its  temperature,  i.e.,  with  its  distribution 
modulus,  which  refers  to  the  time  interval  during  which  the  sub- 
system is  quasi-independent  of  the  largo  system.  During  such  a  time 
interval,  6  is  not  the  temperature  of  the  large  system  either,  since  0 
has  the  meaning  of  temperature  only  in  equilibrium. 

The  temperature  and  energy  of  a  system  are  not  related  quite  un- 
ambiguously: at  a  given  energy,  temperature  can  experience  slight 
fluctuations,  and  at  a  given  temperature,  the  energy  fluctuates. 

Thermodynamic  inequalities.  From  formulae  (48.15)  and  (48.16) 
there  follow  the  very  important  thermodynamic  inequalities: 


The  state  of  a  substance  can  be  stable  only  when  these  inequalities 
are  satisfied.  If  the  equation  of  state  of  a  substance  indicates  that 
these  inequalities  break  down  «at  certain  p,  V,  and  0,  then  the  sub- 
stance is  unstable  for  such  p,  V,  and  0  and  must  break  up  into  separate 
phases  (liquid  and  vapour,  for  example),  to  which  other  values  of 
V  correspond. 

The  mean  product  of  the  fluctuations  of  two  quantities.  Let  us  now 
consider  together  the  fluctuations  of  volume  and  entropy.  In  this  case, 
the  formula  for  fluctuation  probability  looks  like  this: 

W=se-Ti[-  0£-)*  <**>•  <  -»(£)«  A"AS  '  (IIVH  .        (48.18) 

Here,  the  expression  on  the  right-hand  side  no  longer  separates  in- 
to the  product  of  two  factors  that  depend  on  each  variable  separate- 
ly. Therefore,  besides  the  volume  fluctuation  at  constant  entropy, 
and  the  entropy  fluctuation  at  constant  volume,  the  mean  value  of 
the  product  of  their  fluctuations  also  differs  from  zero:  AF  A$^0. 
Let  us  calculate  this  mean  from  formula  (48.18).  We  write  (48.18)  in 
shortened  notation: 


(48.19) 
In  this  notation,  the  required  quantity  appears  thus: 


AFS5T— 


—  00     — 00 


In  order  to  calculate  the  integral,  we  write  the  quadratic  expression 
in  the  exponent  in  the  form  of  a  sum  of  quadratic  terms 


554  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part    IV 

^T  AF+  -£Lr 


After  this  we  change  the  variables  in  the  integral,  denoting 


an 


The  integration  variable  £  varies  within  the  same  limits  as  A  F  and 
AS,  i.e.,  from  —  oo  to  oo.  The  integral  in  (48.19)  is 


(48.20) 


=  21/-JL 

r    at1 


Valla22~a12 

From  this  we  obtain  the  required  mean  value: 


AFAS=-  -- 


W* .  (48.5 


We  shall  now  show  that  this  mean  quantity  is  nothing  other  than 

__0(  —  |  =0f——  )  .  We  consider  the  inverse  quantity 
\dp/o         \dO/p 


_ee\      /  ap_\      ^/r  _  m  \  _  I8p\  iav\  __ 
dvh^  \Bvls  IBQ\    ~~\av)s    \dvis\9Sh 

\ 

ls 


.    ^ 

\dSlv       \dVls\dSh' 

But  if  the  pressure  is  represented  as  a  function  of  entropy  and  volume 
in  the  form  p=p  [S,  V  (S,  0)],  then  the  latter  expression  is  —  1-^-)  > 
whence  it  follows  that 

(48.22) 


The  volume  and  entropy  fluctuations  are  said  to  be  related,  or  cor- 
related. This  is  understandable,  since  if  the  volume  of  a  system 
increases,  then  the  statistical  weight  of  its  state  (i.e.,  its  entropy) 
also  increases. 

Scattering  of  light  by  fluctuations.  Because  of  fluctuations,  no 
medium  can  be  completely  homogeneous.  For  this  reason,  electro- 
dynamical  equations,  for  which  the  constants  of  the  medium  s  and  x 


Sec.  48]  FLUCTUATIONS  555 

are  regarded  as  being  fixed  and  everywhere  the  same,  are,  strictly 
speaking,  nowhere  valid.  There  always  exist  small  imperfections 
in  the  homogeneity  which  must  affect  the  propagation  of  light  in  the 
medium.  Plane  waves  cannot  be  propagated  in  a  nonhomogeneous 
medium;  fluctuations  cause  scattering  of  the  waves.  Let  us  consider 
the  quantity  of  scattered  energy  as  a  function  of  the  frequency. 

We  shall  consider  that  only  the  dielectric  constant  e  experiences 
fluctuations  (since  x  is  always  close  to  unity  in  transparent  media). 
The  wavelength  of  visible  light  X  is  about  half  a  micron,  which  is 
considerably  greater  than  the  mean  dimensions  of  regions  in  which 
any  noticeable  fluctuations  occur;  this  is  because  very  many  mole- 
cules are  still  contained  in  subsystems  of  volume  10~13  cm3  ~  X3, 
and  even  in  gases  under  normal  conditions. 

The  period  of  oscillation  in  a  light  wave  is  of  the  order  10~15  sec, 
and  is  considerably  less  than  the  time  during  which  fluctuation 
occurs.  A  time  of  at  least  10~10=  10~n  sec  is  required  for  the  establish- 
ment of  statistical  equilibrium  in  the  very  smallest  subsystem.  For 
example,  under  normal  conditions,  the  time  interval  between  two 
collisions  of  a  gas  molecule  is  about  10~9  sec,  and  there  is  absolutely 
no  reason  for  equilibrium  to  be  established  in  the  condensed  phase 
a  million  times  faster.  The  velocities  of  the  molecules  are  very  close 
in  all  phases  at  the  same  temperature,  and  interaction,  in  establish- 
ing equilibrium,  must  be  transmitted  over  distances  not  less  than 
10-6==10-7  cm. 

We  can,  therefore,  consider  that  in  the  region  where  fluctuation 
has  occurred  the  parameters  of  state  of  the  medium,  including  polar- 
izability,  have  changed  somewhat.  The  polarization  of  the  medium, 
produced  in  this  region  by  a  harmonic  light  wave,  depends  upon 
time  in  accordance  with  the  same  law  that  determines  the  electric 
field  of  an  incident  wave,  i.e.,  like  e-i(*'.  Since  the  dimensions  of 
the  region  are  very  much  smaller  than  the  wavelength  of  the  in- 
cident light,  the  polarization  has  the  same  phase  over  the  whole 
region.  Consequently,  the  polarization  may  be  integrated  over  the 
whole  region,  so  that  a  resultant  dipole  moment  is  obtained  propor- 
tional to  e~i&t.  The  light  scattering  problem  must  be  considered 
here  to  a  dipole  approximation,  in  accord  with  the  condition  r  <  X 
being  satisfied  (see  Sec.  19). 

The  total  scattered  energy  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the 

second  dipole-moment  derivative,  i.e.,  eo4  or  -rj-  provided  we  neglect 

the  way  that  polarizability  depends  upon  frequency. 

When  light  from  the  sun  passes  through  the  earth's  atmosphere, 
the  blue  rays  are  scattered  more  than  the  red,  because  the  wave- 
lengths of  the  blue  rays  are  shorter.  Therefore,  the  blue  portions 
of  the  solar  spectrum  predominate  in  the  scattered  light  from  the 
sky.  This  explains  the  colour  of  the  sky. 


556  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Exorcises 

1)  Write  clown  Poisson's  formula  (48.2)  for  large  N  and  AT".  We  represent 
(48.2)  as  __  _ 

„„     __          l  _  f  -N+NlnN-NlnN  +  N 
"N  —    ,  /~    _     p  » 


where  AM  is  written  to  the  same  accuracy  as  in  exercise  1,  Sec.  39. 

Jjf  /        £f  _  ~}f  \ 

Further,  wo  must  express  In  -^r-  as  —In  II  H  --  —  —  -1  and  expand  in  a  series 

up  to  the  second  term  inclusively.  This  loads  to  the  Gaussian  distribution: 

(N-N)2 


N 


The  same  value   (A  A7)2  is  obtained  from  the  exact  Poisson  formula  if  wo 
write  __ 

Tva        \TT  ^T«  -  NTT     ^     •*»"•     ^       V^  N  —~N~rf     &     ~^r     &       N 

N*  ==    >     A  2  Z^'N  ==  C  A    —  =r  A    --  r-     >     —  A-^~   =  6      ^  A7    --^r  A^  —  rrr  6^    = 

^  aAr      c,v  ^  -v!  ajv      a^ 

-  AT2  -h  .V;  lY2  -7/2  =  JV. 

2)  Find  the  pressure  fluctuation  for  constant  entropy,  and  the  entropy  fluc- 
tuation for  constant  pressure. 
Answers  : 


3)  Find  tho  mean  value  of  AOAp. 
Answer : 

-.-,-7-  O2 


4)  Find  the  fluctuation  of  the  energy  and  the  number  of  quanta  for  an  electro- 
magnetic field  of  given  frequency. 
Proceeding  from  the  expression 


wo  ol)tain,  with  the  aid  of  the  formula  derived  in  Sec.  45  (45.22) 

/tCO 


This  formula  can  be  represented  thus: 


(/•"-l         (e"«W-l)2J 


Sec.  49]  PHASE   EQUILIBRIUM  557 

~jp 

Introducing  the  number  of  quanta  of  given  frequency,  N^—  -,  — ,  wo  have 

n,  ca 


The  fluctuation  of  the  number  of  quanta  appears  differently  from  the  fluctua- 
tion of  the  number  of  particles  of  a  Boltzmann  gas  (cf.  exercise  1). 

5)  A  vertically  hanging  mathematical  pendulum  performs  fluctuation 
oscillations  about  the  equilibrium  position.  Find  the  mean  square  deviation 
angle. 

Let  us  denote  the  length  of  the  pendulum  by  I  and  its  mass  by  m.  The  poten- 
tial energy  at  a  deflection  angle  9  is  equal  to  —  mlg  92.  In  this  case  it  is  the 

£i 

minimum  work  appearing  in  the  fluctuation  probability.  This  gives 


6)  Determine  by  how  much  the  energy  flux  of  a  plane  electromagnetic  wave 
decreases  in  unit  length  in  a  gas  as  a  result  of  density  fluctuations. 
The  dielectric  constant  of  the  gas  is 

e  =  1  -f-  4nn$, 

where  n  is  the  number  of  molecules  in  unit  volume,  (}  is  the  polarizability  of  a 
single  molecule.  The  additional  dipolo  moment  introduced  iu  some  volume  V 
by  the  density  fluctuation  is  equal  to 

d  =  EQ  (N  -  N)  ft  -  E0  •  AJV  ^L  . 
The  square  of  its  time  derivative  is 


After  averaging  over  fluctuations,  we  obtain 

cF=  to*E$N\^~^\    . 


The  attenuation  in  the  energy  flux  of  a  plane  light  wave  over  unit  length  is 
equal  to 

2    d*     I  c          __      o4      (7—  I)2  __  87T3  (i—  I)2 
T  C8  V  I  "ST      °  ~    6:rc4  r        ~~  ~3          %4  ,7 


Sec.  49.  Phase  Equilibrium 

Separation  into  phases.  A  substance  consisting  of  molecules  of  a 
single  type  is  characterized  by  four  quantities:  the  number  of  par- 
ticles, the  temperature,  the  pressure,  and  the  volume.  Only  three 
of  the  four  quantities  are  independent,  since  the  equation  of  state 
must  always  be  satisfied.  Thus,  for  an  ideal  gas  the  Clapeyron  equation 
holds. 


558  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

An  ideal  gas  uniformly  fills  the  whole  of  its  permissible  volume 
and  in  this  sense  is  more  an  exception  than  the  rule.  Thus,  for  example, 
if  we  take  one  gram  of  water  at  a  temperature  of  20°  C,  then,  no  matter 
what  the  positive  pressure,  it  is  impossible  to  make  it  uniformly 
occupy  a  volume  10  cm3  (concerning  negative  pressures,  see  below 
in  this  section).  One  gram  of  water  at  20°  C  placed  in  such  a  volume 
separates  into  two  parts  —  liquid  and  gaseous;  in  other  words,  it 
does  not  remain  homogeneous.  And  a  certain,  very  definite,  equi- 
librium pressure  is  established  in  the  system. 

In  the  state  of  statistical  equilibrium,  the  mean  number  of  mole- 
cules going  from  water  to  steam  in  unit  time  is  equal  to  the  mean 
number  of  molecules  going  from  steam  to  water.  It  will  be  seen 
immediately  that  this  condition  cannot  be  satisfied  for  all  pressures: 
the  number  of  molecular  impacts  against  the  liquid  surface  is  directly 
proportional  to  the  pressure,  whereas  the  number  of  evaporating 
molecules  depends  very  weakly  upon  the  pressure.  Therefore,  at  a 
given  temperature,  only  one  pressure  corresponds  to  equilibrium 
between  liquid  and  vapour.  Under  other  conditions,  separation 
may  occur  into  a  liquid  and  a  solid,  into  a  gas  and  a  solid,  or  into  solids 
of  various  crystalline  modifications  or,  in  general,  into  phases. 

The  condition  for  phase  equilibrium.  Equilibrium  pressure  can 
be  determined  by  the  methods  of  statistical  physics  and  does  not 
require  a  detailed  examination  of  the  transition  from  one  phase  to 
another. 

In  the  equilibrium  state,  the  temperature  and  pressure  in  both 
phases  are,  of  course,  the  same.  This  condition  is  necessary  though 
not  sufficient  for  equilibrium.  In  addition,  a  sufficient  condition 
is  that  the  thermodynamic  potential  O  be  a  minimum  (see  Sec.  46). 
The  termodynamic  potential  is  additive:  it  is  equal  to  the  sum  of 
the  potentials  of  both  phases,  and  the  condition  of  it  being  a  minimum 
is  written  as  follows: 

d^^d^  +  d^.  (49.1) 

For  a  given  temperature  and  pressure,  the  entire  change  of  Ot  and 
O2  can  occur  only  due  to  a  change  in  the  number  of  particles  : 


(49.2) 
But  as  many  molecules  leave  one  phase  as  enter  another: 


Whence  it  follows  that 

(Hi-|A,)«itfi  =  0.  (49.3) 

Since  dNl  is  any  number,  the  phase-equilibrium  condition  consists 
in  the  equality  of  chemical  potentials: 

).  (49.4) 


Sec.  49]  PHASE  EQUILIBRIUM  559 

This  equation  may  be  represented  in  the  form  of  a  curve  in  the  p, 
6  plane.  In  other  words,  to  a  certain  temperature  there  corresponds 
very  definite  pressure. 

And  three  phases  of  the  same  substance  can  occur  in  equilibrium. 
In  this  case  the  equilibrium  condition  is 


These  two  equations  define  a  single  point  in  the  p,  0  plane  (the  triple 
point).  Out  of  it  come  the  equilibrium  curves  between  each  two 
of  the  three  phases  (see  Fig.  56). 

Heat  ol  transition.  Usually,  two  phases  of  the  same  substance 
differ  greatly  from  one  another:  their  specific  volume,  entropy, 
energy,  and  other  additive  quantities  experience  a  discontinuity  at 
the  transition  point. 

Let  us  find  the  quantity  of  heat  released  (or  absorbed)  at  the 
transition  point.  Since  the  transition  occurs  at  constant  pressure, 
the  quantity  of  heat  is  equal  to  the  change  in  the  heat  function. 
We  shall  refer  this  heat  to  a  single  molecule,  so  that  the  heat  function 
must  also  be  referred  to  a  single  molecule.  Such  a  heat  function  will 
be  denoted  by  i  (to  distinguish  it  from  7)  while  the  entropy  referred 
to  a  single  molecule  will  be  denoted  by  —  s.  The  heat  of  transition 
to  a  single  molecule  is  correspondingly  equal  to 

?  =  *a  —  *i-  (49-6) 

The  heat  function  is  connected  with  the  thermodynamic  potential 
by  the  relation  /  =  O  +  0/S.  Going  over  to  quantities  which  relate 
to  a  single  molecule,  and  applying  (46.48),  we  obtain 

i  =  fji  +  6s.  (49.7) 

Whence 


But  in  equilibrium  [L2=pi  so  that  the  heat  of  transition  is  equal 
to  the  temperature  multiplied  by  the  entropy  change: 

q  =  6  (Sz-sJ.  (49.8) 

This  result  is  quite  understandable  since  phase  transition  is  a  rever- 
sible process. 

The  Clausius-Clapeyron  equation.  Let  us  consider  two  phases  of 
the  same  substance  occurring  in  mutual  equilibrium.  We  suppose 
that  the  temperature  in  the  equilibrium  system  is  changed  somewhat. 
It  is  required  to  determine  how  the  pressure  must  be  changed  so  as 
to  keep  the  phase  equilibrium  intact.  In  other  words,  the  derivative 

-—-  must  be  determined  along  the  equilibrium  curve. 


560                                               STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  dependence  of  equilibrium  pressure  oil  temperature  is  given 
in  the  form  of  an  implicit  function  (49.4).  Hence,  the  derivative  is 
found  according  to  the  usual  rule: 

radz,-^-] 

dP.  ^  _  I  ___  ae__  _Jp  .  (49  9} 

"56  ""             -  l    '  ' 


___     __  _ 

raW-  ii,)  I 

I.       <>P       Jo 
From  (46.48) 


where  v  is  the  volume  referred  to  a  single  molecule.  Multiplying  the 
numerator  and  denominator  of  the  right  -hand  side  of  (49.9)  by  6, 
and  making  use  of  (49.8),  we  obtain  the  required  equation: 

dP    ___  _      __?    __  (AQ  11\ 

do'  ~  T(v~-vj'  '  i^.nj 

which  is  known  as  the  Clausius-Clapeyron  equation. 

Let  us  assume  that  a  transition  is  considered  for  which  q  is  positive, 

for  example,  fusion.  Then  the  sign  of  the  derivative  -,*j-  is  dependent 

upon  which  phase  has  the  greatest  specific  volume  :  liquid  or  solid. 
For  example,  the  specific  volume  of  water  at  the  melting  point  is 

less  than  the  specific  volume  of  ice,  so  that  ~^-  is  a  negative  quantity. 

If  the  pressure  above  an  equilibrium  system  of  water  and  ice  is 
raised,  the  melting  temperature  falls. 

In  the  transition  to  the  gaseous  phase  (vapourization,  if  the  transi- 
tion is  by  a  liquid,  or  sublimation,  if  the  transition  is  by  a  solid  body) 
we  have  the  inequality  v^v^.  Neglecting  vl  in  equation  (49.11) 


and  replacing  v2  by  — ,  we  obtain 

Q 

dlnG 


Vapour 

'       This  derivative  is  always  positive.  Therefore,  the 
water  equilibrium  curves  close  to  the  triple  point 
f&~    may  be  represented  approximately  as  shown  in 
Fig.  55.  The   equilibrium   curve   between  water 
rC£>        "       and  ice  has  a  negative  derivative  in  accordance 
*-/?     with  what  has  been  said. 


Fig.  55  Van  der  Waals'  equation.  We  shall  now  show  how, 

from  the  equation  of  state  of  a  substance,  it  is 
possible  to  ascertain  the  necessity  of  a  phase  transition.  It  is 
convenient  for  this  to  make  use  of  the  well-known  van  der 
Waals  equation  of  state  for  "real  gases."  This  equation  cannot 
strictly  be  derived  from  the  fundamentals  of  statistical  mechan- 


Sec.  49]  PHASE   EQUILIBRIUM  561 

ics  on  any  assumptions,  and  neither  is  it  supported  by  accurate 
quantitative  experiments.  Nevertheless,  it  is  the  simplest  of  the 
equations  suited  for  a  qualitative  description  of  a  very  wide  range 
of  states,  from  an  ideal  gas  to  its  condensation  into  a  liquid.  Let  us 
remind  ourselves  how  the  van  der  Waals  equation  is  formed. 

It  is  first  of  all  assumed  that  a  gas  cannot  be  compressed  indef- 
initely, but  only  to  a  certain  volume  6,  which  is  related  to  the  charac- 
teristic volume  of  all  the  molecules.  This  is  taken  into  account  in 
the  Clapeyron  equation  pV~NQ  by  putting  F — b  instead  of  V 
(in  actual  fact  this  has  no  strict  foundation,  even  if  the  molecules 
are  regarded  as  solid  spheres).  Over  large  distances  between  mole- 
cules the  acting  forces  are  those  of  attraction,  which  fall  off  rapidly; 
iii  the  absence  of  such  forces,  condensation  into  a  liquid  would  be 
impossible  altogether.  These  forces  reduce  the  pressure.  The  reduc- 
tion in  pressure  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square  of  the  volume 
occupied  by  the  gas;  this  can  be  shown  by  the  following  reasoning. 
The  gas  pressure  on  a  wall  is  proportional  to  the  density  of  its  kinetic 
energy.  The  kinetic  energy  of  a  molecule  incident  on  a  wall  decreases 
clue  to  the  attraction  of  this  molecule  to  the  other  molecules  occurring 
in  the  volume.  This  attraction  is  due  principally  to  the  couplings 
of  the  molecules,  because  the  contribution  of  triple  interactions  is 
slight  in  the  case  of  small  gas  densities.  The  quantity  of  interacting 
pairs  is  proportional  to  the  square  of  the  gas  density,  or  inversely 
proportional  to  the  square  of  the  volume  it  occupies.  Since  the  energy 
stems  from  the  attractive  forces,  its  density  is  negative,  and  it  results 
in  a  reduced  pressure.  The  van  der  WaaJs  equation  is  finally  written 
thus : 

P-T^-TT.  <49-13> 

where  the  second  term  takes  into  account  the  attractive  forces. 
This  term  in  the  equation  of  state  can  also  be  rigorously  substantiated 
by  the  methods  of  statistical  mechanics,  but,  of  course,  only  at  den- 
sities which  are  still  very  much  less  than  the 
density  of  the  liquid  phase,  where  each  mol- 
ecule is  in  constant  interaction  with  many 
neighbouring  molecules.  Therefore,  the  exact 
equation  of  state  for  a  real  liquid  must  be 
immeasurably  more  complex  than  the  van 
der  Waals  equation.  It  is  doubtful  whether 
it  is  possible  to  write  a  single  exact  equa-  j^-  5(j 

tion  appli cable  to  a  wide  class  of  liquids. 

Van  der  Waals'  equation  and  phase  transition.  We  shall  now  show 
how,  from  the  van  der  Waals  equation,  the  existence  of  a  range  of 
states,  in  which  the  substance  separates  into  gaseous  and  liquid 
phases,  can  be  demonstrated.  Equation  (49.13)  is  third  degree  in 

36-0060 


562  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

volume.  It  must  have  three  real  roots  for  certain  values  of  6  and  p. 
In  other  words,  the  pressure-  versus  -volume  curve  at  constant  tem- 
perature (isotherm)  is  of  the  form  ABFD,  as  shown  in  Fig.  56.  But 

the  derivative  (—  ^1  is  positive  between  the  points  B  and  F  and, 
in  accordance  with  the  first  inequality  of  (48.17),  the  state  of  the 


substance    is    unstable   if    -yf^l  >0.  Hence,  the  necessity    for    the 

separation  of  the  substance  into  two  phases  in  this  region. 

The  portion  of  the  curve  AB  corresponds  to  the  liquid  state  (small 
volume).  As  the  pressure  is  reduced  the  liquid  expands  to  the  point 
K,  after  which  change  occurs  along  the  straight  line  KL.  The  points 
K  and  L  are  uniquely  defined  from  the  equality  condition  of  the 
chemical  potentials  (49.4),  and  the  intermediate  points  along  the 
line  correspond  to  a  mixture  of  liquid  in  a  state  corresponding  to 
J\,  and  vapour  in  a  state  L.  We  notice  that  the  position  of  the  point 
K,  at  a  temperature  corresponding  to  the  given  isotherm,  is  defined 
uniquely. 

The  portion  KB  is  not  absolutely  unstable,  since  on 

The  states  of  this  portion  can  be  attained  without  allowing  the 
formation  of  vapour  bubbles  in  the  liquid  (a  superheated  liquid). 
For  this  the  liquid  must  be  free  from  foreign  agents,  for  example, 
bubbles  of  dissolved  gases,  which  favour  vapourisation.  Sometimes 
the  portion  KL  lies  partly  below  the  abscissa  axis,  thus  corresponding 
to  a  negative  pressure,  i.e.,  an  extension  of  the  liquid.  A  liquid  can 
indeed  be  extended  if  it  adheres  everywhere  to  the  walls  of  the  vessel 
and  does  not  have  a  free  surface.  The  portion  FL  corresponds  to 
a  supercooled  vapour,  which  can  be  obtained  if  condensation  centres 
are  prevented  from  forming.  Such  condensation  nuclei  or  centres 
easily  arise  from  ions,  for  example.  This  is  the  underlying  principle 
of  the  Wilson  cloud-chamber  for  the  observation  of  the  tracks  of 
charged  particles. 

The  critical  point.  At  a  sufficiently  high  temperature,  the  first 
term  on  the  right  in  the  van  der  Waals  equation  predominates  over 
the  second.  The  equation  then  becomes  very  similar  to  the  Clapeyron 
equation  for  a  volume  V  —  b.  But  this  equation  has  only  one  real 
root  for  each  value  of  p.  This  corresponds  to  the  well-known  fact 
that  at  high  temperatures  a  substance  does  not  split  into  two  phases 
at  all. 

Let  us  find  the  temperature  at  which  separation  into  phases  ceases. 
On  the  corresponding  isotherm  A'  CD'  (Fig.  56)  the  points  B  and 

F,  where  the  derivative  \-^\  becomes  zero,  merge  into  one  point  C, 

and  the  region  of  unstable  states  disappears.  All  three  roots  of  equa- 
tion (49.13)  merge  at  the  point  C,  so  that  C  corresponds  to  the  triple 


Sec.  49]  PHASE  EQUILIBRIUM  563 

root  of  this  equation.  But  the  expansion  of  the  function  with  respect 
to  the  difference  F  —  Vc  must  begin  with  a  third-order  term  if  Fc 
is  a  triple  root.  The  linear  and  quadratic  terms  in  the  expansion 
become  zero  if  the  first  and  second  pressure  derivatives  with  respect 
to  volume  are  equal  to  zero  at  the  point  C.  It  is  easy  from  this  to 
determine  the  position  of  the  point  C  from  the  van  der  Waals 
equation. 

Let  us  write  down  the  condition  that  the  first  and  second  deriv- 
atives become  zero: 


dp  \     _  NQc         ,     2«  ,          . 

""  ~          ^        +      *    "    '  (          } 


„  _6a    __  (  9      } 

8**     "  ~V-  fc3   "    >4     ~  (  } 


(Vc 

From  this  we  obtain 

Vc-b  _    Vc 

2        ~~     3     ' 
or 

Fc-36.  (49.16) 

Then,  from  (49.14),  we  find 

27 


a  — 
so  that 

80  =  —-^-.  (49.17) 

27    No 

The  pressure  at  the  point  C  is  determined  from  the  van  der  Waals 
equation : 


. __       __ 

™   Fc_6         Fc2  -  27  62  '  . 

If  we  represent  the  phase  equilibrium  curve  in  the  p,  6  plane,  then 
this  curve  will  end  in  the  point  p  =  pc,  6  =  6c.  C  is  called  the  critical 
point.  Separation  into  phases  does  not  occur  at  temperatures  6>6c. 
The  critical  point  can  exist  only  on  the  equilibrium  curve  between 
two  such  phases,  which  have  no  feature  that  is  incapable  of  varying 
continuously.  An  example  of  such  a  feature  is  the  regularity  of  crystal 
structure:  in  principle,  the  position  of  an  atom  in  an  ideal  crystal 
defines  the  position  of  the  whole  crystal  (with  the  exception,  naturally, 
of  its  orientation  in  space).  Yet,  the  position  of  an  atom  in  a  liquid 
affects  only  the  position  of  its  closest  neighbours.  And  so  for  certain 
substances  a  continuous  transition  between  the  solid  crystalline  phase 
and  the  liquid  phase  is  impossible.  The  curve  dividing  the  crystalline 
and  liquid  phases  cannot  end  and  cannot,  therefore,  have  a  critical 
point. 

36* 


664  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  law  ol  corresponding  states.  Eliminating  the  constants  a,  6 
and  N  with  the  aid  of  (49.16),  (49.17),  and  (49.18),  we  have 


(49.19) 


The  last  of  these  three  equations  shows  by  how  much  the  equation 
of  state  of  a  substance  differs,  at  the  critical  point,  from  that  of  an 

o 

ideal  gas:  pc  Vc  =  -%•  NQc.  But  we  should  note  that,  as  a  general  rule 

this  relationship  is  not  really  satisfied.  As  has  already  been  mentioned, 

the  van  der  Waals  equation  is  qualitative  in  character,  and  so  there  is 

^ 
nothing  surprising  in  the  fact  that  for  real  substances  pc  Vc  T^-TT  NQc. 

If  we  now  substitute  (49.19)  in  (49.13),  we  get 

_  3  IJL\*  (4Q  *0\ 

m  (          ' 


JL  _  _  _ 

PC  ~  (3F/FC)-1          \Vc 

Formula  (49.20)  expresses  a  special  form  of  the  so-called  law  of  corres- 
ponding states  :  for  two  different  substances,  the  ratios  -^-  ,  -v.— 

Q  PC          V  C 

and  —  are  related  by  a  single  universal  equation.  It  should  be  noted 

that  in  general  form  the  law  of  corresponding  states,  especially  for 
substances  of  similar  structure,  is  satisfied  better  in  practice  than  the 
specific  formula  (49.20)  based  on  the  interpolation  van  der  Waals 
equation,  because  this,  more  general,  law  does  not  impose  a  definite 
functional  form  on  the  equation  of  state.  However,  there  are,  of 
course,  deviations  from  the  law  of  corresponding  states  also  :  the  ratios 

-y—  are  not  strictly  the  same  for  two  substances  having  identical 


PC  Oc 

The  properties  of  a  substance  elose  to  the  critical  point.  Let  us  now 

investigate  the  properties  of  a  substance  close  to  the  critical  point  in 
general  form,  without  assuming  that  the  van  der  Waals  equation 
(49.13)  holds.  We  shall  only  make  use  of  the  fact  that  the  derivative 

(iRT/  '  c^ose  ^°  ^^e  critical  point,  must  tend  to  zero  like  the  square  of  the 
difference  V  —  Vc,  because  the  expansion  of  p  on  the  critical  isotherm 
begins  with  a  term  proportional  to  (V  —  Fc)3.  At  temperatures  suffi- 

ciently close  to  critical,  1-ojH    differs  from  n^L^e     ^y  first-order 

quantities  in  (0  —  0c),  because  the  relationship  between  pressure  and 
temperature  close  to  the  critical  point  does  not  exhibit  any  peculiari- 

ties. Thus,  the  expansion  \-^\   in  the  critical  region  is  of  the  form 


(|f)e=-X(F-Fc)2-v(e-8c).  (49.21) 


Sec.  49]  PHASE  EQUILIBRIUM  566 


Here,  v  >  0,  because  the  inequality  -        <  0  must  always  be  satis- 
fied at  temperatures  higher  than  critical.  Therefore,  A>0  also.  At 

temperatures  lower  than  critical,   1^-)    becomes  zero  at  two  points. 

\vv  /e 

They  correspond  to  B  and  F  in  Fig.  56 


VB  —  Fc  -  -  l/~"(6c-6)  ,     FF  -  Fc  =  I/Y  (6c~6)  '       (49>22) 

Let  us  now  find  the  points  on  the  isotherm  that  correspond  to  K 
and  L,  i.e.,  to  phase  equilibrium. 

For  this  we  make  use  of  the  phase  equilibrium  condition  [JLK  ==  \LL. 
It  is  conveniently  written  in  the  form  of  an  integral  taken  along  the 
isotherm  on  which  the  points  K  and  L  lie  : 


(49.23) 


Multiplying  by  N  and  then  replacing  dO  by  V  dp  for  0  =  const,  we 
obtain 

L  L  L 


K  K  K 

L 

because  the  integral  \dp  is  equal  to  PL — PK  and  becomes  zero  accord  - 

K 

ing  to  the  condition  PL  =  PK-  Now  substituting  the  initial  expression 
(49.21)  we  see  that  the  equality  of  chemical  potentials  reduces  to  the 
requirement 

VL 

'(F-  Fc)  [X(F-  Fc)2  +  v  (6  -  8c)]  dV=  0.  (49.24) 

K 

The  integrand  is  odd  in  F — Fc.  Therefore  the  integral  becomes  zero, 
if  at  the  integration  limits  (i.e.,  FK — Fc  and  VL — Fc)  the  values  of 
F — Fc  are  equal  and  opposite  in  sign  or,  in  other  words,  the  volumes 
VL  and  FJC  differ  equally  from  critical. 

We  also  represent  the  condition  of  pressure  equality  in  integral 
form 

L  VL 


^dF=0.  (49.25) 

Substituting  (49.21)  here  and  integrating,  we  obtain 


566  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

y  (  VL-  Vcf  +  v  (  VL-  Vc)  (8 -6c) -  y  (  VK  -  Vc)*  - 

-v(FK-Fc)(e-6c)=0. 

Making  use  of  the  fact  that  VK — Vc  — — (Fi. — Vc),  we  obtain  the  re- 
quired eqiiation 

V  (  VL  -  Vc)3  +  v  ( Vi.  -  Vc)  (6  -  6c)  =  0 , 

O 

from  which  it  follows  that 


VL  -  Vc  =  Vc  -  VK  =  p      .  (49.26) 

Thus,  close  to  the  critical  point,  the  region  of  absolutely  unstable  states 

is  narrower,  in  the  ratio    -  -  ,  than  the  whole  region  where  phase 

V* 
separation  occurs. 

Let  us  now  find  the  heat  of  transition  close  to  the  critical  point. 
By  definition  we  have 

Q**Qc(tiL-flK)  -  Oc~       (VL  -  VK).  (49.27) 


d 

At  the  critical  point,  the   derivative  -^  maintains  a  finite  value 
it  is  equal  to  (-^1^  •  Therefore,  the  heat  of  transition  is  proportional 

to  (6c  —  6).  Right  at  the  critical  point  it  becomes  zero,  as  expected. 

Close  to  the  critical  point,  the  density  of  the  substance  experiences 

large  statistical  fluctuations,  because  density  fluctuations  are  inverse- 

ly proportional    to    f-^yL-  -But,  as  we  have  seen  in  the  previous  sec- 

tion, this  results  in  a  strong  scattering  of  light.  As  a  result  of  this  scat- 
tering, the  substance  acquires  a  certain  turbidity,  similar  to  the  tur- 
bidity of  opal  (critical  opalescence). 

Phase  transitions  of  the  second  kind.  At  the  phase  transition  point 
the  thermodynamic  potentials  of  both  phases  are  equal.  The  other 
additive  quantities  (such  as  entropy,  energy,  and  volume)  experience 
discontinuities.  But  there  also  exist  phase  transitions  for  which  not 
the  additive  quantities  themselves  are  discontinuous,  but  only  their 
derivatives  —  specific  heat,  compressibility,  etc.  An  example  of  such 
a  transition  was  already  given  in  Sec.  43:  this  is  the  transition  of 
helium  at  a  temperature  of  2.2°  K. 

The  specific  heat  at  the  transition  point  changes  discontinuously. 
Another  example  is  the  transition  of  iron  from  the  ferromagnetic  to 
the  nonfeiTomagnetic  state  at  770°  C  (the  Curie  point). 

Phase  transitions  of  the  second  kind  are  very  frequently  observed 
in  crystals.  In  this  case  they  correspond  to  a  certain  change  in  the 
translational  or  vibrational  symmetry  of  the  lattice.  Since  the  form 


Sec.  49]  PHASE  EQUILIBRIUM  567 

of  the  symmetry  cannot  change  continuously  (the  symmetry  property 
either  exists  or  it  does  not),  symmetry  always  changes  disconti- 
nuously.  If  an  entropy  discontinuity  is  then  experienced,  we  have 
a  phase  transition  of  the  first  kind;  if  the  entropy  is  continuous,  and 
the  derivatives  experience  discontinuities,  the  transition  is  of  the 
second  kind. 

Let  us  interrelate  the  derivative  discontinuities  of  various  quantities 
on  the  lines  of  phase  transitions  of  the  second  kind.  Since  entropy  and 
volume  are  continuous,  we  write 

AS  =  #2  -  $i  --=  0  ;  AF=  P2  -  V\  =  0.  (49.28) 

Let  us  differentiate  these  equations  with  respect  to  temperature  along 
the  transition  line.  We  then  obtain 


Here  -~-  denotes  the  derivative  of  pressure  with  respect  to  temperature 
along  the  transition  curve.  Further,  (yH  —""(#(5")  tsec  (46.46)] 
and  i-vnr)  =  "-.Whence,  after  eliminating  A(~-J  ,  we  obtain 


Thus,  along  phase  -transition  lines  of  the  second  kind,  the  specific  heat 
discontinuity  at  constant  pressure  is  associated  with  a  compressibility 
discontinuity.  A  similar  expression  can  also  easily  be  found  for  the 
discontinuity  in  specific  heat  at  constant  volume. 

Sometimes,  phase  transition  lines  of  the  first  kind  become  a  phase 
transition  line  of  the  second  kind  at  some  point.  If  the  transition  is 
associated  with  a  change  in  symmetry,  then  neither  line  can  simply 
terminate. 

The  thermodynamic  theory  of  phase  transitions  of  the  second  kind 
has  been  developed  by  L.  D.  Landau  (see  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lif- 
shits.  Statistical  Physics,  Gostekhizdat,  1951.) 

Exercises 

1  )  Find  the  specific  heat  of  one  of  the  phases  of  a  substance  along  the  curve 
of  phase  transitions. 

From  the  definition  of  specific  heat 

3V 


568  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

2)  Show  that  Cp  becomes  infinite  at  the  critical  point. 

Use  the  result  of  exercise  4,  Sec.  46,  and  the  condition  defining  the  critical 
point. 

3)  Find  the  discontinuity  in  specific  heat  (expressed  in  terms  of  compressi- 
bility discontinuity)  at  constant  volume  along  a  phase -transition  line  of  the 
second. 


Sec.  50.  Weak  Solutions 

Weak  solutions  and  ideal  gases.  Weak  solutions  exhibit  many  regu- 
larities which  make  them  similar  to  ideal  gases.  The  reason  for  this 
similarity  can  be  easily  seen  in  the  fact  that  the  molecules  of  a  dis- 
solved substance  in  a  weak  solution  interact  just  as  little  as  ideal  gas 
molecules.  But  the  molecules  of  a  dissolved  substance  interact  strongly 
with  the  surrounding  molecules  of  the  solvent,  whence  the  differences 
between  a  solution  and  a  gas. 

The  thermodynamic  potential  of  a  weak  solution.  We  shall  proceed 
from  the  general  expression  for  free  energy  in  classical  statistics: 

r  -1 
jF=  -einje    e  dT  (50.1) 

[we  have  omitted  the  unessential  factor  (2  nh)N].  The  integral  is  taken 
over  all  physically  different  states  of  the  system.  If  one  takes  into 
account  the  identity  of  all  the  N  molecules  of  the  solvent  and  the  n  mole- 
cules of  the  dissolved  substance,  ho  can  extend  the  statistical  integral 
over  the  entire  phase  space  and  divide  it  by  the  total  number  of  per- 
mutations of  all  identical  particles.  The  number  of  such  permutations 
is#!  wl. 

We  now  write  down  the  thermodynamic  potential  of  a  weak  solution 

(50.2) 

where  the  integral  extends  over  the  whole  phase  space  of  the  system. 
Let  us  expand  the  expression  in  brackets,  on  the  right-hand  side  of 

(50.2),  in  powers  of  the  small  quantity  -~-  ,  taking  into  account  that 
the  zeroth  term  in  the  expansion  is  the  thermodynamic  potential 
of  a  pure  solvent  O0.  In  addition,  we  replace  In  n\  by  win  —  according 
to  Stirling's  formula: 

(50.3) 


We  can  refine  the  dependence  of  B  (p,  8,  N)  on  the  number  of  solvent 
particles  N  by  noting  that  the  thermodynamic  potential  must  be  an 


Sec.  50]  WEAK  SOLUTIONS  569 

additive  function  of  N  and  n.  In  other  words,  if  N  and  n  increase  a 
certain  number  of  times,  for  example,  twice,  O  must  also  increase 
by  a  factor  of  two.  But  in  (50.3),  this  requirement  is  satisfied  directly 
only  by  the  potential  of  the  pure  solvent  O0,  equal  to  N  [Z0,  where 
[JLO  is  the  chemical  potential  of  the  pure  solvent.  For  the  second  and 
third  terms  to  be  additive,  let  us  first  write  the  third  term  in  the  form 


After  this,  the  thermodynamic  potential  will  look  like 


In  order  to  obtain  an  additive  expression,  we  must  demand  that 

JD 

the  function  -~-  -f  6  In  N  should  not  be  dependent  on  N  at  all.  The 

result  is  a  general  expression  for  the  thermodynamic  potential  of  a 
weak  solution: 

9,0).  (50.4) 


The  chemical  potential  of  a  solvent  in  solution  is  equal  to 


while  the  chemical  potential  of  the  solute  is 


Osmotic  pressure.  Certain  semipermeable  membranes  pass  solvent 
molecules  freely,  but  do  not  pass  molecules  of  the  dissolved  substance. 
The  solvent  must  be  in  statistical  equilibrium  on  both  sides  of  such  a 
membrane.  But  this  is  possible  only  when  the  chemical  potentials  of 
the  pure  solvent  and  the  solvent  in  the  solution  beyond  the  membrane 
are  equal.  The  temperature  of  the  substance  on  both  sides  of  the  mem- 
brane is,  of  course,  the  same,  for  otherwise  equilibrium  could  not  set 
in.  Only  the  pressure  can  differ,  provided  the  pressure  difference  is 
held  in  check  by  the  membrane.  Denoting  the  pressure  difference  by 
A  p,  we  obtain  the  equilibrium  condition: 

Ho  (P>  0)  =  ^  (P  +  Ap,  0)  =  MP  +  Ap,  0)  -  -^  .         (50-7) 

Let  us  expand  \LQ  in  a  series  in  powers  of  Ap,  to  the  linear  approxi- 
mation. This  expansion  is  justified,  since  the  pressure  difference  for  a 
liquid  Ap  is  a  small  quantity.  Therefore, 

Ap,0)  =  ^(p,0)  +       -  Ap.  (50.8) 


570  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

But  the  derivative  -—•  is  equal  to  the  volume  of  a  single  molecule  of 
pure  solvent: 

1*  =  JL 

dp         N  ' 
Whence  we  obtain  the  equation 

V-kp  =  nQ.  (50.9) 

The  excess  pressure  A  p  in  the  solution  is  called  the  osmotic  pressure. 
liquation  (50.9)  bears  a  striking  resemblance  to  the  Clapcyron  equa- 
tion for  ideal  gases.  It  was  originally  found  experimentally  and  served 
as  the  basis  for  the  formulation  of  a  thermodynamic  theory  of  solu- 
tions. We  obtained  equation  (50.9)  by  proceeding  from  the  general 
principles  of  statistics. 

Phase  equilibrium  of  a  solvent  (Raoult's  laws).  We  shall  now  consider 
another  case,  when  equilibrium  is  also  established  between  solvent 
molecules.  Let  the  solution  occur  in  equilibrium  with  another  phase 
of  the  solvent,  while  the  solute  does  not  pass  into  this  phase.  We  find 
the  displacement  of  the  phase  equilibrium  curve  in  the  p,  0  plane. 

Let  us  call  the  chemical  potential  of  the  phase  into  which  the  solute 
does  not  pass,  jij.  Then  the  phase-equilibrium  condition  of  the  pure 
solvent  is  determined  by  the  equation 

Mp>0)  =  Mp,8),  (50-10) 

while  the  equilibrium  of  the  other  phase  of  the  solvent  and  solution  is 
displaced  and  is  given  by  the  following  condition  : 


^  (p  +  Ap,8  +  A6)  =  ^(p  +  Ap,6  +  A6)  —  ».  (50.11) 

Let  us  expand  the  chemical  potentials  in  a  series  in  &p  and  A0: 
ji,  (p  +  Ap,0  +  A6)  —  [ioO>  +  Ap,0  +  A0)  -  MP,0) 


=  (»!  —  i'0)Ap  —  K  —  6'0)A6.  (50.12) 

We  shall  now  assume  that  the  pressure  in  the  system  is  the  same  as 
above  a  pure  solvent,  i.e.,  that  Ap  =  0.  Then  the  equilibrium-temper- 
ature displacement  A  6  will  be  defined: 


where  Q~NQ  (sl  —  s0)  is  the  heat  of  the  phase  transition  of  the  pure 
solvent.  For  vapourization  Q>0;  therefore,  A0>0  if  the  solute  does 
not  pass  into  vapour,  so  that  the  equilibrium  temperature  is  raised. 
Indeed,  the  solution  has  a  higher  boiling  point  than  the  pure  solvent. 


Sec.  50]  WEAK  SOLUTIONS  571 

Let  us  now  suppose  that  the  solute  does  not  pass  into  the  solid  phase 
of  the  solvent.  Then  Q  is  the  heat  of  solidification,  Q  <  0.  It  is  seen 
from  this  that  the  fusion  temperature  of  the  solution  is  lower  than  that 
of  the  pure  solvent.  The  use  of  cooling  mixtures  is  based  on  this  prop- 
erty of  solutions. 

Let  us  now  consider  equilibrium  at  a  given  temperature,  A6  =  0. 
Then  the  reduction  in  equilibrium  pressure  over  the  solution  is  deter- 
mined from  (50.12): 

(50.14) 

V  ' 


—  7  —    -r^. 

fa  —  t'0)A 

If  a  solution  is  in  equilibrium  with  vapour,  then  i\^>  VQ.  The  product 
Ni\  is  the  volume  of  the  entire  solvent  in  the  vapour  state.  If  it  were 
possible  to  transform  the  solute  to  vapour  together  with  the  solvent, 
the  partial  pressure  of  the  molecules  of  the  substance  would  equal  the 
reduction  in  the  equilibrium  pressure  above  the  solution.  The  relative 
pressure  reduction  —  &p/p  is  equal  to  the  concentration  of  the  solu- 
tion n/N. 

Solute  equilibrium.  A  solution  is  termed  saturated  if  it  is  in  equilib- 
rium with  the  dissolved  substance.  The  equilibrium  condition  con- 
sists in  that  the  chemical  potential  of  a  pure  solute,  (ji'0,  is  equal  to  its 
chemical  potential  in  the  dissolved  state  : 

^0  =  li'  =  ein-^  +  X(p,6).  (50.15) 

We  have  supposed  that  the  saturated  solution  is  also  still  regarded  as 
weak,  i.e.,  n0<^N. 

If  a  pure  substance  occurs  in  a  gaseous  state,  then  its  chemical  poten- 
tial depends  upon  pressure  according  to  the  law  [see  (47.17)] 

|i/0=einp  +  /1(8).  (50.16) 

The  function  x  (p>  6)  is  but  slightly  dependent  on  the  external  pressure  : 
X  (p,  6)  is  determined  by  the  properties  of  the  condensed  phase,  which 
do  not  change  when  the  external  pressure  varies  over  several  atmos- 
pheres. Comparing  (50.15)  and  (50.16)  and  taking  antilogarithms,  we 
find  that  the  equilibrium  concentration  of  the  dissolved  gas  is  propor- 
tional to  its  pressure  above  the  liquid  (Henry's  law) 

^-=a(0)p.  (50.17) 

The  coefficient  of  p  depends  very  weakly  on  pressure. 

Heat  of  solution.  The  heat  of  solution  is  equal  to  the  difference  in 
the  heat  functions  of  the  substances  comprising  a  solution  before  and 
after  being  dissolved.  The  heat  function  is  related  to  the  thermo- 
dynamic  potential  in  the  following  way  : 


572  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part   IV 


Therefore,  the  heat  of  solution  is  equal  to 

(50.19) 


where  (JL'O  is  the  chemical  potential  of  the  dissolved  substance.  The 
quantities  appearing  here  may  be  expressed  in  terms  of  the  concentra- 
tion of  the  saturated  solution  nQ/N  with  the  aid  of  the  saturation 
condition  (50.15).  This  yields 


rhi—  •  (50-2°) 

O         n-Q 

The  heat  of  solution  for  one  molecule  is  equal  to  Q/n=q,  or 

q  =_02  J  Lln._"_  =  J!!.^L  .  (50.21) 

*  30         rc0         n0    56  v  ' 

Thus,  if  the  concentration  of  a  saturated  solution  increases  with  tem- 
perature, then  heat  is  absorbed  in  dissolution. 
The  Le  Chatelier-Braun  principle*  Let  us  suppose  that  heat  is  supplied 

to  a  saturated  solution  in  equilibrium  with  the  solute.  Then,  if  -j~-  >  0, 

part  of  the  substance  will  further  dissolve,  and  the  heat  is  spent 
not  only  in  raising  the  temperature  but  also  in  dissolving.  But  if 

—  -'-  -<0,  then  some  of  the  substance  comes  out  of  solution,  on  which, 

in  accordance  with  (50.21),  heat  is  also  expended.  In  both  cases, 
changes  occur  in  the  equilibrium  system  that  counteract  the  external 
action  (raising  of  the  temperature).  The  foregoing  example  illustrates 
a  general  rule,  known  in  thermodynamics  as  the  Le  Chatelier-Braun 
principle.  The  Clausius-Clapeyron  equation  can  be  examined  on  the 
basis  of  this  principle. 

The  phase  rule.  Let  us  suppose  that  there  are  k  substances  (compo- 
nents) distributed  in  the  form  of  solutions  of  arbitrary  concentration 
over  /  phases.  How  many  parameters  define  the  equilibrium  state  of 
such  a  system  ? 

The  chemical  potentials  of  the  substances  depend  upon  temperature, 
pressure,  and  relative  concentrations.  The  concentrations  of  all  the 
substances  in  any  phase  satisfy  the  equations 

k 

£c{=l>  (50.22) 

(«i 

since,  by  definition,  the  concentrations  are  equal  to 


Sec.  50]  WEAK  SOLUTIONS  573 

/  __     m 


The  equilibrium  conditibn  consists  in  the  equality  of  the  chemical 
potentials  of  each  of  the  k  substances  over  all  /  phases  : 


,  e,  cj,  cj,  .  •  •  ,  4)  =  .  .  .  =  (4  (p,  e,  cf  ,  4  .  .  .  ,  c£)  .  (50.23) 

Here  the  superscript  always  denotes  phase,  while  the  subscript  de- 
notes the  substance. 

Equation  (50.23)  involves  k  concentrations  in  /  phases,  and  two  other 
variables  (temperature  and  pressure),  so  that  there  are  kf  +  2  variables 
in  all. 

There  are  /  —  1  equations  (60.23)  for  each  substance  and,  in  addition, 
the  concentrations  satisfy  /  equations  (50.22),  so  that  in  all  there  are 
k  (f  —  !)+/  equations  for  determining  kf  +  2  variables.  The  number 
of  independent  variables  which  may  vary  arbitrarily  is  equal  to  the 
difference  between  the  number  of  variables  and  the  number  of  equa- 
tions, i.e., 

r  =  kf  +  2  —  k  (/—I)  -  -/  =  k  —  f  +  2.  (50.24) 

The  quantity  r  is  called  the  number  of  thermodynamic  degrees  of 
freedom  of  the  system.  (50.24)  expresses  the  Gibbs  phase  rule:  the 
number  of  degrees  of  freedom  is  equal  to  the  number  of  components, 
minus  the  number  of  phases,  plus  two. 

For  example,  if  a  single  substance  occurs  in  equilibrium  in  two 
phases,  then  r  =  1  ;  in  such  a  system  ,  one  may  change  arbitrarily  a  single 
variable:  temperature  or  pressure.  In  a  two-component,  two-phase 
system,  there  are  two  degrees  of  freedom  :  the  component  concentra- 
tion in  one  of  the  phases  can  be  varied  together  with  the  temperature 
or  pressure. 

Strong  electrolytes.  The  thermodynamic  properties  of  solutions  of 
strong  electrolytes  exhibit  noticeable  deviations  from  the  laws  obtained 
in  this  section  for  the  solutions  of  neutral  substances.  It  is  natural 
to  look  for  the  cause  of  these  deviations  in  the  fact  that  ions  interact 
electrostatically.  This  type  of  interaction  was  not  taken  into  account 
at  all  in  the  theory  of  weak  solutions. 

Aqueous  electrolyte  solutions  exhibit  very  strong  dissociation,  the 
cause  of  which  can  be  qualitatively  understood  if  we  take  into  account 
that  the  static  dielectric  constant  of  water  is  equal  to  81.  The  potential 
energy  for  the  atomic  interactions  of  a  heteropolar  molecule  in  a  solu- 
tion is  less  than  in  vacuum  by  roughly  s  times,  so  that  in  water  the 
atoms  of  such  a  molecule  are  more  weakly  bound  by  a  factor  of  81. 


574  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

Thermal  motion  in  the  solution  disrupts  the  bonds,  and  instead  of 
molecules  we  have  ions  in  the  solution.  The  interaction  forces  between 
ions  are  Coulomb  forces  ;  they  fall  off  with  distance  much  more  slowly 
than  the  interaction  forces  between  neutral  molecules.  Let  us  deter- 
mine the  correction  to  the  chemical  potential  for  a  weak  solution, 
which  correction  is  due  to  the  interaction  forces  between  ions. 

The  ionic  atmosphere.  For  simplicity,  we  shall  consider  an  electrolyte 
which  contains  only  singly  charged  ions  of  both  signs,  for  example, 
H>  and  Cl~  in  a  weak  aqueous  solution.  Both  positive  and  negative 
ions  can  occur  close  to  a  positive  ion.  The  density  of  positive  ions  near 
an  ion  of  the  same  sign  is  reduced,  compared  with  the  mean  density, 

_  e(p 

by  the  Boltzmann  factor  e  e  ,  where  9  is  the  potential  produced  by 
the  charge  distribution  at  a  given  point  in  the  vicinity  of  the  positive 
ion.  The  negative-charge  density  at  the  same  point  is  increased  by 

?<p 

the  Boltzmann  factor  e  °  .  If  p0  is  the  mean  ion  density,  then  the 
charge  density  at  the  point  of  the  solution  considered  is 

_  ccp  eq> 

e  p0e     °  —  e  p0  e  °  =  —  2  Poe  sh~9-  . 

From  equation  (14.  6),  this  quantity,  multiplied  by  --  -~,  is  equal  to 

l  e 

the  Laplacian  of  potential  [we  must  introduce  —  into  equation  (14.6) 

in  order  to  take  into  account  the  reduction  of  the  electric  field  in  the 
medium].  This  equation  of  electrostatics,  written  down  straightway 
in  spherical  coordinates,  is  of  the  foim 

I       d       9   dq>  Sic  v     6<p  ,.,_  rt-. 


We  shall  consider  the  solution  to  this  equation  for  points  in  space 
for  which  the  inequality  69^  0  is  satisfied.  It  is  only  this  region  which 
is  of  practical  interest.  If  the  indicated  inequality  is  satisfied,  then 

sh-JL  is  replaced  by  its  argument,  and  equation  (50.25)  becomes 
linear: 

J_  ^    2^!==8lL£!L£l(p.  (50.26) 

r2    dr        dr  eO      T  v  ' 

We  shall  look  for  a  solution  to  (50.26)  in  the  form  of  the  usual  Cou- 
lomb potential  corrected  by  the  screening  factor  £  (r)  : 

9  =  -£r5(r).  (50.27) 

Then,  substituting  into  (50.26)  leads  to  an  equation  for  £: 

d«g 

dr* 


Sec.  50]  WEAK  SOLUTIONS  575 

Putting 


ee 
we  obtain  a  solution  of  (50.28)  in  the  form 

£(r)  =  f-*r.  (50.30) 

Of  the  two  solutions  of  (50.28),  only  the  one  with  a  minus  sign  in  the 
exponent  is  retained.  The  constant  of  integration  is  put  equal  to  unity, 
since  screening  should  not  have  any  effect  at  small  distances  from  the 
ion;  close  to  the  ion,  9  (r)  becomes  the  usual  Coulomb  potential. 
From  (50.27)  and  (50.30)  we  have 

9  =  ~e~xr'  (50.31) 

The  potential  decreases  e  times  for  .a  distance  1/x  from  the  ion. 
1/X  is  termed  the  radius  of  the  ion  cloud  surrounding  the  given  ion.  Tn 
actual  fact,  there  is  no  "cloud,"  but  simply  an  increased  charge 
density  of  opposite  sign  and  a  reduced  charge  density  of  the  same 
sign,  which  leads  to  the  screening  of  the  given  ion  field  at  a  distance  I//. 

Thermodynamic  quantities  lor  strong  electrolytes.  The  potential 
produced  by  the  ion  cloud  at  a  certain  point  is  equal  to  the  difference 
between  the  potential  9  (r)  and  the  potential  of  the  free  charge  not 
surrounded  by  ions.  At  the  point  where  the  original  positive  ion  is 
situated,  this  additional  potential  is 

89  =  lim— (*-*' 

r->0  er 

It  is  of  finite  magnitude.  It  was  for  this  reason  that  the  solution 
(50.31)  could  be  extrapolated  to  such  small  distances  away  from 
the  ion  that  the  linear  approximation  (50.26)  does  not,  strictly  speak- 
ing, hold.  The  additional  free  energy  of  the  ion  can  be  calculated 
as  the  work  produced  in  taking  the  charge  e  to  a  point  of  potential 
§  9.  It  is  necessary,  here,  to  take  into  account  that  the  potential 
89  is  produced  by  the  charge  e  itself.  Therefore,  the  work  done  in 
introducing  the  charge  is  not  equal  to  089,  but  to  the  integral 

c 

189^6.  Here,  the  charge  is  the  external  parameter  X,  while  the  po- 

o 

tential  S  9  is  the  generalized  force  A  (see  Sec.  46) : 

c 

~,  (50.32) 

OS 

0 

where  the  fact  that  e  K  ~  e2  was  taken  into  account  in  the  inte- 
gration. From  this  it  is  easy  to  obtain  the  addition  to  the  thermo- 


576  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

dynamic  potential  for  the  ion,  which  is  associated  with  the  correction 
to  the  free  energy: 

*fr  =  iA-V^±=-V*-±r(l£).  (50.33) 

x  is  inversely  proportional  to  the  square  root  of  the  volume,  so 

ft     /  Si  W*  \  ^^}7?T 

that  -™-  I—  fr-l  =  —  Y  1/2  -  Since  8  [x  refers  to  a  single  ion,  the  addition 

per  ion  pair  (comprising  a  single  molecule)  is  the  required  correction 
to  the  chemical  potential  of  the  solute 


,  (50.34) 

where  p  is  the  solvent  density  I—    e°3  es  j  . 

To  the  therrnodynamic  potential  of  the  whole  solution  we  add  the 
quantity 

,  (50.35) 


while  for  the  chemical  potential  of  the  solvent  of  a  strong  electrolyte 
we  obtain  the  correction 


This  theory  of  strong  electrolytes  was  formulated  by  Debye  and 
Hiickel. 

Implications  of  the  Debye-Hiickel  theory.  If  we  introduce  8  JJL 
into  equation  (50.7)  for  the  osmotic  pressure,  then  instead  of  (50.9) 
we  pet 

AP.F-2»9(  1-4-1/34^)  (50.37) 

(the  factor  2  takes  the  complete  dissociation  into  account).  The 
correction  factor  inside  the  brackets  tends  to  unity  as  the  solution 
concentration  njN  decreases,  but  its  derivative  with  respect  to 
concentration  tends  to  infinity. 

The  additional  term  involved  in  equation  (50.15),  which  determines 
the  concentration  of  a  saturated  solution,  is  proportional  to  Vn. 
It  also  contributes  infinite  additions  to  the  derivatives  as  n  tends  to 
zero. 

See.  51.  Chemical  Equilibria 

Reversible  and  irreversible  reactions.  Like  all  processes  whose 
velocities  do  not  coincide  with  the  rate  of  change  of  the  external 
parameters  of  a  statistical  system,  chemical  reactions,  which  proceed 


Sec.  51]  CHEMICAL   EQUILIBRIA  577 

with  finite  velocity,  are  irreversible.  For  example,  when  an  explosive 
mixture  (hydrogen  and  oxygen)  burns,  water  vapour  is  produced 
irreversibly. 

If  a  certain  quantity  of  the  oxyhydrogen  mixture  is  prepared  in 
a  closed  vessel,  the  state  of  the  mixture  will  be  thermodynamically 
unstable  with  respect  to  the  reaction.  True,  the  reaction  by  no  means 
proceeds  directly  according  to  the  "gross  equation"  2  H2  +  O2  = 
—  2  IPO.  To  do  so,  the  molecules  would  have  to  overcome  very 
high  potential  barriers.  In  actual  fact,  the  reaction  must  proceed 
through  stages  involving  the  intermediate  unstable  substances  OH, 
H,  O  with  nonsaturated  valences;  these  are  the  so-called  active 
centres. 

The  initial  formation  of  active  centres  is  very  difficult,  so  at  room 
temperature  an  oxyhydrogen  mixture  may  be  preserved  indefinitely. 
But  if  active  centres  are  somehow  produced  (by  a  powerful  electric 
spark,  for  example)  then  they  are  renewed  and  multiplied  in  the 
course  of  the  reaction  (a  chain  reaction).*  When  the  multiplication 
of  active  centres  is  fast  enough,  the  reaction  proceeds  explosively. 

But  chemical  reactions  never  proceed  to  the  end.  If  an  explosion 
is  produced  in  a  sufficiently  strong  vessel  (bomb),  then  the  finite 
equilibrium  state  will  contain,  hydrogen,  oxygen,  and  water  vapour 
in  certain  (strictly  definite)  concentrations  that  depend  upon,  the 
temperature  and  pressure  and  the  initial  composition  of  the  mixture. 
This  finite  equilibrium  stato  is  termed  chemical  equilibrium. 

When  the  state  in  an  equilibrium  system  is  changed  slowly,  the 
equilibrium  will  shift  in  one  direction  or  other,  i.e.,  the  quantity 
of  initial  or  final  products  may  increase.  But  these  chemical  reactions 
proceed  with  the  same  velocity  as  that  with  which  the  external 
conditions  change.  Hence,  such  reactions  are  reversible — as  are  all 
processes  whose  velocity  is  not  established  spontaneously  but  is  all 
the  time  equal  to  the  velocity  of  change  of  the  quantities  that  the 
equilibrium  state  of  the  system  is  given  by. 

Chemical  equilibrium.  The  state  of  chemical  equilibrium  can  be 
found  with  the  aid  of  the  therm odyiiamic  functions  of  the  substances 
involved  in  the  "gross  equation"  reaction,  quite  independently  of 
the  mechanism  by  which  the  reaction  proceeds.  This  is  why  the 
theory  of  chemical  equilibria  had  already  been  formulated  in  the 
nineteenth  century,  while  the  study  of  the  velocity  of  chemical 
reactions  is  still  developing  vigorously  at  the  present  time.  In  this 
sense,  the  situation  is  similar  to  that  in  statistics  in  general,  i.e., 
in  the  science  of  equilibria,  and  in  kinetics — the  science  of  the  ve- 
locities of  macroscopic  processes. 

*  The  majority  of  chain  reactions  aro  associated  with  an  active  centre.  This 
wasf  established  by  N.  N.  Semyonov,  the  discoverer  of  chain  reactions,  and  his 
pupils  (and  independently  by  C.  N.  Hiiisholwood). 

37-0060 


578  STATISTICAL  PHYSIOS  [Part  IV 

For  a  given  temperature  and  pressure,  chemical  equilibrium  is 
attained  only  when  the  thermodynamic  potential  in  the  reacting 
mixture  has  a  minimum 

0.  (51.1) 


When    p  =  const    and    0  =  const,    the   minimum    condition,    dO=0, 
appears  thus: 

(51.2) 


Here,  [Li  is  the  chemical  potential  of  the  ith  substance  appearing 
in  the  "gross  equation"  reaction.  For  an  oxyhydrogen  mixture, 
for  example,  the  only  substances  of  this  kind  are  hydrogen,  oxygen, 
and  water  vapour.  But  the  numbers  dNi  are  not  arbitrary:  they 
change  as  the  reaction  proceeds,  and  are  therefore  interrelated  by 
the  reaction  equation.  In  other  words,  NI  may  vary  only  in  equiv- 
alent (stoichiometric)  quantities.  For  example,  if  we  take  the  reaction 


then  d  NCO-   d  No3*  d  Ncot  =  —  2:  —  1:2.  In  the   reaction   of  the 
thermal   dissociation  of  hydrogen 


dNi^:  dNu~  —  1:2.  In  general,  the  number  d  N{  is  propor- 
tional to  the  equivalent  of  the  given  substance  in  the  reaction  v,  ; 
equation  (51.2)  can  also  be  rewritten  thus: 

J£Vv,  =  0.  (51.3) 

i 

This  equation  expresses  the  condition  of  chemical  equilibrium  in 
a  system. 

Law  of  mass  action.  Equation  (51.3)  is  especially  useful  when 
we  have  an  explicit  expression  for  the  chemical  potential  of  the 
reacting  substances,  as  in  a  weak  solution  or  in  an  ideal  gas,  for 
example.  In  the  latter  case,  the  equilibrium  concentrations  of  the 
substances  may  be  determined  if  there  are  sufficient  data  about 
the  structure  of  all  the  molecules  in  equilibrium. 

The  chemical  potential  for  a  gas  in  a  mixture  of  ideal  gases  is 
[see  (47.17)] 

w—ein«Afl!>,  (51.4) 

where  /»  is  a  statistical  sum  taken  over  all  momentum  values  of  the 
molecule  as  a  whole,  and  also  over  all  its  rotational,  vibrational, 
and  electronic  states.  The  latter  are  essential  only  when  they  occur 
close  to  the  ground  state  of  the  molecule  and  are  far  from  its  disso- 


Sec.  51]  CHEMICAL  EQTJIUBRIA  579 

elation  limit.  If  they  occur  close  to  the  dissociation  limit,  the  mole- 
cule decomposes  before  such  highly  excited  states  can  in  any  way 
affect  the  values  of  the  statistical  sums  (see  exercise  2). 

Substituting  the  expression  for  chemical  potential  into  the  chemical 
equilibrium  condition  (31.3),  and  eliminating  6,  we  obtain 

£  v/ln  ^  =  JIT1  v,-  In  6  /,-. 

Taking  antilogarithms  of  this  equation,  we  obtain  the  equilibrium 
condition  (expressed  in  terms  of  partial  pressures)  from  the  formula 

fl  Pi  v'-ri(0  A)*''  -K.  (51.5) 

i  i 

This  equation  can  also  be  written  in  terms  of  the  relative  concen- 
trations of  the  substances  by  replacing  the  partial  pressures  with 
the  aid  of  (47.15): 


Here,  c,  denotes  the  concentration  of  the  ith  component  of  the  mix- 
ture: 

c,.  =  ^-.  (51.7) 

The  pressure  on  the  right-hand  side  of  (51.6)  has  still  to  be  expressed 
in  terms  of  the  initial  pressure  or  in  terms  of  the  initial  density; 
this  can  always  be  done  easily  with  the  Clapeyron  equation,  if 
we  take  into  account  the  change  in  the  number  of  particles  (relative 
to  the  initial  number  of  particles),  for  a  given  equilibrium  of  the 
chemical  reaction. 

The  component  concentrations  depend  upon  the  initial  quantities 
of  the  original  substances  involved  in  the  reaction.  Thus,  also  the 
equilibrium  concentrations  depend  upon  these  quantities  (or  masses). 
Therefore,  equation  (51.6)  expresses  the  so-called  law  of  mass  action. 

The  quantity  appearing  on  the  right-hand  side  of  equation  (51.5) 
is  called  the  equilibrium  constant  of  the  given  reaction,  because  it 
does  not  involve  the  concentrations  of  the  mixture.  Its  dimension- 

F  ?v'l 
ality  is  [pl    \  ' 

Heat  of  reaction.  The  heat  of  a  chemical  reaction  occurring  at 
constant  pressure  is  defined  as  the  difference  in  the  heat  functions 
of  the  reacting  substances  before  and  after  the  reaction.  It  is  conven- 
ient to  write  this  heat  as  calculated  for  a  single  elementary  act  of 
the  reaction 

*  =  8i=-e2w-ir  <5L8> 

37* 


580  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

[cf.  (50.18)].  But  in  an  elementary  act  8  ^>=^  W  v»  so  that  the 
heat  of  reaction  is  ' 


This  expression  denotes  the  heat  absorbed  during  the  reaction. 
The  heat  evolved  would  have  to  be  defined  with  opposite  sign. 

When  the  law  of  mass  action  applies,  the  heat  of  reaction  is  ex- 
pressed in  terms  of  the  equilibrium  constant  K: 


Formula   (51.10)   agrees   with  the  Le   Chatelier-Braun  principle, 
which  can  be  easily  seen  from^  the  following  argument.  If  —  ^  —  >  0, 

then,  as  the  temperature  increases,  the  equilibrium  tends  towards 
a  predominance  of  those  substances  that  enter  into  the  reaction 
equation  with  positive  coefficients  v,-.  The  concentrations  of  these 
substances  appear  in  the  numerator  on  the  left-hand  side  of  equation 
(51.6).  But  then,  according  to  (51.10),  the  system  absorbs  heat, 
so  that  reactions  occur  in  it  which  oppose  the  rise  in  temperature. 
The  increase  or  decrease  in  the  temperature  of  an  equilibrium  system 
can  produce  reversible  reactions  in  it  in  any  desired  direction. 

Exercises 

1)  Write  down  the  equations  of  the  law  of  mass  action  for  the  reaction 
2CO  +  Oa  =  2COa,  if  a  moles  of  CO  and  6  moles  of  Oa  initially  take  part  in  the 
reaction. 

Let  x  moles  of  O2  react;  then  2x  moles  of  CO  enter  into  the  reaction  with 
them,  and  2x  moles  of  CO2  are  formed.  In  all,  there  are  a-\-b  —  3x-\-2x  =  a  +  6  —  x 
moles  of  different  substances  in  the  system.  The  concentrations  are,  re- 
spectively, 

a  —  2x 

e<X>=a  +  b-x' 
b-x 


2x 


so  that  the  equilibrium  equation  appears  thus: 

(2  a)2  (a  +  6  -  x) 
(a-2x)*(b-x)  "" 


pK. 


Here,  p  is  the  equilibrium  pressure,  which  differs  from  the  pressure  of  the 

original  substances  pQ  (for  the  same  temperature)  by  the  factor =- — .  Whence 

&  4~  o 

the  equation  for  the  required  quantity  x  is  - — _  o   ^a  (b  —    \  **  4  /    — M~  * 


Sec.  51]  CHEMICAL   EQUIUBBIA  581 

2)  Calculate  the  equilibrium  constant  for  the  thermal  dissociation  of  nitrogen, 
using  the  following  data. 

The  ground  state  for  a  nitrogen  atom  is  *S.  The  first  excited  state  lies  2 . 4  ev 
higher  (2£>),  the  next  lies  3.5  ev  above  the  ground  state  (2P). 

The  formation  energy  of  an  N2  molecule  at  absolute  zero  is  equal  to  9. 70  ev 
(this  value  is  now  reliably  established). 

The  moment  of  inertia  for  the  ground  state  Nz  is  J  —  13.84  x  10~40  gm/cm2. 
The  vibrational  quantum  of  a  molecule  is  equal  to  0.287  ev.  In  the  ground  state 
of  the  molecule,  the  orbital  and  spin  angular  momenta  of  the  electrons  do 
not  have  projections  on  the  line  joining  the  nuclei.  The  first  excited  state  lies 
higher  than  C  ev  above  the  ground  state  of  the  molecule. 

The  statistical  sum  for  the  atoms  is 


Here  and  in  future,  it  is  convenient  to  express  0  in  electron -volts,  taking  into 
account  that  1  ev  corresponds  to  1 1,600°.  We  shall  confine  ourselves  to  tempera- 
tures for  which  the  statistical  sum  for  a  molecule  involves  only  tho  electronic 
ground  state.  Then  wo  obtain  [see  (47.21)]: 

„  9.76 

2  isJ  0  4-n       6 


Tho  equilibrium  constant  for  tho  reaction  N2  =  2N  is,  from  (51.5),  equal  to 

/  2.4  3'5\2  «          /  *    Mil     /  h<*\  9'76 

K  =  lpL=  4+10e--ir+6e-ir    .   2   /me_«/,1_6--0-  e--!r 

/Na  X  Jh    \      *      I 

To  illustrate,  let  us  find  tho  fraction  of  dissociated  molecules,  if  the  tempera- 
ture is  equal  to  1  ev  and  there  are  2.7  x  1019  molecules  in  1  cm3.  Then  the  equa- 
tion of  the  law  of  mass  action  equation  is 

-0.494  .  10«  •  5.90  -  10-5  «  24.2. 


1  -x 

Here,  the  factor  before  the  exponential  is  equal  to  ^  5  x  106,  while  the  exponen- 
tial is  equal  to  5.9  x  10~5.  The  equilibrium  degree  of  dissociation  is  x~  0.88. 
Thus,  when  the  temperature  is  equal  to  only  one  tenth  of  the  dissociation  energy, 
88%  of  all  the  molecules  have  already  dissociated.  Tho  predominance  of  the 
pre-exponential  factor  over  the  exponential  is  explained,  for  such  relatively  low 
temperatures,  by  the  fact  that  tho  statistical  weight  of  the  dissociated  state  is 
determined  by  the  entire  volume  occupied  by  the  gas,  while  the  nondissociated 
state  is  determined  only  by  the  volume  of  the  molecules;  therefore,  at  atmospher- 
ic density  of  the  gas  (2.7  x  1019  rnole/cm3),  dissociation  is  already  highly 
probable. 

3)  Find  the  degree  of  thermal  ionization  for  helium  as  a  function  of  its  tem- 
perature and  pressure.  Do  not  take  second  ionization  into  account. 

The  first  ionization  potential  of  helium  is  24.47  ev,  while  the  first  excited 
state  lies  20.5  ov  above  the  ground  state. 

The  ionization  equilibrium  satisfies  the  law  of  mass  action 


«He 


582  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  statistical  sums  here  are: 

.        0  (2*^6)3/2 


.                 (27rmHc  0)3/2 
JHe    =  *  - — T&Thfi ' 

24.47 
(27rmiic  0)3/2    — ^ — 

/Ho  =*         (2rc  7i)3         6 

(the  factor  2  takes  into  account  the  spin  of  the  electron  and  Ho+  ion). 
From  this  wo  express  the  equilibrium  constant  as 


If  the  initial  pressure  of  helium  is  p0,  then  the  ionization-equilibrium  equation 
assumes  the  following  form: 

x*      _    K 

T^~x  ~~p7' 

To  illustrate,  we  shall  take  a  temperature  of  4  ev  and  a  molecular  density 
2.7  x  1018  mole/cm8.  Then  the  equation  of  ionization  equilibrium  is  written 
numerically  thus: 

--  -  3.47  •  103  •  2.19  •  10-3  =  7.6;   x  =  0.90. 


Here,  as  in  the  previous  example,  the  pro  -exponential  factor  predominates 
over  the  exponential,  equal  to  2.19  x  10~3,  as  a  result  of  the  largo  statistical 
weight  of  the  ionized  state.  Excited  states  of  the  helium  atom  make  a  negligible 
contribution  to  the  statistical  sum.  At  higher  temperatures,  the  first  ionization 
is  practically  complete,  so  that  there  are  simply  no  neutral  atoms  which  could 
be  excited. 

4)  Relate  the  e.m.f.  of  a  primary  cell  to  the  heat  of  the  chemical  reaction 
occurring  in  it. 

By  definition,  the  e.m.f.  is  the  work  done  in  carrying  unit  charge  around  a 
conducting  circuit.  If  a  primary  coll  is  connected  in  the  circuit,  then,  in  travers- 
ing it,  reversible  chemical  reactions  occur  that  neutralize  the  ions  at  the  elec- 
trodes. The  work  done  in  a  reversible  reaction  is  equal  to  the  change  in  thermo- 
dynamic  potential,  while  the  heat  is  equal  to  the  change  in  the  heat  function. 
Whence,  from  equation  (51.9),  we  obtain 

e.  m.  f. 


0 


Sec.  52.  Surface  Phenomena 

The  thermodynamic  potential  of  a  surface  layer.  We  have  so  far 
considered  only  the  volume  properties  of  a  substance,  so  that  all 
the  results  relating  to  phase  and  chemical  equilibria,  and  to  equilibria 
in  solutions,  refer,  strictly  speaking,  to  very  large  systems. 

The  surface  layers  separating  different  substances  or  different 
phases  of  the  same  substance  exhibit  special  properties,  which, 
however,  depend  both  on  the  nature  and  the  states  of  the  volumes 
in  contact. 


Sec.  52]  SURFACE    PHENOMENA  583 

The  thermodynamic  potential  for  unit  surface  of  contact  of  two 
media  depends  upon  the  temperature  6  and  pressure  p  in  the  sur- 
rounding media.  In  equilibrium,  0  and  p  are  constant  over  the  whole 
surface.  Interaction  between  the  contacting  portions  occurs  across 
their  boundaries.  The  dimensions  of  the  boundaries  are  proportional 
to  the  first  power  of  the  linear  dimensions  of  these  portions,  while 
their  areas  are  proportional  to  the  squares  of  the  linear  dimensions. 
Therefore,  for  sufficiently  large  dimensions,  the  portions  of  the  sur- 
face layer  may  be  regarded  as  quasi-independent  subsystems,  like 
the  way  in  which  we  considered  volume  subsystems.  Hence,  the 
thermodynamic  potential  of  a  surface  is  additive  for  the  same  reason 
as  the  volume  potential  is.  If  the  thermodynamic  potential  for  unit 
interface  surface  of  two  media  is  denoted  by  a  and  the  magnitude 
of  the  whole  contact  surface  is  £,  then,  by  virtue  of  additivity,  the 
potential  for  the  whole  surface  will  be  equal  to 

O-oct;.'  (52.1) 

Surface  tension.  The  work  done  at  constant  pressure  and  temper- 
ature is  equal  to  the  change  in  thermodynamic  potential  (Sec.  46). 
Therefoie,  in  changing  surface  area  by  unity,  work  is  performed 
equal  to  a.  This  work  is  called  the  surface  tension  of  two  given  media. 

It  is  easy  to  demonstrate  the  relation  between  this  definition  of 
surface  tension  and  its  elementary  definition.  Let  a  film  of  liquid 
be  stretched  on  a  rigid  II-shaped  wire  frame,  closed  by  a  movable 
member,  completing  a  rectangular  liquid  surface.  If  the  length  of 
the  movable  member  is  equal  to  unity,  then  a  force  acts  on  it  (from 
the  direction  of  the  film)  equal  to  twice  the  surface  tension  of  the 
film  (because  the  film  has  two  sides).  When  the  cross-member  is 
displaced  by  unit  length,  the  force  of  surface  tension  performs  work 
numerically  equal  to  double  its  magnitude.  But  the  total  surface 
of  the  film  increases  in  this  case  by  two  units,  so  that  the  work  done 
in  increasing  the  surface  by  unity  is  indeed  equal  to  the  "force" 
of  surface  tension. 

When  the  surface  area  is  increased,  part  of  the  atoms  leave  the 
volume  for  the  surface  layer;  to  do  so  it  is  necessary  in  part  to 
overcome  the  attractive  forces  due  to  other  atoms.  This  is  what 
explains  the  origin  of  the  work  that  is  lost  (or  gained,  depending 
upon  the  nature  of  the  volumes  in  contact)  in  increasing  the  area. 
The  surface  tension  of  a  condensed  phase  at  the  boundary  with  a 
vacuum  is,  of  course,  always  positive. 

The  thermodynamic  potential  is  at  a  minimum  when  in  equilibrium. 
In  this  case,  the  minimum  is  attained  simply  for  the  least  area  £. 
Therefore,  a  liquid  film,  stretched  on  a  certain  (in  the  general  case  a 
nonplane)  frame  assumes  the  least  possible  surface  area  for  the  given 
frame.  A  liquid  drop  in  ideal  equilibrium  assumes  a  spherical  form 
that  has  the  least  surface  area  for  a  given  volume. 


584  STATISTICAL  PHYSICS  [Part  IV 

The  heat  of  surface  increase.  When  surface  area  increases,  heat  is 
evolved  in  addition  to  the  performance  of  work.  Since  the  process  of 
surface  increase  is  reversible,  the  heat  is  determined  from  the  general 
formula  (46.18)  Q^Q&S.  The  entropy  of  the  surface  is  calculated 
from  formula  (46.46).  Substituting  the  thermodynamic  potential  for 
the  surface  (52.1  )  into  this  formula,  we  find  an  expression  for  the  heat: 


Thus,  heat  may  be  evolved  or  absorbed  depending  upon  the  sign  of  ~~  . 

The  equilibrium  vapour  pressure  above  a  drop.  The  phase  equilibrium 
condition  changes  if  the  surface  thermodynamic  potential  is  taken 
into  account  in  addition  to  that  for  volume.  Of  course,  the  general 
condition  dO  =  0  still  holds,  but  it  no  longer  reduces  to  the  form 
(49.4)  (jij  ==  fJL2.  Instead,  it  is  necessary  to  write,  generally, 


Let  the  subscript  1  refer  to  the  vapour  phase  contained  in  a  large 
volume,  and  the  subscript  2  relate  to  a  small  liquid  drop  of  radius  R. 
Then,  for  the  first  phase, 


while  for  the  second  phase, 

The  derivative  of  the  second  term  is  calculated  in  the  following  way : 


If  the  density  of  the  liquid  is  p  mole/cm3,  then  R  —  I  -^  -  j  3  ,  so  that 

IT*"] 

—  ~~—  C&n 

dN  ~~   3   N  '  ^•/> 

Substituting  this  in  (52.6)  and  now  expressing  N  in  terms  of  R,  we 
obtain 

dt    _      Sir.*'      _    2a 

""'"-  B"8 


Thus,  the  equUibrium  condition  between  the  vapour  and  liquid  drop  is 

)  +        .  (52.9) 


Sec.  52]  SURFACE    PHENOMENA  585 


We  represent  the  pressure  p  as  p0  +  Ap,  where  pQ  is  the  equilibrium 
pressure  on  a  plane  surface.  The  expansion  of  chemical  potential  in 
powers  of  Ap  gives  [cf.  (50.12)] 

(*!  —  r.)Ap  =  |£.  (52.10) 

Neglecting  the  specific  volume  of  the  liquid  compared  with  the  specific 
volume  of  the  vapour,  we  find  a  final  expression  for  the  excess  pressure  : 


The  analogous  expression  for  the  pressure  in  a  vapour  bubble  within 
a  liquid  leads  to  the  same  formula,  but  with  opposite  sign. 

The  stability  of  supersaturated  phases.  We  have  thus  seen  that  the 
equilibrium  vapour  pressure  over  the  convex  surface  of  a  drop  is 
greater  than  that  over  a  plane  surface,  while  that  over  the  concave 
surface  of  a  bubble  is  less.  This  explains  the  relative  stability  of  super- 
saturated phases,  which  was  mentioned  in  Sec.  49.  If  a  liquid  drop 
appears  in  a  supersaturated  vapour  with  pressure  pf>pQ,  whose 
radius  is  less  than 


then  this  drop  evaporates  once  again,  and  further  condensation  on  it 
is  highly  improbable,  since  it  is  a  fluctuation  phenomenon.  Only  if 
inequality  (52.12)  is  reversed  can  the  drop  begin  to  grow.  But  the 
spontaneous  formation  of  a  large  drop,  like  any  large  fluctuation,  is 
highly  improbable.  Therefore,  condensation  usually  begins  on  small 
nuclei  that  are  already  in  the  vapour,  for  example,  ions. 

In  exactly  the  same  way  we  can  explain  why  a  highly  purified 
superheated  liquid  does  not  boil.  Boiling  of  a  liquid  consists  in  the 
formation  of  vapour  bubbles  in  its  volume.  In  order  that  such  a  bubble 
should  not  collapse  due  to  external  pressure,  the  equilibrium  pressure 
of  the  vapour  must  be  at  least  that  of  the  external  atmospheric  pressure 
above  the  liquid.  But  if  the  equilibrium  vapour  pressure  above  a 
plane  surface  is  only  equal  to  the  external  pressure,  then  there  is  not 
sufficient  pressure  in  the  bubble  for  equilibrium.  Therefore,  a  bubble 
of  insufficient  size  cannot  grow. 


APPENDIX 

An  integral  of  the  form 


ft 
is  calculated  in  the  following  way.  The  function  (e*±l)~l  is  expanded  in  a 


fe-l 

The  series  is  integrated  term  by  term,  and  the  integral  lor  each  separate  term 
is  calculated  thus: 


I  e~kx  xn  dx  =  -jjt+i  (e~*zn  dz  . 


o  o 


Tho  latter  integral  is  equal  to  n\  for  integral  n,  as  may  easily  be  shown  from 
integration  by  parts.  For  n  half-  integral,  it  may  be  taken  according  to  the  for- 
mulae derived  in  exercise  3,  Sec.  39.  Indeed,  putting  \/z=ut  we  obtain 


and,  in  general 


We  shall  call  this  quantity  (m  --  ^-1  !,  so  that  in  general 

\ 


Hence, 


APPENDIX 


687 


The  summation  with  the  upper  sign  may  be  reduced  to  the  summation  with 
the  lower  sign.  Indeed, 

!_.!_  +  _! L.+     . 

i);|+J         l         OH -1-1  ,4114.1         I      *    '    ' 


J_  +  _J_  +  _1_+          -2.-J-/H  _JL_  +  _i_+         U 

oM+i    '    314-1    '    4«+i  ~  *  '  '  2rt+1  \         2M+1         3M+1         *  '  '  / 

j^T+  4^+-")- 


-          -- 

2n I  \         2n  +  l        3n+1 
Finally,  the  summation  involving  positive  signs  has  the  following  values: 


1 

n  =  T 

i 

3 
2 

2 

5 

T 

00 

y    l    _  o  61o 

1.645 

1.341 

1.202 
i 

1.127 

2/  *«+i  -^IAJ 
fe-i 

1.0823 


For  odd  n,  the  following  formulae  obtain: 


Therefore, 


™ 

"90" ' 


Wo  also  note  that 


fe-1 


f^1/2^  _  VvL  Y-^ 
]e*-l  ~~     2    ^ 


Ti 


2.612  =  2.31  . 


\\'e  have  met  with  the  integral  (44.39) : 


J(e*  + 


1)  (1  +  «-*)" 


_         2 
^ 


26          3 


588  BIBLIOGRAPHY 

BIBLIOGRAPHY 

Part  I 

1.  *L.  T).  Landau    and    E.  M.  Lifshits,    Mechanics,    Gostekhizdat,    Moscow- 

Leningrad  (1958). 

2.  *G.  K.  Suslov,    Theoretical   Mechanics,    Gostekhizdat.    Moscow-Leningrad 

(1944). 

3.  *T.  Levi-Civita  and  I.  Ainaldi,  Lezioni  di  meccanica  razionale,  Bologna 

(1930). 

4.  E.  T.  Whittaker,  Analytical  Dynamics  (1937).  A  Treatise  on  the  Analytical 
Dynamics  of  Particles  and  Rigid  Bodies,  Cambridge  (1927). 

5.  A.  Sommerfeld,  Mechanik  (1944). 

(5.     G.  Goldstein,  Classical  Mechanics,  Cambridge  (1950). 

Part  II 

7.  *N.E.Kochin,   Vector  Calculus,  GITTL  (1934). 

8.  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits,  Field  Theory,  Gostekhizdat,  Moscow- 
Leningrad  (1948). 

9.  *I.  E.  Tamm,   Fundamentals  of  the    Theory  of  Electricity,   Gostekhizdat, 

Moscow-Leningrad  (1954). 

10.  *Abraham  and  Becker,   Theorie  der  Ekktrizitdt,  Bd.  I,  Leipzig  (1932). 

11.  *P.  Becker,  ElektronentJworie. 

12.  A.  Einstein,  The  Meaning  of  Relativity,  Princeton  (1953). 

13.  P.  G.  Bergman,  Introduction  to  the  Theory  of  Relativity  (1942). 

14.  * Einstein  and  Modern  Physics,  Gostekhizdat  (1956). 

Part  III 

15.  L.  D.  Landau   and   E.  M.  Lifshits,  Quantum  Mechanics,   Part    1    (1948). 
lt>.  *D.  I.  Blokhintsev,  Fundamentals  of  Quantum  Mechanics  (1944),  2nd  ed. 

(1949). 

17.  *V.  A.  Fok,  The  Principles  of  Quantum  Mechanics  (1932). 

18.  H.  A.  Bethe  and  E.  E.  Salpeter,  Quantum  Mectianics  of  One-  and  Two- 
Electron  Systems,  Springer- Verlag  (1957). 

19.  P,  A.  M.  Dirac,   The  Principles  of  Quantum  Mechanics,  Oxford  (1957). 

20.  E.  V.  Shpolskii,  Atomic  Physics,  Parts  1  and  2  (1950). 

Part  IV 

21.  L.  D.  Landau  and  E.  M.  Lifshits,  Statistical  Physics  (1950). 

22.  *V.  G.  Levich,  Introduction  to  Statistical  Physics  (1954). 

23.  *M.  A.  Leontovich,  Statistical  Physics  (1944). 

24.  *M.  A.  Leontovich,  Introduction  to  Thermodynamics  (1950). 

25.  *E.  Fermi,  Molecules  and  Crystals  (1947);  (Molekiile  und  Kristalle,  1938). 

26.  *A.  G.  Samoilovich,  Statistical  Physics  (1955). 

*  As  far  as  the  author  knows,  these  have  not  been  translated  into  English. 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


589 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


Abberation  of  light :  200 
Absolute     thermodynamic     scale     of 
temperature:  522 

-  -  electrostatic  system  of  units:  106 

—  black  body:  457 
Absorption  of  light:  170 
Action:  82 

—  for  a  particle  in  an  electromagnetic 
field:  218 
for  an  electromagnetic  field:  117 

—  in  the  theory  of  relativity:  211 
Additive  quantity:  15 

—  integral  of  motion:  35 
Adiabatic  process:  520 

—  demagnetization:  543 
Alpha  disintegration :  283 
Amplitude:  61 

Analogy,  Mandelshtam:  282 
— ,  optical -mechanical :  235 
Angle,  Eulerian:  79 
— ,  solid :   54 
Angular  momentum:  36 
--,  of  a  field:  124 
— ,  as  a  generalized  momentum:  42 
— -,  composition  of:  309,  337 
Antiparticle :  401 
Antiproton:  401 
Aphelion:  45 

Atmosphere,  planetary:  441 
Atom,  vector  model  of:  369 
Atomic  units:  316 
Atoms,  hydrogen-like:  322 
— -,  metastable  367 
Barrier  factor:  282 

-  for  alpha  disintegration:  284 
Biot-Savart  law:  137 

Bohr  theory  of  atomic  structure :  229 

-  magneton:  330 

-  -  quantum  conditions :  290 
Boltzmann  distribution :  430 
Born  approximation:  385 
Bose  condensation:  474 
Centre  of  mass:  26 
Proper  time:  205 
Chemical  equilibrium:  576 

-  potential:  568 
Circulation  of  a  vector:  95 
Close  action:  134 

Coefficient,  mutual  induction:  160 

— ,  self-induction:  160 

Collisions,  elastic :  51 

— ,  inelastic :  50 

Commutative  relations  for  operator:  298 

Condition,  Lorentz :  115 

Conductors:  149 

Constant,  equilibrium :  579 


Constant,  Planck's :  230 
Constraints,  ideal  rigid:  16 
Contraction  of  the  length  scale:   198 
— ,  time  interval:  197 
Coordinate  system :   1 1 
— ,  centre  of  mass :  49 
— ,  inertia! :  15 
— ,  laboratory:  49 

-,  rotating:  69 
Coordinates,  curvilinear:   101 

-  -,  generalized:  12 
— ,  normal:  65 

,  normal  electromagnetic  field :   275 
— ,  spherical:  24 
Coupling,  j-j:  339 

-  ,  Russel-Saunders :  338 
Critical  point :  562 
Curl:  96 

Current,  displacement:  111 
Cyclic  variables :  43 
Deflection    of   light    rays    in    a    gra- 
vitational field :  210 
Degree  of  freedom :  1 1 
— ,  thermodynamic:   573 
Density,  charge:   109 
-•-,  current:    110 
— ,  energy:    122 
— ,  probability:  244 
— ,  probability  flux :  250 
Diamagnetic  substance :  151 
Diamagnetism  of  electrons :  485 
Dielectric:  149 

—  constant:  153,  162,  442 
Diffraction,  electron:  239 
— ,  x-ray:  239 

Dipole  approximation:  185,  362 
Dispersion:  379 

—  formula:  382 
Distribution,  Boltzmann:  430 
— ,  Bose-Einstein :  425,  474 
— ,  Fermi-Dirac:  426 

— ,  Gibbs:  502 
— ,  Maxwell:  432,  477 
Divergence,  vector:  94 
Domains :     152 

Effect,  anomalous  Zeeman:  374 
— ,  Compton:  231 
— ,  Dopier:  207 
— ,  linear  Stark:  377 
— ,  normal  Zeeman:  374 
— ,  square-law  Stark:  377 
Effective  cross-section, 
differential:    54,  385 
— ,  total:   391 
Efficiency:  622 
Eigenfunctions :  253 


590 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


Eigenvalues:  253 

— ,  angular-momentum  projection:  294 
,  degenerate:  416 

-  of  square  of  angular  momentum:  308 
Einstein  formula  for  fluctuation  pro- 
bability: 550 
-,  radiation  laws :   464 
Elements,  rare-earth:  342 

-  -,  transuranium :  243 

Emission  of  quanta,  spontaneous  and 

forced:    462 

-,  magnetic  dipole:   188,  366 
,  quadrupolo:   188,  367 
Energy:  31 

-,  field:   121 

-,  hydrogen  atom:   410 

-,  in  the  theory  of  relativity :  213 

-,  of  potential  gauge  calibration :  44 

-,  potential:   19 

-,  rest:  213 

-,  solid  body:  467 
— ,  calculation  of:  468 
--,  total:  32 
Energy  levels,  electronic :  448 

-,  — -,  fine  structure  of:  330 

-,  multiplet:  339 

-,  rotational :  452 

-,  spectroscopic  notation  of:  339 

-,  vibrational :  449 
Entropy:  506 
-—  of  a  subsystem:  507 
Equation,  Clapeyron:  436 

-,  Clausius-Clapeyron :  559 

-,  Dirac :  395 

-,  Schrodinger:  246 
— ,  Thomas-Fermi :  487 

-  -,  van  dor  Waals :  560 
Equations,  Euler:  78 
--,  Hamilton:  89 

— ,  Lagrange:  19 

— ,  Maxwell:    109,  113 

— ,  in  complex  form:  157 

Excited  state  of  a  system :  254 

Expansion,  eigenfunction :  304 

Experiment,  Fizeau:  200 

— ,  Michelson's:    191 

— ,  Stern-Gerlach:  295 

Factor,  Lande:  372 

Fermi -Dirac  distribution :  426,  477 

Ferromagnetism :  151 

Filled  levels,  shell:  370 

Fine  structure  of  atomic  levels :  330 

Fizeau  experiment :  201 

Fluctuation,  absolute  energy :  504 

— ,  relative  energy :  504 

Force:  14 

— ,  central:  24 


Force  centrifugal:  73 
— ,  Coriolis :   72 
--,  electromotive :  106 
— -,  friction:  16 
— ,  inertia:  71 
— ,  Lorentz :  220 
-,  magnetomotive :  112 

-  -,  oscillator :  384 
Formula,  barometric:  441 

-,  Debye :  470 

-,  dispersion:  382 

-,  Planck:  464 

-,  Poisson :  548 
— -,  Rutherford:  55,  387 
— ,  Stirling:  423 
Formulae,  Fresnel :  172 
Free  energy:  524 
Frequency,  of  oscillation:  58 
Function,  Hamilton:  88 

-  -,  Lagrange :  22 
— ,  for  field:  117 
Galilean  transformation :  68 
Gauge  calibration,  potential :   115 

—  invariance:  116 
Gibbs  distribution:  502 
Gradient:  98 

Ground  state,  electromagj1  etic  field:  277 
—  of  a  system :  254 
Hamilton's  equation:  89 

—  function  (Hamiltonian) :  88 
Harmonic  oscillator:  61,  265 
Heat  of  reaction :  579 

—  of  solution:  571 
Helium,  orthostate  of:  349 
— -  paras tate  of:  349 
Ideal  gases:  415 

Index,  adiabatic :  542 

— ,  refractive:  170 

Induction,  electric:  148 

— ,  magnetic :  148 

Integral  principles :  82 

Integrals  of  motion :  31 

Intensity,  dipole  radiation:  187 

Interval:  202 

Intervals,  space  and  time :  203 

Invariant  electromagnetic  field :  223 

Inversion:  320,  403 

Irreversible  process :  520 

Isomers,  nuclear:  367 

Isothermal  process :  519 

Kepler  problem :   47 

Lagrange's  equation :  22 

— ,  integrals  of  motion:  31 

Lagrangian:  19 

— ,  field:  117 

Land6  factor:  372 

Laplacian  operator :  100